Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
15 - BUY
Ankur Rudra
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
+91 22 6650 5059
Following its recent IBM IoT deal, Persistent is now powered by four
strong growth drivers: IoT, digital, outsourced product development
(OPD) services and intellectual property (IP). Its recent reorganisation
should help streamline the business and improve profits. We expect
Persistent to be a Double Bagger over the next three years powered by a
21% revenue FY16-19 Cagr and recovering margins. At 12x FY18CL, it is
an attractive next-generation services play and we reiterate our BUY call.
Digital remains a dominant near-term driver
Persistents early focus on digital/SMAC (social, mobile, analytics and cloud)
helped to expand its addressable market to financial services, telecom and
healthcare enterprises. Its focus on front-end digital offerings and softwareas-a-service platforms differentiates it from larger peers. Its enterprise
business has grown to 29% of revenue and should continue to deliver a Cagr
of more than 30%.
22 June 2016
India
Technology
Reuters
Bloomberg
PERS.BO
PSYS IN
Rs771.25/579.28
Rs900.00
+29%
Shares in issue
Free float (est.)
80.0m
61.5%
Market cap
US$818m
Rs100.1m
(US$1.5m)
3M
12M
Absolute
Relative
(3.7)
(9.2)
(6.0)
(11.9)
(2.3)
(2.2)
Abs (US$)
(3.9)
(7.6)
(8.1)
1000
(Rs)
(%)
150
904
100
808
712
50
616
520
Jun-14
0
Feb-15
Oct-15
Source: Bloomberg
www.clsa.com
Jun-16
15A
18,913
2,906
36.3
16.6
19.2
1.0
3.9
4.0
22.1
11.1
16A
23,123
2,974
37.2
2.3
18.7
1.4
1.6
3.4
19.5
15.1
17CL
30,210
3,451
43.2
103
16.1
16.1
1.2
4.5
2.9
19.3
45.8
18CL
35,772
4,595
57.5
113
33.2
12.1
1.5
5.7
2.4
21.7
88.3
19CL
41,302
5,724
71.6
119
24.5
9.7
1.9
7.3
1.9
22.0
144.1
Source: CLSA
Find CLSA research on Bloomberg, Thomson Reuters, Factset and CapitalIQ - and profit from our evalu@tor proprietary database at clsa.com
We would like to thank Evalueserve for its help in preparing our research reports. Chirag Gandhi (Financials); Nikhil Gada (Midcaps); Aniket
Sethi (Cement, Oil & Gas); Niket Gajra (Autos & IT); Vishal Nathany (Cap goods, utilities & power) provide research support services to CLSA.
Over the past five years, Persistent has successfully evolved from a service
provider limited to the hi-tech industry for offshore product engineering
services to a niche next-generation service provider for enterprises across
financial services, healthcare, telecom and hi-tech. The key driver for this
transformation was its early recognition of technology changes leading
towards digital/SMAC (social, mobile, analytics and cloud) services.
It recently signed a
landmark deal with IBM
It signed a landmark deal with IBM in March 2016 for the development and
maintenance of applications on the US companys Watson Internet of Things
(IoT) platform. Persistent has been contracted to build and maintain
applications leveraging IBMs IoT platform for enterprise customers. This
further expands its ability to provide next-generation services besides its
digital capabilities. Its recent reorganisation towards creating four distinct
business units - digital, IBM, intellectual property (IP) and services streamlines leadership and improves its focus.
Digital/SMAC for enterprise: Persistent has broken away from its digital
services unit that focuses on enterprises customers into an independent P&L
after its reorganisation. This is under the leadership of Sunil Kulkarni, head of
sales. The unit focuses on providing digital transformation and implementing
SaaS platforms such as Appian, Salesforce.com, Oracle Identity management
and SAP HANA. The unit has grown at a breakneck speed of 35-45% YoY over
the past couple of years to US$52m (annualised) and has now achieved the
critical mass to grow independently. This part of the business has the highest
onsite mix given recent investment and hence the lowest margins in high
single digits. As growth continues, improvement in onsite utilisation can drive
substantial margin improvement. Continued strong traction in digital services,
leveraging its early focus and expertise is likely to remain a key driver of
long-term growth potential.
Figure 1
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
2
Persistent: Revenue and Ebit estimates from the new IBM alliance
25
(US$m)
20
18
17
15
15
14
13
15
11
10
0
(5)
(2)
(2)
(1)
(0)
(0)
Persistents IP business
grew to US$70m in FY16
22 June 2016
3
similar acquisitions and extend the life of acquired IP. This provides the
benefit of differentiation, customer acquisition and wider margins.
Figure 3
Figure 4
Citrix
products
US$0m
30
Others
US$11m
Radia/HP CA
US$17m
(US$m)
IP revenue
25
150
20
Aepona
US$7m
100
15
50
10
Location
(openwave)
US$8m
IBM TNPM
US$13m
4QFY16
3QFY16
2QFY16
1QFY16
4QFY15
3QFY15
2QFY15
1QFY15
4QFY14
3QFY14
2QFY14
1QFY14
4QFY13
3QFY13
2QFY13
1QFY13
4QFY12
3QFY12
2QFY12
Connectors
US$9m
(50)
1QFY12
0
rCloud
US$4m
200
Engineering-services
business is expected to
grow in the mid-single
digits
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
4
Figure 6
Figure 7
50
(%)
45
12
Expect 2-6%
QoQ growth ahead
10
Expect 13-35%
YoY growth ahead
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
3QFY19
1QFY19
3QFY18
1QFY18
3QFY17
1QFY17
3QFY16
1QFY16
3QFY15
1QFY15
3QFY14
1QFY14
3QFY13
1QFY13
3QFY12
1QFY12
1QFY11
3QFY19
1QFY19
3QFY18
1QFY18
3QFY17
1QFY17
3QFY16
1QFY16
3QFY15
1QFY15
3QFY14
1QFY14
3QFY13
1QFY13
3QFY12
1QFY12
3QFY11
1QFY11
(2)
3QFY11
14
FY15
FY16
FY17CL
FY18CL
FY19CL
5,113
6,623
8,093
9,112
10,278
14,944
14,898
15,275
16,013
16,496
76
99
124
146
170
33.2
29.1
25.3
18.0
16.2
40,981
42,328
45,377
52,184
58,427
4,222
4,223
4,377
4,457
4,480
173
179
199
233
262
3.3
3.3
11.1
17.1
12.5
59
67
77
87
97
19.9
13.0
15.4
13.0
11.5
53
70
90
32.1
28.6
309
352
452
536
618
12.6
14.0
28.6
18.4
15.5
18,913
23,123
30,210
35,772
41,302
13.3
22.3
30.6
18.4
15.5
Total revenue
YoY growth (%)
Source: Company, CLSA
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
5
Persistent has seen significant margin investments over the past couple of
years as it invested heavily into sales and an onsite presence for its
enterprise business. Structurally, its business earns a higher billing rate over
similar-sized peers. We expect margins to recover with rising onsite utilisation
in digital, growth from the IBM IoT deal and rising sales productivity.
Figure 9
Figure 10
14
12
35
40
60
30
30
50
25
20
40
20
10
30
15
20
10
(10)
10
(20)
FY11
FY19CL
FY18CL
FY17CL
FY16
FY15
FY14
FY13
FY12
FY11
10
70
40
FY19CL
16
50
EPS
FY18CL
18
(%)
80
FY17CL
20
(Rs)
60
FY16
(%)
FY15
FY14
Ebit margin
FY13
(%)
FY12
22
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14
FY15
14.9
17.1
19.7
19.6
15.7
13.9
13.5
15.2
16.2
1.3
1.1
1.0
1.0
1.3
1.2
1.1
1.1
1.2
0.9
0.7
0.7
0.7
0.7
0.8
0.7
0.7
0.7
0.9
1.0
1.1
1.2
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.3
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.3
1.3
1.3
1.3
1.2
1.2
20.1
17.9
20.0
22.3
22.1
19.5
19.3
21.7
22.0
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14
FY15
100
62
65
65
80
61
61
60
62
43
(5)
55
89
74
30
72
68
71
ROAE (%)
Source: Company, CLSA
Figure 12
We value Persistent at
Rs900, which equates to
16x 1Y forward PE
22 June 2016
Valuation details
We value Persistent at Rs900, which equates to 16x one-year forward PE. This
is based on a combination of DCF and a fundamental PE multiple, implying 31%
upside. The multiple is 1sd above its past five-year average PE. It is also at the
upper end of domestic peers and below intnl mid-sized IT service providers of
a similar product development heritage (eg, EPAM, Luxoft and Globant).
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
6
DCF valuation of
Rs909
DCF valuation
We detail below our 15-year DCF, which assumes 5% terminal growth and
13% cost of equity (COE) with a RFR of 7.5%, equity-risk premium of 5.5%
and applying a beta of one. With a net cash balance sheet, WACC is equal to
COE. This leads to a one-year forward fair value of Rs909.
Figure 13
DCF valuation
PV of forecasting period up to FY29 (Rsm)
36,712
28,155
64,868
7,834
72,702
909
Source: CLSA
Figure 14
We expect Persistents
discounted FCF to remain
stable over the years
Free cashflow
4,000
(Rsm)
PV of FCF (LHS)
WACC
ROE
(%)
30
3,500
25
3,000
20
2,500
2,000
15
1,500
10
1,000
5
500
0
FY18 FY19 FY20 FY21 FY22 FY23 FY24 FY25 FY26 FY27 FY28 FY29
Source: CLSA
Figure 15
Even at 4% terminal
growth rate, the fair value
of Persistent is
Rs868/share at 13%
WACC
WACC
3%
4%
5%
6%
7%
11%
1,033
1,097
1,182
1,300
1,475
12%
923
968
1,026
1,104
1,211
13%
834
868
909
962
1,032
14%
763
787
818
855
904
15%
703
722
745
772
806
Source: CLSA
Theoretical PE implies a
share price of Rs916/sh
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
7
Figure 16
Theoretical valuation
methodology for
Persistent indicates a PE
of 15.9x FY18CL earnings
20
25
20.0
77
8.3
25
7.5
5.5
Beta (J)
1.03
13.2
#PE (x)
15.9
57.5
916
Source: CLSA
#PE = (A*(1+B)*((1-(1+B)^K/(1+C)^K)/(C-B)))+D*(1+B)^K*(1+E)/((CE)*(1+C)^K)
Source: Aswath Damodaran
We expect Persistent to deliver a 24% earnings Cagr over FY16-19; using 16x
PE (1sd above the five-year average) we arrive at a three-year target of
Rs1,542. With a dividend yield of 1-1.5% over the next three years, we
expect the stocks total returns to exceed 100%.
We expect Persistent to
deliver a TSR of 129%
over next three years
Figure 17
We expect total returns from Persistent to exceed 100% over next three years
Company
Mcap Current
(US$m)
price
(Rs)
Persistent
821
1-year
target
1-year
return
(%)
Div
yield
(%)
1-year
TSR
(%)
3-year
target
(Rs)
2-year
div
(%)
3-year
div
(%)
3-year
return
(%)
3-year
TSR
(%)
Rec
900
31.3
1.1
32.4
1,542
1.5
1.5
125.0
129.1
BUY
685
Key risks
The key risks to our growth estimates include:
Volatile revenue from
legacy business and rupee
appreciation are some of
the key risks
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
8
We value Persistent at
16x one-year forward PE,
which is 1sd above its
past five-year average
(x)
21
19
17
+1sd 16.2x
15
13
Avg 12.6x
11
9
-1sd 9.0x
7
Jun 11
Jun 12
Jun 13
Jun 14
Jun 15
Jun 16
Mindtree
Cyient
Mphasis
Persistent
110
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
Jun 11
Jun 12
Jun 13
Jun 14
Jun 15
Jun 16
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
9
Figure 20
Ebitda
Cagr (%)
(CY15-17)
CY16
CY17
Nopat
Cagr (%)
(CY15-17)
EV/Ebitda (x)
EPS Cagr
(%)
CY17 (CY15-17)
EV/Nopat (x)
CY16
PE (x)
ROE (%)
CY16
CY17
CY16
CY17
2.0
14.3
14.2
12.1
15.0
19.6
16.6
14.0
19.0
16.8
34.5
33.3
Infosys
2.0
15.7
12.2
10.2
15.1
18.7
15.6
11.8
18.9
16.5
22.5
23.1
Wipro
1.6
14.3
9.7
7.9
13.8
14.5
11.8
9.1
14.5
13.0
19.4
19.2
HCL Tech
2.2
19.0
11.7
8.3
17.4
15.3
11.4
16.6
16.1
12.2
23.9
26.7
Median
2.0
15.0
12.0
9.3
15.0
17.0
13.7
12.9
17.5
14.7
23.2
24.9
Mean
2.0
15.8
11.9
9.6
15.3
17.0
13.9
12.9
17.2
14.6
25.1
25.5
2.0
10.8
9.2
8.0
10.7
14.3
12.4
8.3
14.8
13.5
21.4
20.2
Hexaware
4.7
11
10.4
9.0
10.6
15.0
12.8
9.3
15.7
13.6
28.2
30.5
Mindtree
1.7
17
10.6
9.0
19.0
16.2
13.6
15.1
15.7
13.5
26.1
26.4
eClerx
0.5
13.2
13.0
10.5
12.1
15.8
13.5
11.3
16.7
14.9
33.4
30.7
Persistent
1.3
25.4
10.1
7.3
26.2
17.5
12.2
20.8
17.0
13.3
19.4
21.1
Polaris
5.3
55
6.0
5.2
NA
NA
NA
13.7
10.7
9.1
21.1
23.4
Median
1.8
12.3
9.0
8.5
12.1
15.8
12.8
12.5
15.7
13.5
23.8
24.9
Mean
2.6
13.9
9.1
8.2
15.7
15.8
12.9
13.1
15.1
13.0
25.0
25.4
Next-generation IT companies
Globant
0.0
51
20.1
17.1
80.3
43.8
26.4
65.4
34.0
27.9
22.0
21.1
Luxoft
0.0
18
12.9
10.7
20.1
15.4
13.1
17.6
19.9
16.7
30.9
27.6
EPAM
0.0
46
15.2
12.5
49.3
21.3
17.5
47.2
23.2
19.5
22.1
21.6
Median
0.0
46
15.2
12.5
49
21.3
17.5
47.2
23.2
19.5
22.1
21.6
Mean
0.0
38
16.1
13.4
50
26.8
19.0
43.4
25.7
21.4
25.0
23.4
Source: Bloomberg estimates for not-rated companies, CLSA; *GAAP EPS; Priced as of 17 June 2016
Persistent has nine directors on its board of which seven are independent. Its
board has a strong combination of directors with diverse mix of distinguished
careers in technology, financial services and marketing roles.
Management has a robust track record. After scaling up its OPD practice since
its listing, Persistent spotted an early opportunity in digital/SMAC services.
The company faced challenges in its go-to-market strategy for expanding in
enterprise accounts and has changed its sales leadership several times to
drive change towards strengthening its sales. While its stated strategy has
seen some course correction over the past five years from partner-sales for
SaaS customers to IP-lead strategy to digital and more recently a
combination of digital and IoT, the underlying theme has been the expansion
of its addressable market beyond hi-tech customers.
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
10
Figure 21
FY15
5,113
FY16
6,623
FY17CL
8,093
FY18CL
9,112
FY19CL
10,278
14,944
76
14,898
99
15,275
124
16,013
146
16,496
170
33.2
40,981
29.1
42,328
25.3
45,377
18.0
52,184
16.2
58,427
4,222
4,223
4,377
4,457
4,480
173
3.3
179
3.3
199
11.1
233
17.1
262
12.5
59
19.9
67
13.0
77
15.4
87
13.0
97
11.5
53
70
32.1
90
28.6
309
12.6
352
14.0
452
28.6
536
18.4
618
15.5
Total revenue
18,913
23,123
30,210
35,772
41,302
13.3
7,596
22.3
8,819
30.6
11,027
18.4
13,602
15.5
16,079
40
3,690
38
4,647
37
5,747
38
6,760
39
7,813
Ebitda
Ebitda margin (%)
3,906
20.7
4,171
18.0
5,280
17.5
6,842
19.1
8,267
20.0
D&A
939
965
1,198
1,393
1,587
Ebit
Ebit margin (%)
2,967
15.7
3,206
13.9
4,082
13.5
5,449
15.2
6,680
16.2
PBT
Provision for tax
3,900
993
3,956
983
4,680
1,229
6,252
1,657
7,787
2,064
Net income
2,906
2,974
3,451
4,595
5,724
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
11
Figure 22
FY15
FY16
FY17CL
FY18CL
FY19CL
13
13
14
22
29
31
18
18
15
15
Ebitda growth
Ebit growth
(9)
(9)
7
8
27
27
30
34
21
23
Gross margin
Ebitda margin
40
21
38
18
37
17
38
19
39
20
Ebit margin
PAT margin
16
15
14
13
14
11
15
13
16
14
36.3
37.2
43.2
57.5
71.6
YoY growth
Cash EPS (Rs)
17
48.1
2
49.2
16
58.1
33
74.9
25
91.5
18
29
22
Margin (%)
YoY growth
Cash conversion ratios (%)
CFO/Ebitda
80
61
61
60
62
FCF/PAT
Return ratios (%)
74
30
72
68
71
ROE
ROCE
22
17
20
16
19
17
22
19
22
19
ROIC
18
17
20
26
30
15.7
13.9
13.5
15.2
16.2
1.3
0.7
1.2
0.8
1.1
0.7
1.1
0.7
1.2
0.7
1.1
1.3
1.2
1.3
1.3
1.3
1.4
1.2
1.3
1.2
22
20
19
22
22
ROAE (%)
Source: Company, CLSA
Valuation details
We value Persistent at Rs900, which equates to 16x one-year forward PE, 1sd
above its five-year average and the average since listing. This is justified by
its strong focus on digital/SMAC, the key industry growth driver that could
transform Persistent into a leading futuristic IT services firm. Our TP is based
on a combination of DCF and a fundamental PE multiple.
Investment risks
Key risks include: rupee appreciation, which could hurt earnings given that
Persistent benefits from a weaker local currency - we estimate every 1% drop
in Rs/US$ boosts margin by 30-40bps and earnings by 1.5-3%, all else being
equal; discretionary spend on new technology services such as SMAC across
enterprises and hi-tech firms; adverse immigration regulation, which can hurt
Persistent's ability to staff projects at client locations in the USA; and the
inability to successfully penetrate enterprise customers due to "go-to-market"
issues when competing with larger Indian and global IT services firms.
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
12
Summary financials
We expect US$-revenue
growth to accelerate from
14% in FY16 to 29%/
18% in FY17/18
IBM contract to be
margin-dilutive in FY17
Year to 31 March
Summary P&L forecast (Rsm)
Revenue
Op Ebitda
Op Ebit
Interest income
Interest expense
Other items
Profit before tax
Taxation
Minorities/Pref divs
Net profit
2015A
2016A
2017CL
2018CL
2019CL
18,913
3,906
2,967
932
0
3,900
(993)
2,906
23,123
4,171
3,206
750
0
0
3,956
(983)
2,974
30,210
5,280
4,082
598
0
4,680
(1,229)
3,451
35,772
6,842
5,449
803
0
6,252
(1,657)
4,595
41,302
8,267
6,680
1,107
0
7,787
(2,064)
5,724
3,206
219
965
(838)
(1,012)
2,541
(1,659)
881
276
429
(955)
(15)
(1,040)
(212)
(1,266)
319
916
1,235
4,082
0
1,198
(816)
(1,229)
3,235
(740)
2,496
598
(142)
0
(640)
0
(640)
2,454
1,235
3,689
5,449
0
1,393
(1,069)
(1,657)
4,117
(971)
3,146
803
(168)
0
(552)
0
(552)
3,397
3,689
7,086
6,680
0
1,587
(1,061)
(2,064)
5,142
(1,051)
4,091
1,107
56
0
(735)
0
(735)
4,463
7,086
11,548
1,235
4,275
6,615
4,453
175
4,311
21,065
1,651
1,647
26
1,349
0
16,393
21,065
3,689
5,586
6,321
3,995
175
4,311
24,076
1,851
1,647
26
1,261
0
19,292
24,076
7,086
6,614
6,561
3,573
175
4,311
28,320
2,051
1,647
26
1,445
0
23,152
28,320
11,548
7,637
6,800
3,037
175
4,311
33,508
2,251
1,647
26
709
0
28,875
33,508
22.3
6.8
18.0
12.9
25.9
24.8
(7.4)
19.5
17.5
4.0
30.6
26.6
17.5
11.4
18.7
26.3
(19.0)
19.3
19.9
6.4
18.4
29.6
19.1
12.8
18.7
26.5
(30.5)
21.7
25.6
12.1
15.5
20.8
20.0
13.9
18.7
26.5
(39.9)
22.0
30.3
16.8
Ratio analysis
Revenue growth (% YoY)
Ebitda growth (% YoY)
Ebitda margin (%)
Net profit margin (%)
Dividend payout (%)
Effective tax rate (%)
Ebitda/net int exp (x)
Net debt/equity (%)
ROE (%)
ROIC (%)
EVA/IC (%)
13.3
(9.2)
20.7
15.4
18.7
25.5
(6.3)
22.1
18.0
4.5
Source: CLSA
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
13
Important disclosures
Companies mentioned
Persistent Systems (PSYS IN - RS696.15 - BUY)
Citrix (CTXS US - US$85.14 - OUTPERFORM)
Cyient (N-R)
eClerx (ECLX IB - RS1,438.7 - OUTPERFORM)
EPAM (N-R)
Global Logic (N-R)
Globant (N-R)
Haman Connected Services (N-R)
HCL Tech (HCLT IB - RS768.8 - BUY)
Hexaware (N-R)
IBM (IBM US - US$153.61 - OUTPERFORM)
Infosys (INFO IB - RS1,205.9 - OUTPERFORM)
Intel (INTC US - US$32.17 - UNDERPERFORM)
Luxoft (N-R)
Microsoft (MSFT US - US$50.07 - OUTPERFORM)
MindTree (N-R)
Ness Software Engineering Services (N-R)
Oracle (ORCL US - US$39.73 - UNDERPERFORM)
Pactera (N-R)
Polaris (N-R)
Salesforce.com (CRM US - US$81.22 - BUY)
SAP (N-R)
Symphony Teleca (N-R)
Tata Consultancy (TCS IB - RS2,647.3 - BUY)
Tech Mahindra (TECHM IB - RS537.3 - OUTPERFORM)
Wipro (WPRO IB - RS560.3 - OUTPERFORM)
Covered by CLSA; Covered by CLSA Americas
Analyst certification
The analyst(s) of this report hereby certify that the views expressed in this research report accurately reflect
my/our own personal views about the securities and/or the issuers and that no part of my/our compensation
was, is, or will be directly or indirectly related to the specific recommendation or views contained in this
research report.
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
14
Important disclosures
Important disclosures
Stock price (Rs)
1,200
BUY
U-PF
N-R
O-PF
SELL
1,000
800
600
400
Date
22 Mar 2016
26 Jan 2016
27 Oct 2015
Rec
BUY
BUY
BUY
Target
900.00
970.00
1,030.00
Date
04 Sep 2015
20 Jul 2015
20 May 2015
Rec
BUY
BUY
BUY
Target
1,100.00
1,000.00
996.10
Source: CLSA
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
Important disclosures
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
16
Important disclosures
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
17
Important disclosures
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
18
Important disclosures
Research subscriptions
To change your report distribution requirements, please contact your CLSA sales representative or email us at cib@clsa.com.
You can also fine-tune your Research Alert email preferences at https://www.clsa.com/member/tools/email_alert/.
22 June 2016
ankur.rudra@clsa.com
19