Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 20

Aircraft Noise

Comparison
The Facts

This brief presentation sets out to


clarify some misconceptions on aircraft
noise emissions and give facts
pertaining to the likely noise impact of
the mix of aircraft at Oxford Airport,
actual, anticipated or hypothetical

Turbine Business Aircraft


vs.
Piston Training &
Recreation Aircraft

Noise Nuisance & Disturbance


1 biz jet an hour is clearly more tolerable
than 50+ piston training aircraft an hour*
A business jet or turboprop goes straight
in or out of the airfield disappearing quickly
Piston training aircraft routinely do circuits
and touch & gos business aircraft dont
In last 18 months we have logged just two
complaints relating to a jet movement
* Anticipated jet activity/hour versus peak pilot training traffic/hour seen in the past, now migrated to USA

Popular Misconceptions
All jets are noisier than all turboprops which
are noisier than all piston aircraft

WRONG
The most popular training aircraft a Piper
PA28, is twice as noisy as the quietest
business jet (Cessna Citation Encore) on
take-off - US FAA certificated noise data

Popular Misconceptions
Cessna
Encore

- 58.3 dBA*

is half as noisy as a
Piper PA28 - 68.0 dBA*
* US FAA A-weighted 14 CFR
Part 36 @ take-off

Effective Perceived Noise Level*

Cessna 207 - 74.3 dBA


is +20% noisier than a
Boeing BBJ - 71.8 dBA
(737-700)
* US FAA A-weighted 14 CFR
Part 36 @ take-off

Effective Perceived Noise Level

Gulfstream V
68.0 dBA

Cirrus SR22
73.6 dBA

The Cirrus is effectively +50% noisier than the


Gulfstream V on take-off under the same criteria

Worlds Best Selling Piston Aircraft


Todays best selling
family of piston aircraft
the ultra modern
Cirrus aircraft, are
NOISIER than almost
EVERY modern
business or regional jet
and turboprop in
existence at 73.6 to
72.1 dBA* on take-off.
Effective Perceived Noise Level US FAA Aweighted 14 CFR Part 36 noise standards

Aircraft Noise School vs. Jet Aircraft

Oxford Aviation Training


Piper PA34-200T
(Twin Piston)
is noisier on take-off than:
* Canadair RJ, Citation CJ, CJ2, II/Bravo, Excel,
Encore, Dornier 328 Jet, Lear 60, Lear 45

Aircraft Noise Piston vs. Jet Aircraft

Worlds most popular aircraft


(still produced after 50 years)
Cessna 172
is noisier on take-off than
the most popular business jets:

* Citation CJ, CJ2, II/Bravo, Excel, Encore, Lear 60,


Lear 45

Noise Perception
On an apples for apples basis, certificated
take-off noise levels for aircraft that could
land at Oxford range from*:
Jets:

58.3 dBA to 89.7 dBA

Turboprops:

57.0 dBA to 78.3 dBA

Piston:

51.0 dBA to 76.0 dBA

* Sourced from FAA Advisory Circular April 2002 AC No. 36-3H

Turboprop Airliner vs. Light Piston


The most common
regional airliner (de
Havilland Dash 8-Q400)
with 75 passengers on
take-off.
.makes exactly the
same noise level (61
dBA*) as the most
common light piston GA
aircraft (Cessna 172)
* Effective Perceived Noise Level US FAA A-weighted 14 CFR Part
36 noise standards

Turboprop Airliner vs. Light Piston


One of Oxfords small
single-engined training
aircraft (PA-28) is
TWICE as noisy on
take-off.
.than a 75-seat
regional airliner (de
Havilland Dash-8-Q400)

Aircraft Noise - Facts


Numerous jets and turboprops are quieter
on take-off than many piston aircraft types
Over 60 different jet models are quieter on
take-off than the noisiest piston aircraft
The noisiest business jet (Westwind) that
could use Oxford is three times noisier than
the quietest business jet (Encore)

Aircraft Noise - Facts


The most common business jets that
we anticipate using Oxford hereon and
see today, are in the main no noisier on
take-off than the OAT* school Piper
Senecas - whilst new jet movements
will represent a fraction of the daily
activity and around 1% of the 90,000
movements lost over the last six years
* Oxford Aviation Training

Aircraft Noise Facts


An HGV at on the A44 at
5m, is noisier (95dBA)
and dirtier, than a typical
business jet at (75dBA)
at 450m from the runway
centre on take-off.
we average just 2 jet
visits/day vs. several
hundred HGVs day and
night on the A44

Annual Adjacent Transiting Traffic


8.8 million vehicles pass
the end of the runway
(A44) every year
nearly 25,000 a day.
.producing massively
greater emissions than
any past or anticipated
future airport activity
Source: OCC Traffic Flows 2005 A44 north west of Peartree Roundabout

Summary
Aircraft noise is clearly not directly related to
aircraft size or engine type as shown herein.
Modern business jet aircraft are far more
environmentally friendly than most older airliner
types and many turboprops and piston aircraft.
Anticipated future Oxford Airport user fleet mix will
reduce overall noise and noise nuisance with new
Section 106 limitations (noise mitigation
agreement) and huge reduction in overall traffic
compared with ten years ago

Aircraft Emissions at Oxford


Have Already Halved