Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
www.elsevier.com/locate/epsl
Institut de Recherche pour le Developpement (ex-ORSTOM), Unite de Recherche 104, Universite Paul Sabatier, Toulouse III,
38 rue des Trente-Six Ponts, 31400 Toulouse, France
b
College of Oceanic and Atmospheric Sciences, Oregon State University, Corvallis, Or 97331, USA
Received 27 September 2004; received in revised form 15 March 2005; accepted 31 March 2005
Editor: E. Bard
Abstract
Small volumes of Cretaceous alkaline basaltic magmas have been identified in the sedimentary infill of the Ecuadorian Oriente
foreland basin. They are characterized by a restricted range of compositional variation, low LILE/HFSE ratios and SrNd isotope
values within the range of oceanic island basalts (OIB). Reflection seismic data show that a pre-existing NNESSW Triassic and
Jurassic rift controls the location and occurrence of these alkaline eruptive sites. Radiometric ages (40Ar39Ar, incremental heating
method) and the biostratigraphic record of their surrounding sediments indicate a NNESSW systematic age variation for the
emplacement of this alkaline volcanism: from Albian (110 F 5.2 Ma) in the northern part of the Oriente Basin, to Campanian
(82.2 F 2.0 Ma) in the west-central part. The geochemical, geochronological and tectonic evidences suggest that asthenospheric
mantle has upwelled and migrated to the SSW, into the region underlying the pre-existing Triassic and Jurassic rift (thin-spot?).
We propose that subduction was abandoned, subsequent to the accretion of allochthonous terranes onto the Ecuadorian and
Colombian margin in the latest Jurassicearliest Cretaceous, causing the relict slab material, corresponding to the eastwardsdirected leading plate, to roll-back. Unmodified asthenospheric mantle migrated into the region previously occupied by the slab.
This resulted in partial melting and the release of magmatic material to the surface in the northern part of the Oriente Basin since
at least Aptian times. Then, magmatism migrated along the SSW-trending Central Wrench Corridor of the Oriente Basin during
the Upper Cretaceous, probably as a consequence of the lateral propagation of the transpressive inversion of the Triassic
Jurassic rift. Eventually, the Late Cretaceous east-dipping Andean subduction system was renewed farther west, and the
development of the compressional retro-foreland Oriente Basin system halted the Cretaceous alkaline magmatic activity.
D 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Northern Andes; Ecuador; Oriente Basin; alkaline magmatism; Cretaceous; roll-back; transpressive inversion
* Corresponding author. OXY Ecuador, Ave. Naciones Unidas E7-95 y Shyris, Edificio Banco del Pacfico, Quito-Ecuador. Tel.: +593 2 299
3700; fax: +593 2 299 3701.
E-mail address: roberto_barragan@oxy.com (R. Barragan).
0012-821X/$ - see front matter D 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.epsl.2005.03.016
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
671
1. Introduction
Intra-continental plate alkaline magmatism is
reported from numerous locations in Mesozoic and
Cenozoic strata along the Pacific margin of the
Americas and the Antarctic Peninsula [111]. Different models, each related to a tectonic setting, have
been proposed to explain the generation and occurrence of alkaline magma. Possible mechanisms
include: (a) mantle plumes with abnormally high
asthenospheric temperatures beneath continental
crust [1214] (e.g., Columbia River Basalts in the
NW United States [15]); (b) upwelling and decompressional melting due to lithospheric extension [16]
and rift propagation (e.g., Andean Jurassic back-arc
77 00' W
PUTUMAYO BASIN
(COLOMBIA)
TAPI
CAYAMBE
0o 00'
REVENTADOR
NAPO
UPLIFT
VISTA
ANTISANA
LAGUNA
SUMACO
AUCA
PUNGARAYACU JAGUAR
YURALPA
DAYUNO
PASTAZA
DEPRESSION
SUB-ANDEAN FORELAND BASIN
Quito
ECUADOR
ORIENTE
BASIN
GUAYANA
SHIELD
PUTUMAYO
BASIN
ORIENTE BASIN
(ECUADOR)
CUTUCU
UPLIFT
MARAON BASIN
(PERU)
Guayaquil
MARAON
BASIN
100 Km
Talara
Real Cordillera
Subandean System
Central Corridor
Active volcanoes
Fig. 1. Regional location map. Synthetic tectonic map of the Ecuadorian Oriente Basin (modified from [20]).
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
CHRONOSTRATIGRAPHY
LITHOLOGY
50
CHALCANA
continental
ORTEGUAZA
shallow marine
UP. TIYUYACU
continental
EOCENE
LOW.TIYUYACU TRANSPRESSION
continental
PALEOCENE
60
UP. TENA
continental
LOW. TENA
continental
70
80
LATE
90
100
106 5
(40Ar/40K)
110
Basal Tena
v
v
TRANSPRESSIVE
INVERSION
UP. NAPO
82.2 2.0
(40Ar/39Ar)
91.2 4.6
(40Ar/39K)
Foreland
Isostatic
Rebound
FORELAND MEGASEQUENCE
40
MIOCENE
OLIGOCENE
30
TECTONIC EVENT
shallow marine
Initiation of Foreland
v
v
LOW. NAPO
shallow marine
CRATONIC BASIN
v
v
HOLLIN
shallow marine
continental
v
v
PRE-OROGENIC
MEGASEQUENCE
20
NEOGENE
10
ROCK UNIT
PALEOENVIRONMENT
MERA-MESA continental
CHAMBIRA/CURARAY
continental/shall marine
ARAJUNO continental
PLIOCENE
PALEOGENE
CRETACEOUS
672
EARLY
MIDDLE-UPPER
JURASSIC
v v v v
v v
v
v v
v
v
175
228
LOWER
JURASSIC
TO
UPPER
TRIASSIC
v
v
v
v
v
v
PA
L
B A EO
ZO
SE
I
M
EN C
T
130
2. Geological setting
MISAHUALLI /
CHAPIZA
volcanoclastic
continental
SANTIAGO
coastal plain
to shallow
marine
platform
BACK-ARC
EXTENSION
SUBDUCTION
ONSET
PRE-CRETACEOUS
MEGASEQUENCE
120
RIFTING
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
sional systems, inherited from the NNESSW paleorift structures [26], have been tectonically inverted
along three major oblique NNESSW right-lateral
transpressive wrench-fault zones (Fig. 1), which
have deformed the foreland basin system since the
Late Cretaceous [20]. From west to east, these tectonic
domains are: (i) the northern Sub-Andean system
(Napo Uplift), formed by an echelon NNWSSE
positive flower structure, which was mainly active
during the Pliocene and Quaternary, but currently
still exhibits strong seismic and volcanic activity; (ii)
the Central Corridor, developed in Late Cretaceous
78
673
77
76
COLOMBIA
1105 Ma(a)
1065 Ma(a)
ANDEA
RIO AGUARICO
102.42.4 Ma(b)
Laguna
Jivino
Puma
Pungarayacu
Oso
RIO
NAP
RIO N
APO
93.3.4 Ma(b)
91.24.6 Ma(a)
Cononaco
Yuralpa
82.22 Ma(b)
Auca
Jaguar
Waponi
Shushufindi
Vista
N COR
DILLER
Tapi
Armadillo
Ginta
933.4 Ma(b)
Dayuno
842 Ma(b)
EXTRUSIVE EVENTS
basaltic tuff cones
Villano-1
INTRUSIVE EVENTS
gabbroic sills
Oil Wells
Sample Sites
2
RI
Central Corridor
(Pre-existing Triassic-Lower
Jurassic rift structural limits)
PA
AZ
10 20 30 40 50
KILOMETERS
Fig. 3. Geographic distribution and location of Cretaceous extrusive and intrusive events along the Oriente Basin. Geochemically and
radiometrically analyzed sample sites are shown. Samples level with panel (b) are 40Ar39Ar and with panel (a) are 40Ar40K.
674
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
Fig. 4. Reflection seismic sections showing the emplacement of extrusive magmatic rocks facies in the Ecuadorian Oriente Basin during
deposition of the Campanian upper Napo Formation. Interpretation is based on well and seismic data correlations. Reflection seismic data show
the structural control of pre-existing extensional features on the emplacement of alkaline eruptive sites: (a) Jaguar extrusive structure (tuff cone).
(b) Puma structure (tuff cones). See Fig. 3 for the location of seismic profiles.
Extrusive events
Area (*)
NNE Tapi
Vista
Jivino
Laguna
IndillanaItaya
Auca
Armadillo
Cononaco
Puma
Jaguar
Pungarayacu
Waponi
M Yuralpa
WSW Dayuno
Intrusive events
Basaltic
Thickness Stratigraphic
glassy tuffs (m) (**) record
200250
180200
Biostratigraphic
age
Middle Albian
Hollin Fm
Upper HollinBasal Napo Middle Albian
30
1580
4080
5070
30
90135
10
LowerNapo
LowerNapo
Upper Napo Fm
Upper Napo Fm
Upper Napo Fm
Upper Napo Fm
Upper Napo Fm
Upper Napo Fm
80
70
Upper Napo Fm
Upper Napo Fm
SantonianCampanian
SantonianCampanian
Radiometric
age (Ma)
110.2 5.2
106 5
102.4 2.4
92 3.9
12
12
125
5060
20
0.11
50
150
5190
50
93.0 3.4
82.2 2.0
84 2
Radiometric
method
40
Ar/40K (***)
Ar/40K (***)
40
40
Ar/39Ar
40
Ar/40K (***)
40
Ar/39Ar;40Ar/40K (***)
40
Ar/39Ar
Ar/39Ar
40
Ar/39Ar (***)
40
Biostratigraphic information based on [21,22]. New 40Ar39Ar data are shown in Tables 3a and 3b. Bold ages in the right column indicate 40Ar39Ar plateau ages determined in this
study.
(*) Related to exploratory oil wells along the Oriente Basin of Ecuador (source: Petroproduccion-Geolab).
(**) Apparent thickness defined from well log analysis and the associated seismic section.
(***) Unpublished radiometric age data (source: Petroproduccion Library facilities). Age determinations on whole rock samples were performed by request of Texaco Petroleum
Company at the Geochron Laboratories Division, Krueger Enterprises, Inc.
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
Table 1
Summary of the extrusive and intrusive events recognized within the Cretaceous section of the Oriente Basin and found at different exploratory oil wells
675
676
SiO2 (wt.%)
Al2O3
TiO2
FeO
MnO
CaO
MgO
K2O
Na2O
P2O5
LOI
Total
Ni (ppm)
Cr
Sc
V
Rb
Sr
Ba
Nb
Zr
Y
Jivino-1
DJGJ1
Auca-16
DJGA16
Auca-23 Auca-20 Pungarayacu-9 Pungarayacu-16 Pungarayacu-39 Yuralpa-1 Waponi-1 Yuralpa-2 Pungarayacu-10 Yur
Dayuno-1
DJGA23 A FLD DJGP9
P9BX16
P9BX39
DJGY1
RBTW1 RBTY2 PUNGA
Centro-1 ONI 2
AL C1
45.62
11.28
3.03
11.52
0.17
11.86
10.30
1.27
2.62
0.58
4.19
102.44
258.00
317.00
24.00
264.00
26.00
662.00
518.00
60.50
194.00
25.00
43.02
12.58
3.05
13.02
0.11
10.31
8.01
1.91
2.42
0.79
8.75
103.96
58.00
277.00
22.50
276.00
38.00
1008.00
697.00
84.00
246.00
26.00
43.47
9.51
2.61
11.48
0.13
11.81
13.63
0.77
1.85
0.73
7.12
103.11
344.00
482.00
21.20
250.00
16.00
460.00
380.00
60.00
187.00
23.00
43.25
12.33
3.06
14.12
0.12
10.31
8.24
1.90
2.19
0.82
8.88
105.22
75.00
304.00
21.70
266.00
35.53
916.66
605.38
73.76
223.17
26.10
42.31
10.85
3.15
11.97
0.19
12.22
12.37
1.17
3.13
0.84
2.48
100.68
234.00
314.00
28.00
297.00
14.00
782.00
559.00
81.00
233.00
26.00
42.04
10.31
2.89
11.85
0.18
11.78
14.56
1.20
2.98
0.78
1.77
100.35
409.26
550.30
24.90
242.33
16.53
873.67
478.02
76.29
207.95
24.87
41.83
10.91
3.11
13.17
0.20
11.80
12.54
1.54
2.64
0.83
1.95
100.52
264.66
348.78
27.20
263.82
21.59
740.36
507.61
79.11
219.38
26.79
46.29
9.53
2.54
12.43
0.18
11.10
15.86
1.09
2.57
0.44
0.46
102.49
404.00
535.00
32.50
246.00
17.00
383.00
301.00
93.28
168.00
32.41
41.69
9.22
3.74
12.42
0.20
11.82
15.47
0.23
2.14
0.97
5.93
103.83
329.00
520.00
30.60
286.00
6.43
726.12
621.77
100.04
290.15
29.90
46.22
12.76
3.29
11.38
0.16
10.69
9.27
1.61
2.85
0.70
2.32
101.26
178.00
256.00
23.90
264.00
29.13
740.55
460.91
62.71
252.50
28.28
43.01
10.75
3.06
12.52
0.18
12.48
12.84
0.96
2.77
0.82
3.70
103.09
323.00
410.00
19.00
272.00
12.16
860.44
514.21
73.78
209.41
24.85
45.23
9.14
2.45
12.25
0.18
11.07
15.54
1.08
2.56
0.47
0.65
100.60
404.00
557.00
24.10
225.00
19.01
519.80
317.22
40.04
150.74
18.92
41.70
9.42
3.73
12.88
0.21
12.37
14.41
0.23
2.66
0.97
4.33
102.90
334.00
524.00
22.60
279.00
4.73
706.27
601.66
99.44
281.61
26.31
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
Table 2
Representative analyses of major and trace elements by XRF. REE, Th, Ta, Hf, Sc, U and Cs were analyzed by ICP-MS
36.93
70.41
34.85
8.16
2.73
7.61
5.90
1.04
2.34
0.31
47.57
88.99
41.64
9.65
3.11
8.12
6.12
1.06
2.43
0.31
40.77
77.11
38.49
8.60
2.81
7.49
5.57
0.95
2.15
0.27
1.73
0.25
4.73
3.55
2.29
8.33
3.57
1.10
66.00
0.70519
0.70503
0.51282
0.51272
1.70
1.49
0.24
0.22
5.34
4.61
4.50
3.47
3.78
5.59
10.21
9.11
4.87
3.81
1.57
1.21
57.00
72.00
0.70442
0.70428
0.51284
0.51275
48.49
90.03
42.78
9.81
3.16
8.49
6.12
1.05
2.45
0.30
1.18
1.69
0.24
5.30
4.38
4.49
10.32
5.59
1.58
56.00
47.08
89.20
43.39
9.67
3.20
8.55
6.36
1.06
2.43
0.30
1.69
0.23
5.52
4.86
3.46
10.44
4.81
1.64
69.00
45.91
84.47
40.22
9.24
2.97
8.20
5.84
0.98
2.20
0.27
1.12
1.47
0.21
4.95
4.60
2.45
9.62
5.71
1.62
72.50
47.51
88.16
42.28
9.76
3.12
8.60
6.23
1.05
2.32
0.29
1.19
1.56
0.22
5.23
4.75
4.59
10.04
5.89
1.71
67.00
57.51
107.03
52.46
12.25
3.97
10.53
7.69
1.32
2.84
0.34
1.49
1.83
0.25
6.92
5.82
2.23
12.51
7.10
1.58
74.00
0.70355
0.70345
0.51282
0.51274
57.13
107.72
51.50
11.62
3.61
9.98
6.89
1.16
2.64
0.33
1.36
1.76
0.25
6.84
6.46
4.06
12.31
7.65
2.19
73.00
41.61
79.56
38.99
9.22
2.99
8.27
6.28
1.09
2.57
0.33
1.19
1.83
0.27
6.11
3.91
4.04
9.19
5.64
1.51
64.00
46.95
86.61
41.32
9.52
3.04
8.45
5.98
1.01
2.29
0.28
1.16
1.53
0.21
5.22
4.55
4.94
9.91
5.40
1.55
69.00
26.60
51.32
26.77
6.69
2.20
6.07
4.52
0.77
1.76
0.22
0.85
1.21
0.17
3.99
2.58
2.78
6.15
2.89
0.82
73.00
57.26
107.15
51.70
11.49
3.62
9.66
6.42
1.05
2.37
0.29
1.26
1.53
0.21
7.02
6.46
3.77
12.39
6.65
1.92
71.00
Representative samples of diabasic dikes and gabbroic sills come from well cores and cuttings (see Fig. 3 for location). The Mg number was calculated assuming FeO/Fe2O3 = 0.33.
FeO* is total iron as FeO. Sr and Nd isotopic ratios of three samples were calculated using international standards [43]. 87 Sr/86 Sr (i) and 143 Nd/144 Nd (i) are age corrected isotopic
data for approximately 100 Ma.
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
La
Ce
Nd
Sm
Eu
Gd
Dy
Ho
Er
Tm
Tb
Yb
Lu
Hf
Ta
Pb
Pr
Th
U
Mg/Mg + Fe
87
Sr/86Sr
87
Sr/86Sr (i)
143
Nd/144Nd
143
Nd/144Nd (i)
677
678
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
4. Analytical procedures
The abundance of major and trace elements in the
alkaline magmas from the Cretaceous Oriente Basin
was determined from 12, well-preserved, core samples
(Table 2). The samples are dykes or shallow intrusive
sills that microscopically do not show significant
alteration to palagonite, if any.
A relatively high LOI of some samples, with values
of up to 8 wt.%, appears to demonstrate a certain
degree of alteration. Nonetheless, based on the Chemical Index of Weathering (CIW [44]), the Chemical
Index of Alteration (CIA [45]), and certain elemental
ratios such as Th/Ta, La/Ta, La/Nb or Ba/Zr besides
many others, lead to the conclusion that even samples
with high LOI do not shift out of the general scheme
demonstrated by samples with usually low LOI which
are considered to be fresh or unaltered of the same
sample set. In particular, CIW values of 2837 and
CIA values of 2736, fall within known fields of
unaltered Mesozoic Basalts [46].
Fig. 3 shows the location of these samples and their
characteristics are listed in Table 1. The distribution of
the OBB was determined by reflection seismic sections provided by the Ecuadorian National Oil Company (Petroproduccion). However, the thick overlying
Cenozoic section severely limits the amount of Cretaceous sedimentary outcrops in the Oriente Basin,
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
K/Ca
A)
679
240
210
102.41 2.37 Ma
150
36Ar / 40Ar
Age (Ma)
180
120
90
60
0.0020
0.0010
MSWD = 0.18
MSWD = 1.93
30
0.0000
0
0
B)
101.70 2.41 Ma
0.0030
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
0.000
90 100
0.008
0.016
0.024
0.032
K/Ca
0.40
0.30
0.20
0.10
0.00
0.0040
160
140
36Ar / 40Ar
Age (Ma)
120
100
80
93.02 3.42 Ma
60
40
20
MSWD = 0.50
10
20
30
40
50 60
70
80
90 100
0.008
0.016
0.024
0.032
0.0040
140
120
0.0030
36Ar / 40Ar
K/Ca
Age (Ma)
0.0010
0.0000
0.000
C)
0.0020
MSWD = 0.94
0
91.44 3.87 Ma
0.0030
100
80
60
82.15 1.99 Ma
40
0.0010
MSWD = 7.03
20
81.47 2.60 Ma
0.0020
MSWD = 0.00
0.0000
0
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90 100
0.000
0.010
0.020
0.030
0.040
39Ar / 40Ar
Fig. 5. Representative age and K/Ca spectra (left) and inverse isochron (right) plots for 40Ar39Ar incremental heating experiments, performed at
Oregon State University on diabasic dikes (Waponi-1 and Jivino-1) and a gabbroic sill (Yuralpa-1) in drilled, whole rock, core samples of the
OBB. The vertical range of horizontal boxes indicates the estimated analytical error (F 2j) for each step age. A plateau age (indicated) has been
determined from the weighted mean of contiguous, concordant step-ages. The 36Ar/40Ar vs. 39Ar/40Ar isotope correlation diagrams are
constructed from the step Ar-compositions measured. The isochron age (indicated) is calculated from the best-fitting line through collinear step
compositions. Tables 3a and 3b present full isotopic data for the new 40Ar/39Ar plateau and isochron ages from the Oriente Basin Basaltic
Volcanism (OBB). Analytical procedures are described in [47,50].
680
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
Table 3a
40
Ar39Ar incremental heating results for sills from the Oriente Basin (Ecuador)
36
Sample, material
Heating step
(8C)
550
0.00035
750
0.00121
950
0.00100
1150
0.00011
1250
0.00001
1300
0.00007
Weighted plateau age (steps
550
0.00783
750
0.00209
950
0.00315
1150
0.00055
1250
0.00031
1300
0.00016
1400
0.00026
Weighted plateau age (steps
550
0.00044
750
0.00167
950
0.00270
1150
0.00007
1250
0.00014
1300
0.00021
Weighted plateau age (steps
37
Ar
37
Ar
39
Ar
40
Ar
(r)
0.02881
0.07585
2.08924
0.95230
0.17775
5.18536
0.05468
0.21133
6.08387
0.07595
0.18560
5.21339
0.98607
0.16004
4.50298
0.57876
0.01561
0.30627
25): 82.15 F 1.99 MSWD: 7.03
0.02832
0.00501
0.20698
0.01204
0.00820
0.29889
0.01639
0.00862
0.34621
0.01382
0.00589
0.21375
0.04887
0.00673
0.24391
0.14883
0.00534
0.19296
0.65012
0.00769
0.27829
17): 93.02 F 3.42 MSWD: 0.94
0.03429
0.01956
0.79728
0.10707
0.09928
3.80170
0.14306
0.18253
6.97685
0.08652
0.15655
5.90993
0.12646
0.11576
4.39505
0.96509
0.08736
5.33395
25): 102.41F2.37 MSWD: 1.93
Age F 2s
(Ma)
%40
Ar (r)
%39
Ar
K/Ca
80.23 F 1.16
84.86 F 2.11
83.77 F 0.93
81.78 F 1.12
81.92 F 0.33
57.50 F 6.79
95.3
93.5
95.3
99.3
99.9
93.6
9.2
21.5
25.6
22.5
19.4
1.9
1.132
0.803
1.662
1.051
0.070
0.012
104.22 F 19.59
92.33 F 5.96
101.41 F 8.75
91.84 F 8.09
91.77 F 6.42
91.56 F 8.03
91.70 F 5.29
8.2
32.7
27.1
56.6
72.4
80.7
78.3
10.6
17.3
18.2
12.4
14.2
11.2
16.2
0.076
0.293
0.226
0.183
0.059
0.015
0.005
109.42 F 5.52
102.98 F 0.85
102.79 F 1.05
101.56 F 0.94
102.12 F 1.21
161.51 F1.74
86.0
88.5
89.7
99.7
99.0
98.9
3.0
15.0
27.6
23.7
17.5
13.2
0.245
0.399
0.549
0.778
0.394
0.039
Ar has been corrected for decay since irradiation. K/Ca ratios are determined from measured
39
Ar/ 37 Ar.
40
Ar (r) is radiogenic
40
Ar.
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
681
Table 3b
Summary of radiometric dating results for five samples from the Oriente Basin basalts
Sample, material
Total
2j
Plateau
fusion age error age
(Ma)
(Ma)
3.64
Pungarayacu,
231.7
whole rock
Yuralpa-1, whole rock 82.38
Waponi-1, whole rock 94.91
Jivino-1, whole rock
110.48
4.98
1.93
3.96
2.50
2j
N
error
None
developed
None
developed
82.15
1.99
93.02
3.42
102.41
2.37
MSWD Isochron
age
(Ma)
4/6 7.03
7/7 0.94
4/6 1.93
2j
MSWD
None
developed
None
developed
81.47
2.60 0.002
91.44
3.87 0.50
101.7
2.41 0.18
40
Ar/36Ar
initial
2j error J
0.001477
0.001402
469.0
299.8
328.8
166.9
4.86
28.8
0.001651
0.001440
0.001534
682
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
K2O+NaO (% wt)
OBB
e
lin
ka ite
l
A le
o
Th
MORB
1
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
SiO2 (wt%)
Fig. 6. Plot of Na2O + K2O vs. SiO2 of 13 samples from the OBB,
showing the divide between alkaline and tholeiitic basalts [51]. Midocean ridge basalt (MORB) composition from [51].
1000
DJGA16
DJGY1
P9BX16
ONI2
DJGA23
RBTW1
PUNGA
AFLD
P9BX39
Rock/MORB
100
10
0.1
1000
OBB
Antartica Pen.
Galapagos (OIB)
San Quintin
Patagonia (CAB)
Reventador (CALC-ALKALINE)
Rock/MORB
100
10
0.1
Rb Ba Th U Ta Nb K La Ce Sr Nd P Sm Zr Hf Eu Ti Tb Y Yb Lu
Fig. 7. MORB normalized incompatible trace element distribution from the Cretaceous OBB, showing (a) the restricted range in compositional
variation, and (b) a comparison of the OBB rocks (representative sample) with selected oceanic island basalt (OIB), calc-alkaline and continental
alkaline basalts (CAB). Data sources are shown in Tables 3a and 3b. MORB average data are taken from [53].
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
continental
magmatic arc
600
=20
/La
Ba
Ba/Ta
683
400
=10
Ba/La
OBB
200
OIB
MORB
0
4
30
20
10
La/Ta
Fig. 8. (a) Plot of Ba/Ta vs. La/Ta ratios (modified from [14])
showing the similarity between OBB magmas and ocean island
basalts (field labelled OIB). The field for Andean continental magmatic arcs is also shown [5].
Table 4
Selected incompatible-element ratios for basaltic rocks of the Cretaceous Oriente Basin and for basalts from several other tectonic settings
OBB
Subduction-related basalts
MORB OIB
HAB and CA
CAB
Mantle plume origin
Slab window
Roll-back
35.567.8
0.060.15
1.792.83
6.338.56
4.937.83
0.570.67
2.633.89
7.769.46
4060
4.716.86
6.518.35
147
0.21
5
157
30
1.86
31
1.8
1.2
216
0.35
7.5
214
13
7.14
29
2.7
3.5
12
0.01
0.1
4
1
0.97
27
2.9
0.7
44
57.560.08
0.1
0.1280.138 0.129
1.7
1.541.83
1.93
7
7.149.19
8.09
5
5.526.86
5.25
0.66
0.660.74
0.8056
4
4.55.37
4.194
7.3
9.647.807 10.34
24.6135.29
2.693.72
4.739.1 4.887.825 8.78
0.0380.119
0.3991.188
2.698.21
1.815.4
0.610.881
4.6577.66
5.4318.57
15.6744.978
2.6064.387
2.589.15
0.090.125
0.8771.43
4.736.14
7.168.52
1.223.47
5.8710.6
4.8110.46
10.9745.33
2.614.6
OBBOriente Basin basalts (Fig. 3). Subduction-related basalts: IATisland-arc tholeiite; HABhigh-alumina basalt; CAcalc-alkaline
basalt (data source: [54,57]). OIBocean island basalt. Data from the Galapagos Islands ([51,56] CABcontinental alkaline basalts; mantle
plume origin. Data from the Cameron line [58], San Quintin [4,55]; slab window-Antarctic Peninsula [8,9], Southern Patagonia [57]; RollbackJames Ross Island [11]).
684
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
685
686
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
plume model can explain the SSW migration of magmatism over time, as suggested by radiometric data
combined with biostratigraphy. However, the relatively small volume of volcanism generated by the
OBB magmatic event (50100 Km3) is not consistent
with this model.
Is it possible then that the OBB alkaline event is an
indicator of slab-window formation in the Ecuadorian
margin during Cretaceous times? The slab-window
Misahualli
Arc
TRIASSIC-MIDDLE JURASSIC
Allochthonous Plate
LATE JURASSIC
EARLY CRETACEOUS (130-120 Ma)
subduction is
abandoned
beginning of
Slab Roll-Back
Alkaline volcanism
Possible Slab
break-off ??
Slab Roll-Back
Tectonic
Inversion
Thin-Spot
(previous lithospheric thinning)
Asthenospheric
Migration
Fig. 9. Schematic model of the geodynamic origin and evolution of the intra-continental thin-spot along the Oriente Basin. (A) TriassicMiddle
Jurassic rift system and post rift back-arc basin associated with the Jurassic Misahualli arc [32]. (B) Collision of an allochthonous terrane (i.e.,
ChauchaArenillas) ([29,3134]) and cessation of the active subduction system ([29,30,60]). Beginning of slab roll-back. (C) Cretaceous (110
80 Ma), progressive slab roll-back and migration of unmodified asthenospheric material towards a region of previously thinned lithosphere
beneath the Central Corridor.
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
collisional event (~ 140120 Ma) [29,3134], subduction was merely blocked and abandoned along the
Ecuadorian margin. Therefore, the Cretaceous OBB
alkalic event is not likely to be related to slab-window
formation.
We propose that slab roll-back, associated with
asthenospheric migration towards areas of continental
weakness (previously thinned lithosphere), can
account for the characteristics described for the origin
of the Cretaceous intra-continental alkalic magmatism
in the Oriente Basin. Similar examples include the
cratonic Patagonia Plateau lavas [6] and basalts from
the James Ross IslandAntarctic Peninsula [9]. Fig. 9
illustrates this possible mechanism. After subduction
ceased (~ 140120 Ma), either the relict slab material,
corresponding to the eastwards-directed leading plate,
was simply rolled-back or detached and sunk as a
result of the large density contrast between the subducted part of the lithosphere and the surrounding
asthenospheric mantle. In both cases, this resulted in
lateral and vertical migration of unmodified asthenosphere, which moved into the region previously
occupied by subduction-modified mantle wedge. Consequently, considerable slab roll-back has occurred
since Early Cretaceous times and may have started
in the north allowing unmodified asthenospheric
material to upwell into the region underlying the
pre-existing TriassicJurassic paleo-rift or lithospheric pre-existing thin-spot [15]. This resulted in
partial melting and the subsequent input of magmatic
material into the northern part of the Oriente Basin.
Major tectonic inversion occurred during Upper Cretaceous times [20,27,60], reactivating pre-existing
extensional features within a dextral transpressive
strike-slip system. As a consequence of the lateral propagation of the transpressive inversion of the Triassic
Jurassic rift, magmatism migrated to the SSW along
the Central Wrenchfault Corridor during the Late
Cretaceous.
Pre-existing structures clearly excerted a fundamental control on the generation of alkalic magmas
during the evolution of the Cretaceous Oriente Basin,
and focused partial melting by facilitating asthenospheric upwelling. Eventually, the Cretaceous alkaline magmatic event was halted by the progressive
effects of east-dipping subduction that was renewed
further west in the Late Cretaceous after the accretion of allochthonous terranes currently exposed in
687
9. Conclusions
The Oriente Basin of Ecuador offers new evidence
of a Cretaceous intra-plate alkaline magmatic activity
associated with the evolution of the northwestern
margin of South America. The geochemical and isotopic compositions of these basaltic rocks are consistent with an asthenospheric source unmodified by
subduction, similar to an OIB-type mantle source. A
slab roll-back mechanism, associated with lateral and
vertical asthenospheric migration, is thought to have
facilitated the generation of alkalic magma when subduction was abandoned possibly after the accretion of
oceanic and continental allochthonous terranes
between the Late Jurassic and Early Cretaceous.
Pre-Cretaceous rift and back-arc extensional structures influenced the generation and location of magma
emplacement, by acting as pre-existing lithospheric
thin-spots, promoting asthenospheric upwelling and
partial melting. Cretaceous tectonic inversion in the
Oriente Basin resulted in the reactivation of extensional features within a dextral strike-slip transpressive system causing a southsouthwestward migration
of magmatism within the Upper Cretaceous section
following the trend of the Central Corridor. East-dipping subduction resumed in the Late Cretaceous and
placed the Oriente Basin into a compressional regime,
which resulted in a cessation of OBB magmatism.
Acknowledgments
We thank D. Geist, T. Toulkeridis, R. Fleming, D.
Quirk, M. Weber, R. Spikings and anonymous for
stimulating comments and informal reviews. We are
grateful to John Huard (Oregon State University) and
Bill White (Cornell University) for assistance in
40
Ar/39Ar radiometric dating and Sr and Nd isotopic
analyses, respectively. We thank the University Paul
Sabatier of Toulouse (France) and Petroproduccion,
especially Jorge Toro for valuable help and discussion. This research was supported by Kerr McGee Oil
688
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
[30]
[31]
[32]
[33]
[34]
[35]
[36]
[37]
[38]
[39]
[40]
[41]
[42]
[43]
Tectonic evolution of South America, 31st International Geological Congress, Rio de Janeiro, 2000, pp. 481 559.
J. Aspden, W. McCourt, M. Brook, Geometrical control of
subduction-related magmatism: the Mesozoic and Cenozoic
plutonic history of Western Colombia, J. Geol. Soc. (Lond.)
144 (1987) 893 905.
J. Aspden, M. Litherland, The geology and Mesozoic collisional history of the Cordillera Real, Ecuador, Tectonophysics
205 (1992) 187 204.
E. Jaillard, T. Sempere, P. Soler, G. Carlier, R. Marocco, The
role of thethys in the evolution of the Northern Andes between
late Permianand late Eocene times, In: A.E.M. Nairn (Ed.), The
Ocean Basins and Margins: The Thethys Ocean, vol. 8, Plenum
Press, New York, 1995.
M. Litherland, J. Aspden, R. Jemielita, The metamorphic belts
of Ecuador, Overseas Mem.-Br. Geol. Surv. 11 (1994) 147.
D. Bosh, P. Gabriele, H. Lapierre, J. Malfere, E. Jaillard,
Geodynamic of the raspas metamorphic complex (SW Ecuador): geochemical and isotopic constraints, Tectonophysics
345 (2002) 83 102.
R. Hoffsteter, Lexque stratgraphque nternational, amerique
latine-Ecuador, Congr. Geol. Int.-Comm. Stratigr., Fasc. 5a
(1956).
B. Faucher, R. Vernet, G. Bizon, J. Bizon, N. Grekoff, M. Lys,
J. Sigal, Sedimentary formations in Ecuador. A stratigraphic
and micropaleontological survey, Bureau Etudes Idust. Coop.,
BEICIP-IFP 3 (1971).
M. Lebrat, F. Megard, C. Dupuy, J. Dostal, Geochemistry and
tectonic setting of pre-collision Cretaceous and Paleogene
volcanic rocks of Ecuador, Geol. Soc. Amer. Bull. 99 (1987)
569 578.
R. Hughes, L. Pilatasig, Cretaceous and tertiary accretion in
the Cordillera Occidental of the Andes of Ecuador, Tectonophysics 345 (2002) 29 48.
R. Spikings, W. Winkler, D. Seward, R. Handler, Along-strike
variations in the thermal response of the continental Ecuadorian Andes to the collision with heterogeneous oceanic crust,
Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 186 (2001) 57 73.
H. Lapierre, D. Bosh, V. Duouis, M. Polve, R. Maury, J.
Hernandez, P. Monie, D. Yeghicheyan, E. Jaillard, M. Tardy,
B. Mercier de Lepinay, M. Mamberti, A. Desmet, F. Seller, F.
Senebrier, Multiple plume events in the genesis of the periCaribbean Cretaceous oceanic plateau province, J. Geophys.
Res. 105 (2000) 8403 8421.
H. Balkwill, G. Rodriguez, F. Paredes, J. Almeida, Northern
part of Oriente Basin, Ecuador: reflection seismic expression of
structures, in: A.J. Tankard, S.R. Suarez, H.J. Welsink (Eds.),
Petroleum Basins of South America, Memoir-American Association of Petroleum Geologists, vol. 62, 1995, pp. 559 571.
G. Walker, Basaltic-volcano systems, in: H. Prichard, T. Alabaster, N. Harris, C. Neary (Eds.), Magmatic Processes and
Plate Tectonics, Geological Society of America Special Publication, vol. 76, 1993, pp. 3 38.
W. White, J. Patchett, HfNdSr isotopes and incompatible
element abundances in island arcs: implications for magma
origins and crustal mantle evolution, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 67
(1984) 167 185.
689
[44] L. Harnois, The CIW index: a new chemical index of weathering, Sediment. Geol. 55 (1988) 319 322.
[45] H. Nesbitt, G. Young, Early Proterozoic climates and plate
motions inferred from major element chemistry of lutites,
Nature 299 (1982) 715 717.
[46] K. Condie, Chemical composition and evolution of the upper
continental crust: contrasting results from surface samples and
shales, Chem. Geol. 104 (1993) 1 37.
[47] R. Duncan, P. Hopper, J. Rehacek, J. Marsh, A. Duncan, The
timing and duration of the karoo igneous event, Southern
Gondwana, J. Geophys. Res. 102 (1997) 18,127 18,138.
[48] A.A.P. Koppers, ArAr CALC-software for Ar-40/Ar-39 age
calculations, Comput. Geosci. 28 (2002) 605 619.
[49] P.R. Renne, C.C. Swisher, A.L. Deino, D.B. Karner, T.L.
Owens, D.J. DePaolo, Intercalibration of standards, absolute
ages and uncertainties in 40Ar/39Ar dating, Chem. Geol. 145
(1998) 117 152.
[50] G. Dalrymple, E. Alexander, M. Lanphere, G. Kraker, Irradiation of samples for 40Ar39Ar dating using the geological
survey TRIGA reactor, Prof. Pap.-U. S. Geol. Surv. 1176
(1981) (55 pp.).
[51] R. Reynolds, D. Geist, Petrology of basalts from sierra negra
volcano, galapagos archipelago, J. Geophys. Res. 24 (1995)
24,537 24,553.
[52] M. Wilson, Geochemical signatures of oceanic and continental
basalts: a key to mantle dynamics? J. Geol. Soc. 150 (1993)
977 990.
[53] J. Sun, W. McDonough, Magmatism in the ocean basins, in:
A.D. Saunders, M.J. Norry (Eds.), Special Publication Geological Society of America, vol. 42, 1989, pp. 313 345.
[54] R. Shinjo, Petrochemistry and tectonic significance of the
emerged late Cenozoic basalts behind the Okinawa Troughs
Ryukyu arc system, J. Volcanol. Geotherm. Res. 80 (1998)
39 53.
[55] A. Saunders, G. Rogers, G. Marriner, D. Terrell, S. Verma,
Geochemistry of Cenozoic volcanic rocks, Baja California,
Mexico: implications for the petrogenesis of post-subduction
magmas, J. Volcanol. Geotherm. Res. 32 (1987) 223 245.
[56] D. Geist, T. Naumann, P. Larson, Evolution of Galapagos
magmas: mantle and crustal level fractionation without assimilation, J. Petrol. 39 (1998) 953 971.
[57] R. Barragan, P. Baby, Volcanogenic evidences of the north
Andean tectonic segmentation: volcanoes sumaco and el
reventador, Ecuadorian sub-Andean zone, 5th International
Symposium on Andean Geodynamics, Extended Abstract,
Toulouse, France, 2002, pp. 73 76.
[58] J. Fitton, H. Dunlop, The Cameroon line, West Africa, and its
bearing on the origin of oceanic and continental alkali basalt,
Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 72 (1985) 23 38.
[59] R. Ellam, Lithospheric thickness as a control on basalt geochemistry, Geology 20 (1992) 153 156.
[60] W. Gil, P. Baby, M. Paz, Continum tectonic during CretaceousPaleocene times in the north Peruvian foreland Basin
(Maranon basin), 3rd International Symposium on Andean
Geodynamics, Extended Abstract, Saint-Malo, France, 1996,
pp. 363 366.
[61] E. Jaillard, P. Soler, Cretaceous to early Paleogene tectonic
690
[62]
[63]
[64]
[65]
[66]
R. Barragan et al. / Earth and Planetary Science Letters 236 (2005) 670690
evolution of the northern Central Andes (0188 S) and
its relations to geodynamics, Tectonophysics 259 (1996)
41 53.
T. Feininger, M. Silberman, KAr geochronology of basement
rocks on the Northern Flank of the Huancabamba deflection,
Ecuador, Open-File Rep. (US. Geol. Surv.) (1982) 82 206.
J. Malfere, D. Bosch, H. Lapierre, E. Jaillard, R. Arculus, P.
Monie, The raspas metamorphic complex (Southern Ecuador):
remnant of a Late JurassicEarly Cretaceous accretionary
prism. Geochemical and isotopic constraints, 4th International
Symposium on Andean Geodynamics, Extended Abstract,
Gottingen, Germany, 1999, pp. 462 466.
P. Gabriele, M. Ballevre, E. Jaillard, J. Hernandez, Decompression at decreasing temperatures in eclogite-facies metapelites (El Oro metamorphic complex, SW-Ecuador): a record of
fast exhumation rates, 4th International Symposium on
Andean Geodynamics, Extended Abstract, Gottingen, Germany, 1999, pp. 245 248.
J. Aspden, W. McCourt, Mesozoic oceanic terrane in the
central Andes of Colombia, Geology 14 (1986) 415 418.
J. Toussaint, J. Restrepo, The Colombian Andes during Cre-
[67]
[68]
[69]
[70]