Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Presentation structure
Slide design
Why are most presentations so bad? Well, most people who give presentations have
not actually considered what is good practice in this field and most students have
had such poor examples presented to them by academics that they do not know any
better.
Many lessons come from the world of business which is now moving away from textrich slides full of bullet points to more visually interesting slides. Death by
PowerPoint is a byword (byphrase?) for any presentation that is so dominated by the
excess use of PowerPoint features (bullet points, animations, complex diagrams, clipart
etc) that the content is lost and the audience are brain dead by the end of it.
Presentation structure
Every presentation should flow like a good story. It should involve the audience
directly.
Design your slides so that these sections look distinctive and any key points stand
out.
Web: www.hull.ac.uk/skills
Email: skills@hull.ac.uk
This structure involves there being a clear distinction between "What is" (the position
before the presentation is seen and acted upon) and "What could be" (the position
after the presentation is seen and acted upon). The idea is that the audience is
introduced to the "What is" state at the beginning of the presentation and then
switched back and forth between "What could be" and "What is" several times before
ending in the "What could be" condition, which she calls "Reward: new bliss".
Nancy explains this better on her website found here:
http://www.duarte.com/books/resonate/sparkline-overview
In terms of academic work the "What is" is the current level of knowledge or previous
thinking on a subject and the "What could be" is the new knowledge or new thinking.
The "new bliss" is what the audience could do or learn next now that they are aware
of the change.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Slide design
There has been a lot of research and much written about what is a well designed,
effective slide. The main finding is that: A slide full of bullet points with a title
that makes no immediate point is a poor slide.
This is a very hard lesson for people creating academic presentations who feel that a
good slide has a simple title then a list of points about that title. Most students will only
ever see presentations where the majority of slides use that format and most will only
ever create presentations which use that slide format.
Ask yourself this question "Is PowerPoint the best way to transfer large amounts of
textual information? The answer is "No, that is what a book or a document is for".
People are very poor at reading and listening at the same time, which is what they
are asked to do when attending most PowerPoint presentations.
PowerPoint is a visual medium; its purpose is to help an audience visualise what the
speaker is saying. The purpose of a presentation should not be information transfer, it
should be about enabling understanding and encouraging further action or research.
This section offers information about what makes a well designed slide and links to
research that supports this finding. There are also links to books which will help you
find solutions on how an audience can visualise information.
1.
2.
3.
Know your material and ditch the notes when you can so you
connect better with your audience
There is no quick fix for learning your material, you just have to get your head
down and do it I'm afraid. Ideally, all you should need is a quick glance at the slide
(or some cue cards) and you should know what you want to say to explain your
point. Nervous and new presenters are clearly going to struggle with this - but
don't panic, use your notes to begin with and eventually you will grow in
confidence and be able to ditch them when you can. The worst case scenario is
that you could take 3 years getting to this point - but at least you will be fabulous
for your first job interview presentation!
4.
5.
Be yourself
If you are a natural performer - go for it. If you
are naturally reticent, keep it simple. The quote
on the image here is from Sir Ken Robinson, a
former government advisor on education who
champions supporting creativity in children. He
has given some of the most-watched
presentations at the renowned TED
conferences. He has a really simple presentation
style with little or no visuals but manages to
keep the audience hanging on his every word by making them feel he is just
having a chat.
Mayer, R.E. and Moreno, R. (2003) Nine ways to reduce cognitive load in multimedia
Learning. Educational Psychologist 38(1) 43-52. Available at
http://isites.harvard.edu/fs/docs/icb.topic448497.files/Stacie%20Articles/cognitiveload.pdf
Mayer R.E and Johnson, C.E. (2008) Revising the redundancy principle in multimedia
learning. Journal of Educational Psychology, 100(2). 380-386. Available online as an
eJournal via the University Library