Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
ExecutiveSummary
ConocoPhillipsisanintegratedoilandgascompanythatrecentlymergedtoformasuccessful
partnership.Thetwocompaniesconsolidatedin2002,andnowareaformidablecompetitorinthe
industry.ConocoPhillipsmaincompetitorsincludelargeoilproducerssuchas:ExxonMobil,BP,and
Chevron.Duetothelargeassetsneededtocompeteinthisindustry,ConocoPhillipsthreatofnew
competitionisveryminimal.Theoilandgasindustryisverycompetitivewiththecurrentcompanies
involved,andConocoPhillipsmustbeverycautiouswhenitcomestosettingpricesinthispricesensitive
industry.ThishighlysensitivepricemarketisthecauseofConocoPhillipstobecomeanintegratedoiland
gascompany.Byintegratingitsprocessfromstarttofinish,ConocoPhillipsisabletokeepproduction
costsdowntohelpachievegreaterprofitsintheend.
ConocoPhillipsmaintainsaratherconservativeaccountingpolicy.Duetotheheavyrelianceupon
assumptionsandestimationsintheenergyindustry,managershavetheabilitytofluffuptheirfinancial
statementstomakeitappearasifthecompanyisverysuccessful.ConocoPhillipsstaysawayfromthis,
andinsteadhasaveryflexibleaccountingpolicythatallowsforamorerationaljudgmentaboutthe
companyscurrentfinancialstanding.Alongwiththisconservativeaccountingstrategy,
ConocoPhillipsmaintainsaverytransparentdisclosurepolicy.Thistransparencyallowsanalyststocome
toamorehonestopinionaboutthecompanyscurrentvalue.
ConocoPhillipsdoesnotwithholdthenegativeinformationaboutthecompanyoranypotential
shortcomingsofthecompany.Thisopenhonestyshowsmanagementsconfidenceinthecompanyand
willingnesstochangewhatiswrongwithitself.Afterdoingfinancialratiosonthecompanyandother
companiesintheindustry,wewereabletoseehowConocoPhillipsmeasureduptoitscompetitorsinthe
integratedoilandgasbusiness.Duetothemergerofthetwocompanies,manyoftheratiosdonevaried
significantlythanwhatwasgoingonintheindustry.However,forthemostpartConocoPhillipsis
steadilyrecoveringsincethejoiningofthetwocompanies,andisnearorabovetheindustryaveragein
manycategories.Forexample,beforethemerger,thetwocompaniesstruggledwiththeirinventory
turnover,andthecompanieswerewellbelowtheindustryaverage.However,aftertheunionbetweenthe
two,ConocoPhillipshastakencontrolofitsinventoryproblemandisnowanindustryleaderinthis
category.AnotherfinancialaspectConocoPhillipshasbeenrecoveringfromafterthemergerisits
creditworthiness.Afterthemerger,
ConocoPhillipswasnearbankruptcyintermsofitsAltmanZ-score,butsincethenthecompanyhas
regaineditsworthiness.ItappearsthatwithtimeConocoPhillipswillbeabletorecoverfromthe
amalgamationofthetwocompanies.Aftercompilingfinancialdatafromthepastfiveyears,we
forecastedfinancialstatementsforthenexttenyears.Indoingso,wewereabletogetabetter
understandingofthepositionConocoPhillipswillbetenyearsfromnow.Weforecastedbaseduponthe
assumptionthatthecompanywillcontinuetogrowattherateithasbeen.Theaccuracyoftheseforecasts
wasoftheutmostimportancebecausethevaluationofthefirmisbasedupontheseforecasts.
Bycarefullyforecastingfuturefinancialstatements,wewerethenabletoanalyzeanddoavarietyof
valuationsonthesestatements.Afterthisanalysis,wecametothejudgmentthatthevalueof
ConocoPhillipsstockisundervaluedbythemarket.Allvaluationmethodsexceptforone,dividend
growthmethod,showedConocoPhillipstobesignificantlyundervalued.Thedividendgrowthmodelisa
verysensitivemodelthatisdependentuponveryaccurategrowthrateforecasts;therefore,webelievethat
ourothervaluationmethodsportrayamoreaccurateassessmentofthefirm.Theotherfourvaluation
methodsaveragedanestimatedvalueof$85.64pershare,whichiswellabovetheobservedpriceon
November1st2006of$60.30.Baseduponthesevaluationsandforecasts,webelievethat
ConocoPhillipsisconsiderablyundervalued;therefore,investorsshouldpurchaseConocoPhillipsstock.
BusinessandIndustryAnalysis
ConocoPhillipsisanintegratedenergycompanyheadquarteredinHouston,Texas,withoperationsinover
40countries.PhillipsPetroleumacquiredConocoInc.onAugust,302002toformConocoPhillips,both
PhillipsPetroleumandConocoInc.hasover100yearsofhistoryintheOilandGasindustry.
ConocoPhillipsoperatesinfourcoreactivities:petroleumexplorationandproduction,petroleumrefining
andmarketing,naturalgasgatheringandprocessing,andchemicalsandplasticsproduction.
ConocoPhillipsisthethirdlargestintegratedenergycompanyintheUnitedStates,basedonmarket
capitalization,andoilandgasprovedreservesandproduction.Theintegratedoilandgasindustryisa
$135billionindustrywithcompetitorsthatincludeExxonMobil,BP,andChevron.Withtherisingprices
ofcrudeoiloverthepastfewyearsandstrongdemandfromtheU.S.andChinamarkets,theindustryis
experiencingsustainedsuccess.ThissuccesshasenabledConocoPhillipstoexperiencesteadygrowthin
thesizeofthecompanyoverthepastfiveyears.Sincethemergerthecompanyhasincreaseditsassets
eachyearwhichhasledtoanexponentiallylargerincreaseinthetotalsalesforthecompany.This
increaseinsaleshassincecausedthestockpricetograduallyrisesincethecollaborationofthetwo
companies.ConocoPhillipscurrentlyhasamarketcapitalizationofaround$95billionwhichiswell
belowtheindustryaverage.
ComparisonData
From Companies' Financials
Income Statement and Balance Sheet
Ticker
PERIOD ENDING (Date)
Income Statement ($000)
Total Revenue
Cost of revenue
Gross Profit
Operating Expenses
Selling, general, and administrative
Depreciation, depletion, and
amortization
Others
Operating income or loss
XTO Energy
Chesapeak
e Energy
Devon
Energy
Apache
XTO
09/30/05
CHK
09/30/05
DVN
09/30/05
APA
09/30/05
Burlingto
n
Resourc
es
BR
09/30/05
2,341,812
2,914,311
7,523,000
5,482,571
5,215,000
115,518
39,640
206,000
152,460
176,000
466,272
656,275
1,647
1,055,583
975,000
547,300
1,212,722
2,218,396
7,315,353
4,274,528
4,064,000
1,212,722
110,559
1,102,163
403,392
936,377
155,623
780,754
284,977
3,490,000
428,000
3,062,000
1,102,000
3,083,214
90,160
2,993,054
1,157,546
21,000
2,873,000
210,000
2,663,000
907,000
698,771
495,777
1,960,000
1,835,508
1,756,000
698,771
495,777
1,960,000
1,835,508
1,756,000
698,771
495,777
1,960,000
1,835,508
1,756,000
12,275
98,879
638,879
66,185
816,218
-
127,102
1,164,607
51,857
1,343,566
256,432
1,095,000
791,000
1,516,000
177,000
3,579,000
918,000
8,106,590
10,677,424
18,722,000
Goodwill
Other assets
Deferred long-term asset charges
213,362
199,245
-
88,207
-
5,729,000
395,000
-
Total assets
9,335,415
12,365,629
29,343,000
96,684
1,359,619
198,436
131,866
1,786,605
15,745,48
5
189,252
131,755
17,853,09
7
2,816,000
1,292,000
159,000
309,000
4,576,000
11,950,00
0
1,093,000
239,000
17,858,00
0
673,431
329,563
312
1,003,306
3,229,585
255,563
1,262,939
5,751,393
1,084,722
957,756
2,042,478
4,329,948
127,755
1,659,128
8,159,309
1,851,000
1,227,000
3,078,000
6,765,000
363,000
5,193,000
15,399,000
1,570,750
320,734
251,780
2,143,264
2,405,359
1,059,294
2,532,329
8,140,246
1,274,000
830,000
12,000
2,116,000
3,893,000
957,000
2,861,000
9,827,000
3,647
1,884,729
1,047,367
3,494
686,426
1,000
45,000
5,543,000
98,387
210,116
5,763,081
Treasury stock
(35,532)
(26,091)
(567,000)
(89,971)
Capital surplus
Other stockholders' equity
Total stockholders' equity
Total liabilities and stockholders'
equity
1,851,604
(120,426)
3,584,022
3,071,255
(576,131)
4,206,320
7,645,000
1,277,000
13,944,000
9,335,415
12,365,629
29,343,000
4,170,164
(438,926)
9,712,851
17,853,09
7
5,000
5,816,000
(2,824,00
0)
3,996,000
1,038,000
8,031,000
17,858,00
0
Liabilities
Current Liabilities
Accounts payable
Short/Current long-term debt
Other current liabilities
Total current liabilities
Long-term debt
Other liabilities
Deferred long-term liability charges
Total Liabilities
Stockholders' Equity
Preferred stock
Common stock
Retained earnings
363,000
34.86
344,000
38.25
444,000
68.64
Market Capitalization
12,654,180
13,158,000
30,476,160
329,000
75.22
24,747,38
0
183,000
378,000
76.94
29,083,32
0
Recommendations
Thisissue(DidCOPpaytoomuch?)receivedalotofdiscussionatthetimeoftheacquisition.After
studentscompletetheanalysis,theymayconcludethatCOPpaidtoomuchforBR.Theactual
acquisitionrepresentsavaluationofBRequivalentto$92.86persharebasedonCOP'sclosingpriceon
12-9-2005,thelastunaffecteddayoftradingpriortotheacquisitionannouncement.Asshowninthe
calculations,onlythevaluationofXTO($93.18basedontheEBITDAmultiple)justifiessuchaprice.
However,allanalysesaspresenteduse2004year-endvalue.Itisimportanttonotethatsomeanalysts
forecastedEBITDAandEBITDAXgrowthratesof25-30%forBRin2005.Whiletheacquisitionprice
of$92.86stilllookshigh,itcanbejustified.Furthermore,therearesynergiestotheacquisition.COP
hasastatedgoalofincreasingitsupstreamportfolio.Also,COPhastheweakestexplorationportfolio
amongthelargestintegratedfirms,andneedstoboostitsinventory.Inthisacquisition,COPistargeting
NorthAmericannaturalgasreserve.
References
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/868809/000119312505216982/d10q.htm
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/895126/000119312505213104/d10q.htm
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1090012/000095013405020387/d29899e10vq.htm
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/6769/000095012905010772/h29394e10vq.txt
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/6769/000095012905010772/h29394e10vq.txt