Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 28



   

!"# $ % &')(*+&,-.


(/01 23!465

798;:<8=7?>A@"BDCAEGFIHKJ LNM8;:<8&OBDP
QR>AHSQR>AT LUWV.XYOD8Z[CA\=QRP]^;>AJ
_3`Sabced=f

g-b.heb=ikjGl-m._-nNjW_-nikjW_emGob-nNpSqGmRc3hW_/r_es3t
uvxwyvxz|{Nvx}2~ LWee

.)k

A<ky)x)%
KK)KSy<SS&%-<y-%%"SS%*%
x3"%yy%KxK?x|yy[k)yRS)[I'S%Sy
kSSSS)SK-k=%S6K%I)")W)-6N-))
S2xS
*2*k)AI*%GW)S6"
-))

.  (/

 I

1.(D!

)%6W3k)kKN3<KAGe3KkKW%3K&k%[K?6e%%[3k6%3%K3K3GeG
6162SekKW1G%3%3e"&yIkKk%eKAK)/GkKG"3k3G%xG/3%33KK333
%36%KY33K3K%kK%<KK)KK36133K%W3)%%S%G33K
yKk)633&GGeG%R)%336/GKK"1W1363%13Ke%033K
3K<%3|3)K6k)kK3<K)3K=e%%K)K)%-3%%-K321)
DkkK3K/G%)3G|%136%eG%
-3%?k1K63K)3K
W%K
6.3%S=2)Kk=)21K*D-I3%3kK%K<2y3%3)3K36-k=31&K
)%K3k3%
/G%S6)3%;2S66D//-k%%kK*%KA&k
K%
G%
Ge3KkK
W% <21K6K)
 

 

&% %'
  
 !"# $
Gk
%GkG3k)KKk)K

"KG|3




)
(




*


+
)
(





.

0
/


)
(




1

2

)
(


)

3

'
%

.


4
3k.%13GGkGk3e% 6--33&5NK=3+$, 6)k65K)7GK=1k2I&e3&G&3K 
 98  
 !;: -</>=@?BADCFEHGI=J?KAML>E
&GS66 61/<33eGP &

&% O N 

Q Q
Q S

 Q -</>=WVXADC'EHGI=WV6AMLYE
Q
 R
&% OZ 
 !UT
[&\ ]_^a` b cedgfhb ij`k`ml_nFnKcjdmogp$qh^OrsnBiedmotXuvog]_p w)xFy{z|d}ierXo|~)xe'ijr_qtXuvog]_p#w#xFy{z|d}iero| Mjj'
H nFdgp&a^a^arBiedmu{pdg`m^acr{b ij`n'dgp&`mp&rXogp$q"ieoog]Fp xXmxx x'lFpd|p&`mp&iedg}]McjrFWpHdgp&r_&pcjrxXomdgl_ogl'dgp$q"ieomdg^a&p&`&
clFJq'pd$_l_rFpMl_u$j'
~#p&n'o}iedmogp&rXo ceOpomdg^a$ijierBqsMcn_l'ogpdkr_^arFp&pdg^ar_'xsj'_|^a&p)|r_^a6pdg`m^ouX clF`ogcrB\pH_ie`|jH}&
~#p&n_iedmogp&rXo ceMcnFlFo}ieog^acjrBijijr_q n_n_a^ap$qsieog]_pvieog^a&`&Bx1$eFBk^a&p) rF^a6pdg`m^ouX|cl_`ogcjr_\pFij`|jXg$j6X
%

Gk



1)<3&GG3Kk%=21%

/333e|kK& 
K3<Gk6e/ KS
KGkK/33R
We% 1Kk%kG K
6
S6 e
  3%kK%R
/33e6%3GG
KK
 6
S6/K1  %;k1

&GkIk/K
kGe3=&1)<2kG%-3K33K%

!#"%$#&')(*!,+.-0/213-547698:/9+ K1
(;"<1=81=->?4%1=!@4BA6*C>9D3(*!,+.-0/213-547698:/9+
G[63Y3% 33)K) GB5kK%2E=KK36%2F?eG%HG/%316I)Se336% -JF?WK
K NKZL .3)[%G32K)kkkKKKNM [3kGe3e% )K3K)%[<K&Gk
3%&3[3
O k3/|%K3KGk1<3P
O k1&|K1k)KK/G%G%336% eG%
K1KG%1<W?)31kG|G%3)1%K31KkK*I<K3kk%[%%eG%
)%336%33WG%
&K@K %,
Q K)SR 33)%G K NUTV1L K1GWe G1YX k)G1%R 33)%G
K NZ[L K NKNUL ]\ G%11%[?1W%kRK"K3%33KG%1)KSk%<3%kK1
K1 3eG|3312 333e kK%^&
G %6%S 3))%%)) 3Kk%GG<%
61G%63kDk%^
_ eG1K63U` %6 kGe33%-1k)kKDG%KKk3[K3 eG%
)%336 Kba L K ZUL K T[L K L K L K a L K N a L K L3f 63%WG%-k"%)G K N L 1KIk%31%
%
%
%.c %Bd %
%.e
d
K1K1%336%<eG% K L 7GK%6%SGKke*<3*K1k K GZ N L
.
%
g
%
g
M )G%|)3 G31%G KKe%<K +h4B8i7!jDj- AV8?13kmln4B!@47C8>9!jop+.k;-0-0/ K3
!jAVAql9i7!,AVr sM K%Gk)KIK)KK161G3KAk%. 3K31K1%)ut K.wv
S
IYIGk% K1Kk)K333K3 3%kxK1@yx KeKy0
z K%kGe3
1eGkK.133K33%kK1K1361G3KGK{
O k%-k GKGk3K3
%S3G 1K%kGW12kK |1%%S%k
|K 6ux I&3%K3 W3kkK {
O k%-
KKK)3%xG"G%*GGK
KGkK3)%kK*1K11%K/GK1Kek)K".133kN%%3
11=G=
SBK} %

PK
k5 kGeY=KSe336% Kba L 2M %36213G
%=3)K.k)%=K3.yKkGe3kGWk)K%|61GG%336%<KGk/33e%KK36%
W%
/G1k&*KK3 ~k%K/y&k
R&k&33K1%G{ 3GG
)/1)&/GkKK%[13%GW 5
[kGW1&&1)[2)%%?G%
0z
eG1%-G%-K.%-3GkGe32)kWkD%
&G3<1K
G1k&GkKK%|6)?KAG)%33kK%[KKK)331%<[)
3W3KkKW%=Ky eGk)616eK;
\63k1G&|% W=<13W3%3%
KG%%336?kGe3kGK366e|63Gk3k



  
.%    -!)K 

 ) +* . "S /  K S   k / y S-!x#"%$' ,&  %.S*!K)x =.* D*=**=*=*=**D*=*=**=*=*D** () ) K) I ) Y+* R.)KW)A0I/ ySKWIS%))Wy3Ky)21.3D/ =5*4 *=*SD*S&=****==**==**==****DD**==**==****==**==**DD**** -6
)) )) 7) I//IKK%%11S26WKky1%%S6%KA% =* D) *S=* *==**==**==****DD**==**==****==**==**DD**** 86
)) )) -6 AS6K%:. %-xkS%%AS)S6KS%k****==**DD**==****==**==**==****DD**==**==****==**==**DD**** ;9
< S7 +* . "S #  1D %K-   )E x %=>K)K?*  *@= *=*A D  *B *=*=*=**=*D*=**=*=*=**D*=*=**=*=*D** CF
7SS7 7) ""SS//A%KGYK=*=***==**==**DD****==**==**==****==**DD**==****==**==**==****DD**==**==****==**==**DD****G*FH
S7 S7 +* "#1D SE y"%yI, SyI))x% **=*=*=**D*=*=**=*=*D**G*H
7S 7S ) "/AK3yI,.)D)yky=**=*=*=**D*=*=**=*=*D**G*J*
S7 - ;2SK3%SID %SK)E yK *D*=**=*=*=**D*=*=**=*=*D**G*J*
S7 6 "S#A
7S 8 S7 S8 S+*)L k%yS)%y yK=M ,k%O/.N )S)x/KyK%*y2D**%**===***===***===******===***DDD***===******===***===***===******DDD***===***===******===***===***DDD******GGG***7))
S7 S8 ) ) =*D**=*=*=**=*D*=**=*=*=**D*=*=**=*=*D**G*K7S 8S 7 PKk%.S/yKy2*=*=*=**=*D*=**=*=*=**D*=*=**=*=*D**G* 6
( --+* Q KS   SG
R   )*
=* * = *T= B *- D ** = *=*=**=*D*=**=*=*=**D*=*=**=*=*D**G*U8
-- )WV KSKK[=*=**=*=*D**=*=*=**=*D*=**=*=*=**D*=*=**=*=*D**G*A9
-- 7 
---- -6 XPP G%%.RWK6ZeY )SV y*D[*N K=KK*K=)*****===***===***DDD******===***===***===******===***DDD***===******===***===***===******DDD***===***===******===***===***DDD******GG )**FFH
-- 8 1D k"- V K]S\ )=*D**=*=*=**=*D*=**=*=*=**D*=*=**=*=*D** ) *
^`_ a - 6   bS
K   c bSdQe =
?
UWf   b.
  
(
g 1$ & ih +
)* j %36%K+KE K)k'ml X y12%?c4 k V1)GK/S)ky
%2"Ok%\S%y"S3*1 =bK4*=S*%n
=P*K*K=6*)V D&*==****==**==S\ **)==*****)DD**-==**2==W**** ==%**-2==**DDS****G *A69
-76 ucjAL vx)Kwzyky S%.A*K=%A)%=x1KS=S1p%W-qo2S"D%S.Oy1 bK)4 %"SK)SIK)Kr r st
%=S*{"D1 S?*O"4 =)1*b4"*y=*KS=)*%=e"*%*.D)S*/|=1S*4S=S**K%=G* =KK**DD******GG )**F;H
89 uc1 bvx;4 wz}y1 S%4~.uTvx=w&y x=Sx)WS)SD%-.yS*=K1-S*)y"K"%)."%*.SKKK)==**==****==**==**DD**** ))J)*
;F ucj vxKwzyyS%.A=%A%x1S=1%W-2SD%S.Oy1bK4"KSK)K
%S{"1S?O4")1 b4 ySkK
)KK")%|1 S4:kP K+YW-6A*=*)&D**** )) -7
* *bH* uu vxvxwzwzyy %%..==xxSSWWSSDD%%..OO11bb44KKSS))%%SS{{11??"44"))yyKK))""%%.S%P WW6%) ==**DD**** )) 86
** 7) ju vxKwzyy S%.A=%A%x1S=1%W-2SD%S.Oy1 bK4 "KSK)K
%S{"1 S?O"4 )1 b"4 y)K-)"W%V K 1 S)4 V yK-\ )DS\ *)* )) ;9
Z

 )(D) 

)

,W R
',W(*"# 

#



 "! #%$'&)(*,+-(/.01(3245.67.0&8:9:.6;*<


K%
A ))eU; 0z  /G{.G%<K/y&X
 -</ ?GL 1>= 5 eP
@,?
1>

 CBDFEHGJIKD  3 MLNIPOPOPO5I ?
 -</ ?GL I
Gk
ML RQSOPOPOQ RQ ZeG 5 eP
U
1 "K1 #LF  GPN0t.3. K  |/G
633DKN3KGKK3? K6%
B  ML'TUOPOPO   BVB G <
W E Ze YXZ L[X6TOPOPZeO<XL 1 ER
E <W
)2G|]\6" ^- 5 Ke
<KK .)%%6K%KR?)33
3?
%/G3LG

`_Ra
`_ A Lh
K@K cbe7"3KKeG0z1336%*?V
K-)K&GUK<K 


#L$MLdX)LG ;T7TeX)T G ,OPOPOj;_e'_eX)_ G
R 1K)33e3K1% =K=X" K%  - / ?GL &)K@  Rb f  fhgeIkh
3ji
- / ?GL &|)K@ki  jl eb 33<3/G1NF5 3K)KGkFm  on i *3 ~k%

69-58i7-1 #q $:AU6*1=C/94Pres Ci7+Nt#r;u3v A:t!,i74PrdwN8l*>9DMxzyk947C13!jo !,k*k9iU8Z{nC1=!@47C8?> C> 476n- N >n8iU1,|~} t


y-|Y^0K
 a0 Le Y^e6V^WUP/)]K ,n i T'  L  |3 ,te3]%1163i |
|
VXA
G
-k
.hV W.VX
KA 5 <Y^e[[
SSeU;V '3i
G #L$MLdX LG ;T7TX T G ,OPOPOe V  V X V G
vK{!13kmo;- xo|Z8 > !,k*k*i7Z8 {nC13!,47C8> /3DK/13%GkGW"3%3%6
K
)G& 1 G) y&1)kKAG&1KG%
F R*M GA1K K3&3
Kk)y3RRhZKNMZ >NZ[Z
W%KKe%K)% |W%.3W3 
Tc kK%IKNK)K7")kWGNZ[Z G3KG%IKR3YNF53%13K)%
)I613% k*G1.kN)-&53K3)G331KK33;1 G) Kf GIG3RKG%GK5)13e G


y5K)Gk*33)%G&KkKW)1K/GK3K.33eKSDK=)K@
Z Z ZZ
)G<
Q K633K)K%316KD|)K, 33eKS   g  %' 63%I I% %I
p

 g

K&3K)3KKK

*,.0($ ++k;$C.(<$ 9 *<&) >:95.6;*<


&Gk)3. k%-=%eK/31eG<3 0zG33e9K/3W3KkKe%%[/G1
%y 3)~k%*G1. k)%S/31K)G%%

Q&1G%/e%
XD

kGW1

1

N3%&e%
K,K%W5 GK)13%G

E=KK36%33k
eG1=.k)G1
Q&k$kGe 1

)*K)KK

% z1K%33e<kGe3

M11k93D5G%e%W3&31GkG3K } A1X XAKk)GKK3K


%6;M <GG%/kK2IkK[K 21K
K331K)36G)K/G)%3*6K%.13G
K%Gk)K%~  KD3 e )3G&5
F ) W ?GkK)%! e G&933GkG1KK=K@K%IGK) 31%G_5
 %%%<kGW1/33)%G|W1KK36%<)31k<K3<33)%G|W)G3

k31)7"3KKeGGk k3W<1K%<<%6 ZW =1K%<G<


z <3k%S==%K
c
T

Approximation of CLOWN
100

50

50

100
150
singular values

10

30

Exact image: k = 200

200

7"3 %  
R 33e|K3kK

"]13-547698:/9+
3Gk=G2G33%=W% G%6).%W
# $ () 
eI$ $ fk
  K
eL0
# T' OPOPO
 L -</#?G 
26%6KR313KIK3GKR3IW%<Y
\ 61GGG3KG3%6
#q q 

iU8jk -5i yiB4U6n8Dj8>9!jo' -0AV81=k;8j+7C 4UC|8?>

y'

K1<)33k2Gk%33G2?Gy K/GG3*KG%*G%k

 CBDFE G B D E G I 


V V V
&G<G13%G% W3U`%6G<1K6K3G%-GG1KSk)G3
K%6KKG6%6KI11GK 
&-3G31%G
KIG
 / 1B *V  $1 %  3
- / %3V

kKK%<<Ytk@;
1K
#6 K$
36%|KGk&2%-3  


 CB G () B eI$ $
V
V
&-3D333kI6kK|K)331kSGK)3K13W3KkK1e% kK&kK6%-3kKeG
1%33K1K6K XD$=K13=kGe<K31k3=SKW3GGK9X I

kK G
K %K% L 

!,k*k9iU8Z{nC1=!@47C8?> 8 WoC>n-0!,ip+hr+h4B-13+
3Gk=G&3<
6N36
K
#q q

yk947C13!jo




  L  T  
  T    
     

OPOPO
OPOPO
OP OPO



 " !
4 A cn$# ! 4 A 

MIIK)3%1I)K,

 l
 @

W&3I%W3K%SI&G&)3KKG K)K DkDk)%X

,

,

 

M/*D%#eG<3&|1*kK

 



, 
      eI 3k   a Gk

 
.)%%/651K6%K~%?G%GK%<W
&% O N  

 
 {  WHn   L Iv - /#?G?;IhIj G -</#?
 

&3/36k65e% .f -3&G%K%SKG%K
 WKK
lT



 33G231&3)
K3?1

, , 
Q KDk/)K@.N.
u
/G3K1% &3%/Gy =31%G 0-|K@K%Kk)K 0
|G1NF5 3316%<GK)<A/3W% 5 GkKk2-k3k|K"3=3K1% =K3K31%G
3G%e% G%6%W
-?e%0KyIk616eK Q
3k
Gk Q /3


 

a

33K1% K
SB}K%
Y^e <
6K

7 )DIGK3 I31G%K3|6K6/K3|G%36%%=3)6kk=KGD5~kk))G3

KG%/&<KKkk33<S* ~kk)

 

ML' kQ ;TK cQOPOPO`Q  ? ka Z


&G%kK%G
K6m0 KeP
KsU
K1 K=Ge% 
 8   : K1 #L  <
6

  mEI3e3G&5 F) -K  &5 A33)%3kxKS31%GK-!KGKG%6%)
3%GK%W
L


)36G%RGK)K, lI )1%X

n
TQ  VXA L 
&G-3% &3))%&Gk3kYe^ 6< } 6W
I
SB}K%
K1
\

S^ ;^@0^
U <
6m3%e

K
^-;h Y^G2I k)eMW%.5 GkKkk)/Dkh KGk31%GK-  Q
 /G

 

 



 

WG%3K/KUO)KK1Ik

96 -58i7-1 #q /9!1 B!j>u iU8 u i7-C>I


"J| ^G6}K|
e3/k1
.}K
1  Q \D
   ^SP^
^
U <
Kk#3%e
K
K;
@2Y^e2IkKW.0 #LF  n  Q ) L   |
VXA
/G|.yK<%32G1K6S-G1&5|e%KI%; M 3kK|G<36k65|K@K%
Kk)K/Se336%KDkK6%|-G6S-G1&5K,K %K.kK&G{ G%K=X 
f K
  6 

eZ "&Gk)
G13%.1K*Ge%

kn IH I
Ra
1  , 
3kK*kK G K L
d g
# q q  yk947C13!jo !j>9/J+Bl9(;8kn47C1=!jo !,k9k*iU8 {nC1=!@47C8> C>I4U6n- r >98ji1
M"G)3"31AKs 1{t .%K
K1.%K
13%GK-"K#F MF 23W5G13kx3W531G  G%
6-WG3&5DK3?36k65W%kK?.%%?3GK)KkDK . D/33K1%*W3X
K%e% GDkh<
 33)%GK- eG
p

%$

#"

+ 

/.

"

. 10.

&

('

'

")"

!*

3254

(,

G



f
 XV A L 
n  G

&3=/Kk6G%|WGG63)16

f76 l   
V

NW %'

Q 6 


  


Q )3)93.   
Q 3K2GK)
K% 63)16 0
0

n
6$5
 t
U P
K;K>A/Gy&G%1*G3k

%K3K 51Khf"3kK  Q kK%9K


6

69-58i7-1 #q  %  Q s
ht
t
U 
KK \Y^G
 
Sk  |6kkht)1330 t 766
  {K
| 5
| | ^es6
S6
6  Q \{ ^0
| }5
%u 
Sk2e p
.[Y^G.k,

| ^W |
6

eY^ek  \  L  ) 6   L  A   n  Q  |


VXA
VXA
<81=k*ln4B!@4UC|8?> &GK@K%DG3xKG%K K%- ON IkK61G%-W3D
N13Gy%-33RH 1A3%13k73K6--33&5IW &%% k k.
3e%K)KK3X
     G   G  Z I  G       G   Z
NWON 
M/kK3&<1 K g gL 
$  ) $  
NWOZ 
&G6KKW.K/K3KN33eKSk3|G*NF5GK)KG), e;936 K
X
Q f N

 VXA L f  n 
 VXA L ,OPOPO_ ? 
NWbT 
G %kK/1G  3K) K  xG3 K, 3[K%33KGK3?%-3%36 %3K
&
KKk)3K%K3, PNF53136%GK)K=G,x KG;Gk
I3K%M 
$s

 6 1 + , - kn
K

(,
.IH# .I10 .
-</ GGk - 2 4 ,  7GKGkK=G%G%/Ikk/K GI c d g L
# q q " k*k9iUZ8 {nC1=!@47C8?> (#rI(*!jo!j>9AV-5/J4Bil9>9AV!@4UC|8?>
R G%&e%  [1K6K) &kK%
PK
)"G2G3*K
3D|K)KK3 NWON  
%W3KRK13K3Kg

   D  3 MLNIPOPOPONI 
NW e
?
M*G)1=G/3/kKk))%K)31K3<K1k)x1W% kK<)K3K)%|1KK36%<K) W|%K3
KIK)3KGK Q
Nk 
K3!
Gk
K3
G3kK3 yIk)KG3



h



H
B
B


#
"
"
B
"
G
G
)6%/)%%6K%KcRk&K
B G " %$ D'& G .G33*KGG%6.) 0z  K B G " R$G
KK3kG|)K1K
&K)KK3%W3K

 D)*( $ G BK1 L  D 6 -*( & KG 3" G K


RkG  KA1KKK@1K 6%%
1
&Gk)
G3KG%kp
X )
D
1DKLNIRD-TX
DKL.- / VKGV
DcT
63K)K3e%)6%X

 

+, HL L HLT VL -.


>T L >
 TT
3L k
 T

 T

&Gk

HL Lv-</ VGV IhVL-</ VGL Is3L-</ CGV

NW c

Q 
L L HL 1*%336%<KGk&e% K3KG%<W
P
K)<e
K;3I&3*e%

 8 H3
1KGG3 ) L K-k%: 3Kk%X 13%k)K%NK3 GKk)K33 NWbT



33*K/<K@K%W5 3K) 31%GR
&Ge%

#q q

$C>nD?l9o!,i -5i747l9i7(*!@47C8>

"

k9k*iU8 {nC1=!@47C8>

R k%%%13%GkGeSAG&B5kK% 0 KeP
KAGke%
K;31%GR9MIA1K%
G1KK16%<K 3%%-%?KKD/W3kGk NW G:feG)%336%|K)GkW3%*K%<W
Q  R  Q


c 

L Ln H
 LTX T T L >T L V
 Ln H
 LTX T T L  T
 8 H3
L
 Ln k
 T6 T T >T L
! n k

 T6 T T L  T :
! T
Q

NW dK

RKG3K1)KSk%?3Kk%*K/KG33e|WKK36%<)13kG)1%
 )(D) 


 '!(D.#)+

K%<3%W%  1K6K)
ON ")K3k336
L   !
&

%

_s

{

:W n


6e1K33%<4NK3%Sk)%*13K%?.S
|G66KGK


-

 

  

 k
  )L  0T6 T   ,OPOPO
&G
2kK%361/KY \2kh%316%<K)GkW%  Q K

&% O Z  1)1/G
KG%-, *6WK3<KG6K)%3332  )K1k&316< 1K*GK)

 

  k Q   Q L   Q T  T  Q  ,OPOPO
Gk6kK-1k*K"%- /G% 

 Q 6I%I N IPOPOPO:I

K   wM
@3KG%-kK% 3
K
K
%6  f=G|6K%33G<3K1%
eGy&K
6 
 =
.
1K }
 
.}
K;,f*GGK/33K%!kK339 K % L
K TVLY MKK-KWGGKR3%3K1%IkK|1%%-%W3k)kK1K3{Ok%-
=%K- %K3KIG 
e U K3 3e6%3G%k 7GK)1)
eGy&K

-  R33K1%
 K%[-%K3&K
3
KK

K;
"16e
K;3Nk2K G K NL K Z7L R W3kkK{ Ok%-G/

K3{ ~k&k K L

%U  R3e6%3G)%k) 7GK61G%63*kIk%[%-&)1GK3
G/%6%-KGk)3Kk%%GkD% Sk)%%S3GK33U `%6 kGe3e KeG%
K % ZL3W 5
)%3368
e MW%k|/Gk%K3G< K3%?p
X"K

 e
K3{ ~k X z>


-=)3KNSk). K L1K3?1k%%[33K:
R)G1 K a L
%.c
%
/G
X;z 13K)96WG3kk963G%69kDk%G 33ek) K3{ ~k1W6%)K3


kKI%-3G%)13WG%k&GI3W 5-R)3KS-k233KG ~k%NG3K
_Wk3WK9 G3G K N c L3)eG%S*3GKN3)K1k=336*%%6%|%WG%3k%
K12G%16DK3K%31K36%33eK1G=)K3k336yKk&1K%WG%36KGKK
/G%
%33WG%3%K3yK%?Kk< %6KK
X;z 3K&% `yK%61Gk)3k6%)[k)k3&3
11k1k G&3K/-kK3kK%% 1?13%GKG)K3k336&
Kk)9 K)GkeG%k Q&kKk3%%k
Gk)|GK)6G2[K33KG%k M91k1%"36
3kGe3ekKA 3G)KN3 Ok3%1)KK3k)K333%2%G)k1%Kk%
3kK%K%33%&DK .G/GK1KR%)3*6Gk W%631K1G2)3KNSk).kGe
)%-3%%%6K-k-k R=3%%-k3GKKYKG%Y3e6%K3 )%%
K 5GW.%k k<W33k%
M K % a L1K1k)%%31K@ R&)33W33K"G%6).%R/G*31K0 R)G3-kGW33D
k1) R)G3-3e6%%%KG*K
3D)%K)312G1K6KK3G=KGkAK
G=K1k1311K6
K1G%63)36DKKWG*3U `%6 G&IKGKK3K? R)G3eKAk%A/G/1K)AkDK3
32%136% W3%G3%3GK%Gk)K ~k%3KK1k/%GG/GG333e6%

G%3%[kK%3)KG33e3Kk%K=GeG%; %-KKNG)%336%
WG%")%336%3Gk%:
Kkk1G|G%%G)%kNK3 G% 6e1K33% WG13KmR&)333e6%%
3k3G&Gk GK)
/G&KKIK)3kK13%G3)K.k)%AGKRKK36%
33kAGk%%31K)G% K Ne N K N LeIK 23%61U `%6%K)K13II
N13Gy
%
% e
%W31 NWO N K1Ky )K@ |33e3=3e%2
)KK3k
M<3 %-3 %I.kekGH K3{ ~k&K3 R&)33.3e6%3G%%* \&K)kWk G636k3K
1k%)GG
7GKk3GkK 0M 1 Kk)3/&.3k1%

3 &(+0( &);$0


Q K OZ [l  I1)
K%YG)kK g
e% K
ON \?kh 1 





'
%

&

%

Q
Q
1G 1<N 
K K[

k6 
 L  K K3 Q       L  Q K &% Q  9G% 
<



Q I   %I<OPOPO I N =\<&K13K 1% y&G3D56SK%- 3K/1 &e% 5
 
 
3kKk
KK.f&3"NK3{~kK6K)~%YW3k)kK*K1KW)-e336%Y1G3.k%-kK
)3%-k"
7 )kG3S %6 U
Sk2) 3K3G
^
S62)
G{.G% 
,
,
+ 
 ,   .  - / , G? I  s OPOPO  , L - / ?G ,
,
,

L
 , 
e%633KGDG{33   K@K%N)eK1/1X


+ )L

0T

  , 0 T

,

OPOPO
OP OPO

.
, A L  h
I 

+ 0T

  ,

OPOPO
OP OPO

,A L .
, A T 


, A L OPOPO 0T ,  L
, A L , A T OPOPO 0T ,
My&3  K3    |/G K{ KX231GkG
3k
  Ze #%IP, OPOPO5I 3, D, 613, G, $K, 6K)~%?K V 
V  "FB

" dI  Ze  l  B dI  Ze a  1K3 "s dIRB dI ={GG21X







  " L K 3

V




%)KGGy&G3)K.k)%*G 
1 K3
8 i7/*-0i +hr+.4B-01 Q 1*3 3{G%<K* y&
X 
 3%
Q
 

 

Q
I  





VB

 K 1-G  3)U`%6R/G

 

Q
 I  
 

e.;

| 

3

ZW %'

iU-5/ml9AV-5/

ZWON 

69-58i7-1 Mq  
 Q
US!A.
S[
K^e{N 


kk W6Y^ek   Q |K
. -

K
Q Q
W{2\Y^e2e3  |
 I G
26L
 "@ ($3+0( &);$0
RDG N K1{~kDkKKWD&33k)K&3WR)G33K6K) ~%&323D56SK%-3K.1R-&1)
N3 k%-R 3133KKGK1%22-1k)kK-K3KeR3kKK R
k  K Us OPOPO  ? L  L
?

p

 - / ?G? - / ? /3% 







Z Z PO OPO Z
% Z OPOPO Z

  
 L 
T


  &Gk  Z % PO OPO Z nn
?
?
 Z Z
PO OPO % n  ? L
K1
B Gk :Wn.)
  ? L ? L "OPOPO}  L I 
/3 { 63kK/63
61GG
3 G K6K)~%?K  ?






? E B

Gk
*KGKK1KRK3
/G3k=)K33%mM*&*1

L 3&1)
E
B

4
E
B

4
E
B


E

E
B
B
?G[
 B B L R 1%&3  E  E fN36 B B L )33k)KG3%K3  G1.k
%%-kGS"y&3 DyGk %6.6 K
/G1 6 33K.3%13W%3 5k
R)G3.K6K) ~% 



K E L E     K E L  K E L   ( G
V RVGV63V k&%V %SkGRK3G633K
V 561
V ?K z<
Gk |211KG
f

K E L 3( yW3KKGGK)K 1K=%' K/G21K6K3G%V6|V WGN1) 613=K
?
V G/%kK1
 f13)U` %6 kKK)G%[GG K6K)~%?K 
2

G3k=)KG3
L
ZWOZ 
V B  E I E - / ?GV I EHGPE3<W V I B

&G)3)<-6N U6  Q /Gy G{G%<K&&


Q
Q
Q
  
G 
I  
G  I  

ZWbT 
p 69-58i7-1 Mq  Q %
^e{ 
K K

kkP Q    #3%IPOPOPO:I | eY^G6K   Q | %6.6
\k 
 Q |
e . \ 2L |
-13!ji:t:+ !#" Q32.kKKk)3Gk%3% 961G 
 Q 3)G@N K3{~kKR&)33D T  
  Kk)1Gk%G%KGKGkkGW1k/G3e6%3G6
KK3 3%
}[t )%
ek

31k1I%-1%|K/K3%)K6K~%3K3xyKSKk))3k
(;" )/1KKN K3{~k =3%e*G<NGk   ZeGK/ % f  f  A&G)%%G1*kK
)% Ut
e^
2kGe3kYR)G113)%W=Gy&| GW%*GK*3%K31)K@?fW1=33%3D%D)%-G%-K
A"  Q %3333)%G<G<3%-3%36 9%K
 9&%16<G<%KG5 kK%9
)3PkK-k;G/%%GA
 )6e1K3)3/13|KGk/%WG%3k%kA&3*%K3/
?

% U
/;"  Q %GK.*KSkK%k A1KYG&%%GMI ;k{
63K# K3{~kK3sR&)33;


V V




 %#1(M /.0*,

Mq #q  p 6n- !j>nA V8j+ !joDj8jiC|476*1hxNiU-5A5lniU+BC &- C13kmo-01=->?4B!@47C8>
C &-> A 3)1  -</ ?G? Ij G -</ ? >9/  E I -</ ?GV (7I - / ? K3







 E3E   ( G Ih G    G  G I Gk
  GjEI>EHGV  <W I Gj(  Z I>EHV G{ Z
V


Gk

G%GK%&G

 

13=K%6K

! !>nA"q8j+s!o|D8jiC|47691

p 8r+BC/*V -5/
2

-</ VGV 31)<3

/G1U`%63
/ ? A

 

G{.G%<KK%W


G E

% L       
XZL 
   L  L
NWhG7 K  3%IPOPOPO:I

L    g{ L
 G  L

1k

  K
G  X
b 
  3X n X n  X
 A L   b G 
 A L 



b
X A L  A L  A L
&Gy&G)%311G


V6A L X XV A L 2 VG

 G

V 

 V

VG

   n
G

G F
A L
 


A L

L 

b

VXA L VXA L 2 VG

K3

E V  YXZL X6T%OPOPOFX V 


V 

  V 
 





o oo

VXA L g  I
Mq #q p 6n- " iU>98o/mC!joDj8jiC|476*1hxNiU-5A5lniU+BC &- C13kmo-01=->?4B!@47C8>
C &-> A 3)1  -</ ?G? Ij G -</ ? >9/ 
E - / ?GV ( -</ ? 3K1



Gk

69-

"



Gk
 E 
 E  ( 25VG I &
E G E I>E G E <W V I E G ( 

* yGk  k6)6 K)<I/G3U`%6

iU>98o/mC!joDj8iUC|476*1

% XZL  
( L 
NWhG7 K 



 b

V -



VXA L HI{ V G -

-</ VGV 33<3

3{G%<K=K%W

 L  T%OPOPO  V  "&3k
 E V E V V 


f  L  ,X LG 
f

nX L  L #E L 
 YXZL f  L    L

   
 

 KXZL

N
3%I I OPOPOH I n %
( X A L 


Q
E A L  E X A L   2 G

 
 3X A L -  E G L 2 ( A
L   n E A LQ -! A
LA  



-13!ji::t + !#" R k (  KX n E - .G)%33K.K"GNR)G11W6%)kYMkK<G|3&
K1*%33K*1~k%mM*G)3/G/3 %K[k - *)3%? 3/G 3K)
Ze
(
E



G
K1 3&3k"
KX 31& (  ]WVn E E 3X
(; " 
M E  G K/X ek)3
G%$# *)3K3K;GK3 GG R)G3KKK)363kG%=&<GHK3{~k

KKK)3<

6.6;$ @
"  ($K#$ F#&( *,.0($
&G[636k1K;k{
65 MG KG
K3{~k|K3 R&)33*K6K)~%1=K|S)W316%YW
eK%3% K N d L MKKKkk k 31%G[KAG%%?kKA3kk%?%K%-xK3%kK
&%

'J*,+&/.0/9,0;:.6

6GK1KGG%K%-KG%*33%K

%K%

NK%&e333
NK%/%K1)

XKKGkK)%K1

Nk  3%K2%K%-xK3%&<3k/3K51KGK3K3?k/G13%GK-
K3K3%G3NK3{~kK
R)G 3;S3KK%K%SKGG)-=3K51KGK"N%3&1I1SL =KS%%K%-KGG)%336%
KGke%!K1KG%2G g5 9k
3U`%6%-[K g
5 2K)Gk


E

E
0

(
2 G

n
'
%

L
L
L
L
W% K/k7")k36GG Gv5K6K~%K
L 
  L  L 
L n WL 
 E L  E L L  ( L 25LG  L &3k E L E L  L I L 
 LG L  L
\Gy)33kGK%13[6-K@g n0% 633.f.k
3%GKG21)3kKRG5
L  L
)|K
36-K3G3%K33Rg
/K3613k
n %
L

Sk
.)YS^ V 
^
K4g n%  G.%  >
Y^
p 69-58i7-1 Mq  6<Ye^ N
SKH%kt 
L
|

60 p L      W n   E L> E L
 W.0^
0 - 
|Ye^ 2J
?
L
L
L L  ( 2 LG L

 













&31W6%)2kK)k.%%%3KGk3-=KS%%K%-x KG%  %  G )%336%K)Gk




W%/G36I1%K1%K3*=1/GK)3K%-&2GGKk/6GK6<K6G%R

 @7.01(  691('! .0( $

"

&G?)3KW_W^F?k3W 9K%GkK~k%Kk)KGK33) R)G3&K3 K3{~k|kGe3k


K%[Ge3KkKAW%
"[kK/-k- 
"K39K-kKk"G G3K
_W RKK)3 3e336%ID %136%KGkDW% D 1DLPIPOPGOP%O:I Q %SDK D  LPIPOPOPO:I ;A/G
)%336%?W% &3K&3)K-k%[1K3?3V K1KRkK&313*6Gk F?K)kKkG2%%6
KISk).-/&1)Gkk)G%/G%316%[eG%3KKKG% 3)W6%K3 3K
G%|G/WG3k/1G)KK1<kK%

 ++0(M#& 32 .0%&)0("M0#*<*,#

&G[31K)W3%/%316Y3)K.%Y% %% 3[k%% 31K R)G3


13K)[GkK%K%< K a Lf1KGG?/*GK&%S)3GkGe*%3=GK%GkKRk
%
K
_ey3U `%6kGe3k]
MK %G31K%Y. =ju  66 k,
K;?3%K K
]   V
e[  k,
K;@ DG3K1%'&3)KI%3*=DK eG3I N13Gy%-13
k1)%K3G%31eG3%3kGW1G)%336%%-33k
61%36KGkK1GK2
6k)K3GIk)|1KkGG%3I33K|.k% %%6%*G|3e%
)KK13K[k%[xK1KN
e362GkGe[K61K3)eG%G2%)K@ 
33)%G3
3e% KK3/&<61G1k)K&33RWD2KG%K3K?K<33)%G
G1KK16%|%336R
K%  K
O N & g   % G|kU N K

"
i
- / ?G? GGG2y&G
eWK%k/%-1  &% 
i
i
Z
ZW

 {

e 

c 

G&%kKDG<G{ 3KG|%K)39K3K1k1K)KK3 NWON  /3%339kDk%


3%GkKKK3&X
i T 
ZW
%N

F[KkyKk%3%K%SKG%/Ki
i 
,

%W3K3GD5~kkK@K%G1=xK3%=KYM
2 4

, {32 4 , 0 N %

n   L ." n8n   L

 *1

0

71GGk)KKR3kK3 T GK)0KI3W(%, K% -  T  i  %G5 eP


3{DKi GK
Kk<13K3 ikKD%R33)%G%<W<* )K@|)I&GkkKG
G%=k33&KG%GkK&ji 3G%=)K@ 31%G|*
V
 T
*  i V   VXA L i $


"

&Gp
R33)%G E=KK36%^
F[kGW Kba L/K%3
WWK%k W3K3K %336%K)3kK
KK36%e%k)K%&G3/61G331.K)Gk/1KK36%|%K~% NW

' -0+.AViCkn47C8?>J8 4769- +.8oln47C8>


\2G kG)|33GK"G =j K 66k,
K; WZ e  M=I%:W3&|33i
i
i
Z

.


W
W

Z
Z
Z
Z

nh  
W   
W  
n 
&3=GKK%3-i kK613%331U` %6?kGe 
Mq#q 

c 

&G<

  E`E TL # I E   EE;TL


DGD5 G3%SG%
#
#9
L
T
L
T
T

E


{

H

E
[

E
h
n

E


E
Q
 nh 3&Gk) # E;T # E T  L A/Gk)kK3G<X
E#LeE T  L
&G%)K@
33)%G[ji &)%%3
*t
= S))eU;3RRk E  K E E L - / T ?GV

3G%?I23%K
f

3&3k

K3KK3KL ;G T G GG 3)G3
E
3
E


W
E
>
L


B

L
;
E
h
T


B
T

B
L

B
T
G
G
G
K1 T
T <V W YR3G3  KWA%K32y&A3 E T 3K3eK@<G&%K%-KG%IK

3k3GGV K# M&&3&G%0z Ki kK?6e3%%?KKi

 BL   "B T G =61 G
3%)K@
13%G?ji9Dk&[G3  5 k G%6.) 


E#LPIeE`T{- / ?G? E`T
3.)K,
Z

{
nh
Gk
K)GKK3Km
E
E L G E L E T G E T
3)<1%
 1E L E T  L { 1E#L


E L
E`T 

M E T
<W L Y#
Q
E T   #
i


Nk

 V  

&GkkK

 E#L {HE;T  E L
nhE T  E T
 I %   V   &%  I%   V   &%  I % 
 1E L V {" 1E`T V ; 1 E#L
nh 1E T V ; 1 E T




#
#

 /G%

 6 
 6 

G
#

V
V

 B L V V k .
 " B T V V   B L V V  # V  m V
nB T G V HB T V V  V # V
Gk
#
\-1*K3K<3k)%)]WeK%k%-1
B L G m V  ZK1 # V 
G
V
V
V
B L G V  i V  i V  {1B T V  Z

%Z

&3=1%DGkK&%-3

 i V  i V  { nh i n i V  n i n i V 

Gk

 VXA L  XV A L 

V CB L V  V  V B T G

G%)K,
13%GKI36K)KK8i9V &G/KGKSk 766G G{G%
Ky&X |kG 0z KG<6KKKji
 BDFE G DK3G<%2K@ 33)%GK-
i
A&G%  Q =K%<-

V CB V D V E V G

Q  R  Q


Q


98 E V HG E E V
T
V

E G
V :

ZW dK

k %[%%Kk)3KkGeK=G{33||)%336%K)3keG%
Gy&GG4Rk i Q  G
%)K@
31%Gji9 1G1K%K%-xK33%6[K i Q
Gk

$ V ! V G &
/G%<K[33e%1KK36%e% =K3KG%K
V

$ <W V
VG V

Q  R  Q


G $
G
ZW g
 V $ V V V V :
&GKGKSKK"3/kGW?&3<&)kk)%<K SB}K%
H

%5 |32%WG%;1*3


 8

613%K
"1KK16%%316%[e%k
|K6u2&GG&6GG1KK16%?%K~%[K
33NK)3kW% 1)kRK1G% )31kGGWGkKG1%%S[KD3KKK)3
)3yW3%<<%6<ZW OZ0fK3kK/kK<33< Kba L
73KK.DK) Gc G]
F MF kKKN
G&%kK3 ZW 3KG{ .G%[13%3
g
e
 &%16KI
111*kGe<s
F M F W%kGI3e6k%W%2%33GGW%  e%   &3<3K
3KK)3k%3/W3K3K1ek)B 



  98 




+,
:

 G

|


-.

G 

ZW 

I G

G)
&
/ekK3*G%[3
%kD/G
 G  1f 63%WG  % - //i  kK%& Gk  i
)%K33Gk Kk%KAk%G0K G% 3 
 G6
T










|





KKK|K


 f3K&GkK/k Kba L


+h4B8k9kmC>nD AViC|4B-5iC8>
Mq#q
R 6 5 %6K31DW[&G 53K)
"

KGG|{;,
@

Q
Q Q
Q
 _){,n0 5WHn ,
  E V 5WVn   L  . n 5WHn   L E V G n :Wn 
QK61=k)%)|{;,
3~kk E G  B E  Ze 33k
V
V








5WHn  E :Wn%E G E*  L E G  5WVn  EVE G :Wn E E G   L 

R13/D)1KGK1K*3 E G  K W ZULfk/|3=1K
V

L L  LT Iv    L Is  B3L kT


   K
 TL K
 TT 
 T 
%

&G%|3/K*6W1%|%6%

 L
nhKT LF :W V n 
 L L  L  V
GK VE" n :Wn%E G E L E G n :Wn 3L K W n 5WHn HL L L LT LA%36


 B   L 3L kT -n 
W
L HLT 
V

L

3

L

W


n
5WHn


L

L

L

 T
>
nh>T LF 5W V n HL L  
M21K6K) D 3K


+,

 

HH


 

 

HH

  

 



-.

 

- />= T VXAM?KEHGI= T VXAM?KE

&G1k=3*G%33Ke%*G%)6)%W|K   3)K.k*3K) 
G&G
B

Fh FK[GkKk N f3&3%33KRe%0KGG&1KK-GG&K3?G1G%3K
kK%K3613%
616G|K3<Gk)kK2 53K) 

B

8 74 6n- +.8oln47C8>
&Gy&G-KKS K kk?1h7")k.D2KG _e R)G3R%W3)%&%kK

Mq#q 

<8?13kmln4B!@47C8>

G2K%6K 1K3%63eK|k)KG%%%GSK6K1W5%e3|KKK3 KKkGk*&



1k%)G&3%K%

I E G E3<W`I E G  Z
% HWGK G 3)U`%6%^WeK%k%W33 -[1K6K3961G30z K=G
nh E3E # 

 & {HE  & #

K 4I I L 

&.

NW AX U`%6/-G1K6K"G)K%/G1=xK3%
 I%  

&%
E E V
V 


 
#


"


I
%
 G  #  V
V


#
V G
&% I 

V 
V
V
ZW K%6&G3U`%6% WeK%k&%-3?|GKk1K6K
m   GNE
#
V V hE V V G G4G  V
WK  G $ $ # G  n
m
TG R` K%6K1<3U`%6X
K EI HL  - K E I $ L 
#

n 1E G E V

n3WhEVE G E
-13!,iJt YM&G3)%%<3&G%-13/ % DK3 WZ K
 .V# E
E L  E L  I   Z G m #
L
L
 Z

n
E`T 
E`T 
n G   @T    @T  

)K%-MG RHF M1k%)% R)G31k3W ;Q-Kk)3D%W3%
DkKk&6-Kk$5


K%16%|Kk6%k)%[&<G)3)%6*K6K) ~%

 






%.e


(D)   # (/+ &R#!

M3D%6I31GKKK)3D%-G%K3k%-D3W3KkK1e%A236G)K
WG%3131G2WG%3G%/)K1kW3%;G 1Kk&eG%;3kK%|.%K W3%;3K35
K&GkDK  k%W
\ )%33632K)3kKIW 3%/&? 6
L xK3KK % % Z  165HN
)G&3K)GkKDGe%k  N
f GW32.kK=GGk g f K3 31Gk f K3 GKGkKI)%336%
W% %?
F KkyKk%"GGK)Kk~ % T K@K %G3KG%KD%K)eG%
Gk16%7G"NF5
K1 NF5R<N[K ?.kk61)kDk%93e%k" 7"G) Z|DK[G %KGkKk
)%336
V WK%kKk)K36 [/11 33&Gy 33K)GkkK%136%9K
3<K% ? k)K36K<3DkG<kGK K( DG|%KkGe% 933)%GK M kK|k%
7"3"Z|3KG?KW3%K3 e%k)K16KG%3K Z Z L G133GeG%A
33G%333eKIGG3GK63=%kP kK%RG% k)K36xKGGkkG%
3%336%eG%
6k%[K"KI3kGe3k6G6k3G)3KY
_ ekGe/GK)GkK
3%316%?eG%NK1?G2%K%-xK31K6%%S61k%K3[G2KGk1K3<G
3K
_ )WykGWRGG3K*)GW3Sk).|S&K3|G-kKk &3)GkkG%


3-32k/K"%-&G%k*-k

W)36GK:F?eG%
ED133][
F W3%
&%H?
F eG%
X Kk
K
% D
E %K


N

dZ

Tg
a
% NZd
ZU% T g
Z[Z

ED3kIK)<7"k %

g
Z

Z
N%

N%
%

%
%

Z d%
e
% NZ
Z%

11N/3W%/3%K&61)G3W3%%336?KKK)3

M%K)G1%6.%D*3) 13%6)DG*W% K3G%31G*KKK)3k&GIy&G


W 3K-%D1K%%K<kKK G)K%D)G3IxKG&KG%-3%36%3KG33K3

)%336%<K)3keG%k GKW3K-<K&G26K%33GkKW%k G-WW3*1K



KNG31K3%336%K)3k=W%k;
F?K)kKk%33%K
K1
GKKGkK*e%=
T
3% e36KK36%|%316<K3<33)%G1KK36%|, )%336|33)%GK-=Iks

KU 6G
)KK=K3GeG%A6G6k3=GG%DWG%SD3 K33&)%3:
`3KIGKkIKDG
kK%k

% 

.6 &Z.0  >*,( $;

&3DeG%KN6G%- G3Kk)W6e33 KRG MSk33K:W1K6 WRYM=3KN Z


%

d
%kM ZG1G=K3<
ZG1GkI/G%K/KGk%/3xG/ Z

Z
/G
n %K% %
3K)K ~k% K@ K%AG3xKG%KGW%G
7G{
NF5e%
\33e G e%
 %336%9W3%KIKGk*
Z 
R)G1K18
NK3{ ~k2KKK)1
d G36Ge%!N F MFGs
3K31%R/G<)%3K-%336% K)3ke%)G& 1G
TB5e Rk% 3]
1GK
KI)%336% eG%2IK -1D%;&G% ekA%%kKG|G%G<Dk%-3%3k%k)D%
13%G%R 7"3%
TB59Gy&GK%33xKG
 
KDG%-3%36[)%3KI3kK
W%kW
G3K*
_eGW%k%6;
`K GyIkK33Gk)%-G%1k%k E=GKGeGk)
% %WG%36?kK%k3KG1G%kKK13GK/3.%kK123%%6K-k
\ ]_p  &cedmdgp&`mnKcr_qF^ar_hogci!vcjd}q'pd)dgp$qFlF&p$q`u'`ogp&^a`^a6p&r1tXuog]_pd}iog^ac#" b]_pHdgp%$ ierBq&$  iedgpog]_p>Oidgp&`o
"
(
ijrBq  ' Oiedgp`o `m^ar_jl_Oied|jijal_p#ceDog]_p)`u'`ogp& dgp&`mnKp&og^a6p&uX
(
* y_ced|cnBidg^a`mcr'b p)rFcjdgvieO^)&( p#og]Fp)]_^a]Fp&`ok#ier_f6p&x^OrFlFJid+M* ieOlFp#cjp&ij}]s`u'`ogp&ogcsj

st

%.c

10

10

10

10

10

Building

10
Structural

10

10

Cd Plyaer
8

10

10

10

10

10

10

Beam

12

12

10

10
Butterworth

14

14

10

10
Heat

16

16

10

10

18

10

butterworth

18

50

100

150

200

10

250

20

40

60



 

80

100

120



"!$#&%('()+*,"-./'0!213#$-4/5!$768"!$5'91:;:<=?>A@'(8B
C)C'0!DCE:5B3BF'(FGHFBF@+I!JB'0KDL!M"N'()POQ'9"R"-Q)P13BF5LSB5!

C)C'(!UTV<=OQ>
EH5CB3B'0G:/3B@PIQ!JB'09DCO5#$!$)C#$-4QDWHXYN!M[Z'((\

 cc  `fi"j= "c ^ `  fhk3l h


b ^ `
]_^ a`QbcK acd` ^ b  `  2b ^e  bS"f ]  ^hg "
^ g c ]  g Mm g  b ^ ` n bl2+ VcS8"o,ph a`  j   ] 80b 2 V 
 ]V]  ^"q e  b ^ `r acKbl2 s ^ 0cSbdt ^ uj ^ s
 `frl l28dt"v 2"` g "c"o
w x
  j Pyzj= acSbcKbl2 "j  b {C"|}i~
 `f}i ` ^  e c
n


n


t

b
2
l


8

0


0


c
c

c
S
b



c
S
c
8

"


`
U
t

b

2
l


V
m


2



C




b

`
H
j


j
{

c

b
2
l


V
l




2
l
"

S
c

b
8

0


0

8
c
o


`
c af80 a`2  ^ bl

^
^
e
^e
^
^
^
^
}

blP"j  b a{C}
wul2` n v  acb

bl

] j ^ bc
 V
] ]  "
^ q e  `Qbc

bl

^ 0  a`o

U

` ^  e

JCy8

&?8 |

 `C"j

J?8 

xJC8

a`2o
H8b8o

 j  ` g "f

 b8o

` ^  e
~

 n j ^ {

x8 |

yJC8

28

xJyCy8

x j Py,"j  b {C ^ 

^  e

cdt ^ 

bS0 g b 2  j

^ f2"j

  j  ` g "f0"f g b ^ ` acbl  "


 cSb8o
` ^  e c8 ^ ` ^  e c  `fbl2sul ^ j +t"v 2"` g n   `CC

n



 jaj
A
t

b
2
l



t


=
j
j
0

2
f
8



`

f

b
2
l
u

0

"


f

"

f
0

2
f
8

K

c

c
S
b

c
0




c
l
u
s
`
i
a

m


2





/

,
o


b




b
l
b
^
^
g
^
e
^
^
g
 f28 e^ f2"j{C8 n s"jaj qhg  ] bt ^ K
   b ^ `  j_  n j ^ {sul g lif28{  bS"c   ^ `f
e  b g lblt jaj ^ 0

r,3F3V

f "j ^ t P V
ajaf a`
bl ^ cK`2C"ja"c,` {C80c0 b n ^ c ] b  j  su abl+ ^Q^ (c,  g lrl  {h a`2zyPf8C8"c
e^ 2
^ tt8"f ^e `  e "j n f ac ] j  g  e "`bc a`  `ff  g b ^ `c8  `f ^ b  b ^ `Aouu"` g sl  {Cz?i{  0 x j "cusu bl
bl t ^ jaj ^ su a`b n ]  ^ t
cS g[^ `f ^ 0f28ufV M80"`b  j"v  b ^ `f2"c g 0  a`2
bl2+f n `  e g c ^ t
bl2+c n cSbS e 
wul ac =cbl2

A A
sl28

H

acKblP a` ] b8o

2oa 

g  `

 

cSb  bS[3c ]  g t ^  e

] 2b a`Qb ^

S

,
S

H 

n

2oa 
f[m` a`2

U?

?xd?H&[(S_J:?H?(Y0h?:(7A/
0C9?/?K/(0h?:M?(37/

k/n vs tolerance
1

build
butter
beam
CD
heat
struct

0.9

0.8

0.7

k/n

0.6

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.2

0.1

0
18
10

16

10

14

10

12

10

10

10

10
tolerance

10

10

10

10


  
  
 
 !
"#%$ '( )
"*" )#! ,+&
+/.
01 ) 324"'*
56#7* 
'** 8#9
: ;2<"
"#9=#6
: ?>@'*A!"") =# * ?BCDFE
G@HJIK # ! LMA 3@:""'* 3N<OQPSRUTWVVVXT/Y[Z
#\
: ;"*] (^_DFE
G`ObaB C DFE
G`Odcfe*gDFE
G@H
h : K'

* !ij'*]! 2<"k :'J") lnmL # o'A'
# K#]# o')# " *]Hp"q
: ' !rk24] L
: K]_"
"'* '*(*"<
: ;24=# 
56/r'q: 'q
_])A s _*"\tKuvxwuzy{RT| C H h : ;@:"'* #\*" @# ! 35 = 'q)   ! 
"@ ('*5'
* 2}"~")  kRH h : ?=
 '*'
#  J 3 `;"~
: 3~[
s # !5o
'*]_"# '* K"~
: 3
 ! 9") 
'
5'** 2# "~q
: 6 

"'
5'** 26' 
9'
:"MK##{> 
' w#8
'
]f !
 5H\# ! <
: 4 !rk]# ')"#1"~q
:
*@# '*~F K~ # !
"#{4DG(
"# ?OQW
'

'# # '

 
 ! ,'*5k'** 24'?~F"?K)#"= # # !"'LfMA
26 6 '* 6"~A
: o'
: ~[* { )')"#"~q
: '* ojMA"2< 
: " ' M
:4ORH h : 4 !_ !"~(): "7"'
=#<' ,"M
~F
s # !5<]_"#7#9_ "'

 8#<> 
3iDK)#" # 9# !"'A
'
#6 
54""8] ]
"r24#7
'J~F"

: "M~F
s7 # !5\)# G@H h : '
2< z'~["?)
"# ;
5k"\2< 
: " 'K'MA LM
:?OR @:"'* #'
"# ("~
: =#n* 
]_"
"#]_"#7
'H0d: #4!"2<]
4*"?d'
42< 
:"k 'L
: 24"2< #n
'J24
): =#2< 
:"k '
) 2 @:8_ ** #9
: "MX~[
s # !5o)# HJ?2<"#<
: k?U'* \24 
:"'L'
# =A]_ 

 

"#9# 
# ! )   !
"#24 
:"' 
o
: 6_ '*~F"z
: o"M~F
s # !51# ::~F
s # !5{)# o
'*]_ !
 5H
0: #M 1!"# ') 6
: M: " ,~F
s # !5)# LK# =## d'
#6]_ 

)
"#
{"'* 8*"
:
"@# `24" H8qz#* @24' "~() 
 68 
)"#")2LI?# A#")2] ] 
"rk26
"#' 
: o_ '*H?'
!rk]_ !* @
"# J
5"fLK)#"p# # !"'z
'
 =#: :

 o 

")'  4*"
: "# 

H
?2<"#8
: 2L)
"# ;)5"'?
: <_ '*Hz
4i= '**)* 'K
: 4#75s '*?]"
'3"~
: <~ ") ;# 

: z)   ! {") '
5'** 26'H h : >
<'
:"M'3
: ] ] )"r24#7
';24
):1
: #75ks7 ='*K]"
'3"~J
: <~ 
"@ 2<"k s * ;MA H
q# ! 
IK#  
k# H 
H
HA;
5k"
# !"'
K)#"

9}#")2}"~ 
)"
)w/loyRT|
vxT6yRT |
vxw4yRT |
7vxkR yRT|
7vxmw4yRT|
Rvx 4yRT | e

e # ")2}"~ 
)"
uvTloyRT|
wvxu4yRT |
u*lnu6yRT | e
RvRR yRT| e
Rvxuw4yRT| e
vx  4yRT | e

h  ;l J 


  )
"#")26'q #24" 
Rm

Structural Model Reduced Systems for tol = 1e3

Singular Values of the Error Systems for Structural Model, tol = 1e3

10

40
Full Order
Balanced
SPA
Hankel
Rat. Kry

30

80

40

100

50

120

60

70

140

160

80

180

90

200

100

220

110
2
10

10


;l
>@?BA

10
10
Frequency(rad/sec)

DnG

10

Balanced
SPA
Hankel
Rat. Kry.

60

Singular Values

Singular values

20

240
2
10

10

10

10
10
Frequency(rad/sec)

DFfG

10

10


  !"#!$# %  '&)(*+!-,.-,/(
,0&1*2!#3!.4 567
8 ! 9 ! !:(
;<5=.,.;

CEDGF8HJI$KMLON@PQKRTSVUWR3I@D X

h : ")# '*5k'** 2 '?4]* zM


:jMA"8: ?'*" )! 'K#, M"9]_"#n
'K"~`2< '
 
2< #7
'Lf '
!)_ \5\
:
: < s7 
"#H 24" A"~K") R'z" 
#  75'
]
q '
!) 

"#H h : 8
A]
"~
: \]_"
"'* '*;*"\
: 426# 
5,/r';'tRvxuoy RT| e H/Y3='3"'* 
 1~F
"2 > 
4uij\
: ;
: '3'*5k'** 2 ='3)
: 
'
5,*"\] ] 
"rk=24* z')# ! z
: <IK# '
=# ?/= 'K 5 
5)]= 5H h : ):"'* #{*" )# ! "~KRT |
  'J*"z
 ! o2<"k 'J"~") (Hk#! 
: 'A'J[
 ZJYZ]\ '*5'
* 2\L# !"'(# 9@#" MA 
3#"q] ] H
?'( !rk]_ !* L 2< 
:"k 'q # @* '

'
~F!*"
58] ] )"r24#7
'24
):#<
: ;~ ") 24" f
:)":8
:
MK:" 3~[) s7 #!56)# 9D'*  ;>) ;mG@
H \3# 54
: )
"# 
5"o24 
:"\:''*"2< ;] )" 24'q~F"2<"k )*
~F
s #  '   <*",
: 6 # *"26* ): "! 4"~(#7* 
]_"
"#{]_"#7
'H h : o#n5ks7'*3]"
' "~A
: 4~F") 
#<
: 
 ! <") '*5'
* 24'J
K'
:"MK#4#z>) ijkH h : (> 
(
 'J
: J'J=#
: '**)!
) 2<"k L
@
"# 
5"\: '6] 
" 2 24
):#6
: ~ _") ?'*5k'** 2 )" # \
: ")#H0
:
: !r! ] 
"#"~

: )
"#;)5"<] ] 
"rk26#nL
: K#75ks7 ='*`]"
'"~
: ?] ] 
"rk26#n
'A
3"'* *"z
: A"~
: ~  ") 
24" H
8 #")2 "~ 

" e #")2 "~ 

"
q# ! 
uvT <yRT |
vxuw4yRT | e
K] ] 
"rfHJqH
lvxu<yRT|
lvxwm4yRT| e
IK#  
Rvx <yRT|
wvRw4yRT| e
k# H 
H
uvx <yRT|
7vx 4yRT| e
HA;
5k"
Rvxu<yRT | e
uvTR yRT | C
h    
 

"#"@24'("~
: : 24" ]] 
"r24#7
'
>@?>

^`_ba0X4FdcTD e

h :  'q'*5k'** 2  '
!@_ '
: 5#24'A_ jMA  #\
:  # '(!
*"K# 8
: ;@ _)2 ]_"'

"#o"~]_"


f ]=5 H h : <2<"k p: '<RuT\'*
* ' M
:{\'
#  z=#]3# {\'
# "*]H h : ]f" z"'
'*;*"\
:
=24# 
5/rk'p:'
k]
 s k*"4tKuv ln yRT | e H] ]
"r24#7
'p:  ") RuH h : A>)'
24"2< #np"~
:
'
5'** 2='K )"HzIK # ! L#'** "~ !rk]#  =#6
: *)#'*~[ ;~ # !
"#)" # 1<OdLMA < !r]# {;
" # 
R

Structral Model Reduced Systems Nyquist Plots for tol = 1e3


4

0.06

0.04

Full Order
Balanced
Rat. Kry
Hankel
SPA

Building Model Reduced Systems Nyquist Plots for tol = 1e3

x 10

Full Order
Balanced
Arnoldi
Lanczos
Hankel
SPA
Rat. Kry

0.02

Imag

Imag

0.02
2

0.04
3

0.06

0.02




0.02

0.04
Real

DnG

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

4
1

3
Real

DFfG

7
3

x 10

.  3; 
 
  ; ;%(#,,-, ,.35=Q,; 2 #7 ! '&)( *7 ! !:(
;d5=.,.;G&1*31 ; , 

9O uTT{) /'* H h : ' " )!"24 '<


: 8 
k"MK#"~K
: 9# !"'] 
"k!  ) H01 '
" '
o
: 8'
: ~[* 
 @'
"#9"~
: ;K)#"  ] 
"k!  
?M
:8OXuTTz)/'* HJ
RT/ij<= '**)* 'J
: ;
 '*q'
#J
"~
: ~[) s7 #!5
'*]_"# '* z"~J
: z)   ! ") ;2<"k '?*" 
: MK
:,
:;"~J
: ~ "@ ;2<" H \3#
'):" 9#"
! 3
: q"# 56)
"# _;
5k"6
): '
: ?]f k'(
" #o
: ?~F
s # !54@# <RTJt RT g @ /'* H

K"8k?Q'* ,2< 
: "24
): '?
:"'
]_ 'Hq?2<"#6
: 3Q'
"# 'LfIK#  #"@2 ] ] )"r24
"#
='
: ?MA")'*(
"# 93OTkL # 8'
"z
"# \?O H h : 3
 '*('
#  A/ '"~
: ?~[
s # !5o
'*]_"# '*
"~p
: 

"?'*5k'** 24'?#8>) 6RT/i{
 
:
: <? '* ,24 
:"'
f ** ?M: #,M z!"# '
 
:
MK:" 3~[) s7 #!5o)#  HJ? '*]* "=#<]f )~[ !  *",3OT4# 3O dL)
"# ;
5k"8: 'q
: :: '*
) 
 # oe8 )
"o#"@24'4'6='** #
 ,wHdq6"# ,'
:"#"
! 
:4)
"# ;
5k"'
')]_ )";*"
: oK)#"p# # !"'] 
"k!  
' !rk! ] z
: o~[
s # !5{)#  RT e t RT @  /'* H0: #
MA <!"# '
 K
: M: " ~F
s # !5)#  L# ! 
 !
"#='?=#
: z_ '*H;) i= '**)* '
:
#75ks7 ='*J]"
'J"~
: ?~  ") (# 9
: ?
  ! o") ('*5k'** 24'$
H \;# 5
: ?)
"# _;
5k"4] ] 
"rk26#nq: '
'
"2< oD'
24=[G =
"#\~F
"2 
: ;~ f") K2<" H
q# ! 
K] ] 
"rfHJqH
IK#  
k# H 
H
HA;
5k"
K)#"
# !"'

8 # ")2 "~ 

"
v l6yRT |
v l6yRT|
vTRyRT|
Rvxuu<yRT |
vxwT4yRT | e
RvxmkRyRT| e
Rvxum<yRT| e

e # ")2 "~ 

"
vxu4yRT |
vxu4yRT|
lvx4yRT|
lvRw4yRT |
lvTw4yRT | e
Rvxm/loyRT| e
Rvxum4yRT| e

h  w  


 

"#"@24'q~["
:
>@?

^`X4FU D I`DGFU


U]5 

R3I D X

 '"Y
G\zHY ('q#9" 
# o5o'
]
f '
!


"#9"~#
h : ?=2<]_ 6_ 2 2<"k f: '( /lnm'*
* '# 8
]] 
"] )=* ]

= f 
#7
 s7 
"#H h :z
=#]) ] 
'* #7
'?
: ~F")! <] ]= \*"8
: '**) !
) z?
:
uT

Building Model Reduced Systems for tol = 1e3


40
Full Order
Balanced
SPA
Hankel
Rat. Kry
Lanczos
Arnoldi

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

120
2
10


w

10

10

10

10

10


8 !  '!"#!$# %   ,.,[. !5=7# %   1 ; ,  65.,.;

~F
 ? # L# o
: 3"*]q'
: ?
'
 
=# ='*]! 2< #7Hp"(
: ' !r2<] Lk
: ?
f]
A"~
: 3]_" K"'* '*
*"24# )5/r'p'qtKvTqy4RT|H01 K] ] 
"rk26* 
: '*5k'** 2QM
:<2<"k k"~"@ R 4DF*" @# ! RT|G@H
h : ]"
'"~
: ) '*'
#   ;"~p
: ~[) s7 #!5o
'
]f"#'* "~
: ]] 
"r24#7
'# 

"?'*5k'** 24'
) 8'):"M##>) RR ij1# RR i
'*]_ !
 5Hk# !  O TkLJ=#") z*"{] )  #n
: 8 
k"M#"~
# !"'LM  !rk]# 8
: *)# '*~F ~ # !
"#,6D/Gq"~
: ")# '
5'** 2 
" # OTkvR# '** 8"~`3O
MA 8'*"1 '* o
: \'
: ~F* K)#"J2< 
:"kM
: 8O TkvRo@  /'* H1
"#A
5"'z#
: 9_ '*~F"
_"
:,OT4# ;O dH Y #    !r! ] K~["K
: ~F
s # !58)# _  M  #Tkvxw6#, T6@  /'* L
:'2< 
:"k
 '3
: f '
3]] 
"r24#732<"#
: <2< 
:"k 'H# !"';# 1K)#"= ] )"!   
'3'*"\ *"\"7"k
]] 
"r24#7
'? '*]_ 58~F"3
: ~[
s # !5,)# T tRz)  /'* H h :''3  *"8
: <):"=! z"~Az'39"M
~F
s # !5<]_"#7HpA=# ! 82<" 
 !
"#9'J
: K_ '*"# ;2<"#z
: ;k? 2< 
:"k '~F* 3O R@  /'* H
Y # * )24'"~? 

"4# ")24'LAk? '* 2< 
: " '<) \f ** <
:#2<"2< #7624
):#{'* 2< 
: " 'L`

: Sf ) # ! ';
4#";': :'3~F";
: <] ) "'K !r2<] 'HK#L)
"# p;
5k"'3
: _ '*;2<"#
24"2< #nq24
@: #z2< 
:"k 'H h : ?#n5ks7'*`]"
'J"~
: K~F") q# o
: )   ! o") '
5'** 26'A) K'
:"M#
=#8>
4RuijkH h :'q>) '
:"MK'
: ?_
: ]] 
"r24#7
'24
@:,
: 
: #75ks7 ='*(]"
'("~
: ~F =_") 
24" _MA 3
H Y #   L
:''q
: f '
24
):,"~#75s '
(]"
'(2<"#o
: '
r9 !r2<] 'H
q# ! 
IK#  
k# H 
H
HA;
5k"
K)#"
# !"'

9}#")2}"~ 
)"
uvR!loyRT|
uvx<yRT |
vxum4yRT|
v ln4yRT|
v u4yRT|
v ln 4yRT |

e # ")2}"~ 
)"
7vxw4yRT|
mvRT6yRT |
lvxmm4yRT| e
mvxmm4yRT|
Rvxwm4yRT| e
Rvxw<yRT | e

h  7  


 

"#"@24'q~["
: 2<]_ 8_ 2
>@?

OR 
@FPQP

 N3HQH.DGe `R e.H XMH.DGe

h : K~ ") (2<"k _'Az"M(i]')'Aq** )M"



:9>f* q"~") ;RTTzM
:9
: 3*"{~[) s7 #!56;RK@ /'* H
h : ,#")26 I?# ?'
# =4/= '6
'
:"M#%#>
uij# >
uiH Y 9'
:" f #"
! 
ukR

Singular Values of the Error Systems for Building Example, tol = 1e3

Singular Values of the Error Systems for Building Example, tol = 1e3

50

105
Balanced
Hankel
SPA

Arnoldi
Lanczos
Rat. Kry,

100

110

115
Singular Values (dB)

Singular Values (dB)

150

200

250

120

125

300

130

350

135

400
2
10

10


7

10
10
Frequency (rad/sec)

DnG

10

140
1
10

10

10

10
Frequency (rad/sec)

DFfG

10

10

&)( * &)1*7! # %   '! !$# %   ! 3. !567# %1 ; ,  65.,.;


:#  o
: 8"
: 4'*5k'** 24'L`
: 8=# 
Au{'
# =  '
8 s7H h : ) ~["
LJ
: 'z'*5'
* 2 # #"
_ <
 ! 1_ "M") uH h : 4] ]
"r24#7
'#1
:';'* o: 6"@  H \3# 4'
:"1#"
! 4
:
:
*@# '*~F z~ # !
"#"~K
: ' !rk2<] \: '#" )"'H h : '@#" #  # !"'<]
"! 
'z"# "zMA"
~
MA 9 !r]#
: 9*)# '
~[ z~F# !
"#4DG;
" #O dH Y # '** LpM 9 !r]#  6D/G 
" #9O TkvRH{?'
>
\R ij= '**)* 'Lp24"2< #n26
): # \'* 12< 
:"k ';:  6 9 j5 '*]_ 5)" # {
: 4*"
~F
s # !5H?2<"#{
: 2LJ# !"'<#K)#"= '):"M} 
5'
24= 
'

'#  
8f ** <
:#@
"# 

5"fH \3#
: "
: 3: # Lfk?Q'* 24 
:"'MA"
\M
:" ] 
" 24'(] 
"k  =#"7"k]] 
"r24#7
'
~F"(
: ;M: " 3~[
s # !5o)# H`?2<"#<
: k? '* 24 
:"'LIK# #")2}] ] 
"rk=24
"#\'A
: ;_ '*
=#1* )24' "~A8#")2LM: = <'
: 4M"@'* #1* @24'"~( e #")2\H\k# =;]f )


"#124 
:"'# 
# ! 8
 !
"#8'
:"MX )59"'
?_ : ")'A~["(~F
s #  '( ')'
:#1R3)  /'*  ')'* s #7
5L7# ! 
)   !
"#4='`_ ** Hp
Rui8 ]=!
'`
: #75ks7 ='*`]"
'`"~
: ~ ") J# 4
: 
 ! 4") '*5'
* 24' 
# "
! ;
: 2<"2< #724
@: #<2< 
:"k '(
;~(~F
"2 24
):#
: ;~ ") 2<"k HJ3'* \2< 
:"k '
 "4#"5k 9 
58"7"k] ]
"r24#7
'L  q!"24]
*"6
: ;~["@2< L 
: 58"4<_ **  "H
q# ! 
K] ] 
"rfHJqH
IK# 
k#H` 
H
HA;
5k"
K)#"
# !"'

8 # ")2 "~ 

"
wvxu4yRT|
wvxu4yRT|
vxwm4yRT|
wvx  4yRT |
RvTu4yRT
RvTu4yRT
RvTloyRT

e # ")2 "~ 

"
vR4yRT|
vR4yRT|
Rvxw4yRT|
vxukR yRT |
lv lloyRT| C
vx m4yRT| C
vxwm4yRT| C

h  m J 
  
)"#")24'~["
: A ** 
M")
:\>* 



  !"#
$%&' !&( *)$+-,

h : K #~[5k#;~F 

?"~f2<"k 
  !
"#92< 
:"k '] 
'* #7* 9f" ;'J
:A
: 56
?" 
# o75o2< # '
"~/.10+24365%798;:<2>=/?@H *@,OBAC ZLDA`EC FHG &/I $ LKJMLONpL_ ?] 
" * !
"#L
: p'CUZPAUORQ $ H h : A!")
'*]_"#  # 
uu

Heat Model Reduced Systems for tol = 1e3

Singular Values of the Error Systems for Heat Model, tol = 1e3

30

0
Full Order
Balanced
App. Bal.
SPA
Hankel
Rat. Kry

20

10

Balanced
App. Bal
SPA
Hankel
Rat.Kry

10

20

Singular Values

Singular Values

30
10

20

30

40

50

60
40
70

50

80

60

70
3
10

10

 
m

10

10
Frequency(rad/sec)

DnG

10

10

90
3
10

10

10

10

10
Frequency(rad/sec)

DFfG

10

10

10

! #   !-'! # ! '&)( *2,-, (#,`&1*2!#3!Q !567


% ( @,    [5=.,.;

)   ! \") 2<" 


 #D RHx G'q" 
# ,'(~["="M'
c
^

D C Z  AzG c
 XD C Z  G 
D AG c 

DHRG

h : s7j5z"~_
: ] ]
"r24#7J'`24 '

4=#<* )24'p"~_
: K~[) s7 #!5
'
]f"#'* K4D
AG`O D
QJt  G)| C  H
\3] 
24_I?# #"@2 # 8##< 2<]:'
 3 # 
58"~)2424=# '

R 
R



C
C


UO >u @ D
 Qt  G |   Z D
 Qt  Z G |  dO >u @ D
Q t  Z G | C Z D
Q t  G | C 
|
|

5"{2< 
:"k '; ] *",~[
s # !5
'*]_"# '
#1 2<]: ') <

 o!"#n*)
"# '?"~ D
Q<t  G | C  H
h : # M2< 
: "8 2<]: '
 '(
:  # 
59"~
: !
"'
')2424#
R  
O >u @ D
 Qzt  G | C  Dt
 Q t  G | C 
|



~["
:  S_ 
#7q24 
:"'
'(~F""M'H
RH"!#"$&%('*),+.-0/1$&%(2+.3#45$JH"   67  Z8   Z(OTkL  Z9:;   Z OXTkLk#
_"#n*"z
:
"24##n(  #'*]! "~1<;
 H
uH>=@?&+.3BAC"!ED:"$GF"'H!I$G4"-AJ"?G?1-.4LK&3BAC2+.3#45J
$ HA" ;~F"
: ;@2424# 'HEMJ2f \=#\4"'
'
 '
'q*)# '*~F 

h :

2 :;7 5 ?"2

.#0+2+395(7 8 2>0E?

!.1042+395(7 8

~F# !
"#\# \]
"  !"#n*"6
''*
 ;  # '*]! H

HNO-.P&!#4*Q8RS1UTV'L)WU?1?G-04LK&3#AC2+.3#4X$`H`J
"  !"#n*"o
):  5o#  "K"'* 
=j56'
]! 'H

lHYO'*Z[A\'*+.]G4^)JHz`
" * !"#7*"\
: 4'*]! 4'
]# # 5
: 4 "24# #7K@:n')# ? !*")' ";  #ki
 !*")'K"~
: !
"'
'@2424#H
h : 7%2_.5` 5baK: 8Bc"~A
: '* <2< 
:"k '; '
=#7dD56=/?65 !"2<]_"'

"# '
k#\#7*"!" #7;"# 5, "24# #73* )24'
"~
: *"
!"'*L='('~F""MK'
u

CD Player Reduced Systems Nyquist Plots for tol = 1e3

Heat Model Reduced Systems Nyquist Plots for tol = 1e3


80

10

Full Order
Balanced
App. Bal.
Hankel
SPA
Rat. Kry

Full Order
Balanced
Arnoldi
Lanczos
Hankel
SPA
Rat. Kry

60

40

4
20

Imag

20

4
40

6
60

10
5




DnG

10

15

20

80
40

25

30

20

10

10
Real

DFfG

20

.    3; # 3#   ; ;%(


,,., #:,.35.,.; 2  7 ! '&B( *2 -( 35=.,.; &1"*

RH"!#"$&%('*) + -0/1$G%92+.3#45$JH
DF  #  !"24]f"')
"#G@H

30

40

50

60

 ; ( #

"2<] * )2624# ' /T>N D")


: 2oG ]_ 
~F")2 # #  Q T>N

uH>=@?&+.3BAC"! D:"$&F5'L!$&45-0AJU?G?1-04*K&3BAC2+.3#45$JH
# =#<# \ 2f  # XwT>N/H

"2<]* 3)2424#'
/T>ND ")
: 29G ]_ 
~F")2

HNO-.P&!#4*Q;U?G?1-04*K&3BAC2+.3#45$JH`K] ] 
"rk26* 5MJ e 1
N
"]_ )
"#'H
h : 7%2_.5` 5baK: 8Bc,'
# E.K.1042VaK: _ 8 59#  "M? . >0E?65o !"24]f"')
"# 'L`='<'<~["="M'H _ 8
:  @
# 2_ ("~#"#i 
"4  2< #7
']_ (
"M #  L# , J9_ ;
: # 2 _ ("~ !r]# '
"#8]_"#7
'H h : #
RH"!#"$&%('*)

+ -/G$G%92+03 4X$`H3)2424#'C  # # 8D G@H


uH>=@?&+.3BAC"!ED:"$GF"'H!I$G4"-AJ"?G?1-.4LK&3BAC2+.3#45$JH?)2624# ' C  
HNO-.P&!#4*Q;U?G?1-04*K&3BAC2+.3#45J
$ H`K] ] 
"rk26* 5!e  "]_ )
"# '
J N

*J N

6J




2f  #8D NG@H

 &%$(

# 
: 'p# "* M (]
'* #7* 4;!"2<])
 '*
 5z"~_'*  #4")
: 24'~F"J2<"k k
  !
"#L# 2< 5f # ! 

24" _)   !


"#L] ]
"r24* ;=# ! 8
  !
"#L'
# =A]_ 

 

"#92< 
:"kL I?# #")2 ]] 
"rSi
26
"#LnK)#"n] )"!   
L# !"'J] 
"k!  
L#)
"# ;)5"2< 
: "H h : '
")
: 26': _  #
]] {*"{'
Sr1 S_ 
#7 5k# 24`'
5'** 26'H h : <>@'*~F"24 8 '* 6"~(
: 6I?# ')# ; '# 

: ** ?
:
 z
'
"#24
): =#6"~
: z2<"2< #7
' H Hq
: !"P o #7
'"~p
:  
#nK !r]# '
"#,"~

: K*)#'*~[ q~ # !
"#o
" # 9'*"2< 3]_"#7J"~
: ?!"2<] !r6]# H h : 
') 
'A'
:"M
: A#! o)   !
"#
#] ] 
"rk=24* <# ! 
  !
"#1) 4
: <_ '*;" z
: 4MK:" ~[) s7 #!5)#  H6A jMA  #
: '
4jMA"L
]] 
"r24* (# #:'p
: #7
 
: J`!"2<]* '# ` _!2>? 8 # ! <
 ! 4'*5k'** 2 :;8 5P0 8;:!>5 ` c
MK
:"" 
# #   # ! 9

"#6"~
: K~ "@ ('*5'
* 2>)'*Lk# o')'* s #7
5*) # 
# L7
: '
)   #o
: <!"2<]

"# p!"'*# {'**") <) s7 
2< #7
'H ?
:":{3: '3
: <"M '*; )
";#")2
=#2<"'
z"~K
: \'* 'LAz  'z*"
: 8:: '*z e 

"4#")2H{A # {"q## 

82<"2< #7424
@: #
24 
:"'`Mq5k' 4*": : ` 

"A#")24'p
:#93'* 424 
:"' n `
: 5
  ! 
: !"2<] 

"# 
Y

u/l

CD Player Reduced Systems for tol = 1e3

Singular Values of the Error Systems for CD Player, tol = 1e3

40

50
Full Order
Balanced
Hankel
SPA
Rat. Kry
Arnoldi
Lanczos

20

Balanced
Arnoldi
Lanczos
Hankel
SPA
Rat. Kry
0

Singular Values (dB)

Singular Values (dB)

20

40

60

50

80
100
100

120

140
1
10

10

 
<RTk

10

10
10
Frequency (rad/sec)

10

DnG

10

150
1
10

10

10

10

10
10
Frequency (rad/sec)

DFfG

10

10

10

 ; (  

! #   !-'! # %  '&)(*T,-,[(#,0&1*2!#3!Q !567


8 ! 

!"'
K# '
*") 
s ) 2< #n
'
24
5HAK2<"# 4
: 2\L @
"# ;)5"o '_ ** 
') 
'  ;*"4
:
!rk 5;"~f
: '*  !
"#<"~#7* 
]_"
"#z]_"#7
'HI"M  Lk
: '
 !
"#<"~_
: '* ]f"=#n
'M:):< * @24# '

: 
  ! ,2<" '#"#*"24* ] 
"k! '
'# :'(*"4_ '*]_ S> 858
:  '* LM
:\*
 ? # !
~F
"2
: 
: ")5<"#o:"M*"z):""'* ?
: '* K]f"=#n
'HpA54!"#7*)'*L#<
: K"
: q2< 
:"k '  #o 

"J*" )# !
  * )24# 'q  )57
: =#H

 

9 

  

PSR Y H f H?#n*" ='L = 045%7-0%? : 5P=#5P?%? >=5dM0(5` 8 5bdH8 2E.1:<7P?


24
 f "#7*
"L 
R  RRukR i)RR 1D RmwG@H

: =

: =#5 >0

c _
?

@L

?P8 5

M MM

h )# ')!
"# 'K"#?*"i

P uY H f H ?#n*"'LHHA=L H#L# 
 H f H0 24'L = 8#-5 ?62`/8;:<2>= 2 8#-5>_: = :#_ `0 8;:<2>= ` : =18 5P0
.-2` 8;:<2>=
.#0+2 ` 5 _L # AK  ) #
Y
'K] ]=
"# 'Lk]_ dY '
'
 K"# Z*)Sr6J
" 24'L   !
kRR i  D RTnG@H
P Y H f HK#7*" '`#"H f H0 24'L#$%5 :;2>0 ` E.K.1042 K7
"#?*"24
 f "#n*
"L
R ! Rwi)RmTu{D R G@H

M8 2

: =5 >0

ba G_ d `
5

D798

!2 D5

&%L"Y MM

: =

h )# ')!
"# '

P lY H f HK#7*"  'L '5%7-0%? : 5 _ 2VdD5 ` : =% 2d>: ?P760(568 5 8;:#_ 58;:#_ 5 ?95P0 :<5P?@L%YZ " 2< "#,=# ?  )<~F"
f "#7*
"L H  #?"7"
##
 ?H 0UH 05k24#:MJ *"@'L] )#  Ap @L ( )_ R i uTD R G@H

P Y H f HnK#7*" 'L*MH* H?@242< # ozH f H"


#'* #L =+E5 :;2 0%? ,*0 8;:<2>= `: = 8 5P0 .-2` 8;:<2>=-, =5d8#-5/. >=17
0 2 ? ` % 2>0E:;8#(_L_`
"kHR /
: Y k f h ) # # =01"@ f "#) '
'Lk# )# '
!"L )2<"#,J
'
' D RwG@H
P wY H f H?#n*"'L# .K.1042Va :#_ 8;:<2>=B2` : =#5 >0 2E. 5P0 8 2>0E? : =O8#-5213 =12>0_LA]_ $Y'
') 6"~?# ?  )
# K] ]=
"# 'A"#54G `#` 5P=% 5 ? : =26 8;0 : a87&-5%2>0c/L) -! A Ti kRwLpD RmG@H

PY H f H K#7*" 'L# .K.1042VaK: _ 8;:<2>= 2>` : =#5 >0 dc>= _:;7 ` ?c ? 8 5_ ? L#9
: ;0 5M# !5k"]_  "~GMJ !*)
#  M !*
"# ' M##  @#Lk   * \5H zH 01 '** L "2< 9 JlT ilnuuD RG@H
P mY H f Hk?#7*" 'L. 5(798:-0(5
*"6] ]_ DuTTRG@H
?

2>=

#

8 -5

E.K.1042VaK: _

8;:<2>=

>` ;%
2

u

>0

 ` dc _
5

?67

>=

:<7

`?c

_

? 8 5

L?)~[L<YZ J
'
'L

Clamped Beam Model Reduced Systems for tol = 1e3

Singular Values of the Error Systems for Clamped Beam Model, tol = 1e3

80

50
Full Order
Balanced
Arnoldi
Lanczos
Hankel
SPA
Rat. Kry

60

40

Singular Values

Singular Values

20

20

50

100

40

60

Balanced
Arnoldi
Lanczos
Hankel
SPA
Rat. Kry

150

80

100
2
10

10


4RR

10

10
Frequency(rad/sec)

DnG

10

200
2
10

10

10

10

10

10
Frequency(rad/sec)

DFfG

10

10

10

! # !  !- '!-"#


% ! '&B( *2,.,[(
,0&)1*2#3. !5=7# 8; (#5",[1"(#5

P Y H f H K#7*" '# H f H"


#'* #L 0+24365%798;:<2>= _ 568#-2Vd ?8P2>0/ ` >=#7E5bd
M f M`i f ? Z? ] 
'LK! ?#  )'
j5L ] * 2_ KuTTTkH

_ Vd ` bd 
2 D5

0(5

/7 8;:;2 =

L h @: # 7 ]_"




PSRT/Y H f H?#n*" ='z#H ZH#?""


#LU-2>0 8"7%2 -0E?65 2 =O8#-5 E.D.10+2 a :#_ K8;:;2>=B2` :0 % 5  ?P7 ` 5Odc>= _:;7 `
? c ? 8 5 _
?@Lf"
Y Z?# #  Z  
#Lfk#  #L 
*"6K!"L5DuTTTnG@H
PSRR YHI"=2< 'L H`H 24 5L#  HA 
""L 7-0H` 56=17E5 , 7%2-5P0(5P= 8 ?P8;0  7 8: 0(5 ? ,>d c = _:;7 ` ?c
? c__
568;0c/L f 2 ) 6Z"2<")]:'"#
Z ): #'L f 2 )= K# )'
 5oJ
'
' D RwG@H
PSRuYzH`HA" 5L"0 c` 2 !? . K7E5_ 598#
! '
'
# L q  imD R/l7G@H

Vd
2

?!2>=

? 8 K8 5

 
? .

K7 5

`G_ Vd ` @L

7E2>= 8;042

_

? 8 5

5d


?

)
'L5k'** 24'L#k# `
"i

PSR YHk  4


2 #8# 9
 H 0UH
 # L
76: 5P= 8 ` : =#5 >0 79: 047-:;8 >= ` c ?E: ? c (d5 E.K.1042Va :#_
_ 568# 2VdL YM M M h @ # 'H f "2<]* *ij? \? '
#LLw i w/lnL`D RG@H

8;:<2>=

. >=17 0

PSR!lYH 0UH 
 # L-'5bd  7E5d 42>0d 5P0 _!2 dD5` : =&% 8 5%7D= :  5P?  ?95bdM2>="0c`2 ?  ? . K7E5P? >=5d 8#-5P: 0  ?65
?E:#_
L ` 8;:<2>= L
K 24 )?# 5k'
' Z#7 ')!)] mi ijTuLA _")*") 'L  @ 
51D RmmG@H

: =

2 ?

76: 0+7 -: 8

PSRYz0 H ?H ?)\# Hf#  s '*L  = 8#-5. 0 8;:  `0(5 ` : 0 8;:<2>=H.10+2` 5_L# ??  )o# JY 
'3K] ]/i

"# 'Lk]f =%Y '
'
 ;"## ?5k'** 24'#  f " #n*
"L
 ui kRD Rm G@H
PSRwYMH* H ?)=242< L"0c0` 2  0+24365%798;:<2>= 6
#"'LK
# /i f : 2<]#L=D RG@H

# Vd 

568

2 >?

62>0

Vd `' d 
2 D5

5

798;:<2>=

LJ:HH h : ')'L"M

M? ]

HL H"~3Y i

PSRY<H3=#L MH*H ?)2424 Lq#%HJ`#?"7") #L # ?c_.8 2 8;:;7 >5 P2>0_ 5 ` 8;:<2>= : 045P? 8 >0P8 5bd
. > =#7 0 2>? _ 568# 2VdLfK] ]  Z
:H ** )'Lf Ai mTD R/l7G@H
PSRm
Y MH* H 3)242< L`zH f Hk"
# '* #L#  Hp`#?""
#L 6 2VdD5 ` 045d  798;:<2>= 2 ? 8 8 5 ? . D7E5 ? c ? 8 5 _ ? : >=
: _.5` :<76:;8B` c
045P? 8>
0P8 5bd". > =17 0 2 ? _ 598# 2VdL
K2< )?")
:24'L&) R i kRoD RG@H
PSR[
Y Y@H ZH =2<"k: kL MH ZH'
# 5
L  _.5` :<76:;8B` cO045P? 8> 0P8 5bd"0c`2 ? P? . K7 5\_ 598# 2Vd ?@62>0'? 8 ` 5 . 0 8;: `
045 
` : 0 8;:;2 =/?@L" Y Z  H Z*)Sr\?# H K] ]HL! w  i wu{D RG@H
uw

Beam Example Reduced Systems Nyquist Plots for tol = 1e3

Butterworth Filter Reduced Systems Nyquist Plots for tol = 1e3

5000

1.5
Full Order
Balanced
Arnoldi
Lanczos
Rat. Kry
Hankel
SPA

4000

3000

Full Order
Balanced
Arnoldi
Lanczos
Hankel
SPA
Rat. Kry

2000
0.5

Imag

Imag

1000

1000
0.5
2000

3000
1
4000

5000

2000

) 4Ru

1000

1000
Real

DnG

2000

3000

1.5
1.5

4000

0.5

P uuYzHo#\KHzH \zH ?#  @'*"#L


*
"L   R i)R!lT{D RmG@H

d

. 4 3; 
:3
% !  ; ;8(
, !-,., #:,.35=.,.; 2 #7  '&)(*7; (
5=",[1-(
5 G&1"*

P ukR Y HL`AH0#L H0d:* L# = 5 76: 5P= 8/. c .-=12


2>0 dD5P0>_
2VdD5 ` ?"2  : = 8 560+7E2>= =#5%798LJ
"H w/
:`YM M M /
LD RG@H

045

0.5

DFfG

f "
H Z"7") L
 798;:<2>= L%Y

MM M
# `#`

1.5

Real

P uT/YHzHf""*"kLH8MH \ Z 5L_H# #7 


L : =%3L` >0./5P0P8:-0
8#-5(2 0 c >
= 2 >560 :<5 pL # / 8 2_ 8;:<7 L &) Ru i)R uLpRwH

P u Y?H

 :

&% H`

: 

0
./5P0P8 -0

f Z

?65

E.K.1042Va :#_

8;:;2 =

>=5dH2>0 dD5P00(5bd 

8;:<2>=/?

   d

? '
#9?*"24
"#
K8;:;2>=

  ` bd c _

8;:<2>=

>=#7E5

P u/lY<H 3" L *2E.8;: _ ` >= K5`  =#2>0 _ .K.1042Va :#_ 8;:;2 =/?M2` : =5 >0_ /8;: ` 0E:  ` 5
5P0 0+2 0
 2  =Xd @? L%Y#7HH f "#n*
"L  KRRRi)RR D Rm/l7G@H
(
P uwY Hk: L-' 8;:;2 = `"0c`2  ` %D2 0E:;8#(_
KH ] ]HL f Aum i uD Rm/l7G@H

P2>0

=12 =/?

P uYzH f H"
#'* #L  _.5` :<76:;8 .K.5` :;7 8;:;2 ='2.-2` c
K#H ]]HL  i mD RuG@H

c__

_  ` `

=#2 :

P umYH`#?"7") #L 0 _: >=$ ?95bd_ 2Vd 5` 045d  798;:<2>=


Z,  
=#Lfk#+n #L  
*"4=!"L 5DuTTTnG@H
P uYH`#?"7"
#L &7 -5 . =17 0 2 ? ` %D2>0
"#5k'** 24'# f " #7*
"JD RG@H

#*_

: 8

568;0 :;7

   ?

>0

 `
5

?67

8;:<2>=/?

7&

-5

8 5 .

? 8 5

c _
? 8 5

 
?

0 =12

>:

_ a

568 -2

:;7

Lk:"

f

5d #

8;0 :

? 8 5 "?

_ d `
!2 D5

8 -56: 0

?95!Ln5k'** 24'

568;0 :;77

d c  _  ` c _

8;:<2>=/?


?

` d &_ # VdL"Y

`

7E2>= 8;042

LdY#7HH f " #ki


?

6: ` :;8Bc >=5d

?95P0

c__
?

` 5
.10+2` 5_

5P=

>=Xd 9d 
5 E.K.#0+2VaK: _

u

8 560%?: =

:` ;%
2

56:



: =

62>0
% 5P=5P0 8;: =&% 0(5bd  7 5bd 
"#~F 
# ! L
M \3) # 'L

` 7%2_.-2>=5P= 8
>= ` c ?E: ? : =:` : =#5 >0 ? c ? 8 5 _
7E2>= 8;042`#` 6: ` :;8Bc , 2 
h )# ')!
"# '("#?*"24
= f "#7*
"L
R)( Ri uD RmkRG@H

798;:<2>=

 

E.D.10+2 K7

0 : =179: .

P uY h H #L : % 56= ` 5 dD5%7 c % 2 -=5d ?XP2>0 ?P2 `/8;:<2>=/?2 . c E .-=12
#  f "#7*
" ** )'L * "o] ]_ DuTTTnG@H

.  +   ; !

 : 0E?@L# 
.

L3"Y Z

HZ*)r
K# # 

" )'* LA # r


Z  
#

Butterworth Filter Reduced Systems

Singular Values of the Error Systems for Butterworth Filter

20

50

100
Singular Values

Singular Values (dB)

20

Full Order
Balanced
Hankel
Sing Pert.
Rat. Kry
Arnoldi
Lanczos

40

60

Full Order
Balanced
Hankel
Sing Pert.
Rat. Kry
Arnoldi
Lanczos

Balanced
Hankel
Sing Pert.
Rat. Kry
Arnoldi
Lanczos

200

80

250

100
1
10

300
1
10

10

DnG

Frequency (rad/sec)

) 4R 

150

DFfG

10

Frequency(rad/sec)

! # !  !- !  


8 ! '&)( *+,.,/(#, &)1*2#3. !5=7#

um

. ! ! 2
 #! ! ;