Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Recep Oruolu
Advisor
Lecturer Bar Kuleyin
2012
Subject Code:
Department Code:
Surname: Oruolu
Name: Recep
Turkish Name of The Project: Amonyum nitrat yknn snflandrlmas analizi ve gemisahil operasyonlarnda alnmas gereken emniyet tedbirleri.
English Name of The Project: Analyzing classification of the ammonium nitrate cargoes
and safety issues for ammonium nitrate ship-shore operations.
Year: 2012
Language: English
Number of Pages: 124
Number of References: 60
... of Advisor:
Title: Lecturer
Name: Bar
Surname: Kuleyin
1- IMDG Code
1- IMDG Kod
2- Hazardous Goods
2- Tehlikeli Ykler
3- Ammonium Nitrate
3- Amonyum Nitrat
5- Safety Precautions
5- Emniyet nlemleri
Date: 02/05/2012
Signature:
ii
PREFACE
One of the most traded inorganic, chemical fertilizer and blasting agent
ammonium nitrate, examined by the angle on sea transport, safety, IMDG Code, UN
Regulations and Country Regulations.
This thesis will help improving safety issues and briefing what to do in an
emergency situation while handling ammonium nitrate and ammonium nitrate based
fertilizers.
I am greatful to Lec. Bar Kuleyin for sharing his dear opinions and leading
me to finish this project.
I appriciate Ege Gubre Sanayi A.S. for allowing to visit M/V Sultan Atasoy and
also officers, crew and company DPA Mr. Burak Atasoy, for sharing information.
I want to thank who I enqired information or documents via e-mail. Fertilizers
Europe (EFMA); Baltic and International Maritime Council (BIMCO); The
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA); Government of
Western Australia, Director of Dangerous Goods Safety Mr. Philip Hine; Fertilizers
Europe Technical Director Mr. Dr. Antoine Hoxha.
Recep Oruolu
TURKISH SUMMARY
Bu tez projesinin amalar, gemi-sahil operasyonlarnda amonyum nitrat (AN)
ellelenmesinde alnmas gereken emniyet tedbirlerini arttrmak, bu ykn deniz
yoluyla tanrken alnmas gereken koullar incelemek, hangi koullar altnda bu
ykn tehlikeli olduunu anlamak ve acil durumlarda nelerin yaplp yaplmayacan
aklamaktr.
Amonyum nitratn tehlikelerini ve emniyet tedbirlerini aklarken IMO kitaplar
ile birlikte dzenleyici kanunlar kullandm. Amonyum nitrata olan bak etkileyen ve
ilgili kurulularn snralamalar getirmesine yol aan, gemite yaanm kazalar ve
terrizm olaylarn inceledim. Bununla birlikte, saha almas olarak Ocak 2012'de
Aliaa Ege Gbre Liman'nda gerekleen bir amonyum nitrat ierikli gbre
tahliyesine nezaret ettim; bu almay gzlem yaparak ve Avrupa Gbre reticileri
Birlii'nin (EFMA) hazrlad kontrol listesi ablonu ile kyaslayarak yaptm.
Amacm, amonyum nitrat yk ellelenirken alnacak emniyet tedbirlerinin
artrlmasn ve deniz yoluyla tanrken ykn tehlikelerine dikkat ekmeyi
salamaktr. Bu balamda, emniyet kontrol listeleri, depolama kurallar ve satta
yaplan snrlamalar hakknda nerilerde bulundum.
ii
ABSTRACT
The purposes of my project were improving safety precautions while handling
ammonium nitrate (AN) in ship-shore operations, learning sea transportation
requirements, determining under which conditions the cargo can be dangerous, and
what are the do's/don'ts in an emergency situation.
I have used regulatory articles, IMO books for decribing what were the
hazards and safety precautions of AN. I have studied past accidends and terrorism
incidents that affected the worlds outlook and made the related organizations to do
restrictions. Besides, I had inspected an ammonium nitrate based fertilizer discharge
operation as a case study in January 2012 at Aliaga Ege Gubre Port, by observing
visually and controlling my template checklists which was prepared by EFMA.
According to accidents, my point is to carry out improving safety at ammonium
nitrate ship-shore operations and attract awareness while sea transport of AN. I
proposed that checklists and regulations about storage and restrictions of sales.
iii
CONTENTS
PREFACE
TURKISH SUMMARY
ii
ABSTRACT
iii
CONTENTS
iv
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
LIST OF TABLES
xi
LIST OF FIGURES
xii
INTRODUCTION
xiii
CHAPTER ONE
THE MARKET OF AMMONIUM NITRATE AND OTHER FERTILIZERS
1.1. World Fertilizer Statistics
10
iv
CHAPTER TWO
ANALYSIS AND CLASSIFICATION OF AMMONIUM NITRATE AND AMMONIUM
NITRATE BASED FERTILIZERS
2.1. Classification of Ammonium Nitrate
13
13
13
13
14
14
16
20
21
2.4.1. Fire
21
2.4.2. Explosion
21
2.4.3. Decomposition
22
23
23
23
24
24
24
24
25
25
25
26
2.8. Loading
26
26
27
28
29
CHAPTER THREE
AMMONIUM NITRATE ACCIDENTS, TERROR INCIDENTS AND EFFECTS
3.1. Accidents
30
30
31
31
33
33
34
34
34
35
36
36
vi
37
37
38
40
40
42
42
44
44
44
45
3.4.2. Australia
46
46
47
CHAPTER FOUR
SAFETY PRECAUTIONS OF AMMONIUM NITRATE AND A CASE STUDY AT
ALIAGA EGE GUBRE PORT
4.1. Safety Precautions of AN
48
48
49
49
49
vii
50
53
54
55
4.4.2. Observations
55
58
CONCLUSIONS
59
REFERANCES
60
APPENDICES
65
66
79
84
86
90
91
100
102
115
118
119
120
viii
121
APPENDIX 14: Gemi - Sahil Emniyet Kontrol Listesi (Tm Gbre Tipleri in)
122
123
124
ix
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
AN: Ammonium Nitrate
ANFO: Ammonium Nitrate Fuel Oil
AS: Ammonium Sulphate
CAN: Calcium Ammonium Nitrate
CAS: Chemical Abstracts Service
COAG: Council of Australian Governments
DAP: Diammonium Phosphate
EmS: Emergency Responce Procedures Guide
EPA: The United States Environmental Protection Agency
EU: European Union
IFA: International Fertilizer Industry Association
IMDG: International Maritime Dangerous Goods
IMO: International Maritime Organization
IMSBC: International Maritime Solid Bulk Cargoes
MAP: Monoammonium Phosphate
N: Nitrogen
N-P-K: Nitrogen-Phosphorus-Potassium
RDX: Royal Demolition Explosive (cyclotrimethylene-trinitraamine)
TSP: Triple Super Phosphate
UN: United Nations
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1.1.: World Fertilizer Production
10
50
51
xi
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1.1.: From Raw Material to Fertilizer Flow Diagram
17
18
21
31
32
32
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
43
54
56
57
58
xii
INTRODUCTION
The text is divided into four chapters; the market, classification and hazards,
accidents and terror incidents, and safety precautions to be held.
First chapter gives information about the global and domestic ammonium
nitrate with other fertilizers trade statistics.
In the second chapter, I worked for explaining the sections while categorizing
and classification of AN according to UN Regulations and IMDG Code. Also test
procedures and certificates are given in appendices.
I was influenced while searching the third chapter of this thesis, learned how
the accidents occured. Also starting with 1995 U.S. Oklahoma City terrorism
incident, there were lots of terrorist attacks which include bomb of AN. What is the
world's decisions about preventing AN usage for terrorism? Restrictions, bans and
the effects of terrorism incidents are discussed too.
The last chapter which includes a case study of AN discharge operation in
January 2012 that gave me an observation chance, Besides this chapter inludes
what are the safety precautions while handling and transporting AN. To improving
safety at ship-shore operations and ship officers and crew awareness for hazards of
AN; I have proposed checklists which are in appendices in Turkish format.
xiii
CHAPTER ONE
THE MARKET OF AMMONIUM NITRATE AND OTHER FERTILIZERS
World is becoming more and more populous every year. In 1950, grain
production was 1000 million tons in one year to feed 4.5 billions of people. This fact
has changed to 2500 million tons to feed 7 billions of people in 2000's.
(http://faostat.fao.org)
When you consider that every field of crops in the world is made up of
individual growing plants, each in need of nutrients, the fertilizer industry has a
distribution and economic challenge unrivaled in almost any other business.
The most important components of fertilizer for plant nutrition are known as
the primary nutrients. These primary nutrients are nitrogen, phosphorus, and
potassium. The flow diagram which shown below that explains production of
fertilizers.
Figure 1.1: From Raw Material to Fertilizer Flow Diagram
Source: http://www.fertilizer101.org
650000
600000
550000
500000
450000
400000
350000
300000
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
UREA
23%
TSP
1%
SULPHUR
8%
POTASH
8%
PHOSPHORIC
ACID
6%
AMMONIA
25%
AN
7%
PHOSPHATE
9%
MAP
3%
CAN
DAP 2%
5%
AS
3%
"Table 1.3." shows that the total export/import quantity which transported
between countries in one year.
Table 1.3.: Global Export/Import Values
Global Export/Import Values
220000
200000
180000
160000
140000
120000
100000
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
UREA
18%
AMMONIA; %10
AS
5%
CAN
4%
SULPHUR
15%
DAP
7%
POTASH
22%
MAP
3%
PHOSPHORIC
ACID
3%
PHOSPHATE
6%
Oceania: Australia
Source: http://faostat.fao.org/
Table 1.5.: World AN Export Values by Regions
Source: http://faostat.fao.org/
1990-1995
1996-2000
2001-2005
2006
2007
2008
AS
299
215
139
147
141
219
108
AN %26
1028
1201
1149
930
1131
942
847
AN %33
32
42
72
94
225
293
Urea
455
551
363
345
147
145
TSP
458
159
104
85
114
121
119
DAP
416
286
229
114
192
226
143
Composite
986
1365
1542
1459
1312
1379
1304
Total
3642
3809
3568
3152
3131
3112
2959
(1000 Tons)
1990-1995
1996-2000
2001-2005
2006
2007
2008
AS
440
342
310
305
388
360
292
AN %26
1584
1401
1228
933
973
1006
809
AN %33
132
401
752
896
889
744
Urea
517
650
838
781
807
772
770
TSP
264
128
60
39
53
40
19
DAP
432
659
633
501
637
428
149
Composite
1171
1395
1627
1509
1571
1614
1313
Total
4410
4707
5097
4820
5325
5109
4096
(1000 Tons)
1990-1995
1996-2000
2001-2005
2006
2007
2008
AS
13
33
69
AN %26
28
46
26
72
20
AN %33
11
Urea
146
76
45
17
32
TSP
285
47
29
DAP
222
20
32
123
95
Composite
13
27
10
66
39
47
45
Total
696
222
25
201
173
274
204
(1000 Tons)
1990-1995
1996-2000
2001-2005
2006
2007
2008
AS
168
141
192
233
250
231
253
AN %26
532
245
81
21
42
AN %33
137
450
723
860
560
555
Urea
220
258
557
546
812
943
789
TSP
22
14
32
DAP
223
365
351
424
414
310
164
Composite
234
70
64
181
260
55
265
Total
1401
1220
1701
2142
2628
2144
2043
(1000 Tons)
Loaded
Discharged
Handled
Imported
Exported
2004
13200
720288
735925
720288
10500
2005
664751
668750
664751
2006
789463
793963
788460
2007
5068
634797
639869
634797
5068
2008
90499
585182
675681
508172
37689
2009
40275
936052
976327
914395
28142
2010
30007
670439
700446
657818
18897
10
CHAPTER TWO
ANALYSIS AND CLASSIFICATION OF AMMONIUM NITRATE AND AMMONIUM
NITRATE BASED FERTILIZERS
The classification of AN and AN based fertilizers were explained according to
IMDG Code, IMSBC Code and UN Recommendations on the Transport of
Dangerous Goods Model Regulations in this chapter.
IMDG Code contains relevant information for hazard class, subsidiary risk(s)
(if any), packing group (where assigned), packing and tank transport provisions,
EmS, segregation and stowage, properties and observations.
In the IMDG Code, substances are divided into 9 classes. A substance with
multiple hazards has one 'Primary Class' and one or more 'Subsidiary Risks'. Some
substances in the various classes have also been identified as substances harmful
to the marine environment. (IMDG Code, 2010; 35-40) (Zorba, 2009; 91-95)
IMDG Classes are given below:
Class 1: Explosives
Division 1.3: substances and articles which have a fire hazard and
either a minor blast hazard or a minor projection hazard or both, but
not a mass explosion hazard
Class 2: Gases
11
12
not less than 90% ammonium nitrate with not more than 0.2% total
combustible/organic material calculated as carbon and with added
matter, if any, which is inorganic and inert towards ammonium nitrate; or
ii) less than 90% but more than 80% ammonium nitrate with other inorganic
materals; or
iii) less than 90% but more than 70% ammonium nitrate mixed with calcium
carbonate and/or dolomite (calcium magnesium carbonate) and not more
than 0.4% total combustible/organic material calculated as carbon; or
13
not more than 70% ammonium nitrate with other inorganic materials;
14
not more than 80% ammonium nitrate mixed with calcium carbonate
and/or dolomite and not more than 0.4% total combustible organic
material calculated as carbon;
Note:
"Non-hazardous" may only be used if the chemical or physical properties of an
ammonium nitrate based fertilizer are such that, when tested (in accordance to
Appendix 1 and Appendix 2), it does not meet the established defining criteria of
any IMDG class.
15
16
17
18
2.2.1. Examples
Classification of three fertilizer compositions are shown below according to
logic diagrams based on the source material content. It is assumed that the
organic/combustible material content is within the specified limits.
Example 1:
Fertilizer composition by weight %
Ammonium nitrate 75
Ammonium sulphate 4
Ammonium nitrate 75
Ammonium nitrate 69
MOP (KCl) 9
Ammonium sulphate 22
Trough
test
shows
it
to
be
not
capable
of
self-sustaining
decomposition.
Answer: The fertilizer is not classified.
Source: (EFMA, 2012; 1-20)
19
20
21
temperature will quickly rise above 300C, giving off other gases including brown
vapours of toxic nitrogen dioxide (NO2).
The temperature will continue to rise through self-accelerating reactions, and a
detonation may occur. In a fire, for example, pools of molten AN may be formed and
if the molten mass becomes confined, such as in drains, pipes, plant or machinery, it
could explode, particularly if it becomes contaminated. Fires involving AN have
caused many explosions in the past. It is also true that there have been many more
fires involving AN that did not lead to explosions.
The potential for an explosion is always pres ent when the AN melt is
contaminated and the following explosion reaction is catalysed:
NH4NO3 N2 + 2H2O + O2 (+ 1580 kJ/kg)
An explosion is favoured by the increased heat of explosion and increased
sensitivity when further mixed with the optimum amount of fuel (such as diesel fuel,
a hydrocarbon represented by CH2) so that the following oxygen-balanced reaction
(as in the explosion of ANFO) occurs:
3(NH4NO3) + CH2 3N2 + 7H2O + CO2 (+ 4017 kJ/kg)
AN is ideally set up as an explosive substance, since it carries the oxidising
nitrate ion in intimate contact with the fuel element, the ammonium ion. All that is
required are small amounts of contaminants to act as a catalyst, explaining the
unpredictability of AN under fire conditions. (W.Aus.Gov., 2008; 19-20)
2.4.3. Decomposition
Molten AN decomposes at about 210C to give off toxic gases.
If AN is heated in an open and unconfined situation, it will decompose
completely to give gaseous products in a steady controlled way with white fumes
and vapours. The primary reaction is irreversible, exothermic and produces nitrous
oxide (N2O), a medical anaesthetic, and water.
NH4NO3 N2O + 2H2O (+ 450 kJ/kg)
If the reaction temperature is allowed to exceed 250C then it is accompanied
by an endothermic reaction producing ammonia (NH3) and nitric acid (HNO3).
22
23
24
25
27 to 42
1000
1.0
Size
Class
Group
1 to 4 mm
5.1
26
Due consideration shall be paid to the possible need to open hatches in case
of fire to provide maximum ventilation and to apply water in an emergency, and the
consequent risk to the stability of the ship through fluidization of the cargo.
During loading, the following provisions shall be complied with:
Smoking shall not be allowed on deck and in the cargo spaces and "NO
SMOKING" signs shall be displayed while this cargo is on board.
Bunkering of fuel oil shall not be allowed. Pumping of fuel oil in spaces
adjacent to the cargo spaces, other than the engine room, shall not be allowed.
As far as reasonably practicable, combustible securing and protecting
materials shall not be used. When wooden dunnage is necessary, only a minimum
shall be used. (IMSBC Code, 2010; 66-69)
2.8.2. Ammonium Nitrate Based Fertilizer UN 2067 - Class 5.1
Angle of Repose
27 to 42
900 to 1200
0.83 to 1.11
Size
Class
Group
1 to 5 mm
5.1
27
Due consideration shall be paid to the possible need to open hatches in case
of fire to provide maximum ventilation and to apply water in an emergency, and the
consequent risk to the stability of the ship through fluidization of the cargo.
During loading, the following provisions shall be complied with:
Bunkering of fuel oil shall not be allowed. Pumping of fuel oil in spaces
adjacent to the cargo spaces, other than the engine room, shall not be allowed.
As far as reasonably practicable, combustible securing and protecting
materials shall not be used. When wooden dunnage is necessary, only a minimum
shall be used. (IMSBC Code, 2010; 69-73)
2.8.3. Ammonium Nitrate Based Fertilizer UN 2071 - Class 9
Angle of Repose
27 to 42
900 to 1200
0.83 to 1.11
Size
Class
Group
1 to 5 mm
28
Bunkering of fuel oil shall not be allowed. Pumping of fuel oil in spaces
adjacent to the cargo spaces, other than the engine room, shall not be allowed.
(IMSBC Code, 2010; 72-74)
2.8.4. Ammonium Nitrate Based Fertilizer (Non-Hazardous)
Angle of Repose
27 to 42
1000 to 1200
0.83 to 1.0
Size
Class
Group
1 to 4 mm
Not applicable
29
CHAPTER THREE
AMMONIUM NITRATE ACCIDENTS, TERROR INCIDENTS AND EFFECTS
3.1. Accidents
Although ammonium nitrate generally is used safely and normally is stable
and unlikely to explode accidentally, accidental explosions of ammonium nitrate
have resulted in loss of lives and destruction of property. These accidents rarely
occur, but when they do, they have high impacts.
Past accidental explosions of ammonium nitrate have included some of the
most destructive on record. Several of these, including two in Germany in 1921,
occurred during attempts to break up large piles of solidified or caked ammonium
nitrate-ammonium sulfate mixtures using a blasting explosive. The blasting initiated
explosions in the ammonium nitrate - ammonium sulfate mixtures. Other large
explosions were triggered by fires involving ammonium nitrate in confined spaces,
including the Texas 1947 explosion of two cargo ships. A fire in the hold, involving
ammonium nitrate fertilizer coated with wax and stored in paper bags, caused the
explosion of the first ship; the ammonium nitrate in the second ship exploded some
time later, apparently as a result of a fire caused by the first explosion. As a result of
such accidents and subsequent studies of the properties of ammonium nitrate,
caked ammonium nitrate no longer is broken up with blasting agents, and wax
coatings are no longer used for ammonium nitrate fertilizer.
Explosions of ammonium nitrate, involving relatively small quantities, have
occurred during the preparation of nitrous oxide. In these cases, the explosions of
ammonium nitrate occurred as a result of excessively high temperatures and
confinement during processing.
3.1.1. 1921 Oppau - Germany
On 21 September 1921, when the technician was preparing the holes
for the firings in the "silo 110" at 7.00 am, a very powerful explosion took
place in the silo at 7.32 am, creating a 90m x 125m crater and 20m deep.
According to witnesses, there were two successive explosions, the first
one being weak and the second one devastating. Seismographic readings
30
from Stuttgart, at 150 km from Oppau also showed two distinctive explosions
that occurred at an interval of half a second.
The explosion was heard in Munich, 275 km from the plant and caused
panic among the masses. Material damage was reported at several dozens of
kilometers away from the accident site.
The official human casualty reported included 561 deaths, 1952 injured and
7500 people left homeless. Around 80% of the buildings in Oppau were destroyed.
(Braun O.,1953; 33)
Figure 3.1. : Photo of Oppau Accident.
Source: http://en.wikipedia.org
3.1.2. 1942 Tessenderloo - Belgium
Use of blasting explosive led to a detonation in AN pile on April 29th 1942,
killing 189 people at the plant and in the town. (IFA, 2002; 8-9)
3.1.3. 1947 Texas City - USA
One of the worst disasters in history occurred on April 16, 1947, when the ship
SS Grandcamp exploded at 9:12 A.M. at the docks in Texas City. The French
owned vessel, carrying explosive ammonium nitrate, caught fire early in the
31
morning, and while attempts were being made to extinguish the fire, the ship
exploded. Fireballs streaked across the sky and could be seen for miles across
Galveston Bay as molten ship fragments erupted out of the pier.
Figure 3.2. : SS Grandcamp.
Source: http://texashistory.unt.edu
Figure 3.3.: View from Galveston.
Source: http://texashistory.unt.edu
The ship SS High Flyer, in dock for repairs and also carrying ammonium
nitrate, was ignited by the first explosion; it was towed 100 feet from the docks
before it exploded about sixteen hours later, at 1:10 A.M. on April 17. The High Flyer
32
exploded in a blast, witnesses thought even more powerful than that of the
Grandcamp.
The precise number of dead was impossible to establish given the power of
the explosions, confusion, and commuter nature of many dock workers. The anchor
monument records 576 persons killed, of whom 398 were identified, while 178 are
listed as missing. The number of injured is generally estimated at around 3500,
which roughly equaled 25% of Texas Citys estimated population of 16000. In the
1947 the property loss amounted to about $100 million along with 1.5 million barrels
of petroleum products consumed in the flames of the disaster valued at about $500
million. One-third of the towns 1519 houses were condemned, leaving an estimated
2,000 people homeless. (Stephens, 1997; 1-20), (Armistead, 1947; 1-16).
3.1.4. 1947 Brest - France
On 23 July 1947, the Norwegian cargo vessel Ocean Liberty arrived in Brest
after crossing the Atlantic. 5 days later, a port worker noticed smoke coming from
one of the holds which had not been opened as its contents, more than 3000 tons of
ammonium nitrate, were bound for Le Havre and Boulogne. The worker,
remembering the Grandcamp disaster which had occurred three months earlier in
Texas City, warned the captain, the fire brigade, the port authority and the Marines.
A major and potentially very dangerous fire indeed then broke out onboard the
Ocean Liberty and spread rapidly due to the east wind. A towing attempt was made
but the vessel grounded on shoals near the port. While the team attempted to
scuttle the vessel, still in the clutches of flames, to put out the fire, the cargo
exploded. All the windows in the city and its surrounding area shattered into pieces.
As in Texas City, a tidal wave caused by the explosion swept along the coast and
sparked panic among bathers. In total, 22 people were killed in this accident, 4 went
missing and hundreds were injured. (http://www.cedre.fr)
3.1.5. 1953 SS Tirrenia Wreck
SS Tirrenia was a Finnish cargo steamer of 3826 grt. On the 23rd January
1953 when on route from Constanta for China with cargo of ammonium nitrate and a
general cargo she suffered a fire and explosion after it. Ship sank at 145 nm east of
Port Sudan. (http://www.wrecksite.eu)
33
34
Source: http://www.exponent.com
3.1.9. 2001 Toulouse - France
A terrible explosion of ammonium nitrate, killing 30 people, occurred on 21st
September 2001, in Toulouse. The manufactured chemicals in the plant were mainly
ammonium nitrate, ammonium nitrate-based fertilisers and other chemicals including
chlorinated compounds. (Dechy, Bourdeaux, Ayrault, Kordek and Le Coze, 2004;
131-138)
35
36
37
deep inside the hold, continued as evidenced by the increasing size and density of
the plume.
On the fifth day, the plume increased in size to many times the ships length
when emergency personnel sent aboard opened the cargo hold. A salvage company
was then appointed on the 22nd February to provide specialized assistance and
took control of the incident from the Spanish emergency services. Over the next
couple of days, the fire is brought under control until it was declared extinguished on
23rd February by using 240m of water. (Hadden, Jervis and Rein, 2009; 1-18)
Figure 3.7.: 21st Feb 2007 the Ostedijk.
38
Source: http://fotogaleri.hurriyet.com.tr
39
Source: http://upload.wikimedia.org
40
41
42
Source: http://gazetearsivi.milliyet.com.tr
43
44
45
3.4.2. Australia
In 2004, Australian governments agreed to a set of principles for the regulation
of ammonium nitrate. The proposed control measures were intended to improve
national security by reducing the potential for ammonium nitrate to be obtained for
illegitimate purposes but allow continued access for legitimate users primarily
miners and farmers. (Chemicals and Plastics Regulation Australia, 267)
Australian Government have enacted laws to regulate the movement of
dangerous goods that can harm humanity, handling, storage and sale of a number
of readily available chemical compounds like ammonium nitrate that are serving
both mankind and the terrorists at the same time.
In Australia, the Dangerous Goods Regulations had also come into effect in
August 2005 to enforce licensing in dealing with such substances and licenses were
only granted industries with appropriate security measures in place to prevent any
misuse. (see Appendix 8)
3.4.3. United Kingdom
United Kingdom, recommend farmers to secure their fertilizers from stealing.
They advise a ten point plan which shown below: Do not's and Do's.
(http://www.secureyourfertiliser.gov.uk)
Do not store fertilizer near to, or visible from, the public highway.
Do, wherever possible, and with regard to store fertilizer inside a locked
building or compound.
Do fully sheet fertilizer when stored outside and regularly check to ensure
that the stack has not been tampered with.
46
immediately.
Do purchase your fertilizer from an approved supplier.
47
CHAPTER FOUR
SAFETY PRECAUTIONS OF AMMONIUM NITRATE AND A CASE STUDY AT
ALIAGA EGE GUBRE PORT
48
The hatches of the cargo spaces, whenever this cargo is on board, shall be
kept free to be capable of being opened in case of an emergency.
When the bulkhead between cargo space and the engine room is not
insulated to class A-60 standart, this cargo shall not be accepted for loading unless
the competent authority approves that the arrangement is equivalent.
Appropriate
precautions
shall
be
taken
to
protect
machinery
and
accommodation spaces from the dust of the cargo. Bilge wells of the cargo spaces
shall be protected from ingress of the cargo.
Due consideration shall be paid to protect equipment from the dust of the
cargo. Persons who may exposed to the dust of the cargo shall wear goggles or
other equivalent dust eye protection and dust filter masks. Those person shall wear
protective clothing as necessary.
The cargo spaces carrying this cargo shall not be ventilated during voyage.
Hatches of the cargo spaces carrying this cargo shall be weathertight to
prevent ingress of water. The temperature of this cargo shall be monitored and
recorded daily during the voyage.
(IMSBC Code, 66-77,323-324)
4.1.2. Ammonium Nitrate UN 2067 - Class 5.1 (IMSBC Code)
Same as 4.1.1.
4.1.3. Ammonium Nitrate UN 2071 - Class 9 (IMSBC Code)
This cargo shall only be accepted for loading when, as a result of testing in the
trough test, its liability to self-sustaining decomposition shows decomposition rate
not greater than 0.25 m/h.
Other precautions are the same as 4.1.1. except the detonation test.
4.1.4. Emergency Procedures (IMSBC Code)
All of ammonium nitrate cargoes have the same procedures as defined below,
in accordance with IMSBC Code.
49
Emergency Procedures
Wear protective clothing and self-contained breathing apparatus.
Fire in an adjacent cargo space: Open hatches to provide maximum ventilation. Heat
transferred from fire in an adjacent space can cause the material to decompose with
consequent evolution of toxic fumes. Dividing bulkheads should be cooled.
identify all relevant hazards and risk factors associated with the
handling of this material; and
50
51
52
53
Flag: Turkish
LOA: 106.80 m
Beam: 16.83 m
Draft: 7.05 m
Dwt: 6400
54
55
56
57
Instruction to the Ships Crew for the Handling of Emergencies Involving the
Decomposition of Ammonium Nitrate Based Fertilizers (See Appendix 16)
58
CONCLUSIONS
Accidents of ammonium nitrate rarely occur but when they occur, the impacts
could be devastating like 1947 Texas City Disaster and 2001 Toulouse AN Plant
Disaster.
It is a question that need of using AN in agriculture and a blasting agent in
mining industry. This subject is ascertainable.
If the ship personnel misunderstand disregard the hazards of AN, there will be
risks that costs life and damage to environment. I have wished to inspect the wreck
of M/V Dogu Haslaman, which ship carrying AN from Ukraine to Israel, sunk near
coast of eme on 30th December 2011, but I did not allowed to reach details.
In sea transport of AN, there is a risk when the ships that bearing AN, passing
the narrow seas of Turkey.
I think, production and importing of AN with high than 26-28% N content would
be banned in Turkey, because of the higher N content, the more explosiveness of
AN.
Leaning to organic fertilizers from inorganic and urea -has more N content
than AN- usage of urea and organic fertilizers can be a good solution, composite
fertilizers can be a solution that include e.g. N-P-K percentages of 15-15-15, 20-200.
There is no regulation in Turkey for securing the AN that sold to farmers, for
preventing AN usage in terrorism. Furthermore, a few incidents occured lately that
terrorists have been caught with ammonium nitrate before as they planned to use to
make a bomb.
59
REFERANCES
Armistead, G. (1947). Report to John G. Simmonds and Company, Inc. on the Ship
Explosions at Texas City, Texas, on April 16 and 17, 1947 and Their Results.
Washington, D.C.
Braun, O.K. (1953). Hystory of Both Rhine Villages Oppau and Edigheim.
COAG (Council of Ausralian Governments). (2005) Chemicals and Plastics
Regulation Australia. pp 267
COAG (Council of Australian Governments). (2008). Security Sensitive Ammonium
Nitrate. pp 269-280
CSBP Limited, (2011) Material Safety Data Sheets.
http://www.csbp.com.au/Media/MSDS/AN/MSDS_Ammoniun_Nitrate.aspx
(12.11.2011)
Dechy, N. & Bourdeaux T. & Ayrault N. & Kordek M.A. & Le Coze J.C. (2004). First
Lessons of the Toulouse Ammonium Nitrate Disaster, 21st September 2001, AZF
plant, France. Journal of Hazardous Materials.
EFMA (European Fertlizer Manufacturers' Association) (2004). Guidance for Sea
Transport of Ammonium Nitrate Based Fertilizers, Belgium.
EFMA (European Fertlizer Manufacturers' Association). (2007). Guidance for the
Storage Handling and Transportation of Solid Mineral Fertilizers, Belgium.
EFMA (European Fertlizer Manufacturers' Association). (2012). Guidance for UN
Classification of Ammonium Nitrate Based Substances, Belgium.
EPA (Environmental Protection Agency). (1995). Report of the Investigation
Committee, "The Terra Port Neal Explosion. December 13, 1994".
FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of United Nations). (2012). World fertilizer
statistics from FAOSTATS website. http://faostat.fao.org/site/575/default.aspx#ancor
(15.04.2012)
60
61
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/5179014.stm (15.04.2012)
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/3584009.stm (15.04.2012)
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/manchester/3227876.stm (15.04.2012)
http://texashistory.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metapth11803/?q=texas%201947
(15.04.2012)
http://texashistory.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metapth11825/?q=texas%201947
(15.04.2012)
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/cb/OklahomacitybombingDF-ST-98-01356.jpg/408px-Oklahomacitybombing-DF-ST-98-01356.jpg
(15.04.2012)
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-14260297 (15.04.2012)
http://www.cedre.fr/en/spill/ocean_liberty/ocean_liberty.php (20.04.2012)
http://www.denizhaber.com/index.php?sayfa=arama&aranan=Lady%20Juliet&basla
=0&bitir=50 (10.04.2012)
http://www.exponent.com/process_plant_explosion (15.04.2012)
http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/history/famous-cases/oklahoma-city-bombing
(15.04.2012)
http://www.kansascity.com/2009/04/25/1162352/report-surfaces-in-1988explosion.html (20.04.2012)
http://www.oda.state.ok.us/forms/cps/faar.pdf (15.04.2012)
http://www.ohs.org/education/oregonhistory/historical_records/dspDocument.cfm?do
c_ID=B5F03F96-E94E-A4A6-290AB607EF449F4D (20.02.2012)
http://www.wrecksite.eu/wreck.aspx?160318 (19.02.2012)
62
63
Stephens, H.W. (1997). The Texas City Disaster 1947. Austin: University of Texas
Press.
T.C. (Trkiye Cumhuriyeti) Tarm ve Ky leri Bakanl. (2002) Kimyevi Gbre
Denetim Ynetmelii 25/4/2002 tarihli ve 24736 sayl Resm Gazete
T.C. (Trkiye Cumhuriyeti) Tarm ve Ky leri Bakanl. (2004). Tarmda Kullanlan
Kimyevi Gbrelere Dair Ynetmelikte Deiiklik Yaplmasna Dair Ynetmelik
18/3/2004 tarihli ve 25406 sayl Resm Gazete
The Daily Oklahoman Newspaper. (1995) 20 April 1995.
TK (Trkiye statistik Kurumu). (2011) Deniz Ticaret statistikleri. 2004-2010
http://www.denizcilik.gov.tr/dm/yayinlar/istatistik.pdf (10.11.2011)
UN (United Nations). (2005). Recommendations on the Transport of Dangerous
Goods. Model Regulations, Fourteenth edition.
USA Today Newspaper. (2001) "Victims of the Oklahoma City bombing". Associated
Press. 20 June 2001.
Zorba, Y. (2009). Uluslararas Deniz Ticaretinde Tehlikeli Yklere ilikin Gvenlik
Ynetimi: Uluslararas Denizde Tehlikeli Yk Tasmacl Standartlar (IMDG Code)
ve Trkiye Uygulamalar (Trke) Dokuz Eyll niversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstits.
64
APPENDICES
65
APPENDIX 1
UN MANUAL OF TESTS AND CRITERIA
Purpose of the test is the United Nations scheme for the classification of
explosives. It includes a description of the procedures and test criteria considered to
be the most useful for providing competent authorities with the necessary
information to arrive at a proper classification of explosive substances and articles
for transport.
The test procedures allow assessment of the hazard of explosive substances
and articles so that an appropriate classification for transport can be made by the
competent authority.
1. Acceptance Procedure
The acceptance procedure is used to determine whether or not a product as
offered for transport is a candidate for Class 1. This is decided by determining
whether a substance provisionally accepted for Class 1 is either too insensitive for
inclusion in Class 1 or too dangerous for transport; or whether article(s) or packaged
article(s) are too dangerous for transport.
2. Test types
The question "Is it an explosive substance?" is answered on the basis of
national and international definitions of an explosive substance and the results of
three types of Series 1 tests to assess possible explosive effects. The three types of
test used are:
Series 2 tests are used to answer the question "Is the substance too
insensitive for acceptance into Class 1?". In general the basic apparatus used is the
same as that for Test Series 1.
66
Type 2 (a): a shock test with defined initiation system and confinement
to determine sensitivity to shock;
Type 2 (b):
confinement; and
67
Any other result is considered "" and the substance not to propagate
detonation.
2.1.1.1.3. Test Apparatus
The apparatus for solids is shown in Figure 1. The test sample is contained in
a cold-drawn, seamless, carbon steel tube with an external diameter of 48 2 mm,
a wall thickness of 4.0 0.1 mm and a length of 400 5 mm.
2.1.1.1.4 Examples of Results
68
69
70
"F": Tube fragmented into three or more mainly large pieces which in
some cases may be connected with each other by a narrow strip;
"G": Tube fragmented into many mainly small pieces, closing device
undamaged; and
"H":
71
72
73
74
Figure 4: Examples for the effect types "D", "E" and "F"
75
76
77
78
APPENDIX 2
CLASSIFICATION PROCEDURES, TEST METHODS AND CRITERIA RELATING
TO CLASS 9
1. Ammonium Nitrate Fertilizers Capable of Self-Sustaining Decomposition
This section contains classification procedures, test methods and criteria
relating to substances and articles of Class 9.
New products offered for transport should be subjected to the classification
procedure if the composition is covered by the definition for UN 2071. The
classification procedure should be undertaken before a new product is offered for
transport.
The test method should be performed to de termine if a decomposition
initiated in a localised area will spread throughout the mass. The recommended test
method is given in below. Whether the substance is an ammonium nitrate fertilizer of
Class 9, or not, is decided on the basis of the test result.
Packing group III is assigned to all Class 9 ammonium nitrate fertilisers.
Ammonium nitrate fertilizers with the composition given for UN 2071 may be
regarded as not subject to the Model Regulations if shown not to be liable to selfsustaining decomposition and provided that they do not contain an excess of nitrate
greater than 10% by mass (calculated as potassium nitrate).
2. Trough Test For Determination of the Self-Sustaining Exothermic
Decomposition of Fertilizers Containing Nitrates
A fertilizer capable of self-sustaining decomposition is defined as one in which
decomposition initiated in a localized area will spread throughout the mass. The
tendency of a fertilizer, to be offered for transport, to undergo this type of
decomposition can be determined by means of the Trough test.
In this test localized decomposition is initiated in a bed of the fertilizer
contained in a horizontally mounted trough. The amount of propagation, after
removal of the initiating heat source, of decomposition through the mass is
measured.
79
80
81
82
83
APPENDIX 3
A-60 CLASS BULKHEAD CERTIFICATE
84
85
APPENDIX 4
RESISTANCE TO DETONATION TEST
1. Principle
The test sample is confined in a steel tube and subjected to detonation shock
from an explosive booster charge. Propagation of the detonation is determined from
the degree of compression of lead cylinders on which the tube rests horizotally
during the test.
2. Sample Preparation
The test must be carried out on a representative sample of material. Before
being tested for resistance to detonation, the whole mass of the sample is to be
thermally cycled five times between 25C and 50C in sealed tubes. The sample
shall be maintained at the extreme temperatures, measured at the centre of the
sample, for at least 1 hour during each thermal cycle and at 20C after complete
cycling until tested.
3. Materials
Seamless steel tube to ISO 65-1981-Heavy or equivalent
Bottom plate (160 x 160 mm) of good weldable quality steel, thickness 5 to 6
mm to be butt-welded to one end of the tube around the entire circumference.
Initiation system and booster
86
4. Procedure
Test temperature is 15 to 20C. Figures 1 and 2 show the test arrangement.
Fill the tube about one-third of its height with the test sample and drop it 10 cm
vertically five times on the floor. Improve the compression by striking the side wall
with a hammer between drops. A further addition shall be made such that, after
compaction or by raising and dropping the tube 20 times and a total of 20
intermittent hammer blows, the charge fills the tube to a distance of 70 mm from its
orifice.
Insert the plastic explosive into the tube and press it down with a wooden die.
Place the compressed pellet centrally in the recess within the plastic explosive.
Close it with a wooden disc so that it remais in contact with the test sample. Lay the
test tube horizontally on the 6 lead cylinders placed at 150 mm intervals, with the
centre of the last cylinder 75 mm from the bottom plate, on a firm, level, solid
surface that is resistant to deformation or displacement. Insert the electrical blasting
cap or the detonating cord.
Ensure that all necessary safety precautions are taken, connect and detonate
the explosive.
Record, for each of the lead cylinders, the degree of compression expressed
as a percentage of the original height of 100 mm. For oblique compression, the
deformation is taken as the average of the maximum and minimum deformation.
5. Results
The test is to be carried out twice. If in each test one or more of the supporting
lead cylinders are crushed by less than 5%, the sample is deemed to satisfy the
resistance to detonation requirements.
87
88
89
APPENDIX 5
RESISTANCE TO DETONATION CERTIFICATE
90
APPENDIX 6
MATERIAL SAFETY DATA SHEET EXAMPLE
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
APPENDIX 7
DECISION No 1348/2008/EC OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE
COUNCIL
16 December 2008
Ammonium nitrate, which is widely used throughout the Community as a
fertiliser, can act as an oxidising agent. In particular, it has the ability to explode
when mixed with certain other substances. Ammonium nitrate fertilisers should
therefore meet certain requirements when placed on the market to ensure that they
are safe against accidental detonation.
Regulation (EC) No 2003/2003 of the European Parliament and of the Council
of 13 October 2003 relating to fertilisers provides for harmonised requirements,
including safety requirements, for ammonium nitrate fertilisers. Fertilisers complying
with those requirements may be labelled EC fertiliser and may circulate freely
within the internal market.
Annex III to Regulation (EC) No 2003/2003 specifies a test of resistance to
detonation for ammonium nitrate fertilisers containing more than 28 % by mass of
nitrogen in relation to ammonium nitrate. It also specifies a number of physical
characteristics and limits on the chemical impurity content for such fertilisers in order
to minimise the risk of detonation. Ammonium nitrate fertilisers that comply with
those requirements, or that contain less than 28 % by mass of nitrogen, are
accepted by all Member States as being safe for use in agriculture.
Ammonium Nitrate;
Shall not be placed on the market for the first time after 27 June 2010 as a
substance, or in preparations that contain more than 28 % by mass of nitrogen in
relation to ammonium nitrate, for use as a solid fertiliser, straight or compound,
unless the fertiliser complies with the technical provisions for ammonium nitrate
fertilisers of high nitrogen content set out in Annex III to Regulation (EC) No
2003/2003 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 October 2003
relating to fertilisers.
100
101
APPENDIX 8
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
APPENDIX 9
ISM PROCEDURES OF M/V SULTAN ATASOY
115
116
117
APPENDIX 10
LETTER TO PERMISSION
118
APPENDIX 11
Ykleme ncesi Ambarlarn Durumunu Kontrol Listesi
(Amonyum nitrat ve amonyum nitrat ierikli gbreler iin rnektir)
Gemi Ad
Yk Tipi
naa Yl
UN No/IMDG Class
Gross Tonaj
Ykleme Liman
nceki Yk
Tahliye Liman
Ambar zellikleri
Tek Gverteli
Gladoral
Kutu eklinde
Ambar Kapaklar
elik Katlanan
elik Ponton
Dier:
Ambar Taban
elik
Dier
sim ve Soyisim
mza
Tarih
Saat
Enspektr
Kaptan
Yklemeye uygun grlen ambarlar
HAZIRLAYAN: RECEP ORUOLU
119
APPENDIX 13
Gemi - Sahil Emniyet Kontrol Listesi
(Amonyum nitrat ierikli UN 2071 gbreler iin)
Gemi Ad
Liman
Rhtm
Var draft
Kalk draft
Var Tarihi
Var Zaman
Ykleme/Tahliye edilecek yk
Yk miktar
Talimatlar
Liman operasyonlarnn emniyetli bir ekilde yaplabilmesi iin aada verilen tm sorular, gemi ve liman temsilcileri tarafndan kesin ve olumlu ise kutulara
iaretlenmelidir. Eer uygun bir cevap verilemiyor ise bir neden belirtilmeli, gemi ve liman arasnda uygun nlemler iin karar verilmeli ve uygulanmaldr. Eer
sorularda uygunsuzluk varsa aklamalar stununa sebepler yazlmaldr.
No
Kontrol Edilecekler
Eer iinde UN 2071 gbre olan ambara baka bir yk alnacak ise bu
iki yk birbiriyle kimyasal deiim geirmeyecek ekilde uyumlu mu?
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
Terminal
Aklamalar
10
Gemi
Liman
sim ve nvan
sim ve nvan
mza
mza
Tarih - Saat
Tarih - Saat
120
APPENDIX 14
Gemi - Sahil Emniyet Kontrol Listesi
(Tm gbre eitleri iin)
Gemi Ad
Liman
Rhtm
Var draft
Kalk draft
Var Tarihi
Var Zaman
Ykleme/Tahliye edilecek yk
Yk miktar
Talimatlar
Liman operasyonlarnn emniyetli bir ekilde yaplabilmesi iin aada verilen tm sorular, gemi ve liman temsilcileri tarafndan kesin ve olumlu ise kutulara iaretlenmelidir. Eer uygun
bir cevap verilemiyor ise bir neden belirtilmeli, gemi ve liman arasnda uygun nlemler iin karar verilmeli ve uygulanmaldr. Eer sorularda uygunsuzluk varsa aklamalar stununa
sebepler yazlmaldr.
No
1
2
Kontrol Edilecekler
Gemi
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
Aklamalar
Terminal
Dil:
121
122
Yangna veya kimyasal bozunmaya kar kpk, CO2, kum veya ykn kalan
ksmn kesinlikle kullanmayn.
123