S.

No

Description

DETAILED ENGINEERING SERVICES - CBM FIELD DEVELOPMENT PROJECT

SWOT ANALYSIS
Saipem India Projects Limited
Technip KT India Limited

Aker Power Gas Ltd

Strengths

i)Well established office & infrastructure at Mumbai

and this location adds significant advantage from
logistics and coordination point of view. Considering
i)Well established office & infrastructure at Chennai
the field development for all phases spans over a
ii)Executed the design of major projects in Oil & Gas,
period of 7 to 8 years, Mumbai based Consultant is
petrochemical & refineries
i) Well established office & infrastructure at Noida
preferred.
iii) Experienced and competent design Personnel
ii) Executed the design of major projects in Oil & Gas,
ii)Executed the design of major projects in Oil & Gas,
iv)Principle office at Fano,Italy has extensive experience petrochemical and refineries
petrochemical and refineries, including RIL's KGD 6
in Gas pipeline projects.
iii) Experienced and competent design personnel
onshore gas terminal project.
v) Committed deployment of Pipeline design specialist iv) Global offices at France & Germany have
iii)Worked with RIL in the past , working with current
from Fano office to Chennai for the project duration.
extensive experience in Electrical & Pipeline projects
projects of RIL at other locations.
vi) Has in house process for ArcGIS and has experience
iv)Familiar with project planning , control, material
in executing projects using ArcGIS
management and Document management processes
of RIL
v) Experienced and competent design personnel

Weakness

i) Execution centre is not in Mumbai and considering

i) Execution centre is not in Mumbai and considering the
the long development plan for the field,co-ordination
long development plan for the field,co-ordination will be
will be of a disadvantage with this bidder.
i) Lack of experience in Gas Engines
of a disadvantage with this bidder.
ii) Commitment for full time deployment of specialist
ii) Lack of experience in Gas Engines
services for pipeline to be obtained.

Opportunities

Threats

i) Utilisation of Technip's experience extracted from

i) Utilisation of Saipem's Strong pipeline experience for
their global offices on electrical and pipeline fronts
our project.
for our project.

i) Worked extensively in RIL's KGD6 project and can

meet RILs expectation in executing the project more
effectively thus implementing the lessons learnt from
the past project.

i) The Bid documentation submitted by APG shows two

organization charts wherein VEC is almost
independently carrying out work for the pipeline and
well site scope. Though VEC being a pipeline expertise
can execute the part of the project scope without any
concern, there are ares such as at the well sites and
i) Expats to be deployed for this project from their
water gathering clusters which are scattered plant
global offices are for limited time. Any slighter delay
facilities and are required to be executed only by main
on account of company would lead into increase of
bidder APG.
Expat manhours subject to their availability for
project.
ii) When this issue was taken up with APG , it
confirmed that it takes over all responsibility for the job
but the same was not visible in the CTR which still
showed the individual responsibility between both the
companies and this approach will lead into
coordination problems.

DETAILED ENGINEERING - CBM PROJECT SWOT ANALYSIS

HIRING OF LIGHT MOTOR VEHICLES - CBM PROJECT

SWOT ANALYSIS
S.No

Description

Strengths

M/s.Bhagawati Cools Pvt. Ltd

M/s.Sheetal Travels

i)Well established office & infrastructure at Jamui

,Shahdol (M.P) and operates at Shahdol.
ii)M/s Bhagawati Cools is financial strong and ready to
invest and provide services to RIL , M/s Bhagawati
Cools is a Group company of M/s Bhagawati India
Motorized Pvt. Ltd a distributor of Mahindra LMV at
Shahdol and renowned in MP.
iii) Excellent trained Group of drivers available at a
time.
iv) Spares and Services are available at his office
24*7.
v)During failure replacement of vehicles will be
available at short span of time.
vi) M/s Bhagawati Cools is the only vendor who is
ready to provide any number of vehicles with vehicle
registration on the name of bidding identity.

i) Well established office & infrastructure at Shahdol.

ii) M/s Sheetal travels has been associated with RIL CBM project for
last 6 years. His services is good. He is very cooperative and
supportive.
iii) M/s Sheetal Travels is the only vendor who is presently providing
approximately 50 vehicles.
iv) M/s Sheetal travels have trained man power resouces eith good
experience and well conversant with the RIL requirement.

i) Well established office & infrastructure at Shahdol. i) M/s R V Enterprises ia already providing vehicles on
ii) M/s Balaji Enterprises has been associated with us hire basis to Government hospital and Zila
for the last 6 years.During the tenure his performance Panchayat,Anuppur which is near district to Shahdol .He
is good.
is base at Amlai near to Anuppur district.
iii) M/s Balaji Enterprise is also working with RIL Group Ii) Consider the base location RIL may utilize his services
company RGPL . He received Award from RGPL for
during Project work at phase-2.
Five Million Man-Hours without Lost work case.
iv) During project phase of vendor provided 20
vehicles at a time to RGPL.
v) Currently providing 8 vehicles to RIL CBM Project.

i) M/s Sheetal Travels Statutory Compliance not satisfactory.

ii) Out of 50 vehicles approximately 25 vehicles have being hired by
third party.
iii) M/s Sheetal Travels is a firm runned by proprietor and not able to
supply all the vehicles with vehicle registration on his firm
name.Ready to provide vehicles with ownership of family member &
vehicles owned by family members.

i) M/s Balaji Enterprise is a firm runned by proprietor

and not able to supply all the vehicles with vehicle
registration on his firm name. Ready to provide
vehicles with ownership of family member & vehicles
owned by family members.

i) M/s Bhagawati Cools have no past experience of

providing vehicles on hire basis.

Weakness

i)M/s Bhagawati Cools have excellent team of

technical experts and good infrastructure near to RIL
Lalpur office which helps us to receive good services
Opportunities in future.
Ii)II) M/s Bhagawati Cools is new entry in RIL list for
providing vehicles , this gives competition to other
service providers.

Threats

i) Being Financially sound in case of any disputes

arises between RIL and M/s Bhagawati Cools ,they
have capacity to off load their vehicles.

M/s.Balaji Enterprises

M/s R V Enterprises

i) M/s R V Enterprises have no well estabilished office ,he

operates from home and coordination is done through
mobile.
Ii) M/s R V Enterprises have no past experience to work
with RIL.

i)M/s Sheetal Travels is already providing services to RIL and will be i) M/s Balaji Enterprise is already providing services to
utliize for the same.
RIL and will be utliize for the same and for other
i) Services may be utilize in future for RIL Project work at
services in future.
Phase -2.
II) M/s R V Enterprises is new entry in RIL list for
providing vehicles , this gives competition to other
service providers.

i) M/s Sheetal Travels is not able to provide all the vehicles on his
firm name , since vehicles registration is on family members , hence
in future conflict arises between family members ,they may off load
the vechicles.

i) M/s Balaji Enterprise is not able to provide all the

vehicles on his firm name , since vehicles registration
is on family members , hence in future conflict arises
between family members ,they may off load the
vechicles.

HIRING OF VEHICLES- CBM PROJECT SWOT ANALYSIS

i) Lack of experience in statutory compliance .

Ii) Being a partnership firm in future if conflict arise
between Partners it may effect on services provided by
the contractor to RIL.