PAC3542 Reflective Report Marking Rubric #3; Focus Project Development/Teamwork Final report Part B (worth 20% of

unit marks)
Brief
description
of event(s)
(10%)
Emotional
response(s)
(20%)

Learning
and
changed
actions
(20%)
Depth of
reflection
(20%)

Communicat
ion (10%)

Task
compliance
(20%)

HD/D (1)
Full details of incident(s)
provided including the
situation, participants,
and other key details.
Evaluation of thoughts
and personal feelings
generated from the
incident(s).

Comprehensive
description of lessons
learnt from the process
with detailed plan for
personal development.
The personal insights
provided are well
developed and show an
improved understanding
of the inter-relationships
between various
elements of group work
and the students
capacity.
Extensive vocabulary, no
spelling or grammar
errors.
Met expectations on all of
the following:
- Length (1000 100
words)

D/C (0.75)
Clear description of
incident(s).

C/P (0.5)
Description of incident(s),
with minimal detail.

N (0)
Incident(s) not described.

Clear description of
personal feelings and
thoughts resulting from
the incident (s), strong
evidence of selfawareness.
Honest analysis of
lessons learnt and initial
development of plan for
change.

Description of personal
feelings and thoughts
resulting from the
incident(s), some
evidence of selfawareness.
Clear articulation of
lessons learnt or points of
concern raised by the
incident(s).

Description of thoughts
or feelings without linking
to the incident(s)

The personal insights

provided are well
developed and show an
understanding of the
inter-relationships
between various
elements of group work.

Evidence of reflective
practice, surface analysis
of problems and specific
solutions presented with
little or no reference to
global skills.

Limited or no evidence of
reflective practice.
Commentary on events
provided.

Extensive vocabulary,
minor spelling or
grammar errors.

Appropriate vocabulary,
limited spelling or
grammar errors which do
not hinder meaning.
Met expectations on the
following:
- Length (1000 100
words)

Meaning frequently
clouded due to spelling,
grammar or vocabulary
mistakes.
Failed to meet
expectations on any of
the following:
- Length (1000 100

Met expectations on the

following:
- Length (1000 100
words)

No change in action(s)
based on event(s)
described.

- Timeliness
- Topic (project
development/teamwork)
- Anonymity
- File naming, type
- Used a std. reflection
model

- Timeliness
- Topic (project
development/teamwork)
- Anonymity
And only one of the
following:
- File naming, type
- Used a std. reflection
model

- Timeliness
- Topic (project
development/teamwork)
- Anonymity

words)
- Timeliness
- Topic (project
development/teamwork)
- Anonymity