Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
No. 10-2378
GLORIA EUNMI LIM; KELLY WU; CHUN WON HWANG; IL HWAN OH; UYN
SON YANG; SOONAE JEON; STEPHEN GHANG; SONG C HO; JIIN KIM;
LISA YOUNG HEE KIM; JUNG HAE KIM; KUM HEE KANG; KEVIN WU;
JONG HUI LEE; OLIVIA SHANELLE KIM; EMILY SUNWOON KIM; SOON
RYEAH LEE; SUNG HO LEE; SAE RHO MEE KIM; SUNGKYOON PARK;
XIAO PEI YANG; SOK K YI; HYUNG MIN KIM; HYUNG NIM YI; JAE
SUN PARK; YOUNG R CHANG; XIA JIN; JANICE S KO; LINDA T KO;
ANH DOAN; SOON JA KIM,
Plaintiffs,
v.
MERRIFIELD TOWN CENTER LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, a Virginia
limited
partnership;
UNIWEST
GROUP,
LLC;
UNIWEST
DEVELOPMENT, LLC; MICHAEL COLLIER; WALKER TITLE AND ESCROW
COMPANY, INC.,
Defendants Appellees,
and
MCWILLIAMS-BALLARD, LLC; JONNIE JAMESON; HAENG JA KIM,
Defendants.
Appeal from the United States District Court for the Eastern
District of Virginia, at Alexandria.
T. S. Ellis, III, Senior
District Judge. (1:08-cv-00374-TSE-JFA; 1:08-cv-00566-TSE-TRJ)
Submitted:
May 1, 2012
Decided:
June 6, 2012
PER CURIAM:
The
plaintiffs-appellants
condominiums
in
Falls
are
purchasers
Virginia. 1
Church,
Relying
on
of
the
the
sales
During
condominiums
contracts
the
and
course
seeking
the
of
rescission
return
its
of
of
their
thorough
their
condominium
purchase
consideration
deposits.
of
this
are
the
subject
of
this
appeal.
After
carefully
after
warning
the
Fitzgerald
appellants
that
Merrifield
Town
Ctr.
Ltd.
Partnership,
711
F.Supp.2d
576
(2)
the
scope
and
length
of
the
violations
have
to
plaintiffs
and
future.
provide
Plant
their
I,
sufficient
counsel
711
deterrent
from
F.Supp.2d
to
similar
at
noncompliant
conduct
587.
The
in
the
Fitzgerald
review
sanction
dismissal
order
for
abuse
of
consider
judicially
recognized
factors
constraining
its
standard
of
review,
we
easily
conclude
that
the
judgment
in
Plant
against
II,
the
the
district
Altmiller
5
court
appellants
entered
on
their
ILSFDA
claim,
holding
that
they
could
not
recover
for
the
to
establish,
as
necessary
element,
that
the
did
not
err
in
granting
Nahigian
v.
Juno-Loudoun,
1511815,
*6
(4th
necessary
element
Cir.
of
LLC,
2012)
an
summary
---
F.3d
(holding
equitable
judgment.
---,
that
See
2012
also
Westlaw
materiality
rescission
claim
is
under
ILSFDA).
Based on the foregoing, we affirm. We dispense with
oral
argument
adequately
because
presented
in
the
the
facts
and
materials
legal
before
contentions
the
court
are
and