Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Questions: A debater can ask the Speaker if the member is willing to take a question on
an issue.
Heckles or brief, pertinent, witty interruptions are permitted.
Cross-Examination Debates
The First Affirmative speaker outlines the motion (the resolution) being debated and
presents evidence and a plan for change.
The Second Negative speaker questions the First Affirmative to expose flaws.
The First Negative then speaks in a constructive manner saying that there is no need for
change and the opposition's ideas are flawed.
The First Negative is cross-examined by the First Affirmative to force an admission that
the plan is worthwhile.
The Second Affirmative gives a constructive speech which attacks the negative claim's
philosophy.
The First Negative then cross-examines the Second Affirmative .
The Second Negative gives a constructive speech which attacks the plan and completes
the negative case.
The Second Negative is cross-examined by the Second Affirmative .
Rebuttal break. (sides confer).
Rebuttal by First Negative followed by a rebuttal by First Affirmative .
For more information on types or styles of debating see: An Introduction to Academic,
Parliamentary, and Cross-Examination Styles of
Debatehttp://csdf.freeservers.com/styles.html
2015 LEARN - All Rights Reserved
http://www.learnquebec.ca/en/content/curriculum/social_sciences/features/debate/teachers/teach
_typ.html
depth instead of breadth provided by the restriction can make for interesting rounds that often
come down to arguments that might otherwise pale in other formats.
-Extemporaneous debate
Extemporaneous debate is a style involving no planning in advance, and two teams with a first
and second speaker.
-Lincoln-Douglas debate
Lincoln-Douglas debate, a form of United States high school debate named after the LincolnDouglas Debates of 1858, is a one-on-one event focused mainly on applying philosophical
theories to real world issues.
-Karl Popper debate
It focuses on relevant and often deeply divisive propositions, emphasizing the development of
critical thinking skills, and tolerance for differing viewpoints. To facilitate these goals, debaters
work together in teams of three, and must research both sides of each issue.
-Public Forum debate
Public forum debate was established in 2002 by the National Forensic League. It is designed to
teach students to debate in a manner that is accessible to ordinary people, rather than other
debaters. Public Forum combines aspects of both Policy debate and Lincoln-Douglas debate,
with shorter speech lengths and more frequent changes in resolution that serve to emphasize
brevity and eloquence over exhaustive research and technical debating.
Other Forms of Debate:
-Online debating
-U.S. presidential debates
-Comedy debates
Source(s): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debate