Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
1. Introduction
Over many years the liquid-crystal display (LCD) industry
has stimulated an enormous research effort in the development of new liquid crystals (LCs).[1] These are mostly required to be transparent and highly insulating, as well as easily
and very quickly reoriented in an electric field. A wide range
of chemically, photochemically, and electrochemically stable
liquid crystals and additives have been developed to fit these
criteria. However, the continued dominance of LCDs in the
area of flat panel displays is now being challenged by rapid
improvements in organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs), an
emissive and potentially more efficient display technology recently introduced to the market.[2,3] The wide viewing angle,
high brightness, video-rate addressing, and low power consumption of OLEDs compare well with the capability of current LCDs. Unsurprisingly, OLEDs have a different spectrum
of material requirements: e.g., some must be highly conjugated for light emission; molecular energies must be engineered
DOI: 10.1002/adma.200300009
1135
PROGRESS REPORT
cost option to fabricate multilayer OLEDS with the added advantage of being photolithographically patternable.[8,9] The
photonic band-structure of (optically active) chiral nematic
LCs, well known for producing vivid colors in reflection, has
recently been used to provide feedback for mirror-less, solidstate organic lasers.[10]
This Progress Report discusses the potential role of liquid
crystals in luminescence, electronic transport, and photonics.
In Section 2 we discuss the material properties and device
configurations of OLEDs, photovoltaics, and transistors, to
provide a context for subsequent discussion. The charge-
substrate
light
Fig. 3. Schematic of a single layer OLED.
Mary O'Neill was born in Ireland and received her PhD in Physics from the University of Strathclyde. After a postdoctoral fellowship in Integrated Optics at the University of Glasgow and a
short spell in industry, she joined the Physics Department of the University of Hull. She is joint
leader of an interdisciplinary team investigating new photonic and optoelectronic applications
for liquid crystals. Other research interests include the photoalignment of liquid crystals and
hybrid inorganicorganic optoelectronic devices.
Steve Kelly has spent over 27 years involved in the synthesis of many different kinds of liquid
crystals for use in LCDs and about 10 years designing new reactive mesogens for various electrooptical applications including OLEDs and new photovoltaic devices. He is only the third chemist
to report the synthesis of over 3000 liquid crystals. Some of these are to be found in many types
of commercial LCDs. He has worked with G. W. Gray and E. P. Raynes at Hull, T. J. Scheffer
and J. Nehring at ABB and M. Schadt and J. Fnfschilling at Roche. He is now joint head with
Mary O'Neill of the Organophotonics Research Group at Hull, where the use of light-emitting
and charge-transporting liquid crystals in OLEDs has been pioneered.
1136
http://www.advmat.de
ganic film under the influence of the applied electric field (see
Fig. 4). The coulombic attraction between an electron and
hole at the same chromophore site results in the formation of
an exciton, a bound electronhole pair, which recombines to
vacuum level
EA
anode
LUMO
cathode
Ee
IP
SC12H25
S
C7H15O
N
Eh
HOMO
anode
emitter
cathode
Fig. 4. Energy level diagram of single-layer OLED under forward bias. Ucathode
and Uanode refer to the work functions of the cathode and anode, respectively.
DEe and DEh refer to the barriers for electron and hole injection, respectively.
produce luminescence. More sophisticated devices have multiple layers with the luminescent layer sandwiched between
hole- and electron-injection/transport layers. Efficient devices
require the matching of energy levels to minimize the barriers
for carrier injection and to trap both electrons and holes in
the luminescent region.
A high carrier mobility (l), defined as the electron or hole
velocity per unit electric field, is required and it is important
to balance the injection of electron and holes. The luminescent material must have high quantum efficiency. The optical
mode pattern and recombination zone must be matched for
efficient out-coupling of the light. New OLED configurations
are being investigated to enhance output coupling by reducing
the fraction of light trapped in the device by total internal reflection. Finally the materials must be photochemically, thermally, and electrochemically stable to maintain long-term operation. There are many excellent review articles giving
detailed examinations of these issues for the two classes of organic materials that are normally used: small molecules and
main-chain conjugated polymers both stabilized in the glassy
state.[1114] The first system to be developed was the thermal
evaporation of materials of low molecular weight, which form
thermally stable glasses. Discrete thin films of different materials of low molecular weight are sublimed in sequence to optimize the device configuration. This multilayer approach has
proved very successful and has resulted in the best OLED
performance reported to date: a power efficiency of 60 lm W1
and an external quantum efficiency of 19 %.[15] Alternatively,
cheaper and scaleable deposition methods, such as spin-casting and ink-jet printing, are used to form electroluminescent
(EL) and charge-transporting films of main-chain conjugated
polymers. These thin polymer films are also stabilized in the
glassy state below the glass-transition temperature. A power
efficiency of 20 lm W1 has been obtained.[16]
With two very well established and commercially viable
technologies it is not immediately obvious that organic EL
requires a third approach involving liquid crystals. However,
the physical vapor deposition of low-molar-mass organic comAdv. Mater. 2003, 15, No. 14, July 17
http://www.advmat.de
7O-PBT-S12 is a typical example of the kind of low-mass calamitic (rod-like) LCs applicable to OLEDs.[19] The aromatic
core forms the chromophore, and, in a similar way to non-liquid-crystalline chromophores, electron-donating and electronaccepting groups can be incorporated within the core to facilitate hole or electron transport, or to control the luminescence
energy. However, the length and shape of the aromatic core
and aliphatic end-chains, as well as the presence of lateral substituents, must be balanced to obtain a LC phase at an appropriate temperature. Can we justify adding this complexity to
the range of properties required for OLEDs? We believe that
the intrinsic advantages of high charge mobility, low-cost multilayer fabrication, lithographic photopatternability, polarized
emission, and enhanced output-coupling make LC polymer
networks formed by the polymerization of LC monomers (reactive mesogens) viable organic materials for OLEDs.
There are many recent reviews on organic photovoltaics.[2022] Figure 5 illustrates the energy level diagram of a
photovoltaic blended device under short-circuit conditions.
The photovoltaic effect requires i) absorption of solar radiation and the photogeneration of electrons and holes and
ii) charge separation, and the transport of electrons and holes
for collection at the cathode and anode, respectively. Each of
these individual processes should be highly efficient and there
should also be a minimum of charge recombination. Absorption is via exciton formation. Charge separation is achieved
by ionization of the exciton at either a single hetero-interface[23] or over a distributed interface between electron-donating and electron-accepting species. The separated carriers
drift to the external electrodes in the built-in field introduced
by dissimilar electrodes. Distributed interfaces can be formed
eLUMO
anode
HOMO
LUMO
cathode
HOMO
h+
donor
acceptor
Fig. 5. Energy level diagram showing charge separation and transport in a blend
consisting of an electron donor and acceptor placed between a dissimilar anode
and cathode, which provide a built-in field.
1137
PROGRESS REPORT
PROGRESS REPORT
either by phase separation of main-chain polymers having different electron affinities and ionization potentials[24] or, for
example, by dispersing a C60 electron-acceptor in a mainchain polymer.[25] Another option is the dispersal of a holetransporting organic in a mesaporous dye-sensitized TiO2
layer.[26] Power efficiencies above 2 % are obtained in many
configurations.[2426] It has recently been noted that charge
transport is a greater limitation on the efficiency of blended
polymer photovoltaics than charge generation.[27] This suggests a role for high-mobility LC materials.
The widespread interest in organic field-effect transistors
(OFETs) is based on their large-area coverage, structural
flexibility, and low-cost processing.[28] A typical OFET configuration is shown in Figure 6. For a p-type semiconductor,
conduction of charge between the source and drain electrodes is governed by the gate voltage. When the gate is posisource
drain
semiconductor
insulator
gate
insulator
substrate
A convincing demonstration that liquid crystallinity enhances carrier transport was provided by studying the 9,9dioctyl polyfluorene PFO as a uniformly aligned nematic
glass.[33] An exceptionally large room-temperature hole mobility of 9 103 cm2 V1 s1 was obtained, which compares
with a hole mobility of 4 104 cm2 V1 s1 when the same
polymer is deposited as an isotropic film.[34]
C8H17 C8H17
n
PFO: Cr ~ 170 C, N ~ 270280 C, I
OC5H11
n
PPV: intractable
1138
O
C5H11O
C5H11O
OC5H11
OC5H11
R=
R=
R=
CN
R=
gated, e.g., the terthiophene, 8-TTP-8, shows hole and electron mobilites above 1 102 cm2 V1 s1 in the smectic G
phase at elevated temperatures.[37]
S
C8H17
C8H17
OC12H25
C8H17
R=
The transport properties of HAT have improved substantially on incorporation of a stoichiometric amount of a substituted phenyltriphenylene (PTP), which interleaves the triphenylene in the columnar stacks, thus increasing the order
and stability of the columnar mesophases. A glass is formed
on cooling to room temperature retaining a high hole mobility
of 1.6 102 cm2 V1 s1.[43] There have also been some developments in electron-transporting discotic materials. A perylene diimide having high-temperature discotic and smectic
ordering shows mobilities > 0.1 cm2 V1 s1 in the LC phase.[44]
An electron-deficient columnar plastic crystal at room temperature has recently been synthesized.[45]
C2H5O2C
CO2C2H5
C2H5O2C
CO2C2H5
OC5H10
N
C5H10O
http://www.advmat.de
S
OC5H10
1139
PROGRESS REPORT
PROGRESS REPORT
4. Light-Emitting LCs
The luminescent material in OLEDs must have a high
quantum efficiency of photoluminescence (PL). This can be a
formidable task since many molecular emitters, which are
highly efficient in solution, are dim in the solid-state. In solution, PL originates from singlet excitons and vibronic peaks
are observed. The PL spectrum red-shifts and broadens when
aggregates or excimers are formed and intensity is quenched
in the solid state. Various molecular strategies are used to
maintain exciton emission in the solid-state and to avoid
quenching configurations.[12] The aliphatic side-chains of polyfluorenes, many of which are liquid-crystalline, act as spacers
reducing intermolecular forces of attraction due to steric effects. This can result in high solid-state PL quantum efficiencies; up to 60 %. PL quenching can also be avoided by energy
and charge transfer from a host to fluorescent or phosphorescent dopants. In this section we discuss linear and circular
polarized emission and show how liquid crystallinity can improve the output-coupling of OLEDs to improve the observed
brightness.
The luminescence properties of polyfluorenes have been recently reviewed by Neher.[59] He discusses strategies, e.g., endcapping of chains, for eliminating the unwanted excimer emission resulting from molecular rearrangements during OLED
operation. Many low-molar-mass LCs are luminescent,[37,6063]
but there has been very little effort to quantify their PL quantum efficiency. Time-resolved PL shows that the quantum efficiency of the fluorene-based reactive mesogen, diene 2, is limited not by aggregation or excimer formation, but by spatial
diffusion to traps.[64]
The polarization properties of the luminescence from LCs
have been more widely studied with the aim of maximizing
the linear or circular polarization ratio. Linear polarized emission requires uniform alignment and this is discussed in Section 5.2. Polarized EL is discussed in Section 6.1. The anisotropy of PL is given by Ipara/Iperp, where Ipara and Iperp are the
PL intensities parallel and perpendicular to the orientation direction, respectively. It depends on second, P2, and fourth,
P4, rank components of is the orientational order parameter.[65] Small molecules have a maximum P2 value of 0.7.
The elongated molecule diene 2 shows a PL anisotropy of
0.72.[66] Polymers, on the other hand, can have very high orientational order parameters, but the PL polarization ratio depends on the chain conformation. The recently developed oligomeric approach, which combines the high order parameters
of polymers with the monodispersity and solubility of small
molecules, presents an alternative, but chemically more challenging approach.[67,68] High orientation order parameters are
possible without the high-temperature LC phases or the coiled
conformations of polymers. Fluorene oligomers, for example
F(MB)10F(EH)2, show anisotropies of up to 18:1 in PL.[68] A
microcavity containing an aligned PFO samples is used to
spectrally separate the cavity modes for PL polarized parallel
and perpendicular to the alignment direction.[69] A polarization ratio > 300:1 is obtained for the most intense mode.
1140
Circularly polarized emission is characterized by the circular dissymmetry factor denoted by ge = 2(ILIR)/(IL+IR) where
IR(L) is the right-hand (left-hand) circularly polarized luminescence. There are two approaches to obtain circularly polarized
light from chiral nematic LCs. One exploits the photonic band
structure of chiral nematic LCs and will be discussed in Section 7. The other relies on coupling between the electric and
magnetic transition dipole moments. Normally the vectors are
orthogonal so no coupling can occur. Polyfluorene adopts a
helical configuration and intra-chain coupling between
twisted monomer units rotates the magnetic transition dipole
moment giving rise to partially circularly polarized emission.[70] The ge factor of 0.28 is low, but substantially greater
than that obtained by inter-chain coupling of PPV with chiral
side-groups.[71]
The external quantum efficiency of OLEDs is limited by total internal reflection which traps photons emitted at large angles to the normal of the device within the organic thin films
and substrate.[72] The total intensity coupled out of the device
increases by a factor of 1.6 when the emitters are aligned in
the plane compared with an isotropic orientation. This is a significant improvement in terms of device efficiency. Many lowmolar-mass calamitic LCs spontaneously adopt in-plane alignment in the nematic or smectic state and so can promote this
enhanced output coupling. The orientational order of calamitic LCs provides another advantage in guest-host systems
based on Frster energy transfer. This involves a dipoledipole interaction between an excited donor and ground-state
acceptor so that excitation is spatially transferred to the latter.
The rate of energy transfer is proportional to the orientational
factor for dipoledipole interaction. This is six times larger for
perfect parallel alignment of the donor and acceptor compared with a random alignment.[73] Calamitic LCs adopt a
roughly parallel configuration and should exhibit an enhanced
Frster transfer rate. Efficient energy transfer in a LC polymer guesthost system results in an extremely low threshold
fluence of 3 nJ cm2 per pulse for optically pumped lasing.[74]
A microcavity was used to provide feedback in the device.
http://www.advmat.de
The UV polymerization of small liquid crystalline molecules is a well-known technique to develop thermally stable
passive optical devices such as optical retarders,[75] and is an
extremely promising approach for OLEDs because it renders
the thin film insoluble so that multilayer devices are easily
formed and transport and recombination zones vertically defined. Figure 7 is an idealized illustration of an anisotropic
polymer network.
crosslink
spacer
chromaphore
spacer
Reactive mesogens are formed by attaching a polymerizable end-group via a flexible spacer to each end of a molecular core. Polymerization and crosslinking occur either by the
thermal or photoinduced generation of free radicals or by ionic photoinitation. Polymerizable acrylate end-groups were
added to a light-emitting phenylvinylene-containing molecule,
which was then aligned and thermally polymerized in the liquid-crystalline state by heating up to a temperature of
180 C.[76] Photopolymerization offers a further advantage of
pixellation by photolithography, and this approach was applied to OLEDs by the Hull group who demonstrated EL
http://www.advmat.de
1141
PROGRESS REPORT
PROGRESS REPORT
1142
Drop-casting with slow evaporation was used to uniaxially orient HBCPhC12, with a LC phase at room temperature, and
slow solvent evaporation in a sandwich cell enabled epitaxial
growth of a room-temperature crystalline hexabenzocoronene
on PTFE.[85] OFET mobilities of up to 1 103cm2 V1 s1 were
obtained from the latter, significantly smaller than typical values obtained using a microwave conductivity technique.[40] A
similar crystalline coronene was zone cast through a nozzle
onto a moving untreated glass substrate.[86] This allowed selfassembly of the molecules into uniaxially oriented columns
over large areas without using a PTFE layer.
http://www.advmat.de
PROGRESS REPORT
H7C3 C3H7
OC6H12O2CCH=CH2
2
H2C=CHCO2C6H12O
2
As discussed in Section 5.1, the formation of polymer networks allows the solution processing of multilayer devices.
Promising preliminary results have been obtained by Contoret et al. who compared the spectra of EL devices consisting of
a hole-transporting/luminescent polymer network with and
without an overlying electron-transporting polymer.[9,77] As
Figure 9 shows, the spectra are almost identical indicating that
EL comes from the same layer in each case. The small shifts
in the wavelength of the vibronic bands results from slightly
different environments in the two and three layer device.
EL Intensity
(b)
(a)
400
500
600
Wavelength (nm)
Fig. 9. Electroluminescence spectrum from a polymer network of diene 2,
a) without and b) with an overlying electron-transport layer.
6.3. Transistors
The first application of LCs to OFETs exploits the high 1D
carrier transport properties of oriented liquid-crystalline polyfluorene block polymers.[93] The source and drain electrodes
are deposited onto a rubbed polyimide alignment layer. The
polyfluorene and gate electrode are then deposited in sequence. A FET mobility of up to 2 102 cm2 V1 s1 is obtained only when the quenched polyfluorene glass is oriented
along the transport direction between the source and drain.
This shows that the rate of intra-chain transport of holes is
very much greater than the hopping rate between chains:
aligning the chains along the channel minimizes the number
of inter-chain hops.
6.2. Photovoltaics
http://www.advmat.de
n
n
pitch, p
n
Fig. 10. Helical structure formed from uniformly aligned chiral nematic LCs.
1143
PROGRESS REPORT
1144
OCH3
H
N *
R1 = CO2C2H4O
O
CH3
O
http://www.advmat.de
stood, the major limiting factor in our judgement may be nonoptimal LC morphology. Here, we summarize what we believe
are the potential benefits and challenges of using different
classes of LCs in electronic devices other than LCDs. Discshaped LCs show high mobility resulting from enhanced molecular order when the discs self-organize into 1D columns. These
intrinsic advantages can be realized in real devices as demonstrated in very recent breakthroughs in photovoltaics and
OFETs. However, the materials used do not possess an optimal
morphology: they are either crystalline or liquid-crystalline at
room temperature. This leads to trapping at crystal grain boundaries and layer flow, respectively. A possible solution to improved performance is to use glassy, plastic or more sophisticated crosslinked columnar films. Increasing the size of the
crystalline grains is another option. Self-organized electronand hole-conducting channels remain a vision potentially to be
realized using new supramolecular dendritic structures.[116]
The in-plane spontaneous alignment of rod-like LCs gives
higher output-coupling efficiencies as well as anisotropic
transport for OLEDs. Their lower mobilities compared to discotics is not a major disadvantage for OLEDs, where the
balance of electrons and hole densities is more important. We
have shown that highly efficient OLEDs require multiple
layers or at least vertical segregation. The lithographic formation of nematic polymer networks is a promising approach for
this and has the added advantage of photopatternability for
pixel formation. Devices have been demonstrated, but more
research is required to improve the performance of these
OLEDs and to ascertain long-term photochemical stability.
New strategies in the molecular design of smectic LCs are required to lower the melting point and clearing point of the
smectic phases. Other challenges are to extend the color range
and efficiency of LC emitters. Improved alignment layers are
also essential components for many applications: alignment
layers with high hole mobility are required for more efficient
polarized EL; the formation of a well ordered interface for
OFETs requires an alternative to rubbed or friction-transferred alignment layers.
The application to mirrorless lasing of 1D photonic bandgap
structures using chiral LCs has intrigued many scientists and a
wide range of systems have been investigated. Many issues
must be resolved if the phenomenon is not to remain a laboratory curiosity. The threshold fluence for lasing remains high
but there is a lot of scope to reduce this, for example, by operating in the defect mode configuration. So far optical pumping
has been exclusively used and electrically pumped lasing in
chiral systems would indeed be a major breakthrough.
[1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
S. M. Kelly, M. O'Neill, in Handbook of Advanced Electronic and Photonic Materials (Ed: H. S. Nalwa), Vol. 1, Academic Press, San Diego, CA
2000, Ch. 1.
C. W. Tang, S. A. VanSlyke, Appl. Phys. Lett. 1987, 51, 913.
J. H. Burroughes, D. D. C. Bradley, A. R. Brown, N. Marks, K. Mackay,
R. H. Friend, P. L. Burn, A. B. Holmes, Nature 1990, 347, 539.
J. J. M. Halls, C. A. Walsh, N. C. Greenham, E. A. Marseglia, R. H.
Friend, S. C. Moratti, A. B. Holmes, Nature 1995, 376, 498.
H. Sirringhaus, N. Tessler, R. H. Friend, Science 1998, 280, 1741.
http://www.advmat.de
1145
PROGRESS REPORT
PROGRESS REPORT
Abbreviation
Columnar
(hexagonal ordered)
Crystalline
Isotropic
Liquid-crystalline
Nematic
Chiral nematic
Smectic A
Smectic B
Smectic C
Smectic F
Smectic G
Colho
Cr
I
LC
N
N*
SmA
SmB
SmC
SmF
SmG
______________________
1146
http://www.advmat.de