Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
orgJournalofMetallurgicalEngineering(ME)Volume2Issue3,July2013
CorrosionInhibitionofCu37ZnandCu10Ni
AlloysinSimulatedSeaWaterUsing
Benzotriazole
I.M.Ghayad1*andA.Y.Saad2
1Central Metallurgical Research and Development Institute (CMRDI), Cairo, Egypt, 2National Research
Center(NRC)
ighayad@yahoo.com;aya_saad70@yahoo.com
Abstract
Thispaperinvestigatestheeffectofbenzotriazole(BTAH)on
the corrosion of Cu37Zn and Cu10Ni alloys in 3.5% NaCl
solution contaminated and noncontaminated with sulfide
ions.
Potentiodynamic
polarization,
potentiostatic
polarizationandpolarizationresistancemeasurementswere
performed in this investigation. At lower concentration of
BTAH (0.001 M) Cu37Zn exhibited slightly better behavior
thanCu10Niwhileathighconcentration(0.005M)theCu
10Ni alloy showed excellent inhibition efficiency. The
contamination of sea water by sulfide ions diminished the
protectionaffordedbyBTAHforbothalloys.
Keywords
Brass; CuNi; Polarization; Corrosion; Inhibition; Benzotriazole;
SEM
Introduction
Brass corrosion has been much investigated in
chloride solution by many authors [N. Bellakhal et al
(2004);Antonijevicetal(2005);AbdElRehim,etal
(1995); Fenelon and Breslin (2001); Quraishi, et al
(2000);Martin,etal(2000)].AbdElRehimetal.(1995)
investigated electrochemical behavior of brass in
aerated NaCl solution. Results showed that at more
negativepotentials,Zndissolutionoccurswhileabove
a critical potential simultaneous dissolution of both
copper and zinc occurs. Fenelon and Breslin (2001)
haveinvestigatedelectrochemicalbehaviorofCu,Cu
37Zn and Zn in chloride solutions containing BTAH,
and found that BTAH causes inhibition of CuCl2
formationaswellasformationofaproductrichinZn.
Quraishi et al. (2000) postulated 9095% inhibiting
efficiency of aminoalkyl mercaptotriazoles on brass
70/30 tested in 3% NaCl solution. Martin et al. (2000)
investigatedbrass dissolution in a0.5 mol dm3 NaCl
solution, clearly observing two separate regions, the
first of which is unstable, obtained by dissolution of
100
JournalofMetallurgicalEngineering(ME)Volume2Issue3,July2013www.mejournal.org
nCu++nBTAH=[Cu(I)BTA]n+nH+(2)
Youda et al. (1990) suggested that adsorption and
complexformationareinequilibrium,i.e.
nCu+nBTAH(ads)=[Cu(I)BTA]n+nH++ne(3)
Eq.(3)revealsthattheriseofthepHvaluecontributes
totheincrementofthepotentialinthenobledirection
or the inhibitor concentration which favors the
formation of the protective polymeric film. On the
other hand, benzotriazole inhibition efficiency is
lowered when the medium is contaminated with
sulfideions[AlKharafietal(2007);Allametal(2007);
Allam and Ashour (2008); Boyapati and Kanukula
(2013);Khadom(2013)].
Thepresentworkaimstoinvestigateandcomparethe
corrosioninhibitioneffectofbenzotriazoleonCu37Zn
andCu10Nialloysinseawater.Italsoaddressesthe
effect of sulfide pollution on the performance of
benzotriazole. To our best knowledge, there is plenty
workoncopperwhereaslittleattentionhasbeenpaid
tobrassandcoppernickelalloys.
Experimental
Electrodes were prepared from brass (Cu37Zn) and
Cu10Niasthetestingspecimens.Theelectrodeswere
intheformofrodshaving0.96cmdiameter(i.e.0.7234
cm2 cross sectional area. The immersed length of the
rodwascoatedwithaprotectiveadhesivesothatonly
the cross sectional area is exposed to the solution.
Electrical contact to the external circuit is made
through the rod. Electrodes were polished using SiC
papers successively up to 2400 grits, followed by 0.3
micron alumina to acquire a mirrorlike finish. A
conventional threeelectrode cell was used with an
Ag/AgCl reference electrode (0.197 V SHE) and a
platinum counter electrode. Solutions were prepared
using deionized water, benzotriazole (BTAH) from
Aldrich,NaClandNa2SfromFluka.Potentiodynamic
polarization curves were measured (at 5 mV s1 scan
rate) in 3.5% NaCI in the absence and presence of
different concentrations of BTAH and/or Na2S. The
potential was controlled using a computerized
potentiostat (Autolab PG STAT). Potential scanning
started from the less to the more noble potentials.
Measurements were performed at 251oC while the
electrolyte was stirred using a magnetic stirrer. The
electrodeswerepreirnmersedfor15mininthetesting
solutionbeforethepolarizationcurvesweremeasured
1.0
0.00 M BTAH
0.001 M BTAH
0.005 M BTAH
0.01 M BTAH
Potential / V (Ag/AgCl)
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
10-8
10-7
10-6
10-5
10-4
-2
Current / Acm
10-3
10-2
FIG.1:EFFECTOFBTAHONTHEPOTENTIODYNAMIC
POLARIZATIONCURVESOFCu37ZnALLOYIN3.5%
NaClAT5mVs1VOLTAGESCANRATEAND25OC.
101
www.mejournal.orgJournalofMetallurgicalEngineering(ME)Volume2Issue3,July2013
1.0
Potential / V (Ag/AgCl)
0.0 M BTAH
0.001 M BTAH
0.005 M BTAH
0.01 M BTAH
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
-0.2
-0.4
10-11 10-10 10-9 10-8 10-7 10-6 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2
Current / Acm-2
FIG.2:EFFECTOFBTAHONTHEPOTENTIODYNAMIC
POLARIZATIONCURVESOFCu10NiALLOYIN3.5%
NaClAT5mVs1VOLATGESCANRATEAND25OC.
0.020
(4)
Cu-37Zn
Cu-10Ni
0.016
E#
AC exp
1
RT
C/
0.008
0.004
0.000
0.000
0.006
0.008
0.010
0.012
FIG.3LANGMUIRADSORPTIONISOTHERMSOFCu37ZnAND
Cu10NiALLOYSIN3.5%NaClINTHEPRESENCE
OFBTAHAT25C.
PotentiostaticPolarization
Figures.4&5 present the effect of addition of BTAH
and injection of 103 M HS on the potentiostatic
polarization curves of copper alloys treated in 3.5%
NaClat0.0V(Ag/AgCl).Part(a)ofeachcurveshows
thesteadycurrentsobtainedinthesaltsolutioninthe
absence of both BTAH and HS ions. Steady current
valuesofabout0.002and0.001Acm2wereobtained
for Cu37Zn and Cu10Ni, respectively. The presence
of 0.01 M BTAH decreases the current towards very
small values that can be neglected, indicating the
excellent inhibition efficiency of BTAH. Steady
currentsof 7.0x108 and 3.5x108 A cm2 were obtained
for Cu37Zn and Cu10Ni, respectively (part (b) in
eachcurve). However,upon injection of0.001 M HS,
thecurrentjumpstowardsvaluesashighas105Acm2
(part(c)ineachcurve).Theextentofcurrentjumpwas
slightlyhigherforCu37ZnthantheCu10Ni.Inspite
1
C (6)
K
102
0.004
-1
KC (5)
G 0
1
K
exp
55.55
RT
0.002
C / mol L
0.012
(7)
JournalofMetallurgicalEngineering(ME)Volume2Issue3,July2013www.mejournal.org
ElectrochemicalImpedanceSpectroscopy(EIS)
PolarizationresistanceofCu37ZnandCu10Nialloys
was determined in 3.5% NaCl in the absence and
presence of different concentrations of BTAH using
electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS)
technique. The polarization resistance (Rp), can be
calculated by subtracting the impedance at the high
frequency which represents the solution resistance
(Rs) from the impedance at the low frequency which
representstheRp+Rs.Thisalsocanbedoneusingthe
instrument software by fitting the data to an
equivalent circuit predetermined in the software.
Figs.6&7 show the EIS spectra of Cu37Zn and Cu
90Ni alloys. Rp values calculated using these spectra
are presented in Figure 8. The polarization resistance
isinverselyproportionaltothecorrosioncurrent(icorr)
accordingtothesternGearyrelationship.
1.0
Potential / V (Ag/AgCl)ata
Cu-37Zn-0.0 M HS
Cu-37Zn-10-3 M HSCu-10Ni- 0.0 M HS
Cu-10Ni-10-3 M HS-
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
10-11 10-10 10-9 10-8 10-7 10-6 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2
Current / Acm-2
Rp=ac/2.3(a+c)icorr(4)
FIG.4:EFFECTOFSULFIDEIONSONTHEPOTENTIODYNAMIC
POLARIZATIONCURVESOFCu37ZnANDCu10NiALLOYSIN
3.5%NaClSOLUTIONCONTAINING0.01MBTAHAT5MVS1
SCANRATEAND25OC.
10-2
(a)
10-3
-2
Injection of 10 M BTAH
10-4
(c)
10-5
10-6
Injection of 10-3 M HS
(b)
10-7
10-8
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
Time / s
FIG.5:EFFECTOFINJECTIONOFBTAHANDSULFIDEIONS
ONTHEPOTENTIOSTATICPOLARIZTIONCURVES
OFCU37ZNANDCU10NIALLOYSIN3.5%NACL
AT25OCAND0.0V(AG/AGCL).
10-2
-2
3.5% NaCl
-- + 0.001 M BTAH
-- + 0.005 M BTAH
-- + 0.01 M BTAH
Injection of 10 M BTAH
(a)
104
10-4
(c)
Z / ohm
-2
10-3
10-5
10-6
Injection of 10-3 M HS
10
102
(b)
-7
10-8
0
2000
4000
6000
Time / s
8000
101
10-1
10000
100
101
102
103
Frequency / Hz
FIG.6:EFFECTOFINJECTIONOFBTAHANDSULFIDEIONS
ONTHEPOTENTIOSTATICPOLARIZATIONCURVES
OFCu37ZnANDCu10NiALLOYSIN3.5%NaClAT
25OCAND0.0V(Ag/AgCl).
103
104
105
FIG.7:EFFECTOFBENZOTRIAZOLECONCENTRATION
ONTHEIMPEDANCESPECTRA(BODEPLOT)OF
Cu37ZnTESTEDIN3.5%NaClAT25OC.
103
www.mejournal.orgJournalofMetallurgicalEngineering(ME)Volume2Issue3,July2013
3.5% NaCl
--- + 0.001 M BTAH
--- + 0.005 M BTAH
--- + 0.01 M BTAH
105
Z / ohm
104
103
102
101
10-1
100
101
102
103
104
105
Frequency / Hz
FIG.8:EFFECTOFBENZOTRIAZOLECONCENTRATIONON
THEIMPEDANCESPECTRA(BODEPLOT)OFCu10Ni
ALLOYTESTEDIN3.5%NaClAT25OC.
200
Cu-37Zn
Cu-10Ni
Rp / Kohm
150
100
50
0
0.6 M NaCl (B) B+0.001 M BTAH B+0.005 M BTAH B+0.01 M BTAH
Testing Solution
FIG.9:EFFECTOFTHECONCENTRATIONSOFBTAHONTHE
POLARIZATIONRESISTANCE(RP)OFTHEMETAL/
ELECTROLYTEINTERFACESOFALLOYS
TESTEDIN3.5%NaClAT25OC.
SurfaceCharacterization
Figure 9 shows the scanning electron micrographs of
Cu37 and Cu10Ni before and after corrosion testing
in the absence and presence of sulfide ions. Image a
and b represent the uncorroded surface for both
alloys. It is seen that the Cu37 Zn alloys is severely
attacked in the sulfide contaminated salt water. The
attackoccurredonboththegrainsurfaceandthegrain
boundaries (image c). The presence of benzotrtiazole
opposes the harmfull effect of sulfide ions. The grain
surfaces remained unattached while the grain
boundaries attack was much weaker than that in the
absence of BTAH. However; the presence of BTAH
could not totally prevent the occurrence of
intergranularcorrosion(imaged).Ontheotherhand,
Cu10Ni alloy suffered much lower degree of
104
JournalofMetallurgicalEngineering(ME)Volume2Issue3,July2013www.mejournal.org
Conclusions
Cu37ZnandCu10Nialloysweretestedinseawater
intheabsenceandpresenceofdifferentconcentrations
of BTAH. At sufficiently high concentration ( 0.005
M) of BTAH, the Cu10Ni alloy showed excellent
inhibition efficiency compared to Cu37Zn. EIS
showedthatthepolarizationresistance,Rp,andhence
the corrosion resistance is increased with the
incrementoftheconcentrationofBTAH.Theexcellent
inhibitionefficiencyshownbyCu10Nicanberelated
totheincorporationofnickelintheoxidefilmformed
on the alloy surface improving its characteristics.
BTAH loses its protection when sea water is
contaminated by sulfide ions because the stability of
CuSismuchhigherthanthatofCu(1)BTA.
FIG.10:SEMPHOTOGRAPHSOFCu37ZnANDCu10Ni
ALLOYS;(A)&(B)REPRESENTTHEUNCORRODEDCu37Zn
ANDCu10Ni,REPECTIVELY;(C)AND(D)REPRESENTSTHE
SULPHIDECORRODEDCu37ZnALLOYINTHEABSENCE
ANDINTHEPRESENCEOFBTAH,REPECTIVELY;(E)AND(F)
REPRESENTSTHESULPHIDECORRODEDCu10NiALLOYIN
THEABSENCEANDINTHEPRESENCEOFBTAH,
REPECTIVELY.
REFERENCES
A.A. Khadom, A. S.Yaro, A. H. Kadhumj, Chil. Chem. Soc.
55(2010):p.150.
AneesA.Khadom,J.Mater.Environ.Sci.4(4)(2013)510519.
A.M.Fenelon,C.B.Breslin;J.Appl.Electrochem.,31(5)(2001)
509516.
A.Milosev,M.MetikosHukovic;Electrochim.Acta42(1997)
15371548.
A.N. Kamkin, A.D. Davydov, G.D. Zhou, V.A. Marichev;
Russ.J.Electrochem.35(1999)531539.
DaquanZhang,LixinGao,GuodingZhou;Appl.Surf.Sci.
252(2006)49751750.
105
www.mejournal.orgJournalofMetallurgicalEngineering(ME)Volume2Issue3,July2013
Soc.,147(2000)17671769.
(1990)10111017.
S.M.Milic,M.M.Antonijevic,Corros.Sci.51(2009):p.28.
Corrosion47(1991):p.677.
S.S.AbdElRehim,F.H.AssafElSaued,A.Zaky;Br.Corros.
J.30(4)(1995)297301.
S.S.ElEgamy,Corro.Sci.50(2008)928937.
Ateya,Appl.Surf.Sci.253(2007)89868991.
T.Chieb,K.Belmokre,M.Benmessaoud,S.E.Drissi,A.S.,N.
G.Kear,B.D.Barker,F.C.Walsh;Corros.Sci.46(2004)109
135.
12601267
Fernandez,P.Esparza,S.Gonzalez,R.C.Salvarezza,A.J.
(2013)122.
Arvia;J.Phys.Chem.B.104(34)(2000)82298237.
J.A. Dean, Langes Handbook of Chemistry, 14th ed.,
W.A.Badawy,K.M.Ismail,A.M.Fathi;Electrochim.Acta
McGrawHill,Inc.,NewYork,1992.
50(2005)36033608.
W.A.Badawy,K.M.Ismail,A.M.Fathi;Electrochim.Acta
Desalin.205(2007)140146.
51(2006)41824189.
(2000)7880.
Compd.491(2010)9297.
M.Donahue,K.Nobe,JElectrochem.Soc.112(1965):p.886.
N.Bellakhal,M.Dachraoui,Mat.Chem.Phys.85(2004)366
369.
N. K. Allam and E. A. Ashour, Appl. Surf. Sci. 254 (2008)
50075011.
N.K.Allam,E.A.Ashour,H.S.Hegazy,B.E.ElAnadouli,
B.G.Ateya;Scr.Mater.54(2006)16731677.
N. K. Allam, H. S. Hegazy, and E. A. Ashour, Int. J.
Electrochem.Sci.2(2007)549562.
R.G.Blundy,M.J.Pryor;Corros.Sci.12(1972)6575.
Dr.GhayadisamemberoftheEgyptianCorrosionSociety.
106