1/21/2015

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

Like

Share

search...

ArithmeticAptitudeDataInterpretation
LogicalReasoningVerbalReasoningNonVerbalReasoning
GeneralKnowledge
SudokuNumberpuzzlesMissingletterspuzzlesLogicalpuzzlesPlayingcardspuzzlesClockpuzzles
CProgrammingC++ProgrammingC#ProgrammingJavaProgramming
MicrobiologyBiochemistry
BiotechnologyBiochemical
Engineering
Electronicsand
CommunicationEngineering
CivilEngineeringMechanical
EngineeringChemical
EngineeringNetworking
DatabaseQuestions
ComputerScienceBasic
ElectronicsDigitalElectronics
ElectronicDevicesCircuit
SimulationElectrical
EnigneeringEngineering
MechanicsTechnical
Drawing
PlacementPapersGroupDisucssionHRInterviewTechnicalInterviewBodyLanguage
AptitudeTestVerbalAbilityTestVerbalReasoningTestLogicalReasoningTestCProgrammingTestJavaProgrammingTestDataInterpretationTest
GeneralKnowledgeTest
DataStructuresOperatingSystemsNetworkingDATABASEDatabaseBasicsSQLServerBasicsSQLServerAdvancedSQLServer2008JAVACore
JavaJavaBasicsAdvancedJavaUNIXUnixFileManagementUnixMemoryManagementUnixProcessManagemntCInterviewQuestionsTheC
LanguageBasics.NETInterviewQuestions.NETFrameworkADO.NETASP.NETSoftwareTesting
Home
Aptitude
LogicalReasoning
VerbalAbility
GK
Puzzles
Engineering
Interview
OnlineTest

Indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy
@:Home>GroupDiscussion>PoliticsDiscussionRoom

Pointstorememberbeforeyouparticipateinthisdiscussion:
Assume,youoneofthememberofarealgroupdiscussion.
Taketheinitiativetoparticipateandcontributeyourthoughts.
Expressyourpositiveattitudetowardsprovidingthesolution.

Akshatsaid:(Wed,Jan21,201501:27:22PM)

Guysaccordingtomeoneleaderisnotenoughtohandlethewholeaffairsofthecountry.Thoughthereisakind
ofinstabilityinthepresentformofgovernmentbuthowcanwesaythatafteralltheaffairsofourourcountryis
giveninthehandsofthat1personwillhebeabletomanagethecountryaffairs?
Ratethis:+0

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

1/15

1/21/2015

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

Dipksaid:(Wed,Jan21,201509:19:22AM)

Yes,Indiashouldadoptthepresidentialformofgovernment,becauseifweseetoday'sscenario,ifgovtwantto
bringchangeofanykindthenmostofthetimegetswasteinsatisfactionoftheoppositionandpeople.Its
impossibletomakefeelourrivalpoliticalpartysatisfiedwithourview.
Sotheraisestheirvoiceincriticismwithnoreason.Whichdefinitelydelaysthedecisionofchangeandbadly
impactourgrowth.Ifweadoptthepresidentialformofgovernment,andifwegotpresidentwithgoodknowledge
thennoonecanstopournation'sgrowthforwhatsooverreason.
ThankYou.
Ratethis:+1

Debayansaid:(Thu,Jan8,201501:29:00AM)

Idon'tthinkanoverpopulatedcountrylikeIndiashouldnotgoforpresidentialgovernmentbecause:
1)CountriesliketheUnitedStateswhichhasthepresidentialformofgovernmenthaveadequateresourcesand
thecorrectpersonnelinthecorrectplacesforonemantoruletheentirecountrybutinabackwardcountrylike
Indiawhichhasapotpouriofuncoordinatedservicesitisnotpossibletobringintoexistenceandsustainthe
presidentialformofgovernment.
2)HavingMP'sandMLA'shelpinbettermanagementparticularlyintimesofcrisisandriots.
3)Itisnotpossibleforonemantoknowthedemandsandnecessitiesoftheentirecountrynorvisiteverywhere
inperson.
SotoconcludeIwillsaythatapoliticallyunstablecountrylikeIndiashouldnotimplythepresidentialformof
government.
Ratethis:+6

B.H.Gollarsaid:(Sun,Dec28,201411:21:36AM)

Ithink,Indiashouldnotgoforpresidentialformofgovernment.BecauseIndiaisoneofthemostdiversitycountry
intheworld.OurConstitutionmakersalreadywhohadbeenthoughtthatonlyparliamentaryformofgovtvery
muchsuitableforIndia.Theyhadabestfuturisticvisionforthecountry.
SotilltodayIndianconstitutionisworkingsmoothlybecauseofparliamentaryformofgovernmentThisgovtwhich
hasmuchresponsibilitythanpoliticalstabilitybutinpresidentformofgovtwhichhasmostpoliticalstabilityless
responsibility.Politicalstabilitywhichmaynotbedevelopmentorientedbutresponsiblefarmofgovtwhichis
alwaysworkingforpeoplewelfare.
OncewhotheyforgottenTheirresponsibility,peopletheythrowoutthegovtbecauseultimatesovereigntyliesin
people.ButinPresidentfarmofgovtpeopletheycan'tdoaslikeinparliamentgovernmentBecausepresidency
farmgovthavefixterm.SoIndiashouldalwaysgowithparliamentaryfarmgovtotherwiseIndiawillnotlead
anotherfarmofgovt.
Ratethis:+3

Parsaid:(Tue,Dec23,201410:52:22PM)

IthinkpresidentgovernmentisrightsinceinIndiapeopledoesnotgave100%voteandduetothatbuythevote
ofthepeopleduethatgovernmentformisnotcapableofsolvingthequestionsofthepeople.Ifthereis
governmentofpresidentsoitispossibletotakethedecisionratherthananypoliticalparty.
Ratethis:+6

Anusaid:(Fri,Dec19,201404:58:19PM)

Hifriends,
Itisnecessarytohavecontactwithpeople.Soasinglepersoncannotdecideallthethingsforthebenefitofour
country.Theymustalsogettheopinionofthepeople.Ifwetakeaclassroomasinglepersonisinchargeforthe
entireclassformaintainingtheclassingoodcondition.Similarlyasinglepersonischosenaspresidentfor
maintainingthecountryingoodconditionbyalsoconsultingwithpublic.SoIpreferpresidentialgovernanceis
necessary.
Ratethis:+3

Lakshmisaid:(Wed,Dec17,201407:29:35AM)

InmypointofviewourP.Misnotaliteratepersonbuthehavelotofexperience.Hetakewonderfuldecisionsfor
growingyouthfuture.Andsomanyprojectsaretakenbyhimforourcountry.Becausehethinkstochangeour
countryfromdevelopingcountrytodevelopedcountry.Sopeoplearefirstgiveachancethinkwhohavecapable
forthatposition.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

2/15

1/21/2015

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

Thankyou.
Ratethis:+2

Godwinsaid:(Thu,Dec11,201411:14:44AM)

IbelievethatpresidentialformgovernanceisnotpossibleinIndia.WhenwespeakaboutIndiawearespeaking
aboutacountrywithdifferentreligions,languagesandculture.Anypoliticaldecisiontakenalwaystendtohave
religiousorcasteclashes.
Alsoitisnotpossibleforaleadertospeakinonelanguagealonefore.g.inHindiinourcountry.Becauseitangers
peopleofnonHindispeakingstated.Howcanthenasinglepersonmakedecision?PracticallyspeakinginIndia
ourmodernsystemisthebest.
Ratethis:+12

VijaySsaid:(Mon,Dec8,201410:06:32PM)

Inmypointofview,Indiashouldgoforpresidentialformofdemocracy.Asmanyofthemsaid,thereisnochange
inourcountry'sdevelopmenttilldate.Thesedayswearelivingforthepoliticianswhorulethegovernmentand
notforus.Peopleblindlyvotingforpoliticianswhohadbeendisappointingusagainandagainforsomanyyears
bysayingtheirfalsepromises.Thisiswhathappeningthesemanydays.
Sotheremustbeachange.Decisionsofonemanwillbefinalandnoonecantakehisauthority.Finally,Isupport
forpresidentialformofdemocracyforbettermentofIndia.
Ratethis:+7

Suryasaid:(Thu,Nov13,201407:01:28AM)

InmyviewIndiaisbetterwithparliamentaryformofdemocracy,ifanystatefeelsthememberscontestingforthe
presidentcannotyieldtheappropriatedevelopment,thenthepeopleofthestateshouldbegiventherightto
electtheirownheadofthestate.Whereasinpresidentialdemocracythepowersofthestateconsulatesare
limited.
Ratethis:+4

Naveensaid:(Mon,Nov10,201407:46:26PM)

Iagreewiththestatementthat"Indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy".
Onlyonemanwhoiscapableoftakingourcountryforwardshouldbetheretotakethedecisions.
Indiaisademocraticcountrybutintheshadowofthisdemocracyhowfarwehavegone?
Whatwehaveachieved?Nothing.
Andwhereareweheading?towardscorruption.
TheconditionofIndiawasmuchbetteratthetimeofBritishrulesascomparedtopresentcondition.Todaywe
chooseleadersofourchoicebutwhatwegot?nothingmorethanfakepromisesandmoreandmorescamsand
risingcorruption.
Andrarelyifsomebodygotcaughtthenbecauseofhis/herpowerhegotbailandnothingelse.
SotostopallthisandtotakeIndiaforwardI'dsaythat,
"Indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy".
Ratethis:+13

Jugsaid:(Sun,Nov9,201410:32:19AM)

LookingatthediversityofIndia,Presidentialformistheonlysolutionforqualityleaderstoenterparliament.That
willensurequalitypoliticaltalenttoenterparliament.Ourcurrentparliamentarysystemhasfailedtoletquality
talenttoreachparliamentandhadmanyshortcomingwhichprevent/discourage/impedeshonest/capabletalentto
reachparliament.Thetalentsittinginourparliamentisbyenlargeveryaverage,partlycriminal,rarelycapable.If
wecandothisitwouldrevolutionize/accelerateIndiasuccessstory.
Parliamentarysystemwilldisconnecttheexecutivefromlegislature.Therootcauseofaallcorruption.Ifamember
trytoreachparliamentwiththeobjectiveofgettinganexecutiveseat(ministerialrole).Aconflictofinterestexist
therebetweenaparliamentarian/legislatureroleandaministerialrole.
Noelectedmembershouldbegivenrighttotakeaministerialposition.Ministerpositionshouldbegivento
qualifiedindividualswithdueprocessofselection,notelection.Itwillensurequalityministerialtalentwhohave
properexperience/knowledgeofthesubjecttotakedecisionsandleadtheaspecificministry.Ourcurrent

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

3/15

1/21/2015

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

parliamentarysystemhasgiventhenationveryaveragetalentatministerialpositions.
Presidentialformofsystemwithproperchecks,willgiveusthequalitytalentfortopexecutivejobandquality
ministerialtalent.
Ratethis:+10

Srusaid:(Fri,Nov7,201405:18:29AM)

No,inmypointofviewIndiashouldnotgoforpresidentialsystem.AsIndiaisademocraticcountryweareknown
forourparliamentarygovernment.Thisisaunique,soweshouldnotletitgo.Alsoalwaysonepersoncannot
thinkbroadly.Sometimeshe/shehastopayfordecisions.Rulesshouldbemodifiednotchanged.Wecansolve
thisproblembyselectingappropriategovernment.
THANKYOU.
Ratethis:+6

Keshavsaid:(Thu,Nov6,201410:53:35PM)

Asforas,Iamconcernedthatatthispointoftimecountry(citizenofIndia)shouldthinkaboutthatinourcountry
morethan30to40%ofpeoplesarenotawareandnotgettingtheirfundamentalrightfully.
Oneofthemainreasonsaretheliteracyeventheycan'ttakedecisionintheirwellbeingandtheyarebusyinto
gettingtofeedhisfamily.AndonemorethingthatwearegoingtomakemorestrongercountrythanwesternI
meanthatitwouldtakesometimebecausewehaveP.M.ThegreatvisionaryNarendraModi.Andifwetalkabout
thedecisionthenIwouldsaythatweshouldhavebelieveinourgovernment.
Thistimeeverydevelopedcountryarelookingtowardsourcountrybecauseherewearegoingtobecomeyouth
country.EveryMNCsarelookingtowardstousbecauseofourpopulation.Wehavegreatmarketofeveryproduct.
Thisisthebesttimetolookforwardforeconomystrengthen,growthrateofeverysectorwhichhasthemajor
importantinGDP.
NOTTOEXPENDTHEMONEYINCHANGINGTHEDEMOCRACY.WEAREGOINGTOFORMACOUNTRYOFEPITOMEFOR
OTHERS.
Ratethis:+4

SumitSontakkesaid:(Thu,Nov6,201403:22:20PM)

IrespectsallthepointmentionedabovebutNo,Idon'tfeelthatIndiashouldacceptthe"Presidentialformof
democracy".
Weallshouldcreateawarenessbetweenthepeopleandproperguidanceabouthowagovernmentshouldbe
rathersettinganewdemocracy.
Ratethis:+2

Sasankmoulisaid:(Tue,Nov4,201408:19:58PM)

Indiashouldgoforpresidentialdemocracy.Thefirstthingisifanimportantdecisionshouldbemadeitshouldbe
takenimmediatelyforthecountrybutnotdiscussingonitinstagesforweeksandthenpassingit!.
ManydecisionsIndiatookcanbetakenyearsago!Buteverydecisionisbeingsenttoall2loksabhasandare
beingdraggedforyearsormonths.IfwefollowthisitwouldtakedecadesforIndiatodevelop.Inpresidential
democracytherewon'tbesillypolitics!
Ratethis:+7

TomCruisesaid:(Sat,Nov1,201410:34:38AM)

Firstofall.
PresidentialsystemexistsinUSA(UNITEDstates).
ParliamentarysystemexistsinIndia(IndianUNION).
Nowifwecomparethetwogeographicalextentsandthepolitythereinwaybackinthe18thcentury,the
Americanrevolution(177681).Therevolutionreflectsthatthepeopletherewereawareoftheirrighttolifeand
personalliberty(notaxationwithoutrepresentation)andtheawarenessthattheycanformtheirown
government.
Evenafterindependencetheyformedtheir13independentstateswiththeirownmilitiaagainstthecommon
enemy(British).
AndnowcomingtoIndiaduringthisperiodthepeopleofIndiangeographywerebusyinconspiraciesagainsteach
other,nonawareness,4foldcastesystem,noliberalideasnonationalfeelingetc.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

4/15

1/21/2015

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

Theframersofourconstitutionwerewellawareofallthismakingreservationandotherwellframedrightsand
freedomsforWELFARESTATEbecauseitwasn'tamong.
Concluding:
ItwillnotbewrongtosaythatIndiansarewaybehindthewestthepresidential/parliamentarysystemdepends
onthebackground.Infactpresidentialsystemisthenextstageofparliamentarysystem.
SofarsogoodPARLIAMENTARYANDNOTPRESIDENTIALSYSTEMISGOODFORUS.
Ratethis:+5

Tanujasaid:(Fri,Oct31,201410:34:38PM)

Well,hellofriendsIonlywanttosaythatyesIndiashouldgoforapresidentialdemocracybecauseifanimalsneed
thedirectionsthenwhynotwe,aswearethehumanbeingsandwewantsomeonewhoisabletoputastepup
accordingtousanditcouldn'tbepossiblewithoutaleadersowewantapresenterthroughpresidency.
Ratethis:+2

Praveensaid:(Sun,Oct26,201409:31:15AM)

InmypointofviewIndiashouldhavepresidentialelectionbecauseprocessofgivingacountrytomany
dishonouredpersonitssafetogiveittoasinglepersonwhodoesgoodforanationanditwillbeeasytoidentify
ifhedoessomethingwrongtonation.Indemocraticitsverydifficulttofindwhereisthemistakeoccurs.Andits
veryimportanttowhomwegivepower!
Thankyou!
Ratethis:+4

Kundansaid:(Tue,Oct21,201410:16:49PM)

WeallknowthatIndianleaderexpandmuchmoneyoncampaign.Sowehavetopreferdebitbetweenallthe
candidatewhoiswillingfortheparticularpositionlikePM,CMetcandthisdebateshouldbeshowntoallthe
nationafterthateachvotersharehis/herchoiceonthewebsiteofrelatedprogramandonthebasisofthevoting
theycanelect.
Ratethis:+2

Ganeshsaid:(Sat,Oct18,201401:13:33PM)

Yes,itwouldsavealotoftimeandmoney.Reasonourdemocracyisdistributedandforthisdistributeddemocracy
werequiremoremoneyandtime.Ifwefollowpresidentialgovernmenti.e.centralizedgovernment.Automatically
itwillreduceexpenditureonelectionandwillsavealotofmoney.
Ratethis:+4

AnilKumarsaid:(Thu,Oct2,201401:09:20PM)

NO.Accordingtome,Indiashouldn'tgoforpresidentialelection.AsallweknowIndiandemocracyisuniqueinall
overtheworld.Andthroughitweknowninallovertheworldsoweshouldn'tletitgo.Asacc.
IndianconstitutionhasgivesworktoPMandrestworkgiventopresident.Duetothisdistributionofpowersgives
abetterpathtoworkaccordingly.AndinanyproblemsoccurincountrythenPMorPRESIDENTconsulttoeach
otherandeasilysolvedthematter.Whileinthecaseofpresidentialformofdemocracytheresoissomuchburden
onpresidentandheorshehavetotakeurgentdecisionwhichmaysometimepayfortheirdecision.
THANKYOU.
Ratethis:+12

VijayMandalsaid:(Tue,Sep30,201406:19:43PM)

No,IdonotSupportthestatementthatIndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy,Indiahasavast
populationandresidedifferenttypesofcultureandreligion.So,powerofonepersoninwholecountrycouldnot
fulfilltheunderstandingOfthatparticularsituationwithoutlocalMLA&MP.
Ratethis:+17

Sunnysaid:(Sat,Sep27,201407:47:53PM)

PresidentialdemocracyisbestsuitedforacountrylikeIndia.UsuallyinIndiathetotalpowerisdistributedamong
ahugenoofpoliticians.Allthepersonsinapartymaynotbehonest.Ifoneamongthepartymembersdoneany
mistakethewholepartysupportshimasitwouldbringbadreputationtothewholeparty.UsuallyinIndiaa

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

5/15

1/21/2015

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

politicianspendsalotofmoneytowininanelectionitsbecauseheisconfidentwhenhegetsthepowerhe/she
couldlootthemoney.Whereaschoosingasinglehonestpersoniseasythenformingagovernmentwithahuge
bodyofmembers.
Ratethis:+8

DivyaSharmasaid:(Sat,Sep27,201401:07:43PM)

Ithinkdemocraticformofgovernmentismuchbetterthanpresidentialform.Itssimplybecauseofthereasonwhy
toputalltheeggsinasinglebasket.Whynotdistributedindifferentdifferentbaskets.Soevenifonebasketfalls
downtheothersaretheretotackleanddothealternatives.
Ratethis:+10

Bindhyasaid:(Tue,Sep23,201410:04:24AM)

TheExactoptionforourcountryispresidentialdemocracy.InIndiathepoliticalpartyandleadersarerulingthe
entirecountry.Alwaysrichpeoplearegettingmorerichandthepoorpeoplegettingmorepoorthisonlybecause
ofthecheappoliticalstrategyandmanipulations.Nowadaysthereisnowaytopreventthis.Presidentialsystem
isthebetterandbestforourcountry.Itwillreducestheentirepoliticaldramas.Eachandeverycitizencandecides
thebestperson,whoiscapabletoleadourcountry.Ifwewanttobeadevelopednation,itistheonlyway.Let
thenextgenerationmayundergointoajustifiedsystem.
Ratethis:+26

Suyashsaid:(Sun,Sep21,201405:32:41PM)

Hellofriends,
1.Themainbenefitinthepresidentialformofsystemisdirectvoting.Itisawayfromthedirtypoliticsoftheparty
whichmakeallianceatveryendtimetogetmajority,orbuyingofleadersofotherpartytogetmajority.Critical
mainlywhencompetitioniscloseorpartyisnotgettingclearmajority.
2.SoIthinkthatinparliamentarysystemmainleaderisboundedbymembersofparty,sometimememberseven
quitthethepartyiftheyarenotinfavorofleaderortheirmotivecanbeselfish.Sowehavetoexaminethewhole
partyandexaminethepartyofnationallevelisdifficult.
3.Anynewcandidatewhoiseducated,whoisgenerousandwanttosomethingforthecountryhavetomake
partyatnationallevelwhichisverychallengingandthusleadstomisconceptionthatstudentandcommonpeople
shouldliveawayfrompolitics.
4.Inpresidentialsystemwehavetoexamineonlyonepersonwhichissimpleandawayfromshrewdpoliticsof
party.
5.Parliamentarysystemisgoodwhenallpartymemberaregoodandunitedbutthereshouldbesomesystem
equivalenttopresidentialsystemwhichgivedirectopportunitytocommonpeopleandstudentstofightsome
nationallevelorstatelevelelectionswithoutspendingtoomuchmoneyonmediaandothercorruptresourcesetc.
Thiswillalsonotdiscouragethecommonpeoplethatnothinggoodwillhappenforthiscountryandalsotwo
independentcrosscheckingsystemwithequalpowerdistributionwilldobetter.
Ratethis:+27

Bhagyashreesaid:(Sat,Sep20,201407:05:26PM)

IwouldsayaparliamentarytypegovernmentshouldprevailinIndia.Unlikeothercountriesourcountyisa
democraticcountry,wehavebeengivenrightstoelectthemostsuitablepersontobealeaderinrespective
states.Soitsuswhocanelectamoresuitablepersonwhocanbringachangeinourcountry.Electionshouldnot
bebiasedwithcaste,religionoranyotheraspect.Thechosenleadershouldacttowardsthewellbeingofthe
country.
Ratethis:+7

Kamsaid:(Sat,Sep20,201410:36:22AM)

Hifriends.
Ithinkpresidentialtypeofgovernmentisgoodforourcountry,inpresidentialdemocracyatleastalliancesystem
isnotexist.Alliancesystemisverydangerousforourcountry.Inpresidentialsystemonlyonepersonistakingall
thedecision.Whichisgood.
Ratethis:+3

BharatJainsaid:(Wed,Sep10,201410:42:29PM)

Thepresidentialformofdemocracyprovideabettersolutionforproblemsbecausethisprovidethepowertoa
manandthatpersonusuallyworkinthefavorofcountry,thatpersonnotdependsonthepartyorallianceswhich
arepresentlyfollowinginIndia.ThepresentsysteminIndiaisalsogoodbutcandidateselectionisthebiggest

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

6/15

1/21/2015

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

drawback.
Soitwillbeagooddecisionbychoosingpresidentialsystembecauseitwillalsoremovereligiondifferencewhich
arepresentlypromotinginIndiabydifferentpoliticalpartiesandpresidentialsystemisbestoptionforremovalof
thisreligionwisecontest.
Ratethis:+6

Snehasaid:(Tue,Sep9,201403:20:16PM)

Hieveryone!
Mypointofviewonthistopicisthat,Indianconstitutionwassetandparliamentarysystemwasadoptedafter
keepingcertainpointsinmindsuchasdiversityinthenation,natureofpeopleinthecountry,anditisduetothis,
governmentcouldatleastrunthecountrytilldate.Ifallofasuddenitschangedtopresidentialform,thewhole
systemmightcollapsebecauseonepersoncannotthinkinabroadmanner,so,insteadofmakingsuchadrastic
changeweshouldmakesmallandstepbystepchanges.Rulescanbemodifiednotchanged,selecting
appropriategovernmentcanbethesolution.
Ratethis:+24

SaiCharansaid:(Sun,Sep7,201408:45:22AM)

HiFriends!
Indiashouldadoptfor"PresidentialFormOfDemocracy".SincethesemanyyearswearefollowingParliamentary
formofgovernment,butthereisnonoticeablechangeintheprogressofourcountry.SolikeUSA,ifIndiacould
followpresidentialform,Iexpectthattheremaybetremendouschangeinthepositionofourcountry.

Ratethis:+8

SaiKiransaid:(Mon,Sep1,201411:04:26PM)

Inmyview,ParliamentaryformofgovernmentisbestforINDIA.Because,eachandeverycitizenofINDIAhasright
tovote.But,wearemisusingitbyvotingtopersonswhobelongtoourcasteorreligionandwearenotthinking
whethertheyaregoodcandidatesorcriminals.So,insteadofchangingtheformofgovernmenttopresidential
form,It'sbettertochangeourmindandeverycitizenshouldknowhisresponsibilitiesandrights.
Ratethis:+46

ThamilarasiRajendransaid:(Fri,Aug22,201402:51:37PM)

DemocracyIndia
GovernmentMoney
VotinginIndia

Hifriends,
Weareallsayingthat"weareinabigdemocraticcountry"withveryproud.Butitisnotreallytrue.Wearejust
sailingontheboatwhichisunderthecontrolofpoliticalpartiesratherthandemocracy.
Ifwehaveachancetomakethepresidentialformofgovernance,wewilldefinitelyworktowardsthegrowthof
ournation.Noonecanputcontrolonanybody.
Politicalpartiesaremakingrulewhicharefavourforthemselvesonly.Acommonmancan'tgetanything.
SothatIwouldliketosupport"INDIASHOULDGOFORPRESIDENTIALGOVERNMENT".
Ratethis:+29

Raghvendrasaid:(Sun,Aug17,201410:48:56PM)

IhavemyfavourwithpresidentialformbutinIndiaitisnotusefulbecauseatthistimeIndiahassodense
populatedstateswhichcan'tbehandledbyonemanwiththeirsatisfactionsoforIndiaI'llgowithparliamentary
formalthoughitisnotworkingwellexcepttheirprofitofthepartybutwhateveritisnotsoworseaswillbe
presidentialformifitisinsystem.
Ratethis:+4

FirozAlamsaid:(Sun,Aug17,201403:25:59PM)

IamagreewithyouallmyfriendsbutIthinkweshouldnotseeotherscountryperspective,weshouldcreateour
ownexamplebeingnothavingpresidentialformwecanlivepeacefully.It'salluptoushowwemanage,because
ifwedon'tcontributethenformwillbehelpfuluntilorunlessweshowextraeffort.
Ratethis:+4

ChandanKumarsaid:(Sun,Jul13,201401:23:18AM)

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

7/15

1/21/2015

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

HellotoeveryoneAccordingtopresentpointofviewswehavewellknowntoourparliamentarysystem.Inthis
systemwehavecertainaspectstofindoutthevariousissuesaccordingtovotemajority.Butthepresidential
systemvotedbyalsoourselvesbyindirectlySoIrealizesomebasicpointsforit.
1.WhenourSystembeingnotgoingonproperwaythemainactivitytaketothempresidentialpart.
2.AllaspectsofpresidentialformatisvisiblefortheLawsystem(Alllevelsofcourts).
3.Electedbypresidentiswelleducatedandwellmanneredpeople.etc.
LastlyIsaythatthemainproblemisnotthatsystemwillnotworkproperly,thematterhowwetackleitinproper
way.
Thankstoall.
Ratethis:+11

12

NavinAmangsaid:(Mon,Jul7,201411:38:25PM)

Apresidentialformwillbemoreeffectiveinourcountryasourpolityhaslesspowertoexecutebecausemost
powerofaleadergoesinformationofgovernmentwithdifferentparties.Peopledonotgettherightpersonto
governthemasselectionisindirectinourcountry.Democraticformalsoputssomecandidatesintoimportant
ministrieswhichtheyarenotmasterin.Presidentialformwillempowerleadertochooseministersfrompeople
whoexcelinrespectivefield.HereourleaderwillnotbeopposedbyMPsandbestbrainswilltakecareofpeople.
Example,ascholar,researcherandexperiencedpersonfromElectronicsandITwillgetInformationand
broadcastingministryandnotjustaelectedmemberhavingnoknowledgeofit.
Ratethis:+7

Anilsaid:(Tue,Jul1,201408:32:30PM)

Inindia,wefollowdemocratictypeofgovernmentnotdictatortypewhichisapartofpresidentialformof
governmentitcancausecivilwarinourowncountryasithappenedinsrilankabetweensinhaleseandtamil.Also
peoplewillnothaveopportunitytoselecttheirrepresentativesandthereforewhichmayformcanbeacorrupt
typeofgovernmentDuetotransparency.
Ratethis:+11

Pranalisaid:(Sat,Jun28,201404:13:45PM)

Wehaveeradicatedpresidentialsystemmanydecadesagosowhytobringitagain.Presidentialsystemmay
againbringtodictatorshipinadditiontocorruption.Onepersoncannothandlesuchadiversecountry.
Soratherthanchangingthesystem,peopleshouldshouldchangetheirattitudetowardscountry.
Ratethis:+16

AnkitPachorisaid:(Thu,Jun26,201401:03:58AM)

YesitwillbefollowinIndiabecauseregionalpartymakegovernmentunstableandreducethedecisionmaking
powerofgovernmentifpresidentsystemwillfollowinIndiathendecisionmakingpowerofgovernmentwill
increaseandablackmailingwhichisdonebyregionalpartywillbeend.
Ratethis:+9

VikramMandalsaid:(Wed,Jun18,201410:03:31AM)

Wealltillnowhavetastedthepresentpoliticalsystemandknowthatsomethingisneededtobechangedor
modifiedforabetterfuture.
WhathappeningiswejustputourfaithonaleaderandselectaMP(Sometimeswedon'tevenhaveourfaithin
thatMP)andnowourleaderisdirectlyselectedbythoseMP's,nowatthisinstantourroleisoverandallthe
decisionsaretakenbyMP'sandtheynowsometimesaskourleaderforaspecialpositionorbenefitsfor
continuingtheirsupportandsometimesgetsold!sothissystemisactuallyweakeningourleaderandhecan't
takegooddecisionratherthanhegottangledonlyinpolitics.
Whatifweareabletodirectlyselectourleaderandthenhewillsetupthesystemtowardsdevelopmentandthis
ispossibleifweswitchtopresidentialpolitics.
Ratethis:+7

GSNsaid:(Sat,Jun14,201409:47:06PM)

ItdoesnotreallymatterwhichformofdemocracyholdsinIndia.Thestrengthofournationdependsonthe
leaderswhoareelected.Insteadofchangingthesystemofdemocracy,itwouldbebetterifpeoplestopbeing
selfishandelectsomeonewhowouldactuallyworkforthecountry.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

8/15

1/21/2015
Ratethis:+10

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

ZubaidaAlisaid:(Thu,Jun12,201409:02:18PM)

Guys,IbelievethatIndiashouldhaveapresidentialformofgovernment.Thebenefitofhavingapresidentialform
ofgovernmentisthat,therepresentativeofthepeoplei.e.thepresidentwillbechosenbyindirectelection.This
willensurethathe/she(representative)hasagoodeducationalqualification,doesnothaveanycriminalrecord
andhastoprovehisabilitybeforewieldingpower.AnotherbenefitofhavingapresidentialsystemisthatIndia
willremainfreefrompartypolitics,whichisveryactiveinIndia.
Atthispointonemayarguethat,sinceisadiversifiednation,therepresentativewillnotbeabletorepresentthe
differentsectionsofpeople.Butthen,whynot?thedifferentsectionsofpeoplewillberepresentedintheLower
HouseoftheParliament(LokSabha)andthedifferentstatesoftheIndianUnionwillberepresentedbytheRajya
Sabha(UpperHouseoftheParliament).
ThebestexampleofPresidentialsystemofGovernmentisTheUSA.Todayitisthemostprosperousnationofthe
World.AllcreditgoestothePresidentialSystemoperatinginthestate.
IfirmlyadheretothestatementthatIndiashouldhaveaPresidentialformofgovernment.
Ratethis:+20

SwatiSaxenasaid:(Sun,Jun1,201406:31:39PM)

InsteadofchangingthetypeofdemocracyinIndia,it'sbetterthateachandeveryindividualshouldcontributein
eradicatingcorruptionfromthesystem.Thiswillrequireawarenessamongpeopleanduntilandunlesswewillnot
demandforchangenoneofthesystemcanhelpsolvingtheproblem.Ourconstitutionisthelargestintheworld
andthebestpartisthatthereareprovisionsforamendments.SoI'llsuggestthatpleaseactivelytakepartinthe
governmentformingpolicybecauseafterallit'syourownIndia.
Ratethis:+5

10

Vikramsaid:(Fri,May23,201411:37:00PM)

Ithinkcurrentformofthedemocracyisgoodforindia,asmentionedanyofmyfrndaboveIndiaisverymuch
divergedcountry,thereshouldbeoneleadertoleadthem.
AndmoreoverIndiahasthebiggestconstitutionandprovisiontochangethelawsaccordingtoneedoftime.Soits
timetochangeourmindsandusetheavailableresourcesinthebestway.

Ratethis:+5

Vaibhavsaid:(Wed,May14,201408:01:43PM)

Thecurrentformatisperfectforpresentscenarioandsoforthefuture.OurP.M.IfworksasP.M.ofrepublicof
Indiaandpeopleidentifythemselvesascitizenthenwewillhaveadirectlinkwiththefollowersandheadofthe
institution.Consideringthepresidentialform,powersinonehandwillneverbebeneficialforthenation(if
consideredtoday'sscenario)andwhattypeofsystemthenationneedsisalreadybeenwrittenintheconstitution.
Andwillsatisfyingthosewholikesitandforthosewhothinksofchangeinthesystem,itsaverylongdebate.
Ratethis:+3

Aneeshsaid:(Wed,May7,201403:50:41AM)

Somehow,Ihavecometodisliketheword"diversity".Weareculturallyandreligiouslydiverse,nodoubt,but
shouldn'twelimitourcultureandreligiontoourpersonallivesandnotletitleakoutintopubliclife?(will
appreciateyourviews).Moreover,nowadaysthewordisusedbypoliticiansfordividingthesocietyratherthan
unitingit.WeareunitedbecauseweareallIndians.Istronglyadvocateforpresidentialsystemofgovernment
becauseatleastthentheexecutivewillbefreefromlegislature.Politicalinterferenceisthebiggesthindrancefor
policyimplementation.
Inthepresentsystemofgovernment,thebuckstopswiththeprimeminister"oneman"headofthegovernment.
Idon'trememberhimfavouringaselectgroupofpeople.Wejusthavetomakesurethatthepresidentdoesnot
doitaswell,ifatallwegetapresidentialformofgovernment.
Wehavetoaskourselves,"dowewantaneducatedandtrainedexecutivetorunourcountry'sadministration,or
letagroupofeducatedpeoplesupportedbyahostofuneducatedfools,whoarebentupondividingus,runit?".
Ratethis:+24

Mandarsaid:(Mon,May5,201401:36:11PM)

LikeMyotherfriend'shaddescribedupper.
Iwantedtotellyouisthat,IfeltveryawfulwhensomeonesaidthatIndiaiscorruptedanditjustbecauseof
bluntpolitician,butisthattruebecausethatpoliticmemberischosenbyus.Sojustdon'tblamethoselone.Just

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

9/15

1/21/2015

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

gothroughtheircareergraph,andseewhathedoesforusinthatyearofspan,judgethemwiththeirgoodwork
andifwefeellikesothenonlychoosethepersonandseethedifference.Iknowthatpersonsurelywilltakeour
countryonatoppositionandwefeelproud.ThatwehadselectedaRightperson.
Ratethis:+8

Maniksaid:(Fri,May2,201410:10:49AM)

GreetingtoallfriendasourIndiaisacountryofdifferentculture,religion,language,etcwealltogetherare
stayinghappyandfreelybecauseofdemocracyiftheallpowerswilltransfertosingleindividualthetherewillnot
bepossibletomakeallequallysatisfiedtheremaybechancethatthesingleonewillgiveprioritytothatgroup
whichbelongtohisorhersoaccordingtomepresidentialsysteminIndiawillnotbefruitful.
Ratethis:+8

Gaurvasaid:(Tue,Apr29,201409:18:08AM)

Inmyopinionpresidentialsystemforourcountryastherewouldbeonlyonepersonwhowouldtakecareofthe
nationalissueswhilenotgivingdueimportancetoselfinterestsoftheMPs.Inourformofgovernmentthereisno
clearcutconsensusamongMPsandsituationbecomesmessyattimeswhichisinnomannerhelpfultoour
country.
Ratethis:+4

VeerendraSinghSikarwarsaid:(Fri,Apr25,201411:34:43AM)

Gentlemen,Indiaisverydensepopulatedcountry,havingdifferentreligionindifferentstatesandPeopleofthese
statehaverighttoelecttheirrepresentativeaccordingtotheirwish.Theserepresentativeplaysanimportantrole
informationofgovernmentAndlaw.
Thisshowsthatindirectlyeverypersonwhovote,playanimportantroleincountrypolitics.Andthisisthereason
ofourunityindiversity.
Presidentialformofgovtcannotfulfillthecurrentneedofcountrypeople.Soit'sbettertocontinuewithcurrent
formofgovt.
Allweneedistothinkon.Howtoimproveandincreaseeffectivenessofcurrentsystem.Sothatwecancontrol
overcorruption.
Ratethis:+16

Samiasaid:(Sun,Apr20,201408:27:50PM)

InmyopinionparliamentaryformofgovernmentismostsuitableforIndiabecausebyhavingpresidentruleeach
andeverycornerofcountrycan'tbereachedandthesepartofcountrybecomemoreignorantthannow.
Ratethis:+3

Mehaksaid:(Sat,Apr12,201407:09:48PM)

Foryearsago,wehaveeliminateddictatorshipfromourcountrythenwhytochooseitagain.Idon'tthinkthatif
Indiawillgoforpresidentialformofdemocracywillbecomeasolutionbecauseatpresent,wehaveparliamentary
formofgovernmentwhereeverymemberofparliamentworkforhisstatethenalsomanybackwardareasare
ignoredbythem.Ifsomanypersonsarenotabletoworkforasmallstatethenhowasinglepersoni.e.a
presidentwillbeabletoworkforthewholecountryincludingbackwardareas.Idon'tthinkchoosingpresidential
formofgovernmentwillcontributeforpovertystrickenpeople.Thiscanbedonebychoosingaeffectiveand
honestpartywhotrulywantstoworkforthewelfareofpeople.
Moreover,itwillbeverydifficulttokeepaneyeoncorruption,offeringbribes,reservation,unemploymentforthe
wholecountrybypresidentialrule.
Ratethis:+33

Vishalkumarsaid:(Tue,Apr8,201411:58:14PM)

Hereispoliticalinstabilityinthepresentsystemwhereasthepresidentialformofgovernancegivesriseto
stability.
Apresidentialsystem,isasystemofgovernmentwheretheexecutivebranchexistsandpresides(headedbythe
president),separatefromthelegislature,towhichitisnotaccountable,andwhichcannotinnormalcircumstances
dismissit.Whereasinaparliamentaryformofgovernment,theexecutiveisapartofthelegislature(parliament)
andabillbecomesalawonlyaftertheapprovaloftheparliament.Eventhoughpresidentialgovernmentmaybe
morestable,but,incaseofIndia,itmightnotbethatfeasible,sinceIndiaisadiversenationwheredifferent
viewscoexist,anditisjustified,thateverysectiongetsasayinthe'makinglaws'process.
Ratethis:+9

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

10/15

1/21/2015

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

Ragavsaid:(Sat,Apr5,201408:15:37PM)

InmyopinionIndiashouldgoforthepresidentialform0fdemocracybecauseincaseofIndiandemocracy
governmentisformedbymanypoliticalpartiesinwhichsomepeoplearegenuinebutsomearecorrupt.Inpresent
daytherearemanyvoterswhohavenoknowledgeaboutthepoliticianbackground,theireducation,eitherthey
arecriminalorgenuineperson.
Andatthetimeofvotingtheycasttheirvotestothemwithouthavinganyinformation.Andsotoeradicatethis
problemthereshouldbepresidentialformthewholeconcentrationistowardsoneman.Andthismancantake
decisioneasilyratherthanwastingtimeinparliamentforapprovalofbill.Soifwewantchangetheconditionof
countrythenwehavetodosomechange.
Ratethis:+5

AnilKumarSuhanasaid:(Sat,Apr5,201407:22:48PM)

Ya,Iaminofsupportivenature,asthereismanyconflictamongvariousgovernancerulesinsidetheIndian
territory.Herearemanyreligionsandvarioustypeofthinkablepeople.Forbetterachievementandfulfillingthe
goalsofthepeoplewerequireapresidentinsidewhowepeopletotallygoverned.
Today'sinelectingatcentrallevelandunnecessarypoliticalactivitiesareplayingavastimportancetodegradethe
custom,unity,developmentofindia,sotheremustbeafullpowerinthehandofourrespectedpresidentandthe
selectionprocessshouldalsobeconsideredinsomedifferentway.Fore.g.TheAmericanpresident.Theseare
differentactivitiesthatareaobstacleformakingIndiainthenameofdevelopedcountry.
Ratethis:+1

Vickysaid:(Sat,Apr5,201403:02:14PM)

IagreewithmyfriendsopinionbutIndiaisademocraticcountryandpeopleherearediversifiedonthebasisof
religionandcasteism.WhilecomparingIndiawithUSliteracyrateismoreinUSthaninIndiaandhencepeoplecan
understandpresidentialformofgovernancebuthereinIndiaitisnotpossible.Implementingpresidentialformof
governancemayleadtodictatorship.Insteadofit,itsbettertimetocreateawarenessamongthepeople
regardingtheirpoliticalpartywiththehelpofmedia,socialnetworksratherthanchangingthepolicyofIndia.Its
wepeoplewhohavetowakeupandworkforit.
Ratethis:+7

Himanshusaid:(Tue,Mar25,201405:17:39PM)

Inmyopinion,thepresentformofgovernmentisbetter.Themainadvantageinthepresidentialformofgovtisthe
differenceoftheideasandbeliefsofthecandidateandthemajorityofthepopulationasIndiaishighlypopulated
country.Abovethatthepublicitywouldneverbepossiblefortheweakersectionsofthesociety.Therewillbea
newerawhichwouldberuledbythearistocratsonthebasisofcapital.
Ratethis:+5

Jaysunsaid:(Thu,Feb20,201402:53:03PM)

1.PresidentialSystemalongwithMultipartysystempossible?
2.ThecountryhavingaHindumajorityandcastereligioussentiments,relatedproblems?
3.Beingavastcountry,withhighpercentageofilliteracy,informationaboutthemeritofthecandidatemaynotbe
properlydisseminated.Canbeahighnegative.LocalMPs/MLAsmeansmanyseethemandknowthempersonally.
4.Ifmultipartysystemisnotallowed,itwillhurtthesentimentsofminoritycommunities.
Ratethis:+3

SravyaSaahithisaid:(Mon,Feb10,201403:38:12PM)

Indiashouldgoforpresidentialformofgovernment.Bythiswaypeoplewillgetthechancetochooseasingle
personinsteadofgettingconfusedinknowingthewholeparty'sbackground.He/shecanconcentrateonlyona
dynamicperson(s)whosuitsfortheposition.Andmostofthemoneyarewastinginmakingaparliamentaryform
ofgovtsuchasmoneyarewastedwhilegivingpublicityfortheirparty,moneyarewastedduringthesanctionofa
project.Andpeoplehavetowaitforthedecisionsofsomeissuesforlongertime.Ittakesmuchtimeforthe
approvalofabillortopassagovernmentorder.Andwhilechangingleaderfortheconstituencyevery5years,
mayleadconfuseacommonmantofollowandwhoevertoelectnext.So,itseasytoelectapresidentratherthan
aparty(s).He/shewillbeelectedbythepeopleso,he/shewoulddothebest.Ifitsnotthecase.He/sheshould
berejectedfornextcontext.
Itwillnottakemuchtimeinmakingaquickdecision.He/shehastoholdthecountriesdevelopmentso,willexhibit
theirpotentialandleadingthecountry.
Ratethis:+16

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

11/15

1/21/2015

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

AbhilashDixitsaid:(Wed,Oct9,201306:54:56PM)

Hellofriends,Indiaisthebiggestdemocracyandpoliticalinstabilitymakeusthinkinthisdirection.Butpresidential
democracyisbetterthandynastypolitics.Asyouthweshouldunderstandthedemocracyinabetterway.
Presidentialdemocracyistoodangerousforsuchavastcountry.ByelectingcleancandidateswecanmakeIndiaa
globalpowerbyimplementingbetterpolicies.
Ratethis:+3

Gude.Vineelasaid:(Mon,Aug26,201303:11:44PM)

Outdemocracy,agreatgifttous.Asyouthitisourresponsibilitytoknowaboutourpolitics.Therearemanygreat
leadersfoughtagainstbritisherstogetusfreeandestablishourdemocracy.Butnowadaysthepoliticalleaders
foughtagainstustogetmoremoney.Butsomeleadersarecorruptedandworkingforpeople.Wecan'tbuilda
societywithoutcorruption.Soatleastwecanbuildasocietywithpoliticalleaderswhoareworkingforpeople.
Ratethis:+9

AakashPunjabisaid:(Sun,Mar3,201310:19:40AM)

Conclusionispresidentialformofgovernmentshouldbesupportedifpeoplemakearightchoicetoelecta
presidentbutviewingtoourcurrentsituationsisnotthecase.
Soitishazardousandmonotonousforourcountrytosupportpresidentialformofgovernment.

Ratethis:+10

AmitKumarRaisaid:(Fri,Aug24,201210:14:17PM)

Post90stherehavenotbeenasingleprimeministerinourcountrywhoseparthadthecapabilitytoform
governmentonitsown.Coalitionpoliticshasreducedthepowerandprivilegesofourprimeminister.whenitcomes
totakedecisiononcertaincrucialmattersthefearofoffendingcoalitionpartiesrestrictprimeministertoworkon
hisown.Thistrendofkeepingthepartyinpowerhaspushedourcountryintoaspateofscams.Changingthe
politicalconfigurationfromWestminstersystemtopresidentialsystemisnotgoingtobringanydrasticchangeand
aboveallitisnotapracticalsolutioninIndiancontext.Firstofallforthatwewillhavetooverhaulthemultiparty
systemandformtwopartysystemwhichgiventhecultural,religiousandgeographicaldiversityofIndiaisnot
possible.Secondnoonecaninsurethatwieldingallpowertoasinglepersonisalwaysgoingtoresultintaking
rightdecision.Itmightwellendupbeinganauthoritarianformofgovernmentwithminimumpeople'sparticipation.
soIthinkandIbelievethatthepresentformofourpoliticshasthepotentialtodelivergoodresult.citizenswill
havetoplayaveryimportantroleinit.Wemustbeingjustastatisticsonaconsensuschartandactively
participateindemocraticprocess.
Ratethis:+21

SamirKhansaid:(Mon,Aug6,201206:00:51AM)

TodaythebiggestproblemforIndiaisourcoalitiongovernmentbecausenoonepartyisgettinganabsolute
majorityinloksabha.Asaresulteveryimportantdevelopmentworkisgettingdelayedinthecountry.Thebest
waytoescapethisparalysisisapresidentialformofgovernment.
Ratethis:+7

Rajsaid:(Tue,Jul10,201212:19:00PM)

AfterreadingalltheabovementionedcommentsIfoundthatmajorityofmyfriendsgowithpresidentialformof
democracy.See,friendsIndiahasthebiggestconstitutionintheworld.Andthereissharpviewforeverylawsthat
hadbeencrafted.Therearealsoprovisionsforaddingorupdatingsectionsaccordingtodemandoftime.

Thisisthehightimetomakesomemajorchangesbutnotintheformof'presidentialformofdemocracy'but
implementingavailableresourcesinthebestway."presidentialformofdemocracy"istheworstsolutionour
countrycanhave.Decisionofonemanisnotworthforacountrywithworldsbiggestpopulation.
Theactualrootofcorruptionisavoidingitinourdailylifeorparticipatingwithfuleffort.Somehowwehavegrown
withatendencytodoourneedfulbybribing.
Secondpointismostofthecitizensignorethewholeelectionprocessevenatverygroundlevel.Wedon'ttryto
knowaboutbackgroundofthecandidatesliketheireducationetc.
Weshouldhaverighttoboycotelectionifmajorityofusfoundthatpartiesinvolvedarenotgood.
Ratethis:+43

AkramAlisaid:(Fri,Jul6,201203:48:25AM)

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

12/15

1/21/2015

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

Presidentialsystemmaybeanalternatetogetridofffromthecurrentfacingproblems.Ithinknowthetimeshave
tobecometoseesomechangesincurrentpoliticalsystemsothereismanyalternatetochangetheexisting
systembutwearetakingalternateasparliamentarysystem.
Inparliamentarysystemitseasyforpeopletoelectasuitable,honestanddeservingcandidatebuttheproblem
comeoutfromparliamentarysystemisthat'sit'svarydifficulttoustochoose455MPinwhichallarehonestand
loyalfornationsoIthinkpresidentialsystemisgoodalternateforthedevelopingnation.
Ratethis:+13

SunilZutshisaid:(Wed,Jul4,201201:10:10PM)

Lawshavetobemade,thepersonwhocomestopower,shouldbelimitedto3yearsinsteadof5years,with
conditionthatifhedoesn'tachievethesaiddevelopmentworkwithintheseyears,willnotbeallowedtocontest
future&alsopenaltyshouldbeimposed.Secondindependentbodiesshouldcheckprogressofgovtonallfronts
regularly&submitthereport.Nopersonwithslightofcriminalrecord,shouldnotbeallowedinpolitics.Theseare
fewstepsthatcanbetakenonurgentbasis.
Ratethis:+20

Praveensaid:(Sat,Jun9,201204:17:48PM)

Beitparliamentaryformofgovernmentorpresidential,curruptioncannotbeuprooteduntilandunlesspeopleof
Indiawakeup.Politiciansarethemirrorsofoursociety.Ifwesaycaste,theysaycasteifwesaydevelopmment,
theysaydevelopmment.Foregreservation.Thisisoneoftheformsofcurruption.Whetheritisparliamentary
formofgovernmentorpresidential,majoritywillalwaysrule.
Ratethis:+7

KeshavShetyesaid:(Mon,Mar12,201205:14:11PM)

YesitishightimeforIndiatogoforanPresidentialformofgovernmentPresentlyinourcountryyoucannotfinda
singlepartybeitcongress,BJP,NCP,RJD,SP,BSPandotherregionalpartiesareworthlessgoodfornothing,over
theyearstheyhavehadmadeaverybigdamagetothecountry,Thesepartiesarediseasesworstthancancer,
Aids.IndemocracyweneedmajorchangethtwouldbringtheyoungstersrightfromPanchayat,Nagarsevak,MLA,
MPnewfacesandthrowoutthecurrentpoliticiansinpoliticsnoneofthemis.AffectionatalybeingcalledPolitical
animals.Theyarevultures,mosquitossuckingbloodsofourindiansandhellbendonprovingthelegendsmartyars
suchasSirSubhashChandraBose,TrioBhagatSingh,Sukhadev,Rajguru,Chandrasekharandothers,hatsoffto
those.
Ratethis:+13

22

Sudhakarsaid:(Mon,Jan30,201202:22:43PM)

Inourcountrythecorruptionisoccurduetodemocracysystem.Ifwegettingthepresidentialgovernmentmeans
noonebethebelowofpovertyline.
Ratethis:+6

12

Vikassaid:(Sat,Dec31,201109:16:03AM)

IfwecanlearnbyUnitedStatesofAmerica,thenformagovernamentlikethiersoramorebetteronewitha
flexibleeconomy&adirectlinkofPeoplewithPresidentisestablished,thenforsureapresidentialdemocracyis
thebestone.
Ratethis:+10

Sonaleesaid:(Thu,Aug4,201112:23:22PM)

Ithinksuchatypeofdemocracytoelectindia'spresidentbypeoplewillnothelpinanymannerbecausewewant
tofinishcorruptiontotallyfromIndiawhichdependonindivisual'smindwhichwecantchange.
Ratethis:+7

SamirDevnanisaid:(Thu,Jul21,201108:43:18PM)

IthinkthatpresidentialdemocracyisthebestforIndiaasthenwecanblameonlyonepersonresponsibleforthe
corruptionoranythingwhichgoeswrongwhichisthepresident.ifwesucceedinelectingagoodpresidentwe
shallbeabletostoptheblamegameweplayinIndianpoliticsandshallbeabletocometoadecisionfaster.
Ratethis:+8

26

Annsaid:(Sun,May8,201110:02:14AM)

WethepeopleofourCountryhaverighttoelecttherightpersonfortherightjobbutyousayIswearedoingthe

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

13/15

1/21/2015

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

same.
Ratethis:+8

12

Rajeshsaid:(Mon,Feb28,201106:21:07AM)

YesIsupport"Indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy"becausewhyshouldfollowthiswhichis
nowalmostuselessforINDIA,severalpoliticalpartyhasraisewhocreatesconfusionandunstablegovernment&
country.Expenseonelectionburiedthecountryspeciallymiddleman&poorclassofcountryifwefollowthe
presidentialformthenwehaveoneleaderresponsibleforalldecision,andIndiawillbemuchmorestrongerthen
presentlikeUSA,chinawhofollowthis.Friendsyoursuggestion&criticismisvaluable.
Ratethis:+39

Priyasaid:(Sun,Jun20,201001:19:35AM)

Thereispoliticalinstabilityinthepresentsystemwhereasthepresidentialformofgovernancegivesriseto
stability.
Apresidentialsystem,isasystemofgovernmentwheretheexecutivebranchexistsandpresides(headedbythe
president),separatefromthelegislature,towhichitisnotaccountable,andwhichcannotinnormalcircumstances
dismissit.Whereasinaparliamentaryformofgovt.,theexecutiveisapartofthelegislature(parliament)anda
billbecomesalawonlyaftertheapprovaloftheparliament.Eventhoughpresidentialgovt.maybemorestable,
but,incaseofIndia,itmightnotbethatfeasible,sinceIndiaisadiversenationwheredifferentviewscoexist,
anditisjustified,thateverysectiongetsasayinthe'makinglaws'process
Ratethis:+44

SpeakYourMind:

...

Pleasedonotusechatterms.Example:avoidusing"grt"insteadof"great".

Submit

Relatedtopics:
RulesareMeanttobeBroken
ShouldSmokingbeBannedCompletely?
CanOneContributetotheSocialSectorwhileBeingEmployedintheCorporateWorld?
TheNostradamusCode:WorldWarIII
Inoureconomicmatters,thereisanexcessivetendencytowardsthethinkingratherthandoing.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

14/15

1/21/2015

IndiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracyGroupDiscussion

20082014byIndiaBIX T echnologies.AllRightsReserved|Copyright|T ermsofUse&PrivacyPolicy

Contactus:info@indiabix.com
Bookmarkto:

Followusontwitte r!

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/indiashouldgoforthepresidentialformofdemocracy/

15/15