1/21/2015

Presidentialv/sParliamentaryFormofGovernmentinIndiaGroupDiscussion

Like

Share

search...

ArithmeticAptitudeDataInterpretation
LogicalReasoningVerbalReasoningNonVerbalReasoning
GeneralKnowledge
SudokuNumberpuzzlesMissingletterspuzzlesLogicalpuzzlesPlayingcardspuzzlesClockpuzzles
CProgrammingC++ProgrammingC#ProgrammingJavaProgramming
MicrobiologyBiochemistry
BiotechnologyBiochemical
Engineering
Electronicsand
CommunicationEngineering
CivilEngineeringMechanical
EngineeringChemical
EngineeringNetworking
DatabaseQuestions
ComputerScienceBasic
ElectronicsDigitalElectronics
ElectronicDevicesCircuit
SimulationElectrical
EnigneeringEngineering
MechanicsTechnical
Drawing
PlacementPapersGroupDisucssionHRInterviewTechnicalInterviewBodyLanguage
AptitudeTestVerbalAbilityTestVerbalReasoningTestLogicalReasoningTestCProgrammingTestJavaProgrammingTestDataInterpretationTest
GeneralKnowledgeTest
DataStructuresOperatingSystemsNetworkingDATABASEDatabaseBasicsSQLServerBasicsSQLServerAdvancedSQLServer2008JAVACore
JavaJavaBasicsAdvancedJavaUNIXUnixFileManagementUnixMemoryManagementUnixProcessManagemntCInterviewQuestionsTheC
LanguageBasics.NETInterviewQuestions.NETFrameworkADO.NETASP.NETSoftwareTesting
Home
Aptitude
LogicalReasoning
VerbalAbility
GK
Puzzles
Engineering
Interview
OnlineTest

Presidentialv/sParliamentaryFormofGovernmentin
India
@:Home>GroupDiscussion>PoliticsDiscussionRoom

Pointstorememberbeforeyouparticipateinthisdiscussion:
Assume,youoneofthememberofarealgroupdiscussion.
Taketheinitiativetoparticipateandcontributeyourthoughts.
Expressyourpositiveattitudetowardsprovidingthesolution.

Sonu,Akshay,Samadhansaid:(Tue,Jan20,201512:08:13PM)

IthinkparliamentaryformofgovtismorebetterthanpresidentialformofgovernmentItworkdemocraticallyand
onthatthecontrolofallpeoples.Theyarebindingwithpeopleandforthework.Theparliamentaryformcontrol
ongovt.Andifanycouncilofministerismisusethatpower,thenrepresentativeofparliamentaskthequestionto
thegovt.Duetothisitiseasytodismissthegovt.Inpresidentialformofgovt,itisdifficulttoremovethegovt.In

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/presidentialvsparliamentaryformofgovernmentinindia/

1/13

1/21/2015

Presidentialv/sParliamentaryFormofGovernmentinIndiaGroupDiscussion

this1mancantakealldecisionsometimesbutinParliamentarywhichisnotallowed.
Ratethis:+0

PawanKumarsaid:(Wed,Dec31,201412:11:26PM)

Formebothparliamentaryandpresidentialsystemhavetheirownmeritsanddemerits.Ifwelookinthe
parliamentarysystemthenthegoodthingisthatthereisnooneisasinglebossofthewholesystem.
Becausethedecisionsaretakenforthecountrypeopleandthatshouldbetakenbaythegroupofpeopleselected
bythepeopleofthecountryfortheirrightsandreligionissue.Whileontheothersideofthisisthateverytimeall
ofthemarenotagreeonthesamepointeveryonehavetheirownopinionandtheycanconflicteachother
opinion.Thismayleaddelayinsomeimportantdecisionsormaybeneedtoneglectthedecisioncompletely.
Onthepresidentialsystemallthepowerisinthehandofonepersonandheisresponsiblefortakingallthe
decisionandhecantakedecisionwithoutanypermissionormajority.Thatwillremoveallthedemeritsofthe
previouslydiscussedsystem.Butthissystemisgoodforthoseareawherethepeoplesareofonereligionora
largemajorityofthat.
ButnotforthecountrylikeIndiabecausetherearealmostallthereligionspeopleandalmost1000andabove
casts.Singlepersonwillbeofsinglereligionorcastmaybeitispossiblethatheisverygoodtotakedecisionsfor
thecountryandisabovetheseallthingslikecastsandreligionsbuthecan'tgeneratefaithinallthereligion.
SoformePresidentialcanbegoodforthecountrylikeUSAbutnotforourcountry.Yesthissystemleaddelayin
thedecisionsbutwecan'tavoidtheimportanceofinvolvingallinthedecision.
Ratethis:+6

AnshulaSonisaid:(Mon,Dec29,201405:40:50PM)

Ithinkparliamentaryformofgovernmentismorebetter,aseverydecisionistakencollectivelybythe
representativesofthepeoplebelongingtodifferentstates.
Ratethis:+5

RamyaKRsaid:(Fri,Dec19,201407:37:23PM)

Accordingtome,parliamentaryformofgovtisgood.Indiaisasecondlargestnationintheworldwhichhas
differentreligion,castesotakingdecisioningroupisbetterthanindividual.Inparliamentaryformofgovernment
decisionhavetakenthroughgroup.
Incaseofpresidentialformofgovt,allthepowerisinhandofsinglepersontheyonlytookthedecisionitsnot
goodbecausetheirischanceofmisusingthepower.Parliamentaryformhavetakenmoretimetotakedecision
becausedifferentpeoplehavingdifferentopinioncausesreputesbutthedecisionmustbefirm.
Ratethis:+5

Mansisaid:(Mon,Dec15,201405:07:53PM)

Ibelievethatparliamentaryformofgovernmentisbetterthanpresidentialformofgovernmentbecauseifwe
wouldseeinparliamentaryformofgovernmentallthepowersarenotinthehandsofonepersoninsteadofthat
theirisateamtotakeacollectivedecisionwithamajorityofmanypeople.Butinthepresidentialformof
governmenttherealpowerisinthehandsofonlyoneperson.
Itmayalsohappenthatthedecisiontakencouldnotbegoodforeveryoneandwouldaffectthecountrymen.But
whenacollectivedecisionistakentheirisnosuchchance.Althoughinsuchdecisionsthetimeistakenbutthe
finalresultismostlyacceptedbyall.
Ratethis:+5

Sitharasaid:(Thu,Oct23,201408:44:28AM)

IbelieveparliamentaryformofgovernmentisgoodinIndia.Indiaiscountryofvastpopulationwithdifferent
caste,religionsandpeoplewithvaryingfinancialstatus.Agovernmentshouldbeasystemwithbetter
understandingofthecountry'sproblems.Aparliamentaryformofgovernmentholdsrepresentativesofdifferent
categoriesofpeopleinournation.
Ratethis:+25

SrujanaVenkateshsaid:(Thu,Sep25,201408:51:56PM)

Ifeelthattoselectforprimeministerorforpresidentmustkeepatest,thetoptenpersonsareeligiblein
elections.Andhe/sheshouldnothaveanycriminalrecordandshouldbeasocialworker.
Ifthisispossiblewhateverthesystemisgood.Herethepersonisimportantnotthesystem.
Ratethis:+18

16

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/presidentialvsparliamentaryformofgovernmentinindia/

2/13

1/21/2015

Presidentialv/sParliamentaryFormofGovernmentinIndiaGroupDiscussion

Avinashsaid:(Tue,Aug26,201403:46:26PM)

Inmypointofviewparliamentaryformisfarbetterthanpresidentialform.IfpresidentialformisoptedbyIndians
thanthedayisnotsofarwhenarmytrytotakeoverthegovernmentlikeArabcountries.
UnityindiversityisthebackboneofIndiaandourcountryisacombinationof1000casteandnumberofreligion
andtheirgroups.Allgroupswantstheirrepresentativeingovttoprojecttheirminorbutsoimportantissuesto
sortout.Inthesecasepresidentialformisnotsuccessful.Thankforlisteningme.
Ratethis:+32

17

Moumitasaid:(Fri,Aug22,201410:18:19PM)

Iamsurethatyoudon'trememberthatwhenwewerenotfree,allIndiansparticipatedequallyinthefighttoget
freedom.Soourconstitutionchosetheparliamentarysystemofdemocracysothatalltheethnicgroups,religious
groupsandthetribalgroupshaveequalrights.IfyoustudythehistoryofdemocracythenIndiawatheonly
countrywherewomendidn'thadtofightfortheirvotingright.
Sowhenwearelivinginafreecountryforwhicheveryoneofourpeershadfoughtfor,whyshouldtherebeonly
onepersonandhis/hercolleagueswithallthepowerstorunthecountry.Allsystemshastheirdemerits.Anditis
truethatthemultipartysysteminIndialeadtoalotofpoliticsandcorruptionbutifpresidentialformof
governmentcomesinthentherewouldbeabiggerproblem.Indiawillbefightingforindependenceagainoreach
statewillbefightingtobefreefromIndia.Thinkaboutit.Isn'titthepoliticalsystemIndiaresponsibleforthefact
thatthecountryisnotdisintegratedintosmallercountriesinsteadofstates?
Ratethis:+32

RishabhAgnihotrisaid:(Fri,Aug15,201404:12:51PM)

PresidentialformofGovernmentisinarguablytheneedofthehourforIndiabecausethisformofgovernmentdoes
awaywiththisnewconceptof"proxyheadofstate"whichhasbeenthereasonforIndia'srecentwoes.Moreover
having100+partiescompetingatthenationallevelmaketheelectionprocesscomplicatedandcumbersome
ratherthanofferingmorechoicestovotersasisperceivedbecausethemajorplayerinIndianpoliticsarejusta
fewparties.
Ontheotherhandthepresidentialformofelectionsisafightbetweentwoleadersandthevotershaveaclearcut
ideaaboutwhomthearevotingfor.Thisleavesnoroomforlastminutechangeofpowerandleavesnoroomfor
defecation.
Ratethis:+14

15

Lillysaid:(Tue,Jul15,201409:21:38PM)

Ithinkparliamentaryformofgovernmentisbetterastheseareparticipationbypeopleinthedecisionmaking
processandgovernmentbyconsent.Oneofthecommonlyattributedadvantagesofparliamentarysystemisthat
itisfasterandeasiertopasslegislation,astheexecutivebranchisdependentonthedirectandindirectsupport
oflegislativebranchandoftenincludesmembersoflegislature.Thustheexecutivehasamajorityofthevotes,
enablingthemtopasslegislation.Inaparliamentarysystem,withacollegialexecutive,powerismoredivided.
Ratethis:+14

Ramachandransaid:(Thu,Jul3,201412:28:33PM)

HavingaPresidentialformofgovernmentforcertainperiodassaidbyKavyaistheneedoftodayinIndia.Thiswill
helptoweedoutcorruptiontosomeextent.Whenwearenotabletocontroltheleadersfromsuchevils,by
invitingaPresidentialsystemwecanatleastmakethemtosleepforsomeperiod.
Ratethis:+12

23

ThakurjiGuptasaid:(Fri,May23,201410:22:27AM)

Asifwewantsomechangesinourlifethenwehavetochangeourhabit,followethicalvalues,notinvolvein
corruptionetc.AfterfollowingallthementionedpointwecanchangeourIndiainnext20years.
Idon'tthinkthatPresidentialformofgovernmentcanbehelpfulforIndiabecauseIndiaisvastdiverseofreligious
peoplelivingtogether,fromKashmirtoKanyakumariandGujarattoAssam,havedifferentlanguage,wayofliving,
andthinking.
Thisiscan'tbehandlebyjustoneortwopartysoparliamentaryformofgovernmentisneededtobindtogether.
SopresidentialformofgovernmentwillnotapplicableinpopulouscountrylikeIndia.

Ratethis:+29

13

RivuGhataksaid:(Tue,May20,201401:34:07PM)

Anumberofkeytheoreticaldifferencesexistbetweenapresidentialandaparliamentarysystem:

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/presidentialvsparliamentaryformofgovernmentinindia/

3/13

1/21/2015

Presidentialv/sParliamentaryFormofGovernmentinIndiaGroupDiscussion

Inapresidentialsystem,thecentralprincipleisthatthelegislativeandexecutivebranchesofgovernmentare
separate.Thisleadstotheseparateelectionofpresident,whoiselectedtoofficeforafixedterm,andonly
removableforgrossmisdemeanorbyimpeachmentanddismissal.Inadditionheorshedoesnotneedtochoose
cabinetmemberscommandingthesupportofthelegislature.Bycontrast,inparliamentarianism,theexecutive
branchisledbyacouncilofministers,headedbyaPrimeMinister,whoaredirectlyaccountabletothelegislature
andoftenhavetheirbackgroundinthelegislature(regardlessofwhetheritiscalleda"parliament",assembly,a
"diet",ora"chamber").
Aswiththepresident'ssettermofoffice,thelegislaturealsoexistsforasettermofofficeandcannotbe
dissolvedaheadofschedule.Bycontrast,inparliamentarysystems,theprimeministerneedtosurviveavoteof
confidenceotherwiseanewelectionmustbecalled.Thelegislaturecantypicallybedissolvedatanystageduring
itslifebytheheadofstate,usuallyontheadviceofeitherPrimeMinisteralone,bythePrimeMinisterandcabinet,
orbythecabinet.
Inapresidentialsystem,thepresidentusuallyhasspecialprivilegesintheenactmentoflegislation,namelythe
possessionofapowerofvetooverlegislationofbills,insomecasessubjecttothepowerofthelegislatureby
weightedmajoritytooverridetheveto.Thelegislatureandthepresidentarethusexpectedtoserveaschecks
andbalancesoneachother'spowers.
Presidentialsystempresidentsmayalsobegivenagreatdealofconstitutionalauthorityintheexerciseofthe
officeofCommanderinChief,aconstitutionaltitlegiventomostpresidents.Inaddition,thepresidentialpowerto
receiveambassadorsasheadofstateisusuallyinterpretedasgivingthepresidentbroadpowerstoconduct
foreignpolicy.Thoughsemipresidentialsystemsmayreduceapresident'spoweroverdaytodaygovernment
affairs,semipresidentialsystemscommonlygivethepresidentpoweroverforeignpolicy.
Presidentialsystemsalsohavefewerideologicalpartiesthanparliamentarysystems.SometimesintheUnited
States,thepoliciespreferredbythetwopartieshavebeenverysimilar(butseealsopolarization).Inthe1950s,
duringtheleadershipofLyndonJohnson,theSenateDemocratsincludedtherightmostmembersofthechamber
HarryByrdandStromThurmond,andtheleftmostmembersPaulDouglasandHerbertLehman.Thispatterndoes
notprevailinLatinAmericanpresidentialdemocracies.
ThusParliamentaryformisbetterthanpresidentialgovernment.
Ratethis:+36

14

SmitShahsaid:(Sat,Apr19,201408:19:01PM)

PresidentialsystemisagoodforIndia.BecauseIndiaParliamentsystem.
Allleaderarecorrupted.OnepersoncantakethegooddecisionitisgoodforIndia.Sothisispresidentialsystem
betterthanparliamentarygovernment.
Ratethis:+17

42

KavyaYsaid:(Tue,Apr15,201412:05:00PM)

Istandforintroducingpresidentialformofgovernmentjustforaspanof5to10yearsbecausepresentlyIndiais
facingmanyobstaclesandriddlesinthemiddleinimplementingitspolicies,Thismaybebecauseofhierarchyor
corruptionorwhatever.Letsgoaheadwithpresidentialsystemandcheckwhetherwecangoaheadsuccessfully
inturningoutIndiaintoadevelopedcountry,ifnotwecandiscloseouroldsystemintopractice.
Ratethis:+23

20

Ashwanisaid:(Mon,Apr14,201411:41:08PM)

Nosystemofgovernancecouldbefreefromdemerits.Thesurvivalofanysystemdependsuponitspeople.Our
mainproblemsarecorruption,casteism,lackofaccountabilityonofficialparts,votebankpolicyandsimilarother
factorswhichmustberemovedthenonlywecanbringpeoplefaithinthesystemandsubsequentlytheir
cooperation.Itisveryimportanttoidentifyandrectifythedifferentsnagexistinginorgansofoursystem.
Ratethis:+23

Vaibhavsaid:(Mon,Apr14,201402:53:36PM)

Apresidentialsystemensuresthatthepresidentneednotbotheraboutlosinghis/herseatduetooppositionfrom
legislatorswithvestedinterests.Thepresidentwillbeabletotaketoughandlonglastingdecisionsandthe
stabilityofthegovernmentwillensureastableandvibranteconomywithconsistentgrowthinallsectors.
Thepresident'spowersandauthoritywillnotbemisusedbecauseofapowerfulandindependentjudiciary.
Ratethis:+10

DileepV.Sathesaid:(Tue,Apr1,201408:30:56PM)

IamacitizenofIndia,bybirth,andaretiredHSCphysics/chemistryteacher.Ihaveexercisedmyfranchiseof
votinginmanyelections.Thereforemyfollowingpointswillbeusefulinhavingatrueandablegovernment,which
willreallytakecareofthesociety.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/presidentialvsparliamentaryformofgovernmentinindia/

4/13

1/21/2015

Presidentialv/sParliamentaryFormofGovernmentinIndiaGroupDiscussion

1).Firstofall,Iamagainsttheparliamentarysystembecauseitgrosslyviolatesthebasicprincipleofdemocracy"
thatisforthepeople,fromthepeoplebythepeople".Asaresult,inourcountrypoliticalpartieshavebeen
mushroominginthelast66years,thistrendautomaticallyputsanobstacleforhavingpropergovernance.Onthe
otherhand,thesepartiesmakeadverseeffectonthegovernance.ThereforeIthink,wehavetoadoptthe
presidentialsystemjustlikeintheUSA,onlyrulingandopposingparties.
2).Secondly,inmyopinion,ademocraticsystemcannotsurviveifitsfoundationishaving*religious*cracksand
thereforethereshouldnotbeanyconcessionbasedonany*religiousfactor*inthenationalandprovincial
governance.Everyrule,law,actetc.Inthegovernancemustbebasedonnaturalscience.Asaretiredscience
teacher,letmestateoneimportantfact.ForNature,everychildbybirthisa*Homosapiens*andNaturerecords
deathofapersonasdeathofaHomosapiens"notasaHinduoraMuslimoraChristian.AndhenceIfirmly
believethatconcessionsbasedon*religion*muststoppedbecausetheyaredangerousforthenationalintegrity.
Ifthesereformsareimplementedtoday,wewillhavetowaitforatleast25yearstoseethefruits.Butwemust
doit,ifwereallywanttochangethegloomypictureof50years.
Ratethis:+39

11

Adityasaid:(Mon,Mar17,201407:08:08PM)

Hifolks,accordingtomyviewforacountrylikeIndiavestingabsolutepowerinhandsofonepersoncanbearisky
ventureasLordActonsaid"Powercorruptsandabsolutepowercorruptsabsolutely".Iamnotsayingthat
parliamentarysystemiscorruptionfree.
ButifwepeopleofIndiajointogethertoforceourgovernmenttoapplypropernormsandrestrictionsandwork
togetherthenwecanmakethissystemasuccess.Lokpalintroducedrecentlyifimplementedjudiciouslycanprove
tobesuccess.WehaveNOTAoptionalsotouseofelectoralchoicewiselyifwedon'tfindanycandidateworthyto
beselected.Sobyapplyingproperruleswecanmakeourdemocraticsystemasuccess.
Ratethis:+16

Namitasaid:(Thu,Feb20,201411:12:10PM)

Indiaisanywaysufferingfromthe'virus'calledcorruptionsinceyearsdespiteofhavingaparliamentaryformof
government.Sowhynottakeariskof5yearsandtrythepresidentialformofgovernment?riskarehighbut
there'snoharmintakingone!maybethatcouldleadtopoliticalstabilityinanorganizedway!
Ratethis:+17

DineshStudentOfKalpnaMamsaid:(Thu,Feb6,201408:11:18AM)

HellomyselfDineshwearetalkingaboutparliamentaryvspresidentialIthingpresidentialsysteminIndiais
betterthanparliamentarysystembecausemyfriendyouknowthatourIndianspoliticalsystemisessentialforor
ourcountry.
Ratethis:+9

41

NishaURajasaid:(Sun,Feb2,201401:21:52PM)

Inparliamentaryformofgovtexecutiveisaccountableforitseveryactiontolegislativebutdelayinimplementing
decisions.Inpresidentialformofgovttherecanbequickprogressinimplementingdecisionbutitcanbeturned
intoanarchyifweallowitinIndiabecauseexecutiveisnotaccountable.Bettertofollowparliamentaryformof
govt.
Ratethis:+12

Dr.ShivajiBhisesaid:(Thu,Dec12,201307:32:23PM)

Withtheexperienceofmorethan60yearsoftheparliamentarysystem,thesituationisdisappointinginevery
walk,henceevenafterconsideringsomedemeritsofthepresidentialsystem,itissuperior&shouldbeaccepted.
Itwillcurbthepresentchaos&corruptiontoalargeextent.
Ratethis:+16

12

PritamRajwadesaid:(Sat,Nov9,201308:44:44PM)

TheparliamentaryformofgovernmentisideallysuitedtoademocraticsetupsuchasIndiaasagainstthe
presidentialformadoptedbytheUSAwhichhoweveraccordingtoyouisabetterformofgovernment.Support
youranswerwithrelevantexamplesandarguments.
Ratethis:+11

16

Kritikasaid:(Thu,Nov7,201306:47:06PM)

Indiashouldhavepresidentialformofgovernmentsothatitcantakequickdecisionsandperformbetterinthe
future.Andatthesameparliamentformofgovtisalsogoodbecausethereischoiceforthepeopletochoosetheir

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/presidentialvsparliamentaryformofgovernmentinindia/

5/13

1/21/2015

Presidentialv/sParliamentaryFormofGovernmentinIndiaGroupDiscussion

leaders.
Ratethis:+25

10

MohanMGobalsaid:(Sat,Oct19,201305:24:33AM)

ItisalrighttodiscussthebestformofgovernmentoverpresidentialorparliamentarysystembutnowinIndia's
thecurrentsituationwarrantsthatforanotherfiveyearperiodweneedapresidentialformofgovernmentby
electingapartytopowerwhichisrepresentedbyastrongleader.BydoingsoIndiacanbebroughtbacktothe
growthpathThiswillbearealtesttodecidewhichformofgovernmentissuitedforIndia.Atthisjunctureone
shouldrememberinthepresentsystemduetocorruptpoliticianswehaveseenonlydynasticrule.
Ratethis:+16

12

AdnanShahidsaid:(Sun,Oct13,201311:11:30AM)

IthinkparliamentaryformofgovernmentisbetterasbecauseUSwhichfollowspresidentialformisranked19th
mostcorruptcountrywhileIndiaisranked94thmostcorrupt.Therearemanymoresuchexamples.Whichcan
provethisfact.
Ratethis:+16

28

Bholanathsaid:(Wed,Sep18,201311:33:38PM)

AsweallknowthatINDIAisademocraticcountrywhichmeanspeoplechoice,thatis"forthepeople,bythe
peopleandofthepeople.INDIAisthelandculture,morethen1000ofreligionsexisthere,differentpeopleleave
heretheyhavedifferentinterestwhichmaycreateconflictofinterestbetweenthem.SoIthinkthatthereshould
beparliamentaryformofgovernmentsothateverypeoplerepresentativecangivetheirviews.NowINDIAhas
developedalotinmanysectorsandmoretodevelopalsoandthiscanbedonebythepeopleonly.Wecannot
takeriskwithourcountry,cannotfollowpresidentialformofgovernmentlikeUSA.Soaccordingtomethereshould
beparliamentaryformofgovernmentforinfuturealso.
Ratethis:+12

21

MurtazaBagwalasaid:(Tue,Sep3,201305:22:24PM)

Indiaisdevelopingnotbecauseofthepoliticalsystem.Indiaisdevelopinginspiteofthepoliticalsystem.With
properandaccountableformofgovernance,Indiacouldhavebynowreachedasuperpowerstatusgiventhe
resourcesandtheabilitiesofthepeople.
Indiaexperimentedwithparliamentarysystemofdemocracy,copiedlargelyfromUK.Unfortunatelyithasnot
workedforIndia.Indiaasanationisdeeplydividedintoseveralgroupswithconflictinginterests.Indian
democracyinpracticehasnotbeenabletoabolishcastesystemthatdividesthemajoritycommunityintogroups
withconflictinginterestsdespitemanylaws.AccountabilityisthemajorcausalityintheIndianstyleofdemocracy.
ThePoliticalpartiesoftengiveimportancetothewinningchancesbasedonthegroupandcastefollowinga
candidatehas.Evenincabinetformation,casteplaysitsrole,manytimesintheformationofCabinet.Casteand
communaldividemadeIndiaintooneofthemostcorruptnationsintheworld.Somecredibleestimatesputthe
annualcorruptionat50Billiondollars.
Tofightthetwincausesofcorruptionandcaste,maybeIndianeedtodebateonapresidentialformof
governmentontheUSmodel.AstrongexecutivePresidentdoesnotneedthesupportofcasteandcommunal
votebanks.Hecangoaheadwithreformsthatmaketheadministrationmoretransparent,lesscorruptandmore
accounttothecitizensandthenation.Apowerfulandcommitted,andaccountableadministrationistheneedof
thehour.
Ratethis:+57

17

Raziasaid:(Sat,Aug31,201305:13:21PM)

IguessitsparliamentformofgovernmentwhichisbettertocountrieslikeIndiabecausewecannottakeriskofd
futureofourcountrybyhandoverthefullauthoritiestothepresident.Itmayleadtoanarchy.Whilein
parliamentaryformthepeopleofallreligionsImeantherepresentativestogetherhaveangoodideasandshare
opinionsbydiscussionsaboutdprogressofourincredibleINDIAwhereIbelieveastrongdecisiontakeningroups
neverfailandfall"UNITEDWESTANDDIVIDEDWEFALL".
Ratethis:+9

21

AdityaSinghsaid:(Sun,Aug25,201304:19:54PM)

GovernmentHelp
Presidential
StateGovernment

1.IntheParliamentaryformofgovernment,therearetwoheads.Oneisanominalheadwhileanotheristhereal
head.Forexample,inIndia,thePresidentisthenominalheadwhilethePrimeMinisteristherealhead.The
PresidentofIndiaistheheadofstatewhilethePrimeMinisteristheheadofgovernment.ButinthePresidential
formofgovernment,thereisonlyonehead.ThePresidentofAmericaistheheadofstateaswellastheheadof
government.
2.IntheParliamentarysystem,theCouncilofMinistersheadedbythePrimeMinisterisresponsibletothe

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/presidentialvsparliamentaryformofgovernmentinindia/

6/13

1/21/2015

Presidentialv/sParliamentaryFormofGovernmentinIndiaGroupDiscussion

legislature.ButinthePresidentialtype,thePresidentandhisministersarenotresponsibletothelegislature.
3.IntheParliamentarytype,theCouncilofMinisterswillloseofficeifitlosesthevoteofconfidence/no
confidence.ButinthePresidentialtype,thePresidentcannotbeoustedfrompowerbyavoteofnoconfidence.He
canberemovedfromofficethoughimpeachmentwhichismuchmoredifficultthanthevoteofconfidence/no
confidence.
4.IntheParliamentarysystem,thegovernmentdoesnotenjoyafixedtenure."Forexample,inIndiathe
governmentcanstayinpowerforfiveyears.Butanytimeduringthisperiod,thegovernmentcanberemovedfrom
powerthroughavoteofnoconfidence.InthePresidentialsystem,thePresidenthasgenerallyafixedtenure
becauseitisnoteasytoimpeachhim.
5.ThereisnotstrictseparationofpowersintheParliamentarytype.Theministersarealsomembersofthe
legislature.But,inthePresidentialtype,theprincipleofseparationofpowersisstrictlyfollowed.IntheUS,the
PresidentandhisMinisters(Secretaries)arenotmembersoftheCongress.
6.IntheParliamentarysystem,thePrimeMinisterisnotfullyfreetochoosehisministers.Hehastochoosethem
fromamongthemembersofParliament.ButinthePresidentialsystem,thePresidentenjoysmuchmorefreedom
inselectinghisministers.Heselectsthemfromamuchwiderfieldtakingintoaccounttheirexperienceand
expertise.
7.AtthetimeofcrisisthePresidentialexecutiveismoresuccessfulintakingpromptandbolddecisionsthanthe
Parliamentarygovernment.
8.ThePresidentialsystemofgovernmentprovidesmorepoliticalstabilitythantheParliamentaryformof
government.
9.AsthegovernmentintheparliamentarysystemisresponsibletotheParliament,itismoredemocraticand
respectfulofpublicopinionthanthePresidentialexecutivewhichisnotresponsibletothelegislature.
Ratethis:+64

15

HemlataPalariasaid:(Fri,Aug23,201307:39:02PM)

Indiashouldhavetheparliamentaryformofgovernmentbecauseinthissystem,theGovernmentisresponsibleto
thepeoplethroughtheirrepresentatives.However,thisisnotsoinPresidentialformofGovernment.
Ratethis:+7

15

PayalSamarsaid:(Mon,Aug12,201305:19:03PM)

ForacountrylikeIndia,presidentialformofgovtisbetter.Ithelpstotackleproblemslikecorruption,reduced
growthratesetcbetter.Delayeddecisionmakingisasetbackfortheparliamentaryform.Forquickandinstant
decisionslikewarpoliciesetc,thevetoofthepresidentcomeshandy.
Ratethis:+43

13

Adarshsaid:(Fri,Aug2,201303:50:04PM)

IfavourparliamentaryformofgovernmentinIndia.Thepresidentialsystemisquiteflawedandisnotsuitablefor
acountrylikeIndiawhichisthesecondbiggestnationintermsofpopulationandwhosediversityintermsof
language,cultureandreligionisimmense.Thepresidentialsystemhasmanydemeritssuchas:
*Encouragesa2partysystemwhichmaynotrepresenttheinterestsofallIndians.Thereisnoscopeforathird
partytoeverwin.
*Voterswouldvoteforapartybasedonthepersonalityofthepresidentialcandidateandnotontheideology,
whichisagainstthespiritofdemocracyi.e.thepartyisbiggerthantheperson.
*Presidentmaybefromoneparty,butthegovernmentmaybefromanotherpartywithacompletelydifferent
ideology,whichcanleadtoobstructionismandpolicyparalysisifthereisaclashofviews,aphenomenonwhich
shouldneveroccurindevelopingcountries,wherestrongandconsensualdecisionsareamust.
Ratethis:+21

20

Shreycoolsaid:(Wed,Jun19,201305:25:32PM)

Indianeedspresidentialformofgovernmentbecauseduringemergencies,theparliamentwilltakealongtimeto
giveoutasolutionduetothenumberofpeoplepresentintheparliamentarymeeting,butinpresidentialformof
governing,thegovernmentcangivequickresolutionswhichcanhelpthenation.Anotherthingisthatpresidential
governmentletsyouchoosetheleaderdirectlysothatmeanyourthoughtsarebeingheard,butinparliamentary,
youhavetochooseafewrepresentativesandthosefewrepresentativeswillchoosethePM.
ThereforeIndianeedsapresidentialformofgovernment.
Ratethis:+33

20

PururvaLakkadsaid:(Mon,May20,201310:18:13AM)

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/presidentialvsparliamentaryformofgovernmentinindia/

7/13

1/21/2015

Presidentialv/sParliamentaryFormofGovernmentinIndiaGroupDiscussion

Wemaysaythatbothsystemshavemeritsanddemerits.Whilepublicopinionhasbetterchancetoinfluencethe
government'spoliciesanddecisionsintheParliamentarysystem,thePresidentialsystemismoresuccessfulin
providingpoliticalstability.AnysystemofgovernmentwillsucceedinIndiaifdifferentorgansofgovernmentwork
sincerelyandfollowtherulesofthegame.Anothercriticalfactorinthisregardistheawarenessandalertnessof
people.
Eventhough,boththegovernmentshaveattractivefeaturesnecessaryfordevelopmentinIndia,Parliamentary
formofgovernmentwhichiscurrentlyprevalentmustbecarriedon.Indiaisadevelopingcountryand
malfunctioninggovernmentmaycauseittodeteriorate.Thecurrentgovernmentundoubtedlyrequiresnecessary
changesbutifanewtypeofgovernmentisintroduced,theriskofinefficiencywillsurelyhoveronIndiawhichis
notdesirable.Manyotherfactorswillinfluencethenewgovernmentlikepoliticalandciviliansupport,requirement
efficientleaders,etc.Duetothis,currentlytherearenorequirementsofanyothergovernmentinIndiabut
Parliamentarygovernment.
Ratethis:+37

17

Lakshmibhavanisaid:(Tue,May14,201309:00:59AM)

YesIndiamusthaveparliamentaryformofgovernment.SinceIndiahasworld's2ndhighestpopulationso,
presidentialformofgovernmentisnotsuitable.
Ratethis:+13

30

SipraPradhansaid:(Fri,May10,201311:39:50AM)

Inmypointofview,parliamentarygovernmentisbestforIndia.BecauseIndiaisademocraticcountry.In
presidentialgovernment,thereisonlyonepersonwhoistheheadofthestateaswellasthegovernment.So,we
shouldn'treplacetheparliamentarygovernmentwithpresidentialgovernment.
Ratethis:+12

18

SureshKumarsaid:(Fri,May3,201310:18:59PM)

Indianeedmorerefinedformofgovernment.ItneedsemipresidentialgovernmentwherePMcandidateshouldbe
declaredbeforeelectionbypoliticalpartiessothatpeoplemayguessabouttheirleader.Andpmshouldmade
morestrongsothatnoMPcangiveresignwithouthispermission.Onecanchangepartyonlybetweencodeof
conductandcabinetministercanbemadefrompartieshavingmorethan28MPs.Weshouldpopularizetwoparty
systemasitisinUSA.25percentcabinetministershouldbetakenfromoppositionpartysothattheyfeel
themselvespartofgovernment.
Ratethis:+7

12

RoshanKosurisaid:(Mon,Jan28,201310:29:08PM)

Ifavourtheparliamentaryformofdemocracy,throughandthrough.Historysaysthatmostpresidentialformsof
democracieshavebeenmisusedandabusedtobecomedictatorship.Inaparliamentaryform,itisabsolutely
difficulttotransformthough.Giventhenatureofourpoliticians,presidentialformofdemocracywillbedisastrous.
Parliamentstopsthatsinglepersonfromabusingpower.JustlookatEgypt,Afghanistan,Syria,Iraq,Russiaand
manymanycountries.Eventhoughtheremightbepolicyparalysisandinaction's,always,andalways,a
parliamentarysystemmeansstability.Presidentialsystemworksonlywhenthereislessdiversityandthepeople
aremorehomogeneousandspeakmoreorlessthesamelanguage.ItwillfailinIndia.Indiashouldessentially
remainaparliamentarydemocracy.
Ratethis:+61

18

NehaTulisaid:(Fri,Jan11,201307:14:06PM)

INDIAisawellknowndemocracy.TheIndianconstitutionisaverystrongconstitutionamongallothercountries.
Soinsteadofpracticinganynewformofgovernment,effortsshouldbemadetoremovethediscrepanciesofthe
presentformandbringanimprovementinitbecauseifwegoforpresidentialformalldecisionsmaygoinone
handWHICHMAYNOTLEADTOFRUITFULRESULTS.
Insteadeffortsshouldbemadetoremovethediscrepanciesinthepresentsystemlikebyprovidingidentityanda
dignifiedpositiontoapersonaccordingtohisworkabilityandstandards.Thereshouldbeflexiblestandards
made.
Ratethis:+19

22

AnuhyaChikkalasaid:(Sat,Dec29,201210:26:58AM)

ConstitutionofIndiaprovidesforaParliamentaryformofgovernment.IndoingsoitfollowstheBritishmodelof
government.Infact,thesystemofgovernmentthatoperatedinIndiabefore1947wasquitesimilartotheBritish
modelofparliamentarygovernment.ThemembersoftheConstituentAssemblythereforedecidedtoadoptthis
formofgovernmentforIndependentofIndia.TheConstitutionofIndiaprovidesfortheorganizationof
parliamentarygovernmentbothatthecentralandstatelevels.Allthefeaturesofaparliamentarygovernment:

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/presidentialvsparliamentaryformofgovernmentinindia/

8/13

1/21/2015

Presidentialv/sParliamentaryFormofGovernmentinIndiaGroupDiscussion

Closerelationshipbetweenthelegislatureandexecutive,responsibilityoftheexecutivebeforethelegislature,
headofthestateasthenominalexecutive,andPrimeMinisterandtheCouncilofMinisterastherealexecutive,
havebeenadoptedinIndia.
Ratethis:+10

11

SwateeMadhusmitasaid:(Fri,Nov16,201210:41:54AM)

Seefriends,Iamjoiningtoolate.ButIndiaisdifferentcase.Inchina,95%areHans,moreorlesstheyhaveakind
ofsameideologybutIndiaasmanyhavesaidhereismultilingual,multiculturalcountry,presidentialformcannot
begoodoption,butwiththesamesystemifwecanholdourgovernmentofficialsaccountabletotheirwork,then
thissystemwillalsowork.Whytodestroysuchuniqueformofgovernmentwearehavingwherethelegislative,
executive,judicialwingshaveindependentpowers.
Ratethis:+19

18

Archana.Singhsaid:(Thu,Nov8,201210:13:11PM)

Accordingtomeparliamentaryformisthebestformofgovernment.Hereeveryonehasarighttodoanything.No
personcaninterfaceinit.Indiaisoneofthemostpopulatedcountryintheworldsoitisbetterformtoremovethe
inequalitiesandpovertyagainstthepeople.
Ratethis:+16

15

Nishisaid:(Mon,Sep24,201212:36:49AM)

WhatIthinkisthateachoftheformshaveadvantagesaswellasdisadvantages.Althoughwecannotdenythe
factthatpeopleofIndiahasalwaysdemandedastrongleadertoleadtheme.g.Mahatmagandhi,bhagatsingh
andmanymoreleaders.SoIthinkthatpresidentialformofgovernmentisbetterforIndiaprovidedthepower
doesnotgoesinwronghands.
Ratethis:+11

34

Jessiesaid:(Sun,Aug26,201211:20:54AM)

ParliamentaryformofgovernmentisthebestforIndiabecauseifpresidentialformisusedallthepowerswouldgo
inoneperson'shandsandIndiawouldnolongerbeademocraticcountry.TodaythepowersofIndiaaresituated
bothinthepresident'sandtheprimeminister'shands.Sowenowthatourcountry'sheadisnotonepersonbut
twopersonswithdifferentthinking!!
Ratethis:+23

31

Kamnasaid:(Tue,Jul31,201208:49:23AM)

Itsgreattohavepresidentialformofgovernmentbecausecountryneedsadynamicfreeandfearfreeleaderwho
canworkofhisownsopresidentialwouldbegood.
Ratethis:+37

35

Chloesaid:(Mon,Jul30,201210:50:44PM)

SinceIndiaisahugecountrythatisstillintheprocessofdevelopingandthatwhichhastonsofreligionandcaste
Ibelievethataparliamentarysystemofgovernmentisbestsuited.Peoplearedyingfortheirvoicestobeheard
andgrievancescanbeaddressedwellonlywhentheleaderismoreaccessible.
Apresidentialsystembecomesmoreinaccessibleforthepeopleastherearesomanyilliteratepeopleinthis
nation.Andinaparliamentarysystemallthevariousgrievancescanbediscussedandactioncanbebrought
aboutaccordinglybyvariouspartiesandnotjustonevoice.
Ratethis:+40

21

Pratiksaid:(Sat,Jun30,201209:12:24PM)

Indiatrulyneedsapresidentialformofgovernment.Today,ourproblemslieintheveryrootsofparliamentary
democracy.Forexample,thePrimeMinister'spowerisextremelylimitedbecausehe/sheneedstheapprovalfrom
thepresidentandabovealltheparliament.IftheparliamentisnothappywiththePrimeMinister,ithasthepower
toholdtheconfidencemotion.Also,thePrimeMinisterneedstoformacoalitionwithotherregionalpartiestostay
inpower,meaningthePrimeMistermustkeepeveryoneinhis/hercoalitionhappy.
Furthermore,somepeopleinthisbloghavebeencriticizingthepresidentialformofgovernmentbecausetoomuch
powerisvestedinonepersonandthatthePresidentialsystemDOESNOTrepresentdifferentcastesandreligions
(norepresentation).
Tothosewhosaythatpresidentialsystemleadstoanunequalrepresentationofthepeople,youaremistaken.
Today,thepeopleDOESNOTELECTthePrimeMinisterbutwethepeopleelecttheparty.Thepartythenchooses
thePrimeMinister.Bottomline,thePrimeMinisterisnotheldaccountablewhenreelectionscomeorduringany

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/presidentialvsparliamentaryformofgovernmentinindia/

9/13

1/21/2015

Presidentialv/sParliamentaryFormofGovernmentinIndiaGroupDiscussion

electionswithinthestates.
WhydohavecriminalswithinthestateassembliesandtheParliament?Thisisthereason.Ifthecriminalrunsfor
office,arationalpersonwouldnotvoteforthiscriminal.However,likeIsaidbeforewethepeopleina
parliamentaryformofgovernmentelecttheparty,thepartythenchoosesacandidatetoholdofficeregardlessof
abackgroundcheck.
IndianeedsaPresidentwhocanexecutepowerwithoutthethereatfromparliamentandtheparty.WhatImean
bythisisthatweneedaleaderwhoiselectedforafixedtermof5years.
Inconclusion,Iagreewithsomepoststhatademocracymustrepresentitspeople.Perhapsnosysteminhistory
representsthepeoplemorethattheparliamentaryformofgovernment.However,IndianpoliticiansDONOT
representthepeoplerathertheyareinofficefortheirownselfinterests.Toaddinsulttoinjury,ourcountry
suffersfromilliteracy,whichmakesitextremelytoughforthepeopletounderstandandultimatetakechargeof
thesituation.
Ratethis:+108

25

AbhikDuttasaid:(Wed,Jun27,201211:50:41PM)

It'snottheformofgovernmentthatisimportant.Themainthingthatisimportantisthehealthyinteraction
betweentheleaderandhis/hersubjectsandbothshouldhavetrustineachother.Andincaseitdoesn'thappens
thecountrycannotbedevelopedbychangingtheformofgovernment,butitselfseemstobebombardedand
doomedbyvariousproblems.
Ratethis:+37

15

Sravyasaid:(Thu,May10,201210:32:09PM)

InmyviewparliamentaryformofgovtisthebestbecauseasIndiaisavastcountry.Manypoliticiansarerequired,
therebyseekingsmallresponsibilityineverypolitician.Andmisuseofpowercanbereduced.Butinpresidential
formofgovtpowerliesinonceindividual.Therebywholeauthoritycomesintohishandsintakinganysortof
decision.Therebytherewillbenopoweraheadtopunishhim.Leadingtodisasters.Andthreats.So"INDIASUITS
TOBEINPARLIAMENTARYFORMOFGOVERNMENT".
Ratethis:+26

17

RahulSwarnkarsaid:(Mon,Apr2,201204:03:29PM)

Idon'tthinkanygovernmentformwillcreateanyimpactonpeoplesinIndia.Wehavetomakesomechangesin
ourselves.AmericahasaPresidentialformofgovt.Buttheyaresuccessivenotduetotheformofgovt.Theyhave
butbecauseofitsjudicialsystem,lawandorderandalmostnocorruption.Ifwecanremovecorruption,enforce
lawandorderandholdthegovernmentanditsofficialsaccountable,oursystemwillwork.Thesearetheroot
causeoftheproblemsthatwehaveinthiscountry.
Ratethis:+71

11

JyoteermoyDuttasaid:(Tue,Mar20,201209:40:43AM)

InIndiatherearevariousreligionsandcastssoparliamentarygovermentisnoteffectiveinIndiaasEngland.Now
adaysduetothistypeofgovermentmanyregionalpoliticalpowersarerisingwhichisveryharmfulforthenation
ofIndia.Istronglysupportpresidentialrule,buttherearesomeconditionslikeitshouldbedemocratic,the
presidentmustbeelectedbythepeopleofindia,andafacewhichiswellknowntoallshouldbegiventhepower
becauseifthepeopleareawareofthecharacterandthenatureofthenominatedpersonsthenitwouldbebetter
toelectthebestone.
Ratethis:+22

12

Rheasaid:(Fri,Mar9,201204:58:01PM)

DEMERITSOFTHECURRENTPARLIMENTARYSYSYEM:.
1.Theelectoratethroughthegeneralelectionselectapartytopower,butmoreoftenthannot,thenameof
personwhowouldbecomeprimeministerafterbeingelectedtopowerisnotdisclosed.Evenifitisdisclosedvery
frequentlyitischangedafterbeingelectedtopower.Theprimeministerisinvestedwithseveralkeypowersthe
electorateshouldhavetherighttoknowhisidentity.
2.Thecabinetministers,whoplayanintegralroleinthefunctioninganddevelopmentofthecountry,arenot
directlyelectedbythepeople.Thismakesthewholeprocessofvotinglessdemocraticinnature.Therealpoweris
notinthehandsofthepeople.
3.Thisuninvolvementofthepeopleintheelectionsalsodecreasestheinterestandneedofthepeopletovote,
astheydonotactuallyplayadefinitiveroleintheformationofthegovernment.
4.VeryfrequentlyinIndia,thegovernmentformedisacoalitionofparties(E.G.TheUnitedProgressiveAlliance).
Insuchasystemtherecouldbeconstantfrictionsbetweenindividualparties,duetothedifferenceinideologies.
Onaccountofthistherecouldbestagnationofpublicworkprogrammes,implementationofpoliciesetc.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/presidentialvsparliamentaryformofgovernmentinindia/

10/13

1/21/2015

Presidentialv/sParliamentaryFormofGovernmentinIndiaGroupDiscussion

5.Theconceptofvotebanksisunfortunately,firmlyinstilledintheIndiansystemofaparliamentarydemocracy.
Votebanksarecreatedindifferentareasandconstituenciesbydifferentcandidatesandparties,onthebasisof
cast,race,religionetc.Corruptionanddefectiontooisrampant.Amoretransparentsystemisrequired.
Henceclearlyapresidentialsystemisrequired.

Ratethis:+47

14

Viswasaid:(Wed,Mar7,201202:17:55PM)

AsformyopinionpresidentialfromofgovernmentiscorrectinIndia.Becauseinparliamentarygovernmentthereis
distributedpowersamongtheleaders.Noonehasspecificpowerstodevelopmentthrowtheirways.Soitisdelay
theprocesstowardsthelight.OurfriendsaidthatIndiaisinsecondplaceinpopulationbutthefirstoneChina
followsthepresidentialgovernmentanditstilldevelopmentispossibleinit.
Ratethis:+14

19

PalakBatrasaid:(Tue,Feb7,201206:00:46PM)

Iguessparliamentaryformofgovernmentisabetterformofgovernmentascomparedtopresidentialformasin
presidentialformofgovernmentthereisonlyonepersonwhoistheheadofthestateaswellasthegovernment
givingsomuchpowerinoneperson'shandcanleadtomisuseofpower.AcountrylikeIndiahavingvast
populationneedsamixtureofpeoplefromdifferentcastesandreligionstoformagovernmentsoasto
understandeachandeverygroup.Inparliamentarysystemeverypersongetsafairopportunitytorepresent
his/herreligion'sorcaste'sproblems.
Ratethis:+24

13

SvMadhusudansaid:(Wed,Dec28,201108:19:24PM)

PresidentialformofgovtistheonlywayfordevelopmentofIndiathenparliamentaryform.Becauseinpresidential
formpeopleelectonepersonandvestpowerinhisorherhand,nottothousandslikeparliamentaryformwhich
leadtomisuseofpower.Soaccordingtomepresidentialformistheonlywaytoindia'ssuccess.Becauseright
personatrightplaceandatrighttimetoact.
Ratethis:+27

SvMadhusudansaid:(Sun,Nov27,201109:44:41AM)

Peoplesaythatpresidentialformmayleadtodictatorship,soparliamentaryformisgood.Iwanttosaythatevery
problemhasitsownsolutionwhichleadstoresearch.AccordingtomyresearchIconcludedwithmypointsthat
therewillbenomisuseofpowerinpresidencyformwhichmayleadtodictatorship.Andtheyare.
*nopresidentcanholdtheofficeformorethantwoyearstermmeans10years.
*ifpeoplefindthatpresidentisgoingwrongthentheymaywithdrawpowerbyvoting.
*ifpresidenttriestosupresspeoplethenpeoplearehavingrighttoactandinformsupremecourtinwhichcourt
ordersmilitarytotakeaction.
Sothesearethestepstobetakenifthepresidentgoestyrant.

Ratethis:+42

17

Anushasaid:(Mon,Nov21,201111:42:49AM)

Indiabeingademocraticcountryitshouldhaveaparliamentaryformofgovernmentbecauseheregoodqualityof
decisionsaremade.
Ratethis:+16

31

AasthaTewarisaid:(Tue,Oct18,201109:30:39PM)

IthinkinUSAwehavePRESIDENTIALDEMOCRACYasthecitizenschoosetheirownleaderandtheleaderhasthe
supremepower.
Ratethis:+14

25

KunalGodhwanisaid:(Wed,Oct12,201102:03:25PM)

IndiafollowedthesamestructurewhichwasalreadythereinIndia.IngovernmentofIndiaact1935Indiawas
havingaparliamentaryformofgovernmentwhichtheyfollowed.Itwasdifficulttotakenewthingswhileforming
theconstitutionsothey(membersofconstituentassembly)preferredthesameformofgovernmentwhichwas
alreadythereinIndia.AnditisverydifficuttochangetheformofgovernmentandthattooinIndia.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/presidentialvsparliamentaryformofgovernmentinindia/

11/13

1/21/2015
Ratethis:+11

Presidentialv/sParliamentaryFormofGovernmentinIndiaGroupDiscussion

13

NikiSharmasaid:(Mon,Aug22,201104:46:12PM)

SinceUSAhaspresidentialformofgovernment.
Itcanalsoleadtodictatorship.(somepossibility)
thatismypointofview.
notthatpresidentialfromofgovt.doesn'thaveanymerits.Like
Lessofpartypolitics
Theyhaveafixedtenure
stabilityofgovt
parliamentaryfromofgovt.toohasmanydemerits.
Ratethis:+24

10

PriyankJainsaid:(Fri,Aug5,201112:08:42AM)

Ya,myfriend,itistruethatpresidentialformofgovernmentcanbringdownthecorruptedpoliticiansonthe
groundandnoonecanmisusetheirpowers.ButinIndiatheirare1000ofcastsandreligionsandtheirforewhile
electingthepresidentdirectly,theirwillbealotofcontradictionsamongthepeopleofdifferentreligionsandthis
willtendtocreateaviolentenvironment.Butinparliamentaryelectionspeoplecanelectministersdirectlyandthe
parliamentarymemberswillelectthesuperiorauthority.
Ratethis:+28

15

FesalFernandessaid:(Tue,Jul26,201109:17:37PM)

Asinthepresidentialformofgovt,thepresidentiselectedonthebasisofdireactelection.Itwillbeanadvantage
toallindianstochosealeaderoftheirchoise.theleaderwillalsobeobligedtothepeoplethentheother
ministers.
Ratethis:+11

17

Ankursaid:(Sun,May22,201109:19:23PM)

InUSA,beinginapresidentialformofgovernment,UScitizenshaveneverlosttheiridentity.Indiashould
immediatelyswitchedtopresidentialformofgovernmentifitwantsprosperityofthenationasawhole.
Ratethis:+15

28

Subhosaid:(Wed,Dec29,201006:11:31AM)

ThatisaverygoodpointManjubutdon'tyouthinkthatthepresentformofgovernmentinIndiaisParliamentary
anditisinnowayexemplary.Ofcoursethereare1000ofdifferentreligionbuthasn'tthatspawnedtheproblemof
reservationsinourcountry.maybeitshightimewethinkoverourculturalaspectsandpersonalidentitiesand
thinkaboutthecountry.APresidentialruleforabout5yearswillatleastbringdownthecorruptpoliticiansoutof
powerandmaybethenanewgovernmentcanbeformed.
Ratethis:+18

20

ManjuTavanesaid:(Mon,Dec20,201010:52:10PM)

AsformeparliamentaryformofgovernmentshouldbeinIndia.ActuallyIndiaisoneofthebiggestdemocracy
country.Herepeoplewanttoexpresstheirfeelingswithoutanyobjection.SoweneedParliamentarytypeofgvt.
Inthiscountryhaving1000ofreligions.,andalsoitis2ndbiggestnationinpopulation.Ifpresidentialisformed
here.,allpeoplesarelossestheiridentity.Theyworktothatpresidentonly.Whathesaytheyshouldthatthing
only.
Forexample:InHitlertimetheirpeoplelossestheiridentityandtheyareslavesforhim.Thereisnotheirwon
culturaleventsforthem.
Indiahaving1000ofdifferentreligionanddifferenttypeoffestival.IfIndiaalsofollowedpresidentialformhuman
beingslossestheiridentity.
Ratethis:+44

22

SpeakYourMind:

...

Pleasedonotusechatterms.Example:avoidusing"grt"insteadof"great".

Submit

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/presidentialvsparliamentaryformofgovernmentinindia/

12/13

1/21/2015

Presidentialv/sParliamentaryFormofGovernmentinIndiaGroupDiscussion

BestCBSESchoolTrichy
admissions.mountlitera.com/Trichy

Aschoolwithworldclassinfra&innovative
curriculum.EnrollNow!

JEEMainsSamplePapers
airtelbroadbandonline
SubmitYourResume

Relatedtopics:
FlexiTimingsorFixedTimingsWhichisbetteratWork?
IsDependenceonComputersaGoodThing?
PoliticsisrunbytheBarrelofGun
Doctors'AccountabilitytoImproveHealthCare
ThereisNoRightWayofDoingtheWrongThing

20082014byIndiaBIX T echnologies.AllRightsReserved|Copyright|T ermsofUse&PrivacyPolicy

Contactus:info@indiabix.com
Bookmarkto:

Followusontwitte r!

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/presidentialvsparliamentaryformofgovernmentinindia/

13/13