Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
Contents
1.
Introduction
2.
Parameters
3.
Design model
4.
5.
Design situation 2: Determine the design axial load resistance of a column base
10
6.
11
7.
References
12
Annex A
13
Page 1
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
1.
Introduction
This NCCI covers the design of simple bases of I section columns transmitting an axial
compressive force and a shear force (i.e. a pinned column base). The rectangular base plate
is welded to the column section in a symmetrically position so that it has projections beyond
the column flange outer edges on all sides (see Figure 1.1). The base plate may be positioned
eccentrically on the concrete foundation.
If not required to resist moment, it is usual practice in many countries to attach this type of
column base to the concrete foundation by two anchor bolts symmetrically placed about the
web on the columns major axis. However in some countries, such as the UK, it may be
required to have four anchor bolts in order to better ensure the stability of the column during
erection. Anchor bolts provide resistance to any uplift forces which arise in the column and
also, but only under certain conditions, may be used to provide resistance to shear at the
column base.
The present NCCI does not cover
Created on Wednesday, August 18, 2010
This material is copyright - all rights reserved. Use of this document is subject to the terms and conditions of the Access Steel Licence Agreement
df
a)
bfc
bb
bf
hc
hb
c)
c)
hf
Key:
1. I section column
2. Base plate
3. Grout
4. Concrete foundation
5. Anchor bolt
Figure 1.1
Page 2
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
A simple column base may be assumed to be a nominally pinned joint in the global analysis
of the frame. Noting that there are no criteria given in EN 1993-1-8 for the nominally
pinned classification of column bases, it is possible that National Annexes provide
information.
Page 3
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
2.
Parameters
The following are the parameters referred to in this NCCI (see Figure 3.1 and Figure 3.2):
Table 2.1
Parameters
Parameter
Definition
Parameter
Definition
hf
cc
hc
hp
tfc
leff
twc
tp
M0
Ac0
bp
Ac1
bf
bfc
Cf,d
beff
FRdu
Ff,Rd
df
Fv,Rd
fyb
fyp
Nj,Ed
fjd
Nj,Rd
Vj,Ed
fcd
3.
Design model
3.1
General
The design model for the axial compression force is based on 6.2.5 and 6.2.8.2(1) of EN
1993-1-8. The basic design approach is to ensure that the bearing stresses under the base plate
neither exceed the design bearing strength of the foundation joint material nor lead to
excessive bending of the base plate.
Page 4
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
The design model assumes that the bearing resistance of a column base on its foundation is
provided by three non-overlapping T-stubs in compression, one for each column flange and
one for the column web, as shown in Figure 3.1. For each T-stub, the design bearing
resistance is determined by multiplying its bearing area (length by width) by the strength of
the foundation joint material.
The length and width of each T-stub depend on the dimensions of the relevant flange or web
and on an additional bearing width, cantilevered from the T-stub stem as shown in
Figure 3.2and Figure 4.1. While the theoretical value of the additional bearing width
depends on the elastic bending resistance of the base plate and on the design strength of the
foundation joint material, the effective total bearing area needs to be corrected if use of the
latter width leads to overlapping of the individual T-stub bearing areas between the flanges.
bfc
bp
bf
hc
hp
hf
Figure 3.1
3.2
Column base and non overlapping T-stub bearing areas (see Figure 6.19 of EN
1993-1-8)
There are two basic types of base plate identified in EN1993-1-8, large projection base
plates and short projection base plates.
For the large projection base plate, the projection of the base plate beyond the column
section perimeter is such that the design bearing width on each side of all three T-stubs is
usually equal to the value of the additional width (c). A large projection base plate is
illustrated in Figure 3.2a).
For the short projection base plate, the projection beyond both column flanges towards the
base plate edges, while being less than the value of the additional width (c), is adequate to
allow fillet welding of the flanges to the base plate. Usually, for the latter purpose, a width
approximately equal to the column flange thickness is provided. A short projection base
plate is illustrated in Figure 3.2b).
Page 5
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
3.3
Note that when some H-section columns are used with thick base plates, the flange T-stubs of
additional bearing width c on the web side would overlap in the central area between the
flanges as shown in Figure 3.2c) and Figure 3.2d). In such cases, since there would be no
bearing area left for a web T- stub, the effective bearing area would be reduced to a simple
rectangular area as follows:
Short projection base plate: Aeff. bearing = Ac0 = leff beff = hpbp
Large projection base plate: Aeff. bearing = Ac0 = leff beff = (hc+ c)(bfc + c) hpbp
hc
tfc
tfc
tfc
c
bfc
tfc
twc
leff bp
twc
bfc
hc
leff = bp
bfc + 2tfc
hp hc + 2c
beff
beff
hp hc + 2 tfc
b)
a)
hc 2tfc 2c
tfc
hc
tfc
tfc
tfc
twc
twc
bfc
leff bp
bfc
leff = bp
bfc + 2tfc
c
hc 2tfc 2c
c
hc
hp hc + 2c= beff
c)
c
hp hc + 2 tfc = beff
d)
a)
b)
c)
d)
Figure 3.2
Page 6
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
4.
If the column section and the axial compression force are given, the following procedure can
be used to dimension the base plate.
Step 1: Choose the design strengths of the materials
Base plate steel strength:
A design value for the yield strength f yp of the base plate steel is adopted.
Bearing strength of the foundation joint material (grout):
It is shown below that, in most practical cases, the value of the design bearing strength of the
joint material can be taken as equal to that of the design concrete strength in compression, i.e.
f jd = f cd . Table 4.1provides typical design bearing strengths for typical concrete grades and
foundation joint materials.
Table 4.1
Bearing strength for typical foundation concrete and foundation joint material
20
25
30
35
40
45
Bearing strength
fjd (N/mm2)
13,3
16,7
20
23,3
26,7
30
More generally, the design bearing strength of the foundation joint material is given as:
f jd = jf cd
Where:
Ac1 / Ac0 accounts for the concrete bearing strength enhancement due to diffusion
of the concentrated force within the foundation over the area Ac1 (see Annex A). In
practice, the value of 1,5 is commonly used..
f cd
With the above assumptions for the values of the coefficients j and one obtains
f jd = jf cd = (2 / 3)(1,5) f cd = f cd , which is the basis for the design values given in Table 4.1.
It is usual practice to use a concrete of medium strength for foundations and quality grout for
the joint material in all cases.
For other concrete classes and assumptions, see Annex A.
Page 7
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
hcbf c f cd
Ac0 =
N j,Ed
f cd
c=
B B 2 4 AC
- for which positive solutions only are of interest.
2A
Table 4.2 gives the expressions for the constants A, B and C , under the relevant non
overlapping T-stub column.
Page 8
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
Table 4.2
Constant
+(bfc + hc)
+(Nj,Ed/2fjd) (2bfctfc+4tfc2+0,5hctwc-tfctwc)
+ (bfctfc+0,5hctwc-tfctwc) (Nj,Ed/2fjd)
+ (bfchc)/2 -(Nj,Ed/2fjd)
Short projection base plate: change to a large projection base plate and recalculate c.
Large projection base plate: recalculate c based on having the entire area between the
column flanges in bearing in the design expression. The design condition for the large
projection base plate then becomes:
Nj,Ed Nj,Rd = fjd [(bfc + 2 c)(hc + 2 c)]
The corresponding expressions for A, B and C to be used in the solution for c are given in the
last column of Table 4.2.
Step 5: Determine the required minimum plan dimensions of the base plate
The final plan dimensions of the base plate are based on the following:
Short projection base plate:
bp (bfc + 2 tfc)
hp (hc + 2 tfc)
Large projection base plate:
bp (bfc + 2 c)
hp (hc + 2 c)
Step 6: Determine the minimum required base plate thickness
The minimum required thickness of the base plate is obtained from the condition that the
plate, assumed to act as a cantilever off the column perimeter, is not subject to more than its
elastic design bending resistance under a uniform bearing pressure equal to fjd acting over the
additional width c (see Figure 4.1). The value for the minimum required thickness is given
by:
tp
c
f yp
(3 f jd M0 )
0, 5
Page 9
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
tfc or twc
tfc
tfc
tp
tp
c c tfc
tfc or twc
a)
b)
a)
b)
Column web T-stub and Large projection base column flange T-stub
Figure 4.1
5.
Design situation 2: Determine the design axial
load resistance of a column base
Step 1: Establish basic parameters and assumptions
-
Foundation dimensions (df , bf , hf ) and base plate position parameters (eb, , eh).:
-
df
, 1 + 2 eh , 1 + 2 eb ,3
If known, = min 1 +
hp
bp
max(hp , bp )
Where eb = (bf bfc -2 tfc)/2 and eh = (hf hc -2 tfc)/2.
Page 10
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
c = tp
f yp
3 f jd M 0
Nj,Rd = 2 Ffc,Rd + Fwc,Rd = fjd [2 (bfc + 2 c)(2c + tfc) + (hc 2 c 2 tfc)(2 c + twc)]
If c > (hc 2 tfc)/2 , (hc + 2 c) hp and (bc + 2 c) bp (overlapping) the design resistance in
compression is given by:
Nj,Rd = 2 Ffc,Rd = fjd [ (bfc + 2 c)( hc + 2 c)]
Otherwise, the design resistance in compression is given by:
Nj,Rd = 2 Ffc,Rd = fjd [min((bfc + 2 c):bp)min((hc + 2 c ): hp)]
6.
The design shear resistance is based on the friction resistance developed by the compressive
load applied by the base plate on the joint material. It is given as (EN 1993-1-8 6.2.2(6)):
Fv,Rd = Ff,Rd
Where: Ff,Rd = Cf,d Nc,Ed
Nc,Ed is the column design compressive load and
Cf,d is the coefficient of friction between the base plate and the grout layer. A value
of 0,2 is specified for sand-cement mortar. Otherwise tests in accordance with
EN 1990 Annex D are required to determine the coefficient value for any other type
of grout.
The design check is: Vc,Ed Fv,Rd
Page 11
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
7.
1
References
Cost C1 Column Bases in Steel Building Frames
European Commission Brussels, Edited by Klaus Weynand RWTH Aachen , 1999.
Lescouarch, Y.
Page 12
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
Annex A
If the foundation dimensions are sufficiently large compared to those of the base plate, the
bearing strength can be significantly greater than the concrete design strength in compression,
since optimal diffusion of the load is possible (see Figure A.1 d)). If full diffusion is not
possible the design bearing strength can be considerably less than the maximum bearing
strength (see Figure A.1 a), b), and c)).
The maximum bearing strength corresponds to the situation when the ratio
(the limiting condition given in EN1992-1-1 6.7(2)).
Where
Ac1
Aco
When the ratio Ac1 / Ac0 is at the maximum, the required base dimensions (width, depth and
thickness) will be the smallest possible.
Although the theoretical minimum value for the Ac1 / Ac0 ratio is unity, it is common
practice to adopt a minimum of 1,5. This minimum corresponds to having uninterrupted
foundation dimensions of bf = 1,5bp and hf = 1,5hp (see figure A.1 e)). To ensure that this
distribution can be achieved, the foundation depth must satisfy the following:
df max[bfhf /(bf + hf) , 3bphp /(2bp + 2hp)]
Page 13
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
bb
eb < bb
2eb
1
2
2eh
df
a)
hb
eh < hb
df
b)
3hb or 3bb
hb or bb
hb or bb
hb or bb
2
2
df > 2hb
df > 2bb
df < 2hb
df < 2bb
c)
d)
bb or hb
Ac1 = 9 Ac0
1
1
eb = 0,25bb or 0,25hb
0,5bb or 0,5hb
df
e)
Key:
Figure A.1:
Distribution area in the foundation: effect of the base plate size and position
= Ac1 / Ac0 is the coefficient which accounts for the concrete bearing strength
enhancement due the diffusion of the concentrated force within the foundation,
f cd is the design compressive strength of the foundation concrete.
The use of the j = 2/3 coefficient value requires that the relevant conditions on the grout
compressive strength (EN 1993-1-8 6.2.5(7)) be met:
Page 14
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
If the grout thickness min (50 mm; 0,2 hp ; 0,2 bp), the grout compressive strength
should be at least equal to 0,2 f cd
If the grout thickness > 50 mm, the grout compressive strength should be at least equal
to f cd
The determination the value of the bearing strength enhancement coefficient requires
knowledge of the foundation dimensions, information which is rarely available at the stage
the dimensions the column base plates are fixed.
If the foundation dimensions are known, the design bearing strength of the foundation joint
can be calculated:
f jd = j f cd Ac1 / Ac0
Where:
And:
Ac1 / Ac0 =
= min 1 +
df
, 1 + 2 eh , 1 + 2 eb ,3
max(hp , bp )
hp
bp
Page 15
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
Concrete classes, concrete strengths and bearing resistances (N/mm2) for j = 2/3
Table A.1:
12
16
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
60
10,7
13,3
16,7
20
23,3
26,7
30
33,3
40
5,3
7,1
8,9
11,1
13,3
15,6
17,8
20
22,2
26,7
10,7
13,3
16,7
20
23,3
26,7
30
33,3
40
16
21,4
26,6
33,4
40
46,6
53,4
60
66,6
80
fcd = cc fck / c
Notes: Some countries may have national practice requirements on the minimum concrete grade to be used for the foundations.
For example some countries now require that mass concrete foundations be of grade 20 and reinforced concrete foundations
be of grade 25.
The base plate area is estimated as the largest of the following values:
1
AC0 =
Ac1
N j, Ed
2
in which Ac1 (hcbfc)
j f cd
df
d f
e
e
, 1 +
, 1 + 2 h , 1 + 2 b ,3
= min 1 +
hp
bp
hc + 2tfc bc + 2tfc
Where eb = (bf bfc -2 tfc)/2 and eh = (hf hc -2 tfc)/2.
Foundation dimensions unknown:
Ac0 =
= 1,5
N j,Ed
j f cd
Page 16
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
NCCI: Design model for simple column bases- axially loaded I section columns
SN037a-EN-EU
Quality Record
RESOURCE TITLE
Reference(s)
ORIGINAL DOCUMENT
Name
Company
Date
Created by
Ivor Ryan
CTICM
21/04/2005
Alain Bureau
CTICM
March 2006
1. UK
G W Owens
SCI
17/3/06
2. France
A Bureau
CTICM
17/3/06
3. Sweden
A Olsson
SBI
17/3/06
4. Germany
C Mller
RWTH
17/3/06
5. Spain
J Chica
Labein
17/3/06
G W Owens
SCI
11/7/06
Page 17