Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
O.P.Murty , Anshoo Agarwal , Kanageshwarri A/P N.S.Murugiah , Siti Nurzawani Abdul Rahman ,Nor Syuhada
1
1
Binti din Mustafaha , Kamarul Ariffin Abu Bakar
1
Abstract
This is a retrospective study of sports related deaths on the human bodies brought for autopsy in the last 10 years
(from 1995-2005) at University Malaya Medical Center (UMMC), Kuala Lumpur. The objective of this study was
to know the cause of death, manner of death, ethnicity, food habits, timings of incident, number of cases and
other related information like history of metabolic disorders or any other underlying diseases. All cases were
analyzed in relation to age, gender, race, causes of death, type of sport activities and victims profile. The present
study included those subjects who had died either during playing or immediately after it. Our results showed the
most common age group affected in such sports related sudden deaths to be ranging between 40 49 years and
the least affected were between 0 9 years of age. Out of 44 cases reanalyzed, 33 were male and1 was female.
Among the ethnic group, most of the subjects were Chinese (45.45 %) followed by Malays (20.45%). This study
also showed that 80% of the deaths were caused by ischemic heart disease IHD (50%) or coronary heart disease
CAD (30%). Deaths were seen to be more in the subjects above 30 years of age which could be associated with
the associated risk factors related to ageing. A significant number of deaths were observed while playing
badminton and jogging. No serious need for mass screening was felt as the numbers of cases each year were not
significant and they were isolated incidents. Although, there are few basic preventive measures like cardiac
screening , lipid profile, avoidance of stressful working conditions which can be easily adopted to decrease
loss of life. Incidence may decrease with recreational and health maintaining activities, but absolute prevention
may still not be possible.
Key Words: Sudden death; Sports activities; Causes of death; Types of sport activities; Family history; Risk
Factors.
regarding these events are not as extensive as in
the western regions in which the causative factors
Introduction:
may vary given the diverse environment, cultural,
Sudden death is defined as "an abrupt unexpected
social, economical and climacteric factors.
death of pathological or idiopathic cause, in which
In this study, consideration of subjects was based on
death occurs within 1 to 12 hours of onset of
the following criteria (3):
symptoms" (1, 2). The majority of sudden deaths in
Individuals that participated in organized
this study occurred during or immediately after
competitive sports
exercise (game, conditioning, training, etc). Autopsy
Individuals that exercised regularly and
is most often the only means in making a definitive
vigorously
diagnosis and for determination of the cause of
Physically conditioned persons, e.g. military
sudden death.
personnel
Sports are often regarded as a part of lifestyle owing
Individuals
that lead a sedentary lifestyle and
to the widely held perception that it betters health
exercise
infrequently
were also included in this study
and life in whole. The possibility of those indulge in
as
the
circumstances
indicate that these subjects
sports to be susceptible to sudden death often
were
in
some
points
close
to the sporting events that
seems to be ironic and counter intuitive.
led to sudden death. Fortunately, sudden death
Nevertheless, such sudden catastrophes continue to
associated with sports is rare. Its exact prevalence is
occur, usually in the absence of prior symptoms.
unknown, since there is no national or regional
database to track deaths in these individuals. The
Attempts to understand the causes of such events
largest available studies estimate the risk among
regularly revolve around cardiac aetiology and to
high school and collegiate (who are active in sports)
certain extend other causes. However, studies
115
Methodology:
Count
15
10
Male
Total
malay
Age
20
indian
others
Results:
0-9
10-19
20-29
30-39
40-49
50-59
20
3
4
5
17
14
43
Female
1
Total
1
3
4
5
17
14
44
chinese
ethnic group
%
2.27
6.82
9.09
11.36
38.64
31.82
100
116
10
Count
4
7
2004
2005
2
3
2
2000
2001
0
1996
1997
1998
1999
2002
2003
year of incidence
Table 2: Correlation between causes of death and age group distribution of sudden deaths victims during
sports activities
coronary
artery
disease
age
Total
cause of death
acute
ischemic
myocardial cardiomy
opathy
heart dss
infarction
Total
miscellaneou
s
0-9
10-19
20-29
30-39
40-49
17
50-59
14
22
13
44
117
25
20
Count
15
22
10
13
5
2
0
coronary artery
disease
acute myocardial
infarction
cardiomyopathy
ischeamic heart
dss
miscellanous
cause of death
Figure 3 showed that 22 sports related sudden deaths occurred due to coronary artery disease which actually
contributes to the highest number of cases in the past ten years. Out of 44 cases, 13 victims died due to ischemic
heart disease. Another 5 victims died of acute myocardial infarction. Cardiomyopathy contributed to 2 cases of the
total number. Associated miscellaneous conditions such as Kleibsella infection and choking have accounted for 2
deaths.
Figure 4: Correlation between causes of death and the specific sporting activity
Causes of Death During Specific Sports
others
golf
swimming
hockey
miscellanous
ischeamic heart disease
cardiomyopathy
acute myocardial infarction
coronary artery disease
cycling
exercise
jogging
tennis
badminton
football
0
5
count
118
16
15
14
12
10
count
8
6
6
4
3
2
0
football
badminton
tennis
jogging
exercise
cycling
hockey
swimming
golf
others
Figure 4 depict the relation between deaths and the specific sporting activity. In figure 5, the category others
shows only 4 numbers of sudden deaths. Others here include rugby, snooker, squash and playing in water theme
park. These activities did not sum up to significant number and presented as isolated cases, often as exclusive
cases. 15 deaths occurred while the victims were playing badminton followed by playing football in 6 cases,4
deaths occurred while jogging and cycling, followed by death during exercising in 3cases, swimming, 2 deaths
each happened while playing tennis, golf and playing hockey .
Figure 6: Distribution of sudden deaths that occurred in cases with associated risk factors
Count
obesity
smoking
family history
alcoholic
underlying dss
0-9
10-19
20-29
30-39
Age Group
119
40-49
50-59
Count
12
10
yes
no
6
4
2
0
coronary artery
disease
ischeamic heart
dss
miscellanous
Ironically smoking does not seem to influence the number of sudden deaths. The numbers of smokers were less
than the non-smokers who died of various causes of sudden deaths during sporting activity except for only 1 case
in which cause of death was acute myocardial infarction. Associated miscellaneous conditions such as Kleibsella
infection and choking have accounted for 2 deaths and both of them were non-smokers.
Figure 8: Correlation between obesity and causes of sports related sudden deaths.
Count
yes
no
coronary artery
disease
acute myocardial
infarction
cardiomyopathy
ischeamic heart
dss
miscellanous
In our study, we found that the majority of those who died mainly of coronary artery disease were not obese; the
number of these cases is 16 compared to 6 cases which were obese. As for cardiomyopathy and miscellaneous
causes, none was found to be obese. People who died of acute myocardial infarction and ischemic heart disease
were found to be obese with only 1 case more than the non-obese in each cause.
120
11.36%
34.09%
11.36%
Discussion:
121
122
123
References:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
124