Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

Hosting Trco ilimitado

Oferta 1
Dominio
en Busc
Autoins

Voices

Mother Teresa wasn't a saintly person she


was a shrewd operator with unpalatable
views who knew how to build up a brand
Im not going to go down the well-trodden route of criticising a person
that Christopher Hitchensonce famously dubbed 'a lying, thieving
Albanian dwarf' but I do intend to let you know about the truth
surrounding this mysterious saint (and it's not all peace and love)
Douglas Robertson | 9 hours ago | 240 comments

7K
shares

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa72248

1/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

Mother Teresa accompanied by children at her mission in Calcutta, India 05/12/1980 Getty

The news has hit the headlines of pretty much every British
newspaper this morning: Mother Teresa has ocially been made
a saint. Following two successive conrmed miracles (dont get
me started), she is today being ocially recognised.
With everything thats happening in the world, why is this
particular person getting so much posthumous airtime? The
Catholic Church, after all, doesnt enjoy the same access to our
political system as the Church of England, so whats the
relevance here? Well, its quite simple really Mother Teresa was
a celebrity, with a very well-managed brand.

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa72248

2/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

READ MORE

Mother Teresa orphanages in India stop adoptions after


liberal reforms

Ask most people what they think about Mother Teresa and theyll
say something vague about what a good person she was, how
benevolent, self-sacricing and generally lovely. I have absolute
sympathy with this stance; thats been the pretty consistent
thread throughout the news coverage of her, both in life and after
death.
Im not going to go down the well-trodden route of criticising a
person that Christopher Hitchens (who played the role of devils
advocate in the discussions surrounding her canonisation) once
famously dubbed a lying, thieving Albanian dwarf thats been
done before, and by people with gifts of expression far superior
to my own.
Much of the criticism levelled at Mother Teresa centres around
the way she promoted views of the Catholic Church that many
would see as dogmatic. Take her stance on contraception: In
destroying the power of giving life, through contraception, a
husband or wife is doing something to self. This turns the
attention to self and so destroys the gift of love in him or her.

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa72248

3/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

Abortion? She didnt hold back with that either: I always say one
thing: If a mother can kill her own child, then what is left of the
West to be destroyed? It is dicult to explain, but it is just that.
Pope Francis gives life advice: in pictures

7K

shares

News

Voices

Culture

Lifestyle

10
show all

Perhaps not the most enlightened of views, to put it lightly (and


somewhat ironically). The Roman Catholic Church, however,
famously has no qualms with either of them, so its not surprising
that they work in her favour. She wasnt perhaps quite as vitriolic
in her criticism of gay people as they might have liked, but I
suppose nobodys perfect. She in fact famously once stopped an
interview when the interviewer used the word homosexuals,
saying that they should be referred to as friends of Jesus. Cute.
I submit however that the reason she is being acknowledged by
the Vatican in this ostentatious and rather costly fashion is much
more to do with the fact that she represents the greatest PR
http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa72248

4/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

victory of the Church in the past hundred years. A suitably


charismatic appearance, a penchant for photo opportunities with
Princess Diana (an incredibly successful and symbiotic brand
collaboration if ever there was one), and a global fundraising
brand (Mother Teresas Missionaries of Charity has raised and
deployed billions of dollars across the world) this, all this
We use cookies to enhance your visit to our site and to bring you advertisements that might interest you. Read our
combined
with
theto publics
belief that Mother, or Saint, Teresa
Privacy
and Cookie
Policies
nd out more.
preached a deliciously palatable message of peace and love which
7K
News Voices Culture Lifestyle

bordered on the hippie.


shares Im not sure when the Roman Catholic
Church last had an advocate who enjoyed her level of prole, at
least not in a positive sense. Im fairly sure that most members of
the public would much more readily recognise an image of her
than any of the last few Popes.

Perhaps even devout secularists such as I shouldnt be too


surprised that Mother Teresa is now being made a saint the
Church, in honouring her in this way, is ensuring the longevity
of a brand that continues not only to raise the prole of their
mission and messages, but surely raises considerable capital into
the bargain. The question is: was a woman who preached virtue
in suering rather than trying to alleviate it and took money from
dictators really that saintly at all?
More about: | Mother Teresa | Pope Francis | Catholic Church

SponsoredLinks byTaboola

Aged 35 he speaks 11 languages - his 11 tricks to learn any language


Babbel

24 Celebs With IQs Too Bizarre To Believe


ZestVIP

Are you a strategic thinker? Test your skills with millions of addicted players!
Sparta Online Game

30 Creepy Places You Didn't Know Exist


GeekVIP

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa72248

5/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

Las tres ancdotas de lotera ms increbles de todos los tiempos


theLotter.com

30 Gigantic Cats You Won't Believe Are Real


PressRoomVIP

We use cookies to enhance your visit to our site and to bring you advertisements that might interest you. Read our
Privacy and Cookie Policies to nd out more.

Life In Occupation on German Photos


EnglishRussia

20 Used Cars To Avoid


Carophile

5 Star Luxury Hotels For Under 99


VeryChic.com

The Only 2 Sites You Need to Know About When Building a Website
Top 10 Best Website Builders

End Your Nightly Snoring Nightmare With This Simple Solution


My Snoring Solution

Suffering From Acid Reux? There Is A Natural Remedy...


Rapid Reux Relief eBook

COMMENTS

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa72248

6/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

COMMENTS
Log in or register to comment

240 Comments
WalterTull

Subscribe RSS
11 minutes ago

Douglas unless you have done something for india's poor you
are nothing and so have nothing to say.
So keep quiet
Reply Share

european

-1 likes

18 minutes ago

Not surprisingly, the decline of ISIS coincides with the


sainthood of Mother Theresa. Just think of the horror of
claiming your 70 virgins and discovering that Mother Theresa
is one of them.
Reply Share

european

+4 likes

20 minutes ago

I see Hitchens is still able to enrage from posterity those who


cannot wait for the Day of Judgment, those looking up in awe
to Mother Theresa just because she succeeded in jumping the
queue.
Reply Share

european

+1 likes

38 minutes ago

It is a mystery, no, a miracle that the Vatican detects a PR


victory in the popularity of a person that denied essential
treatment to those left in her care, the dying and the merely ill
who could have been saved by spending a tiny fraction of the
donations she accepted in their name.
Reply Share

Uzernayme

+5 likes

45 minutes ago

My favourite saint was always Saint N Greavsie


Reply Share

Volsted Gridban

+1 likes

47 minutes ago

How much Catholic tat has been sold since this


announcement? The Saint Teresa tea towels must be ying o
the shelves. You are such fools to believe in this hokum.
http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa72248

7/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

Saints are a sop to the people after monotheism came about.


Can't worship multiple gods anymore? No problem. Simply
call them saints,give them all something they are protectors of
{same as pagan gods} ...and away you go.
Reply Share

youcrackmeup

+2 likes

47 minutes ago

I see anti-catholic bigotry, the last acceptable prejudice alive


and well down here in the comments
Reply Share

83% of my predictions are quite close

-3 likes

1 hour ago

Pathetic.
A married couple should not need contraception because they
should receive children as gifts of God. I wonder what the
AIDS and sexually transmitted disease rates are between a
monogamous couple? Very low.
Abortion. 98% of the 200,000 unborn babies aborted in the
UK each year are completely healthy and 81% of the women
are single according to the Department of Health. In the US,
the Guttmacher Institute found that 1% of abortions were due
to rape and less than 0.5% due to incest.
Therefore, the vast majority of abortions are the killing of
healthy unborn children conceived with consent to single
women. Not a good picture especially given the mental
distress women feel after abortion and putting themselves at
risk in transient relationships. Wake up to the facts. The
Catholic church supports the family and human life in a
brilliant and sensible way.
Reply Share

Athanasius

-3 likes

1 hour ago

The author declares an aversion the Christopher Hitchens


before quoting him. Cosmic. The high point of this article is a
quote from an intellectual prostitute whose commentaries
were click bait and who had all the sincerity of Christmas in
Las Vegas.
Reply Share

OdysseusReturns

-4 likes

1 hour ago

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa72248

8/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

"Im not going to go down the well-trodden route of criticising


a person that Christopher Hitchens once famously dubbed 'a
lying, thieving Albanian dwarf' "
However that's exactly what this dwarf journalist then
proceeds to do, so he clearly has all the self-awareness of a ea.
I am not Catholic or religious in any sense but the sheer
desperation of the existentially confused to make a hero
(secular saint?) of the congenitally nasty dipsomaniac
Christopher Hitchens (not remarkably endowed himself in the
height department) is mind-boggling.
Reply Share 3 replies

De Vise

-2 likes

1 hour ago

Excellent post! Although it's unlikely to be appreciated


by the angry "existentially confused" individuals here.
Reply Share 2 replies

Volsted Gridban

+1 likes

13 minutes ago

We are not 'existentially confused'. I take it by that


you mean we atheists don't believe in god,but you
do. Are you selective in your god worship? What's
your stance on Odin,Zeus,Ra,Helios,Enki,Tengri
and thousands of others? Then we'll start on the
Goddesses.
Reply Share 1 reply

De Vise

+2 likes

3 minutes ago

I am not sure why you feel entitled to claim


that others are not "existentially confused".
How do you know that? I have said nothing
about what I may or may not believe.
However, why don't you outline your
argument about dierent gods and
goddesses which you allude to above? Then
we can see if it will hold water.
Reply Share

0 likes

Show more comments

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa72248

9/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa7224

10/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

CURSOS DE
INGLS GRATIS
http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa7224

11/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

abaenglish.com/cursos_ingles

Aprende Ingls en Lne y


Gratis. Apntate Ahora y
Empieza Ya!

The best and worst


countries in the world
for making friends
7 words you are using
that make you sound
rude
9 things that used to be
cool but now aren't,
according to reddit
What happened after
Sweden introduced a six
hour work day
What you need to know
about sex in 8 charts
and a map

MOST POPULAR
The country that has
completely banned
http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa7224

12/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent
The country that has

completely banned
smoking
Why Mother Teresa
wasn't as saintly as
you'd think

Emergency services
respond to mass chilli
consumption at US
school
Stephen Hawking warns
over Brexit attitudes
towards money
Avatar 2, 3, 4 and 5
director James Cameron
admits he 'overwrote'
SponsoredLinks

Celebs Whose Private Jets Are Too


Bizarre To Believe
ZestVIP

BMW X5 por 44.600


44.600 - autoscout24.es

36 Terrifying Military Photos


GeekVIP

5 tips to learn any language from 2


language geniuses
Babbel

36 Celebrities You Didn't Know Had


Died
PressRoomVIP
byTaboola

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa7224

13/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

Man charged after Eddie


Izzard's beret stolen at antiVIDEO
Brexit march

World's highest glass- 12 celebrities you


bottomed bridge
never knew were
closes two weeks after refugees
opening

SPONSORED FEATURES
13 Handy hair-styling
hacks

Could you be a better


leader than May or
Corbyn?
Could you be the next
Usain Bolt?

How to host your own


music festival

Going for gold: how to


combine elite sports
training with university

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa7224

14/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa7224

15/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

Follow us:

User Policies

Newsletters

Privacy Policy

Jobs

Cookie Policy

Subscriptions

Code of Conduct

Advertising Guide

Complaint Form

Syndication

Contact Us

Evening Standard

Contributors

Novaya Gazeta

All Topics

Install our Apps

Archive

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa7224

16/17

4/9/2016

MotherTeresawasn'tasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowtobuildupabrand|TheIndependent

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/motherteresawasntasaintlypersonshewasashrewdoperatorwithunpalatableviewswhoknewhowa7224

17/17

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi