Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Published by
African Centre for Media Excellence
Plot 124 Nanjala Road (Bunga-Soya), off Ggaba Road
P. O Box 11283 Kampala, Uganda
Tel: +256393202351
info@acme.org
www.acme-ug.org
Facebook: ACME.UG
Twitter: @ACME_Uganda
CopyrightACME 2015
Layout and Design
Harriet Anena
hanena@acme-ug.org
Cover Photo
www.itnews.com
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This report is published with support from the Democratic Governance
Facility (DGF), which has funded ACMEs project on monitoring media
coverage of the 2016 elections. We are grateful for the partnership with
DGF.
Several individuals have contributed to the report and we single out a few.
Project Manager Mohles Kalule Segululigamba, technical advisor George
Lugalambi, and statisticians Yusuf Mulumba and Brian Ssenabulya. We
also recognise the contribution of ACME staff Peter G. Mwesige and
Harriet Anena.
ACME would also like to thank the panel of advisors that reviews the
findings every month before they are shared with the public. Panel
members are David Ouma Balikowa, Charlotte Kawesa Ntulume, William
Tayeebwa, Patricia Litho and Joseph Ssemakula.
ACME further thanks the coders who tirelessly entered data and the
research assistants who recorded broadcast content.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY................................................................................................1
INTRODUCTION...........................................................................................................3
Background....................................................................................................................3
METHODOLOGY................................................................................................11
Scope of the Monitoring........................................................................................11
Sample and Sampling Methods............................................................................11
Methods of Data Collection....................................................................................15
Experience..............................................................................................................25
Freedom to Report....................................................................................................25
FINDINGS.........................................................................................................................27
Tone........................................................................................................................39
Reporting Approach.................................................................................................42
Number of Sources...................................................................................................53
CONCLUSION.........................................................................................55
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This report presents the results of the monitoring of newspaper coverage
of the Ugandan presidential and parliamentary elections in the month of
September 2015. Following are the key findings:
Election stories were generally prominent in newspaper coverage,
appearing above the fold in 72.4% of all cases analysed.
The tone of newspaper coverage of the elections was for the most
part (58% of the time) neutral.
1
INTRODUCTION
This report presents the results of the monitoring of newspaper coverage
of the Ugandan presidential and parliamentary elections in the month of
November 2015. Comprehensive findings on the quantity and the quality
of coverage in nine newspapers, five television stations and more than
two dozen radio stations are presented and discussed.
Background
Fully functioning democracies are associated with periodic free and fair
elections where all contesting political viewpoints are fairly and equitably
communicated through the media so that voters have an opportunity to
make informed choices/decisions as to who their leaders will be. Media
coverage of elections from the process of making electoral laws, the
2 Marie-Soleil Frre (2010). The Media and Elections in Post-Conflict Central African Countries. Brussels: University
of Brussels.
Although both the Constitution and electoral laws provide for equal
access to candidates on state or public media, in all previous elections
the latter have been accused of paying disproportionate attention to
the activities of the incumbent and ruling party at the expense of the
challengers and the opposition. This practice denies the viewing/
listening public access to adequate information against which to judge
all sides in the election.
Denial of access to state/public media by opposition candidates
The media have also been accused of focusing more on the drama and
daily routine of the election campaign at the expense of the issues. They
3 See e.g. Memonet (2011). Uganda media coverage of the 2011 elections: final media monitoring report. Kampala.
also tend to report the election as an event rather than a process. This
practice denies the public not only information but also the context
within which to judge candidates, parties, electoral authorities, as well
the process.
No serious interrogation of candidate claims and promises
It has been said that voters are the most critical players in elections.
Unfortunately, it has been pointed out that media coverage in Uganda, as
in many other countries, tends to pay far more attention to the candidates
and their parties than to the voters. Lost in this kind of reporting, for
instance, are the issues that matter most to the voters as well as their
own evolving evaluation of the electoral process.
Attempts by political actors, especially those in government, to influence
visuals in newspapers and on television
the media are supposed to give candidates the right to reply to attacks
from their opponents. They are also supposed to give candidates and
parties similar opportunity to respond to issues. This has not always
been the case in the coverage of elections in Uganda.
Other concerns and gaps in media coverage of elections have revolved
around the following:
Bias.
Inaccurate reporting.
Bribery of journalists.
Self-censorship.
1. What is the operating environment for the media ahead of the elections?
2. What topics do the media focus on in their coverage of the elections?
10
METHODOLOGY
This section presents the scope of the monitoring exercise, the sample
and sampling methods, methods of data collection as well as the tools
that we used.
Scope of the monitoring
11
all facets of the election coverage that the electorate in its diversity is
exposed to.
Print media
Television
The five TV channels included in the sample collectively cover the whole
country. All but one broadcast primarily in English. Bukedde broadcasts
in Luganda and is one of the platforms owned by the Vision Group.
Uganda Broadcasting Corporation (UBC) is the public broadcaster. The
rest of the stations are privately owned. The channels included in the TV
samples are:
1. Bukedde
2. NBS
3. NTV
4. UBC
5. WBS
Radio
The radio stations selected for monitoring collectively cover the entire
country and represent Ugandas seven major regions: Kampala, central,
eastern, western, south-western, northern, and North-Western/West
Nile. This sample constitutes about 13% of the 250 or so stations in
operation across the country. The selected radio stations generally
accommodate all audience profiles as defined by social class, language,
religion, ethnicity, and geography/geo-politics. Except UBC, the public
broadcaster, all the other channels are either private, faith-based, or
community radio stations. The stations that make up the radio sample
are presented by region on Page 14.
13
MEDIA
FREQUENCY
Kampala (5)
Capital Radio
KFM
Top Radio
Simba FM
UBC Blue Channel
FM 91.3
FM 93.3
FM 89.6
FM 97.3
FM 98
Baba
Open Gate
Rock Mambo
Kioga Veritas
Voice of Teso
Signal FM
FM 87.7
FM 103.2
FM 106.8
FM 91.5
FM 88.4
FM 88.1
Central (5)
Eastern (6)
Western (5)
South-Western (2)
Northern (4)
Radio Sapientia
Voice of Africa
Central Broadcasting Services
Buddu
Spice FM
Kasese Guide
Voice of Toro
Bushenyi
Bunyoro Broadcasting Services
Radio West
Rukungiri FM
Voice of Kigezi
Mighty Fire
Dokolo FM
Mega FM
Rhino
14
FM 94.8
FM 92.3
FM 89.2
FM 101.9
FM 89.9
FM 100.5
FM 101
FM 92.2
FM 98.2
FM 100.2
FM 96.7
FM 89.5
FM 91.5
FM 102.4
FM 102.1
FM 96.1
FM 89.1
FM 94.1
FM 100.9
FM 87.8
FM 88.7
FM 90.9
Social media
Twitter will be monitored in the coming months. It has been selected
over other social media platforms on pragmatic grounds. The objectives
is to ascertain the extent to which the main presidential candidates use
Twitter as an alternative media form during and after the campaign
season as well as to assess candidates use of Twitter to listen to and
respond to queries, demands and debates from the electorate online.
Methods of data collection
15
16
For radio news/current affairs, the monitoring focuses on the two most
important daily news bulletins broadcast around the top of the hour
during the morning and evening prime listening times between 7 a.m.
9 a.m. and 7 p.m. 9 p.m.
ACME plans to pay for and receive comprehensive analytics from the
online monitoring company, Social Bakers as well as internal Twitter
analytics. Areas of interest will include number of followers, change in
followers over time, incoming and outgoing interactions, as well as total
and frequency of tweets.
Key Informant Interviews
17
Although Uganda has some of the most vibrant media in east and
southern Africa, in the last five years, the country has been characterised
by Freedom House as partly free. In one of its more recent reports,
the international press freedom watchdog concluded that although the
countrys constitution provides for freedom of expression and press
freedom, several laws negate these guarantees, and the government
continues to crack down on critical journalists and media houses using
both subtle and blatant methods7.
Legal framework
18
dom-press/2011/uganda
These laws provide for statutory regulation and establish the Media
Council as the primary regulator of the print media but also aspects
of broadcast media, and the Uganda Communications Commission
as the regulator of electronic media and telecommunications. All
journalists are supposed to be licensed by the Media Council, which is
by law required to recognise only those enrolled under the National
Institute of Journalists of Uganda (NIJU). Journalists require university
degrees to become full members of NIJU. These regulations have not
been followed strictly in the last 15 years although they continue to
attract criticism from media freedom watchers, who also fault Ugandas
regulatory regime for not having the necessary independence from the
government.
The fourth Schedule of the Press and Journalist Act provides for a
professional code of ethics that lists nine commandments:
1. No journalist shall disseminate information or an allegation without
establishing its correctness or truth.
21
Its FM radio affiliates include the community station Mega FM, based
in Gulu, and the Kampala-based Magic FM, a sports and music outlet.
Although UBC was expected to have transformed into a public broadcaster, it remains very much a state entity that is largely subservient to
President Museveni9 and the ruling party and rarely provides for views
critical of the government.
22
12 https://hrnjuganda.org/?p=1438
14 http://www.ucc.co.ug/files/downloads/Annual%20Market%20Industry%20Report%202014-15-%20October%2019-2015.pdf.
15 http://www.contadorharrison.com/social-media-use-in-uganda/
16 http://www.observer.ug/news-headlines/38278-who-s-tom-voltaire-okwalinga-tvo
17 https://www.facebook.com/tom.okwalinga?fref=ts
18 https://www.facebook.com/Tvo-Uganda-654610647943658/?fref=ts
19 http://www.monitor.co.ug/News/National/Lawyers-demand-release-of-social-media-critic-/-/688334/2747382/-/r3f7qaz/-/index.html
23
held, the Tom Voltaire Okwalinga Facebook page stayed active, carrying
posts that mocked the government for holding the wrong person.
24
Paper Presented at Breakfast Meeting for Media Owners Hosted by the Civil Society Capacity Building Programme. Kampala, November 15, 2006
Years of Journalism: African media since Ghanas independence. (pp. 97-109). Johannesburg: African Editors Forum,
Highway Africa, and Media Foundation for West Africa.
25
A NRM supporter flashes a wad of money during a rally in the recent 2016 elections. Several
journalists interviewed admitted to receiving money from politicians and their agents during
the 2016 elections. Photo by ACFIM.
26
FINDINGS
Volume of election stories
Although the media monitoring is for both presidential and
parliamentary elections, these results mainly focus on the presidential
elections as they dominated media coverage in September.
A total of 336 articles were analysed, of which 319 were news stories
and the others opinions or letters to the editor. Daily Monitor (27.1%)
carried the most articles on elections followed by the Red Pepper (21.1%)
and Bukedde (17.9%). The tri-weekly, The Observer, had more election
articles than the leading daily, New Vision. The regional local language
titles Rupiny and Orumuri contributed very little to the election article
basket.
Figure 1: Number of election articles
27
28
The New Vision (78.6%), Daily Monitor (78.3%) and The Observer (73.9%)
all gave a far higher proportion of their coverage to the presidential
election. Vision Groups local language regional titles, Orumuri (100%)
and Etop (50%), paid far more attention to the parliamentary elections.
Perhaps this is because the English-language newspapers target a
national audience while the regional publications serve more of a local
readership.
Figure 2-1: Type of election by newspaper
29
30
Among the dailies, Daily Monitor (32.7%) accorded the most space to
the elections with Bukedde following at 26%. At 17.4%, the New Vision
dedicated significantly less space.
Figure 3-1: Space to elections by dailies
31
32
Among the dailies, Daily Monitor (88%) and Red Pepper (87.3%) gave far
more prominence to election stories by placing them above the fold than
New Vision (54.8%).
Figure 4-1: Prominence of election stories by publication
33
34
35
36
37
Location of stories
Location of coverage was used to show the region where the subject
of the story (event) took place or in case of issue-based stories, the
geographical origin of the article.
38
Tone
This is the general character portrayed by the story. For purposes of this
study it applies only to stories that focus on the presidential aspirants
and parties.
The tone is negative when the article in general paints the candidate or
party in bad light, or is critical of or questions the candidate, party or a
particular issue raised by these actors.
The findings show that the general tone of newspaper coverage of the
candidates and parties was in most cases neutral (58.0%). Orumuri had
the highest incidence of articles with a neutral tone (100%), followed by
New Vision (82.6%) and The Observer (66.7%).
The number of articles with a positive and negative tone were just about
the same.
Figure 9: General newspaper tone
39
Red Pepper (39.4%) and Etop (37.5%) had far higher proportion of articles
with a negative tone than any of the other newspapers. Interestingly,
Etop also had the highest proportion of articles with a positive tone
(50%) followed by The Independent (36.4%).
Figure 9-1: Tone of coverage by publication
40
41
Reporting approach
The reporting approach is the style in which the election stories are
reported. Conventional reporting tends to focus on events (hard news)
with fact-reporting as the dominant posture. In interpretive reporting,
explanation is the dominant posture. Under the enterprise reporting
approach, the journalists own initiative and effort are critical in
originating the story, whereas in investigative reporting, exposition is
the dominant posture (i.e. the reporting uncovers information that an
individual or entity may have tried to conceal from public scrutiny, or
information that an individual or entity may have had an interest in
keeping out of the public domain).
The findings show that most of the reporting in September followed
the conventional approach (70.2%). There was a small but significant
proportion of investigative stories (14.7%), some interpretive reporting
(11.9%), and very little enterprise (3.1%)
Figure 10: Reporting approach for election-related stories
42
43
The findings show that whereas there were more stories that focused
on personalities (37.1%) than on issues (24.2%), the highest proportion
(38.7%) focused on both.
Figure 11: Issues vs. Personalities reporting
44
The findings show that Etop (62.5%) and Bukedde (59.6%) paid far more
attention to personalities than issues. The Observer (45.7%) and Daily
Monitor (42.2%) also paid high attention to personalities whereas New
Vision (47.6%) followed by The Independent (40%) carried the highest
proportion of stories that focused on issues.
Figure 11-1: Issue vs personality reporting by publication
45
46
The Independent, Orumuri and Etop (100%) each employed the use of
background and context in all their election stories which required it.
New Vision (53.3%) and Bukedde (50%) had the lowest proportion of
background and reporting.
Figure 12-1: Use of background & context by publication
47
48
The findings further show that Orumuri (100%) did not question
candidate claims or promises at all, while Bukedde (75%) and New Vision
(66.7%) also made it easy for candidates most of the time. Etop (100%),
The Independent (50%) and Daily Monitor (42.6%) and Red Pepper
(42.5%) led the way in interrogating candidate claims and promises.
Figure 13-1: Breakdown of interrogation of claims by publication
49
Note: Multiple responses were allowed in the coding of this variable given
that one story can have several sources. The percentages presented,
therefore, are based on the number of sources and not stories.
The results show that party officials (32.6%) and presidential aspirants
(14.8%) were the most frequently cited sources in election stories.
Ordinary people (2.4%) and civil society (1.2%) were rarely used as
sources. In short, the political class (elite) dominated the election
discourse while ordinary Ugandans were for the most part bystanders
or onlookers.
Figure 14: Sources in election reporting
50
Gender of sources
Gender was coded only if it was stated in the story or if it was obvious.
Once again, multiple responses were allowed in the coding of this
variable given that one story can have several sources. The percentages
presented, therefore, are based on the number of sources and not stories.
The findings show that male sources (84.3%) dominated the reporting,
with women constituting only 15.7%.
Figure 15: Sources of election stories by gender
51
52
Number of sources
At 54%, single-sourced stories dominated newspaper election coverage
in September. Only 23% of the stories had the desirable three or more
sources.
Figure 16: Number of sources
53
54
CONCLUSION
The results show a mixed bag. Newspapers published a relatively high
number of election stories in September, but they did not always cover
all the aspects that would help readers make informed decisions.
Following are the key findings from the monitoring of newspaper
coverage in September:
Considering that only four of the newspapers in the sample are daily
another four are weekly and one is tri-weeklythe results suggest a
relatively high volume of election stories in the newspapers.
55
56
ACME 2015