Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Hedge Fund
Manager
SPREZZATURIAN
INVESTING LESSONS
Mik ae l Syding
| iii
FOREWORD
Thank you for downloading my book from mikaelsyding.com
If you didnt, please visit and subscribe to my newsletter. Its at least as
useful and entertaining as this eBook. And free. And spam free.
Also please note that I was a fund manager, not a designer or writer. This
book reflects exactly that. That said, I hope you will enjoy it. E-mail any
feedback to mikael.syding@gmail.com
Mik ae l Syding
|v
vi|
Mik ae l Syding
| vii
CONTENTS
Forewordiii
Executive Summary - never rush your investments
v
Hej!xi
Always be investing
xiii
xiv
Pictures of Stockholm
xv
xx
Takeaways1
I actually never watch TV; I dont have cable or other means of receiving TV2
Pictures from my apartment3
Bedroom4
My sauna5
The Master bathroom6
The lounge 7
Ronja8
At the office9
Always be investing
10
15 year summary
12
Screen shot11
Performance chart13
Defining moments14
16
17
Jukkasjrvi17
Bullied18
Prize winner19
Errand boy
Top ranked analyst
19
20
22
viii|
24
26
Inception29
Futuris 63 most important decisions
30
Futuris Stock Market Exposure 1999-201431
32
33
33
36
People matter
38
38
38
40
40
41
41
43
44
46
48
49
51
51
52
53
53
55
55
59
Golden gods57
Where are the customers yachts?58
Mik ae l Syding
Dont let luck or hope be your strategy
Redemption - the bear returns
Another nerve-wrecking year of extremes
| ix
59
61
61
65
65
68
70
71
74
74
74
77
84
84
86
89
90
91
Whatever it takes
92
98
Decision paralysis?77
Dare tot ride a bear? Dare fight the Fed?80
Mixed emotions85
So good we were scary86
Close but no cigar88
A sliver of hope still lingered in 201290
Mario Draghi92
Draghis effects on PIGS yields were astounding93
Smaug the mighty client96
Market correction 201497
x|
Defining moments
The giga lesson: the cycle of forgotten lessons:
102
102
103
103
104
105
106
110
Holistic research113
117
Subscribe117
mikaelsyding.com117
Karl-Mikael Syding118
119
Reading tips:
Contact Information
121
121
Mik ae l Syding
| xi
HEJ!
My name is Karl-Mikael Syding, but I often use the handle Sprezzaturian
(from sprezzatura, which means approximately studied nonchalance making hard things look natural and easy)
Here I am in Ibiza in July 2014
xii|
Definitely not a douche. Rather, quite the happy camper: rockin and
arollin.
I want to take this opportunity to share my story...
Mik ae l Syding
AlwAys
| xiii
be investing
xiv|
Mik ae l Syding
| xv
pictures of stockholM
The Swedish Parliament and my dog Ronja
Sweden probably has the least well guarded prime minister and King in
the world. Imagine taking this picture in the US or UK...
xvi|
Mik ae l Syding
Humlegrden & Stureplan
| xvii
xviii|
Mik ae l Syding
| xix
xx|
Please forgive me for using the word retarded. For me, its just wordplay
(retired HF manager that is contrarian and, uhm, special), and I figured,
since its directed toward myself it wouldnt offend anybody.
Mik ae l Syding
|1
TAKEAWAYS
This is the story of how our hedge fund, Futuris (Brummer), came about.
how we outperformed the stock market 7-fold, during arguably
the toughest economic environment since the Great Depression
(turning 1 euro into 7, while the market went nowhere, via a
dizzying booms and devastating busts)
culminating in becoming the European Hedge Fund Of The
Decade in 2010, and the wind-down in September 2014. I
resigned in January that year but agreed to stay on as just the
Managing Director for the rest of the year.
Here is some of what I hope you can take away:
A collection of investment rules of thumb
Professional money managers are just normal people
There is no correct path to join the club of high finance
Running a hedge fund is not for everyone (e.g., me)
A warning regarding the current state of the stock market, just as
valid in March 2016 as it was in March 2015
Always be investing (in yourself)
Hedge funds will have their own quirks and ways of doing things.
Ours was no different - if you want to create real value, you have to
be prepared to go against the grain & trust your individual instincts.
Although I would require a much larger guide to explain everything,
I hope you can take away an idea as to what it took for us to generate
returns for our fund.
My path to becoming Partner and Managing Director of Futuris was not
linear. Im just an ordinary guy from a small town in the very north of
Sweden. I had no contacts, no network, no role models, but still floated
to the top (like a turd)
- I hope it can inspire you if you are interested in using the power of your
mind in the financial services sector. But, in a world where it seems you
2|
can make huge fortunes from a computer screen, I have to warn you that
there is no rose garden.
We had a good ride, but it was stressful. I dont want to leave you with any
false impressions. Personally, I wouldnt do it again, but I am thankful
for everything I learned (as well as my financial independence).
I actually never watch TV; I dont have cable or other means of
receiving TV
Mik ae l Syding
Pictures from my apartment
|3
4|
Mik ae l Syding
|5
6|
Still, I cant deny I made a lot of money; money that makes me comfortable
and gives me time and ability to explore what I really want in life.
I know how it feels to be without money, and one of those feelings is
wanting money, but please take it from me, having a lot is really not such a
big deal. Its not worth ruining your body and wasting your best 20 years
for - in particular if you happen to join the majority that never become
rich anyway.
The Master bathroom
Buying large living quarters, Swiss mechanical watches and Russian art
seemed natural when money came easy, but money is not what defines
me. Investing is.
Mik ae l Syding
|7
The lounge
As long as youve got food on the table, tools to use and something
meaningful to keep you occupied, youre doing better than 99% of folks
throughout the world.
Investing (the science of leverage), using larger numbers to build wealth,
knowledge, a network, etc, are part of the game...
... the game of life.
You dont need a lot of money to play the game. Investing is a lot more
than just money. Investing for me means building, growing, learning and
acquiring tools to become better at becoming better. And yes, you can
invest money too using the same principle.
However, many people put the cart before the horse - thinking money is
the answer to their problems.
Money only solves immediate issues (getting a cab, hiring a web designer);
it does not solve long term problems, which are the root of most peoples
woes.
8|
Sure, I dont have to worry about buying groceries, paying for BBQs,
taking my girlfriend out on spontaneous romantic gestures, or helping
out students who want to learn from my experience by spending real
time with them.
Yeah, I bought a few nice cars, and got fed up with them. And yes, I live
well (albeit no MTV crib life style; Im just not attracted to that), but first
and foremost I have learned that experiences and accomplishments beat
stuff every day of the week.
Ive been on massive highs, and terrible lows, as youll see later in the
book.
But in the end, now that Im a retired (retarded) hedge fund manager,
I value nothing more than the lessons I picked up along our 15 year
rollercoaster. And my dog, Ronja.
Ronja
Mik ae l Syding
|9
If anything, I hope my story shows you that you really dont need contacts,
massive brainpower, some magical talent or anything else to earn a lot
of money.
You simply need to be yourself, some grit, and learn how to invest (never
rush, build consistently), how to grow value exponentially over the long
run.
I am proud of my wealth, but am certainly not ostentatious.
If youre here for easy money, fast cars & fast women, Ill have to disappoint...
Ive turned off the fast lane.
This book, and my entire life, is about investing (in yourself) for the long
term.
At the ofce
About as crazy as it gets -officially (unless you count ripping off your shirt,
10|
If you want to play the money markets, youre likely going to lose. Even
the big guys lose.
And all that talk... the macho chest-beating you get in the financial
world... its all baloney.
No-one can predict the future.
No-one has superhuman powers.
Everyone loses. Everyone wins. Sometime.
All in all, the more you invest, the more youll gain back over time
Its generally a slow and not always particularly steady process
If someone seems to be doing better than you, it might very well only
be temporary, depending on whether he and you use sound principles or
not. They might be speculating rather than investing.
Always be investing
Whether its reading, working out, testing new strategies, the difference
between the best & rest, is the best are always investing (in skills, in sweat,
in contributions).
They are prepared to go without in the short-term, for compounded
gains in the long-term. Financially and personally.
I believe this is what made our little Stockholm hedge fund the European
Hedge Fund Of The Decade.
Mik ae l Syding
| 11
Screen shot
This is where I made my fortune. Pretty boring? By the way, the chart on
paper depicts bank Loan Loss Provisions, one key metric for predicting
bank losses and financial crises.
12|
15 YEAR SUMMARY
Tack. As a Thank you (tack in Swedish. Pronunciation) for taking
time on my site, I want to give you this introspective look at the inner
workings of our hedge fund.
In the most difficult stock market in a century, including two career
crushing crashes and three meteoric bull manias in just 12 years, we
delivered > 600% net return after fees to our clients (with below-market
risk), while the stock market produced nothing but ulcers. Read on to
find out how we did it.
The last few years were a different story though. More about that later:
The walk of shame. Oh, yes, it wasnt always a rose garden.
Having become a decamillionaire managing money doesnt change the
fact that I would have chosen a different career, if I could go back 25 years
in time. I now know that money is not what makes me tick; its investing.
Robotics, AI, water purification, pollution, insect protein etc. is where I
would go if I was young again.
If youre interested in entering the world of high finance, or want to
know what its like away from imperious Wall Street; or maybe are just
interested in how rich guys do business, I would hope this guide serves
your needs, even if I wanted out.
Mik ae l Syding
| 13
If youre savvy with financial growth charts, this is our fund, Futuris (red),
compared to the market (grey and black):
Performance chart
Dont let the compressed nature of the graph fool you. The market
exploded upward at the end of 1999, crashed down to less than half its
peak 3 years later, tripled, halved again and finally tripled again!
Many careers and fortunes were laid to rest during those 15 years. We
(although it was very difficult) thrived. Well, financially at least.
By the way, I see another halving of the stock market coming
soon. Dont get caught fully invested in that one. This statement
is still valid in March 2016.
14|
How Futuris delivered >600% net returns (after fees, commissions etc.)
to clients in a flat market
1: Inception. A rocket taking off in Q4-99; >+50% net return to clients
in 2 months.
x: An agonizing and turbulent sideways year (2000) - had the IT bubble
peaked or not?
y: The loss of one of the two founding portfolio managers - near death
for the young company
19 Sept 2002: One of the two portfolio managers died at the office, but
the fund was thriving
z: Worst month ever, August 2007: -7%
q: 2008, the financial crisis. We were net short, having the time of our
lives, but covered after Lehmans bankruptcy before the market crashed
further.
W: Wow!, we turned on a dime, March 8-9, 2009, from short to long, at
the very trough, buying 150% within 24 hours
H: Hedge Fund Of The Decade gala in London, May 2010
F: Fukushima disaster in April 2011, and three impossibly good trades by
Futuris
P: Peak of Futuris; >+600% in 11.5 years in a flat market
D: Near death experience, as we were >100% net long, right before the
crisis of 2011
: June 2012, we were approaching a new peak for the fund, being
Mik ae l Syding
| 15
extremely net short when CB/Draghi spoiled our party and sparked a
fantastic rally by promising Whatever it takes
s: We were forced to stop our losses in the mid summer 2013 correction
(hardly visible) - a de facto death sentence for Futuris, due to subsequent
ramifications
e: end; Futuris was closed down in September 2014, net long right before
the autumn mini-crash. That was 8-9 months after I officially resigned as
portfolio manager and partner. I was just the Managing Director then.
?:What would have happened? A disastrous stop loss or opportunistic and
successful buying?
16|
The legendary Arne Vaagen December 2, 1999 after a fantastic start for
Futuris.
Mik ae l Syding
| 17
It was only after I was bullied in school, and my attempt to escape their
ignorance, that I happened onto computers, mathematics, science &
numbers.
Heres my quick background for you:
Born in January 1972 above the Arctic Circle ... yes, it is as bleak as it
sounds.
I almost died during my first week of life - we had an issue with our Ford
Taunus (yes, thats correct: Taunus not Taurus) breaking down halfway between two hospitals (100 miles apart). Thankfully, I made it
Jukkasjrvi
18|
I never really understood what my mother did, apart from being active in
the typically Swedish political movement in the late 70s for abolishing
nuclear power, just not right now...
I was bullied (quite badly) in primary school by the rich kids. Since our
family was not as well-endowed as my primary school counterparts, they
treated me like the whipping-boy; not least due to the fact that I was
wearing cheap clothes and speaking with a funny northern accent.
Bullied
Mik ae l Syding
| 19
errAnd boy
When it came to grow some balls and get a job, I was picked up by a
third tier firm in the struggling Swedish stock broker industry during one
of the worst economic slumps (1991-1994) in modern Swedish history.
20|
Mik ae l Syding
| 21
22|
Mik ae l Syding
| 23
24|
Futuris, Brummer!
All ten of my colleagues at Brummer & Partners, who were seated
together at a large round table toward the back of the elegant but packed
room, simultaneously rose and roared irreverently. It was the Brummer
groups fifth big, and most important, win that night, ahead of industry
Mik ae l Syding
| 25
26|
Mik ae l Syding
| 27
nerve to thank...:
the long only herd who made this possible - and markets for taking the first step
toward sanity. I hope markets take a second step this year. If so, well meet again
(*Applause and laughter* Did he actually say that?!)
In my view, thoughtless speculation, by long-only, buy-only, buy
and hold investors, had created a situation where Futuris could make
money shorting the stock market. Consequently, I thanked the useful
ignorants for the opportunity.
I bit off a bit more than I could chew with that one, didnt I, even if we
won the 10-year awards the following two consecutive years (including
the HFOTD).
Its all too easy to confuse genius and deep understanding with ignorance
and lack of perspective, when achieving success on the financial markets.
Guilty.
Grosvenor House, London: Eurohedge 2008 awards
At the time, I considered our strategy, its implementation and timing, not
to mention solid fundamental underpinnings, quite straightforward. Now,
after several years of fruitlessly trying to time the next big short, I know
I was ignorant and overconfident.
28|
Mik ae l Syding
| 29
INCEPTION
The hedge fund Futuris was incepted in October 1999, by the Norwegians
Arne Vaagen and Morten Groven. Due to certain legislative quirks
regarding money management in Norway at the time, as well as Mr.
Vaagens connection* with the Swedish financial giant Patrik Brummer,
the fund company was founded in Sweden.
* Arne was the managing director for the stock broker firm Alfred Berg in Norway.
During his five years at the helm in the second half of the 1990s, Alfred Berg
Norway was the most profitable broker in Scandinavia. It was Patrik Brummer
who hired Arne in the first place (Patrik was the driving force at the parent
company Alfred Berg Sweden for several decades, before founding Brummer &
Partners, the largest hedge fund group in northern Europe)
I owe all of my success in the hedge fund industry to Arne and Morten
who started the fund, raised the money, took the risk, and to my closest
colleague Mattias, for suggesting me as his stablemate at Futuris. Ill
nevertheless sometimes use the notion my fund for short, though it
obviously wasnt my fund; I just worked there and was the second biggest
active shareholder/partner (tied with Mattias).
This happened:
30|
Mik ae l Syding
| 31
32|
Proof is not
good enough
I eventually learned a very important lesson, not just about hedge funds
or clients or running a business, but about people and life in general:
storytelling matters.
In my attempts at persuading client prospects, I navely thought a good
track record of high returns and low volatility would be enough. That
however didnt cut it for serious institutional investors, with hundreds
of billions of dollars to invest; no-oh-oh, they demanded to see a tangible
investment model and evidence of rigorous risk management procedures. If
nothing else, just to have something to show their investment boards or
end clients.
Well, committees and strict procedures is what landed investors with
hundreds of billions of bad housing loans, not to mention fully loaded
stock portfolios right before some of the worst market crashes in history.
Still, we really could have used a good storyteller.
Lesson: Facts and proof never
sway people. Narratives do.
Humans are made for stories. Our brains
make up stories about the world, about past
and present events, to make sense of otherwise
chaotic and overwhelming stimuli. Just facts
are useless in most contexts - unless there is a
compelling narrative.
Mik ae l Syding
| 33
34|
Much later did I understand that our (admittedly belated) sales success
wasnt a result of my genius and unorthodox presentation and narrative it was all about performance after all.
We simply got so good they couldnt ignore us (Cal Newport), despite
all our flaws (eccentric, cocky, black box, style drift): Mastering one
bull market, several bear markets, as well as the 2009-10 BRIC/Fed
turnaround was just too much to pass on. We were the best, and when
you actually are the number one, your style doesnt matter. The problem
is you rarely stay at first place for very long...
Mik ae l Syding
| 35
36|
Mik ae l Syding
| 37
We are a black box.You deal with it.You cant know what positions we will take
or when. We are utterly free from biases and will go net short or leveraged long as
we see fit, at a moments notice if called for by circumstances
...while smiling in a manner I now guess wasnt very reassuring.
Apparently, I was retarded
even before I retired, and
the opposite of what Mark
McCormack called street
smart
Now, at least you know better
38|
Mik ae l Syding
| 39
Daly, above Peter Lynch and Charles Munger on the chart below. Only
Druckenmiller,Rogers,Tepper,Geurin,Daly and Greenblatt outperformed
the market by more than we did (Crucially, though, most of those
legendary investors were active for much longer than we were which
makes a world of difference).
40|
PEOPLE MATTER
Sharing offices with the grim reaper
As if running a fund and marketing it werent hard enough, there is a
whole other dimension of problems and risks to consider. Narrative and
performance are important factors, but to get there at all, you have to
have the people.
I am an unusually calm and composed person, almost detached some
would say (which definitely came in handy during my 15 years in the
hedge fund industry), but I still felt a sinking feeling in my stomach tens
of times per day, when the performance drifted lower. Deep darkness
indeed. In retrospect, the most surprising fact of all is that I didnt quit
much sooner than I did. I definitely thought about it every week during
the last ten years.
In the course of just one single month, we bought and sold several important
(and painstakingly researched) stock holdings, as well as significantly
changed around the overall net exposure (likewise thoroughly discussed,
scrutinized and agreed upon), to accommodate the perplexing puzzle of
changing market forecasts, macro beliefs, risks and client expectations.
That took a lot of very hard work and anguish. And, still, sometimes the
end result was a slowly growing loss, and the realisation that we might
not even get to celebrate the funds one year anniversary before it had to
be buried.The eerie silence when the fund lost another 25 bps ( %) was
the sound of our careers and wealth going down the drain. Dark.
By the end of year 2000, a black swan landed in the companys premises;
one of the two portfolio managers (and founders) decided to leave the
fund. He had better opportunities elsewhere, considering the funds recent
poor performance and subscale Assets Under Management (meaning
the fund management companys fixed costs surpassed the fixed fees on
AUM). Thus, Futuris was at the brink of ruin, despite returning over 50
per cent return after fees in 1999, and actually was up by 6 per cent in
2000.
Mik ae l Syding
| 41
Marooned in realtime
In retrospect, Futuris performance looks steady and predictable. But in
the heat of the battle, in real time a day felt like a month, a week like a
year, and it was hard to fully understand that our clients only cared about
our monthly numbers, or the appearance of the performance chart over
a year - or even several years.
We were marooned in realtime, doomed to experience every minute of
42|
Mik ae l Syding
| 43
That seems like an easy enough stock market environment to work in,
right?
- Just a handful of distinct and pretty long moves upward, and about as
44|
Mik ae l Syding
| 45
despite the devastating crash for IT shares that began in March 2000.The
trick was to stay level-headed and not make mistakes, be patient and not
get carried away.
Lesson: Trends are self-fulfilling
Rising prices are taken as evidence, by most,
of everything being alright even if the proper
conclusion is one of danger (just not necessarily
imminent). Perhaps even more important, every
trend is littered with short term corrections;
dont let those fool you.
No matter how crazy the stock market is, it
can always take one step further into looney
town. Be prepared for being wrong on timing,
no matter how right you are in other respects.
Lesson: Valuation isnt everything
There are times when valuation is important,
but many more when it isnt. Ive had to learn
and re-learn that lesson over and over again,
since I first heard about equity valuation at
finance school (Stockholm School of Economics)
in 1990 and made my first real investments.
Valuation matters reliably only over 10-year
cycles or more.
On the stock market, a 100 dollars is very
seldom just that. A 100-dollar bill can be priced
at 10 or 1000 for so long, that anybody betting
on the real intrinsic value of 100 dollars will be
indistinguishable from being wrong
As an important side note, I was merely an analyst (one of two, the other one being
Mattias Nilsson) and internal speaking partner at the fund during 2000-2002.
The founder Arne Vaagen was the real decision maker and value driver, together
46|
with his partners (first Morten Groven, later followed by Michael Hasselquist).
(It might look like a 100-dollar bill, but its actually just a picture of one)
Lesson: Never go all-in
No matter how good the trade or investment
looks.
All-in is for gamblers, a.k.a. morons. Going short
in Q4 1999 would have been intellectually
correct, a no-brainer really. Just 15 months later
you would have been proven right. The snag is
that the market first appreciated by 80% in a
couple of months, wiping out anybody being short.
Mik ae l Syding
| 47
48|
Mik ae l Syding
| 49
50|
are
no
new
Mik ae l Syding
| 51
* I later invested privately in one of those stocks Futuris traded in in 1999, and
subsequently lost half of my investment by holding on to the story long after the
fund had sold.
52|
Futuris low risk approach during 2000-2003; the green ring of High
Sharpe Ratio
As a side story, in 2002 the investment bank Merrill Lynch held a Casino Night
at Grand Hotel in Stockholm. All guests wore a tux and were given spoof money
to play with. I and my colleague had so much confidence from our winnings in the
market (and free booze) that we managed to break the bank at the roulette wheel
and the black jack that evening.Twice.We used our winnings to clean out the prize
table (the fake money could be used for buying ML merchandise, but they didnt
expect just two people to clean the table) and then ran around handing out hangers,
calculators and other stuff to the less fortunate.
Mik ae l Syding
| 53
54|
Now, lets finish the recount of the extreme year of 2002. Remember
that 2002 was the one year out of fifteen in Futuris history, where
performance was good, no big mistakes were made and life at the firm
was generally good.
With the worst timing possible (in hindsight), one of the two senior
portfolio managers died at the office, in the fall of 2002 (he had a severe
stroke in between two meetings), not long before the BRIC rally took
off and our performance waned.
To clients, our success in 2001-2002, and our troubles the following 5 years,
seemed closely linked to both our changes of style, as well as gaining and
losing a portfolio manager. Consequently, after Michaels passing in 2002,
the loss of this true nestor in Swedish industrial life caused withdrawals
to impact our assets under management, simultaneously with mediocre
performance.
Right at the peak of our game we were hit with that and then the hits
just kept on coming.
Mik ae l Syding
| 55
56|
At least those years drove home one of the most important lessons there
are: dont go all in, no matter how sure you are. By all means, make a
serious commitment, be invested - just not all in.
On the other hand, I was made partner in 2004 - and 2005 was when I
became Managing Director, albeit against my will while I was unconscious.
Yes, true story; nobody wanted to take the helm. We all just wanted to manage
money, not the firm. Hence, Mattias and Arne took a vote when I was in surgery
Such was the retarded process that made me managing director of The Hedge Fund
Of The Decade.
Mik ae l Syding
| 57
58|
Mik ae l Syding
| 59
60|
My own personal breed of hubris involved buying this Hublot Big Bang
Rose Gold in February 2007, despite our near death experience in 2006
right after buying the water scooter:
Personal hubris on display
5 years earlier I could have sworn I would never ever be this stupid. It got stolen
in the fall of 2015 and I just couldnt care less.
Mik ae l Syding
| 61
62|
Mik ae l Syding
We should have kept our patience, as we did
in 2000-2002. Actually we manifested a
certain kind of patience in 2006 as well, when
we doubled up in certain losing positions. This
time, sadly we demonstrated a lack of learning
from our own hits and misses.
Lesson: Know yourself
Analyze yourself, your M.O., your successes
and your failures thoroughly. Be willing to
learn, to question.
We had a winning style in 2000-2003. We
should have seen and acknowledged that, rather
than try to fix unnecessary mistakes by taking
even more risk and changing investment styles.
Lesson: Manage your risk level
according to the opportunities.
Its not always a good time to go heavily long
or short; most often its a grey zone. Size your
risk accordingly.
Wait out good opportunities and dont take
unnecessary risks when in unchartered territory.
Reserve big bets for situations where you have
more control. Always keep some dry powder
and leave room for error.
Lesson: Reposition when risk/
reward calls for it,
Not because you feel lucky/unlucky.
Neither a winning streak nor a losing streak
is reason to increase risk or change style.
Future risk-adjusted return potential and client
mandate are.
| 63
64|
Mik ae l Syding
| 65
The long dark tea time of the soul (mobile pic from one of my afternoon podwalks
in Stockholm)
66|
We killed it the following year, in 2008, just as we had done in 20012002.When everybody else was struggling and suffering, we had the time
of our lives. Personally, I bought a yellow Lamborghini Gallardo Spyder
(convertible) in April 2008 on my way back to the office from lunch; the
hubris monkey was never far away...
Lesson: The situation is never as
bad as you think.
Pick yourself up, take a deep breath and deal
with one issue at a time.
Most important of all: dont panic. If you panic,
get back to ground zero, neutralize everything
and start calmly and methodically from the
beginning; theres never a hurry.
I thought we had reached the end of the line in
2006 but just 12 months later, I was beaming
with pride and newfound riches (virtual) as the
fund was up by around 25% intra month in
July or August, 2007.
Lesson: Easy come, easy go
As confident and happy as I was in July of 2007,
as miserable I was a few months later when we
had lost it all, touching break for the year intramonth after being up by 25% year to date.
Did I mention we booked our performance fees
annually?, meaning all the virtual dividend I
was counting on evaporated in the space of a few
months in the fall of 2007. In July, it amounted
to more than my entire net worth, and before the
autumn leaves hit the ground it was back to zero.
Right before our true claim to fame (in 2008) it
felt as if the end was nigh. For Futuris as well
as for me. Again.
Mik ae l Syding
| 67
68|
how
The big losses we incurred during the correction in August 2007 made
us reconsider the risk of a hard landing for the economy, rather than just
a benign mid-cycle slowdown scenario.
Wolf of Wall Street
Mik ae l Syding
| 69
Those rapid portfolio turns took place several months after what would
prove to be a major peak, before a crash of historical proportions.
In addition, the writing really was already on the wall after HSBCs
subprime warning as early as in February 2007, not to mention the
sudden market correction in August - which showed just how uniformly
positive and unprepared all investors were for a downturn. We, however,
had finally all but given in to the relentless upward march of stock markets
in the five years since the trough late in 2002/early 2003.
Hence, just as in 1999, we were walking a fine line, betting hard on an
upside and a trend we had logically dismissed as irrational. And we did it
right at another generational peak in the stock market. Fortunately, the
foot in the face in August had stirred something deep within, awaken the
slumbering bear that knew that once the right dominos started falling,
everything was at risk.
And so came one of our handful of defining moments, when we in
December of 2007 sold shares within basic resources, oil and oil services,
shipping and financials, on concerns about a US recession and profit
forecast reductions that we assessed couldnt be mitigated by easier money.
Oh, so right we were, and oh so much money we made for our clients
and ourselves -and yet would be proven so wrong with the exact same
analysis a few years later on.
Lesson: a lesson isnt always the
lesson you think it is.
We could be forgiven for drawing the fatally
flawed conclusions that its risk free to fight the
Fed, or that logic and persistence work.
However, we should have realized that the
market had already shown its weak hand in
August 2007, and that was why it was possible
to make money in 2008 being short, despite a
very dovish Fed.
70|
In the beginning of 2008 we added index puts and sold futures, as well as
sold more financials and services stocks, to benefit from a possible market
correction, as we acknowledged an onslaught of negative data that had so
far failed to move markets. It soon would.
Mik ae l Syding
| 71
72|
In 2011, 2013 and 2014 we actually applied the lesson but got stopped
out, due to excessively high positive net exposure during the sudden
corrections (and recoveries) that typically occur during bull markets.
Its ironic that the demise of Futuris was due to being too bullish and too
Mik ae l Syding
| 73
highly exposed on the upside, when most outsiders think Futuris was a
permabear infested cave of eternal pessimists.
I think Ive got it now - always bet on black - (its just that I think I
currently in March 2015 have all the reasons to go short, so here I am
with my private investments - owning gold and being short the stock
market).
I still have more or less the same position in March 2016.
So, no, I still havent learned.
Dont short. Dont short.
Banging your head against a wall repeatedly is not good for you - not
repeatedly going short during bull markets either.
74|
We were wrong
Contrary to a relief rally or a dead cat bounce, the fourth quarter of 2008
saw the largest drop in the market during the entire grand 2007-2009
bear market -and we missed it!
It was the prudent thing to do, very professional, and in the end we hardly
actually lost anything more than a great opportunity and no hard cash,
but we still felt like the biggest doofus in the business:
We, Futuris, the fund that had stayed more or less bearish during the
entire BRIC rally (2003-2007).
We, who had discussed the risks of the US housing bubble for five long
years.
Mik ae l Syding
| 75
We, who had been net short the entire 2008 - on exactly the factors that
eventually took down a Wall Street behemoth and caused the big leg
down in Q4 2008...
We missed profiting from the biggest mammoth kill in a century, the
one kill we deserved together with a select few esteemed and likewise
foresighted business peers.
Biggest doofus in the market
76|
| 77
Mik ae l Syding
we got A MulligAn...
In March 2009, we positioned the fund net long mere hours before the
market turned sharply upward. Once again, with at least as otherworldly
timing as our selling 9 months before.
The market was plunging in panic after Lehmans recent bankruptcy, the
world economy stood still in the first quarter of 2009, but we caught the
falling knife perfectly.
Everybody and their computers were selling with both hands; The
consensus was that it was the worst time to hold stocks since the 1930s,
but at Futuris, we turned around the entire portfolio on a dime and
bought stocks, futures and options for a hundred per cent of our assets
under management on a single day, based on the same kind of hunch as
in July 2008 (never a straight line).
We got it right again, and one day later many others had to play catch-up
and were buying like crazy! When markets roared ahead the following
few days, we felt were invincible.
Decision paralysis?
78|
Mik ae l Syding
Lesson: Dont fight the Fed.
Investors usually learn this rule first of all.
We however had experienced two 50% stock
market plunges while the US Fed was pushing
the interest policy gas pedal to the floor. That
taught us that it can be very profitable to fight
the Fed (under the right circumstances -perhaps
like the remainder of 2015...).
The recent 6 years, since the bounce in early
March 2009, have shown that central bankers
only have one tool - a hammer - and they are
going to pound things with it until they get
their way.
It doesnt mean their method works. Quite the
opposite actually, but they can temporarily sway
short term investors to shun cash and chase
yield, irrespective of compensation for true risk.
| 79
80|
Mik ae l Syding
| 81
Well see in 2015 who has learned the inversion of the following market
internals lesson:
John Hussman, Dec 22, 2014: Market history, including the
series of bubbles and crashes over the past 15 years, does not teach
that valuation is irrelevant, but instead that a key distinction
affects whether stability or instability is likely to prevail. When
rich valuations are coupled with tame credit spreads and uniform
strength across a broad range of market internals and security
types, one can infer that investors remain tolerant toward risk.
In that environment, risk premiums may be low, but theres no
particular pressure for them to normalize, even if the speculation
is driven by mindless yield-seeking.
Trend uniformity and well-behaved credit spreads are an indication
of risk tolerance, which allows overvalued markets to remain
overvalued without immediate consequence. In stark contrast,
increasing dispersion across securities and sectors, deteriorating
market internals, and widening credit spreads are all subtle but
observable indications of growing risk aversion icebergs that can
easily rupture the Titanic of severe overvaluation. Monetary easing
then no longer supports risky assets, because risk-free liquidity is no
longer seen as an inferior asset. This risk-aversion creates upward
pressure on low risk premiums, which normalize not smoothly but
in spikes, resulting in air-pockets, free-falls and crashes.
Despite our belated bullishness, starting in August 2009, the sum of
all our efforts during January 2000 to December 2009 was enough to
earn us the award for European Hedge Fund Of The Decade, which
I proudly accepted at the gala in London. Its probably a good thing no
speeches were allowed, considering how euphoric as well as vengeful
I was feeling (due to the humbling experience of 2003-2007. There is
probably a lesson to draw from my hatred toward that period, not least
since I had to partly relive the experience during 2010-2015):
Anger, resentment, hate and fear are closely related and lead only to
suffering (and the dark side). Ask instead what you did wrong, and how
you can change to keep a cool head and win - never against the market,
always with the market.
82|
Vader, schmader; Bah! - Yoda should have seen the BRIC rally of 20032007
Mik ae l Syding
| 83
Not long after the prize ceremony, our long term bullishness wavered
already by April 2010 (-37% net short at the end of that month), and we
stayed skeptical until a year later (March 2011), with zero average net
exposure for the period.
Worth noting, however, is that I did write a letter to my two PM
colleagues and partners, from the beach of Vietnam in fall of 2010, calling
that specific market correction an all-in opportunity to buy.
That letter, which was based on my taking advantage of being in a
completely different environment and rethinking the big picture, as well
as being physically removed from my two colleagues, at least contributed
to reducing the selling Futuris was just commencing in Stockholm. The
markets soon after surged strongly upward in a move that could have
been very costly for us.
If I hadnt had the calm and solitude to rethink our position, to start
from scratch, to polish my arguments in a written statement, and the
guts to phrase my contrarian bullishness so strongly (all in), I probably
would neither have come to the conclusion to buy, nor have been able to
convince the others to hold off from going neutral or net short.
Lesson: Move
Take a walk, change environment, reset, start
from scratch, rethink everything.
Its easier to think outside the box, if you are
outside the box.
Never mistake sitting still for hours in front
of your spreadsheets and notes for productive
work. The brain is made for moving. The
thinking part is just an unintended consequence
of analyzing movement.
84|
Note that these are life lessons not just market lessons.
A tsunami of money
In March 2011, after 12 months walking in the desert performance-wise
(client-wise we were more than fine, actually preparing to close the fund
for new subscriptions after a 100m USD subscription by a single client),
we were rewarded by a triple whammy in the stock market:
Bond yields in southern Europe rose ominously, ahead of the upcoming
bank stress tests, the spring revolution in northern Africa escalated with a
no fly zone over Libya causing increasing oil prices. On top of it all, Japan
was hit by its own catastrophe-triplet: an earthquake/tsunami/nuclear
meltdown.
Mik ae l Syding
| 85
During the week following the tsunami, we first booked profits by selling
the puts and buying back previously sold futures - right at the height of the
Fukushima crisis. We subsequently sold net short again with perfect timing,
just a few days later when the stock markets had recovered almost all of their
losses. But it was hard to be happy, or show happiness during such a tragedy.
Mixed emotions
86|
One single large client, a tsunami and three perfect trades during the
space of two weeks was enough to earn me my fourth biggest dividend
ever - my last hoorah (fourth biggest by the way in all fairness it was
rather tied second).
So good we were scary
Mik ae l Syding
| 87
88|
Zombies, robots and Futuris managers almost look like normal people,
but there is just something slightly, and very disturbingly, wrong
On the 9th of November 2011 we sold heavily and repositioned the fund
from significantly net long to significantly net short.
Our bearishness was supported by extreme market volatility, growth and
credit downgrades for southern Europe, rising bond yields and CDS
spreads for the PIGS.
As late as by November 25, 2011 our positioning (still) looked genius,
until unexpected and coordinated emergency measures by several central
banks triggered an intense stock market rally.
Stock markets rose by 10% in just three days in the end of November
2011, turning an unusually good month into a really bad one for us, and
an ordinary year into a flat one - obliterating the magical performance
from March that same year (Fukushima).
We still didnt budge. On the contrary we kept selling more toward the
end of 2011, and then further into the beginning of 2012; eventually
going 50-60% net short.We figured central banks had more or less already
gone full retard without any tangible effects on the economy. Banks and
governments in the PIGS countries (Portugal, Italy, Ireland, Greece and
Spain) were still not solvent, and rising bond yields made matters more
urgent by the day.
Close but no cigar
Mik ae l Syding
| 89
So close - looking like a perfect kill just 3 days out - before the end of
November 2011...
To us this looked like a perfect repeat to 2008; the writing was already on
the wall, optimism was equally rampant and unwarranted. We positioned
the fund accordingly (as we perhaps should have done during the
Lehman meltdown in Q4 2008, i.e., kept our short positions) and actually
mirrored the street-smart tactic from January 2008 by buying put options
rather than selling index futures outright. Again, using puts introduces an
element of automatic risk reduction in case markets rise instead of fall.
We had learned we actually might be wrong, and thus used put options
to reduce our risk of big losses. However, our greed and hubris eventually
made us go aggressively short (-50%) in addition to buying the put
options. In the instances of 2000 and 2008 we were positioned more or
less neutral vs. the market - with the puts only more as an insurance, on
a slightly net positive portfolio, rather than a punt. This time our gambit
resembled something more akin to all in!
Death by
central banker
So, Futuris was around -50% net short for the first half of 2012.
Around mid-June of 2012, Futuris appeared to be on the right track. We
were up on the year, were heavily negatively exposed at around -60%
net short, which was a new record net short position for the fund, and
negative data poured in from all over the globe. It seemed all but certain
that the U.S. would slip into recession (if it hadnt already but just didnt
show up in the statistics yet) and the eurozone would break up, wreaking
all sorts of havoc.
90|
Mik ae l Syding
| 91
92|
whAtever it tAkes
The light happened to be an oncoming train. This is the sound it made:
We will do whatever it
takes to save the euro,
and believe me: it will be
enough
Those words have haunted me for two and a half years and will probably
linger in my mind for decades more. Mario Draghis promise to go full
retard, to literally do whatever he could possibly get away with, to make
sure the euro didnt break up, turned markets around. The yields of PIGS
bonds fell on the promise of central bank buying and stocks rose in relief
of an end to bank panics.
In the real world, artificially low interest rates and subsidies to banks and
bankrupt countries would be seen as band aid on broken bones. In the
world of confidence, stocks and money, however, it was seen as genius.
Mario Draghi
Mik ae l Syding
| 93
OK, now Im hating again. (I guess the Greek are too, who have paid
a dear price for staying in the Euro, and now look set to finally leave it)
Draghis effects on PIGS yields were astounding
The Spanish 10 year bond yield - the gift that keeps on giving
It took six months of heavy losses, and our worst year ever (-7.8 per cent
return), to force us to buy into the rally.
When we finally did, we were hit by a market correction (sic) ,but
nevertheless had the mental strength to keep buying; by January 2013
the portfolio was 18% net long.Whats worse is that right before Draghis
Whatever It Takes-speech in June 2012, we were planning to go long
tactically, and perhaps even strategically, exactly on the grounds of
94|
Mik ae l Syding
| 95
96|
During this build-up, the US government shut down due to debt ceiling
negotiations and Russia had invaded Crimea. In addition the US Fed
seemed set on slowly exiting its quantitative easing program, despite
temporarily negative macroeconomic data due to poor weather. Futuris
PMs, however, much like in the aftermath of the Fukushima crisis,
discounted a gradual dissipation of these worries and stayed fully long.
Our major investment themes were focused on a (south) European
recovery, shipping and clean energy (mostly solar energy related stocks).
Just as in 2011 and 2013 we were buying right into the face of danger.
Quite correctly so, albeit with a little too much bravado. Any little
correction could do us in, no matter how right we eventually turned out
to be.
We were playing with fire.Well, to be perfectly clear, I wasnt playing with
anything at all but myself; I resigned as portfolio manager in February
2014 and only stayed on as Managing Director to make the transition
smooth for our clients.
Smaug the mighty client
The extreme net exposure was automatically reduced to only 90% long
in June 2014, when the call options expired. Not long after, a correction
Mik ae l Syding
| 97
98|
RIP Futuris
October 1999 September 2014
Lesson: Dare to be wrong
Dare to think differently, be contrarian.
(just remember it inevitably means you will be
wrong every now and then), so choose the size
and timing of your biggest bets very carefully.
Dont expect trying to be contrarian will
create positive returns, but if you actually
think differently, dare to act on your inherent
independent thinking.
Lesson: Mind your surroundings.
Other factors than your core value drivers are
sometimes more important than your actual
business.
Our risk level wasnt crazy, and as it turned out
we were right in our market call. However, we
were in a weakened state, due to having been
underwater for a long time, a recent and very
costly stop loss, and most importantly we were
dependent on one large client.
Mik ae l Syding
Lesson: There is never a need to
rush to be rich
Be persistent and patient. There really is no
need to rush to be rich or to take extreme risks
once you are up and going. Pace yourself.
Futuris demise was due to taking too much
risk at the wrong time, rather than waiting
for the right opportunity. On the other hand,
Futuris fantastic history only ever happened,
thanks to the outsize risks its founders took on
the outset - both in changing careers and the
actual investment decisions during the first few
months in 1999.
Lesson: Question yourself
Challenge your beliefs, look for evidence to the
contrary of your current convictions.
You inevitably will be wrong often, internalize
that fact and actively look for weak points in
your research and arguments
| 99
100|
Mik ae l Syding
| 101
102|
Mik ae l Syding
| 103
work
104|
well as our comeback in the second half of 2006 were astonishing. Or,
should have been - but from the outside those accomplishments simply
disappeared among our losses on sold futures and on shorts on capital
goods companies.
Mik ae l Syding
| 105
DEFINING MOMENTS
Long technology in fall of 1999, capturing the final euphoric moments
of the IT boom, right before the epic crash; Futuris biggest gain.
Going 150% net long at the peak of the market in August 2007 when
the writing was already on the wall, after the subprime warning shots in
February - thus going full retard long, when the housing bubble we had
discussed since 2003 finally had matured enough.
Revisiting our views in December 2007-January 2008, of an imminent
Minsky moment, after 5 years of being mocked as perma bears. We
almost missed the crash we had been waiting for, due to almost 5 years of
end-of-year rallies and a constant BRIC pull upward. We almost missed
becoming the Hedge Fund Of The Decade.
Worst consequence: Hanging on to over 50% net short in mid 2012 after
Draghis Whatever It Takes-speech, which triggered an epic stock rally
(ongoing three years later). We averaged -50% net short for 2012 - our
worst year ever, the only one with more than 1% negative net return
during our 15 years.
Single worst decision ever: Going from 90% long to slightly negative on
a forced stop loss procedure at the bottom of a mini-crash June 2013.
The stock market soon rebounded, leaving us behind. The risk taken in a
weakened state almost paid off but ultimately became our downfall due
to the ill-timed stop loss in June.
Going 100%+ long in 2014 after 5+ years bull market and several years
without even a single proper correction of 10% in the S&P index. It was
the right move, but clients finally lost confidence in us.
106|
Mik ae l Syding
| 107
108|
Mik ae l Syding
| 109
all been crushed in one single blow, a blow we had asked for,
by going too long in the face of danger (worried clients, our
own underperformance and an erratic market that was due a
decent correction)
110|
Mik ae l Syding
Lesson: Know your clients - be
mindful of different perceptions
We should have seen and acknowledged both
our de facto modus operandi earlier (quarterly
moves rather than daily), and taken into account
that our clients, even by that low frequency, were
surprised by our (too) frequent trading.
Lesson: trading often is a losers
game.
High Frequency Trading may be a winners
game, to the very fastest microsecond trading
(front running) machines for now, but anything
between a millisecond and a months turnaround
time is for losers.
With my own money I would aim for a major
repositioning around every three years and
minor changes once every three months.
Lesson relearned: A is A
Ray Dalio talks about facing reality for what it
is. I think we repeatedly failed to do so, even if
we got it more right than everybody else.
Sometimes we took an almost moralistic
standpoint regarding, e.g., money printing. At
other times we called ourselves long term and
fundamental but traded all over the place.
To our credit, we openly admitted to these
errors, even calling ourselves chicken little (an
erratic little creature), but still sometimes failed
to correct them.
| 111
112|
Mik ae l Syding
| 113
Holistic research
Dirk Gently postulated that everything in the universe was related one
way or another.This holistic approach allowed him to do exactly anything
in order to solve a case.
Lesson: Work smarter not harder
(a classic Dilbert management clich), but there
is some truth to it:
There is too much information to handle
anyway. There is no way to deal with it by
applying brute force, doing more.
Instead, walk, move, enter investigation and
learning mode. Sitting still and working
harder is counterproductive. Walking frees the
mind, whereas sitting inside all but guarantees
stolidness, group think and poor creativity.
114|
Mik ae l Syding
| 115
116|
EPILOGUE
Was it difficult? Could anyone have done it, given enough effort? How
long is a piece of string? Who is John Galt?
Make no mistake, it was difficult, it was hard work, there were no fixed
methods or office hours, no guaranteed income (and very high alternative
costs, considering other career alternatives). And, no, I definitely dont
think just anyone could have succeeded the way we did.
It took a lot of luck as well, but then again, serendipity is there for
whoever gives it a chance (through ambitious and intelligent effort and
preparations).
Futuris downfall, 9 months after I decided to resign, I personally think
was taking too much risk the wrong way at the wrong time, rather than
relying on gradual changes and surroundings-aware risk management.
Market-wise the decisions were right, but unfortunately that is not all
that matters in the short run.
The most important aspect of investing and trading is always keeping dry
powder for the next round not to mention minding auxiliary factors;
Live to fight another day even if you are wrong (or your partner or
important clients abandon you).
Nota bene: You can always be wrong, no matter how well-informed
you are, so never, ever go all-in. Even if you are right, others ignorance
can make you temporarily wrong for so long that your right doesnt
materialize before you are down and out permanently.
/Karl-Mikael Syding, The Retarded Hedge Fund Manager SpreZZaturian
PS: I used to say that staying ahead of the market was too difficult, too much
work. I opted for staying one step behind instead. If decisions were just between
up or down anyway, I should be correct just as often with that strategy of being
retarded.
Mik ae l Syding
| 117
If you happened upon this book by other means than me e-mailing the
link to you, please visit my website mikaelsyding.com
MikAelsyding.coM
118|
Mik ae l Syding
| 119
Futuris har vid ett flertal tillfllen nominerats till och vunnit olika utmrkelser.
Nominering Eurohedge Awards 2011
European Equity
Vinnare Hedge Funds Review Awards 2011
Best Directional Hedge Fund over 10 years
Nominering Hedge Fund Review Awards 2011
Best Directional Hedge Fund over 3 years
Vinnare Hedge Funds Review Awards 2010
Hedge Fund of the Decade
Vinnare Hedge Funds Review Awards 2010
Best Directional Hedge Fund over 10 years
Vinnare Lipper Awards 2009
European Equity L/S
Vinnare Eurohedge Awards 2008
European Equity L/S
(Silver) Dagens Industri och Morningstar 2008
Arets stjrnfrvaltare (hedgefonder)
Nominering HFM Awards 2008
L/S equity
(Brons) Dagens Industri och Morningstar 2002
Arets stjrnfrvaltare (hedgefonder)
(Guld) Dagens Industri och Morningstar 2001
Arets stjrnfrvaltare (hedgefonder)
120|
A final word: I would have loved trying to time the coming crash at
Futuris (see chart above, and draw your own conclusions), but Im still
glad I decided to leave the industry. Heres why:
Every year of my 43 years (in January 2015) has been better than the last.
Every new year has turned out to be my best so far.
However, I think I had to leave finance, in order to guarantee that 2015
had a fighting chance to surpass 2014 - the year I started blogging, got a
dog, quit finance, snowboarded naked and sold my last sports car (yellow
Lamborghini convertible) among other things.
Thank you for reading. Now share this e-book and my website
mikaelsyding.com with your social network
/Karl-Mikael Syding, a.k.a. Sprezzaturian
Mik ae l Syding
| 121
READING TIPS:
The best book ever written about the economy: How An Economy
Grows And Why It Crashes by Peter Schiff
The best sci-fi book series ever: Post-Human by David Simpson
My Newsletter ; )
CONTACT INFORMATION
Facebook: Karl-Mikael Syding
Instagram: Sprezzaturian
Twitter: @TureMasing (Sprezzaturian)
Pinterest: Sprezzaturian (Karl-Mikael Syding)
Google+: Karl-Mikael Syding
Spotify: Karl-Mikael Syding
Linked In: Karl-Mikael Syding/Sprezzaturian
e-mail address: mikael.syding@gmail.com
122|
THE END