Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Annotation
FANCONIS ANAEMIA AND ITS VARIABILITY
characterize a condition, for which the specific pathophysiology may not yet be identified, and FA certainly belongs in
that category. The physical phenotype runs the gamut from
extremely abnormal to normal, the haematological spectrum
ranges from severe aplastic anaemia to normal, and the
malignant potential includes leukaemia, carcinomas, liver
tumours, or no malignancy.
From the diagnostic perspective, patients in any of the
above categories who have increased chromosome breakage
in the presence of DNA clastogenic agents are now considered
to have FA (Auerbach et al, 1981),while patients with any or
every symptom that is considered classic are diagnosed as
non-FA if they do not have increased chromosome breakage
(Auerbachet al, 1989b;Poole etal, 1992). In addition, efforts
to define the pathophysiology of FA have examined many
parameters with often apparently contradictory results from
different laboratories or different patients. Even at the genetic
level, evidence points to mutations on chromosome 9q in
some patients, 20q in others, and elsewhere in still others
(Strathdee et al, 1992a; Mann et al, 1991).
The current dilemma is to sort out from the syndrome
those patients who belong in specific categories, in order to
provide appropriate diagnoses (both post- and ante-natal),
counselling, and advice with regard to prognoses and
treatment options. When all of the many FA genes have been
cloned and their functions identified, the sorting will be
automatic. Until then, various efforts are underway to
categorize the patients, which will be reviewed here.
Historical background
Fanconis anaemia (FA) is a paradigm for aplastic anaemia,
pre-malignancy, and chromosome breakage disorders. It is
the best defined but perhaps most enigmatic of the inherited
bone marrow failure disorders. In 192 7 Fanconi described
three brothers with aplastic anaemia and congenital physical
abnormalities (Fanconi, 192 7). The phenotype was
expanded by other reports, and apparently the eponym was
applied by Naegeli in 19 3 1 (Fanconi, 19 6 7). Approximately
20 years later, Estren & Dameshek (1947) reported two
families in which several siblings had aplastic anaemia, but
whose appearances were normal (except for short stature). It
took another 3 0 years before these two syndromes, Fanconis anaemia and Estren-Dameshek Type II constitutional
aplastic anaemia (OGorman Hughes, 1966) were demonstrated to be part of the same spectrum of disease; one of the
original Estren-Dameshek families was found later to have a
relative with classical FA and diepoxybutane(DEB)-induced
chromosome breakage (Li & Potter, 1978). In fact, this
spectrum had been noted but not recognized as such, when
Dacie & Gilpin (1944)described three brothers, one each with
Fanconisanaemia, leukaemia, and paroxysmal nocturnal
haemoglobinuria. There are other case reports from the
earlier years as well, in which one sibling had apparently
classical FA, while another had aplastic anaemia without
congenital anomalies (reviewed in Alter & Young, 1992;
Young & Alter, 1993).
Physical anomalies
The first descriptions of FA were of patients with both aplastic
anaemia and a specific, albeit broad, range of physical
anomalies (Table I). Published cases were defined thus until
the last decade or so, and extensive literature reviews (e.g.
Alter & Young, 1992; Young & Alter, 1993) contain a
substantial bias, since patients for inclusion had to have both
physical and haematological manifestations. However, as
propositi were identified, and the autosomal inheritance of
FA was recognized, siblings were included in the diagnosis
who had physical anomalies without aplastic anaemia, or
aplastic anaemia or leukaemia without anomalies, or discordance with regard to the types of anomalies. There have even
been identical twins with anomalies in only one (AdlerBrecher et aZ, 1992), or with aplastic anaemia in only one,
emphasizing the importance of environmental factors.
Chromosome breakage
The observation that chromosome breakage was increased in
patients with FA was made in the early 1960s by several
groups (Schroeder et al, 1964; Schmid et al. 1965;Bloom et al.
1966; German & Pugliatti Crippa. 1966; Swift & Hirschhorn,
Correspondence: Dr Blanche P. Alter, Division of Pediatric Hematology/Oncology. Childrens Hospital C3-41, University of Texas
Medical Branch, Galveston, TX 77555-0361, U.S.A.
10
Annotation
Table I. Physical abnormalities in Fanconis
anaemia,
Abnormality
Skin, pigmented
Skin, cafe au lait
Short
Upper limbs
Hypogonads male
Hypogonads female
Head abnormal
Eyes
Renal
Birth weight <2500 g
Retardation
Lower limbs
Ears
Reflexes increased
Other skeletal
Cardiopulmonary
Gastrointestinal
Other
No anomalies at all
Patients (%)
51
23
62
50
40
3
28
27
24
13
13
9
11
8
7
7
4
6
6
8
There may be additional problems with basing FA diagnosis on a specific chromosome breakage test. There are some
patients whose breakage rate varies with time, and others in
whom breakage is clonal, i.e. only a small percentage of cells
may show breaks at a given time (Auerbach et al, 1989b;
Arwert & Kwee, 1989; Schroeder-Kurth et al, 1989; Kwee et
d,1983;Hajianpour et al, 1992). One might then extend this
variation to the extreme: what if an FA patient is demonstrating that variation at the time of study, and the results are
normal! That patient will be labelled non-FA. Another
source of variation is the choice of clastogenic agent, since the
mechanisms of action and cellular bioavailability are not
identical. Which one is to be the gold standard?
Genetic variability
It is clear that the molecular biological approach is the only
way to resolve many of these dilemmas. One of the FA genes
has already been cloned and localized to chromosome 9q, the
gene for FACC (Fanconi Anaemia Complementation group C)
(Strathdee et al, 1992b). Complementation groups were
assigned based on the correction of chromosome breakage in
hybrid cells formed from different groups; hybrid cells of the
same complementation group still demonstrate breakage
(Duckworth-Rysiecki et al, 198 5). The initial complementation studies identified cell lines as A and non-A, i.e. B. More
recently it was found that B actually consists of groups B, C
and D (Strathdee & Buchwald, 1992). The protein product of
the FACC gene is novel and does not resemble anything in the
databank, and thus the role of this gene in normal development or in FA remains to be elucidated. Another FA gene, for
complementation group A, was suggested by linkage analysis
to be located on 20q (Mann et al, 1991;Mathew et nl, 1991),
but this gene and its product have not yet been identified.
There are at least two additional complementation groups (B
and D); their genes are presumably on neither 9q nor 20q
(Strathdee et al, 1992a). Only after all (four or more) genes
are cloned will we be able to determine the specificity of
chromosome breakage tests for FA. If patients with increased
breakage do not have mutations in any of those genes, we will
conclude that there are more FA genes. If patients with the
FA phenotype without increased breakage have mutations in
any of the FA genes, we will learn that the breakage test is not
completely sensitive. And if normal individuals who have no
known FA relatives have mutant FA genes, we may finally
get a better estimate of the frequency of the FA gene(s).
The putative proximal cause of aplastic anaemia can vary
from no known cause, to infections with hepatitis or other
viruses, mycoplasma or tuberculosis, as well as drugs such as
chloramphenicol. In some families the affected siblings
developed aplastic anaemia at the same time, suggesting a
common environmental relationship. while in others the
onset of aplasia was concurrent for the age of the patient;
these variations indicate that the relative roles of genes and
environment are not consistent.
Clinical heterogeneity
The type and degree of haematologic involvement are highly
variable, and Table I1 summarizes our attempt to classify the
patients (Alter et al, 1991b). Some patients demonstrate the
Annotation
11
Transfusions
Androgens
Status
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
No
MCV, mean cell volume. Hb F. fetal haemoglobin. From Alter et a1 (1991b). 'Yes' under
transfusions or androgens means currently receiving regularly.
Outcome
Another example of clinical heterogeneity relates to outcome.
Although >90% of FA patients are presumed to develop
aplastic anaemia a t some point, many have leukaemia and/
or solid tumours, and many of those patients may not have
had or never get aplastic anaemia (Table 111). There seems to
be a temporal continuum, whereby aplasia occurs early, with
leukaemia later, and tumours even later. Those who escape
Cases
All
leukaemia
Other
cancer
Liver
disease
No. of cases
838
73
42
36
100
1.3
0.4
1.6
Male :female
1.3
8.4
7
0-48
10.6
9
0.1-28
14.5
14
0.1-29
13.9
14
0.3-32
9.1
6
1-48
15.8
13
2.5-48
41 (5%)
548 (65%)
17 (23%)
33 (45%)
2 (6%)
343 (47%)
59 (81%)
31 (86%)
1(3%)
Some patients had more than one complication;they are listed here in all relevant
categories. Without androgens or pancytopenia means never received androgens or
never developed pancytopenia. From Young & Alter (1993).
12
Annotation
Table IV. Complementation groups.
Feature
Group A
Group B
High
High
Yes
No
Deficient
Decreased
Decreased
Less high
Moderate
Reduced
Reduced
Reduced
Normal
Normal
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
Efficient
Decreased
Decreased
Normal
Normal
No
No
Yes
No
Yes (group C)
The terminology was often slightly different, although the mechanisms being examined
may be similar, and thus there are multiple topic listings. Group B is now known to include
groups C and D (see text). MMC, mitomycin C: S-MOP/UVA, 8-methoxypsoralenl
ultraviolet: ADPRT, ADP-ribosyl transferase. Each line represents a different study. Adapted
from Young & Alter (1993).
early aplastic anaemia remain at risk of the later complications, and the probability of their occurrence increases with
age. It is the rare FA patient who has none of those problems,
but it may be that FA is not diagnosed until one of those
events occurs. For example, many FA patients even with
typical physical anomalies are not diagnosed until haematological changes develop (Alter, 1991). Although the median
survival for FA patients is now approximately 2 5 years of age
(Young & Alter, 1993; Auerbach et al, 1989a), there are
patients who are not even diagnosed until they are older than
30 (Liu et al, 1991), and several survivors into their 30s and
40s. Only population surveys with molecular probes for FA
mutations will provide the correct data with regard to life
expectancy.
There is variation even among FA patients with aplastic
anaemia, in terms of age of onset, and response to conventional treatment with androgens. Approximately 50% of
patients respond to androgens, although the duration of
response can vary from a few months to >20 years.
Response is related to marrow status as might be expected:
those whose marrow still has some residual haematopoietic
activity and who are only moderately pancytopenic seem to
respond better. Most patients seem to require their androgens
continuously, but a few patients in the literature and in our
own experience who improve on treatment are able to
maintain their blood counts after discontinuation of the
androgens (McDonald & Mibashan, 1968).
The types of leukaemia which do occur in FA are primarily
within the spectrum of nonlymphocytic leukaemias
Annotation
al, 1977), and yet fatherhood has been reported, albeit in a
very small number of patients (Schroeder et al, 1 976;Alter rt
al, 1991a; Liu et al, 1991).
Laboratory heterogeneity
Table TV outlines some of the heterogeneous laboratory
results which have been obtained in efforts to identify thr
primary defect in FA. These often contradictory results were
initially puzzling, but might be at least partly explained by the
fact that there are several different complementation groups
in FA (Strathdee 81Buchwald, 1992). The general consensus
is that patients with FA have a defect in DNA repair, but the
precise localization in the repair pathway has not been
elucidated, and each mutation may be of a different repair
enzyme.
The role of toxicity from oxygen-free radicals is another
controversial area. Decreased levels of antioxidants such a s
superoxide dismutase (SOD) were found in some but not
other patients, but it seems clear now that some of the
variable data may be due to variations among patients with
different mutations, and not necessarily to interlaboratory
variation (Okahata et al, 1980; Yoshimitsu et al, 1984). In a
preliminary test of SOD in vivo, a few patients did have a
decrease in the degree of chromosome breakage (J. Liu and
N. Young, unpublished observation).
Despite the pleiotropic effects of defective DNA repair, the
initial and still major problem in FA is haematologic. In most
cases the numbers of haematopoietic progenitor cells are
decreased, although we did find some correlation of in vitro
colony formation with clinical classification, in that there
was better colony growth from patients in clinical group 6, 5
or 3 in that order (Alter et al, 1991b. 1992). In vitro cultures
from FA patients grew better in low oxygen, but so did
cultures from normal controls. Erythroid colony growth was
improved with the addition of stem cell factor, and the degree
of improvement correlated with the clinical group (Alter et al,
1992). In studies from other laboratories and other patients,
however, stem cell factor did not augment erythroid colony
growth (Bagnara et al, 1992). Those experiments used
enriched progenitor cells depleted of potential accessory cells,
while ours used total mononuclear cells, and the interaction
of accessory cells with progenitors may be important.
Technical differences aside, it is clear that haematopoietic
progenitors are decreased in at least many FA patients, and
the in vitro responses to haematopoietic growth factors are
somewhat variable. In vivo response to haematopoietic
growth factors (GM-CSF or IL-3) has been restricted to the
myeloid lineage, and did not correlate with the in vitro results
(Guinan et al, 1991; Gillio et a!, unpublished observation).
Conclusion
13
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This work was supported in part by the March of Dimes/Birth
Defects Foundation and the American Cancer Society.
Division of Pediatric HematologyJOncology.
University of Texas Medical Branch,
B. P. ALTER
Galveston. Texas
REFERENCES
Adler-Brecher, B., Zhang, Q., Flit, Y., Gray, D.L., Beaver, H.A., Reid,
J.E., Wang. W. & Auerbach. A.D. (1992) Prenatal diagnosis of
Fanconi anemia in monozygotic twin boys with discordant
phenotype. American Journal of Human Genetics, 5 1, A2 5 1.
Alter, B.P. (1991) Arm anomalies and bone marrow failure may go
hand in hand. Journal of Hand Surgery, 17A, 566-571.
Alter, B.P. (1992) Leukemia and preleukemia in Fanconis anemia.
Cancer Genetics and Cytogenetics, 58, 206-208.
Alter, B.P., Frissora, C.L., Halperin, D.S., Freedman, M.H., Chitkara,
U., Alvarez. E., Lynch, L., Adler-Brecher, B. & Auerbach, A.D.
(1991a) Fanconis anaemia and pregnancy. British Journal of
Haematology, 77, 410-418.
Alter, B.P., Knobloch, M.E.. He. L., Gillio, A.P., OReilly, R.J., Reilly,
L.K. & Weinberg, R.S. (1992) Effect of stem cell factor on in vitro
erythropoiesis in patients with bone marrow failure syndromes.
Blood. 80, 3000-3008.
Alter, B.P., Knobloch, M.E. & Weinberg. R.S. (1991b) Erythropoiesis
in Fanconis anemia. Blood. 78, 602-608.
Alter, B.P. & Young, N.S. (1992) The bone marrow failure syndromes. Hematology of Infancy and Childhood (ed. by D. G. Nathan
and F. A. Oski), p. 2 16. W. B. Saunders, Philadelphia.
Arwert. F. & Kwee, M.L. (1989) Chromosomal breakage in response
to cross-linking agents in the diagnosis of Fanconi anemia. Fanconi
Anemia: clinical. cytogenetic and experimental aspects (ed. by T. M.
Schroeder-Kurth, A. D. Auerbach and G. Obe), p. 83, Springer,
Berlin.
Auerbach, A.D., Adler. B. & Chaganti, R.S.K. (1981) Prenatal and
postnatal diagnosis and carrier detection of Fanconi anemia by a
cytogenetic method. Pediatrics, 67, 128-135.
Auerbach, A.D., Adler, B., OReilly, R.J., Kirkpatrick, D. & Chaganti.
R.S.K. (1983) Effect of procarbazine and cyclophosphamide on
chromosome breakage in Fanconi anemia cells: relevance to bone
marrow transplantation. Cancer Genetics and Cytogenetics, 9, 2 536.
Auerbach, A.D., Frissora, C.L. & Rogatko, A. (1989a) International
Fanconi anemia registry (IFAR): survival and prognostic factors.
Blood. 74, 43a.
Auerbach, A.D., Rogatko, A. & Schroeder-Kurth, T.M. (1989b)
International Fanconi Anemia Registry: Relation of clinical symptoms to diepoxybutane sensitivity. Blood, 73, 391-396.
Auerbach, A.D. & Wolman. S.R. (1976) Susceptibility of Fanconis
anaemia fibroblasts to chromosome damage by carcinogens.
Nature, 261, 494-496.
Bagnara. G.. Strippoli. P., Bonsi, L., Brimi, M., Avanzi, G.. Timeus, F.,
14
Annotation
Ramenghi, U.. Piaggio, G., Tong J.. Podesta, M.. Paolucci, G.,
Pegoraro, L., Gabutti. V. & Bacigalupo, A. (1992) Effect of stem cell
factor on colony growth from acquired and constitutional (Fanconi) aplastic anemia. Blood, 80, 382-387.
Bargman, G.J., Shahidi,N.T., Gilbert,E.F.&Opitz,J.M. (1977)Studies
of malformation syndromes of man. XLVII. Disappearance of
spermatogonia in the Fanconi anemia syndrome. European Journal
of Paediatrics, 125, 163-168.
Berger. R., Bernheim, A., Le Coniat. M., Vecchione, D. & Schaison, G.
(1980) Nitrogen mustard-induced chromosome breakage: a tool
for Fanconis anemia diagnosis. Cancer Genetics and Cytogenetics,2 ,
269-274.
Bloom, G.E., Warner, S., Gerald, P.S. & Diamond, L.K. (1966)
Chromosomeabnormalities in constitutional aplastic anemia. New
England Journal of Medicine, 274, 8-14.
Dacie, J.V. & Gilpin. A. (1944) Refractory anaemia (Fanconi type). Its
incidence in three members of one family, with in one case a
relationship to chronic haemolytic anaemia with nocturnal
haemoglobinuria (Marchiafava-Micheli disease or nocturnal
haemoglobinuria). Archives of Diseases of Childhood, 19, 155-162.
Duckworth-Rysiecki, G.. Cornish, K., Clarke, C.A. & Buchwald, M.
(1985) Identification of two complementation groups in Fanconi
anemia. Somatic Cell and Molecular Genetics, 11, 35-41.
Estren, S. & Dameshek, W. (1947) Familial hypoplastic anemia of
childhood. Report of eight cases in two families with beneficial
effect of splenectomy in one case. American Journal of Diseases of
Childhood, 73, 671-687.
Fanconi, G. (192 7) Familiare infantile pemiziosaartige Anamie
(pernizioses Blutbild und Konstitution). Jahrbuch fur Kinderheilkunde, 117, 257-280.
Fanconi, G. (19 36) Der Friihinfantile nephrotisch-glykosurische
Zwergwuchs mit hypophosphatamischer Rachitis. Jahrbuch fur
Kinderheilkunde, 147, 299-338.
Fanconi, G. (196 7) Familial constitutional panmyelocytopathy.
Fanconis Anemia (F.A.). I. Clinical aspects. Seminars in Hematology, 4, 233-240.
German, J. & Pugliatti Crippa, L. (1966) Chromosomal breakage in
diploid cell lines from Blooms syndrome and Fanconis anemia.
Annals of Genetics, 9, 143-154.
Guinan. E.. Nathan, D., Huhn, R., Lopez, K. & Oldham, F. (1991)
Phase 1/11 trials of recombinant human granulocyte-macrophage
colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF) in patients with Fanconis
anemia (FA). Blood, 78, (Suppl. l ) ,97a.
Hajianpour, A.K.. Murer-Orlando, M., Mathew, C.G., Bennett, C.,
Gordon-Smith,E.C.. Tiley, C.R. & Bobrow, M. (1992) The dilemma
of two cell populations in Fanconi anemia. American Journal of
Human Genetics. 5 1, A8 1.
Kwee. M.L., Poll, E.H.A., van de Kamp. J.J.P., de Koning, H., Eriksson,
A.W. & Joenje, H. (1983) Unusual response to bifunctional
alkylating agents in a case of Fanconi anaemia. Human Genetics,
64, 384-387.
Li, F.P. & Potter, N.U. (1978) Classical Fanconi anemia in a family
with hypoplastic anemia. Journal of Pediatrics, 92, 943-944.
Liu, J.M., Auerbach, A.D. & Young, N.S. (1991) Fanconi anemia
presenting unexpectedly in an adult kindred with no dysmorphic
features. American Journal of Medicine, 91, 5 5 5-5 5 7.
Maim, W.R., Venkatraj. V.S.. Allen, R.G., Liu, Q., Olsen, D.A., AdlerBrecher, B., Mao, J.-LWeifTenbach, B., Sherman, S.L. &Auerbach.