Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
3
0066-4804/80/03-0477/07$02.00/0
TABLE 1-continued.
Antibiotic resistance' Entero- Plasmid,d molwt
Strain
C 30 (MIOb) E 15 PB 50 S 10 T 30
Ento-
toiC
Pl1m6,
(x106)
mG+Ce
CBAh
1 S (0.5) S I S R + -
2 S (5) S S S S - -
21 S (5) I S I S - 5.1
26 S (5) I S S S - 5.5
41 S (1) I S S R - -
42 S (5) I S S R - -
66 S (1) S R I S - -
77 S (5) S S S S - -
80 S (10) S S S S - -
103 S (5) S S S R - -
107 S (1) S S S S + -
109 S (1) S S S R + -
110 S (5) I S S S - -
111 S (5) S S S R - -
112 S (5) I S S R - -
113 S (5) I S S S -+,7
117 S (5) S S S S - -
Table 2 summarizes the single antibiotic re- and the E. coli labile toxin (2, 11, 24). Therefore,
sistance frequencies for each isolate series and the toxigenicity of the environmental isolates
compares them to the frequencies reported in was determined (Tables 1 and 3). Overall, 13
the literature. Polymyxin B and erythromycin (25%) of the organisms produced a toxin re-
resistances are decreased, whereas resistances to sponse in Y-1 adrenal cells. A different study by
chloramphenicol, streptomycin, and tetracy- our laboratory of 117 CBAh isolates revealed
cline-widely used and clinically important anti- that 16% produced enterotoxin-like activity and
biotics-are markedly increased in our sample. 57% produced cytotoxin in the Y-1 adrenal cell
The BE strains were responsible for most of this assay (Kaper et al., Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. Soc.
increased drug resistance (and they were se- Microbiol., 1979, N56, p. 188). The question of
lected for this phenotype). But the occurrence enterotoxigenicity in environmental A. hydro-
of tetracycline resistance was highly significant phila will be discussed more fully (Kaper, Lock-
(P < 0.001) in the CBAh organisms as well. The man, and Colwell, manuscript in preparation),
nonantibiotic selected BV series of Vibrionaceae but caution should be exercised in interpreting
strains collected for comparison with the BE set Y-1 cell reactions, since they have also been
contained only three Aeromonas isolates. These
organisms were not antibiotic resistant. TABLE 3. Multiple drug resistance in
Table 3 summarizes the multiple drug resist- environmental strains of A. hydrophilaa
ance phenotypes in our sample. It is clear that BEsen'es
V and
the BE series has a significant level of multiply Resistance
Resi to o (18 series
BE strains CBAh series
(19 stan
TABLE 2. Comparison of the frequency of individual drug resistance phenotypes demonstrated by A. hydro-
phila strains recovered from the natural environment and by clinical and environmental strains reported in
the literature
Orgamams No. of No. of strains resistanta
stram58 C E PB S T
BE 18 3 (17)* 2 (11)* 0* 13 (72)* 12 (67)*
BV, V, CBAh, Ah 35 0 0* 1 (3)* 1 (3) 7 (20)*
Literature
percentageb 222c 0 47 27 5 2
a Numbers in parentheses are percentages. The asterisks mark frequency differences which were significantly
different from the literature values at the 5% level. Abbreviations are as in Table 1.
b
Frequency data were gathered from papers in which adequate taxonomic identification and standard
methods for determining resistance were employed (5, 6, 9, 10, 13, 14-16, 19, 20, 23, 26, 27, 30-32, 39, 41, 45, 48-
50).
c One hundred twenty of these isolates were from environmental sources and 102 (46%) were clinical. The
resistance frequencies of the two groups were identical at the 98% level.
VOL. 17, 1980 ANTIBIOTIC-RESISTANT A. HYDROPHILA 481
reported to be due to a nonenterotoxigenic pro- shows no evidence of being a plasmid-mediated
tein unrelated to adenyl cyclase stimulation (8, trait.
11). DISCUSSION
Choleragen is produced by a chromosomal
gene, whereas the labile toxin gene is generally The antibiotic resistance patterns of the A.
carried on a plasmid (47). Thus, it was of interest hydrophila organisms isolated in this study dif-
to determine whether toxigenicity, as well as fer markedly from data in the older literature
drug resistance, was correlated with plasmid car- (Table 2). In the Bangladesh organisms, we have
riage in the aeromonads. From Tables 1 and 4 it observed a 5-fold increase in the frequency of
can be seen that extrachromosomal DNA ele- streptomycin-resistant strains and a 23-fold in-
ments were detected in roughly 10% of the Bay crease in the frequency of tetracycline resist-
isolates and half the BE strains. Four of the nine ance. Most of the BE strains carry multiple
BE organisms with a plasmid carried two dis- antibiotic resistance, with a streptomycin-tetra-
tinct species, whereas the three Bay aeromonads cycline phenotype which is correlated with the
had single plasmids. Some of the BE plasmids presence of a high-molecular-weight plasmid.
appear to be R factors, whereas the Chesapeake Tetracycline is a widely utsed drug in the Matlab-
plasmids are cryptic. In all series, toxigenicity Dacca area, whereas streptomycin use has de-
clined since 1976. Thus, tetracycline use pro-
vides the overwhelming selective pressure in this
region.
It is particularly interesting to note that three
TABLE 4. Frequency of drug resistance, toxigenicity, and plasmid carriage in strains of A. hydrophila
isolated from the natural environment"
A B C Ratio of re- Ratio of those Ratio of those
Total No. resistant No. toxi- No. with sistant to resistant to
toxigenic to
Series no.
ofto an antibi-
strains
genic piasmid toxigenic ths(A/C)
arry'ng~those carrying a
otic (A/B) plasmnd (B/C,
BE 18 13 (72)b 5 (28) 9 (50) 1/13 (8) 8/13 (62) 0/9 (0)
Ah, BV, CBAh, V 35 9 (26) 6 (17) 3 (9) 2/9 (22) 0/3 (0) 0/3 (0)
a Data from Table 1.
b
Numbers in parentheses are percentages.
482 McNICOL ET AL. ANTIMICROB. AGENTS CHEMOTHER.
viable counts of 105/ml of water, and Salmonella ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
most probable numbers as high as 1.1/g of sed- This work was funded by Public Health Service grant 1-
iment (22). A. hydrophila counts have been R22-AI-14242 from the National Institutes of Health and
reported to be as high as 110/ml of water (Kaper supported by the International Centre for Diarrheal Disease
et al., Abstr. Annu. Meet. Am. Soc. Microbiol. Research, Bangladesh.
1979, N56, p. 188). In contrast, the Chester River
and Chesapeake Beach stations are relatively LITERATURE CIED
clean areas located in the relatively open water 1. Adachi, H., M. Nakano, M. Inuzuka, and M. To-
of Chesapeake Bay. No Salmonella species have moeda. 1972. Specific role of sex pill in the effective
been recovered at either station, and fecal coli- eliminatory action of sodium dodecyl sulfate on sex and
form counts are usually less than 0.03/ml of drug resistance factors in Escherichia coli. J. Bacteriol.
109:1114-1124.
water (21, 22). Total viable counts are usually 2. Annapurna, E., and S. C. Sanyal. 1977. Enterotoxicity
102 to 103/ml, aild A. hydrophila counts are of Aeromonas hydrophila. J. Med. Microbiol. 10:317-
approximately 3/ml. 323.
We do not know the source of drug resistance 3. Aoki, T., S. Egusa, Y. Ogata, and T. Watanabe. 1971.
Detection of resistance factors in fish pathogen Aero-
in the Chesapeake Bay aeromonads. A recent monas liquefaciens. J.. Gen. Microbiol. 65:343-349.
study showed that over 10% of the bacteria in 4. Blair, J. E., E. M. Lennette, and J. P. Truant (ed.).
Jones Falls water were resistant to at least one 1974. Manual of clinical microbiology, 2nd ed. American
antibiotic, compared with 1% at Chesapeake Society for Microbiology, Washington, D.C.
5. Caselitz, F. H., D. Krebs, and W. Maass. 1961. Unter-
Beach (Allen et al., manuscript in preparation). suchungen zur Differenzierung von Mikroorganismen
The polluted station may have increased poten-