Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Pages 84-106
Social structures are sometimes mysterious & hard to see, but they are truly very powerful.
Societies & social structures exert influence over individuals
Set limits on our choices & opportunities
Enables & motivates us to do some things & not others
Makes some outcomes more likely than others
Understanding the social worlds humans inhabit requires us to go far beyond Thatchers
image of a world defined by a bunch of individuals acting freely & without societal
constraints to consider the impact of social structure on the lives of individuals
1. What is social structure?
Social structure as context of human action
How are social structures similar to the physical structure of a building?
What are the 2 key components of social structure?
Social structure is fundamental to entire way that sociologists understand human world
If you are born into poor family, it is much more likely that you will be poor as an adult
than if you are born into a rich family
Rich children are more likely than not to have opportunities for growth (ex: travel
to foreign countries, attending very good private schools, having tutors & other
forms of special help)
o Rich child benefits by his/her place in social structure
Poor children are likely to enjoy few or none of these resources
Social structure: bundle of forces
Hidden in background of everyday life are forces or structures that shape, constrain,
enable everything that we do
Underneath everyday social life is foundation that makes social order possible
Understanding what absence of social structure means is to think about importance of
structure for group activities
Social structure is essential to everything we do, but we are most likely to notice its
importance when its not there
Physical or social structure endures over timeeven as other things change all around it
Like buildingsarchitects & builders can dramatically change a buildings look
but the underlying structure (foundation) is much more difficult to alter w/o
tearing building down completely
Social structures tend to persist over time, giving social life a regularity
Historical changes occur, but happens slowly & modestly
Persistence & durability of structures give them their power
Were familiar w/ social structures
Poor people have world stacked up against them
Rich people have a lot of advantages
Have to show respect to teachers, doctors, judges, ministers, president
Dictatorships are extreme, but all states have capacity to determine how wide the gap b/w
individuals is, how many people will live in poverty, how well advantages can be passed
on to children
Governments in richer countries have more resources to influence outcomes
Government policies provide social insurance & social assistancewelfare state
Can reduce amount of poverty & inequality in society or allow higher levels of
poverty & inequality
Countries w/ large welfare states typically impose higher taxes on affluent citizens & set
limits on how wealthy individuals or families can become
Provides benefits for people who are too old to continue working
Provide health insurance for all citizens
Changes very conditions of social life
4. How is social structure linked to social interaction?
Context of social interaction
How does socialization contribute to the creation of roles & norms?
Individuals define themselves via identities required for such social interaction
Some specific processes influence our social identities & forms of interaction
Social structure & social interaction are linked
Role: expectation to do certain things
Organization establishes roles
Having assigned roles allow people to know what they are supposed to do at any
given time
In ideal world, roles complement rather than interfere w/ each other
In real world, roles often overlap
Most efficient workplaces are those where divisions b/w tasks are reduced so people do
lots of different things & shared responsibilities
Roles are powerful aspects of broader social order
Life course: stage of life
When we shift from one life course to another, we are supposed to transition as we age
By growing up, we are expected to alter behavior to fit new roles
People typically adopt roles in appropriate ways that change their behavior
Social roles create one type of instructions or set of clues for individuals
Social norms act as broader set of constraints
o Basic rules of society help us know what is & whats not appropriate
o Norms are related to formal rules of behavior but are not written down
anywhere
o Rules are straightforward, explicit guidelines whereas norms are
somewhat more ambiguous
Norms & formal rules/laws are important but often violated
Sometimes we can get away w/ petty violations of rules & norms but there are
costs to violations
Violating routine norms can be consequential
Sociological perspective: how responsible are you for your own behavior?
Sociologists refer to process of learning how to behave as socialization
Schools are important institutions when it comes to socialization
Different schools are organized differently & seek to socialize people in different ways
Students who wear uniforms & attend all-girl Catholic school will be socialized
differently than students who attend mixed-gender public school
Socialization occurs throughout life course
Great deal of socialization is about learning rules
When we enter new job or become involved in organization, new forms of
learning occur as we learn about basic ins & outs of new activity or group
Many formal rules & sanctions of legal system remind us of what we can & cant do in
many situations
Formal socialization provided by law has limits
We may obey w/o actively believing that everything legal system tells us is
correct
Churches & religious institutions socialize through ritual & repetitionattempting to
teach moral values & behaviors to followers
Others emphasize that our lives are not so neatly organizedwe belong to many
different groups, play different roles, are affected by multiple structures exerting
influence on us at once
Ex: For some settings, race might be more important influence than class
o Point made by African American sociologist W. E. B. Du Bois
In The Souls of Black Folksargued that people inhabit multiple
roles & are located in different hierarchies
Suggested that black Americans identities are complex things w/
multiple strands & no way to simply categorize people
Others argue that too much emphasis on structuralism leads to the inability to
account how changes happen
o If structures determine how we behave, how is it that anything ever
changes?
Criticism of heavy emphasis on power of free will & individual agency:
Doesnt account for fact that most things tend to stay the same or change very
slowly
o Hierarchies & inequalities tend to persist over generations
Struggle to unify excessive structionalist approaches w/ approaches that leave society &
social structure out altogether
Possible wayconsidering structures as things that enable action
Workplace hierarchies: place limits on what people can do; give individuals a
sense of identity from which their behavior stems
Structures give order to society & w/o order action is impossible
5. Why are social structures slow to change?
Endurance of social structures
Hallmark features of social structures is their endurance
Path dependency
Why are path-dependent processes so powerful?
Path dependency: was in which outcomes of past impact actors & organizations in the
present
Makes some choices or outcomes logical & others illogical
Social structures persist in past b/w earlier departments & institutionalization make it
much easier for individual to work w/n them than try to rip them apart
Ex: QWERTY keyboard
o Nothing in their right mind would invent a keyboard laid out this way w/
many of the commonly used letters placed in hard-to-reach locations
o Yet, attempts to replace QWERTY keyboard failed
o To use the computer, everyone basically learns to navigate the keyboard
o Switching to better-designed keyboard will be initially time consuming &
costly, requiring to master the others keyboard
Path dependency rests on idea that pathsonce adoptedare extraordinarily difficult to
reverse
What has happened in past sets limits on what is possible today or in the future
Deeply historical process & is tied up w/ how, why & when particular institutions
take root
Particular paths are sometimes established for accidental reasons while others emerge in
specific historical moments
United States Constitutionexample of how particular pathway to modern social
structure & society was influenced by single key event
Created by group of menmeeting in 1787 who eventually settled on a document
that has continuously provided foundation for modern American governance
Contains numerous of features that shaped American politics ever seenset up
institutions of democracy that made it difficult for more than 2 political parties to
win elections to Congress
o U.S. electrons for Congress takes place in either districts (House elections)
or individual states (Senate elections)
o Each district or state elects the person who gets the most votes
Existing major parties (Democratic & Republican since Civil War) are too
powerful & efforts to change system have failed
Constitution granted unusual powers to legal system & courts, gave exceptional
powers to state governments
Racial hierarchy in Americaevolved slowly over longer periods of time
Late 19th centurydominant white racial category limited to European whites
from Northern European Protestant countries (later known as WASPswhite
Anglo-Saxon Protestants)
Immigrants from Catholic countries (from Ireland & Italy) & Jews & growing
numbers from Eastern Europe had light skin tone but were subject to many
negative stereotypes
Eventually, racial hierarchy was flexible to expand definition of white to include
all groups (except African Americans)
o Hierarchies can adapt while retaining their importancemaintaining
black/nonblack distinction
o Immigrant Europeans excluded from whiteness choose to struggle to be
included in dominant racial category rather than trying to eliminate race
altogether
o More comfortable living in worlds we know & trying to make them better
than opting for radically new world
Not everyone is averse to change & peopleunder extreme &
unusual conditionsdo opt to try to tear down parts of social
structure rather than reform it
o More often than not, individuals & groups reinforce social structure by
reforming parts that are not working rather than tearing it down
completely
Conclusion: link b/w social structure & social problems
Karl Marx: our ability to act & choices we make are limited by the circumstances in
which we find ourselves
We are continually making choices shaped by the hierarchies & institutions in our
world
Social structures have positive & negative features
Positive b/c social life is possible w/ some social structures
o W/o social structures (in cases of extreme social disorder like natural
disaster or brutal war), structures are broken down & people begin rioting
o Social structures provide order & rhythm to daily life
Negative b/c can be rigid & allow some groups to exploit or dominate others
o Possibility of true equality of opportunity & fairness might be undermined
o Some groups enjoy advantages not shared by others
When social institutions fail to adapt to changing external conditions, they threaten our
well-being
Modern economic systems thrived on ever-growing levels of production & consumption
Governments work hard to maximize both
Understanding social structures is central to larger project of sociological imagination
Sociologists pay attention to understanding different elements of social structure
Try to see where & why the elements limit possibilities for improving human
condition
Only by understanding underlying structures can we then make meaningful progress on
social problems