Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Holkham Hall - the rooms inside The Libraries - book shelves (Photo
credit: ell brown)
by Hannah
McCarthy
Identifying the most effective way of teaching reading to young children has been the subject of
fierce
debate
for
many
decades.
The two most popular methods have been the 'phonics' approach and the 'whole language'
approach. These two methodologies approach teaching reading in very different ways, which has led
their proponents to attack each other's approach as misguided or even detrimental to a child's
learning.
But what are the characteristics of each approach and how do they aim to build the reading skills of
young learners? Furthermore, is it really possible to argue that one is better than the other? Here's
an
attempt
to
answer
those
questions.
Phonics-based
teaching
The phonics approach tries to create an association in the child's mind between the 'graphemes'
(written symbols) and 'phonemes' (sounds) of language. Through the use of repetitious exercises to
drill this link between text and sound, teachers aim to build a familiarity and comfort with the basic
building
blocks
of
written
texts.
Once the child has achieved this proficiency, teachers then encourage them to blend the individual
written elements together to produce whole words; this is known as the 'synthetic approach'. As
such, synthetic phonics is described as a bottom-up approach which builds towards comprehension
through
a
journey
from
the
smallest
elements
of
written
texts.
Advocates of synthetic phonics claim that an emphasis on the child's ability to 'decode' written texts
is essential for creating a foundation on which an understanding of meaning can be constructed.
Its detractors, on the other hand, decry the rigour and repetition of phonics, arguing that children are
often bored and disengaged by the slavish focus on rules and individual sound-text associations.
The discipline required for this approach gives it a traditionalist, back-to-basics quality that has a
recurring
appeal
for
generations
of
educators.
Whole-language
teaching
The whole language approach focuses on comprehension from the outset, with children being given
continuous texts to read in order to build an understanding of vocabulary and meaning. These texts
will be short, often with words being repeated to help develop familiarity with certain key terms and
concepts.
A teacher will initially read with the children, but will gradually say less to encourage more
independence on the part of the young learners. Placing trust in children's ability to build
associations between words and draw conclusions from the text, whole-language teaching has been
identified as a top-down approach which places less emphasis on the rules and minutiae of
language.
Those in favour of whole-language teaching praise its student-led approach, arguing that it is both
more engaging and more meaningful for young learners. Critics claim that such an approach places
a strain on teachers and that it lacks the structure and clear objectives of the phonics method.
A
balanced
approach?
With the differences between advocates of the two approaches at times appearing intractable, some
have argued that a mix of the two methods is most appropriate, allowing teachers to combine the
best of both worlds. This may be true, although it could be argued that a divided focus on bottom-up
and
top-down
approaches
can
be
confusing
for
young
children.
Whatever the solution, it's generally agreed that different children have different preferences when it
comes to learning to read, so teachers would be well-advised to monitor to which methods children
respond
best
and
tailor
their
teaching
accordingly.
Hannah McCarthy works for Education City, a leading supplier of e-Learning software for schools in
the UK. Education City offers comprehensive curriculum-based resources for teachers, including a
range of literacy activities and a new Learn English module for teaching English as an additional
language.
Article
Source: http://EzineArticles.com/?expert=Hannah_McCarthy
http://EzineArticles.com/?Different-Approaches-To-Teaching-Reading&id=7235143
speech
Children learn to "read" by reading and rereading "big books" together with the teacher
and then the teacher gradually withdraws
prompts so child appears to be reading that
book
http://www.hishelpinschool.com/reading/appteachreading.html
All good literacy practice starts with the needs of the individual student. The
materials you use are crucial for addressing the specific needs of the student
and for maintaining motivation and interest. It is sometimes difficult for new
tutors to grasp that there is no curriculum to follow. The language
experience approach or 'Cloze' procedure discussed in this section
demonstrate what effective materials might look like.
It involves the student and gives them a sense of ownership of the material.
Write down verbatim a few sentences which have been dictated by the
student.
Do not change grammar or syntax, but clarify with the student that you have
written down what they intended to say.
Discuss the piece with your student and show an interest in the text.
Read the piece to the student and then read the piece together.
Cut out the first sentence and ask the student to read it.
When the student seems confident reading the sentence, cut it up into
individual words.
Mix the words up and see if the student can put them together to form the
sentence.
You can also ask the student to create new sentences with the cut up words
and to read them aloud.
2. Cloze Procedure
Cloze procedure is a method which encourages learners to develop and rely
upon their own ability to predict meaning in what they are reading, through
the use of context clues and their own previous knowledge.
The method involves deleting certain words or letters from a text and leaving
an underlined blank space. Learners can then read the passage to
themselves, guessing at the missing words or letters and filling in the
blanks. It should be emphasized that there are no right or wrong answers
whatever makes sense when read back is okay.
It is important to avoid leaving too many blank spaces because the reader
may become frustrated by the break in the flow of their reading. About one
deletion for every ten words is the maximum recommended. Read
the Cloze passage yourself to check that it isnt too difficult and that not too
much meaning has been lost through deletion.
The Cloze method can be used for a number of different purposes:
To assess comprehension. Using Cloze procedure gives a good idea of the
- word recognition
- the use of semantic and syntactical information to predict
- ability to seek meaning outside the context of the immediate sentence
To develop prediction skills for reading. It is best to eliminate words central to
the meaning of the passage, so that an appropriate word should spring easily to
mind.
To emphasize grammatical points. In this case it is best to leave out only
those words that are the same part of speech (e.g. adjectives, adverbs, prepositions
etc.).
o
APPROACHES TO READING
This introduction to reading skills is best discussed and worked through with two or
three colleagues. It aims to generate discussion on the key issues in reading we need
to consider as well as giving readers the opportunity to pick one another's activity
closets for those real gems we all have tucked away.
HOME
LANGUAGE
THE SKILLS
Reading is an active skill which involves inferencing, guessing, predicting etc. It also
has, more often than not, a communicative function. We rarely answer questions after
reading a text except in a language class, but we do write answers to letters, follow
directions, choose restaurants and holidays, solve problems and compare the
information to our previous knowledge or the knowledge of others.
Do you think your students are effective readers? Why?
Or are they ineffective readers? Why?
EFFECTIVE READERS
A familiarity with effective and ineffective reading strategies can help the teacher look
for effective reading behaviours in learners, encourage wider use of these strategies,
and be on the lookout for learners using less effective strategies. An effective reader is
one who can select the correct strategy for the purpose and text. Studies have shown
that most effective readers:
discover the distinctive features in letters, words and meaning
try to identify meaning rather than letters or words
use their knowledge of the world
eliminate unlikely alternatives through inference and prediction
have a clearly defined purpose
locate topic sentences
distinguish main points from subordinate ones, and fact from opinion
are aware of cohesion and reference
are aware of explicit and implied relationships between sentences and paragraphs
are aware of the importance of argument, tone and function
are able to work out the meaning of unfamiliar vocabulary from context
have confidence in their own ability and take chances
Which of the above do your students do well?
What activities do you use to develop these strategies?
INEFFECTIVE READERS
On the other hand, ineffective reading is often caused by:
'mouthing'
word-by-word reading
inappropriate translation
inaccurate linguistic analysis
paying attention to unfamiliar words which are not relevant to the purpose of reading
panic
and therefore these students do not take chances.
Which of the above to you see in your classes?
How do you help your students overcome these tendencies?
HOW DO WE READ?
Match the column on the left with the definition on the right and decide which are
most applicable to the above categories.
Skimming
Scanning
Extensive
reading
Intensive
reading
evidence for this theory as yet, but the idea is intuitively appealing. Readers, who do
not know enough of the language, cannot transfer skills from their L1 because they
need to be more proficient in the L2 to activate the skill.
What problems do you find your classes have?
What activities do you use to overcome these problems?
Share your favourite and most successful reading classes.
THE THREE PHASES IN A READING LESSON
PRE-READING
* to introduce and stimulate interest in the topic
* to motivate students by providing a reason for reading
* to provide language preparation for the text
WHILE-READING
* to clarify content and vocabulary of the text
* to help students understand the writer's purpose
* to help students understand the structure of the text
POST-READING
* to consolidate and reflect upon what has been read
* to relate the text to the students' own knowledge/interests/views
* to provide a stimulus for other language activities
POSSIBLE STAGES OF A READING LESSON
Below you will see a number of possible stages for a reading lesson. These stages are
in a jumbled order. Please re-arrange the stages according to what you consider to be
an appropriate order. (Note that in any particular lesson some of these stages might be
omitted and/or other stages added.)
a Students ask the teacher about unfamiliar vocabulary.
b Students work very quickly in order to work out the answers to one or two general
questions.
c Students work out the meaning of selected words and expressions from the context.
d Students predict the content of the text from the title/picture/first line.
e The teacher draws attention to some of the grammar in the text.
f Students complete a detailed true/false exercise.
g Students locate topic sentences in some paragraphs.
h Students discuss topics related to the content of the text.
i Students scan the text to pick out proper names.
ACTIVITIES FOR DEVELOPING READING SKILLS
- Preview/Predict/Anticipate
- Scanning
- Skimming
- Comprehension Questions (e.g. "wh-" questions)
Adding blends (bl, fr, etc.) and diagraphs (ch, sh, th, etc.)
them and then we use them. We dont memorize, write and recite all
the rules and so on. When you teach your child the different
sounds the letters of the alphabet stand for, youre already on the
road to teaching phonics!
Because I like to take a multi-sensory approach to teaching and
because I like to consider my childs learning style as well, I use a
variety of methods and tools to teach phonics. We use flash cards,
rhyme games, fill in the missing letter type worksheets, computer
games and other games. (For example, phonemes or simple words
written on note cards can placed on the floor and then hopped onto
when the teacher calls it out.) Be creative! And have fun with it.
Phonemes:
This is not exhaustive, there are other phonemes you will encounter
as you begin reading (like the sc in science says s instead of sk
and igh which makes a long i sound!)
Those Pesky Sight Words!
Even if you like a strong phonics approach, there are some words
you just HAVE to remember and recognize by sight. Words like
one, said, and are. Also words that we dont say the way they
are spelled (come is not pronounced like comb.) Making lists of
irregular sight words, playing games with them and practicing
reading them can help.
increasing, its time to slow down and sound things out again. Before
you know it your child is really reading and it looks like it, too!
Tips for this phase of reading:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
the reading process is to watch your child for cues. Your child, even
if he doesnt understand them, will give off clues to what he needs
to succeed at this point in his reading journey. While our children
work to decode the words on the page, we can observe and decode
our childrens signals and cues.
http://www.classichousewife.com/2012/10/17/approaches-to-teaching-reading-10days-of-how-to-teach-your-child-to-read/