Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
C0
298
THE SEARCH
6 TRAILBIKE SHOOTOUT: FOR THE BEST
www.mbaction.com
MARCH 2016
JOHN TOMAC:
PIVOT
MACH 6
CARBON
OUTSTANDING BEFORE,
PERFECT NOW
FUN REASONS
WHY YOU RIDE
$5.99
CANNONDALE VS
GIANT VS GT VS
KHS VS KONA
VS SCOTT
GOGGLES vs GLASSES:
SAFE PROTECTION FOR YOUR EYES
BIKE TEST
TRAILBIKE SHOOTOUT
You askedwe delivered
f there is one question we get asked more than any other, its, When will you guys do
another affordable trailbike shootout? Seriously, we get asked this almost every month,
and finally the time has come for us to grant your requests. We started with an e-mail
blast to several of the more prominent bike companies, asking them to send us what they
believe is the best all-around trailbike for the common rider looking to spend $2500$3000
on his or her next bike. We didnt have any specific requirements on wheel size or suspension type, so we ended up with a unique mix of bikes that we are confident will hit on all
major aspects of modern trailbikes.
52
www.mbaction.com
53
TRAILBIKE SHOOTOUT
KHS
SIXFIFTY
5500
54
www.mbaction.com
Climbing: We pushed the KHS over various types of climbs and found that while
the weight of the bike was competitive, the
suspension was very soft, even with the
pedaling switch engaged. A couple riders
did like the longer reach on the climbs, as
they were able to get in more aggressive
positions for steep sections.
Descending: The 5500 felt capable
and stable over rough terrain at high
speeds. The front end tracked well and
went where we wanted it to go. Although
we never felt like the bike was very lively
over rowdier sections of trail, the suspension did give us the cushion we wanted
over ruts and bigger obstacles.
BUYING ADVICE
55
TRAILBIKE SHOOTOUT
GIANT
TRANCE
27.5 2
Maestro, please
56
www.mbaction.com
Moving out:
The bars had a
fairly high feel, and
were surprisingly
narrow for this style of
bike; we are talking 1990World Cup-cross-country-racing
narrow. With a short stem, the cockpit
felt a bit awkward, making the general fit
cramped.
Cornering: With a low standover height
and dropper post, it was easy to push the
Trance into corners and lean the bike, even
though our confidence was shaken at times
with the tiny bars. The Maestro felt active
in corners and kept the rear tire planted.
Climbing: The Trance frame design is
set up more for rocky descents than it is
for climbing. The rear suspension is set
up to be rather plush, so we felt a loss of
power when we tackled steep, technical
TRICKS, TIPS OR
UPGRADES?
BUYING ADVICE
WHICH COMPONENTS
STAND OUT?
57
TRAILBIKE SHOOTOUT
CANNONDALE
HABIT 5
Cultivate the Habit
58
www.mbaction.com
WHICH
COMPONENTS
STAND OUT?
No work needed: Durability is a big consideration when purchasing a new bike. Shimano
components have proven themselves to be
some of the toughest on the trail.
BUYING ADVICE
59
TRAILBIKE SHOOTOUT
GT
ZASKAR
CARBON
ELITE 27.5
A bike with some history
Unchanged for a reason: The triple triangle design has been the most identifying
factor of the Zaskar since its creation in
the mid-1980s. While it doesnt ride
like a full suspension, the triple triangle gave us plenty of compliance.
BUYING ADVICE
WHICH COMPONENTS
STAND OUT?
60
www.mbaction.com
Probably the fastest: When it came to the climbs, there was no doubt the Zaskar was the
best in class this time. Between the carbon frame and Reverb dropper post, the descents
were fast and playful, but the Zaskar did have its limitations when the trail got gnarly.
61
TRAILBIKE SHOOTOUT
KONA
A trail-born slayer:
With 134 millimeters of
travel, on paper the Process
falls into a mid-travel trailbike
mold. On the trail, however,
the capability feels endless
and pushes riders on to
ride faster.
PROCESS
134
One very capable bike
WHICH COMPONENTS
STAND OUT?
The KS E-Ten Integra post was a welcome sight, along with the RockShox
Monarch RL rear shock. Kona did a good
job choosing a beefy tread with the Maxxis
DHF EXO front tire and Tomahawk rear tire
and coupled it with Shimano brakes and
drivetrain.
62
www.mbaction.com
BUYING ADVICE
Time and
time again:
Shimanos XT
Shadow Plus
has proven itself
to be a sturdy
component that
will always come
back for more.
The 10-speed
Shimano
drivetrain is solid
and left us with
confidence that
it can take a
beating.
63
TRAILBIKE SHOOTOUT
SCOTT
SCALE
710 PLUS
WHICH COMPONENTS
STAND OUT?
A solid build: The Scale was near the top when it came
to component specs and build. Between the SRAM
GX1, Fox suspension and Syncros wheels, we felt like
we had plenty of bang for the buck.
BUYING ADVICE
64
www.mbaction.com
65
BIKE TEST
TRAILBIKE
SHOOTOUT
Price
Weight
Frame tested
Bottom bracket height
Chainstay length
Top tube length
Head tube angle
Seat tube angle
Standover height
Wheelbase
Suspension travel (front)
Suspension travel (rear)
Frame material
Fork
Rims
Tires
Hubs
Brakes
Crankset
Handlebars
Shifters
Front derailleur
Rear derailleur
Cassette
Pedals
66
www.mbaction.com
CANNONDALE HABIT 5
$2900
30.7 pounds
Medium
13.5"
16.9"
23.8"
67.5
75
30"
46"
5.5/140mm
5.5"/140mm
Aluminum
RockShox Sektor Silver, 140mm
WTB STP-i23
Maxxis Ardent 27.5x2.25 tubeless
Lightweight Disc
Shimano M506
SRAM GX 1000 32t
Alloy 700mm
SRAM GX 1
None
SRAM GX 1, Type 2
SRAM XG-1150, 10-42, 11-speed
None (weighed with Shimano XT)
$2700
30.2 pounds
Medium
13.2"
17.3"
23.6"
67
73.5
28.1"
45.5"
5.5/140mm
5.5/140mm
Aluminum
Fox 32 Float Performance
Giant S XC-2
Schwalbe Nobby Nice 27.5.2.25 tubeless ready
Giant Sport Tracker
Shimano M615
Shimano SLX 38/24
Giant Connect 680mm
Shimano Deore
Shimano Deore
Shimano Deore
Shimano HG50 11x36, 10-speed
None (weighed with Shimano XT)
$2340
30.9 pounds
Medium
13.1"
16.9"
23.4"
68
74
29.2"
44.7"
4.5"/120mm
4.5"/120mm
Aluminum
RockShox Recon Gold, Poploc Remote
WTB i19
Schwalbe Nobby Nice, Rocket Ron 27.5x2.25
Formula
Shimano Deore
Shimano M617 36/22
Cannondale C3 Riser 760mm
Shimano Deore
Shimano Deore
Shimano SLX Shadow Plus
Sunrace 11-36, 10-speed
None (weighed with Shimano XT)
THE SYSTEM
For the purpose of our shootout, we narrowed down our evaluation to five different
categories: climbing, descending, ergonomics/component group, general likability and
would we recommend this bike to a friend?
We used a panel of test riders ranging in
skill level from beginner to expert, and told
them to hit the trails. These are the results:
Best Overall
While this wasnt the lightest bike in the
bunch, it certainly offered the most versatility. With the Kona, the positives far outweighed the negatives. It really proved itself
to be the best all-around rig. The Kona
offers potential buyers a solid complete
bike and a solid enough platform to slowly
upgrade over time.
Our test riders came from various riding
backgroundsfrom minimalist cross-country riders to rock-slamming downhill
racersbut when the votes were tallied,
almost everyone agreed this was the best
bike of the bunch.
First Runner-Up
There were a few who wondered if this
bike would take the win, but in the end,
fun didnt quite outweigh practicality. While
we thoroughly enjoyed every minute spent
CANNONDALE HABIT 5
Best Fit
If this bike had come stock with a dropper post and a slightly better fork, it probably would have taken top honors. The Habit
is a capable bike wrapped up in a very
affordable package. The minor limitation of
no dropper post shouldnt be too much of a
hurdle for potential buyers to overcome.
Best Suspension
The Trance was not to be overlooked
in the final tally of our shootout. We liked
the build kit and suspension platform, but
never felt quite as confident on the bike,
in large part because of the awkward fit
and cockpit component choices. Fit can be
adjusted, but the process takes time and
can be costly, which our test riders felt was
a major drawback.
Best Value
We initially expected the KHS to win
this shootout. It is arguably the best value
in the bunch, sporting an awesome parts
package, great aesthetics and a Horst-Link
suspension design thats impossible to
poke holes in. Unfortunately, the sum of the
parts didnt quite add up for our testers.
The bike proved to be a little lackluster in
the handling, but still delivered among the
best components in the bunch.
Best Climber
We loved throwing this light cross-country bike around on the trail. The Zaskar
proved to be the best climber in the bunch
by a long shot, and also arguably the best
value. While it wasnt the all-around trailbike we were looking for in the conditions
$2900
32.7 pounds
Medium
13"
16.7"
23.8"
68
74
25.5"
45"
5.5"/140mm
5"/134mm
Aluminum
RockShox Sektor Silver
WTB i29
Maxxis DHF EXO, Maxxis Tomahawk EXO 27.5x2.3
Shimano Deore
Shimano Deore
Race Face Ride 34/24
Kona XC 35 780mm
Shimano Deore
SRAM X5
Shimano XT Shadow Plus
Shimano Deore 11-36, 10-speed
None (weighed with Shimano XT)
67