Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://about.jstor.org/terms
Cambridge University Press, American Society of Church History are collaborating with
JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Church History
This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Sat, 01 Oct 2016 15:14:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
would greatly have impressed the Byzantines and would have caused
have never been closely analyzed for their interesting historical contents. Sophronius delivered his sermon at Christmas, 634, in the face
of dire circumstances. The Arabs had successfully overrun much of
Palestine and had occupied Bethlehem, preventing Christian pilgrims
from visiting the scene of the Nativity for the first time in memory.
The sermon, therefore, is a contemporary record of the deep impression which the very beginnings of the Arab conquest made upon a
foremost Byzantine bishop and theologian. Sophronius found many
Old Testament parallels to the current situation. He believed, moreover, that this extraordinary Arab invasion was a divinely sent punish-
Image (Edinburgh, 1958); R. W. Southern, Western Views of Islam in the Middle Ages
(Cambridge, Mass., 1962). Byzantium and Islam: C. Giiterbock, Der Islam im Lichte der
bysantinischen Polemik (Berlin, 1912); D. Eiehner, "Die Nachrichten fiber den Islam
bei den Byzantinern," Der Islam, Xx111 (1936) 133-244; J. Meyendorff, "Byzantine
Views of Islam," Dumbarton Oaks Papers, 18 (1964), 115-132; Manuel II Palaeologus,
Entr6tiens aveo un Musulman. 7e oontroverse, ed., tr. Th. Khoury (Sources Chr6tiennes,
No. 115, Paris, 1966). On the Arab conquest: A. J. Butler, The Arab Conquest of Egypt
(Oxford, 1902); P. K. Hitti, The Origins of the Islamio State (reprinted, Beirut, 1966);
and M. J. DeGoeje, M6moire sur la conquvte de la Byrie (M6moires d'histoire et de
g6ographie orientales, II, Leiden, 1900).
139
This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Sat, 01 Oct 2016 15:14:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
140
CHURCH HISTORY
indeed contrary to our wishes, we are required to stay at home, not boun
ful."4
religious message):
But we have the Davidic desire and thirst, to see, just as David famous
in song, the water and we are prevented from feasting our souls through
fear of the Saracens alone. For now the slime of the godless Saracens
[Sarakenon gar atheon], like the gentiles at that time, has captured
Bethlehem and does not yield the passage, but threatens slaughter and
destruction if we leave this holy city and if we dare to approach our beloved and sacred Bethlehem.5
biasetita da Costantino agli Iconoeolati (Bari, 1965), pp. 208-209, 357; B. Altaner,
Patrologie (7th ed.; Freiburg, 1966), pp. 520-521; G. Bardenhewer Geschiohte der altiirohliohen Literatwr (Freiburg, 1932) V, 36-41; H.-G. Beck, Kirche und Theologische
Literatur im byzantinisohen Reioh (Munich, 1959), pp. 434-436; cf. also, H. Usener,
1911), 335-336.
3. Sophronius, "Weihnaehtspredigt " 507, Cf. Gen. iii. 24.
4. Sophronius, " Weihnaehtspredigt" 513.
5. Sophronius, "Weihnachtspredigt" 514.
This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Sat, 01 Oct 2016 15:14:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
141
Therefore I call on and I command and I beg you for the love of
the Lord, in so far as it is in our power, let us correct ourselves,
shine forth with repentance, let us be purified by conversion and
curb our performance of acts which are hateful to God. If we con
ourselves, as friendly and beloved of God, we would laugh at the f
our Saracen adversaries and we would view their not distant deat
we would see their final destruction. For their blood-loving blad
enter their hearts, their bows will be shattered and their shafts w
fixed in them. They will furnish a clear way for us having neithe
nor thorns nor impassible points so that we, running boldly and daunt
may possess the child of life, may love the God-receiving chamber
prostrate ourselves before the holy manger. We shall embrace th
producing city [Bethlehem] dancing with lambs, shouting with th
giving glory with the angels: "Glory to God in the Highest and on
peace and good will to men."6
with its tarnished contemporary condition: "For the Romans subjugated, through the will of God, all of the races. But today we see
the Romans humbled."7 Several times he refers to the Roman or Byzantine Empire as the famous fourth beast of which the prophet Daniel had spoken. He comments on the condition of the empire and on
fourth beast, that is, the Roman Empire, is reduced, torn asunder and
shattered, as Daniel said, verily there will be no other, except the ten
claws and the ten horns of the fourth beast, and afterwards a little
horn, completely different, which has knowledge of God. Immediately there will take place the end of the universe and the resurrection
of the dead."8
Justus, one of the participants in the dialogue of the Doctrina, re-
This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Sat, 01 Oct 2016 15:14:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Martin I:
Martin was exiled by the grandson of Heraclius [Constans II] and swiftly
desert, who struck us, the people of Christ. That was the first terrible
and incurable fall of the Roman [Byzantine] army. I am speaking of the
bloodshed at Yarmuk and Dathemon, after which occurred the capture
and burning of the cities of Palestine, even Caesarea and Jerusalem.
After the destruction of Egypt there followed the enslavement and incurable devastation of the Mediterranean lands and islands. But those
ruling and dominating the Roman Empire did not understand these
things. They summoned the foremost men in the Roman Church, cut
out their tongues and cut off their hands. And what then? The requital
from God was the virtually complete destruction of the Roman army
at Phoenix and the destruction of the fleet and the destruction during
his reign of the whole Christian people and all places. This did not
cease until the persecutor [Constans II] of Martin perished by the
10. trnimus Confessor, epist. 14, ad Petrwn iUustrem, PG 91. 540. Date: P. Sherwood,
An Annotated Date-list of the Works of Maximun the Confessor (Studia Anselmiana,
fase. 30, Rome, 1952), 40. In general: 0. Bardenhewer, GeOshichte der altkirchlichen
Literatur (Freiburg im Breisgau, 1932) V, 28-36; B. Altaner, Patrologie7, pp. 521-524;
Beck, Theologie und Kirche, pp. 436-442.
11. Anastasius Sinaita, Sermo 3, PG 89, 1156. Cf. Beck, Theotogie und Kirche, pp. 442-443;
This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Sat, 01 Oct 2016 15:14:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
143
sexual license:
Thus not because He loved them did the Lord God give to the power
to seize the land of the Christians, but because of the lawlessness of the
Christians. The likes of it never had occurred nor may it occur in the
entire generations of earth. For why did men put on the clothes of
adulterous women and prostitutes, adorn themselves as women and
openly stand in the squares and markets of towns and change their
natural practice for an unnatural one ....? Likewise, women did the same
things as the men had done. Father, son and brother had intercourse
with one woman who touched every kinsman, for they were not recognized by the prostitutes.... For this reason God delivered them into the
hands of the barbarians, that is, because of their sin and stench. The
women will pollute themselves through the men who already are polluted
and the sons of Ishmael will cast lots [for them].'l
12. Anastasius Sinaita, PG 89. 1156-1157. Yarmuk: Baladhuri/P. K. Hitti, Origins of the
Islamio State, pp. 207-212; Theophanes, Chronographia, A.M. 6126, ed. C. De Boor
(Leipzig, 1883, I, 338-339); J. B. Bury, History of the Later Roman Empire (1st ed.;
London, 1889) II, 263-265; De Goeje, M6moire sur la conquete de Syrie, pp. 31-34, 103-136.
13. Cf. W. E. Kaegi, Jr., Byzantium and the Decline of Rome (Princeton, 1968), chapters 4-6
1000-1002.
This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Sat, 01 Oct 2016 15:14:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
144
CHURCH HISTORY
The author was careful to emphasize that God had no love for the
Muslim Arabs, that their victories did not signify divine approval of
them or Islam, but instead resulted from strong divine disapproval
-supported by appropriate scriptural quotations-of recent Christian
conduct. The author apparently wished to point out that Arab military
successes did not justify any Christian conversions to Islam.
The Pseudo-Methodius apocalypse proceeded to catalogue and explore, in the most lurid detail, the various horrors which accompanied
the Arab conquest. The author allowed his imagination to run wild
concerning the bloodthirsty and rapacious acts of the conquerors. He
wished to make the conquest appear as horrible as possible to effect
the maximum shock and contrition on the part of his audience:
The land of Persia will be delivered over to ruin and destruction and
her inhabitants to captivity and the sword. Cappadocia and her in-
Sicily will become desolate and her inhabitants will meet slaughter and
captivity. Hellas and inhabitants will meet destruction, captivity and the
sword. Romania [Asia Minor] will undergo destruction and her peo-
ple will be turned to flight. The islands of the sea will become desolate
and their inhabitants will perish through the sword and captivity. Egypt,
the East and Syria will be loaded with an immeasurable yoke of affliction.
They mercilessly will be pressed into service and their souls will be lured
by an irresitible amount of gold. The inhabitants of Egypt and Syria will
experience distress and affliction seven times worse than captivity. The
land of the Gospel will be smitten from the four winds beneath the
heavens and will be as dust in a mass which is gathered by the wind.
There will be plague and famine upon them. The hearts of the destroyers will be uplifted and raised in contempt and they will babble excessively until their appointed time. They will gain mastery over the entrance and exit from the north and east to the west and the sea. All
men will be beneath their yoke and birds and all waters of the sea will
be subject to them, and the deserts, where their inhabitants hunt, will
be theirs. They will register claim for themselves of the mountains as
well as the deserts, fish of the sea, wood of the hills, soil of the land, rocks
and the land's productivity will be their revenues. They will possess
the labors and sweat of the farmers, the property of the rich, the offerings to the saints, whether gold, silver, precious stones, copper or iron,
the holy and glorious vestments, every food and all honorable things.
Their hearts will be exceedingly exalted until they demand the corpses
mercy on laborers, the poor, they will dishonor the aged and will afflict
and have no mercy on the weak and infirm, but will mock and laugh at
those who are distinguished in wisdom and in political and civic affairs.
Everyone will be shamed into silence and will be afraid since they will
not have the strength to reply or to say anything plainly. All of the inhabitants of the earth will be astonished and their wisdom and education, of evil origin, will be powerless to retort to or to alter their [the
Arabs'] proclamations. Their course will be from sea to sea, from east
to west, and from the north to the desert of Yathrib. Their way will be
named the way of difficulty and presbyters and presbyteresses, poor and
rich, laborers and the thirsty and prisoners, will travel it and will
bless the dead.. . . For apostasy is education and it will educate all
of the earth's inhabitants. Since God called Ishmael, their father, a
wild ass, accordingly, wild asses and scorpions of the desert and every
kind of wild and tame beast will be captured, all of the wood of the hill-
This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Sat, 01 Oct 2016 15:14:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
145
Arabs'] swords and will become food for the wild beasts. The
slaughter the priests at home, defiling the holy places, and they w
with their wives in the revered and holy places where the mystica
bloodless sacrifice is performed. Their wives, sons and daughters w
on the holy vestments, they will place these on their horses, the
spread them on their beds and they will tie their cattle in the coff
the saints. They will be corrupted murderers, like a fire testing th
of the Christians.l1
against them with great wrath and will be awakened like a man fro
sleep who had been drinking wine, whom men had thought t
corpse and of no use. This man will come out against them fro
sea of the Ethiopians and will thrust his sword and desolation
as Yathrib, that is, into their fatherland, and will make captive t
wives and children. The sons of the emperor will descend upon th
habitants of the land of the Gospel and will eradicate them from
earth. Fear will fall upon them from all directions. Their wiv
each man will return to his own property and to that of his fath
Armenia, Cilicia, Isauria, Africa, Hellas, Sicily and everyone w
abandoned will return to his property and to that of his fathers
will multiply on the desolate earth like the locusts of Egypt. Arab
be devasted by fire, Egypt will be burned and the coast will be at
The entire wrath of the Emperor of the Romans will be upon thos
deny our Lord Jesus Christ. The earth will be at peace and there
be a general calm on earth such as never has existed and will not
exist, as it is the end. There will be merriment on earth and men w
16. Otkrovenie Mefodiia Patarslago 28-33.
This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Sat, 01 Oct 2016 15:14:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
146
CHURCH HISTORY
dwell in peace and rebuild cities, will free priests from their pa
men will cease to have afflictions in that time.17
of Daniel. He asked:
But who would be able to tell of the horror of the invasion of the Ishmael-
ites [= Arabs], which embraced land and sea? The fortunate Danie
foresaw and prophesied evils similar to those which were to take place on
earth. By four beasts he symbolized the four kingdoms which must arise on
earth. First, the beast with a human form, the kingdom of the west, which
is that of the Greeks. That is clear by his saying, 'Its wings fell and it
was effaced from the earth.' He is referring to the destruction of diabolic idolatry. 'And it made to stand as on human feet, and a man's heart
was given to it.' And here is the second beast, similar to a bear. It was
raised up on one side, the eastern side. It signifies the kingdom of the
Sassanids. 'And having three sides to its mouth,'-he means the king
dom of the Persians, Medes and the Parthians. This is evident by the
fact that one says to him: 'Arise, devour several bodies.' As, more-
over, the world knows he devoured them so thoroughly. 'And the third
beast, like a leopard, with wings of a bird on him and four heads of a
beast.' He means the kingdom of the North, Gog and Magog, and their
two companions, to whom was given the power to fly with force in thei
time from the northern direction. 'And the fourth beast, terrible, dread
ful, his teeth of iron, his claws of bronze; he ate and crunched and
the Bible:
I shall continue to tell of the evils which occurred in our time, including the topic of the rending of the ancient faith, and of the burning and
mortal simoom wind which blows on us and burns large and beautiful
trees and gardens. And we have merited it, for we have sinned against
the Lord and we have enraged the holy of Israel. 'If you take pleasure
in listening to me,' he says, 'you will enjoy the good things of the
earth, but if you do not wish to listen to me, the sword will devour you,
for the word of the Lord has so spoken.'
itself also on all lands, for Babylon is the mother of all the nations and
its kingdom is the kingdom of the regions of the North and also the
17. Otkrovenie Mefodiia Patarskago 40-43.
18. Seb&os, Histoire d'H6raolius, tr. F. Macler (Paris, 1904), 104-105. Cf. Dan. vii. 3-24.
This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Sat, 01 Oct 2016 15:14:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
147
South, that is to say, over the Hindus and over the nations whi
habit, for their part, the great desert, or the sons of Abraham w
born of Hagar and of Ketur: Ishmael. .... It came from the great
enormous desert which Moses and the children of Israel had inhab
following the word of the prophet: 'Like a hurricane, it will com
the south, coming from the desert, a formidable place,' which is
coming from the great and terrible desert from which the storm of
This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Sat, 01 Oct 2016 15:14:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
148
CHURCH HISTORY
internal peace to state and church, but also caused internal dissen
among the arch-enemies of Christendom, the non-believing Arabs
Sebeos, of course, was a Monophysite. He believed, however, t
world, but avenged those who had been wronged: He had no merc
such as had dealt treacherously against Him, but He delivered th
into the hands of the Ishmaelites. And the Moslem thereupon took
field and conquered all of the land of Egypt."21 John of Nikiu
interprets the Arab capture of the citadel of Babylon (in Egypt
a divine punishment for Chalcedonian sins: "Thus God punished t
because they had not honoured the redemptive passion of our Lo
and Saviour Jesus Christ, who gave his life for those who believ
Him. Yea, it was for this reason that God made them turn their
upon them (i.e. the Moslem)."2 Again, speaking of the Arab capt
of Alexandria, John commented: "And they had none to help th
and God destroyed their hopes, and delivered the Christians into
hands of their enemies."23 A contemporary observer, John empha
that the Muslims were "the enemies of God" and he refers to Islam
as 'the detestable doctrine of the beast, that is, Mohammed."24 Thus
21. The Chronicle of Jothn, Bishop of Nikis, eh. 116. 13-14, tr. B. H. Charles (Oxford, 1916),
p. 186; cf. A. H. M. Jones, "Were Ancient Heresies National or Social Movements in
Disguiset," Journal of Theological Studies, N. S. 10 (1959), 289.
22. John of Nikiu, Chrpicle 117. 4 (187 Charles); on the siege of Babylon (= Cairo):
This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Sat, 01 Oct 2016 15:14:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
149
the Arab conquest date from the early ninth century. Thes
cifically, the chronicles of Theophanes Confessor and the
Nicephorus of Constantinople.25 They may depend on lost p
century disasters. These first accounts, moreover, offered little explanation of the events; they mainly sought to place them in chronological framework. These are simply my speculations, of course, but
it is hoped that this paper will inspire further studies by other scholars
This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Sat, 01 Oct 2016 15:14:17 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms