Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Funded by
Financed by
the European Union
Jury Members:
Lilac Osanjo, University of Nairobi, Nairobi,
Kenya
Lorraine Ambole, University of Nairobi,
Nairobi, Kenya
Joyce Akach, University of Nairobi, Nairobi,
Kenya
Silvia Emili and Fabrizio Ceschin, College of
Engineering, Design & Physical Sciences, Brunel
University London, United Kingdom
Emanuela Delfino, Carlo Vezzoli and Elisa
Bacchetti, Politecnico di Milano University,
DESIGN Department, Italy
Jan Carel Diehl, Delft University of Technology,
The Netherlands
Richie Moalosi, University of Botswana,
Gaborone, Botswana
Venny Nakazibwe, Makerere University,
Kampala, Uganda
Mugendi M'Rithaa, Cape Peninsula University
of Technology, Cape Town, South Africa
Contents
Foreword
Index of projects
The winners
23
3
Foreword
Catalogue structure
An introduction to the brief competition precedes
the presentation of the 12 system concepts. Each
concept is illustrated by:
- A text describing the problem addressed with
your concept solution;
- The S.PSS Concept description that specify
what is included in the offer and what customers
pay for;
- The S.PSS Visualisation that represents, with
renderings, photos or sketches, the elements and
Brief
The following brief was given for the competition
to design a sustainable Product-Service System
(S.PSS) that addresses key environmental and
social issues [e.g. food production/consumption,
clothing care, public spaces safety, mobility, education/learning, sanitation, sheltering or home
activities] of a low and/or middle-income community in an African context.
The concept should be based on a Locally-Based
Sustainable Energy System, i.e. coherent with
the
promising
models
of
Sustainable
Product-Service
Systems
(S.PSS)
and
Distributed Renewable Energy (DRE).
In general terms the objective is to improve the
wellbeing by providing access to cleaner and
stable energy services that is based on locally,
renewable, secure, cleaner and economically
viable energy services.
The two models of S.PSS and DRE systems, as
well as their combination, can potentially couple
multiple sustainable benefits: economic (reduced
cost of energy, due to increased resiliency and
reliability), environmental (efficiency gains,
reduced
emissions),
and
socio
ethical
(democratization of access to energy, increased
participation and independence of local people).
In this framework, the focus is on extending the
access to those people/communities that do not
have yet access to energy services and improving
the offer for those who already have access to it,
possibly integrating gender equity issues.
Finally, the concept has to be focused on the
proper configurations of the socio-economic
actors (appropriate partnerships alongside with
appropriate technologies) to locally produce,
deliver and maintain the energy systems
involving any possible stakeholders in the value
production system, including final users.
b) Distributed
definition
Renewable
Energy
Index of projects
The winners
1st prize: Kareberere
2nd prize: Bio-light
3rd prize: Tafaria Solar Energy
10
14
18
24
28
32
36
40
44
48
52
56
The winners
11
The Kaberebere solar water pumping, phone and lantern
charging point project
F. Tuhairwe, R. Sseruwagi, M. Muheki, M. Nuwasasira, R. Ssejjuko.
Makerere University, Kampala - Uganda
Problem addressed
Kaberebere trading centre which is located at
(0.25682, 30.64235 (lat, long) has an existing borehole which has a manual pump, keeps on failing due
to a high iron water content. Borehole failure has
forced community members to collect water from
unsafe water points 500meters away from the trading centre. Community member pay for usage of
water from the borehole to an entrepreneur manning
the borehole, however, the collections are not sufficient to service it due to the costly equipment
required. There is currently no access to electricity
therefore 52 phone owners and 43 lantern owners
travel 5km to the next trading centre to charge their
phones and lanterns.
13
Interaction storyboard
Stakeholders system
map (180x85mm; 300dpi)
1. Energy gumps buys a solar system for water pumping,
phone and lantern charging from the manufacturer
Details
Providers: Energy Gumps Ltd
3. Energy Gumps installs the system
and water collection points to the
Kaberebere community
6. Households in Kaberebere community pay cash for water 6US cents per
20 liters fetched and 30 US cents per phone or lantern charged to the agent
Benefits
Socio-ethical: Awareness and change of
attitude towards using clean energy and empowering the locals with skills in energy systems.
There will more time saved for the stakeholders
to do other activity as clean water will be closer.
Environmental: The service will reduce on the
tendence of using petrol and diesel generators to
charge phones and lanterns, hence reduced
green house gas emissions.
Economic: The system will save stakeholders on
the cost of transport to charge phones and
laterns, as well as buying individual solar Home
Systems.
15
BIO-LIGHT
C. Nuwematsiko, D. Mwesiga, S.G. Khainza, M.Tammukede
College of Engineering Design Art and Technology Makerere University, Kampala, Uganda
Problem addressed
The use of firewood and cahrcoal is one of the primary causes of
deforestation, which leads to soil erosion and increase in emission
of carbondioxide to the atmosphere.
The aim is to providing an alternative solution to reduce
dependence on firewood and hence reducing deforestation,
Reduce pollution, greenhouse gas effect and deforestation.
COMMUNITY GARDEN
17
Interaction storyboard
UNIVERSITY
The NGOs on board supporting sustainability provide the experts to build the
community and some equipment like gas
bags and buckets.
NGO
2. Provide
volunteers to build
the facility and some
of the equipment like
gen-sets or fuel cells
COMPANY
SCHOOLS
HEALTH CENTRES
COMMUNITY
GARDEN
They save Time to go work in the respective The community does communal agriculture
assignments of the day to fulfill the market in a community garden thanks to the slurry
channeled to the communal garden to
demand target.
promote agriculture and hence improving
peoples livelihood programs
TRADING CENTRES
LEGEND
Details
SMALL SCALE
MANUFACTURING
4. Installation,
maintenance &
RENEWABLE ENERGY repair
3. Government
organization to
control operation
and environmental
policies
9. Provide slurry
LOCAL
ENTREPRENEUR
HOUSEHOLDS
GOV. ORG.
material flows
financial flows
Benefits
Socio-ethical: The biogas is a renewable
resource from cow waste thus rendering it
readily available for as long as animals are
present.
Environmental: Tafaria relies on renewable
solar energy to provide basic lighting solution as
an environmentally friendly alternative to carousol lamps, burnt biomas and fossil fuel dependent electricity lighting solutions.
Economic: This is an economical solution in the
sense that the farmers nolonger incur costs of
transporting wood and other fossil fuels for
cooking and lighting. The products are affordable to the user since they are initially subsidized
based on the farmers contribution to the
system.
19
Tafaria Solar Energy
C. Raymond, K. Opoku-Asare, R. D. Debrah, B. Mhungu
The Cape Peninsula University of Technology (CPUT) / South Africa, Ghana, Zimbabwe
Problem addressed
The Government of Kenya rolled out an ambitious schools
electrification programme in 2013 in which all primary schools
in the country would be grid by 2015. This has provided many
rural homes and businesses the opportunity to connect to
electric power due to the deep penetration of, and hence
proximity to, primary schools nationally. Notwithstanding the
barriers which may still exist to households and businesses
such as cost and inappropriate buildings, one of the issues
which has not been explored in this context of availability and
abundance is the appropriateness of on-grid energy sources
for low consumption users in low density, low income settings.
Additionally, the cost of erecting and maintaining power lines
in far-flung areas makes electricity distribution and
infrastructure maintenance costly. This is an opportunity to
explore alternative power sources more appropriate to low
consumption users, low density settings, rural incomes and
customised usage in the area around Tafaria Castle.
DRE Solution
Gamification tools
21
Interaction storyboard
2
PROVIDES TAFARIA
WITH SOLAR ENERGY
SOLUTIONS
MANUFACTURERS
13
OFFERS TRAINING ON
OPERATIONS AND
MAINTENANCE
10
LOCAL
ENTREPRENEUR
11
OFFERS FINANCIAL
SERVICES
1 2
OFFERS REPAIR
SERVICES FOR
THE CREDIT
PERIOD
14
END-USER
5
7
3
1
TAFARIA
15
USER PAYS
TO RENT
OFFERS DISPOSAL OF
PRODUCTS AT
END-OF-LIFE CYCLE
DEVELOP STORE
FOR ENTREPRENEURS
17
12 ENERGY
USING
PRODUCTS
16
PAYS FOR UPGRADES OF
CHARGING STATION STORES
AND ENERGY USING PRODUCTS
Rural
Research
Centre
Details
Providers: private business partner of Tafaria
Entrepreneurs distribute
solar energy solution in Kenya
END-USERS
LEGEND
material
flows
information
flows
financial
flows
labour
gamified
performances training
Benefits
Socio-ethical: improved living conditions of
communities situated in rural Kenya through the
offering of solar lighting solu-tions to Base of
Pyramid end users.
Environmental: Tafaria relies on renewable
solar energy to provide basic lighting solution as
an environmentally friendly alternative to carousol lamps, burnt biomas and fossil fuel dependent electricity lighting solutions.
Economic: Tafaria secures financial income
through two main avenue streams:
1) direct sales to end users.
2) buy-in to franchise from local entrepre-neurs.
Both options are provided witha finance plan to
ensure finance flows between the key stakeholders.
25
CoPika
Cammarano Lucia, Emeny Katie, Falini Eugenia, Maniyar Krishna, Bagga Yuvraj Singh
Problem addressed
S.PSS
concept
description
PSS
concept
description
CoPika is a service for the community that provides
the space to cook and eat meals with other offerings
that are beneficial to the health and wellbeing of
people. Distributed gardens in the same area
provides vegetables for a market inside the Copika
area.The Kitchen Equipment is provided by a Manufacturer specialising in Kitchens, the manufacturer
keeps ownership and for this reason provides durable equipment. The Electricity is provided by and
Solar power Energy company who install and keep ownership and maintenance of the Solar Panels.
A Biomass Company provides and keeps ownership of the equipment used to produce Biogas to the
Kitchen. The Kitchen and Farms will be staffed by the community.
A charity provides the systems, education and training for this business to be set up.
The users can buy meals with money or through their participation of sharing skills or time in the
Farm or Kitchen through jobs. This gives everyone an opportunity to eat.
CoPika includes a delivery service that provides meals to the community, with a discounted price for
people who are less able to walk.
COMMU N ITY
get
H e al t h ly
fo o d
Ki tc h e n
u s ag e
D e l i ve r y
s e rvi ce
In tera c t i o n
E q ui p m e nt s
Common
sp ace
27
Interaction storyboard
COMBINED SPACE
FOOD
GARDEN
USAGE OF KI T CHEN
FOODMARKET
ACCESS
USER
T HE CUSTOMER CAN
BOOK HI S MEAL
FOOD
MAR KET
KI T CHEN
USAGE
KI T CHENS - T OOLS
ENERGY
COMPANY
ow ner of
k itchens
KIT CH EN
MANUFACTURER
cop ika is ow ner
of s ol ar b ike to
d eliver food
FOOD BOX
ow ner of
equip ment and
s ol ar panel s
Details
MUNICIP ALI TY
B I OMAS S
pa yment for
p eriod
Benefits
29
31
33
Design for clothing care in Kibera Slum, Nairobi, Kenya
by Cerboni Baiardi Giulia, Ira Sharma, Teodora Iordanova, Kristian Terziev, Elisabeth
Ulander, Chengxin Hou
Politecnico of Milan, Italy
Problem addressed
In Kibera slum most of the people do not own a
washing machine and they wash by hand using
equipment like buckets and basins.
The washing is done by women. They have to buy
soap and water, about 20 liter jerry cans, and they
come back walking with all this weight. They do the
washing near their houses in common spaces. Often,
also children get involved in this activity, and it can
be dangerous for them.
Washing of the children clothes is done daily, while
the adults one is done twice or thrice a week.
Women have to carry heavy jerry cans with water,
walking for a long time before they arrive to their
houses.
The concept is connected to transport reduction,
resource reduction and toxicity reduction.
Entrance
Energy Resource
Payment
Soap Dispensers
Bathroom
Service Area
Washing Machines
Hydro
Solar
Human
Pay-per-time of
access to energy
Work to get
a wash for free
Type of PSS
DRE Configuration
B2C Business to
Consumer
Distributed/
Local Mini-grid
Waiting Area
40m2
35
Interaction storyboard
MUNICIPALITY
The Municipality builds
the station and installs
the pipe system to
provide water from the
river and build the rain
water harvesting
system. The dirty
water is reused in
order to avoid waste.
DELIVERY
SERVICE
SOAP LOCAL
PRODUCER
Teaching
of maintenance
adn repairing
of the washing
machines
WASHING
STATION
WASHING
MACHINES
PROVIDER
SOLAR/HYDRO
ENERGY
PROVIDER
USER
DELIVERY
SERVICE
Customers
bring their
clothes
Two way
of
payment
Soap from
dispensers
Do the
washing!
SOAP LOCAL
PRODUCER
WASHING
MACHINES
PROVIDER
Local repairing
team
Installation of
washing machines
SINGLE
USER
WASHING
STATION
Distribution of soap
WORKER
WASHING ON
DEMAND
SOLAR
ENERGY
PROVIDER
COMMUNITY
HYDRO
ENERGY
PROVIDER
Washing station
Local people/User
Workers
Details
MUNICIPALITY
Dirty water
Benefits
Providers: Local Cooperative, Public and Govern- Socio-ethical: The station can employ people
ment, multinationl energy supplier.
from the surrounding areas; interested locals are
37
CLOTHING SERVICE SYSTEM IN KENYA
SASAN MEHRAN, EOIN GALLAGHER, KAREN RODRIGUEZ
XIN ZHAO, ZHUANG TIAN, ZIHAN LIN
An electro domestic company in partnership with a solar panels provider, produce a cleaning kiosk
equipped with washing machines, irons and clothes repairing machines through a pay per use
system for local people.
Also it would be the interest of companies to provide dre system (distributed renewable energy)
and water.
Indeed, local people can be trained to repair the machines and work in the kiosk for a limited time .
Additionally those who know about tailoring but dont have the machines can access the ownerless
machines to start a business (startup) and get some income from it.
39
Interaction storyboard
Details
Providers: A Partnership between an electro
domestic company and a solar panels provider.
Customers: Local people in Nairobi, Kenya
DRE System: Ownerless solar panel systems
/ Ownership
Energy-using products: All services in clothes
kiosks.
Services offered: Providing, training, installation.
Payment modality: Pay per month
Benefits
Socio-ethical: Choose nearest clothes kiosk for
Wash, fix, repair and iron clothes. Work opportunity for all local people (men and women).
Considering the abuse of child in this system.
Environmental: Decreasing the environmental
toxicity, using the renewable energy for services.
Economic: Pay per month for use of all kiosk
41
COOK 4U
Mine Kelleci, Huo Ran, Sebile Tatar, Nadia Valcamonico,Giorgia Volinia,Gizem Yenel
Politecnico di Milano / Italy,Turkey,China
Problem addressed
In Uganda, there are a lot of socio-ethical and
echological problems in the whole action of eating.
To begin with women are always responsible for
prepairing and serving. While sometimes children
are responsible of travelling and bringing the food,
men wait to be served and not contributing to any
housework thus creating an inbalance between
gender and family members. Another point is that
even though most of the left over and waste are
getting recycled, the materials used for cooking is
charcoral and firewood which increases the carbon
foot print in two ways; Disposal of toxic gases in the
nature and traders travelling to far distances in
order to find charcoral. So in our project we target
to improve these situations by creating a system for
cooking.
S.PSS
concept
description
PSS
concept
description
COOK 4U is basicly a sustainable catering system consists of a communal kitchen with all appliances
in which local women can cook together, for themselves or for sale, while socializing at the same
time. Women will get daily orders from the community and order raw materials and ingredients from
the local shops accordingly. In the morning with the freshly arrived ingredients, they cook all together in the kitchen which all the electricity need is sustained by solar panels and biogas so completely
green. The prepared products will be delivered by bikes, used by the men of the families, which
eliminate the exhaust gas and the gender inbalance. So the women will be cooking, eating and
socializing while customers will be paying for a healty homemade food.
43
Interaction storyboard
Details
Providers: University, ONG, Local manufacturers
Customers: Community
DRE System: Solar panels, Biogas system
/ Ownership
Energy-using products: Ovens, Cooker, Fridge,
Tools for ordering raw products and receiving the
orders
Services offered: maintanence and installation
provided by the sponsor renewable energy
company
Payment modality: mobile with credit card or
cash
Benefits
Socio-ethical: Workload is ivided equally between
men and women. Local farmers,shops and many
different actors will come together in this created
network. Most importantly through university, local
people will be more concious about sustainable living.
Environmental: Risk of fire and pollution of toxic
fumes are eliminated by the introduction of photovoltaic system instead of using firewood. All kind of
waste is reusable for the cooking area with biogas
system. Using of bicycles instead of trucks for the
transportation will also decrease the carbon foot
print.
Economic: All tools will be shared so there wont be
any unnecessary purchase.
The community will benefit the economical home
made food while the women of cooperative will have
the oppurtunity to take food for free.
45
Community Production Center
J. Onyango, A. Pereyra Decara, A. Ianniello, E. Bukisow, A. Palombelli, N. Urbanczyk,
D. Shenhar
Politecnico di Milano, Italia.
Problem addressed
Clean Water
Safe Cooking
CPC
S.PSS
concept
description
PSS concept
description
First of all we intend to creat a GATHERING PLACE providing a centralised, communal kitchen for the
villagers running on renewable energies such as biogas, solar panels, aquaponics. Second of all, the
goal is to creat and engage a COOPERATIVE that involves the inhabitans to share and produce. They
will cultivate, grow and haverst. Futhermore, we intend to work on the STAKEHOLDER INTERACTION
such as a local restaurant franchise that could get involved with local producers. They will buy food
surplus from the cooperative and will provided them back with their waste in a product or use
oriented PSS. Then we will IMPROVE SOCIAL COHESION by trying to reduce the inequalities
between women and men by providing an equity working platform. Finally, we want to REDUCE the
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT. We replace charcoal and wood based energy provision, with renewable
energies, such as solar and biofuel based one. Also, we will at the same time reduce waste impact
by reusing the organic residues of the restaurants.
WORK
Renewable Energy
FORCE
Comunity
Raw
Food
INCOME
Restaurant
Chain
Organic
Waste
Daily Meals
47
Interaction storyboard
Community
Food +
Services
WaterPump
Work
Service
.1
.2
.3
Teaching processes
and instalation of the
solar panel system.
Kitchen
Biogas
Pay per
Period
Food
for
Cooking
CPC
Fields
Food
for
Selling
Restaurant Chain
Flows legend
.5
.6
Details
Providers: HomeBioGas, Water.org
Customers: Comunity, Restaurant Chain
DRE System: Solar Panels
Ownership: Manufacturer
Energy-using products: Kitchen, Water Pump.
Ownership: Manufacturer
.7
.8
.9
HomeBiogas
Service
Payment
Solar Panels
.4
Fertilizers
Organic Waste
Work
Organic Waste
Service
Fertilizers
Benefits
It is a result oriented PSS, providers are
not just delivering goods but also teaching
how to make a good use of them.
Mantainance and responsible use are the
keys for a sustainable use.
KEYS
-Meals produced under a safe environment.
-Shift to sustainable energy use.
-Link the countryside and the city.
-Gathering place, task unification.
-Water suplier.
49
Energy for Tlokweng
P. Baez, C. Castellanos, M. Hosseini, K. Kanashiro, A.M. Ospina, P. Ricciardelli
Politecnico di Milano / Italy
Problem addressed
The eating system in a typical household in the
Tlokweng village, rural area outside Gaborone,
Botswana is characterized by the use of firewood
and aluminum pots. Meals are prepared by using
firewood. Electricity is not found in all rural areas
and where it is available, it is very expensive as well
as LPG gas. Usually the cooking and collection of
firewood is done by women, men come into the
picture if a donkey cart or truck is used to collect it.
They have to carry a heavy weight for long distances. Due to the large consumption of firewood, it
is becoming difficult to find some near the village
and it produces toxic fumes and waste. The objective is to improve wellbeing by providing access to
cleaner and stable energy services for cooking.
51
Interaction storyboard
SECONDARY
STAKEHOLDERS
Individual
household
Pay-per-period
Pay-per
period
Details
Make arrangment
for supporting
LFC
START
Provides energy
Solar energy Cooking
Local organic food
company
appliances company
cooperative
Joint venture
University
VDC village
development
committee
Financial
Information
Material
Labour
Benefits
Socio-ethical: social cohesion and gender
equality are improved by favoring conditions for
women and kids. Also, accessible and long
lasting alternatives for cooking are provided that
might bring positive behavioral change.
Environmental: production of toxic fumes and
waste is reduced. Soil erosion and desertification are avoided. Renewable energy is used
instead of fossil fuels and consumption of natural resources is reduced.
Economic: Pricing is convenient and not
dependant on supply and demand cycles. Extra
income can be obtained by the community and
food can be obtained at reduced prices. Companies open a new market and generate income.
53
Renewable energy powered Common Kitchen for
Khayelitsha, and related Vegetables Garden
G. Bessone, Y. Chi, A. Frugoni, Q. Qu, M. Wang, J. Zhao
Politecnico di Milano / Italy
Problem addressed
This proposal addresses food safety and lack of food.
Khayelitsha is a partially informal township where
food access is limited: little agriculture, no livestock
farms, no supermarkets. People rely on small
informal shops to access fruit and vegetables (supplied from other informal settlements), that often
are not fresh. People stick to a diet of samp and
beans, they dont eat much fruit and vegetables, and
they use paraffin or coal as cooking fuel: their diet is
not balanced, and the cooking methods are harmful
to their health.
This proposal consists of a more accessible, safe,
cheap and inclusive food system, making fresh food
and safe cooking facilities easily available for the
community while promoting formative/development
activities and social inclusion within the community
and with tourists.
55
Interaction storyboard
Details
4. Themba and the community are
interested in using the kitchen and the
garden to access fresh, cheap vegetables.
As he can't pay for the use of the system,
he gets a loan from a microcreditor
Benefits
Socio-ethical: No exploitment of local
resources/economies (ensure availability for
future generations), age/gender involvement
(elderly as teachers), multicultural integration,
healthier diet, fairness, no heavy duties for kids
Environmental: Less packaging, less waste
(composting on site), no toxic fumes or health
hazard, solar powered cooking stoves, control
on fertilizers, no outsourcing = less distance,
transport reduction
Economic: Access to cheaper/fresher products,
direct production over outsourcing, no need for
initial investment for users, access made easier
with microcredit, pay-per-use at accessible and
fair rates, no packaging and distribution costs
29
57
Solar Electricity for increment Water Pumps Pressure
Carlos Coy, Patricia Beltrn, Negar Karimi , Cui Jiahua,Guo Yijia, Liang Yujia.
Politecnico di Milano/ Italy
Problem addressed
To design a sustainable Product Service System
concept for the Eating/food preparation system in a
typical informal settlement household in Khaelitsha
township, around Cape Town based on a Locally
based Sustainable Energy System, coherent with the
promising models of Sustainable Product Service
Systems (S.PSS) and distributed Renewable Energy
(DRE). In general terms the objective is to improve
the wellbeing by providing access to cleaner and
stable energy services.
The two models, as well as their combination can
potentially couple multiple sustainable benefits:
economic (reduced cost of energy), environmental
(efficiency gains), and socio ethical
(democratization of access to energy, increased
participation and independence of local people)
Problem addressed
(80x80mm; 300dpi)
S.PSS
concept
description
PSS
concept
description
Provide electricty to the water pumps through the use of solar panel, in order to increase the pressure of the pumps and improve the quality of the service in the houses and the irrigation systems
for local crops. The partnership will supply all equipment and physical installation of the system and
the water pumps in the town and as an alternative also give han-pumps as back-up that supports
the operation of the system. The service is a mix of product and services that going to work together looking for a improving in the satisfaction level, health conditions and basic needs of the comumunity. The user need to pay a fixed fee per the use of the system , leaving all the responsability of
installation, maintenance and final product life to the service providers.
PSS visualisation
(210x210mm; 300dpi)
59
Stakeholders system map
Local technicians
Training for system
maintenance
Pay-per period
Service access
Information / Card
Maintenance
Community
7
Salary
Interaction storyboard
private
company
START Partnership
System Provider
financial flow
material flow
information flow
labour flow
main actors
Details
Providers: Private energy company, Public and
goverment entities
Customers: Community
DRE System: Solar Energy/Energy company
-Water/Goverment
government
secondary actors
Benefits