Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Pediatric Demyelination
Sona Narula, MD; Brenda Banwell, MD
ABSTRACT
Purpose of Review: This review summarizes a general approach to pediatric
demyelination as well as specific features of each of the acquired demyelinating
syndromes to help clinicians in their evaluation of children with these disorders.
Case studies are included to illustrate the expanding phenotype of many of
these syndromes.
Recent Findings: With the creation of consensus definitions for the pediatric
acquired demyelinating syndromes, recognition of demyelination in children has
increased, as has understanding of the clinical and radiologic features, prognosis,
and response to treatment. Collaborative studies and multicenter clinical trials are
ongoing and needed to appropriately evaluate emerging therapies for some of the
chronic demyelinating disorders, such as multiple sclerosis and neuromyelitis optica
(NMO) spectrum disorder.
Summary: This review will aid the clinician in identifying key features of the
pediatric acquired demyelinating syndromes and highlights a general approach for
the diagnosis and treatment of these disorders.
Address correspondence to
Dr Sona Narula, Colket
Translational Research
Building, 3501 Civic Center
Blvd, Philadelphia, PA 19104,
narulas@email.chop.edu.
Relationship Disclosure:
Dr Narula has received
fellowship support from the
National Multiple Sclerosis
Society. Dr Banwell serves as
editor-in-chief of Multiple
Sclerosis and Related
Disorders and as a consultant
for Novartis AG. Dr Banwell
receives research support
from the Multiple Sclerosis
Society of Canada.
Unlabeled Use of
Products/Investigational
Use Disclosure:
Drs Narula and Banwell discuss
the unlabeled/investigational use
of glatiramer acetate, interferon
beta, and natalizumab
for the treatment of
pediatric multiple sclerosis.
* 2016 American Academy
of Neurology.
INTRODUCTION
Acquired demyelinating syndromes are
immune-mediated central nervous system (CNS) disorders that can be either
monophasic or relapsing. These disorders include acute disseminated encephalomyelitis (ADEM), isolated or
relapsing optic neuritis, idiopathic
transverse myelitis, multiple sclerosis
(MS), and neuromyelitis optica (NMO)
spectrum disorders. While these disorders may be characterized by overlapping clinical symptoms, the prognosis,
treatment, and characteristic radiographic features of each entity differ.
The International Pediatric Multiple Sclerosis Study Group, which consists of
more than 150 expert clinicians and
researchers from over 40 countries
worldwide, initially proposed definitions for these acute demyelinating
syndromes in 20071 and provided updated criteria in 2013,2 which are summarized in Table 11-1.3Y5
Continuum (Minneap Minn) 2016;22(3):897915
897
Pediatric Demyelination
Syndromes
TABLE 11-1 Summary of the Proposed Definitions for Acquired Demyelinating
and Their Associated Key Clinical and Radiologic Featuresa
Diagnosis
Definition
Monophasic acute
disseminated
encephalomyelitis
(ADEM)2
Multifocal neurologic
symptoms
Multiphasic ADEM2
Clinically isolated
syndrome2
Pediatric MS2
Encephalopathyb
After 3 months from
symptom onset, no new
clinical symptoms or MRI
abnormalities develop
Multifocal neurologic
symptoms
Monofocal or multifocal
presentations
Clinical or radiographic
evidence of lesion
dissemination in both time
and space4; one event that
fulfills criteria initially for
ADEM followed by a
second non-ADEM event at
least 3 months later
associated with new MRI
lesions demonstrating 2010
McDonald criteria for
dissemination in space4
Encephalopathyb
T1 hypointense lesions
are rare
Encephalopathy is
not present
Monofocal or multifocal
features
898
www.ContinuumJournal.com
June 2016
Syndromes
TABLE 11-1 Summary of the Proposed Definitions for Acquired Demyelinating
and Their Associated Key Clinical and Radiologic Featuresa Continued from page 898
Diagnosis
Definition
NMO spectrum
disorder5
Longitudinally extensive
spinal cord lesions
Relapsing NMO
(recurrent optic neuritis
and transverse myelitis
episodes)
2. Detection of the
antiYaquaporin-4
immunoglobulin using best
available method
3. Exclusion of alternative
diagnoses
Diagnostic criteria for an NMO
spectrum disorder without
antiYaquaporin-4
immunoglobulin seropositivity,
or if antiYaquaporin-4
immunoglobulin status
is unknown:
syndrome: episode of
otherwise unexplained
hiccups or nausea
and vomiting
& Symptomatic
narcolepsy or acute
diencephalic clinical
syndrome with NMO
spectrum disorderY
typical diencephalic
MRI lesions
MRI requirements, as
applicable
www.ContinuumJournal.com
899
Pediatric Demyelination
KEY POINTS
h Acquired demyelinating
syndromes may
represent a monophasic
illness or may be the first
attack of a chronic
disease such as multiple
sclerosis or a
neuromyelitis optica
spectrum disorder.
900
www.ContinuumJournal.com
June 2016
a
TABLE 11-2 Differential Diagnosis of Acute Demyelination in Children
Diagnostic Category
Additional Investigations to
Consider (To Be Determined on
a Case-By-Case Basis)
Rheumatologic
Primary central nervous system
(CNS) angiitis, sarcoidosis, Sjogren
syndrome, systemic lupus
erythematosus, Behet syndrome,
Degos disease
Malignancy
CNS lymphoma, metastasis, glioma
Autoimmune encephalopathies
Limbic encephalitis
www.ContinuumJournal.com
901
Pediatric Demyelination
a
TABLE 11-2 Differential Diagnosis of Acute Demyelination in Children Continued from page 901
Diagnostic Category
Additional Investigations to
Consider (To Be Determined on
a Case-By-Case Basis)
Genetic testing
Stroke
Hemoglobin electrophoresis
Moyamoya disease
NOTCH3 mutation
Complicated migraine
Consider MRI
Folate deficiency
Folate level
Vascular
Nutritional
902
www.ContinuumJournal.com
June 2016
KEY POINTS
h CSF examination
remains an important
diagnostic test and
should be considered in
all cases of suspected
demyelination,
especially if central
nervous system infection
is being considered.
h Acute disseminated
encephalomyelitis is an
acute central nervous
system inflammatory
syndrome that is
defined by
encephalopathy (not
attributable to
concurrent fever or
illness) and multifocal
neurologic signs.
h Acute disseminated
encephalomyelitis can
occur at any age, but
most commonly occurs
in school-aged children
(5 to 8 years of age),
and is a monophasic
illness in the majority
of patients.
www.ContinuumJournal.com
903
Pediatric Demyelination
Case 11-1
A 3-year-old developmentally normal boy presented to the hospital with progressive sleepiness and
ataxia over 4 days. His parents reported that he had upper respiratory symptoms, low-grade fever,
and a diffuse erythematous rash about 1 week prior to presentation, all of which resolved. He had not
received recent vaccinations.
Upon initial examination, the patient was found to be afebrile. He was noted to be very lethargic and
was unable to appropriately answer questions because of sleepiness. He had a mild left hemiparesis and
was unable to walk independently because of ataxia. His reflexes were brisk throughout. MRI of the brain
revealed bilateral nonenhancing multifocal lesions involving the deep gray structures and white matter
(Figure 11-1). Lumbar puncture revealed a mild CSF pleocytosis (10 white blood cells/mm3, 84%
lymphocytes) and normal glucose and protein levels. CSF oligoclonal bands were negative. Viral studies,
including tests for herpesviruses and enterovirus, were also negative.
FIGURE 11-1
Panel A reprinted with permission from Narula S, Banwell B, Wiley-Blackwell. B 2016 Wiley-Blackwell.
After reviewing the clinical presentation, MRI, and CSF studies, the patient was given a diagnosis
of acute disseminated encephalomyelitis (ADEM) and subsequently began treatment with IV
methylprednisolone (30 mg/kg/d). His symptoms began to improve by the third day of treatment. He
completed 5 days of IV methylprednisolone and then was started on an oral prednisone taper (at a
starting dose of 1 mg/kg/d, tapered over 10 days).
The patient had completely returned to baseline by his follow-up visit 1 month after discharge.
A repeat brain MRI obtained 6 months after his hospitalization showed complete resolution of the
previously seen areas of T2 signal hyperintensity. The patient was followed closely over the next few
years and remained well until about 2 years later, when he presented with sudden behavioral change
and seizures. He was readmitted to the hospital where he became more encephalopathic and had
progressive speech disturbance, orofacial dyskinesia, and autonomic dysregulation with
904
www.ContinuumJournal.com
June 2016
TRANSVERSE MYELITIS
Transverse myelitis is a spinal cord demyelinating syndrome characterized by
acute to subacute sensory, motor, or
autonomic symptomatology. In 2002,
the Transverse Myelitis Consortium
Working Group developed diagnostic
criteria for idiopathic acute transverse
myelitis that includes: (1) bilateral impairment of sensory, motor, or autonomic function; (2) demonstration of a
clearly defined sensory level; (3) exclusion of a compressive or infectious
etiology; (4) evidence of inflammation
with a CSF pleocytosis, elevated IgG
index, or MRI lesion enhancement;
and (5) progression to peak symptoms
within 4 hours to 21 days of symptom
onset.20 A complete cord syndrome
causes bilateral sensory, motor, and
autonomic impairment, while a partial
cord syndrome is diagnosed when less
complete involvement exists below
the level of the lesion. If a hyperacute
presentation occurs (maximal deficits
reached within 4 hours of onset), other
etiologies (especially vascular) must also
be considered.
Transverse myelitis can occur at any
age, with about 20% of all cases occurring in children.21 Within the pediatric population, a bimodal peak of
incidence occurs at 0 to 2 years of age
and 5 to 17 years of age.22 Aside from
paresthesia, numbness, and weakness,
Continuum (Minneap Minn) 2016;22(3):897915
KEY POINT
Treatment
Initial treatment of transverse myelitis consists of high-dose IV methylprednisolone
www.ContinuumJournal.com
905
Pediatric Demyelination
KEY POINT
h Transverse myelitis is a
serious illness, with risk
of incomplete recovery.
Failure to improve
promptly with IV
corticosteroids should
prompt use of
plasma exchange.
Case 11-2
A 7-year-old girl presented for evaluation of neck pain, left arm paresthesia, and new-onset right-sided
weakness. The neck pain and paresthesia had started about 2 weeks prior to presentation and had
progressively worsened. She was unable to walk independently because of the weakness in her right leg.
She had no preceding illness or trauma.
Upon arrival to the hospital, the patient had
a brain and spine MRI. Her brain MRI was
unremarkable. Her spine MRI revealed a T2
hyperintense nonenhancing lesion extending
from C1 to T3 (Figure 11-2). CSF studies were
notable for elevated protein (110 mg/dL) and
a pleocytosis (90 white blood cells/mm3). Viral
studies from the CSF were all negative. Serum
antiYaquaporin-4 immunoglobulin was
negative. Her ophthalmologic examination
was normal with no evidence of optic disc
swelling or pallor.
She began treatment with IV
methylprednisolone and noted only minimal
improvement after 3 days of treatment. As her
deficits remained severe, she began treatment
with plasma exchange. She received a total of
five exchanges, and her symptoms began to
improve. Her deficits improved slowly, and she
was able to walk independently about 2 weeks
after her admission to the hospital. She was
discharged to inpatient rehabilitation. She was
seen back in the neurology clinic 1 month after
her discharge from rehabilitation and was
completely back to baseline at that time.
Comment. This is a case of idiopathic
transverse myelitis that required plasma
FIGURE 11-2 Sagittal T2-weighted image of a patient
with idiopathic transverse myelitis with a
exchange in the setting of an inadequate
longitudinally extensive lesion (arrow).
response to initial treatment with high-dose
Notable cord swelling and edema is evident.
corticosteroids.
906
www.ContinuumJournal.com
June 2016
data on 118 cases from 34 states nationwide. The median age of children
was 7 years, and most patients were reported to have fever or respiratory
symptoms prior to the onset of neurologic symptoms. In this particular cohort, the limb weakness was often
asymmetric, and many cases of monoplegia were reported.30 Cranial nerve
abnormalities were reported in some
cases. CSF studies typically revealed a
moderate pleocytosis, and some patients had an elevated CSF protein.30
Although enterovirus was found in a
number of respiratory specimens, it was
not found in the CSF of any patient.30
Radiologically, cord lesions in acute
flaccid myelitis primarily involve the
gray matter and anterior horn regions
(Figure 11-3). Lesions were noted at
various levels throughout the cord, and
some were longitudinally extensive.31
When compared to patients with typical inflammatory transverse myelitis,
lesions in acute flaccid myelitis have
prominent anterior horn cell involvement and significantly less cord edema
and white matter involvement. The
prognosis for acute flaccid myelitis is
guarded with variable recovery. With
the most recent cluster, although twothirds of patients were reported to have
some improvement within the first
month,30 few have been reported to
fully recover to date. Slow and incomplete recovery has been reported in
prior clusters of acute flaccid myelitis.28,32 Studies are now ongoing to
better determine the etiology of acute
flaccid myelitis and to identify possible
genetic differences among patients
who develop acute flaccid myelitis.
KEY POINTS
MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS
Although MS is more common in
adults, about 2% to 10% of all patients
with MS will have their first clinical
symptom before the age of 18 years.33Y36
www.ContinuumJournal.com
907
Pediatric Demyelination
FIGURE 11-3
Spinal cord imaging from two children with acute flaccid myelitis. A, Axial
T2-weighted MRI shows prominent anterior horn cell involvement (arrows). B,
Sagittal T2-weighted MRI reveals T2 signal abnormality (arrow) primarily
involving the gray matter of the spinal cord. No significant cord edema is evident.
Typical presenting features of MS include optic neuritis, focal partial transverse myelitis, brainstem symptoms,
hemimotor or hemisensory symptoms,
ataxia, or multifocal features involving
more than one deficit (Case 11-3). Of
children who initially present with clinical features consistent with ADEM, 6%
to 18% experience future relapses that
confirm a diagnosis of MS.37,38 As outlined in the International Pediatric
Multiple Sclerosis Study Group consensus criteria,2 subsequent relapses in a
patient with ADEM must be nonencephalopathic (not ADEM-like), occur at
least 3 months after the initial attack,
and be associated with new MRI lesions
that meet the 2010 McDonald criteria
for dissemination in time4 for a diagnosis of MS to be considered. Of note,
the 2010 McDonald criteria cannot be
applied at the time a child presents
with ADEM.
While many features of pediatric MS
overlap with adult-onset disease, some
distinguishing characteristics exist. For
example, while pediatric-onset MS is
more common in females after the age
of about 12 years, the ratio of boys to
girls is equal in prepubertal children.
908
Pediatric MS is nearly always relapsingremitting at onset, and genetic, metabolic, or structural etiologies should be
strongly considered if a patient presents
with a seemingly progressive phenotype from onset. As compared with
adult-onset disease, relapse rate in the
first few years in pediatric MS is higher;
over 75% of children will experience
a second event within 1 year of their
initial demyelinating attack.35,39,40
Although pediatric patients may experience more attacks early in their
disease, their recovery from attacks is
generally quite good, and patients are
rarely left with residual postattack physical disability. Accrual of progressive
physical disability unrelated to attacks
(secondary progressive MS) does occur in patients with pediatric-onset
disease, with about 50% of patients
reaching this stage 20 years after their
initial attack.35 As more children are
initiating disease-modifying therapy
early in their disease course, additional
long-term prospective studies are needed
to determine the impact of treatment
on disability in pediatric patients.
Despite the lack of physical disability,
more than half of children with MS are
www.ContinuumJournal.com
June 2016
Case 11-3
A previously healthy 12-year-old girl presented for evaluation in the setting of new binocular diplopia.
Her neurologic examination was notable for a left internuclear ophthalmoplegia, bilateral optic nerve
pallor, and hyperreflexia. Her visual acuity was normal. A brain MRI revealed a lesion in the pons in
addition to multiple periventricular and juxtacortical white matter lesions, with some of these
clinically silent lesions enhancing with gadolinium (Figure 11-4). Her spinal cord imaging was normal.
CSF studies were notable for normal cell counts, protein, and glucose. Oligoclonal bands were positive,
FIGURE 11-4
www.ContinuumJournal.com
909
Pediatric Demyelination
KEY POINTS
h Pediatric multiple
sclerosis is almost always
relapsing-remitting at
onset, and treatment
with first-line therapies is
recommended early. The
role of new agents is the
subject of clinical trials.
910
www.ContinuumJournal.com
June 2016
few years, the phenotype of NMO spectrum disorder has expanded, and patients have now been recognized to
have inflammatory lesions in brain regions where aquaporin-4 is highly expressed, such as the area postrema/
dorsal medulla and hypothalamus. Additionally, patients with clinical manifestations consistent with an NMO
spectrum disorder without antiY
aquaporin-4 seropositivity can now
be given a diagnosis of an NMO
spectrum disorder.
As is seen in some cases of MS, an
episode of ADEM can sometimes be
the first manifestation of an NMO spectrum disorder.50 Should a patient with
ADEM have antiYaquaporin-4 antibody
seropositivity, a diagnosis of an NMO
spectrum disorder should be strongly
considered. Further studies are needed
to determine whether these patients
are at high risk for relapse and if they
would benefit from preventive therapy.
Although many of the clinical and
radiographic feature of pediatric NMO
spectrum disorder are similar to adult
disease, differences include that a
higher proportion of children may have
monophasic disease51 and that the
finding of longitudinally extensive myelitis is less specific for an NMO spectrum disorder in children. With regard
to CSF findings, a pleocytosis is seen in
most children (either neutrophilic or
lymphocytic predominant) and can be
higher than 50 cells/mm3 in some
cases.52 CSF protein is also typically
elevated, and oligoclonal bands are
usually negative.51,52
The diagnostic criteria for NMO
spectrum disorder have been recently
updated and require further validation
in the pediatric population.5 The criteria are based on the presence of at
least one or two core clinical features
(depending on whether associated
antiYaquaporin-4 seropositivity exists),
which include optic neuritis, acute
KEY POINT
h Longitudinally extensive
spinal cord lesions can
be seen in all of the
pediatric acquired
demyelinating syndromes
and are not specific
for pediatric
neuromyelitis optica
spectrum disorders.
www.ContinuumJournal.com
911
Pediatric Demyelination
KEY POINT
h Relapses in neuromyelitis
optica spectrum
disorder tend to be
severe and render patients
at risk for relapse-related
disability. Rituximab,
azathioprine, and
mycophenolate mofetil
have all been used
successfully in children to
reduce relapse rates.
912
www.ContinuumJournal.com
June 2016
913
Pediatric Demyelination
914
www.ContinuumJournal.com
June 2016
www.ContinuumJournal.com
915