IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA IN RE: NOMINATION PETITION 3 DOCKET NO. ___- MD - 2016 OF ARMOND W. JAMES. z FOR THE REPUBLICAN NOMINATION ELECTION LAW MATTER FOR REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS FOR THE 13™ DISTRICT s IN THE REPUBLICAN PRIMARY OF APRIL 26, 2016 RULE AND NOW, this __ day of. 2016, upon consideration of the Petition to Set Aside the Nomination Petition of Armond W. James for the Republican Nomination for Representative in Congress for the 13" District for the Primary to be held on April 26, 2016 [the “Objection”], a Rule is granted, directed to Armond W. James [the “Respondent”] requiring Respondent to show cause why the prayer of the Objection should not be granted. Rule returnable the __ day of , 2016 at m, in the Room SiSsSSisssiessisissss eaten » Pennsylvania. Service of this Rule and the Objection shall be made within days upon the Commissioner of the Bureau of Commissions, Elections and Legislation, the Secretary of the Commonwealth and the Respondent by hand-delivery or overnight-delivery or mail. BY THE COURT:IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA IN RE: NOMINATION PETITION ‘ DOCKET NO. _-MD-2016 (OF ARMOND W. JAMES FOR THE REPUBLICAN NOMINATION FOR REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS FOR THE 13™ DISTRICT IN THE REPUBLICAN PRIMARY (OF APRIL 26, 2016 ELECTION LAW MATTER ORDER ‘AND NOW, this __ day of 2016, upon consideration of the Petition to Set Aside the Nomination Petition of Armond W. James for the Republican Nomination for Representative in Congress for the 13" District for the Primary to be held on April 26, 2016 Ithe “Petition”; itis ORDERED, that the Petition be, and the same hereby Is, GRANTED; and itis further ‘ORDERED, that the Objections to the Petition are SUSTAINED; and itis further ORDERED, that the Nomination Petition of Armond W. James for the Republican Nomination for Representative in Congress for the 13" District for the Primary to be held on April 26, 2016 be, and the same hereby is, STRICKEN and set aside in its entirety; ORDERED, that the Department of State is not to certify the name of Armond W. James for inclusion on the ballot in the Republican Primary of April 26, 2016 for the Office of Representative in Congress for the 13th District; and it is further ORDERED, that the appropriate officers of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania refer ten circulators [Joseph J. DeFelice, John Mastrone, Linda Gaynor, Christopher O'Connor, Ken Clipner, Gary Grisofi, Francis A. Rubino, Peter Gozzi, Jr, Lauren Dawn Kusznir and Elijah Myers}—plus others who violated their notarized claims, as per a due-diligence petition-review—to the Office of the Attorney General for possible fraudulent conduct. By the Court:IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA IN RE: NOMINATION PETITION OF ARMOND W. [AMES FOR THE REPUBLICAN NOMINATION FOR REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS FOR THE 13™ DISTRICT : IN THE REPUBLICAN PRIMARY OF APRIL 26, 2016 OCKET NO. MD - 2016 ELECTION LAW MATTER 902 G34 22 PETITION TO SET ASIDE THE NOMINATION PETITION OF ARMOND W. JAMES FOR THE REPUBLICAN NOMINATION FOR REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS FOR THE 134 DISTRICT THE REPUBLICAN PRIMARY OF APRIL. 26, 2016 as 60 To: ‘THE HONORABLE JUDGES OF THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA Petitioner Robert B. Sklaroff, M.D. [the “Petitioner”] files this Petition to Set Aside the Nomination Petition of Armond W. James for Representative in Congress for the 13 District in the Republican Primary of April 26, 2016 [the “Petition”] and, in support thereof, respectfully represents as follows: INTRODUCTION, PARTIES AND JURISDICTION 1. On April 26, 2016, a Primary Election will be held in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania [the “Primary”], at which Primary-registered voters of the Republican Party will be selecting, inter alia, a candidate to be the Party’s nominee for Representative in Congress for the 13% District in the General Election to be held on November 8, 2016 [the “General Election” 2. Petitioner is a duly-qualified and validly-registered and -enrolled elector of the Republican Party in Pennsylvania, and is a resident of Pennsylvania; his address is 1219 Fairacres Road, Rydal [Abington Township], Pennsylvania, 19046-2911, and he understands that the statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. 3. Respondent, Pedro A. Cortés, is the Secretary of the Commonwealth, whose office is located at 305 North Office Building, Harrisburg, PA 17120-0102. 4. __ Respondent, Armond W. James [“James"], who has given his address as 7405 Coventry Ave., Elkins Park, PA 19027-3401, filed on February 16, 2016, a Nomination Petition seeking to be listed on the Republican ballot in the Primary as a candidate for Representative in Congress for the 13 District in the General Election [the “Nomination Petition”). 5. The 87-page Nomination Petition purportedly has 1094 valid and eligible signature-lines; Page I of the Nomination Petition is attached hereto as Exhibit “A.”5. The 87-page Nomination Petition purportedly has 1094 valid and eligible signature-lines; Page | of the Nomination Petition is attached hereto as Exhibit “A. 6. Numerous [542] signature-lines in the Nomination Petition are invalid and/or ineligible; thus, as few as 552 signature-lines are valid and eligible [pending the vetting of this submission] 7. Original and exclusive jurisdiction over the subject matter of this Petition is vested in the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania by the provisions of the Pennsylvania Election Code [the “Election Code”], 25 P.S. § 2937, and the Judicial Code, 42 Pa.C.S.A. § 764, 8. The Pennsylvania Election Code, which governs the matters covered in this Petition, is found at 25 P.S. §§ 2600 er seg. [the “Election Code”]. OBJECTIONS TO NOMINATION PETITION 9. Pursuant to § 2872.1(12) of the Election Code, a candidate for a Political Party’s nomination for Representative in Congress for the 13" District must submit a nomination petition containing at least 1000 “valid signatures of registered and enrolled members of the proper party” in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, 10. In addition, §§ 2868 and 2869 of the Election Code specify the requirements for the circulation and signing of the Nomination Petition and the requisite circulator’s affidavit in order for it to be valid; the requirements include, inter alia, that each signer of the Nomination Petition must also personally sign his/her own name and personally complete the rest of the required information on the signature line. 11, __ Specifically, § 2868 notes that the signer “shall add his residence, giving city, borough or township, with street and number, if any, and shall legibly print his name and add the date of signing, expressed in words or numbers: Provided, however, That if the said political district named in the petition lies wholly within any city, borough or township, or is coextensive with same, it shall not be necessary for any signer of a nomination petition to state therein the city, borough or township of his residence.” 12. The 13" Congressional District does not lie wholly within the City of Philadelphia [because it encompasses sections of Montgomery County] and is not coextensive with same [because sections of the City of Philadelphia are within the 1* and 2"! Congressional District). 13, Therefore, each signer of the Nomination Petition must also personally sign his/her own name and personally complete the rest of the required information on the signature line, explicitly including “his residence, giving city, borough or township, with street and number, if any, and shall legibly print his name and add the date of signing, expressed in words or numbers.” 14. Section 2937 of the Election Code sets for the basis upon which a nomination petition can be challenged and contested. See In re Elliott, 362 A. 2d 438 (Pa, Commw. Ct. 1976), aff'd, 466 Pa. 463, 353 A.2d 446 (1976); In re Nomination Petition of Flaherty, 564 Pa. 671, 770 A 2d 327 (2001)15. _ Petitioner has reviewed the Nomination Petition [a process facilitated by personnel in the Office of the Philadelphia City Commissioner] and, based upon his knowledge, information and belief, avers that the Nomination Petition is invalid and subject to fatal defects (as described herein), that it does not comply with the requirements of the Election Code, and that it should be stricken and set aside. A. James's Nomination Petition Is Defective And Must Be Stricken Because It Fails To Obtain At Least 1000 Signatures From Registered And Enrolled Members Of The Republican Party In The 13" Congressional District. 16. The Nomination Petition is defective, for James failed to obtain at least 1000 signatures from registered and enrolled members of the Republican Party in the 13"* Congressional District. 17, Attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit “B” is a chart (in the format prescribed by the Court) which describes, with particularity, page-by-page and line-by-line, those signatures on each page of the Nomination Petition that are ineligible and the specific reason or reasons for the challenge of each signature; all are from Philadelphia County, the rationales for challenges of sulators are mainstreamed, and all data have been reformatted to fit onto legal-size [8 ¥ x 11] paper. 18. Without 1000 valid signatures from the 13 Congressional District, James's Nomination Petition fails to meet requirements in the Election Code; the Nomination Petition is, therefore, invalid and must be stricken, B. Objection Based Upon Signatures Accompanied By Additional Information That Appeat ‘To Have Been Written FRAUDULENTLY By One Individual 19, Signatures are supplemented by information that was added subsequently—a pattem that was not limited to signature-pairs [e.g., husband-wife]—and circulators duplicated both others’ and their own signatures; key-pages related thereto are attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit “C.” 20. Therefore, Elections Officials should assess the need for prosecuting circulators Joseph J DeFelice, John Mastrone, Linda Gaynor, Christopher ’Connor, Ken Clipner, Gary Grisofi, Francis A. Rubino, Peter Gozzi, Jr., Lauren Dawn Kusznir and Elijah Myers; a candid depiction of the behavior of Mr. DeFelice ef al. has been attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit “D.” 21. — Multiple additional entries include information that appears to have been written in the hand of another, noting their resemblance to contiguous entries; only identical handwriting was flagged, and excluded from the above designation were entries that could have been due to benign oversights. 22, As a result, Petitioner reserves the right to refer additional data to Elections Officials to assess the need to prosecute additional circulators, after any rehabilitation efforts have been completed. 23. _ Inthe interest of efficiency —and because so many signature-lines had been challenged— those entries that were not technically correct were excluded from the list of challenged entries if the signatures resembled those noted on the registration-form; encompassed were instances when the printed name of elector employed a nickname [e.g., Page 2 Line 28: “Jim” vs. “James”] or when the printed name of elector used abbreviations [e.g., Page 2 Line 17: “M. T. Ferraro”].EXHIBIT ACommonwealth of Pennsylvania DEPARTMENT OF STATE ‘Tvs ethan may be wed 10 submit for Nomination te Nae ot One Candidate for One Office Oty. 8. ese reer tte inrcton ge proved wth eon or eee eaten Sox compton of NOMINATION PETITION FOR: REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS DISTRICT NUMBER: 13th Congressional District ‘YEAR OF PRIMARY: 2016 CANDIDATE'S NAME(PRINT OR TYPE NAME}: Armond James OCCUPATION: Edvestor RESIDENTIAL STREET ADDRESS: 7405 Coventry Ave CITY, BOROUGH OR TWP.: Elkins Park COUNTY OF SIGNERS: PHILADELPHIA St PARTY OF SIGNERS: Republican ‘To the SECRETARY OF THE COMMONWEALTH: We, the undersigned, all of whom severally declare that we are qualified electors ofthe County and of the political district set forth above, that we ar reistered and enrolled members ofthe Political Party set forth above, and have signed no petition inconsistent. ‘do hereby petition the Secretary ofthe Commonwealth to have the cendidate whose Name, Occupation and Residence are 2s, set forth above, certified to the County Board of Elections of said County or Counties tn said District, tobe printad on the Primary Ballot of said Party, for the Year and Office set forth above. PLACE OF RESIDENCE SIGNATURE OF ELECTOR PRINTED NAME. [ House No. or City, Boro or DATE OF OF ELECTOR ‘Street or Road | City, Twp. | DATE OF Grrshine Mand 330 L Voila L834} 2/2 Yofgore any Heldaesan |7306 Rua Mul Mie lf aa Eliz Cotrs | 3206 [Gul fed st | Phil 126 |2-"-/2 Melivde Mulvernts B35 GCufort! |Pele (W% |2-FI6 Fehe Swe | 3399 \Gelfeel| Ade 1W5L| A F/L \Téadae Sullitey Ia lex /ad | he Linit |R-P 16 Rickak. Adem. \#3¢ Guifpad | th, KLle Deel Alans (3374 |Gulhea St | Pai 14136 [22-16 Allysam Balog, 3502 |Guiltord sf Pha. 193t | 2-8 ie 002 Konrehy sr] Pet me Rll 2708 ey MAS [Pie 42 ltl, i frect fintin hie 120s tetic Kr fraly [oval 53/>"| Su. (Goh Phbe (1 alo/p, Mich | S502] Lup’ | Phila (736 [3-ro10 emcees ME seesEXHIBIT BLegend *NR = Not Registered *NRA = Not Registered at Address NRDS = Not Registered on Date Signed oc = Out of County Ill legible +*LI0 Information Omitted “DUP Duplicate *IHA Line Information in Hand of Another NiL =Nickname/Initial PRI = Printed Signature *DCA Defective Circulator Affidavit SAC Signed After Circulator’s Affidavit Dated *Other = Any ground for objection not listed above Columns were omitted to compress the data presentation; only those items designated by “*” (vide supra) were invoked and, inasmuch as all challenges were relate to Philadelphia County, this redundant designation was rendered superfluous. Compression allowed for use of 8 ¥4 x 11 [rather than 8 4 x 14] paper without disturbing the width of the four extreme-right columns. Duplicate signatures were designated in ‘{}” in the “Other” column. If a signature-row had two illegible entries [precluding time-consuming ancillary searches}, further analysis was deferred; similarly, if signers [including circulators] were found not to be registered at a stated address, efforts were deferred to discern if those individuals were registered at different addresses. If the signatures matched, any other deviation [such as use of a nickname/initial or use of printing instead of script] was felt to have been mooted; recognized also was the potential for geriatric-age signers to have signatures that were at great-variance with the signatures that had been provided decades prior when registering. In these instances, signatures were flagged when it was difficult to identify any overlapping characters (particularly capital-letters}. Because, candidly, so many signature-lines were challenged, issuing a challenge was deferred ‘when it appeared that the signer had used abbreviations or nicknames [obviating the need for “tehabilitation” efforts to be initiated when the impact thereof would predictably become moot]; this applied to what would otherwise be obvious-errors [Page 2 Line 17, Page 5 Lines 1-3]. Also, individuals designated as “unregistered” included those who had attained an “inactive” status. The threshold to invalidate the petition had been crossed before signature-lines had been checked but, for the sake of completeness, every signature was compared with registration-info, and personnel in the Philadelphia [Voters] Commissioner Office were available over the weekend, ‘The “IHA” and “ILL” designations were denoted by an “*” when the focus was on the signature, rather than on provision of any ancillary data by an individual other than the signer. Further, when ancillary data provided in unitary handwriting was provided for a pair of signers, both were flagged [if unable to differentiate genuine vs, faux] unless signature-comparison suggested which of the signers [if not the circulator] had inserted the identifying address-info.x x + 2 a+ 7 mw 7% a 7z rd ’ om fz 6 7% ane eZ zt oe OT x ot ec mot sot T T T t T T T T T T t a8eg ve w x 4 “ st « a yenoursg a APOEEw S| SSEUPPY yenouag * a * or * 8 « s * ’ bin bis sin s/s s\n aqUDseq 4240 yoo vHI ana on TH WN UN 2Un wopafq0 40} spunoss 212805 “sapoo uonefqo au 4o puadaj e pue suon22sIp paeiap 40} Mojzq des suoRdasIC JBaysPeaIdS UONTDAIa BYR 295 “S “19 YBNOsUg y SuLLNjoD UI SYseW AUE 2yEWIOU OG “y {{o Uuinjoo) i189 ,124Ro aqu9Seq,, 842 UI YODe{go au Jo aunjeU JoeN ayy AyadS ‘pasn s1(430,, UUM 'E o> ayeudoudde ayp uy yBno.ia ¥y suunjoo 403 parea}pu Uojrewoyu} aya ex9jduo9 ‘aunod eudjapelyd Jo anneiap saBuayjey> Aluo sassecwooue yaayspeasdsAD/n {paxp saimeusis z} yesouiag yenouisg yen0wed, ‘uopetv-ON aenowad yenowea yesoulag yesowag, yenowsa D/s SIN s/s s24RO BqUDseq sao yoo vHI ads ‘wog92/g0 404 spunois 21 xyn . . 8 « z x ez . 8 . a + 9 st ve & oz aT a x 9t st € x or + og yenowag 62 az x 9% st v & w x ica x oz x 6t {201810 puz} yous Ue 8t yenowieg a yenowieg st aenoweg oT x eT b/s SIN S/S Jay aquosea 4240 yoo vHI dnd on TI WyN YN aun ‘won2@/q0 404 spunos5 aysoeds |{hued unouyun} 35 Uuad ,999h,, 51 S84PV ‘25 uuad ,959P,, 51 SS94PV ‘3S uuag ,999r,, 51 Ssauppy toe) (6r-) D/A Ds SIN s/s 4430 8quDs9q F240 yoo vHI tuonafqo 410} spunoip sy!ads dna on Ti vein uN aun et zt wt wt 11 11 1 WOLCLOVOLORRRAMMMMDDMMHADRGS a8eg. x x x x a x ‘ x * x x x x x x x of x ‘Allld ON, x + x x x ‘3S uuad ,959P, 51 SS91PY x x x x x x Din is S/N S/S 4aNO aquoseq 22480 vod val dnd on 1 ‘won2af9Q9 404 spunoss ayjads VEN uN aun 17 Te 1 oz oz oz oz oz oz oz oz or 6t 6r er 6r 6 er er 6 or 8. 8. ar a a or ot oT a et et a8eg4/0. 4/5 sin s/s ssaippe ajajduo2yy ssauppe ayajdwoouy ssauppe ayajdwoou ssauppe aieidwoouy ssauppe ayaidwoou) sseuppe ayajdwoouy ssaippe ayaidwoou ssauppe araidwoouy ssauppe araidwoouy ssauppe ayajdwoou ssauppe ayayd.woouy [gques0Uu8} asnods) id 30N) 4240 aqu2seq ki x x x « x x x x x xy x x x eds oweursiy) x 49430 vod HI luo122/a0 40) spunoss oy)veds dna on nm VEN x uN mw om sz 6 8 sz Ls 9 sz Ss st vst ad zt tT st zw uw TW woe oz we Wm a 9 we Ss we a 6 4 £ e mT 8 27 ou IZ = Iz woz 6 I aun a8egDIA Lo/s s/n s/s ssaappe aiajduioau ssaippe aiajduioau ssaippe ayajduioauy ssouppe ayajduoau ssaappe ayajduioaul ssaappe aajduioau ssaippe ayajduoau ssaippe ayajduioau ssoappe ayajduoau, ssaappe ayajduioaul ssaappe aajduioau ssaippe ayajduioau ssaappe aiaiduoauy ssaappe ayajduioauy Jayno aquosea yenowag s840 vod vHI uon2a{q0 40) spuncig 2yloads ana on 1 vuN aN aun az az az 8z az az az az a az 9z 92 9z 97 9% 92 92 92 sz sz sz sz sz sz sz sz sz sz sz sz sz st a8edsarep x 9 of sovep x Ss 0c savep x x + 08 sarep x € 0€ sarep x z of sarep x Te pouersisauun x or 6z pasaisisauun x st 6z pasaisiBaiun x ma 6 poseysifaiun x x a 62 paseysifaiun x 62 pateysi8a.un, x 62 paays/3auun, * wr 8 pasays}se.un x x 1 6 paseysi8aiun x ot Bz pavorsisasun x 6 8 paseysiouun, x 8 Be pesersi8auun x Le pavarsisaiun, x 9 6 paseysifaiun x S$ 6z pavo3siasun x + 67 pauaysiBauun x € 62 pauaisiBaiun, x 2 6 pasansisa1un x 1 6 x 1 8 x 6t Bz x st 8 yenowsa x ft 82 yenouiad x wm Bz . 1 8 x om 8 * 6 8% win v/s SIA s/s Jao aqunsea 420 yoo vHi dnd on Ti VN UN eu aed won}22{g0 404 spunoig a1jads* Ss ze x x ote {ve-te} x x oie x vw Te x x me * x x oO Te x 6 Te x Te yenoureg 1 oe x 9 Te x ze serep {ssauppe] x oof sarep [sseuppe] x St Of seep . we (Of serep ‘ & Of serep ‘ w Of serep x Te Of serep ‘ oof sevep . or Of sevep x ar OE sevep * x it Of serep x st of sarep x x st Of serep x x WOOF saxep x fof sarep x x zr (OE serep . 1 of savep x x or 8 sevep x 6 Of savep x x 8 08 savep x Loe BA be GA s/s sou10 aqu9se0 4310 yoo vHi dna on Tl WN YN aun aed tuonaafgo 404 spunoig ayrnadsag ve ve ve ve * x 9% . x stove * ve ve * 8. ccc recipe . sce - wz ee i ow ee ae oot Ee x St fe x €€ quapuadaput wee aie cues: * 8 * ets x a ze x te x wm ze x s¢ te x wm ote x fc 28 x zal te x wee x ow * sr ze . at . 1% te treed x st te * re DIA Dis SIN s/s JRO aqUDsea 49410 yoo vHI aa on Ti WuN UN euN Bed uon29{q0 10} spunoig 2yloadsIn o/s SIN sis yepowed 42430 aquasaq aysil st uelsy, « patsy) st ,uehuy, « x x 6 x x 4 x x 6 x x 6 x x x x x x 6 x x x x x x 6 2410 you vHI dna on 1won2afgQ 404 spunois a1yads 1 van x BNx v6 x x £ 68 UISIG UIION x 2 6 x tT 6 x vy 8 x St 8E * ve BE * & BE ‘ wz Be + Te Be . x oz oBe . x or Be . x sr BE . x a Be . oT BE . st ge . vt BE . et SE « wr Be C Tr 8€ x or Be . 6 8 x 8 BE * £8 x 9 BE * xs gE * bv 8E * £ 8 x x2 (88 aly-uo aumeuais ON ore x a oe * oe bi DIS Sin S/S 4430 aquaseq 2210 wod vHI dnd on Ti VN YN aun aBeg twoR22{G0 405 spunoip ayiseds9 tw st x + ow € ww tot {t-2eh x ww OTD {ot-ze} x et ty {ot-ce} x or oth ty Ww ty w te ov ov “ 9 s Luo aunqeusis OU x b € vr w Tt ov or g “£ s v T vt [payud] ov oF ov ov ov ov 6 aT 6 6e Tm 6 or GE 6 6 x a 6 ‘ 9 6 6 x § 6 D/A DIS sin S/S sau aqu2sed 420 yoo WHI dnd On TH VUN YN eu aBed uoj32@fq0 404 spunois aysoadsTRL, 51 SS94¥ x 1 0s x v 8y x st 8v x st ev x oe x 6 Sy x z sy x 1 8 x 6z ly x lb . wz ou x ww sdb x a ly UO aanjeUs}s OU st ly x x z ly x 6 ov yenowsa Lob yuo aumet x ot sp x 6 st x 8 st * “Sb ey x se x v eb x € ey * zo x tow x zt x tow . ow * 6 wy DIN DIS SIN. SIS sO. BGS somo yoo vHI dno on TI uN UN aun aBeg 1uon22/q0 404 spunoig sy!2adsus 4s “s us “s 9s 95 T $s 9 9s boss 9 8s s 9s 95 € 96 2 ss Tt o4s 6 8 ‘ 9 z T 5 yenoweg vs €s es es 5 Ts 1s or os 6 0s 8 os 4 os 9 s ’ si SsoupPY S2IpPY sissaippy s1Ss2uppy s1ssauppy TBL, $1 SSEUPPY TBZy $1 S2upPY os os 0s £05 Zz 0s un) aBeg Din Ds s/n s/s 40 yoo vHI dng o7 TI WuN UN at Luon22f@0 404 spunain sy)oadsD/A o/s {9s} {rvs} {evs} {e-vs) {tvs} s/n sis PUNSIp U! OU uaypias «8552, $1 SS2uPPY W4SIPAN £092, S1 SS@uPPY \USI@AN L097, $1 SS@4PPY Sian L097, $1 SSe4PV sian 2092, $1 Ss@4ppY sian L097, $1 SSe4pPV USI@AN L097, $1 SSS4PPY USI@AN L097, $1 SSe4pPY sian £097, $1 SSe4PY sien L097, $1 SSe4pPV Jano aquoseg Isp ul ou ‘i eun yenowag x 2240 vod WHI tuonz2lq 105 spunoss ayisads dna on m uN x aN AAMT NOROATHROMNERORHORONAMNOAMH or aun 89 89 “9 99 99 99 9 9 zs zs zs 19 19 og og og 09 og 6s 6s 6s 6s as 8s 8s 8S 8s as 8s 8s 8s us afeaL/h b/s SIN s/s SpLASIp UI JOU Joyo aqu2seq {y-och {e-00) {c-02 8 2-S9} {1-02 8 so} PISIP wl OU {sso {r-s9} x x Jno voa vi uuop 22/90 404 spunoip aypads dna on at 7 8 tT +e 9 8 et 8 a eB € 8 7 8 a & or ek st ge or ek a ek wr ee 1m or ee 6 & 8 ck 9 se be e & ze To ek ee Eieze SOL £ OL zoe coe Ss 69 £ 69 un aedDIN b/s s/n s/s 2au9 aquosea x x x Jay20 vod vHI 1a{qO 104 spunoD a4}93dS gna on nm vanEXHIBIT CCommonwealth of Pennsylvania DEPARTMENT OF STATE OFFICIAL USE ONLY penunnmaeetonin etn cece tore cc 1. Pease refer tothe instruction poge provided with hs petion for deta tformation about compiction of | "hi form. NOMINATION PETITION FOR: REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS DISTRICT NUMBER: 13th Congressional District YEAR OF PRIMARY: 2016 i CANDIDATE'S NAME(PRINT OR TYPE NAME): Armond James OCCUPATION: ceucator RESIDENTIAL STREET ADDRESS: 7405 Coventry Ave CITY, BOROUGH OR TWP.: Elkins Park COUNTY OF SIGNERS: PHILADELPHIA 51 PARTY OF SIGNERS: Republican ‘To the SECRETARY OF THE COMMONWEALTH: fe, the undersigned, all of whom severally declare that we are qualified electors of the County and ofthe political district set forth above tat we are regsered and ended memes of the Pola Party et forth above. ond hae Signed fo peation Reonsstent herewith, do hereby petition the Secretary of the Commonwealth to have the candidate whose Name, Occupation and Residence are as set forth above, certified to the County Board of Elections of said County or Counties in said District, to be printed on the Primary Ballot of said Party, for the Year and Office set forth above. LACE OF RESIDENCE House No. ‘or Road 7 Twn | ATES Phang Beek er “a2 Gas ln 6 hl6 Aatlony Cot [240 [Furie St | Phila PM 19136) Zl freee, la F DIB fase) Pk Pt (Aie| 2S Faucn act |t323 Oiporalie a a L47e Macrae Damancol 33271 Kegenble 25+ Geanen TOR [3792 | Furlea | Phila Pr eer 2-610 lfuce wl Phe. fa-txp dte/e Bawa Gres 3 9N0 Caedy "(US| o-th ‘faelos SGitess (2510 solo) Lala bo. 2-6-/b mas Sena BEA Man silrar® Sak E16 lies Move tever | 3437 [Scerea on netrurg | 2fe/ie (Zho. Th dae %29| blag h Zila tual ed Brion 303 | deeper |peile muse] afz/ae moms Res Ged hh Pe S1R27-7e ag or comme ENE + gagBEE scurueornacron a et teeters Sacro Vaomtiay Ravtrnd| apie crTom IE fankullv% be fied Phin Lee tM wl Eadsi-[Botr | feeidehe Pole [482 2274 Cnty 3346 Ba he ave ace F Ome ere ListéeS| by. io ROL Th/o- Reha Sd bvde | 3549 (oo floc BILE LocwiErneto pore ploper | Pius ab Keo Lemire sent |wesibe| Chia W290 -b 16 is FB nse bae9 iperriedl Cran 7256 3- P1E Cizeg Y| PEE rasa | Fta 26 2b Like Cie 2d eed LALL. s2_2bvo Une _Gualy dG herd Pella, $3 29 $e yl lh Pony Ud 22H Logie Teesdale | Phil (tsa J-7-fe LAGE [i Wika teckel [zara Teese Mul ites2 12-Fle Kn Aaemee 225 |Mewen |Phily Muse 2-116 Pagrunse Ar. tine _ 225 Wesper Vile (ie ei yf RdG2-t- le ee Lead Lauble,, Faee | Rewoler| file £0 £ -SELTHOF PERERA j encuaronsigagcownre | ‘ Pe ! COUNT OF Mic ss 1 co swsar jar alten thet tam acqunitied elector of the Commarea by pert on hae ‘eaeeet feet below; that the er esses the County cc ive ow ? Z : (ori se j ge sit seen Yb 27 22. s_ i Batno car ore: APs WDE ARAL SLES EH OTANED | a {SA 0 aCommonweaith of Pennsylvania DEPARTMENT OF STATE OFF-CIAL USE ONLY EA 2. tres Beso may be: 8. Pease rete te va tom sericiennttins rote tecremon || a, Pate provide wah this peetan fr dead NOMINATION PETTION FOR: REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS DISTRICT NUMBER: 132h Congressional District. YEAROF PRIMARY: 2036 CANDIDATE'S NAMEIPRINT OR TYPENAME}: Arion mes OCCUPATION: Levcetor RESIDENTIAL STREET ADDRESS: 7405 Coventry ave CITY, BOROUGH OR TWP.: tRne Park (COUNTY OF SIGNERS; PHILADIL PHA 51 PARTY OF SIGNERS: Republican To the SECRETARY OF THE COMMONWEALTH: ersigned, all of whom severally declare that we are qualified elector: of the County and of the political district set ‘registered and eovolled members of the Political Party sel forth above, and have signed ro petition consistent herewith, do hereby petit-on the Secretary of the Commonwealth to have the candidate whose Ksme, Ozeapation and Residence are as Set forth above, cerfies to the County Board at Elections of said Coury of Counties in said District, vs bs arnied en the Primery Ballot ‘Of said Party. for the Year and Office set forth above. a ol STILE nacoresete sionaruae oF exzcron purepnawe |, : OF ELECTOR Tease | Siento ond | Ch Boroarwp | ATES Lge tacch mays [Baar |CoJfenss tallion) Zefon| ON Gad: Jbl Monica.M. Conde S090" rain ex (Fh, 4i-le hed he Fada __| 3h alle b3-Ka Hv : mn binger lal L504 ee if fe Tey cack Th Jade PS fo psp alcanl aisi een eg MALI PAA Th Tes Wile Saha 3) [Bor bt, Fila [9/2 ae kei a soanaass Cewsmoreo Sd THUAN AMATEUR UTA, P° se as"PLACE OF RESIDENCE, House ne. T street or Roe | Gisy, Bora or Twr 3152 Winds k Phila © |edhau U.Ceus wffedlec Ih Lene Mi rSlaw Ene 5 a GAT. BY | Tomy icze | i Mad Cian Ks [Hy Li 6 Ktjby Ve ‘Dh D bere D.Aoatymsy S423 akloront! Pla 3A Gina Moat 3 Daibnrei se Prile Li senor eo — EIRCLLATOR SHOULD COMPLETE 1-5 BELOW ss ir that | rm 3 qualitien elector ofthe Commonwealth, dy teghstered and en & 23 rember of the pobucal party ton hat my residence sas St Torch below that “he thf Ee the same vt rc ther respective residences are correctly sated there ledge and bet, the sgrers are qualified ecto, ay reisered 1 ms pee Con. nd that they are siden Ine Canty peel oe ta Soca to and suntevsea before me this 77 aoe oust Lobssass Dede Shee Hoag 27 ¥‘Commonwealth of Pennsylvania DEPARTMENT OF STATE OFFICIAL USE ONLY ssp owes water et som coon ote | ENN | '5, Raat refer tote instruction poge provided wth ts petition for detald information about completion of ‘hi form. NONMATION PETITION FORE RERESEXTATVE N CONGRESS | DISTRICT RUMBER: 12h Congressional Dic YEAROF MARY: 206 CANDIDATE'S NAMERINT OR TYPENAME): Armond James ccUPATION: actor RESIOENTIAL STREET ADDRES: 7405 Coventry Ave CITY, BOROUGH OR TWP.: Elkins Park COUNTY OF SIGNERS: PHILADELPHIA 51 PARTY OF SIGNERS: Republican ‘To the SECRETARY OF THE COMMONWEALTH: We, the undersigned, oll of whom severally declare that we are qualified electors of the County and of the political district set {forth above, that we are registered and enrolled members of the Political Party set forth above, and have signed no petition inconsistent ‘herewith, do hereby petition the Secretary of the Commonwealth co have the candidate whose Name, Occupation and Residence are as set forth above, certified to the County Board of Elections of sald County or Counties in said District, to be printed on the Primary Ballot (of said Party, for the Year and Office set forth above. PLACE OF RESIDENCE @ SIGNATURE OF ELECTOR PRINTED NAME. : / louse No. or ‘or Twp. | DATE OF i OF ELECTOR use No. | Street or Rood |” City, Boroor Twp. | DATE OE Tenwve facaTt,|a¢28 |frethve. Be hb haf iw lay (aeaddle Vio a Cale. Hitet Mt 12.) nf ia Cl flcd th | ath Lenser puuM| Plot |CeLRAK Vibe Fe whtz & L Ate th °4 0004 Ce D Eg labxfe z aly f waelit | Toten, Dachol Sez Gin Nila fe ei { fino Denonce | Fora | Corus | Mer pa ldha/~ 2 Corattin Banded _| »- Yoaabee| 2063 | Coty | PhiiaPa |Sizhe TL Doidove [iA Kd olf: | Gite, A _| 2/3 le og) gfichs Conor dimefle Ble alate Lise A Che Oho, la--7e Pia |as3//e eked PHN blig((o AA Pee Zs :Page) 7) side 2 PLACE OF RESIDENCE = "or Twp, ] DATE OF OF ELECTOR House No. Stree or Road | “City, Boro or Twp, | O4TE OF Sy seevone [DID |. Rs 27E/ or 216 [Aim [Phila YA [2.ts-¢ Dominic Field [2813 [Fdvenon [Pil [245 i¢ Eh [lis Feater\dr oe hort Vp, Jo. [ald-13 6 4 IL ts be MOA p27 Ly 281 Edgenort Phila A lee as Aesmcotedan lal le-Aivrs®] pale lit falial 2. a 2 2 J a a 20. "AFFIDAVIT OF ORGULATOR — = COMMONWEALTH OF ms vAINA Cuaron sre Commere counry oF. ss noe ora) ht | ama ui ecto fhe Commarea dy regetered sd cred 5.2 meter of the pia arty | AO agCommonwealth of Pennsylvania DEPARTMENT OF STATE OFFICIAL USE ONLY sreront {0 0 ote ‘A This Petition may be wad to subi for Nomination the Name of One Candite fr One Oie Oly. 1, Plesse refer othe instruction poge provided withthe pain for dtalledlnfration some OWT FETONFOR RORESOTATNE COCA OST MBER: TNCngen Ot ves or may: 201 | CWODATES NMEA OF TENE dren es occurance PESBOCTULSTHEETADNESS: 75am Cry, oneueH ORTH hes a Cour or seers: von PROF SAE Tethe SATAN OFTHE coun anders a an sry ace lw ii ttf ate sen ee vt fran te en re a sel eel ty ne ea te ipa ere gr Sey oe are a fe an a Gee a set forth above, certified to the County Board of Elections of said County or Counties in said District, tobe printed on the Primary Ballot Of said Party, for the Year and Office set forth above. SIGHATURE OF ELECTOR PRINTED MAME. or or DATE OF ‘OF ELECTOR House Wo. | Street or Road | City, Boro or Twp. Mala asad Lulon -baAwee 60¢ bpd AAU Yoru dolihe VWhse 8 weiskol4295 Copren | Pes. Wrifie é [EpMoif, KOLA |ppoe | Quy Phile | p-23-%5 Lblbin ALovz-% 2 thane Kerra fh! 2 Arey | Phila Pa ein Phi 24 |2-n-t0 tli ta re Phila Pa [ene ?hila. PArage f _side2 T 8 prerers Bsr oF mton eee econ — [Roasts | Reeareas | Gy Booorton | UE Pe Panes feed | i148 | Fred” | Moto j-30-4 ME, Most na Figstuse [8224 |Pocesale| Pa tn [#3 gen WHE Fit Phra LB f-16 thee! Qorstoc Lt Gils \e-Sh-K Jona Qeley ge [30 |ceder | Ph a . 93%) |Reyhterct| ttn estig hres fous 932d Vaphrer | Prin | 2 tthe NhawelStevers [B06 |dghuny| Phila | atte Naw [2042 Garne | Phila |DIy Buon huevin od Puthdte| Phte |Z to Wiad | apedee lbmebhee | Ado ZL ; % pe |: niion tua [tye yas te | 7 lar se eses Aygiw) | fruits | bth tie af fe. Glo Ace! Gutile |TAnda |\t1e cs wes | Jul E, Saves | gost Same” | Dol zy VJohn Ziegler [tou |meirose [Pavia 4 1 ER OP CRATR SS comomeayg snp | carcuuaTor sHouto COMPLETE cowrvor Ph: fatelh Wa ss, presse eel do swear lr aff) tat am a quai lector of the Commonwealth, dl registered and eval member of the pla party the agree oe qunlied patel raat ny es aC ed a he eons n i tae yaar Toh Sour, ake res oe forme ptt sped these Jswomtoandsutecibed betoremetnie fs 4 ' rasa | leva bree mw Ae, : Teac Crear Ddrad thn [PPS 1 John estrone g Peed None af Grease Sin gu Yess abe =' Commonwealth of Pennsylvania i DEPARTMENT OF STATE OFFICIAL USE ONLY | ‘A This Petition may be used osu fr Nomination Ue Hae of One Candie for One Office Ont. 18, Plese refer to the trun page proved with th petton for dette information about completion of NOMINATION PETITION FOR: REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS DISTRICT NUMBER: 13th Congressional Distiet YEAR OF PRIMARY: 2016 | CANDIDATE'S NAMEIPRINT ORTYPENAMEY: Armond James eae COccUPATION: Educator RESIDENTIAL STREET ADDRESS: 7405 Coventry Ave CITY, BOROUGH OR TWP: Elkins Park CCOUNTY OF SIGNERS: PHILADELPHIA 51 PARTY OF SIONERS: Repubican To the SECRETARY OF THE COMMONWEALTH: We, the undersigned allo whom severly declare that we are qaliied electors ofthe County and of the politica trict set forth above Sat etre ragesred and ened terbers Of Une Police Party set frth above, and have signed no pation inconsstent eater, eta palin the Secretary of the Cammonwesith to have the candidate whose Name, Qcupation and Residence are a5 sel forth above, certified to te County Board of Elections of said County or Counties in said District, to be printed on the Primary Ballot Of said Party, for the Year and Office set forth above. PLACE OF RESIDENCE. PRINTED NAME OF ELECTOR House No. | Street or Road | City, Boroor Twp. | OATE OF pd Grty pean [poop loutly st| phlact( thr |i hohe [Yo Gebracts | $108 Hecwiet | hie Hcl asta Paksewst, | S103 fren | PIL [ache T (Jie Meribel) Philp —\-St-Le Vircr.s M Meuw| 9a Diss rig Lots oo Fh Cesgnwe ABKALS‘Commonwealth of Pennsylvania DEPARTMENT OF STATE OFFICIAL USE ONLY sre eo Petition maybe wre t submit for Meinl th em of ne Candidate fer One Ofice Only. m othe ec pap reed spat fe etd rman So eg NOMINATION PETITION FOR: REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS DISTRICT NUMBER: 13th Congressional Disc YEAROF PRIMARY: 2016 ‘CANDIDATE'S NANE(PRINT OR TYPE NAME): Armond James OCCUPATION: Educator RESIDENTIAL STREET ADORESS: 7405 Coventry Ave CTY, BOROUGH OR TWP.: Elkins Pak ‘COUNTY OF SIGNERS: PHILADELPHIA'S [PARTY OF SIGNERS: Republican ‘To the SECRETARY OF THE COMMONWEALTH: ‘undersigned, all of whom severally. {ot we ar quai lcs of the County and of te pia ati at forth above, that we are registered members of the Political Party set forth above, and have and Party 7 trent do herby petiloe th Searcy of he Comrannealth ta have the coniete whoac Same, Oczapabon and Rscence areas set forth above, certified to the County Board of Elections of said County or Counties in said District, to be printed on the Primary Ballot Of suid Party, for the Year and Office set forth above. Be ccunerorascro ree or eiecren eer DEKE) [5122 Stent bfo2. Lita Phil | aft, TG alae le GIL | abbey | oi[t- toi_|berwe | Phil + Este ri beck PHA Le vores I oe tetlal lLCommonwealth of Pennsyivania DEPARTMENT OF STATE aTTenTiON? ‘Th etn maybe used to ait for Nomination the Name of Oe Cae a ne Oe Oy 5. Reuter hints ae oc is pet eed fron sa colar [NOMINATION PETITION FOR: REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS, DISTRICT NUMBER: 13th Congressional District YEAR OF PRIMARY: 2016 ‘CANDIDATE'S NAME(PRINT OR TYPENAME}: Armond James OCCUPATION: Educator RESIDENTIAL STREET ADDRESS: 7405 Coventry Ave CITY, BOROUGH OR TWP.: Elkins Park ‘COUNTY OF SIGNERS: PHILADELPHIA 51 PARTY OF SIGNERS: Republican To the SECRETARY OF THE COMMONWEALTH: We, te undersigned al of whom severally declare that we ae unified electors of the County an ofthe pial Sirs forth above, that we are restered and envaled members of the Political Party set forth above, and have signed no petition inconsistent herewith, do hereby petition the Secretary ofthe Commonwealth to have the candidate whose Name, Occupation and Residence are 25 set forth above, certified to the County Berd of Elections of said County or Counties in said District, to be printed on the Primary Ballot (OF said Party, for the Year and Office set forth above. PLACE OF RESIDENCE PRINTED NAME = a DATE OF ‘OF ELECTOR House No. | Street or Road | City, Boroor Twp. | DATE OF (Cones sit fLadiodfn [F310 [Buss tre | Ando 79591 2 | lle Meey Crmeezy)| 1639 \usrer ST] Pyiee, Cherie alule Cesaveoegt [ito bpeckien en Meal px +lolre } “atus | 703 |erockphubt st fa A aig Ib zk Die “i | etl: filet 3 Soh Eeronate | Joha Bamocsn, [2% [cuit | 18h ag DSBE-C(S/1) PHILADELPHIA St wpa Se | NE mn “pie sice 1 EeCommonwealth of Pennsylvania ; DEPARTMENT OF STATE | orm isc omy Lnitinsemem ee comcameeteoe ney, | ATE ‘pte tamer ee eoc octet are = NOMMATION PETTION FOR: EPRESEATATE W CONGHESS | DISTRICT NUMBER: 1208 Congress Dict YEAROF Pear: 206 | CANDIDATE'S NAME(PRINT OR TYPE NAME): Armond James Mo occuPAmION: Ear RESDENTIL STREET ADRESS: 1405 Coeny Ae TY, BOROUGH OR TWP: Eins Park COUNTY OF SIGNERS: PHILADELPHIA 51 PARTY OF SIGNERS: Republican ‘To the SECRETARY OF THE COMMONWEALTH: the undersigned, all of whom severally declare that we are qualified electors ofthe County and of the political district sat ‘orth above, tat we ae reseed anc crated rertoers of Ue Foie Puts fort bone and ane sgn nn pation content herewith, do hereby petition the Secretary of the Commonwealth to have the candidate whose Name, and Residence are as set forth above, certified to the County Bord of Election of sald County of Counties in sald District, to be printad onthe Primary Ballot ‘of said Party, forthe Year and Office set forth above. a SIGNATURE OF ELECTOR PRINTED NAME, ~ ely, Borer Twp. | DATE GF fuk an |I/o7he ei Quewie||-26 w Price Fartin_1-25-b ws la ft 230 F* Se) rou ne, a3 | NK | Sz, 7650. (He SBE-SC15/13) PHRADELPHIA St Soomro: te HA HL 1‘Commonwealth of Pennsylvania DEPARTMENT OF STATE | OFFICIAL USE ONLY arrENTON! ‘A. This Petition maybe usd to submit for Nomination the Name of One Cana for ne Ofce ni, Bem refer tote sraon page provided with is petition for detailed information about compat ot NOMINATION PETITION FOR: REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS i DISTRICT NUMBER: 13th Congressional District YEAR OF PRIMARY: 2016 ‘CANDIDATE'S NAME(PRINT OR TYPE NAME}: Armond James SS OCCUPATION: Educator [RESIDENTIAL STREET ADDRESS: 7405 Coventry Ave CITY, BOROUGH OR TWP.: Elkins Park COUNTY OF SIGNERS: PHILADELPHIA 51 PARTY OF SIGNERS: Republican ‘To the SECRETARY OF THE COMMONWEALTH: Wie, the undersigned, all of whom severally declare that we are qualified electors ofthe County and of the potitical district set forth above, that we are registered and enrolled members of the Political Party set forth above, and heve signed no petition inconsistent herewith, do hereby petition the Secretary of the Commonwealth to have the candidate whose Name, Occupation and Residence are a5 Set forth above, certified to the County Board of Elections of said County or Counties in said District, to be printed on the Primary Ballot Of said Party, for the Year and Office set forth above. PLACE OF RESIDENCE | SIGNATURE OF ELECTOR PRINTED NAME. a DATE OF City, Boro or Twp. | DATE OF tfaghe \-24e Le2g-16 Lan4-lb «JL A A (OSBE-SC(5/13) PHILADELPHIA StCommonwealth of Pennsylvania DEPARTMENT OF STATE arrexmions ‘A Ths Petition may be used ist fr Nomiation the ame of One Cada for One Office On. {Phen refer tothe titcton ge proved wath is pete or eae oman oo option of DISTRICT NUMBER: 13th Congressional District NOMINATION PETITION FOR: REPRESENTATIVE IM CONGRESS ‘YEAR OF PRIMARY: 2016 [ CANDIDATE'S MANEPRIT OR TYPE NAME): Armond James ceupATON: eavctor RESDENTIL STREET ADORESS: 7405 Coventry Ave CY, nOROUGH OR TWP. Eins Prk COUNTY OF SENERS: PHMLADELPHA Si PARTY OF SIGHERS: Repbican To the SECRETARY OF THE COMMONWEALTH: ‘st hate red sir Pl ary oh ars, ee ans ttn caatet the Secretary of he Corset have the conchae wore fame, Oczna Reser ares io hereby titan he Se ‘eto ove, eerfid te tie ‘the County Board of Elections of said County or Counties in said District, to be printed on the Primary Ballot of said Party, for the Year and Office set forth above. HEE sounmeornecroe ene nae oF tscron Bian Teese ict Stredhia Levees Daur Koss nt lipzs deeper yam |1749 vans st Phi] g Vaslhe E Corre | 197 |Peoceoll ot{ Pk BIC Mite Gonz W412 _| Morreuse-| Phite Sy lori box h Do f Cozzi. Cc Chanles lor Bg oom bepariment ot tte aCommonwealth of Pennsyivania DEPARTMENT OF STATE arreamont ‘A Tas petiton may be ved wo sb for Noninalin he ame of One Candidate for One Qfce Oty 2 cr ret tector wa pen rere orton seat coin "as [NOMINATION PETITION FOR: REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS DISTRICT NUMBER: 13th Congressional District ‘YEAR OF PRIMARY: 2016 fennel —— comers amtih Milne aor sess cmrersems. navanns munrorsioms tion qr cocta oe coat We, the undersigned, all of whom severally declare that we are qualified eectors of the County and af the political istrict set setae iy maa syed tn nna om on % ame, Occupation set forth above, certified to te County Board of Elections of said County or Counties in said District, to be printed on the Primary Baftot Cf said Party, for the Year and Office set forth above. oreiecron | Hoel | Srentor od | Gy Boo or Twp. | AFECE itt tf Lite. 4 é fofiv V22lte I Bane [236 LIVE LAE Pile 13-1G Qei3-1 Bg eons vce OO Page SP siae 1Sete a electra | DISTRICT NUMBER: 13th Congressional District | YEAR OF PRIMARY: 2016 | CANDIDATE'S MAME(PRINT OR TYPE NAME): Armond James —___________ cameos oe ee eat (COUNTY OF SIGNERS: PHILADELPHIA 51 PARTY OF SIGNERS: Republican Sees eee the undersigned, all of whom severally declare that we are qualified electors of the County and of the political district set {orth abovy that we ae repsered and ccd enters of te Polteal Party se frth above, and hae signed no ptton Cenc dy pet se Secon ofthe Comvcreshdr us wether wtonn heen exerted este ‘whose Name, above, certified to the County Boerd of Elections of said County or Counties in said District, to be printed om the Primary Ballot of cal Prt, foe he Year an Office set fart above Be sommntorniscron Peceonee cic eee ea a (OF ELECTOR House No. | Street orRoed |” Gity, Boro or Twp. | DATE OF | Eine Dedjhe| 1g 7 Zinsog ered Lp, 4a Vreownes Deemtfal///7 |zivosene EA fo |i/sofie g| S| toto | Phdluchfohi_| [-30y chard Sikotate 1509 Benner $+. Phila, PA zjejie raise FUER | [L323 \pethe ed Fae hn Stems | 71S | Morkywe| Pride |2/rz/ry Nites Sedimotler| 190 Lueriequd Prita — lalisliy = RE 5/1) RADE CrowesCommonwealth of Pennsylvania DEPARTMENT OF STATE {Risen re itr mnt of O anit Oe es Oy 8. Please refer tthe stration page prodod with ths petiion for dette ifermaton bout compton of ‘his orm NOMINATION PETITION FOR: REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS DISTRICT NUMBER: 13th Congfessional District YEAR OF PRINARY: 2016 ‘CANDIDATE'S NAME(PRINT OR TYPE NAME}: Armond James OCCUPATION: Educator RESIDENTIAL STREET ADDRESS: 7405 Coventry Ave CITY, BOROUGH OR TWP.: Elkins Park. COUNTY OF SIGNERS: PHILADELPHIA 51 PARTY OF SIGNERS: Republican ‘To the SECRETARY OF THE COMMONWEALTH: {the undersigned, a of whom severally deciare that we are qualified electors of the County and of the political district set ‘orc tnt we ered oa ‘enrolled members of the Political Party set forth above, and have signed no petition ‘inconsistent ‘do hereby petition the Secretary of the Commonwealth to have Une candidate whose Name, Occupation and Residence are as Set forth above, certified to {te County Bosrd of Elections of std County or Counties in sld District, to be printed onthe Primary Ballot of said Party, for the Year and Office set forth ‘PLACE OF RESIDENCE ‘SIGHATURE OF ELECTOR PRINTED NAME, orezcron | oust: | SeestarRend | Guys roarTwp. DATEOF Elyeh Mocs | loko |Ran [Philadelphia | 2-8-1 Mewar Dz law) feo | C219 | Phlae. |2hr he | Cenarove Mlk 2x4 Goereagls| Phite- a6 yg teescoroymmvaares Pomoc Soe | s+ BEXHIBIT DRationale for Referral to Attorney General: Multiple Circulators In the world of blood-banking, it is recognized that social-pressure may prompt people to donate blood even when they know they harbor an illness that would preclude its use; that is why the ‘American Red Cross provides a coded/confidential check-off [for use either on-site or thereafter] if a donor would wish the blood-unit to be discarded [for whatever reason]. Similarly, it is not appropriate to penalize petition-signers for errors [even if they have been made knowingly] when provided an opportunity to respond favorably to a request; therefore, the focus must be trained Uupon a circulator who, for example, observes a spouse forging the name of an absent individual. ‘This onus is even more profoundly placed upon a circulator who knowingly signs multiple times, particularly recalling a notarized-pledge; this is not akin to discovering subsequently that a signer ‘was not an actively-registered Republican [who may not have sought a name-change after having been married] for, again, a compulsion to provide/acquire a signature-line may yield abbreviated questioning “in the moment.” Filling a page with obviously supplemented info violates the Code. This is why additional circulators were identified as having falsified the filing [John Mastrone, Linda Gaynor, Christopher O° Connor, and Ken Clipner]; Gestalt-Therapist isn’t needed to note “in-bulk” insertions therein [Page 4 Side 2, Page 19 Side 1, Page 25 Side 1, and Page 85 Page 1). ‘This misconduct is compounded further by Gary Grisofi; he twice acquired the signatures of Valerie Vitello [37-16 & 41-10] and Kody Rissiter [37-10 & 41-13]. He truly “trumped” these duplicates by, himself, signing-off twice [37-1 & 41-14]. Not to be outdone, Francis A. Rubino cnticed his wife [along with himself] to sign-off on triplicate petitions [Pages 65, 70 & 73], pethaps enticing an out-of-district relative to sign-on (again, duplicated), plus a fourth person. It appears that two circulators [Peter Gozzi, Jr. and Lauren Dawn Kusznir] traveled in-tandem, for how else can one explain the homology of their acquisition of five [5] identical signatures, indeed, on the very same day [Pages 54 & 58]? They did little to hide this aberrance, noting that the signatures appear in-sequence, almost as if one petition had been photostatted for a cohort. Included in this recitation is Elijah Myers, for it is doubtful he had forgotten he had signed on 1/30/2016 [13-3] when he signed his own petition on 2/8/2016 [11-1]. It is suspected that the limits-of-time precluded cross-ruffing other petitions, but the egregious nature of these abuses should suffice to suggest the need to probe the entire petition-acquisition process that occurred. Informal conversations with elections-personnel have suggested that this type of concer is not considered to be of sufficient priority to warrant devoting attention of law-enforcement personnel who are otherwise occupied pursuing perpetrators of more serious crimes. Yet, such corruption cannot be tolerated in a free society that reveres the ballot-box, and it is recalled that another case [of more than two decades ago] riddled with comparable felonies yielded the award of a victory to the apparent-loser in Pennsylvania’s First Senatorial District [coincidentally also in NE-Philly] following extensive federal-court litigation. In short, it is possible that the “tone” of what has ‘occurred was set by “the man at the top” but, regardless, all perpetrators should be probed.Rationale for Referral to Attorney General: Joseph J. DeFelice, Executive Director Philadelphia Republican Party Itis galling that approximately half of the signature-lines have been flagged as potentially-faulty, particularly when many technical violations were ignored if the signature appeared to be OK; concern with a circulator who appears not to be registered [Page 35] is the only borderline filing. Itis shocking that the circulators are not neophytes; indeed, Mr. DeFelice is an experienced and respected party-leader, whose ascendancy was welcomed as a reform that would turn-around a heretofore-ignored philosophical-force that exists in a polity that—just like most other major “American cities perpetuates problems with major quality-of-life decrements [crime/education]. Therefore, it is desirable to probe the six filings that he provided [#2, #3, #27, #36, #47 & #62] because they are emblematic of the unforced-errors that infest the political system which rarely are pursued [whether due to “prosecutorial discretion” or to a desire to maintain the status quo). Noting that he was armed, presumably, with street-lists and that he acquired signatures in his Northeast-Philly neighborhood, it seems to be inexcusable that he has abandoned any semblance of a role-model posture when he violated so many facets of his signed notarized statement. Consider incontrovertible evidence that “someone” wrote the identical information on lines 8/9 [see Page 2], presumably in his presence; either he feigned ignorance of a black-letter statute or he simply didn’t think such deviations therefrom would be highlighted [for whatever reason(s)]. ‘Also, how he could accept a scribbled-loop as a signature on line 10, and how he could accept spouses [presumably] forging signatures of absent individuals, this is just appalling. And he even approached a non-registered individual for anther scribbled signature on line 16, along with spouses who are Democrats on lines 26/27. Finally, challenging 14/20 signature-lines for their containing information that has been inserted “in the hand of another” [6 of which are signatures] reflects the possibility that he has set a “cultural” tone that other GOP-circulators mirrored. Along with the IHA-pattem, Page 3 has another unregistered voter plus [correctible]illegibility. ‘And Page 27 has two more unregistered voters [and 4 more IHA-violations]. Also, Page 36 has a Democrat [and 4 more IHA-violations]. Pages 47 and 62 have more IHA-violations, primarily of the fill-in-the-blanks variety. Obviously, this petition has not yet to have been vetted by Messrs. DeFelice and Jones, although its contents have resulted from delicate conversations with personnel in the offices of the Philadelphia Commissioner. But, overall, assuming these data are found to be valid, it would appear that a pattem of ignoring the Election Code has emerged; ‘elections [e.g., Stinson/Marks, also in NE-Philly] have been overturned in comparable situations. {Lam not an attorney, but I have gamered electoral experience during the past two decades as a GOP Committee-Person in Abington 7-2 [MontCo]; I have found myself on both “sides” of petition-challenge/validation events. I have completed this task assisted only by staffers despite having already tagged far more signature-lines than would be needed to achieve the overt-goal. This is viewed as a due-diligence project that should prompt people to “clean up their acts.”}IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA. IN RE: NOMINATION PETITION : DOCKET NO. 83- MD - 2016 OF ARMOND W. JAMES : FOR THE REPUBLICAN NOMINATION : ELECTION LAW MATTER FOR REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS FOR THE 13™ DISTRICT IN THE REPUBLICAN PRIMARY OF APRIL 26, 2016 ORDER TO COMPEL OR TO SHOW CAUSE AND NOW, this __ day of March, 2016, upon consideration of the Motion to Compel or to Show Cause Regarding the Failure of Armond W. James to Schedule a Meeting to Review His Nomination Petitions for Representative in Congress for the 13” District for the Primary to be held on April 26, 2016 {the “Motion” itis ORDERED, that Jones [either directly or through a representative] schedule this meeting immediately; and it is further ORDERED, that Jones be required—in the altemative—to justify, explain, or prove why he should not be sanctioned for having failed to schedule this meeting immediately. By the Court:IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA IN RE: NOMINATION PETITION : DOCKET NO. 83 - MD - 2016 OF ARMOND W. JAMES Zi FOR THE REPUBLICAN NOMINATION 5 ELECTION LAW MATTER FOR REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS. FOR THE 13™ DISTRICT IN THE REPUBLICAN PRIMARY OF APRIL 26, 2016 MOTION TO COMPEL OR TO SHOW CAUSE REGARDING ‘THE FAILURE OF ARMOND W. JAMES TO SCHEDULE A MEETING TO REVIEW HIS NOMINATION PETITIONS FOR REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS FOR THE 13" DISTRICT IN THE REPUBLICAN PRIMARY OF APRIL 26, 2016 TO: HONORABLE JUDGES OF COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA Petitioner Robert B. Sklaroff, M.D. [the “Petitioner” files this Motion [the “Motion” ]— pursuant to 231 Pa Code Rule 4019(@)(viii)—in follow-up of having submitted a timely [successfilly-amended due to a minor typographical error] Petition to Set Aside the ‘Nomination Petition of Armond W. James [“James”] for Representative in Congress for the 13" District in the Republican Primary of April 26, 2016 and, in support thereof, respectfully represents as follows: 1. That, the Per Curiam Court, “upon consideration of the petition to set aside nomination petition,” issued a “Scheduling and Case Management Order” on February 24, 2016 that mandated, because “signature-line challenges arc at-issuc,” that “Objector shall immediately arrange to meet with Candidate or Candidate’s representative and, if appropriate, with a SURE system operator, to review before the hearing each and every challenged signature-line” [§ 3.A.]. 2. That, on February 24, 2016, within hours of the receipt of this Order [via fax], this Order ‘was personally served upon James’ residence, as per the Certif was submitted a few hours hence [n.b., “approval requested” is on the PACFile website]. 3. That, because Joseph J. DeFelice, Esquire—Fxecutive Director of the Philadelphia Republican Party—has both circulated petitions for James and collected petitions circulated by others for James, Mr. DeFelice was sent copies [via e-mail attachment] of both the original filing [with inter alia a copy of the petitions] and the Amended Petition for Review [Which was subsequently approved]. cate of Service that, itself4. That this Order was served [pursuant to { 1.D.] along with an unambiguous request to schedule a meeting to review the signature-lines “immediately,” as per a letter that is attached hereto as Exhibit “A.” 5. That, to date, Petitioner has received any response to these documents from either James or any representative thereof [such as Mr. DeFelice]. WHEREFORE, the Plaintiff moves for prompt issuance of an Order compelling James either to schedule a meeting to review the signature-lines on his petition “immediately” or to show cause 1as to why he should not be sanctioned for having failed to schedule this meeting. Respectfully submitted, Robert B. Sklaroff, M.D. Prose 1219 Fairacres Road Rydal, Pennsylvania 19046-2911 [Abington] 215-333-4900 215-459-4877 215-333-2023 267-888-5116EXHIBIT ARobert B. Sklaroff, M.D., F.A.C.P. Medical Oncology/Hematology @ Telephone: (215) 333-4900 B Facsimile: (215) 333-2023 ‘Smylie Times Building - Suite #500-C 8001 Roosevelt Boulevard [ rsklaroff@gmail.com Philadelphia, PA 19152 ) February 24, 2016 To: Armond W. Jones Re: Petition Challenge As per the appended “Scheduling and Case Management Order,” please contact me “immediately” regarding your availability to meet @ Delaware Ave./Spring Garden St, as per 1 3.A, “to review..each and every challenged signature line.” | would anticipate that there will be an insufficient number of challenged signature lines that will be subject to rehabilitation, as per 9) 3.C; thus, itis anticipated that this process of creating 2 “stipulation of the Parties” will not be time-consuming, as per 113.8. Hf you would prefer that | communicate, in the future, with any representative you might choose to ¥ pref pr gt invoke [such as Joseph J. DeFelice, Esquire], please so-inform.IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA IN RE: NOMINATION PETITION : DOCKETNO.__- MD -2016 OF ARMOND W. JAMES FOR THE REPUBLICAN NOMINATION : ELECTION LAW MATTER FOR REPRESENTATIVE IN CONGRESS. FOR THE 13" DISTRICT IN THE REPUBLICAN PRIMARY OF APRIL 26, 2016 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Robert B. Sklaroff, M.D., do hereby certify that 1 caused a true and correct copy of the foregoing Petition to Set Aside the Nomination Petition of Armond W. James for the Republican Nomination for Representative in Congress for the 13" District for the Primary to be held on April 26, 2016, to be served upon the parties indicated below, this 22™ day of February, 2016, by hand-delivery [in the case of Mr. James] and by registered-letter [in the case of Messrs. Cortés and Marks] at the following addresses: Mr. Armond W. James 7405 Coventry Ave. Elkins Park, PA 19027-3401 {He was also provided a digital-media device with the Excel data.} Mr. Pedro A. Cortés, Secretary of the Commonwealth Pennsylvania Department of State 302 North Office Building Harrisburg, PA 17120-0102 Jonathan M, Marks ‘Commissioner of the Bureau of Commissions, Elections and Legislation Pennsylvania Department of State 210 North Office Building Harrisburg, PA 17120-0102 Robert B. Sklaroff, M.D. Prose 1219 Fairactes Road Rydal, Pennsylvania 19046-2911 [Abington] rsklaroffi@gmail.com Telephone: 215-333-4900 Telephone: 215-459-4877 Fax: 215-333-2023