Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
PLATFORMS
(MFP’S)
THEIR SOCIO –ECONOMIC IMPACT ON
RURAL LIVELIHOODS
BY
BERNICE AGYEKWENA
AUGUST 2009
-1-
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Introduction…………………………………………………………………3
1.1 Background of the Multifunctional Platform Programme………………5
1.2 What is a multifunctional platform………………………………………6
1.3 Which are the MFP beneficiary communities?...........................................6
2. How beneficiary communities experienced the MFP’s………………….....10
3. Impact of MFP on economic lives of beneficiaries………………………..25
3.1 Changnayili
3.2 Zosali
3.3 Chera
3.4 Nyerigiyili
3.5 Chalaam
4. Impact of MFP on academic lives of beneficiaries…………………………27
4.1 Changnayili
4.2 Zosali
4.3 Chera
4.4 Nyerigiyili
4.5 Chalaam
5. Impact of MFP on social lives of beneficiaries……………………………..28
5.1 Changnayili
5.2 Zosali
5.3 Chera
5.4 Nyerigiyili
5.5 Chalaam
6. A study of a Voggu-Botingli, a community without MFP …………………..30
6.1 Economic life
6.2 Academic life
6.3 Social life
7. Summary of findings…………………………………………………………...33
8. Recommendations……………………………………………………………..35
9. Conclusion……………………………………………………………………..37
10. Appendix……………………………………………………………………....38
-2-
‘The Energy available to man limits what he can do and influences what he will
do’ Fred Cottrell: Energy and Society
1.1 Introduction
With a landmass of 70, 383 square miles, the Northern Region is the largest
of the ten regions that make up the political divisions of Ghana, occupying a third
of the country’s
landmass. It is
bordered by the
Brong-Ahafo and
Volta regions to the
south and the Upper
East and Upper West
Regions to the north.
It also shares
boundaries with Togo
to the East and Ivory
Coast to the west.
Map of Ghana showing ten
political regions including the
Northern Region
With a population of just 374 comprising only 36 households Changnayili does not
meet the criteria under which rural communities are considered for the provision of
basic services such as electricity by Central government.
Zosali- Zosali is a farming community located 59 kilometres from Tamale on the
Bolgatanga road. Following an expression of interest in the Multifunctional
Platform Programme by Mrs Abigail Afishetu Dery, a member of the community,
New Energy conducted a study in the community to assess its viability in July
2006. It was considered for the programme because it was found to be viable.
The study showed that the community suffered from energy poverty, a
-7-
factor that had led to a drastic reduction in the cultivation of cassava, which was
once vibrant in the community, as a result of post –harvest losses suffered by
farmers due to lack of agro-processing facilities to process and preserve them. In
addition, the study revealed that children are often taken out of school to assist
their mothers to process their farm produce in other communities.
As at 2006, the community had a population of 1,255 with a total of 68
compounds. Children were found to constitute half of the population. The people
indulge in a myriad of economic activities including farming, trading, tailoring,
charcoal burning, masonry and transport business. However agriculture dominated
their income generating activities with their highest income originating from
sheanut picking and processing, farming, rice processing, and groundnut
processing.
The community’s primary school at the time of the study had enrolled 104
pupils, with boys constituting 40 percent and girls 60 percent. The school had an
attendance rate of 70 percent and a dropout rate of 10 percent. It was discovered
that lateness to school, absenteeism and drop out were caused by the heavy work
schedule of children in the area.
Chera- Chera is a small farming community with a population of only 165 as at
December 2006. It is located in the West Mamprusi District of the Northern Region
and is 135 kilometers from the regional capital. It is also 30 kilometres from
Walewale, the district capital and nearest source of electricity.
The women of Chera engage in a number of income generating activities,
with the most lucrative being farming, sheabutter processing and groundnut oil
extraction. Men in the community also derive their best incomes from farming,
animal rearing, charcoal burning, hunting and honey tapping.
When Mr Joseph Wuni, a farmer and member of the community approached
New Energy to be considered for the Multifunctional Platform Programme, a study
was conducted in the community to assess the viability of the project. The study
revealed that Chera had a large valley suitable for large scale rice cultivation but
processing was a big challenge for them since the community had no single
grinding mill. As at the time of the study, the applicant had 150 bags of unmilled
rice for sale from which he could have earned more money if he had been able to
process them. The community members, who were very enthusiastic about the
prospect of having their own milling facilities, expressed their willingness to
expand agro-processing activities once they had their own mill. They intended to
increase the quantity of weanimix produced from five to 20 bowls, triple rice
processing and increase the quantity of sheanuts and groundnuts that they process
into oil and butter.
The study also discovered that there was very little energy available to the
-8-
people for both domestic and business ventures, with each household spending an
average of 2.2 Ghana Cedis on dry cell batteries to power equipment such as radios
and tape recorders. The low population of the community was at first considered an
obstacle to the viability of the project but it was discovered that satellite
communities had a higher population of 2,155 which would serve as an additional
market for the project.
In the field of education, Chera had a nursery and primary school with a
population of 317 pupils which served it and other nearby communities.
Nyerigiyili- Nyerigiyili is situated 16 kilometres near Savelugu in the
Savelugu/Nanton District of the Northern region. It has a population of 300 people
comprising 25 households. The people are predominantly farmers and cultivate
cereals such as rice, maize, guinea corn and millet, tubers such as yam, legumes
such as beans and groundnuts with the major cash crop being sheanuts which is
picked from the sheanut tree that grows wild. The people also engage in poultry
keeping by rearing fowls and guinea fowls and also keep livestock such as goats,
sheep and cattle. The community lacks a lot of infrastructure can boast of only a
mosque while it shares a school with Sandu, a neighbouring community. However,
the Non-formal Education Division (NFED) has been running an adult literacy
programme at the community for about 15 years now which is attended by both
men and women in the community.
Nyerigiyili is an energy poor community which had no grinding mill prior to
participating in the Multifunctional Platform Programme. The nearest grinding mill
was situated at Sandu, three kilometers away. Inspite of this, community members
engaged in agro-processing activities such as rice and sheabutter processing and
sold the products at Savelugu market.
Following a request made by Mr Iddrissu Iddi, a farmer and a member of the
community to be a participant in the Multifunctional Platform Programme being
implemented in the region by New Energy, a number of studies were conducted in
the community. After satisfying the criteria for selection, Mr Iddi was admitted to
the programme thus making a grinding mill available to his community.
Challam- Challam is a predominantly farming community, a reality that caught the
attention of the Adventist Development and Relief Agency (ADRA) which assists
them with tractors to plough their fields. The major crops cultivated in the
community are rice, maize, yam, beans, groundnuts, millet, guinea corn and
several other crops suitable for the savanna climate. It has a population of 400
comprising 29 households and is situated in the Savelugu District. It is 18 miles
from Tamale. The dominant economic activities for women are sheabutter and rice
processing, groundnut oil extraction and paste making, as well as the sale of maize
flour. Men in the community derive their major income from farming, grain
-9-
banking, livestock keeping and the sale of meat (butchering).
The community lacks a lot of infrastructure and can boast of only a primary
school and a mosque. In addition, despite the fact that it is an agrarian community,
it has no facilities to process its agricultural produce. The Alzarsi women’s group
in the community applied to be part of the Multifunctional Platform Programme
after they were informed about it by the group’s secretary, Mr Abdulai Alhassan.
Following investigations conducted by New Energy, the community was
recommended for the programme and was provided with a platform in the year
2005.
- 12 -
Operating the multifunctional platform, however, has not always been
smooth sailing. “The machine consumes a lot of engine oil hence the running cost
is high. The rims are weak and the pumps are not good’, said Iddrissu Bambo, the
operator of the multifunctional platform at Chanayili.
Mr Bambo said anytime the machine broke down and they called on the
mechanic, who resided in Tamale, to come, he always delayed in coming to their
assistance. He said the machine had broken down for the past two weeks now but
the mechanic had failed to show up even though he had been informed. He said
despite the fact that he and his assistant, Awal Sulemana, have been operating the
machine ever since it was installed, they have no knowledge about how to repair it.
He therefore called on New Energy to consider training the operators themselves to
repair the
machines when
they break down.
Collaborating the
concern raised by
the operator about
delays in repairing
the multifunctional
platform when it
breaks down, Mr
Ibrahim said,
“recently we had a
breakdown and the
whole class was
deserted because
most of the girls
had gone to Operators idle at the multifunctional platform at changnayili because it has broken
Tamale to mill down
maize and rice for
an impending naming ceremony. The boys capitalized on that and did not come to
school while the little girls were also taken along to nurse their siblings. One
remarkable thing about this village is their community spirit. Anytime there is a
festive occasion all the children are mobilized to work”
Mr Ibrahim said because of the positive impact that the multifunctional
platform has had on their lives, all are concerned about its maintenance. “We pay a
lot of attention to the mill. We contribute money to repair it. Even children are
ready to contribute money to buy fuel to run the mill because they know that if it is
functioning well, they will not have to travel long distances to mill their farm
- 13 -
produce”. He appealed to New Energy to help the community acquire a new
battery for their solar lamp, saying, “We have no lights. The solar lamp has broken
down and the battery will cost us 600, 00 Ghana Cedis.
- 15 -
Contrary to what the teachers said, some of the school pupils who were
interviewed said the presence of the mill has had a positive impact on their
academic lives. Fatimah Alhassan, a 16 year old pupil, said, “Before the mill came,
I used to pound sheanuts in the afternoon after school twice every week. I used to
wish I would be free to play and do other things. But now that the mill is here, I no
longer pound but I only help my mother to carry the sheanuts to the mill.”
Miss Alhassan said her mother now has access to micro-credit, because she
has expanded her business. “She (mother) gives me pocket money. She buys me
more books than before; she buys my uniform and pays my schools fees. I now use
the time for pounding sheanuts in the afternoon to do my homework which I used
to do in the night”.
Eleven year old Iddi Alhassan Sayibu, another pupil of the school, was also
happy about the
presence of the mill at
Zosali “I used to ride to
Kadia after school hours
to grind maize. But
since the mill came, I
have never been sent to
mill maize. My mother
does it.” Master Sayibu
said his mother’s
business has expanded.
“She used to make
kpilikpili, (a local pastry
made from groundnut
paste after the oil has
Women busily crushing and milling sheanuts
been extracted) twice a
week. Now she does it
always unless she runs out of groundnuts”.
He said the presence of the mill has impacted on his academic life. “My
books were not more than ten. Now, I have more than ten books. She bought me a
dagbani text book, pens and sandals. I get pocket money of 50 Ghana pesewas
every day. The mill has been a blessing to all of us”.
Mr. Alidu Tia, a farmer who is also a part time operator of the mill at Zosali,
said the mill enjoys a monopoly when it comes to the extraction of sheabutter at
Zosali and its satellite communities. “There are other mills but they have no
crusher. They have stopped grinding sheabutter and grind only maize.
Mr. Tia was quick to point out that the influx of women to his mill to mill
- 16 -
their sheabutter was not just because of the crusher but the fact that the mill is
always in good condition. “The quality of work depends on the sharpness of the
blades and the strength of the engine. I sharpen my grinding blades regularly”.
On the running of the multifunctional platform, he said he uses two and a
half gallons of engine oil, with each gallon costing 16 Ghana Cedis which he
changes every 30 days. He also uses a maximum of 15 gallons of diesel a month
which he buys at the cost of five Ghana cedis, 20 pesewas. Hence, in a month, M r
Tia spends a total of one hundred and eighteen Ghana cedis on fuel to run the
multifunctional platform. He also charges 30 Ghana pesewas for milling a bowl of
maize, millet or guinea corn and three Ghana cedis for crushing and milling a basin
of sheanuts. He described his rates as standard since all the mills in the vicinity
charge the same rates.
Mr Tia, who described the milling business as profitable, said he earns 10
Ghana cedis a month from working in the mill which belongs to his sister.
- 17 -
Those who could not afford the fare had to walk the 18 kilometres to
Walewale, at times, only to be told that the mill has broken down. Those who were
desperately in need of a mill sometimes spent as much as three days at Walewale,
waiting for a grinding mill to be repaired for them to mill their grain.
The benefits of siting a multifunctional at Chera did not just end at the
digging of a hand-dug for Madam Wuni. “I now use the money I have been saving
on transport as well as the additional profits I have realized as a result of the
expansion of my business to care myself and my children. I have increased the
amount of food I give to my children and I can now provide them with pocket
money for school. I also use the time that I have saved from travelling to other
communities to work on my farm”.
Madam Wuni is
engaged in farming as
well as agro-processing.
“I am a farmer. I also
process rice,
groundnuts and
sheabutter. I have
extended my business
to the rearing of small
ruminants such as sheep
and goats. I also have a
piggery.”
Recounting some of her
experiences at the time
when her community
did not have access to a
mill, she said, “At times
Talata dug a well following the establishment of a multifunctional platform we would travel to
to expand her business Walewale, stay in the
queue until eight pm
only to be told that the fuel is finished or the mill has broken down. This means no
food for that day. At times, we were forced to venture into strange communities in
search of a grinding mill”
Mariama Amidu, a widow, said because she could not afford to pay the fare
to Walewale she used to walk the 18 miles to the grinding mill, carrying her
sheanuts on her head.”But now, after crushing the sheanuts at home, we just bring
it here to the mill to grind it”. Madam Amidu said it takes her about three days to
crush a bag of sheanuts alone. Apart from sheanut extraction, she also brews pito,
- 18 -
processes rice and farms vegetables. She said as a result of the expansion of her
business, her children now eat well and she can afford to give her children and
grandchildren pocket money for school.
Talata Philip, a soap and tie & dye maker said she used to abandon her
business to travel in search of a grinding mill to grind her grains. But now that the
mill is close, she can schedule her activities so that milling grain does not interfere
with her business.
Thirteen year old Edith Kwaku who used to foot to school now rides to
school, thanks to the expansion of her mother’s kenkey business as a result of the
multifunctional platform. “My mother now uses a bag of maize in just three days.
Formerly, she used to prepare just three bowls of maize a day. I used to send the
maize to neighbouring communities to grind for my mother. Anytime it rained, I
got soaked and there were times when I even slipped and fell”.
Kassinu Zaaka, also 13, remembered how his mother used to struggle to
process rice manually each time there was the need for communal labour; “the rice
produced then was of a lesser quality but the rice huller makes the rice very white,
like polished rice.” Master Zaaka also said “Before the mill, my mother used to
make just a small quantity of sheabutter, now she makes more so she has more
money and has bought me a bicycle, a school bag and a uniform. She also gives me
pocket money voluntarily.” He observed that since the arrival of the
multifunctional platform at the village, it has increased the amount of food
available thus improving upon food security in the village: “There used to be
scarcity of rice and sheabutter but now we have them in abundance.”
Afishetu Imoro, 13, said she used to travel to Walewale to process rice for
her mother. “I used to miss classes anytime I was sent to walewale because I will
come back late. My mother now processes two to three bags of rice a month
instead of one bag.” Miss Imoro said the mill has not only improved upon the
financial situation of her family, with her mother now providing her with a daily
pocket money of one Ghana cedi instead of 50 Ghana pesewas but has also eased
the burden of neighbouring communities who now come to Chera to mill their
farm produce.
Iddrissu Martinu, 13, also recalled how his mother and other women in the
community used to pound maize until their hands got swollen, saying “The
presence of the mill has eased the burden of the body”. He said taking late or
irregular meals among community members is now a thing of the past and his
family now dines before eight pm.
Teachers of Chera District Assembly primary school, which serves the
Chera, Yama and Broba communities were of the view that the establishment of the
multifunctional platform at Chera has impacted positively on education since most
- 19 -
mothers used to send the pupils to Walewale to mill grain during classes hours
which affected their academic performance.
Mr. Ishmael K. Dabre, a teacher at the school, said lateness to school and
absenteeism among pupils, especially the girls, has reduced drastically. Besides
parents now feed their children better than they used to in the past and also provide
them with pocket money to buy food when they are hungry. He said several food
vendors now sell food at the school so if pupils are not able to eat at home before
coming to school, they can buy food at school. “Hence, our pupils now eat well
and this has led to better concentration at school. Most of them used to suffer from
low concentration because of hunger”.
“The pupils now have enough time to study. Most of the girls, especially
used to use mortars and pestles to pound grains for hours an end. But they now
invest that time in doing their homework”, Mr Dabre said.
He said the solar component of the multifunctional platform was an added
boost to the community since they used to find it difficult to charge their mobile
phones. “We now charge our mobiles free of charge.” He appealed to the UNDP to
assist the school with a solar battery that can power computers so that they can take
part in the ICT programme that has been introduced for all schools by the Ministry
of education. He was confident that if the school had access to solar electricity
some NGO’s would be ready to assist them with computers.
Mr. Fuseini Abdul Rahman, also a teacher, said the arrival of the mill has led
to a reduction in the price of rice, maize flour, groundnut oil and sheabutter while
Mr. Daniel Sebiyan, another teacher, said he no longer has to travel to Walewale to
buy rice since he can find the same quality of rice at Chera. Besides, anytime he
runs out of cash, he can buy rice from women in the community on credit,
something he cannot do with the women of Walewale.
Mr Joseph Wuni, a rice farmer and owner of the Multifunctional Platform,
said three main factors pushed him into signing up for the multifunctional platform
project with New Energy; the need to process his own rice after harvesting, a
cultural practice among people in the community that required that people be
served with a traditional dish made from maize flour before burying a deceased
elderly person and the need to find a solution to the rampant quarrels between
farmers and owners of piggeries during the farming season.
He said “I was forced to always travel to Walewale to process my rice and
maize and on one occasion I even lost half a bag of rice which I left at the mill
because there was no electricity for three days.”
He said when he became aware of the Multifunctional Platform Programme
at New Energy, he expressed interest and after carrying out a needs assessment at
the community, he was put on the programme. “Since then, my travelling out of
- 20 -
my community do grind my produce has ceased”
He said their traditional funeral rites for the elderly which demanded that a
sheep be slaughtered in addition to the preparation of tuo zaafi or T.Z, a meal made
from millet or maize flour to be distributed to community members before the
corpse can be buried had proved to be burdensome in a community that had no
access to milling facilities. The presence of the mill has come to make the practice
more bearable.
Mr. Wuni said he normally stores the chaff after the rice has been processed
for the feeding of pigs, goats and sheep. This he said has helped to forstall the
situation where keepers of livestock and farmers were always at loggerheads
because the former had allowed their animals to graze on their farms.
He described the milling business as cost effective; “if we mill a great deal
of rice, we make profit. However, hard dried maize does not give so much profit
because one has to mill it over and over again for at least three times. When this
happens, more fuel is consumed but the women still pay the same price. Millet and
guinea corn pose no threat to our profits because they are soft and are milled only
once”.
“African culture also allows blood relations a right to free services hence
members of the extended family expect free services which affects profit”, He
explained.
Mr Wuni said the multifunctional platform also breaks down very often; “the
attachments to the platform, the corn mill and the rice processor frequently break
down. Some parts of the machine have also cracked several times and have had to
be welded twice”. He said it would cost 70 Ghana cedis to buy a new part to
replace the cracked one but he was afraid to do so because he was not sure of the
quality. In addition, the bottom knot to the machine always breaks down.
He said the frequent breakdowns as well as recent increments in fuel prices
have increased the running cost of the mill. However, attempts at increasing the
rates to make the business more cost effective are strongly resisted by the
community members.
Isaac Wuni, son of Mr Wuni and full time operator of the multifunctional
platform, said he always travels to Walewale to buy diesel at six Ghana cedis per
gallon and engine oil at 13 Ghana cedis per gallon to run the machine. He said he
uses a gallon and a litre of engine oil in a month, after which the oil is drained
while he uses twelve gallons of diesel in a week, bringing the total cost of fuel to
37.88 Ghana cedis.
- 21 -
2.4 Lack of credit facilities prevent women of Nyerigiyili from taking full
advantage of multifunctional platform for economic activities.
Following the establishment of a multifunctional platform at Nyerigiyili, a
village near Savelugu, the women who hitherto were not engaged in agribusiness
have taken up some income generating activities in agro-processing. However,
they are of the view that the lack of credit facilities to complement the
establishment of the platform has impeded their efforts at going into big time agro-
processing.
Alhassan Iddrissu, a farmer and member of the community said since the
installation of the platform, women in the community have taken up a lot of
income generating activities such as rice and sheabutter processing and the
extraction of oil from groundnuts. However, due to limited capital, profits realized
from such ventures are minimal and women can only afford to give their children
pocket money for school.
“We eat unpalatable soup
because the money they
make is not even enough to
buy meat for soup”, he said.
Rachia Mahamadu,
who processes sheanuts for
sale supported Mr Iddrissu’s
assertion that their capital is
too small. “Currently, I
process only eight bowls of
sheanuts at a time. I could
Women of Nyerigiyili want credit facilities
have processed one bag if I
had enough capital. Besides,
I have no money to buy a
roaster. I suffer a lot from the heat from roasting sheanuts manually”. Madam
Mahamadu said she makes a profit equivalent to the price of two bowls for every
eight bowls of sheanuts she processes and she spends it entirely on her children.
Fati Iddrissu, who processes 20 bowls of rice for sale said she normally
realizes two bowls as profit after sales. “I either cook it for the children to eat or I
sell it and use the proceeds to cater for their needs”.
Maraima Abdul Rahmani said she normally buys 20 bowls of groundnuts on
credit and after processing it, she is able to extract 18 bottles of oil from it and uses
the by- product to prepare kpilikpili, a local pastry for sale. “From this, I am able to
pay for the cost of the groundnuts after which I use what is left to give to my
children to go to school”.
- 22 -
However, members of the community agreed that despite the limitations
imposed on their income generating ventures by inadequate capital, the
multifunctional platform has a source of relief to them in several spheres of life.
“Before the mill came, we used to go to the farm expecting our wives to
bring us food to eat and they go will and spend the whole day, if not days at the
mill. When this happens, we do not get food to eat and it affects our farming
activities. Also, at times when you want women to assist you with planting, they
are not around because they have gone to look for a grinding mill”, Mr. Iddrissu
explained.
He said women from the community used to go to Savelugu or travel 22
miles to Tamale to mill their produce. At times, young men assist by picking the
produce on a bicycle but a strong woman walks all the way to Savelugu then picks
a vehicle to Tamale if she cannot get a mill there.
Mr Osmana Iddrissu, a farmer and part time operator of the mill which
belongs to his father said he always buys fuel for running the machine from
savelugu, where one gallon of engine oil sells at 16 Ghana cedis while a gallon of
diesel sells at five Ghana cedis, 10 pesewas. He said he uses two gallons of engine
oil and 60 gallons of diesel a month bringing the monthly total cost of running the
platform to 33.8 Ghana cedis. He however admitted that work at the mill is not
always uniform but varies. “We can use over two gallons of diesel on a hard
working day, a gallon when the work is not much and there are times when we
have no work at all”.
On the charges, Mr Iddrisu said the normal charge for a bowl of maize is 20
Ghana pesewas but they often reduce it to 15, especially for soaked maize, guinea
corn and millet because people are poor. He said it is a business technique to
encourage people to choose his mill above other mills in the vicinity. Milling a
bowl of groundnuts is also pegged at 15 Ghana pesewas while a medium sized pan
of sheanuts and a big pan of sheanuts cost one Ghana cedi, fifty pesewas and two
Ghana cedis respectively. The multifunctional platform , he said, enjoys a
comparative advantage since people from surrounding villages also patronize it
while people from his village never go anywhere else to mill.
Mr Iddrissu iddi said he was motivated to go in for in for the Multifunctional
Platform Programme under the auspices of New Energy because of the way his
wives suffered in securing the services of a grinding mill, especially in times when
he had to organize communal labour for farming activities. “There were times
when I was forced to postpone such activities because my wives could not access a
mill to grind flour and rice for us to feed those I had invited”.
He said he was happy that the mill had not only brought relief to his wives
but has also benefited women in the village and nearby communities. He identified
- 23 -
the main obstacle to the efficient running of the multifunctional platform as
inability to access the right spare parts. “The mill wears out and some parts need to
be replaced. The rice huller broke down a number of times and the parts needed to
be replaced. I also had to buy a new engine block to replace the engine.”
Mr Iddrissu said he used profit accrued from running the mill to cater for the
expenses incurred by purchasing new spare parts which normally depleted his
profits. He also sited the issue of people wanting free services from the mill
because of blood relations and familiarity with him as another problem that has
affected the amount of profit made from running the mill.
- 25 -
• Money used to rent bicycles or for vehicle fares to Tamale now used to cater
for other pressing needs.
• Has led to the reduction of the price of rice.
• Women who sell cooked food such as rice have expanded their businesses
because they can afford to cook everyday because they can mill their rice as
often as possible.
• Has abolished losses associated with accidents incurred while traveling to
Tamale to mill farm produce.
- 30 -
The community has no school but had an active adult literacy class that was
established two years before a pre-study was conducted on it by New Energy
following their interest in the Multifunctional Platform Programme in October
2006. Members of the community complained that, because they had no mill in the
village, their farming activities have been undermined.
“If you do not want to stop your child from going to school, you have to stop
farming and go and grind your produce. But if the child goes to the grinding mill,
then he cannot go to school” said Sharatu Alhassan who processes rice for sale at
Gbullung and Tolon. Madam sharatu disclosed that, only 40 percent of the rice
produced in the area is processed for sale. “If we had a huller, we could have
processed 70 percent thus increasing our profits”. She disclosed that her business is
not flourishing due to
lack of a mill;
“presently, I process
only one bag of rice
from which I make
between two to three
Ghana cedis as
profit”. Hence, she
can afford to give her
three children only 20
Ghana pesewas as
pocket money for
school. She said if she
could make more
money from
Teenage girls returning to Voggu-Botingyili after milling their produce in processing rice, she
another community would have liked to
give her children a
nutritious meal before they go to school, give them more pocket money and give
them a good lunch. “I will also like to buy bicycles for them “, she added.
Amina Mahama, who processes sheanuts for sale, said she is forced to
process only a small quantity due to the distance she has to travel to the grinding
mill. “Sheanuts cannot be carried on a bicycle so I process only 20 bowls which
requires two people to carry it. I make about two Ghana cedis profit or more
depending on the quantity of sheabutter”. She recounted an incident last year when
she slipped and fell because it had rained and the ground was slippery. “Everything
got mixed up with the muddy water and I could retrieve nothing.”
“At times, the children get accidents with their bikes and lose all their grains.
- 31 -
If we had a cornmill, such things would not happen”, said Saudatu Yussif, who
processes groundnuts for sale. “I process only ten bowls of groundnuts at a time
from which I make a profit of four Ghana cedis. If Voggu-Botingli had a mill, I
would have increased it to 15 bowls.”
Presently members of the community spend six hours to go to Gbullung to
mill their farm produce and come back home. If they are lucky enough to have a
bike, it may take them three to four hours to make a round trip to Gbullung.
“At times, we go to bed hungry because we cannot mill our flour. If the
machine breaks down, we leave our maize at the mill, come back home and sleep”,
said Madam Alhassan. She said apart from expanding her business, she would have
also increased the size of her farm if Vorgu-Botingli had a mill; “We spend a lot of
time on travelling to other communities to mill our grain and it is affecting our
farming activities”. Madam Yussif on the other hand said she would have used any
extra time resulting from the introduction of a multifunctional platform in the
community to look for extra firewood.
From the scenario enumerated above, it can be seen that certain economic,
social and academic issues arise from the lack of a grinding mill at Voggu
Botingyili. It is therefore necessary to document these issues.
7. Summary of Findings
Information contained in the preceding pages give evidence that the
Multifunctional Platform Programme has had economic, academic and social
impacts on the lives of beneficiary communities. The degree of this impact,
however, was found to vary from one community to another. Three factors appear
to govern how multifunctional platforms impact on beneficiary communities and
thus account for this variation. These are:
• Prevailing conditions or circumstances at the beneficiary community at
the time when the multifunctional platform was introduced- Changnayili
appears to have reaped more social benefits than the other communities,
since the multifunctional platform even became a unifying factor for them
and the neighbouring village of Pagazaa. This is due to two prevailing
circumstances; firstly, Changnayili was at loggerheads with his neighbor,
secondly, Pagazaa, which used to have access to a grinding mill no longer
had because it had broken down beyond repairs thus creating a situation
where the grinding came to play this role of a peacemaker. Another
prevailing condition at Changnayili that led to more social benefits was the
fact that women were unwilling to marry into that community because they
were energy poor. Again, the mill came to create a more favourable situation
leading to more bachelors getting married.
In addition, because Zosali already had a vast number of sheanut trees that
- 33 -
supported sheanut picking, the introduction of energy simply elevated the
community from a predominantly sheanut picking community to a sheanut
processing one. Thus, the prevailing circumstances at Zosali made this
economic achievement possible.
• How prepared the beneficiary communities were for the reception of the
platform- The preparedness of beneficiary communities to take advantage
of the introduction of new energy into their communities in terms of
available capital and their business acumen would normally determine the
degree of economic impact that the multifunctional platform would have
upon their lives, which would then spiral off into the social and academic
spheres. In terms of the availability of capital and business acumen, Chera
seems to be ahead of the other communities which resulted in a greater
economic impact than the rest of the communities. This contrasts with the
situation at Nyerigiyili where the women could not expand their business as
a result of lack of capital.
• The influence of surrounding or satellite communities- Even though
Chera had a small population, the influence of surrounding communities in
terms of population made the establishment of the platform a success. The
population at the school, which was 317 and higher than Chera’s population
of 165 as at the time the platform was installed, led to a thriving cooked food
industry in the village.
Another area where the communities exhibited variation was in the area of
fuel prices. The table below shows the variation:
Name of community Price of diesel Price of engine oil Total per month
Changnayili
Zosali 5.2 x 15 Ghc 16.0 x 2.5 Ghc 235.0 Ghc
Chera 6.0 x 12 Ghc 13.0 x1.25 Ghc 106. 25 Ghc
Nyerigiyili 5.1 x 60 Ghc 16.0 x 2 Ghc 644.0 Ghc
Chalaam 5.1 x 60 Ghc 10.0 x 1 Ghc 316.0 Ghc
- 34 -
the volume of work.
Chalaam spends the second highest amount of money every month on fuel
and also uses 60 gallons of diesel a month, just like Nyerigiyili. During this
exercise, Chalaam reported of a major breakdown of the machine which they
had to use all their profits to repair.
If the figures provided on the amount of fuel consumed by the communites
are a correct reflection of their output, then it can be concluded that the rate
at which the machine wears out, necessitating that certain parts be replaced
is linked to the volume of work it has to perform.
8. Recommendations
In view of the constant occurrence of certain problems affecting the smooth
running of the multifunctional platform as well as its impact on the lives of
beneficiary communities, it has become imperative to take a critical look at these
problems in order to make suggestions geared towards their resolution.
One problem that most of the communities encountered is the rampant
breakdown of the multifunctional platforms. This problem might be due to the
following causes;
• Improper usage or maintenance practices by operators of the platform
• The platform is not sturdy enough to handle the volume of work that it
normally performs
• Stress on the machine from the environment due to overheating, humidity, or
temperature fluctuations.
For the above mentioned causes, the following recommendations can be made;
• Operators and users of the platform should be educated on the right handling
and maintenance of the platform
• More research should be carried out on the technology to develop improved
versions that are sturdier and can withstand the volume of work expected of
them.
• More research should be carried out to develop models that can withstand
the heat, temperature variations and other forms of environmental stress
peculiar to sub-saharan Africa which is situated in the tropics. Research
should take cognizance of the fact that metals contract when cold and
expand when hot. Hence, metals or alloys that are less sensitive to changes
in temperature should be used in the construction of the platforms.
Linked to the incident of the rampant breakdown of the multifunctional
platforms is the fact that, the operators know nothing about how to repair them
when they breakdown and have to wait for recommended artisans to come and
- 35 -
repair them. Some communities have complained that the artisans do not
respond swiftly when they are called upon to come to their aid and they
sometimes have to go for more than two weeks without the services of the
platform because the artisans have refused to show up. In this regard;
• It might be necessary to train the operators themselves to repair the
platforms when they breakdown. Giving such knowledge to the operators
would enhance their understanding of how the platforms work and hence
help them to maintain them better.
• Train artisans who reside in the same communities that the platforms are
located. This would speed up repair works on the platform whenever they
break down and save operators energy, money and time spent in travelling to
other communities to look for the recommended artisans.
Another issue that came up repeatedly was the lack of credit facilities to help
women take full advantage of the platform to embark on or expand upon their
income generating activities. This can be resolved by;
• Linking up women with NGO’s, banks and other organisations that offer
credit facilities for such economic activities.
• Encouraging women to form co-operatives to enable them take
advantage of credit facilities meant for co-operatives.
Some teachers also expressed concern that the increase in profits realized by
women as a result of the expansion of their businesses wrought by the
multifunctional platform might not be invested in important areas such as their
children’s education or better nutrition but rather in their own priorities. Such a
concern is genuine since there is the possibility that the extra income can be spent
on purchasing more cloths and collections of designer bowls and utensils that are
not needed. If this happens, the trickle -down effect expected to accrue from
multifunctional platforms to stimulate development in rural communities may not
take place. In this regard;
• It would be necessary to sensitize women to invest their earnings or profits
in areas that would yield returns such as the education of their children, good
nutrition or in the expansion of their business activities. They should be
made to see that buying trunks of clothing or piles of bowls and basins is a
sterile investment since monies spent on such ventures yield no dividends.
Women involved in the processing of sheanuts and groundnuts complained that
they suffer from over exposure to heat now that they have increased the quantity of
groundnuts and sheanuts that they process. Exposure to excessive heat constitutes a
major health risk that can lead to skin problems and also affects the womb, putting
unborn children and pregnant women at risk. Since the purpose of the
Multifunctional Platform Programme, which is geared towards promoting the
- 36 -
wellbeing of rural communities would be undermined if women and unborn
children are exposed to health hazards, it would be in the interest of the programme
to;
• Encourage women to form groups and contribute money to buy roasters
• Assist them to obtain credit facilities to buy roasters.
Another issue that came to light during this exercise was the fact that, most
often, when multifunctional platforms are privately owned, they are operated by
relatives of the owners who sometimes run them on a part time basis. They are
either not remunerated at all or if they are remunerated, their remuneration is not
based on their output but is rather a token from the owner. It would be better if
private owners of multifunctional platforms adopt a more businesslike approach
and employ capable fulltime employees who would be remunerated according to
their output.
9. Conclusion
Ghana has an agrarian economy with the bulk of food and cash crops that
support this economy produced in the rural areas where 70 percent of its
population lives. Incidentally, it is these same areas that lack the very facilities
necessary for agro-processing to enable rural communities to add value to their
agricultural produce in order to preserve them and also promote the development
of agri-business at the grassroots. Not only does the lack of such facilities hinder
the development of rural economies but it also forces them to go through untold
hardships in a bid to undertake simple household tasks such as milling grains for
food, which also robs them of substantial time and energy that could have been
invested in development and intellectual activities.
It is therefore imperative that the widespread energy poverty peculiar to rural
areas be addressed since the availability of energy is a pre-requisite to all forms of
development.
From the above exercise, it can be concluded that the Multifunctional
Platform Programme that was implemented by the UNDP in conjunction with New
Energy in some rural communities in the Northern Region has injected a certain
amount of energy into these communities which has had a positive impact on their
livelihoods. This impact has been felt in the economic and social lives of members
of the community as well as the academic lives of school children.
In view of the information gathered from community members, devices such
as the multifunctional platforms that allow rural communities to have access to
energy to undertake otherwise simple tasks such as agro-processing could become
a lever for stimulating economic growth at the grassroots. This would in-turn
trickle down to generate other forms of growth such as the development of more
- 37 -
intellectuals from the rural areas since school children would stay in school long
enough to acquire relevant skills and knowledge because they are being given
better care by their parents.
If such children decide to reinvest their monies in the development of their
families and projects for the rural areas as professional adults, it would generate
further development in the rural areas which could then eventually come out of
their poverty.
There would also be a revolutionary increase in the health status of rural
communities since they would eat more nutritious food, which is the number one
pre-requisite for good health, thus putting an end to illnesses such as aneamia and
kwashiorkor in children. By becoming healthier, members of rural communities
would be saving money spent on hospital bills and drugs; mothers would spend
less time nursing the sick and invest this time in productive activities and less
school children would have to skip school because of ill health leading to an
improvement in school attendance and better grades.
Furthermore, if life is made more bearable for people in the rural areas
through the provision of multifunctional platforms which would alleviate the
drudgery of rural live and provide them with employment opportunities through
the development of agribusiness, less people would migrate to the urban areas
where they end up in shanty towns and slums and are lured into crime by
unscrupulous persons because they do not employable skills. These are but just a
few of the numerous and sometimes unforeseen benefits of the platform.
In conclusion, one can argue that, the introduction of energy to rural
communities through the establishment of multifunctional platforms has a
multifaceted impact on development at the grassroots and even higher levels of
society.
10. Appendix
Questionnaire for beneficiary communities of multifunctional platforms.
Questions for women
1. When was the multifunctional platform established here?
2. Before, how were you milling your rice, maize, groundnuts, sheabutter and
other farm produce?
3. How long did you use to walk or how far did you have to travel to access
the services of a mill?
4. How many minutes or hours did you spend walking if you had to walk?
5. If you used a vehicle how much did you pay?
6. If you used a bicycle, did you hire it or borrow it?
7. Did you have to spend a long time queuing at the mill?
- 38 -
8. How many minutes or hours did you have to queue?
9. Were there situations when you travelled to a community and still could not
access the services of a mill or the mill broke down before you could mill
your produce?
10. Did you sometimes encounter unpleasant experience such as accidents, etc
in your efforts to mill your produce?
11. Did you sometimes mill your produce using traditional means such as a
mortar and a pestle?
12. How long did it take you to mill a quantity of rice, maize, millet and
sheanuts?
13. How much time have you saved on milling your produce since the
multifunctional platform was established in your community?
14. How much money have saved on transport.
15. What do you now do with the extra time and energy and money saved on
transport?
16. Do you have anything else to tell us about how the multifunctional platform
has helped you or your experiences before the platform was introduced?
- 41 -