Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Review
The consumption of bioethanol as biofule may reduce greenhouse gases, gasoline imports. Also it can
be replaced with lead or MTBE (Methyl tert-butyl ether) that are air and underground water pollutants,
respectively. Plants are the best choice for meeting the projected bioethanol demands. For this scope, a
comparative analysis of the technological options using different feedstocks should be performed. Our
research and other studies indicate that sweet sorghum can be used as a feedstock for ethanol
production under hot and dry climatic conditions. Because, it has higher tolerance to salt and drought
comparing to sugarcane and corn that are currently used for biofuel production in the world. In
addition, high carbohydrates content of sweet sorghum stalk are similar to sugarcane but its water and
fertilizer requirements are much lower than sugarcane. Also, sugarcane is not a salt tolerant plant. On
the other hand, high fermentable sugar content in sweet sorghum stalk makes it to be more suitable for
fermentation to ethanol. Therefore, it is suggested to plant sweet sorghum for biofule production in hot
and dry countries to solve problems such as increasing the octane of gasoline and to reduce
greenhouse gases and gasoline imports.
Key words: Sweet sorghum, carbohydrate, bioethanol, biofuel.
INTRODUCTION
Each year, fossil energy resource is reducing in the
world. Therefore, a substitute should be found. There are
many crops available for producing energy such as sweet
sorghum which not only produce food (Anglani, 1998 ),
but also energy (Reddy et al., 2005), feed (Almodares et
al., 1999; Fazaeli et al., 2006) and fiber (Murray et al.,
2008a,b). Sorghum can be classified as sweet, grain and
forage types (Almodares et al., 2008b). Sweet sorghum
like grain sorghum produces grain 3 - 7 t/ha (Almodares
and Mostafafi, 2006). But the essence of sweet sorghum
is not from its seed, but from its stalk, which contains high
sugar content (Almodares et al., 2008c). In general, it can
produce stalk 54 - 69 t/ha (Table 1) (Almodares et al.,
2008c).
The sugar content in the juice of sweet sorghum varies
in different varieties (Almodares et al., 1994a). The Brix
range in different varieties of sweet sorghum is 14.32 -
773
Sugarcane
Sugar beet
Sweet sorghum
Crop duration
About 7 months
About 5 - 6 months
Growing season
About 4 months.
One season in temperate and
two or three seasons in
tropical area.
Soil requirement
Water management
36000 m /h
Crop management
Requires good
management
Yield per ha
Sugar content on weight basis
Sugar yield
Ethanol production directly
from juice
70 - 80 tons
10 - 12%
7 - 8 tons/ha
30 - 40 tons
15 - 18%
5 - 6 tons/ha
12000 m /h
Little fertilizer required; less
pest and disease complex;
easy management.
54 - 69 tons.
7 - 12%.
6 - 8 tons/ha.
3000 L/ha.
Harvesting
Mechanical harvested
774
Genotypes
Stem Yield
-1
(t ha )
Brix
(%)
Sucrose
(%)
Purity
(%)
39.14
21.96
14.39
66.71
Cultivars
Roce
Vespa
84.53
20.99
13.05
74.59
Brandes
MN1500
77.14
83.71
18.72
20.71
8.92
12.00
46.39
57.59
E36-1
Soave
48.00
61.57
18.26
20.73
13.41
13.46
76.02
65.00
M81-E
Sumac
103.57
44.43
16.01
21.12
10.26
12.85
65.10
60.10
Sofrah
SSV-108
SSV-94
85.57
62.85
70.14
19.63
22.25
20.64
12.61
13.97
11.75
64.05
62.26
57.12
SSV-96
Theis
62.00
100.14
22.54
19.10
13.71
7.26
60.10
37.59
Foralco
Rio
97.71
95.00
20.40
22.36
12.64
16.06
60.83
71.31
S-35
Turno
58.43
39.86
19.78
11.16
11.58
6.00
58.75
35.86
Satiro
Wary
27.86
126.42
17.16
15.84
10.33
7.85
60.02
49.40
IS 686
61.43
16.54
9.00
54.39
IS 16054
IS 18154
51.85
42.14
21.07
19.04
11.73
12.71
55.83
66.71
IS 6962
IS 9639
43.00
54.00
23.01
21.77
13.61
14.31
58.85
65.23
IS 2325
IS 6973
59.57
33.43
20.70
22.85
14.28
14.21
60.18
61.88
IS 4546
IS 19273
56.43
46.28
22.03
20.29
13.05
15.04
60.12
73.69
IS 4354
33.86
17.66
9.80
55.28
A1 x IS 6973
83.28
16.46
9.53
57.17
A13 x IS
1273
97.00
21.18
14.26
66.78
A1 x IS
19261
88.13
18.69
11.82
63.04
A1 x IS
14446
87.13
16.51
10.51
62.89
A45 x IS
14446
124.13
17.95
13.36
74.06
A1 x IS
19273
128.85
17.82
13.00
73.51
A13 x IS
14446
113.56
14.32
10.73
74.40
Lines
Hybrids
775
Figure 1. Proposed layout for ethanol production and by-product from sweet sorghum.
present in grain of sweet sorghum are fructose, glucose, raffinose, sucrose and maltose. In sorghum
leaves, sucrose is translocated and transformed into
starch during the development of grains (Smith and
Frederiksen, 2000).
Grain plus stem of sweet sorghum has been shown to
yield more fermentable carbohydrates than other fuel
crops (Murray et al., 2008b).
In addition, the grain can be used for production of
high fructose syrup (Hosseini et al., 2003) and animal
feed (Ebadi et al., 1997; Azarfa et al., 1998). Therefore,
sorghum is an excellent crop for biomass production.
The high nonstructural carbohydrate content of its vegetative biomass can be fermented to methane or ethanol
(Reddy et al., 2005). Ethanol production by fermentation of sugar solutions obtained from sweet sorghum
varies widely among years at different locations, fertility
(Almodares et al., 2006, 2008d), moisture, planting/harvest dates (Almodares et al., 1997a; Almodares and
Mostafafi, 2006), preclude a strict linear association
between number of frost free days (Almodares et al.,
2007b). In stems the extent of sucrose accumulation
varies among cultivars (Table 2) (Almodares and
Sepahi, 1996; Almodares et al., 1997a).
Sorghum nonstructural carbohydrates contents are
affected by temperature, time of day (Almodares et al.,
2000), maturity (Almodares et al., 1994b), cultivar
(Almodares and Sepahi, 1996), culm section, spacing
and fertilization (Almodares et al., 2008d). Shading significantly reduces panicle and leaf laminae dry weights
776
of sorghum (Kiniry et al., 1992). Environmental conditions such as water quality (Almodares and Sharif,
2005, 2007) and also growth stage (Almodares et al.,
2007c) and maturity is a factor a affecting carbohydrate
content (Almodares et al., 1994b). In the sweet sorghum, sucrose, glucose and fructose contents increase
after anthesis (Almodares et al., 2008c). In stems, nonstructural carbohydrates contents increase after preboot
(Almodares et al., 2008c) and reach a maximum level
near post anthesis (Almodares et al., 2008c).
Senescence and nonsenescence affect levels of
sugar accumulation in the culm of sorghum cultivars
(Vietor et al., 1990). The nonsenescent cultivars contain
more carbohydrates at all maturity stages than the
senescent cultivars. They reported that harvested
senescent and nonsenescent sorghum hybrids at three
stages of maturity: grain filling, black layer and postblack layer. Plants were shown to be physiologically
mature when the black layer formed in the pedicel of
kernels at the panicle base. McBee and Miller (1990)
reported that closer spacing significantly increased total
carbohydrates at the anthesis stage. Sugar production
of sweet sorghum was compared with sugarcane and
sugar beet and the results showed that sugar production from sweet sorghum is cheaper than both sugar
cane and sugar beet (Blas et al., 2000). Therefore, it
can be used as a supplementary sugar crop (Kualarni
et al., 1995). So, it seems that through cultural practices, breeding and physiological manipulation can
increased the carbohydrate contents in sweet sorghum
plants and because of sweet sorghum has high amount
of sucrose, glucose and fructose which is easily converted to ethanol by microorganism of Saccharomyces
cerevisiae. Thus, sweet sorghum is a suitable plant for
biofuel production.
The important of ethanol in biofule
One method to reduce air pollution is to oxygenated fuel
for vehicles. MTBE (Methyl tert-butyl ether) is a member
of a group of chemicals commonly known as fuel
oxygenates (Fischer et al., 2005). It is a fuel additive to
raise the octane number. But it is very soluble in water
and it is a possible human carcinogenic (Belpoggi et al.,
1995). Thereby, it should be substituted for other
oxygenated substances to increase the octane number
of the fuel. Presently, ethanol as an oxygenous biomass
fuel is considered as a predominant alternative to
MTBE for its biodegradable, low toxicity, persistence
and regenerative characteristic (Cassada et al., 2000).
The United States gasoline supply is an ethanol blend
and the importance of ethanol use is expected to
increase as more health issues are related to air quality.
Ethanol may be produced from many high energy crops
such as sweet sorghum (Figures 1 and 2), corn, wheat,
barely, sugar cane, sugar beet, cassava, sweet potato
and etc (Drapcho et al., 2008). Like most biofuel crops,
777
Figure 2. Mass balance of sweet sorghum juice extraction and ethanol production
(Prasad et al., 2007).
stalk
processing
for
ethanol
Juice extraction
Juice is extracted by series of mills (Almodares et al.,
2008e). The juice coming out of milling section is first
screened, sterilized by heating up to 100C and then
clarified (Quintero et al., 2008). The muddy juice is then
778
779
780