Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
MANAGEMENT
P080-4
Quality Management
P080-4
TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT (TQM)
Introduction :
The term 'Quality' may be defined as the totality of features and
characteristics of a product or service that bear on its ability to satisfy
stated or implied needs. The term 'Quality Control' QC' may be defined as
the operational techniques and activities that are used to fulfil requirements
for quality. In 'QC' the aim is to inspect to prevent defects from occuring and
not to find defects after they have occurred. The QC programme would be
geared to root out the problems that can cause defective products during
production.
Quality evolution phases have been shown in figure 1 below. Operator
inspection and foreman verification phases focussed on part defect detection
through post production inspection. It is concerned with conforming to
standards/specifications and sorting out rejects.
The Statical Quality Control, SQC, concept has been extensively refined
during the last 50 years. SQC can be broken into two areas : Acceptance
Sampling and Statistical Process Control (SPC).
Acceptance Sampling is the basis of traditional inspection based
quality control approaches and is essentially retrospective. It deals with
problems of quality after they have been built in. It is still used where there is
no guarantee of incoming quality from previous stages or from suppliers. The
techniques uses either 100 percent inspection or sampling inspection where
only an 'acceptable number' of defects get through.
On the other hand, SPC, attempts to monitor and improve things while they
are still happening. Statistical methods are employed to detect trends that
will ultimately lead to the production of defective parts. The aim is to identify
the causes for such trends and then taken the necessary corrective actions
before any defective parts are produced. The essence of SPC is that 'if the
process is under control, any variations are due only to random causes. The
basic way of checking this out is via Control Charts. Lack of control of a
process is indicated by the following conditions :
1. A point falling outside the control lines (UCL and LCL).
2. A run of more than 8 points on the same side of the centre
line.
3. A trend with at least 7 points.
4. 13 out of 15 points falling on the same side of the centre
line.
When any of these conditions exists, then corrective actions need to be
taken.
Quality Assurance (QA) Phase.
Quality assurance, QA, recognizes that inspection is not the answer and that
"the entire manufacturing process must be committed to meeting the quality
needs of the design". It incorporates all those planned and systematic
actions necessary to provide adequate confidence that a product or a service
will satisfy the requirements for quality. For effectiveness, QA usually requires
a continuing evaluation of factors that affect the adequacy of design or
specifications for intended application as well as verifications and audits of
production, installation and inspection operations. QA focusses on procedure
compliance and product conformity to specifications through production and
operations management, often using SPC as a tracking tool.
The concept of "QA" originated in early 1960s. However, by 1969, it had
3
Definition of TQM.
TQM is an integrated organisational approach in delighting customers (both
external and internal) by meeting their expectations on a continuous basis
through everyone involved with the organisation working on continuous
improvement in all product/processes alongwith proper problem
methodology. In other words, TQM means activities involving everyone in a
company-management and workers in a totally integrated effort towards
improving performance at every level. This improved performance is directed
towards satisfying cross-functional goals as Quality, Cost, Manpower
development, Quality of worklife etc. These activities ultimately lead to
increased customer and employee satisfaction.
In short, the definition says "Continuously meeting agreed customer
requirements at the lowest cost by realising the potential of all employees".
TQM Culture.
Total quality is a new approach to improve the effectiveness and flexibility of
an organisation as a whole. It basically aims to involve every person in every
department of an organisation working together to eliminate errors and
prevent waste. It is an organisational culture to ensure things are done right
first time.
According to "Ten Compelling reasons for TQM" by Dr. Steve Smith, the
results are almost invariable :
1. Committed customers.
2. Improved productivity.
3. Reduced costs.
4. Improved certainly in operations.
5. Improved company image.
4
6. Dedicated management.
7. Increased employee participation.
The only way to achieve these results is through commencement by
management,starting with the top management. TQM must be
management lead, company wide in implementation, dedicated to
continuous improvement, and the responsibility of every employee.
TQM principles.
The guideline principles of TQM are given below :
1. Agree customer requirements.
2. Understand customers/suppliers.
3. Do the right things.
4. Do things right first time.
5. Measure for success.
6. Continuous improvement is the goal.
7. Management must lead.
8. Training is essential.
9. Communicate as never before.
TQM is a process of change in terms of values, beliefs, style and activity.
The concepts are essentially simple to understand and yet are difficult to
implement.
Where Applicable.
TQM is applicable to all functions as broadly interpreted: Quality means.
Quality of work, Quality of service, Quality of information, Quality of
process, Quality of division, Quality of people, Quality of system, Quality of
company, Quality of objectives etc. Quality has an element of cost
consideration in it. Idea is to minimise the cost with quality as the
objective.
5
Relevant Standards
1. ISO 9000. Quality management and quality assurance standards.
Guidelines for
selection and use.
2.
ISO 9001. Quality System - Model for quality assurance in
design/development,
production, installation and servicing.
3.
ISO 9002. Quality Systems - Model for quality assurance in
production and
installation.
4. ISO 9003. Quality System - Model for quality assurance in fmal
inspection and
testing.
Components of TQM
9
TQM Model
The definition of a quality system as given by the American National Standards Institute (ANSI)/American Society for Quality Control (ASQc) Standard
A3 (1987) is as follows:
Quality System: The collective plans, activities, and events that are
provided to ensure that a product, process, or service will satisfy given
needs.
The systems approach to quality integrates the various functions and
responsibilities of the different units, and it provides a mechanism to ensure
that the goal of the organization is being met through the coordination of the
goals of the individual units.
10
11
BASE CLAUSE
5.3
Establish
organizations
BASE CLAUSE
5.1 Management responsibility
purpose
5.1 Establish Quality policy
5.4.1
Establish
objectives
Develop processes
to achieve the goal
Quality
4.1c
Develop
methods
criteria
12
and
7.1
Planning
realization
of
product
Operate and
maintain processes
4.1 Implement
QMS
and
maintain
8.2.4 Monitor
product
and
measure
Establish goal is
achieved in the best
way
13
8.1 General
8.5.2 Corrective action
8.5.3 Preventive action
8.3 Control of nonconforming
product
5.6 Management review
7.3.7 Control of design and
development changes
8.1 General
8.2.3 Monitoring and
measurement of processes
8.5.1 Continual improvement
8.5.2 Corrective action
8.5.3 Preventive action
5.6 Management review
7.5.2 Validation of processes for
production and service provision
7.6 Control of monitoring and
measuring devices
8.1 General
8.2.2 Internal audit
8.2.3
Monitoring
and
measurement of processes
8.1 General
8.4 Analysis of data
8.1 General
8.5.1 Continual improvement
5.6.2 Review input
7.6 Control of monitoring and
measuring devices
5.6 Management review
8.5.1 Continual improvement
e)
f)
g)
h)
15
16
Corporate terminology :
Purpose - Why we exist, why we do what we do
Mission - Where we are going the journey
Goals - Our intended destination
Vision - What we want to become
Values - What beliefs will guide our behavior
Strategy - How we are going to get there
Policy - Rules that guide our actions and decisions the signposts en route
Principles - Fundamental truth
Objectives - What we want to achieve the results
Targets - What we aim at to achieve objectives
Establishing quality objectives :
ISO 9000 defines quality objectives as results sought or aimed for related to
quality. It also suggests that these objectives be based on the quality policy
19
environment
(d) Vision, values
(e) Mission
3 Organization
(a) Function descriptions
(b) Organization chart
(c) Locations with scope of activity
4 Business processes
(a) The system model showing the key business processes and how
they are
interconnected
(b) System performance indicators and method of measurement
(c) Business planning process description
(d) Resource management process description
(e) Marketing process description
(f) Product/service generation processes description
(g) Sales process description
(h) Order full-fill element process description
5 Function matrix (Relationship of functions to processes)
6 Location matrix (Relationship of locations to processes)
7 Requirement deployment matrices
(a) ISO 9001 compliance matrix
(b) ISO 14001 compliance matrix
(c) Regulation compliance matrices (FDA, Environment, Health, Safety,
CAA etc.)
8 Approvals (List of current product, process and system approvals)
Documented procedures:
The standard requires the management system documentation to include
documented procedures required by ISO 9001.
ISO 9000 defines a procedure as a specified way to carry out an activity or a
process.
21
Records
Records are essential in ensuring the effective operation and control of
processes because they capture factual performance from which decisions
on process performance can be made.
Records are defined in ISO 9000 as documents stating the results achieved
or providing evidence of activities performed. Records are therefore
produced during an event or immediately afterwards. Records do not arise
from contemplation.
They contain facts, the raw data as obtained from observation or
measurement and produced manually or automatically. The information may
have been received verbally, visually or as a printout from a machine
adhering to the policies and practices, following what is stated, not changing
your procedures after changing your practice.
Managing the process then involves managing all the inherent characteristics
of the process in such a manner that the requirements of customers and
interested parties
are fulfilled by the process outcomes. This means:
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
f)
g)
Managing
Managing
Managing
Managing
Managing
Managing
Managing
the
the
the
the
the
the
the
process inputs
work
physical resources
financial resources
human resources
constraints
outputs
dealing with customers and internal functions such as whether the sales
promise matched the true capability of the organization etc.
3 Defined performance standard (the level above or below which
performance
is deemed to be sub standard or inferior)
4 Sensors to detect variance before, during or after operations. There
may be
human or physical sensors each of which has an element of measurement
uncertainty
5 Calibrated sensors so that you can be assured the results are accurate
and
precise. There are two types of measurements to be made:
_ Measurements that tell us whether the process is operating as intended
_ Measurements that tell us whether the process is effective
Procedure Design
24
26