Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Paper is principally wood cellulose, which is considered a fibrous material. Cellulose is the second most
abundant material on earth after rock. It is the main component of plant cell walls, and the basic
building block for many textiles and for paper. Cellulose is a natural polymer, a long chain of linked
sugar molecules made by the linking of smaller molecules.
When these
networks or
matrices of
fibers and
fibrils dry,
they
intertwine
and cling
together
with the
power of
the
hydrogen
bond.
Coating these fibers with Portland cement creates a cement matrix, which encases the fibers for extra
strength. Of course paper has more in it than cellulose. Raw cellulose has a comparatively rough
texture. Kaolinite or China clay is used to add smoothness and semi-gloss to paper. Varnish is added
for the glossy look. Then there are various inks and other chemicals added. Many types of paper are
treated with dyes and bleach that can contaminate soil and plant-life. They are extremely persistent in
soil and cannot be broken down by bacteria. It makes sense to encase them in Portland cement, keep
them out of the landfill, and do something useful with them.
Portland cement is an integral component of papercrete. It is
usually not used in fidobe or padobe. A simple paper and water
mix takes a great deal of time to dry and it shrinks about 15-25
percent. Adding Portland cement in an amount equal in weight
to the paper cuts drying time by about half and reduces
shrinkage to about 3-5 percent. If nothing were added to paper
and water, it would be less strong, highly flammable, and less
resistant to bugs and mold.
No matter what mix you settle on, the great thing about generic
papercrete is how it traps air. When the water drains out and
evaporates, it leaves thousands of tiny air pockets. This is what
Samples made in a coffee can makes the material light and a good insulator. Adding solid
showing shrinkage. From left to material to the mix (sand, etc.) affects weight and insulating
right: No Portland cement, 50-50 quality. The best mix is the one which best fits the application.
Because there is so much waste paper in the United States, it is probably the best fibrous
material to use here. But there are many other natural fibrous materials, such as f lax, hemp and
jute, which could be used to make papercrete in other parts of the world . Less obvious
candidates include: straw, wood fiber, kenaf, wheat, barley and cane. Natural fibers have the
advantage of being renewable. Also, many natural fibers, including pineapple leaf fiber and water
hyacinth, are waste products and are available at minimal or no cost. Research is now being done
to incorporate composites of these materials in ways previously unimagined. Ford Motors, for
example, is committed to using wood and natural fiber-reinforced composites for structural
purposes. Doing this would take these materials well beyond their present cosmetic uses in trim.
Ford has even predicted that car bodies themselves will be constructed from natural fiber
composites in the medium term.
This brings us back to some of the derivatives of papercrete - fibrous concrete, padobe and
fidobe. Fibrous concrete (a.k.a. fibrous cement) is fibrous material (usually paper), Portland
cement and water. Padobe (paper adobe) has no Portland cement. It is a mix of paper, water, and
earth with clay. Fidobe (fibrous adobe) is like padobe, but may contain other fibrous materials.
Actually, classic adobe was made with clay earth and straw - so is adobe actually fidobe? I would
guess so. There are no hard and fast rules, but recommendations are on the horizon.
PROPERTIES
Papercrete is mixed with Portland cement to obtain a very good R-value (2-3 per inch), an
excellent sound absorption quality, to be flame/fungus retardant, and bug/rodent resistant. Since it
is relatively light and more flexible than earth, rock or concrete, it is potentially an ideal material
for earthquake-prone areas. It can be used in many ways -- as blocks, panels, poured in place,
augured, pumped, sprayed, hurled, troweled on, used like igloo blocks to make a self-standing
dome or applied over a framework to make a roof or dome. Papercrete is a very forgiving
material, but like any other mixture, varying the mix, admixtures and curing procedures results in
tradeoffs in its properties. For example, adding more sand or glass to the mix results in a denser,
stronger, more flame retardant material, but adds weight and reduces R-value. Heavy mixes with
added sand, glass, etc. increase mass and strength to a point, but reduce workability. In other
words, a "light" mix with just Portland cement is easier to cut with a chain saw and drive rebar
through than a mix with larger amounts of sand, clay, etc. Adding more than the minimum amount
of Portland cement to the mix increases strength and resistance to abrasion, but also reduces
flexibility somewhat, adds weight and may reduce R-value. So the trick is finding the best mix for
the application. Making walls calls for a lighter mix than stucco. Roof panels will probably be a
different mix than sub-floors.
FORMULAS - Papercrete
The most common mixer in use is Mike McCain's tow
mixer. See Mixers. It has a capacity of about 200 gallons
(900 liters). The following is a starting formula for a 200gallon batch of blocks. A 200-gallon batch will make 25-30
blocks in forms one foot (30 centimeters) wide x two feet
(61 centimeters) long x five inches (13 centimeters) thick..
See Forms.
A starting formula is just that, a place to begin
A tow mixer being pulled behind a experimenting. Some people prefer "lighter" formulas
without sand. If you plan to cut out windows, doors or other
pickup truck.
openings in the walls after they are erected, you will want to
avoid using sand. It will dull your chainsaw blades very
quickly.
But a typical starting formula for a 200-gallon batch is 160 gallons (727 liters) of water, 60 pounds
(27 kilograms) of paper, 1 bag or 94 pounds (43 kilograms) of Portland cement and 15 shovelfuls
or 65 pounds (29 kilograms) of sand. The sand adds thermal mass, reduces flammability and
shrinkage, and packs down the slurry for a denser, stronger block. See above for caveats
regarding sand.
Half a bag of Portland cement will work too, but the slurry will dry more slowly and will shrink
more. The blocks won't be as hard or flame retardant when dry. Some people use two bags of
Portland cement in areas where strength is most important - for blocks at the bottom of walls, roof
panels, and for floors.
Clyde T. Curry's recent formula for one yard (about 200 gallons) of papercrete incorporates 25%
reground Styrofoam. His formula calls for three sacks of Portland cement added to 75 pounds of
hammer-milled cellulose insulation and 25% reground Styrofoam. This cuts the amount of
Portland cement he normally uses by one full sack and significantly reduces shrinkage. He makes
his interior plasters using six sacks of Portland cement per yard, which makes the plaster fire
resistant and forms a flame/vapor barrier equivalent to half-inch drywall.
If the earth stays in a lump after If a worm can be made, it has If the worm will hang, it has a lot
squeezing, it has clay.
more clay.
of clay.
To determine a fairly exact percentage of clay, do a simple "shake test". Using a vertical-sided
transparent jar or glass which will take about a quart of liquid, fill it about two thirds full of water and
almost the rest of the way with earth. (Leave a little space for shaking.) Then shake vigorously for at
least two minutes. Set it down and start watching the separation. Earth should have some percentage
of sand, silt and clay in it. Each material is basically a little more coarse and heavier than the other.
Sand and heavier particles with fall to the bottom almost immediately - within a few seconds to a
minute. Silt will settle on top of the sand in a few minutes to several hours. Clay will settle on top of the
silt within several hours to 24 hours. Best to wait 24 hours for an accurate reading. There will be a faint
but discernable delineation between each layer of material present. Of course, if any of the three
materials - sand, silt, or clay is not present, there will be no layer. The percentage of clay can be
determined by measuring the layers, and figuring the percentages, based on 100% of the total height
measured. If the clay is about thirty percent of the height of the earth, you can make blocks. If it's within
a few percent, you may want to use a little Portland cement to make up the difference.
I have seen something which makes me believe that going totally without Portland cement could be a
problem - termites on the surface of a papercrete block. I was visiting a building site in New Mexico.
Several hundred double fist-sized pieces of papercrete had been tossed in a pile and over a period of
weeks had settled into the damp worksite soil. I began turning over pieces looking for any kind of
damage. For some time I found nothing at all. Pieces embedded in damp mud for a long time were
perfectly clean and intact. Then I found one, which had a small piece of unmixed paper embedded in it,
which had been in contact with the damp soil for some time. The paper was not coated with Portland
cement. There were a number of termites around the unprotected paper. The paper and mud scraped
off very easily and I carefully examined the rest of the surface of the piece. It was completely clean. I
then tried to break the piece into smaller pieces to look inside. It wouldn't break up and the small pieces
that did come off left completely clean surfaces - no dirt tunnels or other evidence of termites. I believe
that the uncoated piece of paper was the only thing drawing the termites. I have heard that some
people put a shovelful of Borax in their mixes to discourage bugs. I have examined other buildings, five
to nine years old, which I'm sure were built without Borax and they showed no obvious signs of bug
attack.
Please consider a safety note on formulas. Unless you add a significant percentage of non-flammable
material to any mix, both papercrete and fidobe (or padobe ) will burn. Papercrete made with a 4-to-1
ratio of cement to paper, by weight, won't burn at all, but that may be too much cement. Papercrete
made with a 1-to-1 ratio of cement to paper, by weight, will smolder like charcoal, but does not burn
with an open flame. Smoldering with no flame could result in unlikely but dangerous scenarios.
One practitioner is particularly sensitive to the possibility of a roof collapse should wide areas of a
papercrete wall smolder for hours without detection. Another practitioner tested this possibility and
thinks that such an occurrence is highly unlikely. He bored a three-inch hole in a papercrete wall and
emptied an entire can of lighter fluid inside. He managed to get the papercrete to begin to smolder, but
it would not continue to smolder for long because of lack of oxygen. It was suggested that fireproof
mortar (high percentage of Portland cement or other fireproof binder) be used between the blocks, and
fireproof stucco be used on the outside of the home to "encase" the blocks in fireproof "containers".
This would limit a smoldering fire to the destruction of only one block, if it should ever occur at all.
Fidobe or padobe made with 3 parts soil to one part paper, by weight, supposedly won't burn either.
Again, that may be too much soil. The intention is to be safe, but not sacrifice the qualities (R-value,
light weight, strength, etc.), which make papercrete and its variations attractive to use in the first place.
More testing needs to be done on papercrete and fire.
OTHER BINDERS
There are alternatives to Portland cement, which can be used as binders, either alone or in combination
with Portland cement. They include fly ash, bottom ash, rice hull ash, Plaster of Paris and lime. There
may be others. Fly ash is ash left over from burning coal, which in the past was allowed to fly out of the
smokestacks of power plants into the atmosphere. It is now caught in giant air filters, bagged and sold. I
examined several structures built with papercrete block using fly ash and Portland cement in a 35
percent to 65 percent ratio as a binder. They were five years old and in excellent condition. Using fly
ash as 35 percent of the binder cuts the Portland cement cost nearly in half and helps recycle fly ash.
Bottom ash is heavier than fly ash so it sinks to the bottom of the furnace. I have heard of bottom ash
being used, but have not seen papercrete made with it. Rice hull ash is burned in power plants in areas
of the country where rice is grown. We currently have 100 pounds (45 kilograms) of rice hull ash on
standby for tests. Test results with rice hull ash will be posted in Tests soon. Plaster of Paris is a variety
of calcined gypsum. You probably have seen it in the form of drywall sheets. In powder form, it is really
quite expensive, but in situations where it is necessary to join papercrete and wood, it is very effective.
A small sample made with it was placed on a 2 x 6 piece of wood and was very difficult to pry off with a
EXPERIMENTATION
It took me some time to get over my skepticism about papercrete. I mixed up small batches and tried
different formulas. Since I have no allergies, and was used to thinking in terms of bricks and mortar, I
just felt more confident using Portland cement. I found some recycled plastic five-gallon buckets to work
in and bought an "X" shaped stucco-mixing blade for my heavy-duty drill to do the mixing.
The drill won't win any RPM contests, but has great low-end
power. I would advise staying away from the normal kitchen
blender for doing experimentation. I burned out a blender and a
circular saw (I had custom adapted it for mixing.) before I
realized that those tools are really meant for high speed and
relatively low torque. Recently, I was told that a heavy-duty food
processor works well to mix papercrete samples. What you need
to mix papercrete is power. You need to tear the paper apart and
mix it, which requires a good deal of force. This is the reason that
Mike McCain's tow mixers work well - they provide the power of
an automobile engine to tear apart everything from
office paper to phone directories.
Mixers
There are a number of kinds of mixers, differentiated mainly by capacity and mobility. The whole idea of mixing
is to tear the paper apart in water to produce slurry, and then mix in additives like Portland cement and sand.
This procedure is followed all the time - when working with small batches in a five-gallon bucket or with 1000
gallon (4500 liter) batches on the back of a 4-wheel drive truck. Get the paper and water mixed first, and then
add the other components.
A number of practitioners prefer to purchase paper, which has already been ripped apart by running it through
a hammer mill. After milling, it looks like cellulose insulation; the type blown into the roof crawl space of many
homes for roof insulation. In fact, it is the same material without moisture resistant and fire retardant chemicals.
The advantage of working with hammer milled paper is that most additives can be mixed in using conventional
concrete mixers. Other special processes require specialized equipment.
$125.00
$ 15.00
$ 30.00
$ 15.00
$200.00
$ 20.00
$ 10.00
$ 6.00
$ 3.00
$ 9.00
$ 30.00
$ 86.00
$ 5.00
$ 7.00
$ 50.00
$ 60.00
$ 4.00
$ 5.00
$ 3.00
$ 3.00
$ 3.00
$ 2.00
$ 20.00
I have seen a few tow mixers in action. They work well if they are designed correctly. When they are
working well, driving at five miles (8 kilometers) per hour for less than mile (less than 1.5 kilometers),
will mix the paper and water or the entire mix if Portland cement and other admixtures have been
added. (The water and paper will be pulped alone when making stucco and plaster. Applying stucco
and plaster takes time so the pulp is mixed with Portland in smaller batches in a small mortar mixer as
needed.)
One of the tow mixers I saw had an unusual custom-made blade, which was incorrectly designed.
When this tow mixer was barely moved, it flung mix outward and skyward creating a papercrete
mushroom cloud. It also required quite a bit of arm-deep repositioning of the wet paper to get the mix
well blended, which took a considerable amount of time.
Ironically, the only complaint I've heard about properly designed tow mixers is that they have to be
towed. If building in extremely rough terrain, there might be very little room for towing. That is a valid
concern but I have seen one used on a small building site being towed in tight circles right around the
home being built. Remember, this mixer is towed at walking speed, so it really doesn't take much room
to tow it around.
One valid complaint about tow mixers (up to now at least) is that they are difficult to seal especially
before the paper has been broken down somewhat. Some people were using toy balls to seal short
lengths of PVC pipe installed (with Bondo) in the rear wall of the mixer. The problem with the ball
approach is that it always leaks and when you remove the ball, there is no way to control how fast the
mix comes out. Ive been using a Hand-Tite Pipe Plug, which seals very well but doesn't easily control
the outflow. The best approach came from Cris Ackerson, one of my workshop attendees. She came up
with a device called a Slide Ditch Gate used in irrigation systems. It comes in many sizes, which seal
extremely well and fit inside PVC of various diameters or can be installed without the PVC. It can be
easily slid up, down, or closed completely to control how much mix comes out. The one in the picture
was welded in place to give it additional stability.
Cris Ackerson adjusts the Slide Ditch The Slide Ditch Gate seals the tow mixer completely and
Gate on her tow mixer.
controls the outflow of the mix extremely well.
the left.
The other axle protrudes through the bottom of the tank and drives the blade inside the tank. By
engaging two-wheel drive, the mixer blade is set in motion with the truck standing still. The blade
speed is controlled by means of the accelerator pedal. If four-wheel drive is engaged, the front wheels
are powered so that the truck can be moved around. That means the 1000 gallons of mix can be moved
to where it is needed.
Zach Rabon does his mixing in a conventional cement truck. He uses paper which has already been
hammer-milled. It is like cellulose attic insulation without the chemicals to retard fire and moisture.
After blending his additives in the rolling cement truck mixer, the mix is sent down the chute into
forms.
but maybe not as large a generator as one to run a heavier electric motor. Every time it's turned on, the
larger generator is going to consume more fuel than would have been needed for a smaller generator.
So the larger electric motor penalty has to be paid whether using the mixer or not. With the tow mixer,
you only burn gas when mixing. An electric mixer may be a better idea if you have ready access to
utility power, but there are two other interrelated issues with electric motors - convenience and safety.
Electricity doesn't mix well with water. The areas around stationary papercrete mixers get wet and stay
wet. A situation like that can lead to equipment damage or bodily injury. The electric mixers I've seen
have motors that are mounted above and to the side of the mixing tank. They have to be mounted
higher than the surface of the tank to keep them out of the wet area and align them with the blade's
drive shaft. The pulley on the motor is connected to a pulley mounted over the center of the tank. This
center pulley is connected to a shaft, which holds the blade a few inches above the bottom of the tank
to do the mixing. So whenever the motor is turned on, hands are often within a very short distance of a
moving belt and a spinning shaft. When something has to be added to the mix, and this is a frequent
operation, one has to remember to turn off the motor or risk catching a hand, piece of clothing, a tool
or a cement bag in the spinning belt pulley or around the spinning shaft. I am told that the more one
works around an electric papercrete mixer, the more tempting it is to leave the mixer on when
adjusting the mix. Cautious people install safety cowling over the moving parts to prevent injury, but I
have seen several without.
With a tow mixer, one has to stop the vehicle and get out to observe or adjust the mix. When the
vehicle is stopped, the blade stops, hence no safety issue.
There are, however, many people who prefer electric motor mixers and have used them successfully.
Kelly Hart has used a 1/2hp electric motor on a 50 gal. drum mixer for seven years with great success.
He even ran it on solar energy.
Recently, a different type of electric motor mixer is being developed for an alternative mix of
papercrete. It is intended for the small contractor rather than the individual builder. It has extensive
safety features such as ground fault interrupters as well as two motors and twin lawn mower blades.
Using this mixer, with an additive like ground Styrofoam, reportedly eliminates almost all shrinkage
and warping of the papercrete block. Initial tests with this new material and its preparation are
promising.
More on this as information becomes available.
THE SITE
The first thing you have to look at in any kind of construction is the site. Orienting the home to take
maximum advantage of passive solar design is of prime importance. It may also be possible to use the
contours of the site to help design the home. For example, if there is a high spot on the site, it may be
possible to build part of the structure into it to take advantage of earth sheltering, or to construct a lower
level or basement. There may be other things on the site, which can help you - and some you may want
to avoid. For example, the earth and rocks on the site may be material you can use for building, but
there may be low areas on the site, which should be avoided due to flooding. Some of these decisions
are value judgments, which require time and contemplation to evaluate. If a spot feels good and meets
practical requirements, it's more than likely the best place. Many additional ideas on "Siting A Natural
Building" can be found in a book titled "The Art Of Natural Building".
BUILDING CODES
Building Codes are intended to protect the health and safety of people occupying a structure or those
possibly affected by it or living near it. There is nothing wrong with Building Codes per se, but they are
sometimes used to unnecessarily prohibit perfectly safe procedures or to limit alternatives. In some
cases this is intentional, for example to limit construction procedures and materials to those
championed by special interest groups. But sometimes there is just not enough good information
available to allow Building Safety personnel to deviate from the book. This is where diplomacy and
knowledge come in handy. Usually showing respect, knowing precisely what you want to do, and
having good plans to accomplish it go a long way toward establishing rapport with Building Safety
personnel. Usually your plans or procedure gain a lot of credibility if you can find a structural engineer
or architect who is willing to approve (stamp) them. This approval stamp often costs quite a bit of
money, but some practitioners have found progressive architects who are interested in working with
innovative materials and charge very little.
Building Safety personnel have reason to be cautious. They don't want to be held responsible for
approving a product or procedure which turns out to be unreliable or even dangerous. In many cases, it
is possible to work with them. I have had very good experiences with those who have time and are
willing to listen. I'm not sure that any of the following construction methods are approved in the
Universal Building Code, but they have been used in structures which have been standing for years.
THE FOUNDATION
The function of a foundation is to support the load of the walls and roof of a structure, prevent settling,
and provide a solid anchor point to hold the structure together. The foundation has to extend to a depth
just below the frost line in your area. Basing the foundation below the frost line concentrates the load of
your structure where it is much less subject to heaving. Heaving is movement caused by the expansion
and contraction of moisture changed to ice during the freeze - thaw cycle. The foundation is usually
comprised of a footing and stem wall. The stem wall is placed on the footing or is poured as part of the
footing. The function of the stem wall is to elevate wall construction materials - in this case papercrete above the ground. This serves to isolate them from moisture and provide a barrier against bugs and
pests.
There are a number of ways to build footings and stem walls. One of the most common ways is to pour
a concrete footing and stem wall in a single monolithic unit. This involves excavating a footing, placing
steel rebar horizontally and vertically, and building forms to support the stem wall. There are variations
on this approach, but they all cost quite a bit of money, and use a significant amount of concrete - in
fact, the footing and stem can cost more than the rest of the papercrete structure combined. Concrete
is strong and quite reliable, but has the propensity to "wick" moisture. If there is water in the
surrounding soil, concrete will absorb the water through capillary action and pool it on its surfaces,
including where the papercrete walls meet the stem wall. Since papercrete is very hydrophilic- absorbs
water quite readily - this situation has to be stringently avoided. Ideally, the concrete footing and stem
wall are isolated from the surrounding soil with drainpipes and/or a layer of gravel to drain water away.
Additionally, some kind of barrier has to be placed between the concrete and the papercrete - either a
good liquid sealer or a physical barrier like a polyethylene sill sealer.
There are other ways to build footings and stem walls with tires
or with rubble and sand bags. These methods are not formally
recognized, but people are using them. The foundation with
tires involves digging a tire-width trench, filling tires with gravel
or earth, laying them horizontally in the trench, filling the tire
openings with gravel or earth, tamping them and then
constructing a stem wall on top of them.
This general approach is used in earth ship (rubber tire)
construction for the foundation as well as the walls. Digging
Tires are stacked offset like bricks. wide trenches and filling tires with earth is very labor intensive,
Drawing courtesy of Building With Earth by
but it works quite well.
Paulina Wojciechowska.
The easiest and least expensive way that I've heard of is to build a solid foundation for papercrete walls
is with rubble and sand bags. It is not code, but variations of it have been used successfully to support
many structures. A trench several inches wider than the wall is dug to just below the frost line.
Thoroughly tamp the bottom of the trench. Starting at the
bottom, layers of progressively smaller stones are placed on
top of one another. The bottom layer should be the coarsest,
perhaps 4 inch (10 centimeter) stone, followed by a layer of 2
inch (5 centimeter) stone, followed by one-inch (25mm) stone
and ending with pea gravel several inches above grade.
Screening your own gravel is a lot of work, and it is not often
possible to get uniform selected sizes commercially. Usually
the sand and gravel yards sell ranges of sizes like 1/2" - 3/4",
3/4" - 1 1/2", 1 1/2" - 3", 3" - 8", 6"+, etc. (1.3 - 1.4, 1.4- 4.0, 4.0
- 8.0, 8.0 - 20.0, 15.0+ centimeters)
Layers of bags are laid with offset joints like brick. Two strands of barbed wire are placed in parallel
along the length of - and between the layers of - the sand bags to keep them from sliding across one
another. To keep the papercrete wall from shifting on the sand bags, 3/8 inch (1.8 centimeters) rebar is
pounded through the sand bags, at two to four feet intervals, as deep into the rubble footing as they will
go. Pounding rebar through the rubble footing may be difficult, but I'm told that the rebar sometimes
finds its way between the stones. Most people start rebar with a post driver.
They cost about $20.00 at Home Depot. Its a lot easier on the hands than using a mall. The post driver
leaves a few inches protruding, so a hand mall has to be used
to pound the remaining length of the rebar all the way in. But
at that point, the rebar is stable enough to save hitting your
knuckles with the mall. If the rebar will not penetrate the
footing at a given point, try pounding it in at a different angle. If
the rebar won't go into the foundation at all, just leave it
impaled in the bags. The idea is to stabilize the first few
courses of papercrete on the sand bags, not nail the bags to
the footing. The weight of the bags and the papercrete will
keep the walls from moving on the footing.
Actually, at least one home I visited had no footing at all. The
A post driver is used to start the
site where the home was to be built was very sandy and had rebar. A mall is used after the rebar
no problem with drainage. The seasonal temperature changes
is far enough in to be stable.
were not extreme enough to cause heaving in loose, sandy
soil. So the builder simply leveled an area for the home, and then spread out about six inches of scoria,
a porous volcanic rock, for sub-floor drainage and insulation. Next he laid a few courses of sand bags
right on top of the scoria. He finished the entire building, walls and roof, with bags of scoria covered
with papercrete. So, absent problems with drainage and frost heave, if walls are thick (i.e. building
loads are spread over a wide base), footings may not be necessary. Many ancient buildings, standing
for hundreds of years, are built on the ground without footings.
In fact, un-reinforced rubble and shaped stone have been used
for foundations and walls for centuries before Portland cement
and rebar were discovered. Some of the early Native American
stone structures of the Southwest, like those at Chaco Canyon
and Pueblo Bonito, are centuries old, several stories tall and
still intact. Some have mud mortar and others have no mortar
at all. Larger stones were chinked so skillfully with smaller
stones that nothing else was needed.
Building With Earth ,by Paulina Wojciechowska, has a detailed section on foundations. We plan
further experimentation with these foundations early next year.
No matter which method you choose to support your roof, the walls are built the same way. The rebar,
as described above, has ideally been pounded into the rubble foundation, and has been allowed to
protrude a few feet above the sand bags.
The first three or four courses of papercrete will have to be
drilled or impaled on the protruding rebar, or poured in place
around the rebar. The rebar is meant to prevent horizontal
movement. Pounding it into the rubble foundation won't prevent
the walls from lifting vertically, but if something
cataclysmic happens to lift the weight of 12-14 inch (18-35
centimeter) thick papercrete walls, chances are that nothing
would have kept the structure from lifting.
When just a few inches of rebar are visible above the courses
Rebar protruding above a concrete of papercrete, it's time to lay a piece of rebar horizontally and
wire it to the protruding vertical pieces. Then pound the vertical
footing.
There are two ways to plan for openings in the wall - either frame as you go or leave the rebar out and
cut openings to size with a chain saw at a later time. If you have all of your windows and doors, or know
the size of the openings, you can build frames for them as you put up the wall.
The wooden plate for the roof is whether you want to build a conventional roof, a papercrete
fastened to the wall with threaded roof or a hybrid papercrete-conventional roof. A conventional
rod welded to rebar. The rebar
protruding vertically is driven
through holes in the plate next to
the holes with the threaded rebar.
The vertical rebar will hold block in
place, which is laid above the roof
line.
roof is quite expensive; it averages about forty percent of the cost of the entire structure. A conventional
roof has to be well insulated, or the insulating value of building the walls with papercrete will be wasted.
Conventional roof systems are much more expensive than papercrete. According to one practitioner, a
six-inch thick papercrete roof can be constructed for about 75 cents per square foot, including a paint
sealer. A Spanish tile roof would cost $11.00 per square foot.
WATERPROOFING
After the second layer of panels are added, a thin layer of papercrete should be added over the outside
surface to fill the cracks and smooth out the entire roof surface. At this point, you can choose to leave
the papercrete untreated, waterproof it, or adopt a hybrid approach - cover it with insulating foam or
steel sheeting.
Kelly Hart has lived in a sand bag home covered with untreated
papercrete for several years with no leaks. His home is located
in an area where there is snow, and accompanying freeze-thaw
cycles. The roof structure on his home has a fairly steep pitch,
like a cone, but he says rainwater does not drain off; it sinks in
before it can reach the ground - and then evaporates.
total R value is about the same as the walls. That is a great envelope for a home, especially
considering that the roof would weigh about eleven pounds per square foot. At that weight, if a wall
were supporting a 25 foot (7.6 meter) span of roof by itself (unlikely), the total load at the base of the
wall would be about 550 pounds per square foot. That is a little less than four pounds per square inch.
Since papercrete is variously rated at well above 100 pounds per square inch, there is a very wide
margin for wet snow or any other additional roof load.
Another approach to roofing in New Mexico was poured
papercrete with a metal roof installed over it. This hasn't leaked
since the building was built five years ago.
Classic El Rey stucco was used on a shed visited in northern New Mexico. This type of
stucco is made with Portland cement, and is colored all the way through - so a scratch or nick won't be
easily seen. The shed was five years old and the stucco was in nearly perfect condition.
Classic stuccoes and a number of new acrylic formulations are available in many colors and textures.
Some are quite expensive and some require an environmental premium. Keep in mind that papercrete
stucco looks great and can wait until a better solution becomes available. Lime might be considered as
well.
Interior finishes include many of the same alternatives as exterior. One approach to interior finish was
used in a large home in Arizona. The owner covered all interior surfaces with a thin layer of drywall joint
compound. A few cracks developed over time.
Kelly Hart has used a white lime wash, which is particularly attractive, in several rooms of his home. He
also discovered a way to mix latex paint 1:10 with water to produce beautiful water-based stains. His
bathroom stain is particularly attractive. Stains not only dress up the look of the papercrete, they also
cut the cost and amount of paint used by ninety percent!
Lime wash on
papercrete ceiling.
A stained papercrete
wall in a bathroom.
FLOORS
Many people using papercrete prefer alternatives to concrete floors, because of expense and
environmental issues. Papercrete itself may not be the best solution for floors since the point pressure
of table and chair legs will indent it - unless a great deal of cement is used. One practitioner we spoke
with makes papercrete floors in yard quantities, about 200 gallons, with six sacks of Portland cement
and about 45 shovelfuls of sand. That provides a hard enough slab to work well with floors.
Some people use papercrete as a sub floor to insulate the floor from the surrounding earth and provide
a base for a radiant heating system.
An earth floor made of adobe, or adobe mixed with papercrete
instead of straw, is an alternative. Earth floors can be finished
and decorated in various ways. There are many books
available about building earth floors.
Another lesser-known option for floors is tamped road base.
Road base, sometimes called "city base," is what is used for
making roads. Be careful. If you simply ask for " road base",
you may get common ABC gravel with little else in it. The type
of road base you need has a mix of rock, sand, clay and dirt in
An adobe earth floor inlaid with specified quantities approved by cities for roadbeds. In the
Phoenix area, the material is called ABC MAG. The MAG
flagstone.
stands for Maricopa Association of Governments. This is a
consortium of cities in Maricopa County where Phoenix is located, hence "city base." ABC MAG has a
mix of under one-inch rock, sand, clay and dirt. This material is applied in several layers. Each layer is
screened finer, dampened, screed, tamped and troweled smooth. After finishing, the top layer should
be as smooth and level as a conventional floor.
Successive screening is a lot of work. With some investigation it's possible to find out what the
constituents of the road base are. Buy them separately and dry mix them using aggregate sizes
FORMAL TESTS
(Find out how to get a papercrete "Technical
Report" compiled in the engineering laboratory of a
major university.)
Anecdotally, a lot is known about papercrete, but
not much has been formally tested. We will be
testing as many parameters as time and funding
permits. As results become available, they will be
This section pertains to setting up a business making and selling great numbers of papercrete blocks,
and/or specializing in building large numbers of papercrete
homes - at least more than one or two. What we are working
on is mainstreaming papercrete as an approved residential
and commercial building material. Our One-Day Papercrete
Commercialization Seminar offers strategies for starting a
business with BetR-blok, a new pressed type of papercrete.
Presently, papercrete in all its forms is a victim of Catch-22. It's
a question of market. Without a market, there's no investment.
Without investment, its difficult to develop a market. Right now, it's a challenge to convince
entrepreneurs to invest in block making operations when few people even know what papercrete is. We
are bringing about gradual change in the area of acceptance, but change takes time, and investors
want a quick return on their investment. So, individuals interested in starting a papercrete business are
probably going to have to work in partnerships like the one we are suggesting or do it on their own - at
least for the time being.
The fact is that there are already markets for papercrete (especially for BetR-blok) just not a mass
market yet. So, to get started, an individual is going to have to develop his or her own market - go out
and get an order for some blocks and then fill the order.
The largest potential market for blocks at this moment is as "in-fill" for homes. Since papercrete is not
formally approved as a "load bearing" building material, it cannot legally be used in most localities to
support a roof. But as in-fill," the papercrete walls are built between roof-supporting posts and filled in
between them, hence "in-fill." The posts are connected to the foundation at the bottom and tied in to
beams on top. The roofing system is built on top of the beams. This approach is commonly called post
and beam." Post and beam design has worked to get many homes and other structures "approved"
around the country - especially in the West. Papercrete works well in this application but the post and
beam approach adds additional un-needed cost and complication to construction. We are striving to get
approval using BetR-blok for "load bearing" applications - no posts. The only hurdle is ICC approval,
which costs money and takes time.
Of course, with some limitations, papercrete can be used to build garages, sheds and other structures,
which do not house people. Another market is garden and perimeter walls, or other landscaping
applications. We have made bowls and planters which have stood the test of time and stood up well in
outside conditions so there are a lot of ways to make money working with papercrete. But here we're
talking about building homes.
It 's possible to build nearly any type of home with BetR-blok if you can find independent engineers to
"stamp" building plans. By approving the plans, the engineers shift the liability from the local Building
Safety office to their own insurance company. Engineers are very dependent on their insurance
companies. They must have liability insurance in order to retain their license to do business. If they
make mistakes resulting in claims, their insurance company may well drop them. If one insurance
company drops them, they probably will not be picked up by another one. This means they will be out
of business - their entire career down the tubes. Engineering firms are especially loath to try anything
new. Their insurance payments are huge and their potential liability formidable. This is the worse case
scenario but it should be understood that it is sometimes difficult to find engineers willing to take on the
responsibility to try something new. And if they do, they will probably want additional tests performed to
justify their assumptions and computations. We have worked with engineers and generally they want
some additional data before they agree to stamps plans - they call it due diligence. As papercrete
becomes more widely known and tested, especially in a consistent form like BetR-blok, it will be less
difficult to find an engineer. Luckily, there are engineers out there - usually individuals - who will work
with papercrete builders. It just takes time to find them. But let's get back to making blocks and building
homes. What are the challenges? The first challenge is getting good information.
INFORMATION
It makes obvious sense to verse oneself on the properties and characteristics of papercrete, whether
you want to sell blocks or build homes. The only way to do that is to read everything available on the
Internet and contact others or read material from others who have already worked with the material.
The frustrating thing about doing that is that previous builders have varying and sometimes conflicting
recommendations about how to do things based on their experience. Most of the knowledgeable people
working with papercrete have not had the time or opportunity to compare notes with other practitioners
about what works and what doesn't. What each person feels is true is only true based on that person's
experience. There are differences of opinion on just about everything - from the "best" mix to the "best"
building method. For example, the construction approach described on this website specifies rebar in
the construction of the walls. Some practitioners feel that rebar is unnecessary. What is needed is a
standard building procedure, which can be permitted anywhere in the country. Part of the problem with
a standard building procedure is papercrete's flexibility. It can be poured, slip formed, formed as blocks,
or as tilt-up panels, "harled," daubed, made into roof panels, etc. A comprehensive building procedure
describing all of these methods will eventually emerge but it hasn't yet. So the best approach is to
decide what product is to be marketed and then set about defining the building approach which fits the
product. That's what we are doing with pressed BetR-blok. No one ever said it was going to be easy,
but we know what works. We've been actively involved in papercrete construction for almost ten years.
We can save people who want to start a business a lot of time and money by passing on our business
experience and offering opportunities for partnerships. That's specifically what we do in our One-Day
Papercrete Commercialization Seminar
VOLUME MIXERS
So far, we and maybe a few other people are the only ones working on equipment to produce
papercrete in volume. This is true because most of the people using papercrete are individuals busy
building their own homes. Part of the reason that volume papercrete mixers haven't been developed yet
goes back to the market for papercrete. Why invest in a developing a mixer for material which isn't in
widespread demand. The other reason is that the people using papercrete are using it because it's
cheap. Environmental and other benefits aside, they are using it because they don't have a lot of
money. So this group doesnt have the time or money to start engineering volume mixers. The lack of a
low cost, high volume mixer has been a barrier to producing papercrete in bulk.
Conventional concrete mixers cannot pulp newspaper or cardboard. But if the paper or cardboard is
hammer milled (pounded by spinning "hammers" into fiber), a conventional small mixer will work fine.
Even a large concrete truck can be used to make the mix with hammer milled paper. But hammer
milled paper cost a lot and therein lies a problem. If the mix components become too expensive, the
profit margin on blocks is lowered to a point where it doesn't make sense to make the blocks that any
mixer is designed to produce. Another approach is to use shredded paper. Shredded paper works in a
conventional concrete mixer. But it takes a lot longer (many more tank turns) to mix papercrete
components using shredded paper, because the shredded paper takes longer to break down than
hammer milled. So the optimum mixer - one which pulps and mixes - does not exist off the shelf.
That's where we come in.
We are perfecting a design for a volume mixer which pulps and mixes newspaper and cardboard - and
then elevates the mix for filling press hoppers or forms. We have a Mega Mixer, which focuses on the
least expensive way to make and move mix. The secret to our approach was our press. Pressed
blocks are strong and consistent regardless of mix variations. That sounds counter intuitive, but the
press makes good blocks with the simplest mix recipe. And simple, in this case - and in most others, is
also the least expensive.
The next challenge to starting a business involves perceptions.
PERCEPTIONS
Most people accept their initial perceptions as fact. "You only
get one chance to make a first impression," as the old saying
goes. This is as true of papercrete as anything else. If a person
goes to look at a home made of papercrete and the home is
minimalist in appearance, that person will equate papercrete
with minimalism. If a person sees a video about papercrete,
and the presentation is amateurishly done, that person will
conclude that papercrete is not to be taken seriously. Once the
impression is made, it's difficult to change. But luckily, some
artist-builders are doing incredible design work with papercrete
Papercrete homes can be built and are radically changing the early impressions of it. There
beautifully, with all the amenities, will be a day in the not too distant future when papercrete will
be a material of choice for beauty, value, and durability.
COMFORT
A home built using innovative or "alternative" construction materials doesn't have to be uncomfortable
to live in. In fact, many of these homes are more interesting to look at and more healthful and
economical to live in than conventional housing - and they usually cost a lot less to build. Shrinking
resources and expanding environmental concerns necessitate closer examination of alternative building
techniques, which at first glance may seem untenable but turn out to offer dividends measured in many
dimensions.
Papercrete, when made with Portland cement, looks a lot like concrete. This is a blessing and a curse.
Many properties of papercrete make it more flexible than concrete, but in some ways it doesnt act or
perform the same as concrete. This leads some people to
think that it isn't as "good" as concrete. The fact is that both
materials have their strengths and weaknesses and both need
to be used properly to be most effective.
When I first saw a pile of papercrete blocks, I was struck by
how rough and irregular they were and how much one block
differed from another. This turns out to be completely natural.
Inconsistencies in mix (see Mixes), the type of paper used, the
makeup of the paper, ambient temperature, humidity, hours of
sunlight and other factors can cause changes in the final
product. Papercrete is very forgiving but not completely
consistent and, fortunately, it doesn't have to be. Pressing is
the solution. Pressed BetR-bloks are strong, straight and
square, and just more attractive than those poured on the ground.
As poured-on-the-ground papercrete blocks dry, they often slump or sag lengthwise and taper inward,
from top to bottom, around their perimeter. This happens especially in a wet mix because there is less
weight at the top of the mix when it is poured and more weight pushing out at the bottom. The result is
a block that is not completely rectangular when viewed from the end, and may be bent slightly over its
length. In addition, the surface of papercrete is often rough and the entire block may have quite a few
small voids in it. At first, papercrete blocks seemed a little primitive to me compared to the perfect
dimensions of concrete blocks and bricks. I quickly came to understand that I had to let "papercrete be
papercrete." It's not concrete or brick or adobe. It's something different and the irregularities are actually
not flaws but characteristics. In reality, the irregular shape is of no consequence and the rough surface
and voids actually allow one block to adhere better to the next block when mortared together with a wet
layer of papercrete.
When a wall of poured-on-the-ground papercrete blocks is
completed, it will never be perfectly smooth - no matter how
much care is taken in laying the block. It doesn't matter that it's
not smooth. In fact, being rough helps the exterior stucco and
interior finish to adhere to the wall. Areas that protrude too
much can easily be trimmed with the claw side of a hammer.
Areas that are too concave are simply built up with papercrete
stucco. In the end, being careful with the outside stucco and
the interior finish covers all seeming imperfections.
Walls made in tall forms, like those used in monolithic concrete
Lex Terry applies papercrete
stucco. No stucco wire is needed. pours, have their own unique characteristics. As explained
HYDROPHILIC
Hydrophilic means having an affinity for water; readily absorbing water. Papercrete is hydrophilic. When
I first learned that, I thought it was a fatal flaw and set about finding a way to make papercrete
waterproof - in other words to make it "hydrophobic." There are ways to waterproof papercrete without
affecting the positive properties of the material. But even without waterproofing, when papercrete
absorbs water (if it was originally mixed with sufficient binder) it doesn't lose its shape. In other words, it
doesn't turn into mush like un-stabilized adobe. When water goes into untreated papercrete, it quickly
evaporates as soon as the rain (or other source of water) stops. Untreated papercrete is temporarily
heavier while carrying the water, but as long as it can shed the water through evaporation (in other
words as long as it can breathe) the water is not harmful. If the water is trapped and retained, mold,
mildew, fungus, etc. may take hold. Trapping water in any building material is to be avoided. That's why
it's best to either let the material breathe or moisture proof it completely. Many structures with untreated
papercrete walls and roofs have been standing for years with no apparent ill effects,
but waterproofing papercrete is practical and possible.
It might not be a great idea to build in a flood plain with papercrete but plywood, drywall and other
materials dont do well in water either. Building in flood plains will probably be prohibited in the not-toodistant future, because insurance companies are trying to refuse issuing insurance to homes
constructed in flood prone areas.
It would seem to make sense that papercrete would do best in dry climates of the world like the Great
American Desert, which comprises a good deal of the western United States. However, there are
homes made partly of paper in locations like Vancouver Island - off British Columbia, Wisconsin and
even Rockport, Massachusetts. The Paper House in Rockport was built in 1924. It's in-filled with
newspapers glued together and covered with varnish. Kelly Hart's home, in the mountains of Colorado,
has been through over 200 freeze-thaw cycles since it was built and has exhibited no degradation or
change in appearance. So humidity, water ,and snow may not be as great an issue as previously
thought.
FLAME RETARDANT
The term "flame retardant" has to be differentiated from "fireproof." Unless you add a significant
percentage of non-flammable material to any papercrete mix, it will burn. It will not burn with an open
flame, but it will smoulder like charcoal and eventually be consumed. Papercrete made with a 4-to-1
ratio of cement to paper, by weight, won't burn at all, but that amount of cement is too costly and may
negatively affect R-value. Papercrete made with a 1-to-1 ratio of cement to paper, by weight, will
smolder like charcoal, but does not burn with an open flame. Smoldering with no flame is considered
flame retardant. So might a fire smolder in a papercrete wall for for some time without detection? The
chances of this happening are extremely low.
A papercrete practitioner tested this possibility and thinks that such an occurrence is highly unlikely. He
bored a three-inch hole in a papercrete wall and emptied an entire can of charcoal lighter fluid inside.
He managed to get the papercrete to begin to smolder, but it would not continue to smolder for long
because of lack of oxygen. It was suggested that fireproof mortar (high percentage of Portland cement
or other fireproof binder) be used between the blocks as walls are erected, and fireproof stucco be used
on the outside of the home to "encase" the blocks in fireproof "containers." This would limit a
smoldering fire to the destruction of only one block in the unlikely event that it should ever occur at all.
In late 2005, we did some additional informal testing on papercrete and fire. A simple mix of boric acid
and borax will completely firepoof papecrete. See the "Informal Tests" section in Tests. In early 2006,
we have been doing experiments with sand content. Adding more sand increases compressive
strength and fire retardancy, but we don't know yet how much it effects "R" value, if any.
So there are significant challenges going into business making papercrete, but every beginning is
difficult. One thing is certain. Papercrete is a concept whose time has come. Papercrete, in its present
form, or something similar to it will have to be developed to stop the avalanche of our forests into our
landfills. In any challenge there is also opportunity. The best future is for those who find the
opportunities in the challenges and benefit themselves, others and the environment with their solutions.
This is our focus.