Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Antacids
The formulation of antacid suspension preparations requires trade-offs between
efficacy and stability, For example, a very stable suspension containing aluminum
hydroxycarbonate and magnesium hydroxide can be prepared if the pH is carefully
adjusted and the is carefully controlled. However, use of a phosphate buffer may
result in a less efficacious product, even though, technically and scientifically
speaking, addition of such a buffer would stabilize the product. The process of
trading off one desire for another could be called optimization. Optimization in the
product development laboratory sometimes results in selecting a balance between
the desires of the formulator and those of the marketing organization. In the
example above, the formulator would have to select a less efficacious buffer to
prevent the insoluble aluminum phosphate from forming so that marketings desire
of having the highest acid neutralizing capacity (ANC) per unit volume (dose) could
be obtained.
Antacids are substances that react with acid in the stomach and, ideally, raise the
pH of the stomach content to between 4 and 5. Antacids neutralize only existing
acid; they do not affect the amount or rate of gastric acid secreted. Antacids do not
neutralize all stomach acid. With usual therapeutic doses they do not raise and
cannot maintain gastric pH higher than 4 to 5. When the pH is increased from 1.3
to 2.3, 90% of the acid is neutralized, and at pH of 3.3, 99% is neutralized.
Antacids also inhibit the conversion of pepsinogen to pepsin, which depends on the
degree of acid neutralization.
Pepsin is most active between pH 1.5 and 2.5. At pH 4 (or greater) pepsin activity
is completely inhibited. For an in-depth discussion of the in vitro interaction
between aluminum hydroxycarbonate and pepsin, the reader is referred to the
papers by Sepelyak et al.(2,3). All antacid products contain at least one of the four
primary neutralizing ingredients: sodium bicarbonate, calcium carbonate, aluminum
salts, and magnesium salts [4]. Pinson and Weart [4] and Garnett [5] describe the
ideal antacid product attributes.
These attributes include:
Potent/Efficient. Small amounts of the product should neutralize large amounts of
gastric acid.
Effective/Long-Acting. The antacid should neutralize gastric acid for a prolonged
period of time without causing either rebound acid secretion or release of carbon
dioxide after reacting with gastric acid.
Safe. The product should not affect electrolyte balance or blood glucose or cause
diarrhea or constipation. The product should neither interfere with other drugs the
patient is taking nor contain large amounts of the other ingredients that might
exacerbate concomitant disease(s).
Inexpensive. The patient may be taking the product for a long time.
Palatable. A prerequisite for successful antacid therapy. Palatability of antacids is
an important issue because the products must be dosed at a high frecuency to
provide consistent suppression of gastric acidity. Therapeutic failure can result
when patients do not comply with dosing regimen [6].
No commercially available product fulfills all of these criteria. Aluminum
hydroxycarbonate is known to cause constipation. Magnesium hydroxide causes
laxation. Sodium carbonate can cause systemic alkalosis, does cause acid
rebound, and releases carbon dioxide. Calcium carbonate may induce gastric
hypersecretion [7-10] and also releases carbon dioxide. In high potency antacids,
hexitols (such as mannitol and/or sorbitol) are added to reduce the tendency of the
product to gel. However, sorbitol can cause laxation if large amounts are ingested.
The taste of an antacid can be affected by the additives. Potassium citrate, which
can be used as a buffer, tastes unpleasant. Parabens, which are used as
preservatives, impart a numbing sensation and aftertaste, which is accentuated by
peppermint [11].
COMPONENTS OF ANTACID OR CLAY SUSPENSIONS
A typical antacid or clay suspension contains, in addition to the active ingredients,
a number of excipients that, in combination, are designed to deliver to the patient a
pleasant tasting, microbial-free, acid-reactive antacid or absorbent clay.
c. Calcium Carbonate. This raw material is used both alone or in combination with
aluminum and magnesium hydroxide. The stoichiometry of its reaction with
hydrochloric acid is
CaCO3 + 2 HCl ---- CaCl2 + CO2 + H2O
Calcium carbonate is a crystalline mineral known as calcite. Crystalline calcium
carbonate reacts rapidly with hydrochloric acid. It quickly raises the gastric pH
above pH 3. Rossett-Rice testing indicates the pH is maintained at 7, which may
trigger acid rebound.
Calcium carbonate is classified as a non-systemic antacid because it does not tend
to cause a systemic alkalosis. However, chronic use of large doses of calcium
carbonate may cause renal pathology or some systemic alkalosis [23). Calcium
carbonate has a constipating effect when used in large doses. It may cause
flatulence because of the release of carbon dioxide when reacted with hydrochloric
acid.
It is available in several grades, differing in particle size. In general, the particle
size is varied by adjusting the concentration of the reactants used in its
manufacture. In suspensions the light grade, exhibiting a mean particle size in the
range of 1 to 4 um, is typically used.
D. Magnesium Trisilicate. This material, having the general formula
2MgO.3SiO2xH2O, has a long history of use as an antacid and as an adsorbent.
The stoichiometry of its reaction with hydrochloric acid is
2MgO.3SiO2.xH2O + 4HCl ----- 2MgCl2 + 3SiO2 + (x+2)H2O
Magnesium trisilicate is a weak antacid. Because of its slow onset of action, it is
not able to meet the current pH requirements for nonprescription antacids [24],
Therefore, it is typically used in conjunction with other antacid raw materials. The
hydrated silicon dioxide is a by-product of the above reaction. Traces of silicon
dioxide may be absorbed and excreted in the urine [25].
In the stomach, unreacted magnesium trisilicate may adhere to the ulcer crater and
provide some cytoprotective action. Magnesium trisilicate is classified as a nonsystemic antacid. The acid-consuming capacity over a 4-hour period at 37C for
magnesium trisilicate is approximately 15 meq of hydrochloric acid per gram of
dried material [27].
Magnesium trisilicate does not inactivate pepsin in solutions below pH 6 [28]. It
does bind some bile acids, but it does so to a lesser extent than aluminum
hydroxide [22]. It has a laxative effect in large doses. It is supplied as a fine white
odorless powder.
B. Suspending Agents
Suspending agents are used to prevent rapid settling and caking of some antacid
raw materials. They are often capable of improving the mouthfeel of antacids,
which, as a rule, are gritty and chalky. Only suspending agents that are stable at
relatively high pH's (7.5-9.5) should be considered.
Because many antacid raw materials have some limited solubility,
suspending agents that may undergo cross-linking in the presence of polyvalent
cations should be avoided. Of course, sequestrants may be used to improve the
stability of anionic suspending agents.
Suspensions develop large aggregates during repeated freeze-thaw cycles;
these settle rapidly and cause a grainy texture. Some polymeric suspending agents
are effective in improving the freeze-thaw stability of a suspension. Hydroxypropyl
methylcellulose, methylcellulose, sodium carboxymethylcellulose, sodium alginate,
and povidone (PVP) have all been shown to offer protection against this
phenomenon.
1. Antacid Suspensions
The following includes suspending agents commonly found in antacid suspensions.
a.Avicel RC 591 (FMC Corporation). Avicel RC 591 consists of 89%
microcrystalline cellulose and 11% sodium carboxymethylcellulose. It is stable over
a broad pH range. Avicel RC 591 forms thixotropic gels at low concentrations that
show shear-thinning with mild agitation. It is flocculated by cationic polymers and
surfactants.
b.Alginates. Alginates are high molecular weight anionic hydrophilic
polysaccharides. Alginates are natural products derived from brown seaweed. The
viscosity of their solutions decreases with increasing temperature, but this is
partially reversible. Alginate solutions are typically pseudoplastic and stable
between pH 4 and 10. Alginates form precipitates with polyvalent cations (except
magnesium) and are incompatible with quaternary nitrogen compounds.
c. Methylcellulose-Hydroxypropyl Methylcellulose. The methyl ether of
cellulose an its hydroxypropyl derivate form water-soluble non-ionic
polysaccharide polymers. They are soluble in in cold water and insoluble in hot
water. Their solutions are typically pseudoplastic and nonthixotropic. The viscosity
of these solutions decreases as temperature is increase until the gel point is
reached. They have some surface-active properties, can function as emulsifiers,
and cause foaming. They are stable in the pH range from 3 to 11.
d. Guar Gum. Guar gum is a high molecular weight nonionic polysaccharide
polymer. It is a natural product and is a cold water- swelling polymer. Its solutions
are pseudoplastic and nonthixotropic. The viscosity of its solutions decreases
reversibly as temperature increases. Prolonged heating causes irreversible loss of
viscosity. It is susceptible to biological attack. Guar gum has good pH stability.
e. Hydroxypropylcellulose. This is the hydroxypropyl derivate of cellulose. It is a
nonionic polysaccharide polymer with optimal stability between pH 6 and 8. It is
soluble in water below 40C and precipitates above 45C. Its solutions are
pseudoplastic and nonthixotropic. It possesses some surface-active properties
and, therefore, may cause foaming. It is incompatible with the parabens.
E. Anticaking-Antigelling Agents
These materials are used to provide for the redispersal of settled solids. They are also supposed
to prevent gelation of antacid suspensions. Listed below are ingredients typically used to
prevent caking and/or gelling.
EDTA. This excipient is used to sequester polyvalent cations that may cause the crosslinking of some suspending agents, thus leading to increased viscosity or gelation.
Citric acid or potassium citrate. These sequesterants are used in suspensions
containing aluminum hydroxide to lower the product's viscosity and to prevent interaction of
aluminum hydroxide with magnesium compounds.
Potassium Phosphate. Potassium phosphate is use both as a buffering and a
sequestering agent.
Silica. Cab-O-Sil, Aerosilm and Quso are commercial forms of silica. They are very
effective anticaking agents, although they may affect both the product viscosity and mouthfeel
in high concentrations. They also can reduce the degree f sedimentation of a suspension.
F. Flavor-Mouthfeel System
The flavor and mouthfeel systems are an important part of any antacid suspension. Because
many consumers of antacids use the products for extended periods of time, the palatability of a
suspension is of utmost importance.
The selection of a flavor involves the evaluation of the following criteria: (a) stability at
high pH, (b) stability in glass or plastic bottle, (c) ability to mask the taste of undesirable flavor
components, (d) appeal to most segments of the patient population, and (e) availability in dry
form, if comparable chewable tablet is planned.
When evaluating various flavor systems for an antacid suspension, one should monitor
the initial taste, mouthfeel, chalkiness, grittiness, and aftertaste.
The following flavors are typically found in currently marketed antacid suspensions: (a)
mints (peppermint, spearmint, and wintergreen), (b) citrus (lemon, lime, and orange), (c) cream
(vanilla), and (d) anise.
Nonflavor ingredients are often used to improve the mouthfeel of an antacid. They
include: (a) mineral oil, milk solids, (c) glycine, and (d) natural and artificial gums.
G. Coloring Agents
All water-soluble coloring agents have a charge and can interact: with oppositely charged
compounds such as antacids and clays. The resulting compound is water insoluble. This can
make the suspension color appear very heterogeneous.
The best way to prevent such an interaction is to use a colored lake.
H. Water
A final ingredient in all antacid and clay suspensions, one having a profound effect on the
palatability and stability of the product, is water. Water is the major ingredient in antacid and
clay suspensions. It acts both as the vehicle and as the solvent for various components in the
suspension.
It should not be overlooked that the quality of water is not necessarily a constant. The
waters method of preparation, its handling and its storage are crucial to the development of a
suitable antacid and/or clay suspension product. Water requires careful consideration and
monitoring.
Various grades of water are available. They include tap water, distilled water, deionized
water, filtered water, and chlorinated water. The major impurities in water are calcium,
magnesium, iron, silica, and sodium. These cations are usually combined with carbonate,
bicarbonate, sulfate, and chloride anions.
Deionization can be accomplished by distillation, ion exchange, or reverse osmosis. The
prevention of growth of microorganisms in the water must also be addressed. Such processes
are chlorination, ozonation, ultraviolet light, heating, and filtration are effective in limiting this
growth.
A final word of caution: All experiments an scaleup testing shoul be conducted with the
same grade of water as that used I the production facility.
VI. ANTACID SUSPENSION FORMULATION
A formulated antacid suspension must meet many specific requirements. The proper
blending of various factors is needed in order to accomplish the objetives. Following is a
list of typical objetives for an antacid suspension to meet:
O.T.C. monograph
Contribution of at least 25% of labeled ANC by each active ingredient
Desired potency requirement (milliequivalents of HCI neutralized per mL)
Listing of acceptable antacid actives
Antiflatulents included?
Permitted sweetener content (artificial versus natural)
Laxation/constipation balance
Permitted sodium content
Viscosity range
Flavor preferences
Color preferences
In general, the role of an antacid is to raise the pH of the gastric contents and, subsequently,
to reduce the amount of acid emptied into the duodenum.
It should be pointed out over 95% of the hydrogen ion concentration is neutralized
at pH 3.5 A further consequence of the raising of the gastric pH is the reduction in the
activity of the enzyme pepsin and the conversion of pepsinogen to pepsin. Finally,
GENERAL PROCEDURE
1. Charge a large mixing tank with purified water at about 40% of the total water required.
2. Add the sorbitol to a smaller mixing tank, and dilute with an equal amount of purified
water. This mixing tank should have a dynamic mixing system. Next, add the citric acid and
sodium saccharin followed by the parabens, which have to be dispersed well under dynamic
conditions.
3. Add magnesium hydroxide paste to the large mixing tank with continuous agitation.
4. Pump the contents of the smaller tank into the large vessel. Rinse the small tank with
purified water into the larger one.
5. Next, add the aluminum hydroxide gel followed by the flavors.
6. Add the remainder of the purified water to the desired end volume or weight.
7. Mix until uniform.
If marketing wants a product with an antiflatulent, simethicone can be added to the
product.
2. Antacid/Antijlatulent Formula
The following example should yield a product providing a dose of about 200 mg of magnesium
hydroxide and about 200 mg of aluminum hydroxide with about 20 mg of simethicone per
teaspoonful.
GENERAL PROCEDURE
1. Charge the mixing tank with the purified water at about 40% of the total water required.
2. In another smaller mixing tank, disperse the methylcellulose with a high-shear mixture
in 1.5% of the above purified water. Once the methylcellulose is completely dispersed,
add the simethicone. When the mixture is uniform pump into the large tank while
mixing. Wash out with 1.0% of the purified water.
3. Mix the methyl and propyl parabens into a slurry with about 2% of the purified water.
Add the paraben slurry to the large mixing tank with agitation. Wash out the small tank
with 112% of the purified water.
4. Mix the AVICEL and hydroxypropyl cellulose with about 13% of the purified water
with vigorous agitation in a smaller vessel. Keep agitating while making the remainder
of the formulation.
5. Add the magnesium hydroxide paste to the large manufacturing tank with continuous
agitation. Pump in the gums from Item No.4 and rinse with 1% of the purified water.
Next add the aluminum hydroxide gel.
6. Add the citric acid, sodium saccharin, and sorbitol solution.
7. Next add the flavorings and the remainder of the purified water to the desired end
volume or weight.
8. Mix until uniform.
If an extra-strength product is desired by marketing, the formulator will have to use a lower
viscosity grade of antacid raw materials. In order to provide a low-viscosity grade of aluminum
hydroxide and/or magnesium hydroxide, manufacturers increase the particle size of the
suspended actives. The reason is straightforward if the reader considers the following
explanation by Hem [35].
GENERAL PROCEDURE
GENERAL PROCEDURE
1. Dissolve the methyl and propylparaben in the sorbitol solution, syrup, glycerin, and 50
mL water previously mixed in a suitable container, by heating to 60C with rapid
stirring.
2. Cool to room temperature and add the antacid product, stirring thoroughly to
disperse antacid.
3. Add the flavor and sufficient water to make 1000 mL.
4. Homogenize. Hand homogenizers, homomixers, and colloid mills are all
satisfactory and yield products with comparable viscosities.
5. Magaldrate Formula
The following formula shows that magaldrate does not need any special buffering to
stabilize the system.
GENERAL PROCEDURE
1. Charge mixin tank with about one-half of required purified water.
2. Add magaldrate gel to tank with agitation.
3. In smaller tank disperse hydroxypropyl methylcellulose with one-fourth of the
required purified water with dynamic agitation. Next add sodium saccharin and
parabens.
4. Pump contents of small vessel into larger mixing tank and rinse with purified water.
5. Add flavors, plus the remaining purified water.
6. Mix until uniform.
Table I is presented in order for the reader to troubleshoot formulations and to help the formulator
resolve common problems that are usually associated with antacid products. Most of the time it is
necessary to balance the pH/PZC ratio and to check particle size of the homogenized suspension at
the same time. These two formulation variables usually need to be optimized in order to balance
these sometimes opposing factors. The effect of pH on the apparent viscosity of two suspensions
that have two different particle sizes was shown by Hem [35]. Hem pointed out that a suspension
containing smaller particle size particles exhibited a tenfold increase in apparent viscosity at the
PZC whereas a suspension consisting of larger particle sizes shows only a fourfold increase in
apparent viscosity at the PZC.