Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Analysis and
Activities
The Shoe
Horn Sonata
Standard English HSC
Act One
The opening scene, with Bridie demonstrating the deep, subservient bow, the kowtow,
demanded of the prisoners by their Japanese guards during tenko, transports the audience into
the past action.
Now in the present, Rick poses questions as music and images from the war period appear
behind Bridie, establishing the element of the filming of a television documentary as Bridie is
asked to arouse the events from fifty years ago. This scene establishes Bridie, and introduces
the given circumstances: the recollection and re-living of memories of the years of imprisonment.
This section also reveals the grave dangers the prisoners faced; over-crowded ships moving
towards an enemy fleet, the fear of rape and the lack of preparedness of the British stronghold in
Singapore for the offensive.
In Scene Two we are introduced to Sheila and the major conflict of the play, where Misto sets up
some of the issues that will arise between the Australian Bridie and the former English girl Sheila.
Sheilas arrival at the motel from Perth introduces the audience to the fact that the women have
been estranged for many decades, as each seeks out basic information about personal details;
marriage and children.
Status and suspense are introduced when Sheila does not reciprocate Bridies exclamation of
delight Gee its good to see you, and the audience is left wondering as to why until the end of
Act One.
The physical language between the two described on Page 26 indicates underlying tension and
yet the scene ends with their re-enactment of an old ritual (The lifting of the suitcase as they
pg. 1
used to lift the coffins of the dead: to the cries of Ichi, ni, san---Ya-ta!), demonstrating that their
connection lies in their traumatic shared experiences. Act One continues with the shared
memories of Bridie and Sheila reflecting those of the audience, through the use of dramatic
techniques.
Scene Three: The audience is reminded of how young Sheila was when she was taken prisoner.
The voice of a teenage girl sings part of Jerusalem, the stirring and visionary song with words
by English poet William Blake, and the mature Sheila joins in. The song returns later when Bridie
and Sheila sing it together.
We also learn in Scene Three that Bridie exhibits a protective manner when they first meet
drifting in the sea after being shipwrecked. Her perception is that Sheila is another stuck-up
Pom, and strikes her with her shoehorn to keep her awake. Sheilas bias is then revealed,
having been taught prejudice towards the Irish by her mother and indeed is the label she plants
on Bridie, the Sydney nurse from Chatswood with an Irish surname.
Scene Five: Further differences between the two surface in the description of the officers club
set up by the Japanese. But by the end of this scene they are recalling the choir and the
orchestra of womens voices set up by Miss Dryburgh.
Scene Six sees a more spirited pair in a conga line singing the parodies of well-known songs
theyd used to taunt their captors and keep their spirits up before their differing attitudes and
tension again emerge as revelations increase about the deteriorating conditions for the prisoners
and the unrelenting deaths, particularly in the Belalau camp.
At the end of the Act, Sheila returns the Shoehorn, she claimed she had sold for quinine to save
Bridies life but in fact she traded sex for medicine with the enemy. Sheila experiences a crushing
realization when she extracts from Bridie, the suggestion through silence, that she would not
have done the same for her.
All these years Ive told myself that youd have done the same for me. [Calmly] I was wrong,
though, wasnt I?
Act Two
Act Two opens in the recording studio, as Bridie and Sheila report the appalling conditions in the
death camp of Belalau where the warning from Prison guards that no prisoners would survive the
war was declared, building suspense as to how this could have been possible for both our
characters. Soon it becomes clear that in the years since the war ended, Sheila has led a quiet
life as a librarian in Perth and has not been able to sustain a sexual relationship; nor felt able to
return to Britain or to face remaining with her family in Singapore. She discloses that she drinks
and experiences nightmarish recollections about Lipstick Larry. Bridie however, had been happily
married for years to an Australian soldier who had flirted with her at Christmas behind the wire
and is now widowed and childless.
Scene Twelve: Bridies tells of an event where, when surrounded by a group of Japanese
tourists in David Jones Food Hall, she runs away with a tin of shortbread and later pleads guilty
in court to shoplifting. I still lie awake cringing with shame, she tells Sheila. She could not
explain the truth to the court or to family and friends. The effect of this event on Sheila surprises
Bridie who decides that peace can only be attained if the truth is faced publically.
There are probably thousands of survivors like us, still trapped in the war, too ashamed to tell
anyone.
Scene Thirteen: It is Bridie who reveals the truth of Sheilas courageousness and self-sacrifice
when she recounts how they were rescued, after which she asks Sheila to clarify her shoplifting
arrest. The tensions between the two now slowly dissolve as all confidences have been
expressed. The scene ends with the assertion Bridie has been waiting five decades for:
pg. 2
pg. 3
Activities: Synopsis
pg. 4
Act / Scene
Main historical
features
Where is this
scene set?
What other
settings does
this scene refer
to in the
dialogue or
stage direction?
What is revealed
about Bridie and
Sheilas
experience of
the war?
What is the
purpose of this
scene?
I, i
I, ii
I, iii
I, iv
I, v
I, vi
I, vii
I, viii
I, ix
I, x
II, xi
II, xii
II, xiii
pg. 5
Each elective in this module requires study of a prescribed text through a key aspect of
language. This provides the basis for the study and use of this aspect of language in other texts,
including texts drawn from students own experience.
Students examine particular language structures and features used in the prescribed text and in
a range of situations that they encounter in their daily lives. They explore, examine and analyse
how the conventions of textual forms, language modes and media shape meaning. Composition
focuses on experimentation with variations of purpose, audience and form to achieve different
effects. These compositions may be realised in a variety of forms and media. (Refer to the
English Stage 6 Syllabus, p 30.)
pg. 6
The Distinctively Visual elements we must use our imaginations to visualise: the imagined
images what we dont see but know to exist; verbal flashbacks, descriptive explanations,
olfactory and other sentient imagery
How the form of Mistos text presents the opportunity to explore Distinctively Visual elements
dialogue, stage directions, directors notes; how verbal imagery creates images of the past or
present; historical language. How language affects interpretation impact of the dialogue on the
other characters in the cast; close examination of how verbal imagery creates the range of
perspectives of the experiences of each woman
How form affects interpretation drama - play - written versus stage performance impact of
gestures; action on the stage; interaction with props and other characters in the cast;
characterisation; costuming; score; lighting; sound effects; symbols; set construction, audience
interaction
How form shapes meaning audience expectations; impact of theatre as a political, social and
cultural medium; impact of sets in engaging and providing context for the audience
You will need to consider the techniques that need to be deconstructed that are explicitly and
literally visual as well as deconstructing the language features of the script itself. You should
consider how visual metaphors are created by the juxtaposition of photographs and props,
characters and staging when combined with the language of the script itself.
pg. 7
reading, listening and viewing that depend on, but go beyond, the decoding of texts
the shaping and arrangement of textual elements to explore and express ideas, emotions
and values
texts.
knowledge understanding and use of the language forms, features and structures of
Texts in English Stage 6 are communications of meaning produced in any medium that
incorporates language, including sound, print, film, electronic and multimedia. Texts include
written, spoken, nonverbal or visual communication of meaning. They may be extended unified
works or presented as a series of related pieces.
Context is used in its broadest sense. It refers to the range of personal, social, historical, cultural
and workplace conditions in which a text is responded to and composed.
Language modes refers to the modes of listening, speaking, reading, writing, viewing and
representing*. These modes are often integrated and interdependent activities used in
responding to and composing texts in order to shape meaning.
It is important to realise that:
the refinement of the skills in any one of the modes develops skills in the others.
Students need to build on their skills in all language modes.
Representing is the language mode that involves composing images by means of visual or other
texts. These images and their meaning are composed using codes and conventions. The term
can include activities such as graphically presenting the structure of a novel, making a film,
composing a web page, or enacting a dramatic text.
Language forms and features is the term used to refer to the symbolic patterns and
conventions that shape meaning in texts. These vary according to the particular mode or medium
of production and can include written, spoken, nonverbal or visual communication of meaning.
Structures of texts is the term used to refer to the relationship of different parts of a text to each
other, and to the text as a complex whole.
pg. 8
Synonyms for text should be inserted to identify the text type being discussed such as:
poem, short story, newspaper article, song lyric, speech, novel, fiction text, website,
image, artwork, documentary, etc
The text suggests
The text provides opportunities
The text challenges
The text highlights
The text provokes
The text indicates
The text educates
The context (social, cultural. political, religious, gender, historical, intellectual, personal) is
(suggested, exposed, highlighted) through the use of
The context has been highlighted through the development of
The composer has provided a contextual focus by.
Contextually the text suggests
The values of the text are conveyed through the use of
The composers values are exposed when
The composers values are exposed by
Values of.. are explored through the text using
The audience for the text is suggested through.
pg. 9
pg. 11
pg. 13
Make reference to your core text and at least ONE text of your own choosing.
To what extent is this statement true in relation to the texts you have studied?
Make reference to your core text and at least ONE text of your own choosing.
(c) We are challenged by the images constructed in texts as they force us to examine the
way we respond to the values of others.
How has this idea presented in the texts you have studied?
Make reference to your core text and at least ONE text of your own choosing.
pg. 14
and the projection of slides of prosperous Singapore before the fall, signifying the last bastion
of the ____________ ___________ . Note the ________________ comment on the last slide
that projects the words, 'Don't listen to rumour' - 'If only they had ...'
Silence
Shoe-horn
Posters
Engaging
Playwrights
Audience
British Empire
Effect
TV studio
Darkness
Darkness
Singapore
Candour
Photographs
pg. 16
How it adds to
establishing main ideas of
the play
Stage directions
Creates audience
anticipation; audience is
questioning and
disorientated; it immerses
the audience in Bridies
narrative and there is an
absence of visual prompts
on the stage
These images are of nurses to
reinforce Bridies assertions
of young women,
embarking off the ships in
Johore Bahrum, the laughter
expressing innocence and
happiness, unaware of the
future that lay ahead. These
images are from the
Australian War Memorial and
as such, are historical
artefacts of the experience.
The visuals are historical
documents that provide
veracity to the historical
nature of Mistos text.
Visual juxtaposition of
images
pg. 17
Shoe-horn is introduced as
Bridie narrates in her
monologue her fathers
response to her enlisting on
p. 20
There are three things
every young soldier should
know. Always use a shoehorn
Rule Britannia
Is juxtaposed to BRIDIEs
disgust of the Britishs failure
to take the invasion of
Singapore seriously and
jeopardise the womens
safety. Rule Britannia is a
Dramatic irony
Imagery
Emotive language
Motif
juxtaposition
Colloquial language
Use of music
pg. 18
jingoistic (patriotic /
nationalistic) British song
celebrating the British
Empire.
pg. 19
1. Use the phrases below to complete the following summary of Act One, Scene Two.
pg. 20
How it adds to
establishing main ideas of
the play
Hearing aid
p. 24
SHIELA: You say
something then? Youll
have to talk into the good
ear.
BRIDIE: Good ear?
[Notices the hearing aid
and says quite loudly.]
Hows that?
Symbolismmetaphor
gloves
[SHIELA is carrying
gloves.]
Dialogue:
BRIDIE: She was sure
youd consider it
unrefined going on
television airing your
feelings.
SHEILA: Well youve got
to admit its not very
dignified. P. 25
pg. 21
Irony
Paradox
pp. 26-29
pg. 22
What visual elements are evident in this scene ? (Provide ONE with an example)
pg. 23
Writing Activity
Convert your answers into a cohesive paragraph. (Topic Sentence, Technique
Example, Purpose, Analysis, Linking Sentence)
pg. 24
Analysis Activities
1. Read the following summary of Scene Three. As you read, highlight dramaturgical and
language techniques in one colour and highlight the effect in another colour. Highlight
visual elements or imagery in another colour. (e.g. projections of images, imagery,
mannerisms etc) that refer to specifically visual elements or imagery. The sections you
need to highlight are underlined.
This scene places the focus on Sheilas story presenting both the similarities and differences
between the women. The parallels are evident - both have had the same experience; they have
common memories and unique insights into the other which, despite the fifty years of separation
presents images that highlights unity with all its accompanying tension. The scene begins with
the two women in a studio; their dialogue is presented in voice over as they settle in to the
interview. The tension and nervousness between them is obvious through the body language
embedded in the dialogue and the antagonistic nature of the retorts between them. The
interviewer is focussed on Sheilas narrative of events thus driving the plot in terms of events and
in introducing her story as the other key protagonist of the play. The male voice, Rick,
immediately engages with the confronting question of why Sheila had remained in Singapore
pg. 25
despite the threat of Japanese attack implying the lack of foresight by the British. Sheilas
response suggests that she has been raised with a sense of propriety and that her mannerisms
and cultural understandings of the world echo the historical perspective of Empire.
The use of slides at this juncture presents literal images that present the evacuation. Mistos
stage directions not only direct the actors here, he uses them to present his personal reflection
and commentary and as these comments would not be spoken on the stage presents insight
into his deep sympathy for the victims of the disaster that impacted on women affected by the
experience.
Imagery is presented in the humourous but ironic depiction of the instructions given to Sheila by
her mother which are a concrete parallel with those presented by Bridies father. Confronting
imagery is presented here by Sheila who describes the contrasting idyllic imagery of what the
women and children thought was a brief, if not crowded sojourn (stop / rest) to the horrors and
panic emphasised by the reference to spotlights.
The staging echoes the verbal imagery with Sheila standing in a spotlight on the stage; her
monologue continues presenting graphic imagery of the events the clarity of her memory is
confronting especially considering the first audience for this play consisted of many women
who had experienced this exact event. Similes, imperative verbs, and the first person
account- sustain the tension and panic of the event, however, the stage directions suggest the
language is presented calmly. Misto is creating here an almost objective account void of
emotion which is further emphasised by the interviewers questions about whether Sheila was
afraid at this point and her denial of being so at least with this perspective of memory. Bridies
re-entering of the action in a brief statement of dialogue at this point negates the calm and
unemotional narrative reinforcing Sheilas British stiff upper lip agenda - provoking Rick to press
for Sheilas emotional response. Sentience (is the ability to feel, perceive, or experience
subjectively) is constructed for the audience through the sound effects of lapping waves the
sensory imagery meant to take both audience and Sheila back to the event a form of aural
flashback.
pg. 26
Sheilas response presents the images of darkness, the smothering effect of oil, the isolation,
and her own remembered images of warmth when she was experiencing shock and the effects
of the cold water.
The stage directions tell us here that this religious connotation is extended and embedded in
Sheilas British Christian concept of self. A young voice, the young Sheila, sings Jerusalem
presenting rousing images of Empire used to fortify the patriotism of its inhabitants. The verb
whimpering, in contrast, is used by Misto suggesting the image of a fragile and frightened child
belying the representation Sheila is attempting to present as an adult. The poignancy of the
voices of the young (off stage voice) and old Sheila (onstage) connect the past and the present.
The lines from Jerusalem imply imagery of deliverance and salvation. The bathos (Bathos is a
story-telling technique that follows serious ideas with the commonplace or ludicrous. The
juxtaposition of these ideas creates humour.) presented in her evaluation of the event, and the
fact that she was there in the sea with no gloves and her comments about being at school and
living in the privileged world of chaperones creates a stark image of vulnerability and reinforces
Bridies comments.
Explicit images are presented on stage again allowing a transition point in the dialogue, to shift
from Sheilas perspective of events to Bridies. The experience in image has shifted from smiling
faces boarding ships to slides depicting the bombing of Singapore harbour with confronting
images of ships burning and smoke filled skies to sustain the historical narrative.
Bridies account also reinforces the sense of calm that she experienced or remembers
experiencing as the Vyner Brooke was attacked by the Japanese. The counting of the bombs,
the fact that so many missed and that it only took one to lead to the demise of the ship and so
many lives presents provocative imagery. Images of death and the lack of organisation impact
on the audience; the visceral images of raw burned hands and women sliding down ropes to
the water emphasises the ingenuity and pragmatism of the experience. Childhood reflections of
conversations with her father and of not being able to swim add weight to the tension of the
scene. Bridie then recounts her first meeting with Sheila which is once again punctuated by the
British propriety she maintains. The imaginary shoe horn is reprised here signifying its
pg. 27
importance to the play as a motif; the sensory imagery of water, cold, hitting, splashing
culminates in both women singing lines, once again from Jerusalem, this time about mental
strength, both in their memories and on stage.
2. Use the above analysis of the scene to complete the table below. You will need to
complete this in your own notes.
Dramaturgy / Language /
Visual Element
Imagery
Motif
Shoe-horn
symbolism
Gloves
pg. 28
pg. 29
pg. 30
pg. 31
Writing Activity
Convert your answers into a cohesive paragraph. (Topic Sentence, Technique Example,
Purpose, Analysis, Linking Sentence)
pg. 32
pg. 33
Writing Activity
Convert your answers into a cohesive paragraph. (Topic Sentence, Technique Example,
Purpose, Analysis, Linking Sentence)
pg. 34
1. How have the women reacted to their television interview? How is the huimour used to
convey their different attitudes?
Name of
character
Bridie
Sheila
2. Comic relief is used in the making of the loin cloths. What insights do we get into Bridie
as well as her relationship with Sheila?
pg. 35
Further Analysis
In this following analysis the dramatic and language techniques are bolded.
The idea are underlined.
The purpose and effect of the dramatic and language techniques are in italics. You are to read
through this analysis with a peer and complete the tables.
Purpose verbs are underlined and in italics.
As you read through you should highlight these in different colours to make it more obvious.
This scene uses tone and mood to construct the juxtaposing image of tension and friendship
between the two women. The literal images of interaction and the body language and
expressions used on the stage are powerful and real. The power of this performance lies in its
ability to confront audiences with the veracity truth of the shared experience; the characters
represent the sense of easy familiarity we have with people we have been intimately involved
with and how that shifts and changes, or, can be reprised so readily even after fifty years of
separation.
Mistos stage directions present many references to looking or seeing in this scene Bridie
closely examining the menu the focus not really about what is on the menu or highlighting the
malapropism (malapropism - the mistaken use of a word in place of a similar-sounding one,
often with an amusing effect (e.g. dance a flamingo instead of flamenco ),), rather, it is
about not seeing - trying to avoid the gulf of unspoken thoughts and emotions that have
been repressed during the period since the women last saw each other.
Other distraction techniques are employed - picking up the glass and fussing, all creating a
busyness on the stage rather than the inevitability of these women really sharing and
remembering; the actions imply a fear of stopping, of saying what needs to be said and the
dramatic tension of the play builds. The stage directions here to engage with how the women
interact and how the adverbs used present the intended visual to be constructed for the
audience.
pg. 36
Mistos dialogue for Sheila directs us to look at and experience her hearing aid an excuse
for shutting off in previous scenes to one of static in this scene selective deafness is one thing
but here Sheilas actions and dialogue force us to consider the noise that she has heard, that the
memories themselves, instinctual visceral and confronting, still resonate despite the time that has
passed. Sheila also refers to the lights in the studio - the bright lights of the studio are
metaphorical reminders of her fears being exposed, of being judged and thus becoming
vulnerable once more anathema which is abhorrent (hated) to her sense of British identity.
The tensions only begin to ease once Sheila proceeds to leave the room. The scene shifts to
reveal the power relationship between the women in the camp. Sheilas claim that she was
ordered around by Bridie reinforces the ways in which the women encouraged and protected
each other during their captivity. Once again the adverbs in the stage directions imply tone
and mood allowing us to engage with the real tension, fear and relationship the two women
have experienced in the past. The complexity of Mistos agenda purpose resonates in the
dialogue: the need to negotiate between criticising the English and their hubristic pride filled
ignorance which resulted in the extensive loss of life and being seen as being racist towards the
Japanese.
Time has shifted the political perspectives and racial derision which was so strongly asserted
during WWII (already referred to in early scenes in the language of Bridies father and Sheilas
mother); to some extent, this play highlights the challenges of coming to terms with what
happened or being able to speak about it by those who suffered at the hands of such cruelty.
The reflective stance, begun when Sheila pretends to face the camera direct address to the
audience presents a visual recount of Sheilas memories of Lipstick Larry. The name
presents humourous visual connotations; however, these connotations become further
reinforced by the images of loin cloths, boxer shorts and rusty pins. The culmination of this
scene reinforces the bonds that unite the women; their laughter and humour is bittersweet
however, as even a humourous memory reminds them of the ever-present fear and danger,
pg. 37
control and disempowerment they experienced. Mistos stage directions, or aside if one likes,
presents the idea that for just a moment the women had defeated the enemy giving
them psychological empowerment.
The sound effects off stage presents confronting aural imagery of the violence perpetrated
against the women. We do no need to see the beating to feel and experience the immense
pain it would have brought in terms of sentient emotional memories for the first audience
and indeed for subsequent audiences. In hindsight, whilst both women can laugh at the
remembered images, the audience sees with poignant reality, why the bond exists between
the women. The scene ends dramatically, the sensory experience of sounds of a women
being beaten and the blackness of the stage present the metaphor of loss dignity and
freedom of the women and the lack of integrity of the captors.
1. Read the scene summary.
2. Write summary statements about the ideas in this scene.
i)
What is the tension in their relationship that is continued from previous scenes?
ii)
What is being said about seeing the truth in this scene? What is being said about
memory in this scene?
iii)
How is the violence against women portrayed in this scene?
3. Complete the following table. You should complete this following table expanded in your
own notes.
Techniques
Tensions in their
relationship
Examples of
Techniques and
quotations from
Shoe Horn
Visual Elements
Effect of visual
elements of the text
Stage directions
Dialogue
Lighting
Use of adverbs
pg. 38
Violence against
women
Direct address to
audience
Use of humour
pg. 39
Motifs
Ideas
pg. 40
Further Analysis
This scene presents confronting imagery of death; callous actions of the Imperial Japanese Army
resulting in the brutal deaths of Australian soldiers, nurses and civilians (albeit defended by the
vagaries of war); starvation of women and children and of the sexual and predatory behaviour
some women were forced to endure during their captivity and, of community and transcendence
of the experience through the references to joining and participating in the choir. The staging
cleverly presents the image of Bridie and Sheila sitting side by side, the equanimity of the
position however, is belied at times by their philosophical positioning and perspective of events.
Inferred tone is presented through the facial expressions and body gestures presented. Mistos
stage directions for the tone, attitude and demeanour of both women covers a range of emotions:
calm, upset, horrified, defensive, surprised, uneasy, annoyed, disgusted, diplomatic, reluctant,
amazed, independent, fond, nostalgic. The dramaturgy required to act out and visualise these
emotions emphasises the intimate sociology of the theatrical experience for the audience as they
interact with the women on the stage.
The sensory experience of sound and image impresses upon the audience the historical veracity
of the event. The score shifts from the ironic beginning track of Happy Times by Jo Stafford
presenting metaphorical images of hope and deliverance which is juxtaposed with the sounds of
machine guns, screams and the crying of women as men and women, nurses from the Vyner
Brooke were taken into the sea and shot. This representation is historically factual and is
referenced in the links below. The visual representation of this scene is depicted by Bridie in
dialogue. Mistos stage directions suggest she says this calmly so the audience see her at this
stage as objective and in control.
The screened photographs used throughout the scene, of women and their daily routine in
Japanese camps, ragged starving children and the close up of the Japanese soldier in menacing
pose has purposeful visual impact. The first image, of the women in the camp is shown at the
same time as the narrative unfolds as Bridie and Sheila recount events about camp life. They
further illustrate this depiction with references to barbed wire and the crowded conditions. The
dignity of the women is presented through the dialogue; visceral imagery of their having to use
toilets in front of the guards also taken from primary sources and accounts of women in the
camps is confronting and disturbing from a human rights perspective. This passage of dialogue,
shared between Bridie and Sheila, demonstrates they have the same image and memory of the
event. The dialogue ends with the confronting image of the Japanese solder reinforcing the
dominance and control that overshadowed their lives during captivity. This image serves as a
transition into the next phase of the interview and whilst the previous passage was confronting,
the ensuing material is even more so.
Tensions rise in the mid section of this scene. Bridie and Sheila share looks between them as the
off stage interviewer asks confronting questions about the sexual abuse they may have
encountered in the camps. The passage reprises the Australian/British patriotism and rivalry
between the women presenting an almost obsessive and defensive nationalism. The stage
directions imply the characters are far more agitated echoing the confronting nature of the
revelations. Whilst Bridie represents anger and rejection of the interaction between the British
and Australian comfort women, Sheila is more circumspect, suggesting rather that the women
who chose or submitted to these ministrations did so to provide food for their children. Bridies
strident and accusative invective clearly has an impact foreshadowing further revelations later in
the play. The depiction of the scene where Bridie was forced to stay behind and be party to the
behaviour of her captors and the ingenuity of one woman to infer she had tuberculosis brings
humour to the scene which barely hides the fear and resentment she experienced. The stage is
darkened at this point and an image of starving children is presented on the screen. This serves
as empathetic justification for those women who did what they felt they needed to do to feed their
children. The end of this vignette reveals images of hunger, deprivation and need. The
pg. 41
interviewer halts with his simile when the women explain about the chop bone; the image left for
the audience to fill in themselves or by the women. The representations of the impact of the
experience in terms of mental health are referenced here building the image that is stated directly
by Sheila. The merciless killing of women who could not cope emphasises the pressures on the
women to sustain a positive outlook referencing the imagery of the song played at the
beginning of the scene. This discussion presents a segue into score of Ravels Bolero. Mistos
stage directions have this score played through to the end of the scene presenting a back drop to
the next vignette.
The women explain their meeting with Margaret Dryburgh and the forming of the vocal orchestra
Misto incorporating this history into his narrative. The passage reprises the motif of the shoehorn and its significance in terms of survival and community. Both Bridie and Sheila relate the
significance of the choir and images of connectedness and transcendence are presented in the
final lines the anaphora emphasising the power of the music to raise them above their
experience. The shoe-horn is the last word in this scene and serves to foreshadow its actual
appearance in the next scene and subsequently the impact it has had on Sheila which ultimately
provides clarification for why she had chosen not to contact Bridie in the fifty years since they last
saw each other.
Dramatic Features
(Specific reference
to the text)
What is visualised
through these
dramatic features?
Brutality of the
Japanese; agony and
fear of the prisoners
Soundtrack of
womens cries heard
off stage p. 41
Horror and
desperation of the
brave and decent
women
Suffering of innocent
civilians and the pity
and horror of war
Understanding of the
depth of their
pg. 42
Issue
Dramatic Features
(Specific reference
to the text)
What is visualised
through these
dramatic features?
Heroism
Power
Truth
Attitudes to women
Resilience
pg. 43
Overview
1. How has the idea in the topic sentence been revealed in the play through to Scene 5?
pg. 44
Writing Activity
Convert your answers into a cohesive paragraph. (Topic Sentence, Technique Example,
Purpose, Analysis, Linking Sentence)
pg. 45
Overview
1. How has the idea in the topic sentence been revealed in Scene 5?
pg. 46
Writing Activity
Convert your answers into a cohesive paragraph. (Topic Sentence, Technique Example,
Purpose, Analysis, Linking Sentence)
pg. 47
Motifs
Ideas
pg. 48
Further Analysis
Ongoing stage tension between Bridie and Sheila presents an intangible (vague / hard to grasp
at) gulf between the two despite the clear sense of common experience they convey. The
opening of the scene with the two women singing the made up lyrics that are still clearly
ingrained in their memory is a poignant reminder of the imprints experience places on our lives.
Percy Graingers English Country Gardens reinforces the irony of the view of the Empire that
begins and end this scene in the stage directions and commentary provided by Misto.
Explicit images are presented in this scene through props on the stage. First, we see Bridie
handling the photographs of Sheila as a young woman and the effect they have on her as a
result of her memories which then resonates in the dramaturgy. Secondly, Bridie shows Sheila
the rusty tin she has kept ever since the war a reminder of the care and responsibility they had
for each other, the affection and friendship that clearly resonates between them.
Imagery (gloves, playing bridge, criticism of Australian men, women going off with the Nips) is
referred to in the dualogue that reprises the ongoing rivalry between British and Australian
values and the conflicting perspectives the women have of the sexual encounters with the
Japanese. The values judgements being placed on these women by Bridie reveal her repulsion
has extended across the decades. Sheila, however, is more circumspect for reasons that will
soon be revealed. The audience may interpret that these arguments existed within the camp as
an integral element of the survival process and had been part of the everyday interactions that
had formed conversation and debate that stimulated minds and reinforced and sustained notions
of identity for those who were held as prisoners of war. Indeed, the story told her resonates with
the range of POW narratives told by men, in particular to Australian POWs and their sporting
prowess over that of the British, New Zealander and Canadian POWS.
The dramaturgy presents both intimacy and distance between the women on the stage allowing
the audience to see the pain Sheila has suffered (and is evidenced through her stage silences
when she is shown the tin). Misto uses a voice over flashback revealing how the tin represents a
visceral memory imprinted on Sheilas mind of ridicule and derision; after Bridie leaves the stage
Sheila goes to her drawer and we, as the audience, visually see the shoe-horn for the first time
on the stage. The poignant imagery is of enormous loss which we can see through the dramatic
irony of Bridie suggesting anyone who has slept with the enemy could not or should not show
their face - a pun as lost face was a mantra of the Japanese in terms of maintaining their
physical and psychological presence as menacing captors of the women. Sheilas silences and
her inability to look at Bridie increase the social tension of the scene and we are witness to the
foreshadowing of revelations that will lead to the climax of the play.
The scene ends with inferred images of Sheila being ridiculed by the Japanese as she sings a
song Its a Lovely Day Tomorrow which was sung by Vera Lynn during WWII. The song is about
optimism and reflects the British view that they could overcome anything. The scene ends with
powerful screened imagery on the stage of two female prisoners. Misto once again adds his
own little commentary that would not have been spoken on the stage but clearly presents his
view of the irony of the British perspective of superiority, the notion of Empire as nothing more
than broken down by the experience. We are confronted by these images as we empathise and
imagine the devastation of what actually occurred.
1. How is the tension between Bridie and Shelia continued in this scene?
2. One of the ideas that is evident in this scene is the ongoing rivalry between the English
and Australian women?
Hint: (Remember: Statement, Techniques, Visualisation, Meaning) Once you have
completed your responses highlight each part of your response in different colours and
underline your technique)
pg. 49
Imagery
Motif
Shoe-horn
Tobacco - tin
Explicit images or
projected images
Use of music
Voice overs
2.
pg. 50
2. Using the textual analysis in the above table, how is Sheilas character further
developed in this scene? (REMEMBER TEPA You must ground your reading
of the play in the features of the text) Write about 200 words.
pg. 51
1.
pg. 53
Dramatic Features
(Specific reference
to the text)
What is visualised
through these
dramatic features?
Photographs
staging interview
studio
spotlight
pg. 54
Techniques
Dramatic Features
(Specific reference
to the text)
What is visualised
through these
dramatic features?
pg. 55
Techniques
Dramatic Features
(Specific reference
to the text)
What is visualised
through these
dramatic features?
alliterative phrasing
imperatives
simile
pg. 56
What is
visualised
through these
dramatic
features?
What is
visualised
through these
dramatic
features?
pg. 57
pg. 58
The final scene of Act One brings the play to a climax. Explicit images of loss and shock are
presented through the dramaturgy including the costuming, positioning of actors in positions of
power on the stage, stage distance as a means of presenting isolation, facial gestures to
demonstrate the impact of the invectives and revelations and of course, the appearance of the
shoe-horn.
Implicit yet distinctively visual images are presented through the depiction of Sheila and other
POWs the evening prior at the dinner these imagined and implied images, whilst humourous,
are deeply troubling and reveal the innateness of memory; the images and experiences have not
dulled in the minds of the women. The fact that the imagery constructed here reveals
psychological hurt and damage is provocative and forces the audience to engage with the extent
of the experience. Further, the emotional reference to the little boy who wanted to ask Santa for
an egg evokes images of Christmas and childish joy being repressed by the conditions of the
camp. Even more evocative is Bridies retelling of other events from the previous evening. Sheila,
in an apparently intoxicated state, rejected Bridie vehemently and publicly reinforced the tension
that has existed between them since the beginning of the play. The dualogue between them
becomes quite aggressive and results in Bridie slapping Sheila a confronting visual of the fear,
sadness, tension and resentment for not keeping in contact and ironically, reveals more about
the affection and sadness than it does about anger. At this point in the scene Sheila is forced to
reveal she has the shoe-horn. The visual appearance of the central motif of the play is both
provocative and confronting. The shoe-horn, as we know from the beginning of the play, was a
gift from Bridies father and thus has rich emotional attachment to images of family and youth,
connectedness, an innocence prior to the war; its role in the camp as a metronome presents
images of community and music, moments of transcendence and the potential to rise above the
psychological constraints of the experience. There has been no mystery about it until this point in
the text, just the acceptance that it was lost and used as a bartering tool with the Japanese
referenced earlier in the play. Revealing the prop at this stage, seeing that it exists and has
existed as a symbol of experience reminds us of the impact and power of material objects and
visuals to evoke emotional reactions and responses.
Sheila having been in possession of the shoe-horn for so many years becomes a mystery to be
unveiled and the ensuing action, the proximity of the women, the sound effects take us back in
time through the dialogue. Sheila mentions Belalau the image of which is written on Bridies
face, and the horrors of that camp presenting a historical narrative from WWII. The imagery,
adjectives of beauty seen in the stunning colours of sunsets, the olfactory images of frangipani
raising sensual and exotic inferences and the descriptions of storms and their wonder and beauty
are contrasted against the horrors and screams of the women in the camp as they fought off
malaria. The evocative aural imagery of Sheila singing to Bridie, her vivid recollections of Bridie
in hospital and her physical condition explore the pain and suffering Sheila witnessed. The
intertextuality of singing Bridies favourite song adds layers of metaphorical meaning as the
nostalgia of the ball is a memory of life prior to the war when innocence and gaiety was the only
priority and at this point in the historical narrative Sheila is implying the fears she had for Bridies
impending death. The proximity of these women on the stage at this point reveals their closeness
in the war as well as the pressure that is on them at this point in the play. Bridies demand to
know where the quinine tablets (medicine used to stave off malaria and of course restricted
during the incarceration to the Japanese themselves) had come from becomes an answer she
fears. Mistos stage directions allow us to see and hear the dread in Bridies voice as she begins
to suspect the worst; the tension of the scene is palpable as the women face each other. Misto
adds sound effects at this point in the scene, crickets, adding an aural quality to the already
established sentience, of the exotic. However, the noise of the crickets is also reminiscent of
white noise, a buzzing to hide truth to stop the clarity of voice from being presented.
The crescendo of the cacophonous noise of the crickets fills the stage for the remainder of the
scene and the sudden silence at the end adds to the dark and light metaphors, a sense of
pg. 59
foreboding and evil that has enveloped the stage as this dramatic revelation is presented to both
Bridie and to the audience.
Sheila presents further images from her memories coffins, symbols of death. We do not need
to see them to experience the sadness and loss that they evoke or the fear that she experienced
in thinking Bridie would die. Her confession that she went to see Lipstick Larry, the alliteration
mocking his looks and presenting a caricature image of a Japanese officer (already punctuated
in audience memory by earlier images of his wearing loin cloths), raises horror for Bridie as she
slowly comes to realise what Sheila may have done to get the quinine that saved her life
reversing the irony of her invective just moments ago in the scene. The visuals we determine
from Sheilas description of the Japanese, pink cheeks, drunkenness reprise the images Bridie
has given us earlier of her experience in Lavender Street (Scene Five). The confronting and
devastating image that is evoked by Sheila retelling how the soldiers first made her sing,
ridiculing her and then dragging her back as she tried to leave resonates with the audience. The
effect on Bridie is also evident on the stage. The cessation of the cricket soundtrack leaves the
characters and the audience in an uncomfortable silence; the dramaturgy has Bridie turned away
from Sheila, unable to face the sacrifice that has been made for her. Sheilas demand for her to
turn and look at her, and Misto placing both women under separate spotlights highlights the
social distancing of them on the stage. The staging presents a metaphorical visualisation of the
distance between them in terms of values and attachment. The scene ends with a voice over of
the young Sheila singing Bridies favourite song. The dramatic irony is palpable; whilst Bridies
war was over the ball (listen to the lyrics to understand the intertextual metaphor here), Sheilas
has never ended and her hopes vanished. Bridies turning to face Sheila and her facial
expressions are the imperative here presenting the heightened emotion, the humility she feels
combined with the regret and disgust for what has happened to Sheila - and her own inability to
resolve the image of what occurred. The heroic stoicism here is profound. Imagery of heroes is
rarely of a young British woman whose sense or propriety has been her strength. The loss of
innocence resulting from this act of sacrifice has clearly had a long term impact on Sheila and to
carry the weight of it, and the shoe horn provokes the audience to imagine themselves in
similarly circumstances and whether they would be as committed to saving the life of another in
the same way.
pg. 60
to the already established sentience, of the exotic. However, the noise of the crickets is also
reminiscent of white noise, a buzzing to hide truth to stop the clarity of voice from being
presented.
The crescendo of the cacophonous noise of the crickets fills the stage for the remainder of the
scene and the sudden silence at the end adds to the dark and light metaphors, a sense of
foreboding and evil that has enveloped the stage as this dramatic revelation is presented to both
Bridie and to the audience.
Sheila presents further images from her memories coffins, symbols of death. We do not need
to see them to experience the sadness and loss that they evoke or the fear that she experienced
in thinking Bridie would die. Her confession that she went to see Lipstick Larry, the alliteration
mocking his looks and presenting a caricature image of a Japanese officer (already punctuated
in audience memory by earlier images of his wearing loin cloths), raises horror for Bridie as she
slowly comes to realise what Sheila may have done to get the quinine that saved her life
reversing the irony of her invective just moments ago in the scene. The visuals we determine
from Sheilas description of the Japanese, pink cheeks, drunkenness reprise the images Bridie
has given us earlier of her experience in Lavender Street (Scene Five). The confronting and
devastating image that is evoked by Sheila retelling how the soldiers first made her sing,
ridiculing her and then dragging her back as she tried to leave resonates with the audience. The
effect on Bridie is also evident on the stage. The cessation of the cricket soundtrack leaves the
characters and the audience in an uncomfortable silence; the dramaturgy has Bridie turned away
from Sheila, unable to face the sacrifice that has been made for her. Sheilas demand for her to
turn and look at her, and Misto placing both women under separate spotlights highlights the
social distancing of them on the stage. The staging presents a metaphorical visualisation of the
distance between them in terms of values and attachment. The scene ends with a voice over of
the young Sheila singing Bridies favourite song. The dramatic irony is palpable; whilst Bridies
war was over the ball (listen to the lyrics to understand the intertextual metaphor here), Sheilas
has never ended and her hopes vanished. Bridies turning to face Sheila and her facial
expressions are the imperative here presenting the heightened emotion, the humility she feels
combined with the regret and disgust for what has happened to Sheila - and her own inability to
resolve the image of what occurred. The heroic stoicism here is profound. Imagery of heroes is
rarely of a young British woman whose sense or propriety has been her strength. The loss of
innocence resulting from this act of sacrifice has clearly had a long term impact on Sheila and to
carry the weight of it, and the shoe horn provokes the audience to imagine themselves in
similarly circumstances and whether they would be as committed to saving the life of another in
the same way.
pg. 62
Example from
Scene
Purpose
to shock
to teach
to broaden our
understanding
to illicit and emotional
response/
engagement
to amuse
to build tension / to
break the tension
to establish historical/
political context
to tell an untold story
to expose
to criticize
Distinctively Visual
Themes / ideas
Distinctive / distinct
Memorable
Imprints on the mind
Unique
Vivid
Stands out
Engages the senses
Rich
Visually engaging
Visually surprising
Visually enticing
Visuals augment our
understanding and
emotional response
War
brutality
dehumanisation
propaganda
patriotism
Music
freedom
hope
unity
courage
Friendship
sacrifice
unity
shared experience
sound effects
Spotlights
dramaturgy
dramatic irony
dualogue;
irony;
pathos;
bathos
pg. 63
Group 2
Dramatic techniques
Example from
Scene
Purpose
to shock
to teach
to broaden our
understanding
to illicit and emotional
response/
engagement
to amuse
to build tension / to
break the tension
to establish historical/
political context
to tell an untold story
to expose
to criticize
Distinctively Visual
Themes / ideas
Distinctive / distinct
Memorable
Imprints on the mind
Unique
Vivid
Stands out
Engages the senses
Rich
Visually engaging
Visually surprising
Visually enticing
Visuals augment our
understanding and
emotional response
War
brutality
dehumanisation
propaganda
patriotism
Music
freedom
hope
unity
courage
Friendship
sacrifice
unity
shared experience
imagery,
repetition
crescendo of crickets
to heighten tension
alliteration
rhetorical questions
punctuation for
phrasing and pause,
flashback in voice over,
pg. 65
pg. 66
Writing Activity
Convert your answers into a cohesive paragraph. (Topic Sentence, Technique Example,
Purpose, Analysis, Linking Sentence)
pg. 67
pg. 68
Writing Activity
Convert your answers into a cohesive paragraph. (Topic Sentence, Technique Example,
Purpose, Analysis, Linking Sentence)
pg. 69
pg. 70
Writing Activity
Convert your answers into a cohesive paragraph. (Topic Sentence, Technique Example,
Purpose, Analysis, Linking Sentence)
pg. 71
Context in play
Fall In Brother
Rule Britannia
Something to
Remember you By
Jerusalem
Act I, Scene 3
Happy Times
Act I, Scene 5
Bolero
Act I, Scene 5
pg. 72
Music
Context in play
Percy Grangers,
English Country
Garden
Act I, Scene 6
O Come All ye
Faithful
Act I, Scene 7
Act I, Scene 7
Act I, Scene 7
pg. 73
Stage Direction or
Context of visual
image
Act I, Sc i
Singapore
What else is
happening on the
stage?
Dont listen to
rumour . If only
they had .
Act I, Scene 3
Japanese flag
Act I, Scene 5
Photographs of the
women in Japanese
POW camps
Act I, Scene 5
Face of fierce
Japanese warrior
Act I, Scene 5
Photographs of
children in the POW
camps stick thin,
obviously starving
and malnourished
Two women
prisoners of the
Japanese in shocking
state of malnutrition
and mistreatment
Act I, Scene 6
pg. 74
Visual Image
Projected
Stage Direction or
Context of visual
image
Act I, Scene 7
Photographs of
women emaciated,
haggard,
impoverished
What else is
happening on the
stage?
pg. 75