Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
www.elsevierhealth.com/journals/jinf
Neurosurgery Department, Haydarpasa Numune Education and Research Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey
Department of Infectious Disease, Haydarpasa Numune Education and Research Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey
KEYWORDS
Aspiration;
Brain abscess;
Computed
tomography;
Corticosteroids;
Magnetic resonance
imaging;
Stereotaxy
Introduction
Despite the decline of the mortality from 3060 to
424% in recent years, brain abscess is still one of
* Corresponding author. Acibadem Gomec Sokak Cangar Ap. A
Blok, 27/11 Kadikoy, 34718 Istanbul, Turkey. Tel.: C90 532 324
32 84.
E-mail address: tayfunhakan@yahoo.com (T. Hakan).
0163-4453/$30.00 Q 2005 The British Infection Society. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jinf.2005.07.019
360
T. Hakan et al.
Table 1
patients
Variable
Initial sign and symptom
Fever and leucocytosis
Headache
Nausea-vomiting
Focal neurological deficit
Mental alteration
Seizures
Meningismus
Papil edema
Cerebellar syndrome
Other
Source of infection
Meningitis
Otitis, mastoiditis
Trauma
Sinusit
Surgery
Tooth abscess
Unknown
Risk factors
Septicaemia
Congenital cardiac disease
Shut-gun injury
Pulmoner infection
Tuberculosis
Organism
Aerobic
Streptococcus sp.
Staphylococcus sp.
Proteus sp.
Pseudomonas sp
Enterobacter sp.
Klebsiella sp.
Enterococcus sp.
Moraxella
Haemophylus sp.
Citrobacter sp.
Anaerobic
Peptostreptococci
Streptococcus sp
Bacteriodes sp.
Fusobacterium
Prevotella
Tuberculosis
No. organism
Number (%)
55 (57)
52 (54)
48 (50)
40 (42)
43 (44)
24 (25)
22 (23)
11 (11)
10 (10)
8 (8)
16 (17)
16 (17)
14 (15)
5 (5)
4 (4)
2 (2)
24 (25)
6 (6)
5 (5)
2 (2)
1 (1)
1 (1)
Results
18 (18)
17 (17)
12 (12)
3 (3)
2 (2)
2 (2)
2 (2)
1 (1)
1 (1)
1 (1)
10 (10)
4 (4)
4 (4)
2 (2)
1 (1)
2 (2)
19 (19)
Patient population
The series included 96 patients (66 males, 30
female) aged 1.580 years (mean 29.7 years).
Twenty-nine of the patients (30%) were under 15
years old.
361
Laboratory findings
Microbiological findings
Eighty-two micro-organisms were identified in 62
(76%) of 81 patients. No microbiological analysis
done in 15 patients (10 of them were treated
medically).
In 48 (77%) patients one type micro-organism and
in 14 (23%) patients multiple organisms were
identified. The organisms were more than two in
five patients. The most isolated micro-organisms
were Streptococcus species, Staphylococcus and
Proteus species (Table 1). Anaerobic organisms
were isolated from 12 (12%) abscesses material and
they revealed mix growth except prevotella and
Fusobacterium. Five cases were tuberculosis
abscesses. Micobacteria isolated in two cases,
micro-organisms was seen with EZN stain in one
case and pathological examination showed tuberculous granuloma in two abscesses.
Treatment modality
Surgery was performed on 86 (90%) patients; in 72
(84%) patients the lesions were aspirated and in 14
(16%) patients were excised. The aspiration was
performed stereotacticaly in 12 patients. The
Figure 1 Demonstration of an abscess case, (a) CT scanning of a huge frontal abscess with midline shift during
admission, (b) after single aspiration the abscess shrank moderately and there is a decreasing of midline shift, (c) after
second aspiration the abscess and the midline shift has disappeared.
362
T. Hakan et al.
Table 2
Variable
Corticosteroid
Corticosteroid (dexamethasone) was given for
diffuse cerebral edema and midline shift (Fig. 1).
It was used in 58% of the surgical treatment group
and 20% of the non-surgical treatment group (pO
0.05). There was a significant correlation between
corticosteroid usage with severe sequel and death
(Table 2).
Outcome
Clinical follow-up for 88 patients ranged from 3 to
84 month (median 9 months). Eight (8%) patients
(seven in the aspiration, one in the excision group)
were died. Three of them were comatose on
No. of patient
55 (57%)
Age
Mean
28.4G20.2
Diametre of abscess
Range
865 mm
Mean
(31.5)
Solitary
49 (89%)
Multiple
6 (11%)
Duration of symptoms
Day
9.50G10.06
Predisposing factors
(C)
43 (78%)
(K)
12 (22%)
Meningismus
11 (20%)
Fever
!38.5 8C
25 (45%)
R38.5 8C
7 (13%)
Leucoytosis
R20.000
7 (13%)
Neurologic grade (GCS)
15
19 (34%)
1413
29 (53%)
129
6 (11%)
87
1 (2%)
63
Corticosteroid
22 (40%)
Moderate
sequela
Severe
sequela
Death
Total
23 (24%)
10 (10%)
8 (8%)
96
33.8G20.1
26.4G19.6
23.1G24.6
29.7G20.64
pO0.05
1867 mm
(33.8)
18 (78%)
5 (22%)
3555 mm
(44.6)
7 (70%)
3 (30%)
3052 mm
(41)
6 (75%)
2 (25%)
867 mm
(32.86)
80 (83%)
16 (17%)
p!0.05
8.4G06.39
7.00G3.09
2.87G3.10
9.22G8.35
pO0.05
16 (70%)
7 (30%)
3 (13%)
8 (80%)
2 (20%)
3 (30%)
8 (100)
5 (62%)
75 (78%)
21 (22%)
22 (23%)
pO0.05
p!0.05
11 (48%)
4 (17%)
6 (60%)
2 (20%)
8 (100%)
6 (75%)
50 (52%)
19 (20%)
pO0.05
p!0.001
5 (22%)
3 (30%)
7 (87%)
22 (23%)
p!0.0001
7 (30%)
10 (43%)
5 (22%)
1 (4%)
15 (65%)
2
3
2
2
1
8
1 (12%)
4 (50%)
2 (25%)
1 (12%)
7 (87%)
28 (29%)
43 (45%)
17 (18%)
6 (6%)
2 (2%)
52 (54%)
pO0.05
pO0.05
p!0.05
p!0.05
p!0.05
p!0.05
(20%)
(30%)
(20%)
(20%)
(10%)
(80%)
pO0.05
Discussion
Brain abscesses still keep their importance with
high mortality and morbidity despite the improvement in diagnosis and treatment modalities in
recent decades.16
The most common predisposing factor for brain
abscesses are direct spread from middle ear,
meninges, mastoid infections and paranasal
sinus.1619 In the present study, the distribution of
the predisposing factors was not equal in the
different age groups and some special features
were determined in contrast with other studies.16,18
The most common cause of brain abscess in the 014
and 1540 age groups was focal infections, in the 41
60 age groups was unknown origin and in above 60
years group posttraumatic abscess was lower than
other age groups. Dental abscess, pulmonary
abscess, sepsis were the other sources of infection
in these series. The 30% of our patients were in
childhood period. Childhood period account nearly
25% cases in some series.2,19 CCHD was a significant
predisposing factor in childrens as high as 650% in
published series, but there is a decline gradually due
to advances in cardiovascular surgery nowadays.
363
In our series ratio of CCHD was 13.7%. In CCHD
diminished arterial oxygen saturation and increased
blood viscosity may cause focal cerebral ischaemia
and play as nidus for infection.1,7,20,21
Clinic symptoms and signs are non-specific
for brain abscesses; they show difference depending on the size and location, the virulence of
infecting organisms and underlying systemic conditions.1,2,15,22 The most presenting symptoms were
headache, nausea, vomiting, fever, focal neurological deficits and alteration of mental status in
this report as in recent studies.16,15,17,22
Seizures ratio were 25% in our patients and there
was no significant correlation between seizures and
abscesses located in frontal lobe in contrast to
recent reports.1 Short duration of symptoms from
the onset of symptoms to admission correlated with
a poorer outcome and characterized patients of 20
60 age groups in other series.13 In this series there
was no correlation between age groups and the
location of abscess with duration of symptoms.
Rutin laboratory tests are not helpful in diagnosis.13 However, there was a significant correlation between leucocytosis (above of 20.000) with
poor outcome and high fever (O38.5 8C) with
mortality in this study.
In patients suspected brain abscess, LP should
not be done for the risk of brain herniation.3,4,15,16
CSF findings are usually non-specific and CSF
cultures are rarely positive.1,15 LP performed only
in three of our patients after checking any mass
with CT,1,23 their CSF examination was sterile, too.
The incidence of multiple abscesses was
reported to be 150% in different series and as
high as 61% especially in the series of infants,1,5,24 it
was 16.7% in the presented study. While formerly
the mortality rate associated with multiple
abscesses has been higher than solitary abscesses,
recently results are similar for single abscesses.17
Reasons of high mortality in multiple abscesses
were delay in diagnosis and treatment. Since, these
patients often had died before receiving any
treatment. 1,5 In this study, the prognosis of
multiple abscesses were similar to solitary abscess.
CT and MRI are used for diagnosis of almost all
intracranial patogenities.13 Mamelak3 reported that
there is no difference between CT and MRI on
finding out the lesions in brain abscesses. But many
studies show that MRI scanning is more sensitive in
diagnoses of the cerebral edema and early cerebritis phase.1,2 Moreover, MRI scanning is accurate
for the diagnosis for the abscesses formation owing
to aspergillus species and the ones locating in brain
steam and posterior fossa.1,2 In three cases, we
were able to determine cerebritis with MRI that
were not detected with CT.
364
The most commonly isolated micro-organisms
were Streptococcus species, followed by Staphylococcus species and Proteus species in this study and
was not significantly different from the isolated
micro-organisms of old reports.3,8,16,18,2530 In
recent years, anaerobic micro-organisms are being
more frequently isolated from brain abscess. The
most common anaerobic bacteria are Bacteroides
(especially B. fragilis), Fusobacterium and anaerobic streptococci and their usually mixed growth is
seen in culture.4,30 We did not notice any increase in
Bacteroides species in contrast to recent reports. In
19 patients no organisms isolated, most of them had
received antibiotics at least 5 days before obtaining
culture material. The most important factor
responsible from sterile culture was the usage of
antibiotics before surgical intervention.3,9,18,20
However, in one case the culture was positive
despite to the antibiotics duration of 10 days before
from surgical intervention.
One of five patients with connection with
tuberculosis had history skin tuberculosis infection
6-month ago. In other four patients, no active focus
of tuberculosis were determined. This result is not a
surprise because tuberculosis is endemic in our
country.
Why the burr-hole aspiration is effective with
minimal risk,1 it is used mostly in our patients. It
reduces mass effect of the abscess immediately
with minimal trauma; it can provide not only the
confirmation of diagnosis but also avoid occasional
antibiotic therapy of some other lesions that can
resemble brain abscesses. Stereotactic surgery is
preferred if it can be applied and it reveals
excellent results.14,31 We used stereotactic aspiration in 12 cases. Total excision and CSF diversion is
preferred for some abscess localized in cerebellum
and for cases that cannot be cured after repeated
aspirations.14,32 It is not advised for the lesions
located in eloquent areas and for the abscesses in
cerebritis stage.
The non-surgically treatment ratio in brain
abscess has been increased since CT scanning has
been used for diagnosis.1 Dyste and Rosenblum33
considered medical treatment should be applied on
cortex localized brain abscess when their diametres
are 1017 mm. Mampalam5 suggests medical treatment when the diametre is around 20 mm and the
abscess is deeply localized. Other authors considered medical treatment when the abscess is
lesser than 30 mm and localized in brainstem.34,35
For the abscess bigger than 30 mm diametre,
surgical treatment is advised.5,11 In CCHD patients
abscesses larger than 2 cm in diametre repeatedly
aspiration is advised because of decreasing
T. Hakan et al.
intracranial pressure and avoided intraventricular
rupture of brain abscess (IVROBA).21
We successfully treated ten patients with
abscesses smaller than 30 mm diametre non-surgically. An antibiotic combination composed of a
beta-lactam and an anti-anaerobic is used.1,9 We
used formerly penicillin G and chloramphenicol
combination and recently the combination of
metronidazole with third generation cephalosporins such as cefotaxim and ceftriaxone. Metronidazole is preferred because of bactericidal activity
against strict anaerobes, reaching to high concentrations in pus and being not influenced by steroid
therapy while passing into the abscess contrast to
penicillin G, chloramphenicol.9,36,37 It was offered
to use in combination with an antibiotic active
against micro-aerophylic streptococci and aerotolerant anaerobes that are resistant to
metronidazole.1
The duration of anti-microbial therapy for brain
abscess is not clear.5,15 In many reports, parenteral
antibiotic therapy is recommended at least 36
weeks.9,10,15,35 Mamelak1 suggests minimum 6
weeks IV antibiotic therapy. In the presented
study, the duration of antibiotic treatment is 46
weeks parenterally, than 26 weeks orally. In the
surgically treated group, the duration of the oral
treatment is reduced according to the response of
the patient; this duration was as long as 1 year for
the abscess of tuberculosis.
In the literature the common causes of death are
determined as mass effect and edema with ventriculitis and thrombophlebitis. In these conditions,
steroids are recommended until the neurologic
condition stabilizes.1,4,5 They are used despite
deletion collagen deposition and decreasing antibiotic penetration.1 Steroids inhibit the migration of
leucocytes and diminish the effectiveness of host
defense mechanisms but encapsulation proceeds
and abscess wall thickness and abscess size does not
effect. In Schroeders38 experimental study on rats,
it is found that dexamethasone had little effect on
mortality rate. It is reported that corticosteroid
administration was correlated with a poorer neurological result; however the tendency of patients who
received corticosteroids to have had worse neurological grades in beginning and therefore steroids
may not have contributed to this result.3 We gave
dexamethasone to 53% of our patients and there
were significant correlation with poor outcome.
The most important factor on prognosis and
mortality in patients is the initial neurological
grade. The mortality is higher in the patient
whose symptoms are shorter, mental alterations
are serious and neurologic dysfunction is rapid.1,3,4
The size of abscess also may play a role in the
365
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
References
24.
1. Mathisen GE, Johnson JP. Brain Abscess. Clin Infect Dis 1997;
25:76381.
2. Sa
ez-Llorens X. Brain Abscess in Children. Semin Pediatr
Infect Dis 2003;14:10814.
3. Mampalam TJ, Rosenblum ML. Trends in the management of
bacterial brain abscesses: A review of 102 cases over 17
years. Neurosurgery 1988;23:4517.
4. Seydoux Ch, Francioli P. Bacterial brain abscesses: Factors
influencing mortality and sequela. Clin Infect Dis 1992;15:
394401.
5. Mamelak AN, Mampalam TJ, Obana WG, Resenblum ML.
Improved management of multipl brain abscesses:
25.
26.
27.
28.
366
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
with unique simultaneous fungal suppuration by myceliophthora thermophilia: Case report. Neurosurgery 1996;
39:124751.
Han XY, Weinberg JS, Prabhu SS, Hassenbuch SJ, Fuller GN,
Tarrand JJ, et al. Fusobacterial brain abscess: A review of
five cases and a analysis of possible pathogenesis.
J Neurosurg 2003;99:693700.
Bamberger DM. Outcome of medical treatment of bacterial
abscesses without therapeutic drainage: Review of cases
reported in the literature. Clin Infect Dis 1996;23:592603.
Dyste GN, Hitchon PW, Menezer AH, VanGilder JC,
Greene GM. Stereotaxic surgery in the treatment of multiple
brain abscesses. J Neurosurg 1988;69:18894.
Nadvi SS, Parboosing R, Van Dellen JR. Cerebellar abscess:
The significance of cerebrospinal fluid diversion. Neurosurgery 1997;41:617.
Rosenblum ML, Hoff JT, Norman DA, Weinstein PR, Pitts L.
Decreased mortality from brain abscesses since advent of
computerized tomography. J Neurosurg 1978;49:45868.
T. Hakan et al.
34. Fulgham JR, Wijdicks EFM, Wright AJ. Cure of a solitary
brainstem abscess with antibiotic therapy: Case report.
Neurology 1996;46:14514.
35. Carpenter JL. Brainstem abscesses: Cure with medical
therapy, case report and review. Clin Infect Dis 1994;18:
21926.
36. Black P, Graybill R, Charache P. Penetration of brain abscess
by systemically administered antibiotics. J Neurosurg 1973;
7059.
37. Gomez J, Poza M, Martinez M, Martinez-Lage J,
Hernandez JL, Valdes M. Use of cefotaxime and metronidazolee for treating cerebral abscesses (letter). Clin Infect Dis
1995;21:708.
38. Schoeder KA, McKeever P, Schaberg DR, Hoff JT. Effect of
dexamethasone on experimental brain abscess. J Neurosurg
1987;66:2649.
39. Zeidman SM, Geisler FH, Olivi A. Intraventricular rupture of a
purulent brain abscess: Case report. Neurosurgery 1995;36:
18993.