Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
brill.com/jss
Abstract
In the medieval Middle East, the Sufi experience was not only a male enterprise.
Women also participated in the development of this mystical representation of Islam
in different ways. Despite the existence of scholarly studies on Sufism in medieval
Anatolia, the role played by women in this period has generally been overlooked. Only
recently have studies started to highlight the relevance that some of these Sufi ladies
had in spreading Sufism in the Middle East. Accounts of womens deeds are especially
abundant in hagiographic literature produced in the seventh/thirteenth and eighth/
fourteenth centuries. However, it has been generally downgraded as historically unreliable for consisting of biased inside accounts of the lives of Sufi shaykhs and their
followers. This article has a twofold goal: first, to investigate what information hagiographies provide about the role of women in medieval Anatolia; and second, to try to
vindicate the option of using hagiographic literature as a relevant source of information in researching aspects of cultural history that cannot be found in other source
materials.
Rsum
Le soufisme dans le Moyen-Orient mdival ntait pas lapanage des hommes. Les
femmes ont galement particip de diffrentes faons llaboration de cette tradition
mystique de lislam. En dpit de lexistence dtudes acadmiques sur le soufisme en
Anatolie mdivale, le rle des femmes dans cette priode a gnralement t nglig.
Ce nest que rcemment que des tudes ont commenc mettre en vidence le rle de
* The research leading to these results has received funding from the European Research
Council under the European Unions Seventh Framework Programme (FP/20072013) / ERC
Grant Agreement n. 208476, The Islamisation of Anatolia, c. 11001500.
The Ladies of Rm
133
Keywords
Awad al-Dn Kirmn hagiography Jall al-Dn Rm medieval Anatolia
Sufism women
134
De Nicola
The Ladies of Rm
135
136
De Nicola
The Ladies of Rm
137
will argue that these sources can provide new and interesting insights into the
social history and daily life experience of women in seventh/thirteenth- and
eighth/fourteenth-century Anatolia.
138
De Nicola
in this latter necessity that women in the family of the shaykhs played a fundamental role as those who establish the link between past and present.19 Patterns
generally repeat themselves in this respect, proving that, in the h
agiographical
narrative, those women chosen to marry shaykhs are claimed to have family
connections with relevant political or religious figures of the time.
Aflk falsely claims at the very beginning of his manaqib that the family of
Rm is connected directly through his father Bah al-Dn Valad (d. 628/1231) to
Sultan Muammad ii Khwrazmshh (d. 617/1220).20 This is done by mentioning a marriage between a daughter of the sultan and Mawlns grandfather
usayn Khab.21 The chronology of this union does not really stand historical
analysis, but the fact that all three hagiographies on Rm echoed the union
highlight the need of the order to claim some linkage to secular authority.22 It
might seem strange at first trying to establish a link with the Khwrazmshh
dynasty. After all, they were descendants of slaves who had ravaged much of
eastern Anatolia, waged war on the Seljuqs and eventually collapsed humiliatingly in the face of the Mongol invasion.23 However, immediately following
19 Ethel Sara Wolper, Princess Safwat al-Duny wa al-Dn and the Production of Sufi
Buildings and Hagiographies in Pre-Ottoman Anatolia, in Women, Patronage, and
Self-Representation in Islamic Societies, ed. D. Fairchild Ruggles (Albany: State University
of New York Press, 2000), 36.
20 Aflk, 1:710 / Feats, 79. The armies of Muammad b. Tekish Khwrazmshh were
defeated by Chinggis Khan during the Mongol invasion of Central Asia between 616/1219
and 618/1221. The sultan escaped and the Mongols followed him across Khurasan until
he found refuge on an island in the Caspian Sea, where he died. See John Andrew Boyle,
Political and Dynastic History of the Ilkhans, in The Cambridge History of Iran, vol. 5, ed.
idem (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 30817. On the successor of the rulers of
Khwarezm in India see Peter Jackson, Jall al-Dn, the Mongols, and the Khwarazmian
Conquest of the Panjb and Sind, Iran 28 (1990): 4554.
21 Another false genealogical connection is made in Feats, 56, when Aflk quotes Bah
al-Dn Valad telling his companions that his grandmother on his fathers side was the
daughter of Ibrhm al-Adham (d. 161/778), who is credited in Sufi tradition with abandoning his position as ruler of Balkh in search of a path of spiritual asceticism. See
Schimmel, Mystical Dimensions, 37; and Erik S. Ohlander, Sufism in an Age of Transition:
Umar al-Suhrawardi and the Rise of the Islamic Mystical Brotherhoods (Leiden: Brill,
2008), 275.
22 Sipahsalar, 6; Aflk, 1:810 / Feats, 89; and Jm, Nafahat al-uns, 459.
23 On the relationship between the Seljuqs, the Mongols and Mawlns order as it appears in
Aflks work see Speros Vryonis, The Political World of the Mevlevi Dervish Order in Asia
Minor (1314 century) as Reflected in the Mystical Writings of Eflaki, in Philellen: Studies
in Honour of Robert Browning, ed. Costas N. Constantinides, Nikolaos M. Panagiotakes,
et al. (Venice: Istituto ellenico di studi bizantini e postbizantini di Venezia, 1996), 41119.
The Ladies of Rm
139
the marital union, the events leading to the break between the Khwrazmshhs
and Rms family are described, making clear to an Anatolian audience where
the loyalty of Rms family lies.24 A final commitment in the narrative to the
dynasty of the Seljuqs of Rm is added, as Suln Valad is mentioned as predicting the defeat of the Kwrazmshh at the hands of his new protectors in
Anatolia. In addition, a blood-link is established to Ab Bakr (d. 11/634), the
first caliph of Islam, but this claim appear to have as little historical validity as
it is charged with symbolic value.25
Kirmns ancestry is something of a mystery. We know that he left Kerman
at the age of sixteen, approximately in 584/118990, due to the turmoil in the
city provoked by the constant incursion of Turkish tribes into the area.26 He
settled in Baghdad, where he had a brilliant career in Islamic law, which, in
turn, granted him the title of Shaykh al-shuykh, directly named by the caliph
al-Mustanir (r. 62340/122642).27 However, his vita does not mention his
mothers name; only a short reference to the shaykhs mother appears at the
beginning in which she advises Awad al-Dn to leave Kerman.28 The omission
of the name suggest that either she might not have been of very noble stock
or that his account precedes that of Rm, and consequently the process of
forming genealogy was still developing at the time when Kirmns manqib
was being written.29 On the contrary, we are told that the mother of Jall al-Dn
Rm was called Mumina Khtn, and that she left Balkh with him and his
father and travelled with them until she finally died in the city of Karaman
in Anatolia.30 She appears to have been one among the, at least four, wives of
Bah al-Dn Valad, but received little attention in the hagiographic material.31
The fact that she died when Mawln was still young might be the reason why
Rms hagiographies mostly omit references to her.
24 Aflk, 1:915 / Feats, 913.
25 Aflk, 1:8 / Feats, 7; and Sipahsalar, 9. For a discussion of the genealogy of Bah al-Dn
Valad see Hamid Algar, Bah-al-Dn Moammad Walad, in EIr.
26 Weischer, Hearts Witness, 1. Apparently, Rms companion Shams-i Tabrz (d. 645/1248)
was also a disciple of Sujs. See Ridgeon, The Controversy, 14.
27 Manaqib, 1213; and Ridgeon, The Controversy, 1415.
28 Manaqib, 12.
29 In Sipahslr, 141, the editor suggests that he fled Kerman due to the insistence of his
mother, but the origin of this claim is not provided.
30 At the time of Rm, the city was called Larende and had a large Greek-Christian population. See Lewis, Rumi, 71. There is now a mosque in the city where the grave of Mumina
Khtn was discovered. See Azmi Avcolu, Karamanda Mader-i Mevln Cami ve
Trbesi, Konya dergisi 5.35 (1941): 20889.
31 On the controversy about the number of wives of Bah al-Dn Valad see Lewis, Rumi, 45.
140
De Nicola
The Ladies of Rm
141
of Gurwar.38 She gave Rm two sons and one daughter, but neither of his sons
were considered as successors in the line of shaykhs, which went through the
more noble and virtuous descent of Gurwar Khtn.39 It appears that becoming a shaykh was connected to the prestige of descent, and, in this case, the
credentials of Gurwar Khtn favoured her offspring instead of Kers as the
legitimate line of descent of Rm. Both Aflk and Sipahslr include anecdotes in which Ker, deprived of the noble stock of Rms first wife, is not
only seen as actively involved in the organisation of the order and interacting
with the Seljuq court, but is also portrayed as superstitious and harbouring
a number of personal fears. By giving room to these personal attitudes, the
narrative allows for Rms skills, in particular the performance of miracles in
response to such attitudes, to be related.40 The role adopted by Ker is much
more active in the narrative, and contrasts with the passivity and scarcity of
stories encountered in Aflk about Gurwar Khtn. In fact, her position in
the order can be seen in the fact that she was buried in Rms mausoleum,
together with other women of her family such as her daughter Malika Khtn.41
In the case of Awad al-Dn Kirmn, we know that he had a main wife and
at least one concubine. As in the case of Rm, his wife also played an important role in legitimising the spiritual credentials of the shaykh. He married
Rukn al-Dns daughter, whose name is not given in the text, but clear mention
of her pedigree is provided.42 Her lineage can be traced back to the famous
Sufi master Ab l-Najb Suhraward (d. 563/1168), a disciple of Amad Ghazl
(d. 520/1126) and founder of the Suhrawardiyya Sufi order.43 Interestingly, the
genealogical connection between both Kirmn and Suhraward is made by
a succession of marriages, firstly the marriage of the daughter of the latter to
Qub al-Dn Abhar, who in turn marries his daughter to Sujs, who finally
marries his daughter to Kirmn.44 In this way, the line of Kirmns wife helps
the hagiographic narrative to construct a spiritual lineage that in turn helps
to legitimise his religious status.45 Yet, in contrast to the position reserved by
38 This information is only provided by Abdulbaki Golpnarl, Mevlanadan sonra Mevlevilik,
trans. Tawfiq Subhani (Tehran: Intisharat-i Kayhan, 1366 sh. / 19878), and referenced in
Lewis, Rumi, 122.
39 Her son was Muaffar al-Dn Amr lim, who unsuccessfully tried to make a career in the
Seljuq administration with the support of her father and the Parvanah of Rm (Lewis,
Rumi, 122). They also had a daughter called Malika Khtnsee below.
40 Aflk, 1:923 / Feats, 68. On her interaction with the Seljuq court see below.
41 Lewis, Rumi, 428.
42 Manaqib, 5960.
43 Schimmel, Mystical Dimensions, 2446.
44 Manaqib, 56.
45 Ridgeon, The Controversy, 17.
142
De Nicola
Aflk for at least one of Rms wives, the manaqb of Kirmn does not make
his wife a character in anecdotes to contextualise the life of the master. It
seems that Kirmns wife occupied a similar role to that of Gurwar Khtn in
Rms hagiography, but the equivalent of Ker Khtn is missing.
The Ladies of Rm
143
his son-in-law.51 Despite the unsuccessful attempt to marry his daughter, the
attempt to intermarry with secular dynasties is revealed here. If we take into
account that Kirmn was a contemporary of Rms father Bah al-Dn, then
both appear to be following the similar marriage strategies of linking their
own families to those of local secular leaders. While the former tried to link his
daughter to the son of the vizier of the region of Akhl, the later was marrying
the young Jall al-Dn Rm to the noble stock carried by Gurwar Khtn.
While mina is presented as coming from a line of shaykhs and was intended
to be married to a local ruler, the story of Kirmns second daughter, Fima,
is very different. She was not only born of a concubine, which in itself would
not have necessarily determined her upbringing,52 but also of a slave whom
his father had bought in a bazaar from a merchant who could not handle this
woman because of her bad temper (bad kh).53 She seems to have passed this
bad temper down to her daughter Fima.54 The worries and concerns to which
the shaykh was subjected by her behaviour are reflected in a few anecdotes
in the hagiography.55 Further, her personal story is also connected to the historical development of Anatolia. Apparently, she was captured by the Mongols
during the invasion of the city of Kayseri in 641/1243 and taken to the region of
Chaghat.56 Her return to Rm was only possible thanks to the intervention of
some Seljuq dignitaries who begged Hleg for her release, which might have
occurred when Hleg invaded Iraq in 656/1258.57 After her return, she married shaykh Amn al-Dn Yaqb, with whom she had a son who died at the age
of eight.58 Hence, despite different backgrounds, both ladies shared a troubled
51 Ibid., 64.
52 See, for example, how Aflk glorifies the role of concubines when speaking of the marriages of Suln Valad (Feats, 698).
53 Manaqib, 68.
54 On her see also Mikail Bayram, Fatma Bac ve Bacyan- Rm (Istanbul: Nve Kltr
Merkezi, 2008), 4558.
55 Manaqib, 6871.
56 Ibid., 701. This is most probably the Jaghatu in present day north-western Iran, where
the Ilkhanid dynasty was particularly active and the Mongol ordos usually camped. See,
for example, Rashd al-Dn Tabib, Rashiduddin Fazlullahs Jamiut-tawarikh: Compendium
of Chronicles, trans. W.M. Thackston (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press,
1998), 548.
57 Manaqib, 36. Among those who interceded on her behalf was Mun al-Dn Parvanah
(d. 6756/1277), husband of Gurj Khtn and patron of Jall al-Dn Rm (ibid. 71).
58 Ibid., 71. In the introduction to the manqib, Furznfar mentions that she married one
of the sons of one of the disciples of Yaqb. See Manqib, Introduction, 37. I was not able
to identify Shaykh Amn al-Dn Yaqb.
144
De Nicola
life of mistreatment and kidnapping; also, both mina and Fima fulfilled the
role of linking the shaykh or the order to both secular and religious powers.
Both women were alive at the time in which the manqib of Kirmn was written, and we do not know what their fate was after the work was completed in
the second half of the seventh/thirteenth century.
An important difference that emerges from the hagiographic account is
the position the daughter (and daughter-in-law) of Rm seem to have had
within the Sufi order in comparison to the daughters of Kirmn. If the lives of
Kirmns daughter and daughter-in-law are rendered in the manqib as biographies of their life and deeds, Rms female offspring are more connected
with the compilation of the stories. In other words, they actively participate in
the consolidation of the order by being included by both Aflk and Sipahslr
as sources for the compilation of the miracles of Jall al-Dn Rm.59 Rms
only daughter, Malika Khtn, was born of his second wife Ker and survived
her father into the eighth/fourteenth century.60 She was married to a wealthy
merchant called Khwja Shihb al-Dn of Konya, who is presented by Aflk
as a miser, Aflk making classic literary use of his professions stereotype.61
The marriage also seems to correspond to the needs of the family to establish
connections with the local community. Being new to the town, marrying his
daughter to a wealthy merchant of the city appears to have been a pragmatic
way of securing status for the shaykh and wealth for the order. Malika Khtn
appears in Aflks account on a number of occasions as a transmitter of stories of her father and as the main character in anecdotes with clear pedagogic
meaning.62 She certainly enjoyed a high degree of respect in the community
for her status as the daughter of Mawln, and her marriage might have contributed to securing some financial and political favour in Konya for the order.63
However, having only one daughter prevented Rms hagiographers from
generating a religious pedigree to the next generation of women. Aflk uses,
then, another character to fill this gap by expanding the hagiographic description
59 See, for example, Feats, 4950, 224, 268, 271, 289, 319, 486, 500, and 644 among others. Also
Sipahsalar, 76.
60 Apparently, she died between 7023/1303 and 706/1306; her funerary inscription at the
mausoleum in Konya is not clear about the date. See Lewis, Rumi, 123.
61 In Aflks story, Rm ridicules his son-in-law in front of his daughter by telling the story
of an extremely miserly wealthy man. See Feats, 224. His businesses might not have been
totally successful when Rm had to write a letter to the Parvanah to forgive Shihb al-Dn
for the tolls and taxes he paid for his business that led to his economic ruin. See Rm,
Maktubat, 956 (quoted in Lewis, Rumi, 123).
62 See the anecdote between Malika Khatn and her slave girl in Feats, 280.
63 See, for example, how the light of Mawln emanated from her in Feats, 438.
The Ladies of Rm
145
of Rms daughter-in-law Fima Khtn, who was married to Rms son and
successor Suln Valad.64 This lady was the daughter of Rms companion
shaykh Sal al-Dn Fardn (d. 657/1258), who was a disciple of Rms master
Burhn al-Dn and a companion of Mawln until his death.65 The role of this
lady is glorified, as she is not only the daughter of an important member of
the Mawlawi tradition and the daughter-in-law of Rm, but also the wife of
Suln Valad and the mother of the third master of the order, rif Chalab
(d. 719/1320), who was the religious mentor of Aflk and the person who
inspired the writing of his Manaqib al-arifin.66 As we will see later, the position that this lady occupied within the order goes beyond her role as a legitimiser of a line of descent. So, with her, a similar structure is constructed to that
of Kirmns hagiography for his daughter; in this case Malika Khtns marriage provides a secular and wealthy link to the society of medieval Anatolia,
and Fima Khtn brings a religious background not only to Rms female
descent but also to Suln Valads marriage and offspring. From a mythical past
to the security of succession, the idea that women played a fundamental role
in securing the line of descent of the shaykhs is not only reflected but also
highlighted in the hagiographic narrative.67 Even further, it appears that this
was a complex mechanism whereby women provided either political support
from secular powers, economic viability from rich elements in society or spiritual legitimation for the male members of the order.
The Shaykhs and Women of the Court in Anatolia and the Caucasus
146
De Nicola
womenas well as menfrom outside the family of the shaykhs are at times
confusing, and it is occasionally difficult to identify the ladies with historical
characters. This is especially the case for wealthy women who are mentioned
as giving donations at the same time as being described as followers of the
shaykhs.69 An anecdote illustrating this can be found in a famous episode
narrated by Aflk in his section on the life of Bah al-Dn Valad. At the time
when his whole family finally arrived in Anatolia, they stayed for a while in
the vicinity of the city of Erzincan. It is mentioned that a lady called Imat
Khtn, the wife of Malik Fakhr al-Dn Arzanjn, had a revelation which told
her that a pole (or pillar) of the world (qub lam) was arriving in the region.70
Immediately after this, she took a horse and rode to the shaykh, who was in
Aqshahr.71 When her husband was informed of the event, he and some of his
guards also mounted horses and went after his wife. After arriving in the presence of the shaykh, they dismounted, kissed the ground in front of the shaykh
and were taken by Bah al-Dn as disciples (murd).72 But the story continues,
mentioning that once the malik invited Rms father to come with him and
stay in the city of Erzincan, the shaykh refused and asked him instead to build
a madrasa in Aqshahr. The request was granted, and the lady is said to have
received religious education under Bah al-Dn in that place for four years.73
Throughout these works, it is possible to find several references to women
becoming disciples or followers, in general terms, and mentions of specific
ladies embracing the Sufi path by joining the master. This is especially present in the work of Aflk, which might suggest that some literate audiences
of women might have existed, to whom writers like Aflk were trying to
appeal as part of their audience.74 As we have seen, Rms mother-in-law was
69 The opposite phenomenon also occurred, as there are many references to personalities
in inscriptions dealing with donations around Anatolia that cannot be attested to in the
historical record, be it hagiographies, chronicles or waqfiyyas. See Redford, Paper, Stone,
Scissors, 15170; and Wolper, Princess Safwat al-Duny wa al-Dn, 37.
70 Aflk, 1:245 / Feats, 1920. Sipahsalar names this lady as Tj Malik Khtn, see
Sipahsalar, 13.
71 There is some confusion as to the location of his town in the narrative. Aflk seems
to indicate that this town was close to Erzincan, where Imat and her husband lived.
However, the location of Aqshahr is a few kilometres north-west of Konya and therefore
nowhere near Erzincan.
72 Aflk, 1:25 / Feats, 20.
73 Aflk, 1:25 / Feats, 20. The account in the Risla of Sipahsalar describes the place as a
khnaqh, or Sufi lodge, instead of a madrasa; see Sipahsalar, 13.
74 In fact, Aflk himself mentions the existence of a woman tutor at the Seljuq court in
charge of the education of the sultans daughters. See Aflk, 2:727 / Feats, 506.
The Ladies of Rm
147
a pparently a student of his own father Bah al-Dn, who once having arrived
in Anatolia and attracted so many men and women that the Sultan himself was
amazed by the situation.75 In fact, the hagiographies try to show this intrinsic
connection between the attraction of the shaykhs and their relationship with
the secular powers that existed in medieval Anatolia.76 Certain ladies of the
Seljuq court appear among those who, according to the hagiographers, felt the
need to engage with the shaykhs.
In the case of Awad al-Dn Kirmn, his relationship with secular powers is
less apparent than that of Rm and his followers.77 However, he is portrayed
on some occasions as spiritually intervening in favour of Seljuq rulers such as
Sultan Al al-Dn Kayqubd I (r. 61834/121937) or as preventing the Mongol
invasion of Rm.78 Also, as has been suggested, it is difficult to imagine that
he could have achieved the high position he held in Baghdad before coming
to Rm without some skills in manoeuvring the complexities of politics and
intrigues at the court of the caliph.79 The image given in his biography with
regard to the proximity of Kirmn to secular powers is not clear. For example,
while he was in Damascus at the khnaqh of shaykh Usman Rm, there is a
mention of the large amount of delicious food sent by Malik dil of Damascus
to this shaykh.80 The story continues by saying that Usman preferred the food
brought by Kirmns beggars because the latter gave him peace, in a clear
attempt to portray Awad al-Dn as above the secular powers. Despite this,
the only woman who appears in this work in full is Rasudn Khtn (r. 61943/
122345), the queen who ruled the Kingdom of Georgia in the seventh/
thirteenth century.81 The story is narrated as a visit paid by the shaykh and some
of his companions to that kingdom. After arriving in the royal palace and being
told at the door that Georgia was ruled by a queen and not a king (pdshh),
they enter the palace and the sight of the lady falls upon the shaykh immediately. She invites him to stay at her palace and he accepts. For a while Kirmn
stays with her, cultivating her love and affection for him. The text mentions
75 Aflk, 1:29 / Feats, 23.
76 Peacock, Sufis and the Seljuk Court, 20626.
77 A list of Kirmns disciples is given in Manqib, Introduction, 456.
78 Manaqib, 18. On the use of powers by shaykhs to promote rulers to power or to prevent
them from attacking, see Peacock, Sufis and the Seljuk Court, 2078.
79 Ridgeon, The Controversy, 21.
80 This was Malik dil Sayf al-Dn Ab Bakr b. Ayyb (d. 615/ 1218), the Ayyubid governor
of Damascus, who in the Manqib is described as a murd of shaykh Usmn Rm (see
Manqib, 62).
81 Marius Canard, Les reines de Georgie dans lhistoire et la legende musulmanes, Revue des
tudes islamiques 37 (1969): 320.
148
De Nicola
The Ladies of Rm
149
Khtn, wife of Rukn al-Dn Qlc Arslan iv (r. 647/1249; 65763/125965) and
mother of Ghiys al-Dn Kaykhusraw iii (r. 66383/126584) whom we cited
above as a donor of sugar.87 The second is Gurj Khtn, a name given by
Aflk to Princess Tamar, a lady of Georgian origin who was probably Christian
or converted to Islam on marriage.88 She was the wife of Ghiys al-Dn
Kaykhusraw ii (r. 63444/123746) and mother of Al al-Dn Kayqubd ii
(r. eastern Seljuq territories 64755/124957).89 Both women financially supported the congregation of Rm supporters and were considered followers of
the shaykh himself.90 In the case of the former, Sipahslr includes her as one
of the transmitters of the shaykhs anecdotes in which she saw Rm entering
the dwellings where the lady was seated with other ladies of the court and
order them to exit the house quickly.91 The ladies ran barefoot out of the house
before the vault of the building collapsed at the feet of the master, thus saving
their lives. In response, the ladies thanked God for bringing the shaykh to them
and gave alms (adaqt) to the poor and the master.92
saw the death of the Lady in Erzurum while he was in Konya, when we know that Pdshh
Khatn died in Kerman in 694 /1295. However, this woman lived in that city for a while,
suggesting that maybe some sort of interaction existed between her and the Mawlawi
order. See Feats, 6223; on her death see Shabnkra, Majma al-ansb, ed. Mir Hashim
Muhaddis (Tehran: Amir Kabir, 1363 sh. / 1984), 2023.
87 A qada poem was composed for her by Rms son Suln Valad in his Dvn. See
Sipahsalar, 169. The name appears as Gmj in Aflk and as Kmj in Sipahsalar.
The mausoleum of this lady is still standing in the city of Konya today. It is known as
the Kz Kulesi; see S. Kemal Yetkin, The Turbeh of Guma Hatun, a Seljuk Monument,
Ars Orientalis 4 (1961): 35760.
88 She was the daughter of the Georgian Empress Rasudn (r. 619643/122345) mentioned
in Kirmns manaqib. On Gurj Khtn see D.M. Lang, Georgia in the Reign of Giorgi
the Brilliant (131446), Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies 17.1 (1955): 86;
and C. Toumanoff, Armenia and Georgia, in The Cambridge Medieval History, vol. 4, ed.
J.M. Hussey (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1966), 625. Her conversion is mentioned by Bar Hebraeus, The Chronography of Gregory Abul Faraj, the son of Aaron, the
Hebrew physician, commonly known as Bar Hebraeus (London: Oxford University Press,
1932), 4034, but challenged by Vryonis, who suggests that her proximity to Rm might
the reason why Bar Heraeus thought she converted. See Speros Vryonis, Another Note on
the Inscription of the Church of St. George of Beliserama, in Byzantina 9 (1977): 19.
89 Lewis, Rumi, 125.
90 Rustam Shukurov, Harem Christianity, 119.
91 In Aflks account, the children of the ladies were also present. See Aflk, 1:335 /
Feats, 232.
92 Sipahsalar, 78. Aflks version of the story specifies that the lady gave the sum of 7,000
suln dirhams for the shaykhs disciples (Aflk, 1:335 / Feats, 232). A similar miracle is
150
De Nicola
The Ladies of Rm
151
Rm to convince the queen to forgive her husband Mun al-Dn for a mistake
he committed and thereby save their marriage.100 Similarly, other non-Muslim
or recently Islamised members of royalty, such as the Mongol Ilkhans and
Khtns, are included in the accounts of similar devotional stories. Although
there is confusion in the account about the chronology and the historical facts,
the charismatic presence of rif Chalab is said to have been requested by
the Ilkhan Ghzn Khn (r. 694703/12951304) through the mediation of his
supposed wife Il-Tuzmish.101 After initially refusing to meet the Mongol ruler,
rif then accepts the invitation and leaves with some of his disciples to the
Mongol court. On the way, he is received by the lady in her tent and engages
in reading the Quran, reciting ghazals and performing sam sessions together
with the lady.102
The religious observance of these ladies towards the shaykhs is also des
cribed in an interesting anecdote in which, again, on the occasion of a trip
she had to make to Keysari, Gurj Khtn ordered that a portrait of the shaykh
should be drawn so she could take it with her on the trip.103 This iconographic
practice appears closer to Christian beliefs than what we would expect from a
Muslim lady, but perhaps it shows indirectly the syncretic nature of religious
life in Anatolia. The proximity of this Christian lady, with her Christian practices, to the Muslim shaykh should not be a surprise but a reflection of the
religious milieu of the time and place. Although their approaches are different, both hagiographies appeal to images of noble Christian ladies to highlight
the virtues of the shaykhs. While in Kirmns case he is depicted as attracting through his charisma the queen of the Christian kingdom of Georgia,104
in Aflk the allegory is a bit more subtle. On one occasion, Gurj asks Alam
al-Dn Qayar (d. 683/1284),105 the architect of Rms mausoleum, why she
100 Aflk, 1:4323 / Feats, 298.
101 Aflk, 2:3123/ Feats, 5912. The confusion comes from the fact that there are two women
called Il-Tuzmish in this period. One was the first wife of Abaqa Ilkhan (r. 66381/1265
82), and then of Gaykhatu (r. 6904/12915), and was therefore not the wife of Ghazan as
Aflk implies. On the wife of Abaqa and Gaykhatu, see Rashd al-Dn Tabib, Rashiduddin
Fazlullahs Jamiut-tawarikh, 515. However, there was another Il-Tuzmish, who was the
granddaughter of Amad Tegder Ilkhan (r. 6813/128284) by his son Mubrak Shh
and who was involved in the process of the conversion of Ghzn Khn and his struggle
with Baidu for the rule of Iran between 694/1295. On this lady, see Rashd al-Dn Tabib,
Rashiduddin Fazlullahs Jamiut-tawarikh, 6012.
102 Aflk, 2:847 / Feats, 592.
103 Aflk, 1:425 / Feats, 2923.
104 Manaqib, 201.
105 Lewis, Rumi, 236.
152
De Nicola
Apart from a relationship comprising both economic and devotional interaction between shaykh and courtly ladies, hagiographies show some inter-female
relationships between women of the shaykhs family and ladies of the Seljuq
court. There is an anecdote in which the wife of Rm, Ker Khtn, received
from her husband a bowl of rose petals brought to him by six men from the
invisible realm while he was praying with Shams-i Tabrz.107 The petals had
curative properties when rubbed over a wounded eye. Although Ker kept
these petals with her until she died as a precious treasure, the final part of the
story adds that she only shared them once with Gurj Khtn with Mawlns
consent.108 Similarly, another account has the same main characters and a
similar narrative construction. In this case, the shaykh disappears overnight
and appears the following morning with his feet covered in sand. Ker Khtn
collected this sand, which a dervish from the order immediately identified as
being from the Hejaz desert. The wife of the shaykhs first reaction was to send
the sand, as she did with the rose petals, to Gurj Khtn, whose belief in the
shaykh increased a thousand times.109 Both stories portray a close connection
between influential people of the court, such as the sultans wife, and members
of the order, by making them participants in the miracles of the shaykhs. These
stories also create a certain intimacy between the court and the shaykhs family
by generating proximity between women of the court and women of the lodge.
This story is not an isolated one; Suln Valads wife Fima is not only described
as someone who performed miracles and a committed ascetic, but also, in passing reference, Aflk claims that she shared these virtues and practices with
both Gmj Khtn and Gurj Khtn.110 This type of inter-female interaction
106 Aflk, 1:519 / Feats, 358.
107 These six men were said to have entered the room by walking through the walls of the
room. In the story, a merchant tells Ker Khtn that this rose only grows in Ceylon (Sri
Lanka) and wonders how it has arrived in Rm (Aflk, 1:901 / Feats, 67).
108 Aflk, 1:92 / Feats, 68.
109 Aflk, 1:2623 / Feats, 1823. The story also appears in Sipahsalar, 7677.
110 Aflk, 2:7201 / Feats, 502. The wife of the Parvanah of Topak is also mentioned among
the ladies who shared experiences with Fima.
The Ladies of Rm
153
between women belonging to the secular power and the religious Sufi family
might be one of the ways in which the Mawlawis attracted some of the wealthy
women of the Seljuq court into their area of influence.111 It might also be simply
one more example of the close relationship between the court and members of
the order, but in this case through a womenwomen relationship. Stories relating this type of connection are exclusive to hagiographic material and provide
an insight into social interaction in seventh/thirteenth- and eighth/fourteenthcentury Anatolia that is not generally present in other historical sources.
The hagiographies analysed here also include anecdotes about women that
denote female activities that are less apparent in other types of sources of the
period. A good number of references are made to women acting as disciples
of the shaykhs and consequently being introduced in Sufi rituals. Among
these rituals, gatherings to perform sam appear to have been common in
seventh/thirteenth- and eighth/fourteenth-century Anatolia.112 On different
occasions, the manqib of Kirmn shows the shaykh organising these social
events to receive noble members of society such as members of the local elite,
merchants and foreign dignitaries.113 Women were also included in these
gatherings and were considered as followers (murdn) of these shaykhs. In
the case of Kirmn, on at least one occasion the performance of sam with
women is recorded with one of his favourite disciples, Zayn al-Dn adaqa.114
As Ridgeon has noted, the apparent opposition of this disciple to the involvement of women in these practices has been used to imply that Kirmn also
viewed female participation of women in sam gatherings with reluctance.115
However, this might be an ad hoc conclusion if we consider the care that
Kirmn put into the religious education of his daughters or, as seen above,
the efforts he made to attract noble ladies to his cause. Further, references to
111 Another example of this inter-female religious interaction can be seen in an allusion to
Moahhara Ktn and Sharaf Khtn, the daughters of Suln Valad and Fima Khtn,
who were allegedly responsible for converting many women in Rm to the Mawlawi order
in the early eighth/fourteenth century. See Aflk 2:995 / Feats, 6978.
112 On sam performances and their controversies see Schimmel, Mystical Dimensions,
17886.
113 See, for example, Manaqib, 40 (while on a trip to Akhl), 65 (he is invited to the session,
assists the meeting but then leaves, promising to come back) or 97 (during a meeting with
other shaykhs in Aleppo). This has been noted in Ridgeon, The Controversy, 23. Similar
sessions were organised for Rm by local elites in Konya, see e.g. Aflk, 1:4889 / Feats,
3367. Sessions at the house of the Parvanah Mun al-Dn and Gurj Khatn were also
organised, see Aflk, 1:48990 / Feats, 337.
114 Manaqib, 1845.
115 Ridgeon, The Controversy, 25.
154
De Nicola
The Ladies of Rm
155
Sufi path for one of them. If we are to believe the account, the daughter of the
shaykh, mina Khtn, after divorcing her husband, went to live in Damascus,
and was there when the work was being written.121 The author claims that in
that city most people were her followers, and because she was the shaykh of seventeen khanaqhs in that town she was known in Syria as the Lady of Scholars
(sitt al-ulama).122 This completes a circle whereby women appear in this
material beyond their role in the shaykh genealogy. Patrons, followers and
scholars were also some of the areas of female involvement in Anatolia, suggesting that women played a more important role in articulating Sufi orders
and Rms political life than previously anticipated.
Conclusions
Despite the general mistrust in scholarship towards looking at hagiographies
as a valuable historical source, when looking at how women are depicted in
them, certain interesting features of womens life in medieval Anatolia can
be observed. Firstly, they confirm the scholarly approach that argues that
women were used as a means to enhance the pedigree of the shaykhs to the
point that succession of the shaykhs depended on the family credentials of
the mother. However, a closer look at this material also suggests that marriage
practices among Sufi shaykhs in the seventh/thirteenth and eighth/fourteenth
centuries respected certain patterns that tried to connect, whenever possible,
female members of the family to both secular and religious establishments
to secure the sociopolitical legitimation and economic viability of Sufi orders.
Hagiographies articulate a narrative to contextualise this process and present
it in a comprehensive way to their public, be it followers of the order, wealthy
local elites or rival religious uruq.
At the same time, hagiographic literature provides a unique insight into
aspects of female religiosity and daily life that are difficult to find in other
source materials. The examples given in this article show that women in
the life of shaykhs were not only those ladies belonging to their family but a
diverse group of women who supported them, followed their teachings and
turned to them in times of need. Also, the role of women who were part of
the shaykhs families was not merely as simple transmitters of a noble pool
of genes from one generation of holy men to the next: some of them played a
121 See also supposedly received a religious education at a young age in Damascus with
Shaykh Shihb al-Dn Suhraward. See Manaqib, 61.
122 Ibid., 64.
156
De Nicola
prominent role in different aspects of the political, economic and religious life
of these medieval Sufi orders. Finally, hagiographies show social dynamics that
cannot be found in other source materials of the period. As we have tried to
show, aspects of inter-female interaction revealed in the anecdotes contained
in these works suggest that women played a more active role in the religious
milieu of the time by spreading Islamic ideas and practices from woman to
woman. The sources not only show a high degree of social integration between
the Seljuq aristocracy and the family of the shaykhs (especially in the case of
Mawln), but also point towards a possible alternative channel of female solidarity through which processes of Islamisation and acculturation might have
occurred in pre-Ottoman Anatolia.