Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
COMMENTS:
A. Tower T-7
1.
a. Wind pressure on various Components: On exposed Area( Str Ht=11.2).
Reply: Noted. The wind pressure on various components revised in Rev-01.
b. Wind on flexible conductors: Moose ACSR (page 6): the value of gust response factor
from table 7 should be 1.8648, not 2.355. Therefore, the wind pressure on exposed area
will be 135 kg/m2.
Reply: the Gust Response factor is revised from table 7 and it is
1.8956 and the
corresponding wind pressure is 149 kg/m2.
c. Wind on shield wire (Ground Wire): the diameter of the shield wire is taken as 0.01098
in the wind calculation, but has been taken as 0.01295m in the load calculation sheets
C3-0 and C4-0. Please confirm the correct values and change wherever required.
Reply: corrected, the diameter of shield wire is 0.01098 as per specification.
d. Wind on pipe structure & all tubular bus bar ( smooth rigid surface): the value of gust
response factor from table 6 should be 1.9536, not 2.335. Therefore, wind pressure on
exposed area will be 169kg/mm2.
Reply: Corrected in Rev-01.
e. Wind on string Insulator; post insulator, switchyard equipments etc: the value of gust
response factor from table 6 is 1.9536, not 2.355. therefore the wind pressure on exposed
are will be 169 kg/m2
Reply: Corrected in Rev-01.
e. Wind on string Insulator; post insulator, switchyard equipments etc: the value of gust
response factor from table 6 is 2.144, not 2.355. therefore the wind pressure on exposed
are will be 185 kg/m2
Reply: Corrected in Rev-01. The actual wind pressure calculated is 194 kg/m2.
f. Wind on solid members- flat sided: the value of gust response factor from table 6 should
be 2.16, not 2.355. Therefore, the wind pressure on exposed area will be 311 kg/m2.
Reply: Corrected in Rev-01.
C. TOWER-T9
a. Wind pressure on various Components: On exposed Area( Str Ht=28.5m).
Reply: Noted. The wind pressure on various components revised in Rev-01.
b. Wind on flexible conductors: Moose ACSR (page 6): the value of gust response factor
from table 7 should be 2.098, not 2.355. Therefore, the wind pressure on exposed area
will be 155 kg/m2.
Reply: Corrected in Rev-01. The actual GC=2.2135 and the actual pressure is 160 kg/m2.
c. Wind on shield wire (Ground Wire): the diameter of the shield wire is taken as 0.01098
in the wind calculation, but has been taken as 0.01295m in the load calculation sheets
C3-0 and C4-0. Please confirm the correct values and change wherever required.
Reply: corrected, the diameter of shield wire is 0.01098 as per specification.
d. Wind on Shield Wire (Ground Wire): the value of gust response factor from table 7
should be 2.2135, not 2.355. Therefore, the wind pressure on exposed area will be 191
kg/m2.
Reply: Corrected in Rev-01.
e. Wind on pipe structure & all tubular bus bar (smooth rigid surface): the value of gust
response factor from table 6 should be 2.14, not 2.335. Therefore, wind pressure on
exposed area will be 185kg/mm2.
Reply: Corrected in Rev-01.the actual wind pressure calculated is 187 kg/m2
f. Wind on string Insulator; post insulator, switchyard equipments etc: the value of gust
response factor from table 6 is 2.144, not 2.355. therefore the wind pressure on exposed
are will be 185 kg/m2
Reply: Corrected in Rev-01. The actual wind pressure calculated is 194 kg/m2.
g. Wind on solid members- flat sided: the value of gust response factor from table 6 should
be 2.16, not 2.355. Therefore, the wind pressure on exposed area will be 329 kg/m2.
Reply: Corrected in Rev-01.