Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
20.0 Introduction
The goal of short circuit analysis is to
identify the range of currents that will flow
in the network under faulted conditions.
The range of currents are identified by the
minimum and maximum currents that flow
under faulted conditions.
What do we mean by faulted conditions?
These are conditions that include one or
more short circuits somewhere in the
network.
Faulted conditions are highly undesirable
because the currents that flow under faulted
conditions are normally extremely high. If
uninterrupted, such currents cause very high
heating in the conductors and likely result in
damage to at least one of them.
1
Example:
Consider the very simple single phase
distribution system of Fig. 1. The per unit
impedance between the generator and bus 2
is 0.03125, between bus 2 and bus 3 is 0.10,
and between bus 3 and bus 4 is 0.025. The
load has a per unit impedance of 3.125. The
generator voltage is 1.0 per unit.
(a) Compute the normal load current in perunit.
(b)
Compute the current for a fault at bus 4
in per-unit.
Fig. 1
Solution:
(a)
The normal load current is easy to get:
1.0
I
0.3048 pu (1)
0.03125 0.1 0.025 3.125
(b) A fault at bus 4 will short the load.
Load
6.4 pu
(2)
0.03125 0.1 0.025
fault
Fig. 2
To make the previous point very clear,
consider a fault at bus 3. Then the circuit is:
Fig. 3
and the fault current calculation is:
1.0
I
7.62 pu
(3)
0.13125
We note in the previous calculation that the
only part of the circuit that was of influence
was the part between the generator and the
fault. As a result, the 0.125 part of the
impedance is not included.
fault
bb
cc
ab
ac
bc
10
aa
02
20
12
21
ab
aa
ab
Fig. 4
We are very much aware that distribution
systems generally do not satisfy the
9
12
13
14
Fig. 5
where we see the sequence impedances are:
Z0=ZY+3Zn
(9)
Z1=ZY
(10)
Z2=ZY
(11)
If the neutral is solidly grounded, then Zn=0
and eq. (9) above becomes Z0=ZY.
15
Fig. 6
17
20.5.2 Lines
In Notes7, the work we did to answer the
question of What if the load (or line, or load
and line) is not symmetric? led to another
question, which was: So what are the
conditions for the off-diagonal elements of
Z012 to be 0?
We have already reviewed the answer to this
question in section 20.3 above, which was:
Equal
diagonal
elements
(phase
impedances must be equal), i.e.,
Z Z Z
(4)
Equal offdiagonal elements (offdiagonal
phase impedances must be equal), i.e.,
Z Z Z
(5)
In this case, the 012 sequence impedances
are:
Z Z Z Z Z Z 0
(6)
Z Z 2Z
(7)
Z Z Z Z
(8)
Equation (6) simply says that all offdiagonal elements on the 012 sequence
aa
bb
cc
ab
ac
bc
01
10
aa
02
20
12
21
ab
aa
ab
18
Fig. 7
It is interesting to compare eqs. (7) and (8)
for a symmetric line (or cable), and note that
19
1. Positive
and
negative
sequence
impedances are equal, i.e.,
Z1=Z2=Zseries
where Zseries is the transformer winding
resistance and leakage reactance.
2. For connection types 4 and 5 in the
above list, the phase shift is included from
low side to high side as
+30 for positive sequence
-30 for negative sequence
3. For zero-sequence network,
a.We will get a complete open circuit
(I0=0) if there is an ungrounded Y on one
or both sides.
b. We will get isolation of primary from
secondary if there is a on one or both
sides. This means that connection
prevents pass-through of zero-sequence
currents. However, we may still get
zero-sequence current flowing if the
other side is grounded Y or .
c.We get no isolation if both sides are
grounded-Y.
22
d. Z0=Zseries+3Znp+3Zns where:
Znp: neutral impedance on primary
Zns: neutral impedance on secondary
A couple of concepts that are important here
in understanding the points under (3) above
are:
There must be a connection to ground on
the high-side for zero-sequence current to
flow from the transmission system into the
high side of the transformer.
If zero-sequence currents cannot flow
on primary (secondary) side of the
transformer, then because currents on the
secondary (primary) side of the
transformer can only arise through
induction of currents on the primary
(secondary) side of the transformer, zerosequence currents also cannot flow on
the secondary (primary) side of the
transformer.
23
Fig. 8
24
2. Grounded Y to Y or Y to grounded Y.
Fig. 9
Here, there is no place for zero-sequence
currents to flow on the Y side (since there is
no neutral and sum of phase currents, which
equals I0, must be 0). Therefore, there can be
no zero-sequence currents flowing on the
other side either. So I0=0 for this connection.
Y to grounded Y is the same.
25
3. -
Fig. 10
Here, zero sequence currents cannot enter or
leave either winding, although it is
possible for them to circulate within the
windings.
26
4. Grounded Y to or to grounded Y
28
5.
Y- or -Y.
Fig. 13: Y to
29
Fig. 14: to Y
Observe that Figs. 13 and 14 are exactly like
Figs. 11 and 12 in the positive and negative
sequence circuits. The only difference in the
zero-sequence circuit, where we see that, in
Figs. 13 and 14, not only can zero-sequence
currents not pass through (which is the case
in Figs. 11 and 12) but they cannot flow at
all.
20.5.4 Generators
30
32
33
Fig. 15
20.6 Obtaining Thevenin equivalent
The first thing to do is to draw all three
sequence networks of the system to be
analyzed, using information from the oneline diagram together with the component
sequence models provided in Figs. 5-15.
Then identify the fault location in each of
the three sequence networks.
Then, for each of the three sequence
networks,
determine
the
Thevenin
equivalent of the upstream portion of the
network as seen from the fault location.
Recall we
Obtain the Thevenin impedance by idling
all sources (short constant voltage sources
and open constant current sources) and
34
Example:
Consider the substation of Fig. 16.
Fig. 16
The transformer is -Y grounded with rated
line-to-line ratio of 69 kV/12.47 kV and
power rating of 5 MVA. The transformer
35
69000 2
1E 6
4761
7.935
0.0017
4761
1
0.0013
5
37
Fig. 17
38
I 012 A I abc
1 1
1
1 a
3
1 a 2
1 1
1
1 a
3
1 a 2
1 Ia
a 2 I b
a I c
1 I af 0
0
2
a I af 120 I af
0
a I af 120
39
Fig. 18
From Figure 18, we compute:
I 1fa
1.0
68.03 pu
0.0147
And of course,
I 0fa I 2fa 0
I 0fa
1 1
2
I fb A I 1 a
I fc
I
1 a
68.03
68.03 120
68.03120
1
fa
2
fa
1 0
a 68.03
a 2 0
Sb 3
3VLLb
1E 6
3 (12.47 E 3)
46.3
I 012 A I abc
1 1
1
1 a
3
2
1 a
1 1
1
1 a
3
1 a 2
1 Ia
a 2 I b
a I c
I af
1 I af
1
2
a 0 I af
3
I af
a 0
41
Fig. 19
From Figure 19, we compute:
I 1fa I 2fa I 0fa
1.0
23.58 pu
0.0147 0.0147 0.013
I 0fa
1 1
2
I fb A I 1 a
I fc
I
1 a
70.74
0
0
1
fa
2
fa
1 23.58
a 23.58
a 2 23.58
I 012 A I abc
1 1
1
1 a
3
1 a 2
1 1
1
1 a
3
1 a 2
1
a 2
a
1
a 2
Ia
I
b
a I c
0
0
1
I bf
3 I bf 90
3
3 I bf 90
I bf
43
Fig. 19
From Figure 19, we compute:
I 1fa I 2fa
1.0
34.01 pu
0.0147 0.0147
1
2
I fb A I fa 1 a
I fc
I 2fa 1 a
3 ( 34.01)90
3 ( 34.01) 90
1
a
a 2
0
34.01
34.01
0
58.91
58.91
45