Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
7
8
Volume of
stationary object
Volume of moving
object
Area of stationary
object
Area of moving
object
Weight of moving
object
Weight of stationary
object
Length of moving
object
Length of stationary
object
Length of stationary
object
Length of moving
object
Improving
Feature
Weight of stationary
object
Worsening
Feature
Weight of moving
object
Contradiction Matrix
15, 8,
29,34
29, 17,
38, 34
29, 2,
40, 28
10, 1,
29, 35
35, 30,
13, 2
5, 35,
14, 2
8, 15,
29, 34
15, 17,
4
7, 17,
4, 35
35, 28,
40, 29
17, 7,
10, 40
35, 8,
2,14
2, 17,
29, 4
14, 15,
18, 4
7, 14,
17, 4
30, 2,
14, 18
26, 7,
9, 39
2, 26,
29, 40
1, 7, 4,
35
1, 7, 4,
17
35, 10,
35, 8,
19, 14
19, 14
2, 14
Speed
Force (Intensity)
Stress or pressure
Shape
Stability of the
object's composition
Strength
Duration of action of
moving object
Duration of action of
stationary object
Contradiction Matrix
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Worsening
Feature
Improving
Feature
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Weight of moving
object
Weight of stationary
object
Length of moving
object
Length of stationary
object
Area of moving object
Area of stationary
object
Volume of moving
object
Volume of stationary
object
2, 8, 8, 10,
15, 38 18, 37
8, 10,
19, 35
13, 4, 17, 10,
8
4
-
28, 10
10, 36,
37, 40
13, 29,
10, 18
1, 8,
35
1, 14,
35
10, 15,
36, 28
10, 15,
36, 37
6, 35,
36, 37
10, 14,
35, 40
13, 10,
29, 14
1, 8,
10, 29
13, 14,
15, 7
5, 34,
29, 4
1, 35,
19, 39
26, 39,
1, 40
1, 8,
15, 34
39, 37,
35
11, 2,
13, 39
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Weight of moving
object
Weight of stationary
object
Length of moving
object
Length of stationary
object
Use of energy by
moving object
Use of energy by
stationary object
Power
Loss of Energy
Loss of Substance
Loss of Information
Improving
Feature
Illumination
intensity
Worsening
Feature
Temperature
Contradiction Matrix
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
6, 29,
4, 38
28, 19,
32, 22
10, 15,
19
3, 35,
38, 18
2, 15,
Area of moving object
16
Area of stationary
35, 39,
object
38
Volume of moving
34, 39,
object
10, 18
Volume of stationary 35, 6,
object
4
15, 32,
19, 32
19, 13
2, 13,
10
35
-
10, 24,
35
10, 15,
35
1, 24
24, 26,
30, 26
30, 16
2, 22
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Reliability
Measurement
accuracy
Manufacturing
precision
Object-afected
harmful factors
Object-generated
harmful factors
Ease of manufacture
Improving
Feature
Quantity of
substance
Worsening
Feature
Loss of Time
Contradiction Matrix
25
26
27
28,
27,
28
35, 26
29
30
31
32
Weight of moving
object
Weight of stationary
object
Length of moving
object
Length of stationary
object
10, 35,
20, 28
10, 20,
35, 26
15, 2,
29
30, 29,
14
26, 4
Area of stationary
object
Volume of moving
object
Volume of stationary
object
10, 35,
4, 18
2, 6,
34, 10
35, 16,
32 18
3, 26, 1, 3,
18, 31 11, 27
19, 6, 10, 28,
18, 26 8, 3
10, 14,
29, 35
29, 40
15, 29,
28
29, 30,
29, 9
6, 13
2, 18, 32, 35,
40, 4 40, 4
29, 30, 14, 1,
7
40, 11
2, 35,
35, 3
16
28, 35,
26, 18
18, 26, 10, 1,
28
35, 17
28, 32, 10, 28,
4
29, 37
32, 28, 2, 32,
3
10
26, 28,
2, 32
32, 3
26, 28, 2, 29,
32, 3 18, 36
25, 26, 25, 28,
28
2, 16
35, 10,
25
22, 21,
18, 27
2, 19,
22, 37
1, 15,
17, 24
1, 18
22, 33,
28, 1
27, 2,
39, 35
22, 21,
27, 35
34, 39,
19, 27
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Weight of moving
object
Weight of stationary
object
Length of moving
object
Length of stationary
object
Area of moving object
Area of stationary
object
Volume of moving
object
Volume of stationary
object
Adaptability or
versatility
Device complexity
Difculty of
detecting and
measuring
Extent of
automation
Productivity
Improving
Feature
Ease of repair
Worsening
Feature
Ease of operation
Contradiction Matrix
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
35, 3,
2, 24
6, 13,
1, 32
15, 29,
35, 4
2, 25
2, 27, 29, 5,
28, 11 15, 8
2, 27, 19, 15,
28, 11
29
1, 28, 14, 15,
10
1, 16
3
1, 35
26, 30,
36, 34
1, 10,
26, 39
1, 19,
26, 24
28, 29,
26, 32
25, 28,
17, 15
35, 1,
26, 24
26, 35
18, 19
2, 26,
35
17, 24,
26, 16
1, 26
26
35, 3,
24, 37
1, 28,
15, 35
14, 4,
28, 29
30, 14,
7, 26
10, 26,
34, 2
10, 15,
17, 7
10, 6,
2, 34
35, 37,
10, 2
Speed
10
Force (Intensity)
11
Stress or pressure
12
Shape
13
Stability of the
object's composition
14
Strength
15
16
Duration of action of
moving object
Duration of action by
stationary object
Length of moving
object
Length of stationary
object
Area of moving
object
Area of stationary
object
Volume of moving
object
Volume of
stationary object
Improving
Feature
Weight of stationary
object
Worsening
Feature
Weight of moving
object
Contradiction Matrix
2, 28,
13, 38
8, 1,
37, 18
10, 36,
37, 40
8, 10,
29, 40
21, 35,
2, 39
1, 8,
40, 15
19, 5,
34, 31
18, 13,
1, 28
13, 29,
10, 18
15, 10,
26, 3
26, 39,
1, 40
40, 26,
27, 1
6, 27,
19, 16
13, 14,
8
17, 19,
9, 36
35, 10,
36
29, 34,
5, 4
13, 15,
1, 28
1, 15,
8, 35
2, 19,
9
-
28, 10
35, 1,
14, 16
13, 14,
10, 7
37
15, 14,
28, 26
1, 40,
35
29, 30,
34
19, 10,
15
10, 15,
36, 28
5, 34,
4, 10
2, 11,
13
3, 34,
40, 29
3, 17,
19
-
1, 18,
36, 37
10, 15,
36, 37
39
9, 40,
28
-
7, 29,
34
15, 9,
12, 37
6, 35,
10
14, 4,
15, 22
28, 10,
19, 39
10, 15,
14, 7
10, 2,
19, 30
-
2, 36,
18, 37
35, 24
7, 2,
35
34, 28,
35, 40
9, 14,
17, 15
35, 34,
38
Speed
Force (Intensity)
Stress or pressure
Shape
Stability of the
object's composition
Strength
Duration of action of
moving object
Duration of action of
stationary object
Contradiction Matrix
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Worsening
Feature
Improving
Feature
Speed
10
Force (Intensity)
11
Stress or pressure
12
Shape
13
Stability of the
object's composition
14
Strength
15
16
Duration of action of
moving object
Duration of action by
stationary object
+
13, 28,
15, 12
6, 35,
36
35, 15,
34, 18
33, 15,
28, 18
8, 13,
26, 14
3, 35,
5
-
35, 15,
18, 34
10, 35,
40, 34
35, 4,
15, 10
28, 33,
1, 18
35, 10,
21
35, 33,
2, 40
33, 1,
18, 4
8, 3,
26, 14
35, 10,
14, 27
9, 18,
3, 40
30, 14,
10, 40
17, 9,
15
3, 19,
35, 5
22, 1,
+
18, 4
10, 30, 13, 17,
+
35, 40
35
14, 26, 13, 3, 27, 3,
28, 25
35
10
39, 3,
35, 23
19, 2
19, 3,
27
14, 26,
9, 25
13, 27, 39, 3,
10, 35 35, 23
27, 3,
26
+
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Use of energy by
moving object
Use of energy by
stationary object
Power
Loss of Energy
Loss of Substance
Loss of Information
Improving
Feature
Illumination
intensity
Worsening
Feature
Temperature
Contradiction Matrix
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
28, 30,
36, 2
35, 10,
Force (Intensity)
21
35, 39,
Stress or pressure
19, 2
22, 14,
Shape
19, 32
Stability of the
35, 1,
object's composition
32
30, 10,
Strength
40
Duration of action of 19, 35,
moving object
39
Duration of action by 19, 18,
stationary object
36, 40
Speed
19, 35,
38, 2
1, 16, 19, 35,
36, 37 18, 37
10, 35,
14
-
4, 6, 2
27, 4, 32, 35,
29, 18 27, 31
10, 26,
35
35, 28
19, 10,
35, 38
16
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Reliability
Measurement
accuracy
Manufacturing
precision
Object-afected
harmful factors
Object-generated
harmful factors
Ease of manufacture
Improving
Feature
Quantity of
substance
Worsening
Feature
Loss of Time
Contradiction Matrix
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
10, 19,
29, 38
10, 37, 14, 29,
Force (Intensity)
36
18, 36
37, 36, 10, 14,
Stress or pressure
4
36
14, 10,
Shape
36, 22
34, 17
Stability of the
15, 32,
35, 27
object's composition
35
29, 3, 29, 10,
Strength
28, 10
27
Duration of action of 20, 10, 3, 35,
moving object
28, 18 10, 40
Duration of action by 28, 20, 3, 35,
stationary object
10, 16
31
Speed
11, 35,
27, 28
3, 35,
13, 21
10, 13,
19, 35
10, 40,
16
28, 32,
1, 24
35, 10,
23, 24
6, 28,
25
28, 32,
1
10, 28,
32, 25
28, 29,
37, 36
13
18
3, 27,
16
3, 27
1, 28,
35, 23
1, 35,
40, 18
22, 2,
37
22, 1,
2, 35
35, 24,
30, 18
18, 35,
37, 1
22, 15,
33, 28
17, 1,
40, 33
11, 3
3, 35
32, 30,
40
11, 2,
3, 27,
3
13
16, 40
34, 27, 10, 26,
6, 40
24
35, 10
Speed
10
Force (Intensity)
11
Stress or pressure
12
Shape
13
Stability of the
object's composition
14
Strength
15
16
Duration of action of
moving object
Duration of action by
stationary object
Adaptability or
versatility
Device complexity
Difculty of
detecting and
measuring
Extent of
automation
Productivity
Improving
Feature
Ease of repair
Worsening
Feature
Ease of operation
Contradiction Matrix
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
32, 15,
26
32, 35,
30
32, 40,
25, 2
2, 13,
1
2, 35,
10, 16
27, 11,
3
29, 10,
12, 27
27
1
35
1, 15,
29
35, 30,
34, 2
15, 3,
32
1, 35,
13
2
10, 28,
4, 34
26, 35,
10, 18
19, 1,
35
16, 29,
1, 28
2, 35,
22, 26
2, 13,
25, 28
10, 4,
29, 15
3, 34,
27, 16
36, 37,
10, 19
2, 36,
37
15, 13,
39
35, 22,
39, 23
27, 3,
15, 40
19, 29,
39, 35
25, 34,
6, 35
10, 18
3, 28,
35, 37
10, 14,
35, 24
35, 37
15, 1, 17, 26,
32
34, 10
1, 8, 23, 35,
35
40, 3
29, 35,
15
10, 14
35, 17,
6, 10
14, 19
20, 10,
1
16, 38
2, 35
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
Length of moving
object
Length of stationary
object
Area of moving
object
Area of stationary
object
Volume of moving
object
Volume of
stationary object
Improving
Feature
Weight of stationary
object
Worsening
Feature
Weight of moving
object
Contradiction Matrix
Speed
Force (Intensity)
Stress or pressure
Shape
Stability of the
object's composition
Strength
Duration of action of
moving object
Duration of action of
stationary object
Contradiction Matrix
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Worsening
Feature
Improving
Feature
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
2, 28,
36, 30
10, 13,
Illumination intensity
19
Use of energy by
8, 35,
moving object
35
Use of energy by
stationary object
15, 35,
Power
2
16, 35,
Loss of Energy
38
10, 13,
Loss of substance
28, 38
Temperature
Loss of Information
26, 32
16
26
35, 28, 28, 27, 27, 16,
31, 40 3, 18 18, 38
10
10
17
Temperature
18
Illumination intensity
19
20
Use of energy by
moving object
Use of energy by
stationary object
21
Power
22
Loss of Energy
23
Loss of substance
24
Loss of Information
Use of energy by
moving object
Use of energy by
stationary object
Power
Loss of Energy
Loss of Substance
Loss of Information
Improving
Feature
Illumination
intensity
Worsening
Feature
Temperature
Contradiction Matrix
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
+
32, 35,
19
19, 24,
3, 14
2, 14,
17, 25
19, 38,
7
21, 36,
39, 31
21, 36,
29, 31
13, 1
1, 6
35, 24,
18, 5
28, 27,
+
18, 31
10, 35, 28, 27,
+
10, 19
38
18, 38
35, 27,
3, 38
+
19, 10
2, 37
28, 27, 28, 27, 35, 27,
+
12, 31 18, 38 2, 31
10, 19 19, 10
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
Reliability
Measurement
accuracy
Manufacturing
precision
Object-afected
harmful factors
Object-generated
harmful factors
Ease of manufacture
Improving
Feature
Quantity of
substance
Worsening
Feature
Loss of Time
Contradiction Matrix
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
35, 28,
21, 18
19, 1,
Illumination intensity
26, 17
Use of energy by
35, 38,
moving object
19, 18
Use of energy by
stationary object
35, 20,
Power
10, 6
10, 18,
Loss of Energy
32, 7
15, 18,
Loss of substance
35, 10
24, 26,
Loss of Information
28, 32
Temperature
24
3, 32
32, 2
35, 10,
24, 31
26, 27
19, 35,
28, 26
28, 26,
30
1, 4
26, 10,
34
15, 34,
33
32
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
Adaptability or
versatility
Device complexity
Difculty of
detecting and
measuring
Extent of
automation
Productivity
Improving
Feature
Ease of repair
Worsening
Feature
Ease of operation
Contradiction Matrix
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
4, 10,
16
28, 26, 15, 17,
Illumination intensity
19
13, 16
Use of energy by
1, 15,
19, 35
moving object
17, 28
Use of energy by
stationary object
26, 35, 35, 2,
Power
10
10, 34
35, 32,
Loss of Energy
2, 19
1
32, 28, 2, 35,
Loss of substance
2, 24 34, 27
Temperature
Loss of Information
26, 27
27, 22
2, 18,
27
15, 1,
19
15, 17,
13, 16
2, 17,
16
6, 32,
13
2, 29,
27, 28
30
31
32
Volume of
stationary object
29
Volume of moving
object
28
Area of stationary
object
27
Area of moving
object
26
Length of stationary
object
25
Length of moving
object
Improving
Feature
Weight of stationary
object
Worsening
Feature
Weight of moving
object
Contradiction Matrix
10, 20,
26, 5
27, 26,
18, 35
3, 10,
8, 28
28, 35,
25, 26
28, 35,
27, 9
2, 22,
13, 24
35, 22,
1, 39
1, 27,
36, 13
15, 2,
29
29, 14,
35, 18
15, 9,
14, 4
28, 26,
5, 16
10, 28,
29, 37
17, 1,
39, 4
17, 15,
16, 22
1, 29,
13, 17
10, 20,
37, 35
Quantity of
35, 6,
substance/the matter 18, 31
3, 8,
Reliability
10, 40
32, 35,
Measurement accuracy
26, 28
Manufacturing
28, 32,
precision
13, 18
Object-afected
22, 21,
harmful factors
27, 39
Object-generated
19, 22,
harmful factors
15, 39
28, 29,
Ease of manufacture
15, 16
Loss of Time
10, 35,
17, 4
2, 18,
40, 4
32, 35,
40, 4
26, 28,
32, 3
2, 29,
18, 36
27, 2,
39, 35
22, 1,
40
2, 5,
34, 10
15, 20,
29
3, 10,
14, 24
32, 13,
6
32, 23,
2
22, 23,
37, 35
17, 2,
40
13, 29,
16, 40
1, 40
35, 16,
32, 18
2, 35,
24
25, 10,
35
34, 39,
19, 27
30, 18,
35, 4
35
Speed
Force (Intensity)
Stress or pressure
Shape
Stability of the
object's composition
Strength
Duration of action of
moving object
Duration of action of
stationary object
Contradiction Matrix
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Worsening
Feature
Improving
Feature
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
Loss of Time
Quantity of
35, 29,
substance/the matter 34, 28
21, 35,
Reliability
11, 28
28, 13,
Measurement accuracy
32, 24
Manufacturing
10, 28,
precision
32
Object-afected
21, 22,
harmful factors
35, 28
Object-generated
35, 28,
harmful factors
3, 23
35, 13,
Ease of manufacture
8, 1
10, 37,
36,5
35, 14,
3
8, 28,
10, 3
37,
36,4
10, 36,
14, 3
10, 24,
35, 19
6, 28,
32, 2
32
28, 19,
3, 35
34, 36
13, 35, 22, 2,
39, 18
37
35, 28, 2, 33,
1, 40 27, 18
35, 19,
35, 12
1, 37
4, 10, 35, 3,
34, 17 22, 5
15, 2,
35, 14
17, 40
35, 1,
16, 11
6, 28, 32, 35,
32
13
32, 30,
30, 18
40
22, 1, 35, 24,
3, 35 30, 18
35, 40,
35, 1
27, 39
1, 28, 11, 13,
13, 27
1
29, 3,
28, 18
14, 35,
34, 10
20, 10,
28, 18
3, 35,
10, 40
2, 35,
3, 25
28, 6,
32
3, 27,
40
22, 15,
33, 28
15, 22,
33, 31
27, 1,
4
28, 20,
10, 16
3, 35,
31
34, 27,
6, 40
10, 26,
24
11, 28
28, 6,
32
3, 27
18, 35,
37, 1
15, 35,
22, 2
1, 3,
10, 32
17, 1,
40, 33
21, 39,
16, 22
35, 16
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
Use of energy by
moving object
Use of energy by
stationary object
Power
Loss of Energy
Loss of Substance
Loss of Information
Improving
Feature
Illumination
intensity
Worsening
Feature
Temperature
Contradiction Matrix
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
35, 29,
21, 18
Quantity of
3, 17,
substance/the matter
39
3, 35,
Reliability
10
6, 19,
Measurement accuracy
28, 24
Manufacturing
19, 26
precision
Object-afected
22, 33,
harmful factors
35, 2
Object-generated
22, 35,
harmful factors
2, 24
27, 26,
Ease of manufacture
18
Loss of Time
10, 5,
18, 32
7, 18,
25
10, 11,
35
26, 32,
27
13, 32,
2
21, 22,
35, 2
21, 35,
2, 22
35, 18,
10, 39
6, 3,
10, 24
10, 35,
29, 39
10, 16,
31, 28
35, 31,
3, 32 32, 2
32, 2
10, 24
1, 19, 1, 24, 10, 2, 19, 22,
33, 22,
32, 13 6, 27 22, 37 31, 2
19, 40
19, 24, 2, 35, 19, 22, 2, 35,
10, 1,
39, 32
6
18
18
34
28, 24, 28, 26,
27, 1,
15, 34,
1, 4
19, 35
27, 1 27, 1
12, 24
33
24, 26,
28, 32
24, 28,
35
10, 28
22, 10,
2
10, 21,
29
32, 24,
18, 16
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
Loss of Time
Reliability
Measurement
accuracy
Manufacturing
precision
Object-afected
harmful factors
Object-generated
harmful factors
Ease of manufacture
Improving
Feature
Quantity of
substance
Worsening
Feature
Loss of Time
Contradiction Matrix
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
Quantity of
35, 38,
substance/the matter 18, 16
10, 30,
Reliability
4
24, 34,
Measurement accuracy
28, 32
Manufacturing
32, 26,
precision
28, 18
Object-afected
35, 18,
harmful factors
34
Object-generated
1, 22
harmful factors
35, 28,
Ease of manufacture
34, 4
24, 34,
28, 32
13, 2,
28
32, 3,
11, 23
35, 22,
18, 39
3, 35,
40, 39
35, 2,
40, 26
3, 33,
39, 10
4, 17,
34, 26
35, 28,
34, 4
29, 1,
35, 27
6, 35,
25, 18
24, 35,
2
+
+
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
Adaptability or
versatility
Device complexity
Difculty of
detecting and
measuring
Extent of
automation
Productivity
Improving
Feature
Ease of repair
Worsening
Feature
Ease of operation
Contradiction Matrix
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
4, 28,
10, 34
Quantity of
35, 29,
substance/the matter 25, 10
27, 17,
Reliability
40
1, 13,
Measurement accuracy
17, 34
Manufacturing
1, 32,
precision
35, 23
Object-afected
2, 25,
harmful factors
28, 39
Object-generated
harmful factors
2, 5,
Ease of manufacture
13, 16
Loss of Time
32, 1,
35, 28 6, 29
10
2, 32, 15, 3, 3, 13,
10, 25
29
27, 10
13, 35, 13, 35,
1, 11
8, 24
1
1, 32, 13, 35, 27, 35,
13, 11
2
10, 34
26, 2,
25, 10
18
35, 10, 35, 11, 22, 19,
2
22, 31 29, 40
19, 1,
31
35, 1, 2, 13, 27, 26,
11, 9
15
1
18, 28,
32, 10
3, 27,
29, 18
27, 40,
28
26, 24,
32, 28
24, 28,
35, 30
8, 35
11, 13,
27
28, 2,
10, 34
26, 28,
18, 23
22, 19, 33, 3,
29, 40
34
2, 21,
2
27, 1
6, 28, 8, 28,
11, 1
1
13, 29,
3, 27
1, 35,
29, 38
10, 34,
28, 32
10, 18,
32, 39
22, 35,
13, 24
22, 35,
18, 39
35, 1,
10, 28
38
39
Volume of
stationary object
37
Volume of moving
object
36
Area of stationary
object
35
Area of moving
object
34
Length of stationary
object
33
Length of moving
object
Improving
Feature
Weight of stationary
object
Worsening
Feature
Weight of moving
object
Contradiction Matrix
6, 13,
1, 25
2, 27,
35, 11
19, 15,
29, 16
2, 26,
35, 39
6, 13,
28, 1
28, 26,
35, 10
28, 27,
15, 3
1, 17,
13, 12
1, 28,
10, 25
35, 1,
29, 2
1, 19,
26, 24
16, 17,
26, 24
14, 13,
17, 28
18, 4,
28, 38
25, 2,
13, 15
2, 27
Ease of repair
35, 11
Adaptability or
1, 6,
versatility
15, 8
26, 30,
Device complexity
34, 36
Difculty of detecting 27, 26,
and measuring
28, 13
28, 26,
Extent of automation
18, 35
35, 26,
Productivity
24, 37
Ease of operation
3, 18,
31
1, 35,
16
26
26
23
30, 7,
14, 26
1, 17,
13, 16
15, 13,
32
35, 30,
29, 7
14, 1,
13, 16
2, 13,
18, 17
17, 14,
13
10, 26,
34, 31
4, 18,
39, 31
1
1, 16
2, 18,
26, 31
35, 37,
10, 2
Speed
Force (Intensity)
Stress or pressure
Shape
Stability of the
object's composition
Strength
Duration of action of
moving object
Duration of action of
stationary object
Contradiction Matrix
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Worsening
Feature
Improving
Feature
33
34
35
36
37
38
Extent of automation
39
Productivity
25, 13
29, 3,
8, 25
11, 29,
28, 27
13, 1,
35
10, 4,
28, 15
19, 29,
39, 25
1, 16,
25
1
2, 16
25, 34,
6, 35
6, 9
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
Use of energy by
moving object
Use of energy by
stationary object
Power
Loss of Energy
Loss of Substance
Loss of Information
Improving
Feature
Illumination
intensity
Worsening
Feature
Temperature
Contradiction Matrix
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
1, 13,
24
15, 1,
28, 16
19, 35,
29, 13
27, 2,
29, 28
35, 38
2, 32,
13
35, 10,
38, 19
35, 34,
2, 10
15, 10,
32, 2
19, 1,
29
20, 19,
30, 34
19, 35, 18, 1,
16
16, 10
28, 2,
27
35, 20,
1
10
2, 19,
13
15, 1,
32, 19
18, 15,
1
10, 35,
13, 2
35, 3,
15, 19
28, 32,
2, 24
2, 35,
34, 27
15, 10,
2, 13
35, 10,
28, 29
1, 18,
10, 24
35, 10,
23, 28
18, 5
28, 10, 28, 10,
29, 35 35, 23
4, 10,
27, 22
35, 33,
27, 22
35, 33
13, 15,
23
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
Reliability
Measurement
accuracy
Manufacturing
precision
Object-afected
harmful factors
Object-generated
harmful factors
Ease of manufacture
Improving
Feature
Quantity of
substance
Worsening
Feature
Loss of Time
Contradiction Matrix
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
4, 28,
12, 35
10, 34
32, 1, 2, 28,
Ease of repair
10, 25 10, 25
Adaptability or
3, 35,
35, 28
versatility
15
13, 3,
Device complexity
6, 29
27, 10
Difculty of detecting 18, 28, 3, 27,
and measuring
32, 9 29, 18
24, 28,
Extent of automation
35, 13
35, 30
Ease of operation
Productivity
17, 27,
8, 40
11, 10,
1, 16
35, 13,
8, 24
13, 35,
1
27, 40,
28, 8
11, 27,
32
1, 35,
35, 38
10, 38
25, 13,
2, 34
10, 2,
13
35, 5,
1, 10
2, 26,
10, 34
26, 24,
32, 28
28, 26,
10, 34
1, 10,
34, 28
1, 32, 2, 25,
35, 23 28, 39
35, 10,
25, 10
2, 16
35, 11,
32, 31
26, 24, 22, 19,
32
29, 40
22, 19,
29, 28
28, 26,
2, 33
18, 23
18, 10, 22, 35,
32, 1 13, 24
19, 1
2, 5,
12
1, 35,
11, 10
1, 13,
31
27, 26,
1, 13
5, 28,
11, 29
1, 26,
13
35, 28,
2, 24
2, 21
2
35, 22,
18, 39
33
Ease of operation
34
Ease of repair
35
Adaptability or
versatility
36
Device complexity
37
Difculty of detecting
and measuring
38
Extent of automation
39
Productivity
Adaptability or
versatility
Device complexity
Difculty of
detecting and
measuring
Extent of
automation
Productivity
Improving
Feature
Ease of repair
Worsening
Feature
Ease of operation
Contradiction Matrix
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
+
1, 12,
26, 15
15, 34,
1, 16
27, 9,
26, 24
2, 5
1, 12, 1, 35,
34, 3
13
1, 28, 1, 32,
7, 10 10, 25
1, 15
27, 4,
1, 35
1, 35,
28, 37
32, 26,
12, 17
35, 1,
13, 11
15, 29,
37, 28
+
1, 34,
12, 3
34, 35,
7, 13
27, 34,
1
35
15, 10, 15, 1,
37, 28
24
15, 1,
28
1, 32,
10
35, 28,
6, 37
12, 17,
28
15, 10,
+
34, 21 35, 18
37, 28
15, 24, 34, 27,
5, 12,
+
10
25
35, 26
12, 17, 35, 18, 5, 12,
+
28, 24 27, 2 35, 26