Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
This paper briefly gives an overview of heavy oil thermal kinetics in a delayed coker and how these reactions effect the
fouling in the delayed coker fired heater. Feed quality, asphaltene content and contaminates play a major role in the
formation of coke on heater tubes. Heater operating conditions, such as the process fluid flowing temperature and
velocity, also affect fouling rates in the heater.
The presentation then discusses design and operating methods to reduce the delayed coker heater fouling and extend
heater run lengths. Current heat flux design practices are discussed and how these practices often do not take full
advantage of available technology.
The use of process injection steam to increase the fluid velocities is discussed. Velocity steam has an obvious effect on
the heater hydraulics and some control practices are discussed. The negative effects that velocity steam has on coke
drums, fractionator, heat removal, and yields are also briefly reviewed.
The presentation then covers a variety of burner and fire box issues such as flame impingement, low NOx and ultra low
NOx burners, tube metallurgy, and O2-levels. Additionally, fuel gas delivery systems, piping metallurgy, and fuel gas
coalescer are reviewed. The presentation concludes that burner management is critical to the reliability of the coke
heater.
The presentation discusses the process best practices for the design, control, and general operation of the fired heater.
Three major heater decoking procedures; steam air decoking, mechanical pigging, and online spalling are reviewed.
Finally, recent innovations in delayed coking heaters and heater process feed measurements are reviewed.
1. Introduction
The delayed coking process is common in todays large, modern, and complex refineries. This is especially
true with refineries processing heavy sour crudes, which have a disproportionate amount of residual material. The
delayed coking process has proven to be an excellent choice in upgrading heavy oils that are highly contaminated with
metals, sulfur, and nitrogen. The delayed coker is a very flexible process, able to operate with a wide variety of feeds
and operating conditions.
Generally, the more difficult the feed, the better the delayed coker economics look compared to competing
processes. Like all process refinery operations, reliability or actual operating days are critical to the overall refinery
economics. Poor operations and reliability of the delayed coker can have significant negative consequences to the
refineries bottom line and even possible future viability of the refinery. The fired heater is one of the most critical pieces
of equipment affecting the reliability of the delayed coker. The fired heater will foul with time and very little can be
done to avoid this eventual outcome. However, a well designed heater and implementation of best practices can
significantly help slow the fouling process.
______________________________
1
Bachelor of Science in chemical engineering, Principal Consultant - KBC Advanced Technologies, Inc.
Sample 2
Sample 3
Sample 4
Sample 5
10.4
7.05
7.3
1.66
1.8
Ash (%)
38.49
37.57
35.55
17.39
27.34
10,270
15,240
14,190
5,623
4,551
241,100
169,400
272,700
301,900
312,000
1,699
2,140
1,760
19,910
8,577
1,023
1,607
1,393
15,880
3,037
251
111
2,385
2,645
2,506
7,799
12,230
9,225
10,130
15,910
5,439
7,227
3,954
7,004
19,800
2,764
3,196
2,107
842
3,519
Analysis of Ash
4. Heater Design
The heat flux on the tubes is not uniformly even because of shading of the radiant heat. The circumferential
surface of the tube does not see the same radiant heat. The heater is designed with a peak heat flux and an average heat
flux. The peak heat flux, however, is what drives the boundary layer fouling. A best practice is to lower the peak heat
flux and have a more even heat transfer. Figure 5 illustrates the differences between a single fired heater and a double
fired heater. The single fired heater has radiant heat on only one side of the process tubes, leaving the other side of the
tubes in the shadow and getting radiant heat from reflection only. The double fired heater has radiant heat (flames) on
both sides of the tubes. The doubled fire heater significantly reduces any shadowing.
1.8
Peak Heat
Flux,
BTU/(Hour
Ft2)
18,000
15,000
1.2
18,000
10,000
12,000
1.2
14,400
12,500
Peak to Average
Flux Ratio
10,000
15,000
5. Tube Metallurgy
Heater tube metallurgy is generally selected by corrosion requirements, which are driven by sulfur
concentration in the coker feed. Most heaters require 9 Cr-1Mo (T9 tubing) because of corrosion, but several other
alternatives are available and have improved properties. Table 3 shows the different metallurgy tubes/piping available
and their recommended thermal limits. The tube or pipe wall thickness is determined by the carrions allowance and the
rupture stress, which is a function of the operating temperature and pressure. Stainless steel (SS) tubes have been used
instead of 9Cr-1Mo because of the increased rupture stress. In one case this was done to reduce the wall thickness and
increased inside diameter. The increased diameter allowed an incremental feed rate, which was used to justify the added
cost of the SS tubes.
Table 3: Tube/Piping Metallurgy
Material
Carbon Steel
C-1/2 Mo
1-1/4 Cr-1/2 Mo
2-1/4 Cr-1 Mo
5 Cr-1/2 Mo
7 Cr-1/2 Mo
9 Cr-1 Mo
18 Cr-8 Ni
16 Cr-12 Ni-2 Mo
18 Cr-10 Ni-Ti
18 Cr-10 Ni-Cb
Alloy 800H
25Cr-20 Ni
Pipe Specifications
Tube Specifications
A161
A161, A209 Gr T1
A200, A213, Gr T11
A200, A213, Gr T22
A200, A213, Gr T5
A200, A213, Gr T7
A200, A213, Gr T9
A213, A271, TP304H
A213, A271, TP316H
A213, A271, TP321H
A213, A271, TP347H
B407
A608, Gr HK40
Temperature Limit,
(API 530 4th Ed, Oct
1996)
540C or 1,003F
595C or 1,102F
595C or 1,102F
650C or 1,201F
650C or 1,201F
705C or 1,300F
705C or 1,300F
815C or 1,498F
815C or 1,498F
815C or 1,498F
815C or 1,498F
1,010C or 1,849F
SS tubes or piping also have less scale buildup on the outside. Contaminates in the fuel and high temperature
excursions can damage the heater tubes. Scale on the outside of the heater tubes is a good indication of the type of
damage and can reduce the heat transfer coefficient of the tubes. Generally, significant scale on the tubes should be
removed. Some facility operators have applied ceramic coating to the outside of the tubing or piping to help prevent
scale buildup; however, a large amount of scale on 9Cr-1Mo tubes implies very high tube metal temperatures and
should be investigated.
Ceramic coating is an effective method of shielding excessive heat flux zones, but here again, this implies poor
fire box design or poor burner operations and should be investigated. Applying ceramic coating will slightly insulate the
tubing and will force more heat into the convection section. This shift in heat load can be beneficial but must be
carefully evaluated.
Additionally, SS tubes are much easier to decoke or spall because of the elevated temperature limits and
because of the higher coefficient of thermal expansion. Spalling, which will be discussed later, is a process of pulling or
shocking coke off the walls of the tube by thermal cycling. Care must be taken because of the higher coefficient of
thermal expansion. Several facility operators have observed SS tubes come off their tube supports because of the high
coefficient of thermal expansion. Finally, SS tubes must be treated (soda ash/sodium nitrite wash as per National
Association of Corrosion Engineers (NACE) recommendations) if they are exposed to chlorides.
One faulty assumption is, because of the higher temperature limits of SS, the coker can run longer with higher
tube metal temperatures. Where it is true that SS tubes will allow higher tube metal temperatures, the coke build up in
6
7. Heater Control
The objective of the heater is to provide sufficient heat to drive the process. This can be measured by the
reliability of the process and the quality of the coke. Lowering the heater outlet temperature will increase the foaming
tendency of the coke drums and raise the weight percent volatile combustible matter (VCM) of the coke. The higher
VCM coke will make coke cutting more difficult. Generally, the heater should provide enough heat to produce a coke
with a VCM of 10 to 12 weight percent. This operating target is very dependent on the feed quality, equipment
arrangement, and equipment maintenance. Coke drums with damaged insulation will require more heat input (higher
heater outlet temperatures) to ensure reliable drum operations.
7
8. Heater Decoking
There are three methods of decoking a heater: steam air, mechanical (pigging), and online spalling. Steam air
decoking is the oldest of these three methods and is quickly being replaced by the other two methods. Steam air
decoking can be rough on the heater tubes, labor intensive and requires a heater and unit shutdown. Some facilities have
moved away from this method because the environmental problems caused when burning the coke out of the tubes.
Online spalling has become the best method of decoking, but is not always possible depending on the heater
mechanical arrangement and the size of the coker. A small delayed coker with few tubes passes will find this method
more difficult than a large coker with multiple drums and heaters. The procedures for online spalling are summarized
as:
Transition from oil feed to steam or boiler feed water (BFW) feed
Adjust firing rate in the box to control heating of the tube metal temperatures; steam or BFW will not
require as much heat - burner will need to be taken offline
Spall the coke off the tubes with velocities using the steam or BFW
Thermal cycle the tubes to accelerate spalling of the coke
Monitor tube metal temperatures to verify spalling is complete
Transition back to oil feed
This process is very attractive as the unit does not require a shutdown and loss of throughput and reliability
problems are kept at a minimum. This procedure is a complex process and must be thoroughly reviewed at each
location. The tube or piping flow path can plug if the coke on the tubes is much more than thick or if the coke is
spall too aggressively. The return bends in the heater and elbows in a 90 degree bend can have erosion problems if not
properly designed and operated.
Finally, mechanical decoking or pigging has become a popular practice for delayed coking. Mechanical
decoking does require a heater shut down, but some facilities have developed isolation procedures where individual
heater boxes can be isolated and the heater passes decoked without a complete shutdown. The time required to
mechanically decoke a heater is approximately the same as online spalling a heater. Since pigging is relatively easy,
8
9. Recent Innovations
The last major innovation in delayed coker heater design was the development of double fire heaters in the
early 1980s but this technical development is more of a standard. One recent innovation is acoustic pyrometry, which
is capable of measuring temperatures in the fire box. This technology measures the flue gas temperature by measuring
the speed of sound waves as they pass through the gas. These short, rapid bursts of sound are arranged in a matrix
around the heater, which are then used to generate a two dimensional topographical thermal map in the heater. This
process can be used to monitor the heater flux across the entire heater, showing how well distributed the heat transfer is
and any possible burner problems.
Another recent innovation has been the individual pass flow measurements. Traditionally, an orifice plate and
orifice pressure taps have been used. These have had problems with plugging the pressure taps. Flushing methods for
the orifice pressure taps have evolved to help this problem, but sacrifice the accuracy of the meter. In the last 10 years,
wedge meters with sealed diaphragm pressure sensors have replaced the orifice plate and flushed pressure taps. Figure
11 illustrates these flow meter types. A well established technology is the Coriolis meter, which uses the vibration of the
flowing fluid. This method has no direct contact with the process, but is sensitive to surrounding vibrations. The
Coriolis meter is extremely accurate and can also measure the density of the fluid. This technology is not new, but few
hot heavy oil processors have implemented this technology because of the higher cost.
10. Summary
The fired heater is one of the most critical components affecting the reliability of the delayed coker. A welldesigned heater and implementation of best operating practices can significantly improve the reliability and overall
operation of the delayed coker. Minimizing the fouling rate in the heater flow-passes can be achieved with a welldesigned and operated heater. Controlling the time at temperature or heat soak history, which is needed for the process,
is also critical to maximizing the heater run-length. Delayed coker thermal kinetics is a complex interaction of the fluid
characteristics and the physical equipment employed and must be handled as such to optimize operations.
10