Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 31

Muhammad Aziz

Advanced Energy Systems for Sustainability, Institute of Innovative Research


Tokyo Institute of Technology

Muhammad Aziz

Total publikasi OIC di tahun 2009 berjumlah sedikit di bawah UK (63 ribu)
1,900 univ di OIC, tidak ada satupun di best 100 (THE).
Hanya 5 negara OIC (Malaysia, UAE, Qatar, Oman, Turkey) mempunyai
innovation index di atas rata-rata dunia
Rata-rata GERD OIC masih di bawah 1 (negara maju GERD > 2)

Sebelum 1979, beberapa univ di Iran menjadi top univ


Academic narcissism
2

1. Switzerland
2. Sweden
3. UK
4. USA
5. Finland
6. Singapore
7. Ireland
8. Denmark
9. Netherlands
10. Germany
11. Korea
14. Hong Kong
16. Japan
19. Australia
21. Israel
25. China
35. Malaysia
41. UAE
42. Turkey
49. Saudi Arabia
50. Qatar
52. Thailand
60. Vietnam
74. Philippine
78. Iran
88. Indonesia
128. Yemen
3

Demographics
Language
Education
Research
State-owned corporation

Professional societies
Resources (financial, incentives)
Authoritarianism
Regional cooperation
Government incompetence

Aaron Segal, The Middle East Quarterly, 1996, pp. 61-70


4

Position
Connections

Chance

Trust

Balanced
Measurable(standardized)
Growing

Fund

Age

Experience

Responsibility

Knowledge
Achievements

Disruptive
Innovation

Quantum-leap
Knowledge Creation
Incremental
Innovation

Global excellence
Grand scenario (integration and sustainability)
Human resource (global )

Enable success

Sustainable
innovation
programs

Value
creation
Discovery &
solutions

Engage globally

Collaborative
innovations

Amplify outcomes

10

Superheated

Preheating
Being educated
Rapid growing

Phase changing

New growing
Self developed
my world

Stuck, no growth
Arrangement
Questioning
Low self-esteem

11

Being exist, not narcissistic ()


Self-reliance
Avoid self-assertion ()
Strategic, find my best way

Self assessment
Friends, connection building
Avoiding academic dishonesty
Bahasa Jepang, cultural understanding
Other supporting activities

12


Self growth

Self improvement

Self education

Independence, being aggressive

Spirit of challenge

Coordinative, flexible

Responsibility, strong mission

Understanding the culture

Communication
13

Hade

vs

Jimichi

14

Keep your position and age balance


PD ~32, Asst. Prof. ~38, Assoc. Prof. 35~48, Prof. 45~

Contract based (fixed term), annual salary system


Independent, achievement based
Be collaborative and extend collaboration network
(publication, grants, etc.)
Be a member of academic organization
Involve in local meeting (do not only pursue the
international one)
Collaborative grants application
15

Other
Professor

Research up to 30%

Associate Professor

Research up to 50%

Assistant Professor

Research up to 70%, entrance for


next career, independent research

Postdoctoral

policy maker,
supervising

Research main (project based)

Research

16

Idea driven
Murni akademik
Menteri pendidikan (COE, G-COE, WPI,
CREST,Sakigake, Kakenhi, Dikti, dll)

Project driven
Disesuaikan dengan tawaran proyek yang ada
Kementerian lain (METI, NEDO, NEPC dll)
Industri, pemerintah daerah

Demand driven
Sesuai dengan kebutuhan dari pemberi dana
Industri, pemerintah daerah, kemeterian lain
17

1. Collaboration research
2. Consigned research
3. Donation research
4. Academic guidance

18

Bachelor thesis

Thesis

(Master thesis)
(Doctoral thesis)

Regular article

Short note, comm.

Academic Papers Letter


Technical

Proceeding

Review article
19

Idea pursuit
Searching capability, sensitivity

Patience
Writing capability

20

Publikasi

Riset
Introduction
References

Rationale
Setting tema riset secara global
Hipotesis
Objectives dari riset

Discussion
References

Effective methods untuk menjawab


permasalahan dan mencapai objectives
Methods
References

Results

Deskripsi jelas atas apa yang dicapai


dari riset
Analisa arti dari hasil riset
Perbandingan dengan hasil riset lain

Pilihan judul yang sesuai


Title

Riset
Analisa hasil
Figures, graphs, etc.

Being indexed

Abstract
Highlights

Deskripsi singkat dari isi paper


Digunakan ketika reviewing dan
searching

Scopus
Researcher ID
ORCID
21

1. Membuat list akan topik riset yang prospektif


2. Pemilihan yang tepat akan bentuk publikasi

Original research: penekanan pada theoretical analysis


dan/atau discussion

3. Pemilihan journal yang tepat (aims, publisher,


IF, editor, dll)
4. Pendefinisan dan penekanan yang kuat atas
originalitas (novelty) yang kita tawarkan
5. Pilihlah newest references dan utamakan dari
journal yang menjadi tujuan kita
6. Berhati-hati dengan plagiarism (similarity <=4%)
22

7. Manfaatkan search engine untuk mencari


references (web of science, science direct, IEEE
xplore, dll)
8. List journal dengan aims dan struktur (writing
style, references) masing-masing
9. Journal dengan IF tinggi bukan berarti lebih
sulit
10. List of potential reviewers
11. Note the keywords and technical terms
12. Hindari predatory publishers
13. Sabar dalam menulis, menjawab review, dan resubmit (rejected)
23

Look at used references


Review recent publications in each candidate journal
Journal scope
Whos the audience?
Average time for publication?
Impact factor
Publication charge
Relation to the academic community we belong to or target
for
Relationship with editors
Make list of candidate journals and group them (fields,
writing styles, references, etc.)
24

Clear, quantified
Understandable message (no complex)
Easy flow of writing
Voluntary work (service to community)
Constraints: making time for multiple review
requests, deadlines

25

Author submits
article to journal

Journal Editor
screens paper

Rejected after
screening

Reviewer
Reviewer

Rejected
Author makes
revisions

Editor assessment of
reviews
Accepted no
revisions required

26

Matching with journals scope


Sufficient quality?

Novel or important work?


Are research, analysis and conclusions valid?
Are the aims and achievements are clearly stated?
Are figures, tables correctly presented?
Are calculations and models correct?
Are the literatures and sources correctly cited?
Lumping references?
Are the judgment sufficiently quantified?

Language
Ethics
27

Membiasakan untuk berfikir lebih kritis


Informasi yang lebih baru dan updated
Social contribution as researcher
Being recognized researcher in the field
Building strong relation and trust with editors
Winning the editors heart for next publication
Owning some privileges from publisher
28

Diriwayatkan dari Nabi SAW, sesungguhnya Beliau bersabda:


Ada dua perkara, tidak ada sesuatu yang lebih utama dari dua perkara
tersebut, yaitu iman kepada Allah dan berbuat kebajikan kepada sesama
muslim
Baik dengan ucapan, kekuasaannya, hartanya atau dengan badannya.
(Nashaihul Ibad, Syeikh Nawawi Al-Bantani)

29

Taqwa
Sincere
Wisdom
Practice
Knowledge
Information
Data

All humans are dead except those who


have knowledge; and those who have
knowledge are asleep, except those who
do good deeds; and those who do good
deeds are deceived, except those who are
sincere; and those who are sincere are
always in a state of worry. Imam Shafii
Knowledge gives power. This power
should be under Deen. Otherwise, it is
pure satanic. A Muslim must Islamize his
knowledge (Iqbal)

Keep being qualified


Be motivated
Be humble
30

Muhammad Aziz, Dr. Eng.


Assoc. Professor
Institute of Innovative Research,
Tokyo Institute of Technology
E-mail : maziz@ssr.titech.ac.jp
Tel : +81-3-5734-3809
http://aes.ssr.titech.ac.jp/aziz/

31

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi