Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Richard J. Havel,5 M.D., Marian C. Cheung,6 Ph.D., and Jean-Louis Vigne,7 M.D.
ABSTRACT The effects of a high cholesterol, high saturated fat diet on serum high density
hipoprotein cholesterol, apo A-I, and apo E levels were studied in six normohipidemic subjects. The
study was done on an outpatient basis and mixed natural foods normally consumed by humans
The strong correlation between elevated terol by increasing LDL cholesterol (7, 8).
plasma cholesterol levels and coronary heart Recent reports show that both the prevalence
disease has led to several metabolic studies and incidence of coronary heart disease are
that have related plasma cholesterol levels in inversely correlated with HDL cholesterol (9,
adult humans to dietary cholesterol and type 10). As elevation of plasma cholesterol may
of dietary fat. In general, increasing dietary be the result of an increase in HDL-choles-
cholesterol from about 200 to 1000 mg/day terol the hypercholesterolemic effect of die-
will produce a 15 to 30% elevation of plasma tary cholesterol and saturated fat could be in
cholesterol (1, 2). Increments in saturated part produced by an increase in HDL-choles-
fatty acids in the diet elevate plasma choles-
terol levels and polyunsaturated fatty acid
Supported in part by a grant from the Nova Scotia
tend to lower them (3, 4). The response of
Heart Foundation, United States Public Health Service
plasma cholesterol to dietary cholesterol and Grant HL-14237 (Arteriosclerosis SCOR) HLHV
fat varies considerably among individuals (5, l2157A, and HL 22285 from the Lipid Metabolism
6). Branch, NHLBI.
2 Associate Professor, Department of Medicine, Dal-
Changes in serum lipids induced by high
housie University, 5849 University Avenue, Halifax,
cholesterol and saturated fat diets are usually Nova Scotia, Canada, B3H 4H7. Author to whom reprint
measured in terms of serum total cholesterol requests should be addressed. Nutritionist, Diabetes
and triglycerides. Since the serum total cho- Day Care Centre, Victoria General Hospital,
lesterol reflects the cholesterol derived from Halifax. Research Associate Professor, Department
of Medicine and Laboratory Director, Northwest Lipid
low-density lipoprotein (LDL), very low-den-
Research Clinic, University of Washington, Seattle,
sity lipoprotein (VLDL), and high-density Washington. J. J. A. is an Established Investigator of the
lipoprotein (HDL), changes in the distribu- American Heart Association. Director, Cardiovas-
tion of cholesterol in these lipoprotein classes cular Research Institute and Professor, Department of
Medicine, University of California, San Francisco, Cal-
are not evident when only total cholesterol is
ifornia. 6 Research Instructor, Northwest Lipid Re-
used as the index of change. However, it is search Clinic, University of Washington, Seattle, Wash-
generally accepted that dietary cholesterol ington. Post Doctoral Fellow, Cardiovascular Re-
and saturated fat elevate total plasma choles- search Institute, San Francisco, California.
The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 33: DECEMBER 1980, pp. 2559-2565. Printed in U.S.A. 2559
2560 TAN ET AL.
Cholesterol feeding in miniature swine The study was conducted over a 5-week period and
(14), dogs (15), rabbits (16), and monkeys done on an outpatient basis with each subject continuing
his/her regular activity.
Before beginning the study each
(17) resulted in a hypercholesterolemia with
TABLE 1
General characteristics of subjects
yr nig/dt mg/dt
A M 34 86 214 98
B F 35 91 186 55
C F 26 92 154 59
D F 33 88 179 50
E M 33 99 157 81
F F 26 98 121 62
TABLE 2
Composition of diets (mean SEM)
Regular 1945 103 15.8 1.0 32.5 1.4 51.7 1.7 0.53 0.06 232.5 32.1
Low cholesterol
Actual 1897 45 16.3 0.2 37.7 0.3 46.0 0.3 1.60 0.01 97.5 1.5
Prescribed 1981 16 39 45 1.6 100
High cholesterol
Actual 2036 16 16.8 0.2 39.5 0.2 43.7 0.2 0.14 0.01 1021.0 2.3
Prescribed 2063 17 40 43 0.14 1028
HIGH CHOLESTEROL ON HDL-CHOLESTEROL 2561
ually counselled by the dietitian who was available at all for apo E in VLDL by this radioimmunoassay technique
times for consultation. In addition the dietitian discussed and that obtained by the method of Kane et al. (23).
dietary details with each subject at weekly intervals. Statistical analysis of the data was by paired t analysis
Food scales were provided and each subject weighed with each subject serving as his/her own control. Two
his/her food portions. Mixed natural foods were used comparisons were made. The effect of the low choles-
and a list of necessary groceries (with brand names) were terol, high polyunsaturated fat diet was evaluated using
provided. Mixed dishes were not permitted as it would the serum lipid and apoprotein levels at the end of the
then by difficult to estimate their carbohydrate, protein, regular diet period as control. The effect of the high
fat, and cholesterol content. Although all subjects con- cholesterol, high saturated fat diet was evaluated using
sumed little alcohol in their daily life, alcohol was not the serum lipid and apoprotein levels at the end of the
permitted during the study period. The actual menu for low cholesterol, high polyunsaturated fat diet period as
each meal of each day of the week for the low cholesterol, control.
high polyunsaturated fat diet and high cholesterol, high
saturated fat diet periods was provided. The subjects
Results
were instructed and kept a dietary diary of each meal
during the entire study. Dietary composition of food
ingested for each period was calculated using the ex- Dietary compliance (Table 2)
change system of food assessment; standard food tables All subjects adhered closely to their pre-
(18) were used to calculate the average cholesterol con-
scribed diets, as evidenced by the closeness of
tent of the diets. Adherence to the prescribed diet was
their actual food intake and their prescribed
TABLE 3
Effect of dietary cholesterol and fat saturation on serum cholesterol and
triglyceride levels (values in mg/dl, mean SEM)
Type of diet
Serum triglycerides 67.5 7.5 49.5 5.2 47.3 6.1 53.3 8.2
P < 0.05 compared with regular diet. Ii P < 0.005 compared with low cholesterol diet. P < 0.0025
compared with low cholesterol diet.
2562 TAN ET AL.
high polyunsaturated fat diet there was no cantly different from that at the end of the
significant change in LDL-cholesterol and regular diet period (1.70 0.3). The ratio
HDL-cholesterol. However, VLDL-choles- after 2 and 3 weeks of high cholesterol and
terol fell significantly. Increases in LDL-cho- saturated fat diet was 1.69 0.35 and 1.58
lesterol and HDL-cholesterol were significant 0.33, respectively. The latter was signifi-
after the 2nd and 3rd week of the high cho- cantly reduced (P < 0.05) when compared
lesterol and saturated fat diet. The increases with the initial value.
in LDL-cholesterol and HDL-cholesterol
after the 3rd week were 15.0 5.3% (mean Serum apo A-I and apo E (Table 5)
SEM) and 29.9 7.8%, respectively. The Serum apo A-I increased in five of the six
increase in VLDL-cholesterol (59.7 19.1%) subjects after 2 and 3 weeks of the high
was significant only after the 3rd week. cholesterol, saturated fat diet. The increase
At the end of 1 week of low cholesterol, was significant only after the 3rd week of the
high polyunsaturated fat diet the LDL-cho- high cholesterol, saturated fat diet. The serum
lesterol/HDL-cholesterol ratio for the group HDL-cholesterol/apo A-I molar ratio in-
was 1.78 0.34 (mean SEM), not signifi- creased from 31.6 2.5 (mean SEM) when
Mean 93.3 88.5 102.3 102.0 56.5 52.3 63.5 67.2 18.0 12.0 13.7 17.8
SEM 12.2 11.9 16.5 15.4 2.8 3.2 3.0 3.2 2.2 1.4 1.7 1.5
After 1 week of low cholesterol, high polyunsaturated fat diet. Comparison with regular diet. After 2
weeks of high cholesterol, saturated fat diet. Comparison with low cholesterol, high polyunsaturated fat diet. After
3 weeks of high cholesterol, saturated fat diet. Comparison with low cholesterol, high polyunsaturated fat diet.
TABLE 5
Effect of dietary cholesterol and fat saturation on
serum apo E and apo A-I levels
mg/dI mg/dt
P <0.05
a After 2 weeks of high cholesterol, saturated fat diet. b After 3 weeks of high cholesterol, saturated fat
diet. Statistical analysis as in Table 3.
HIGH CHOLESTEROL ON HDL-CHOLESTEROL 2563
the subjects were on the low cholesterol, high to show a concomitant decrease in HDL-cho-
polyunsaturated fat diet to 36.0 1.3 and lesterol (28, 29), whereas other have found
36.6 2.3 after 2 and 3 weeks of high cho- that a reduction of HDL-cholesterol contrib-
lesterol, saturated fat diet. The increase after utes to this lowering of serum cholesterol (30,
2 weeks was significant (P < 0.025) whereas 31). Recently, Shepherd et al. (31) showed
that after 3 weeks was not by paired t test. that when compared with the saturated fat
There was no significant change in the diet (P/S ratio = 0.25), a polyunsaturated fat
serum apo E levels. After 2 weeks of the high diet (P/S ratio = 4.0) reduced plasma choles-
cholesterol, saturated fat diet serum apo E terol by affecting the cholesterol in HDL
increased in four subjects and did not change (33%), LDL (20%), and VLDL (25%).
in two subjects. After the 3rd week, the level Only a few studies of the effect of a dietary
increased in four and fell in two subjects. cholesterol and P/S fatty acid ratio on serum
apoprotein levels are available. The present
Discussion study shows that a high cholesterol, saturated
fat diet increases serum apo A-I together with
In this study the serum cholesterol levels of HDL-cholesterol. Shepherd et al. (31) showed
normolipidemic subjects were increased both that a high polyunsaturated fat diet decreased
17. EDELSTEIN, C., 0. FLESS, R. WISLER AND R. SCANU. ANGELINETrA, P. EMIsarr AND S. FURNISS. The
Isolation and properties of a 33,000 dalton polypep- effect of a low-cholesterol, high-polyunsaturate diet
tide from hyperlipemic sera of rhesus monkey: ar- on serum lipid levels, apolipoprotein B levels and
ginine-rich peptide or not? Circulation 50: III 113, triglyceride fatty acid composition. Atherosclerosis
1974. 27: 465, 1977.
18. FEELEY, R. M., P. E. GRINER AND B. K. WATT. 28. SPRITZ, N., AND M. A. MI5HIutL. Effects of dietary
Cholesterol content of foods. J. Am. Dietet. Assoc. fats on plasma lipids and lipoproteins: a hypothesis
61: 134, 1972. for the lipid-lowering effect of unsaturated fatty
19. Lipid Research Clinics Program Manual of Labo- acids. J. Chin. Invest. 48: 78, 1969.
ratory Operations. Washington, D.C.: Department 29. FARQUHAR, J. W., AND M. SOKOLOW. Response of
of Health, Education, and Welfare Publication N1H serum lipids and lipoproteins of man to beta-sitos-
75-628, 1974. terol and safflower oil. Circulation 27: 890, 1958.
20. HAVEL, R. J., H. A. EDER AND J. H. BRAGDON. The 30. NICHAMAN, M. Z., C. C. SWEELEY AND R. E. OLSON.
distribution and chemical composition of ultracen- Plasma fatty acids in normolipemic and hyperhipi-
trifugally separated hipoproteins in human serum. J. demic subjects during fasting and after linoleate
Chin. Invest. 34: 1345, 1955. feeding. Am. J. Chin. Nutr. 20: 1057, 1967.
21. ALBERS, J. J., P. W. WAHL, V. 0. CABANA, W. R. 31. SHEPHERD, J., C. J. PACKARD, J. R. PATSCH, A. M.
HAZZARD AND J. J. HoovltR. Quantitation of apo- Gorro, JR. AND 0. D. TAUNTON. Effects of dietary
hipoprotein A-I of human plasma high density hipo- polyunsaturated and saturated fat on the properties
protein. Metabolism 25: 633, 1976. of high density hipoproteins and the metabolism of