Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
BELLVILLE
TRANSFORMATION
RESEARCH PROJECT
Research done by: The Unit for Religion and Development Research, University of
Stellenbosch in partnership with Transformation Africa
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1 PREFACE AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ........................................................................... 3
2 MOTIVATION AND PURPOSE .............................................................................................. 4
3 PROCESS AND METHODOLOGY......................................................................................... 8
3.1 Consultation with fraternal ................................................................................................ 8
3.2 Day of planning................................................................................................................. 9
3.3 Launch .............................................................................................................................. 9
3.4 Research............................................................................................................................ 9
3.4.1 GPS phase ................................................................................................................. 9
3.4.2 Needs analysis ........................................................................................................... 9
3.5 Processing of the data ...................................................................................................... 10
3.6 Feedback ......................................................................................................................... 11
3.7 Website ........................................................................................................................... 11
4 RESULTS ............................................................................................................................... 11
4.1 Demographics of Durbanville/Bellville............................................................................ 11
4.1.1 Average age of residents .......................................................................................... 13
4.1.2 Average income per household ................................................................................ 14
4.1.3 Education: No schooling for adults 20 years and older ............................................. 15
4.1.4 Housing: Informal dwellings.................................................................................... 16
4.1.5 Unemployment ........................................................................................................ 17
4.1.6 Family: Age of head of household younger than 20 years ........................................ 18
4.1.7 Christian affiliation.................................................................................................. 19
4.2 GPS phase ....................................................................................................................... 20
4.2.1 Places of worship..................................................................................................... 20
4.2.2 Liquor outlets .......................................................................................................... 22
4.2.3 Places of sexual misconduct..................................................................................... 25
4.2.4 Selling of illegal drugs ............................................................................................. 27
4.3 Needs analysis ................................................................................................................. 28
4.3.1 Fisantekraal ............................................................................................................. 28
4.4 Secondary data ................................................................................................................ 30
4.4.1 Census data.............................................................................................................. 31
4.4.2 Health data............................................................................................................... 31
4.4.2.1 People who died as a result of assault................................................................... 32
4.4.2.2 The number of HIV/Aids-related deaths............................................................... 33
4.4.3 Crime data: SAPS .................................................................................................... 34
The report consists of three parts. First, the process of research and the different instruments for the
data collection are described. This is followed by an overview of the results of both the primary and
secondary research. Lastly, the concluding remarks deal especially with the role of churches in
Durbanville/Bellville.
Firstly, we would like to thank everybody who contributed to the successful completion of this project.
Specifically we would like to thank the following people:
The steering committee of the different fraternals: Pastors Willem Malherbe, Mike Whitney, Kobus
Swarts, Deon de Klerk and Mlungisi Mabaso in Fisantekraal;
Everybody in whatever capacity who helped and prayed;
The coordinator of the research in Durbanville/Bellville, Marius de Kock;
The 20+ fieldworkers who diligently mapped their communities;
The sponsors: individuals and Transformation Africa who made this possible financially.
Secondly, we would like to acknowledge the databases received from the following institutions:
StatsSA for the demographic data;
City Health Directorate, City of Cape Town for the database on the causes of death;
Strategic Information Department, City of Cape Town for the GIS data;
South African Police Service (SAPS) for the data on the occurrence of crime and violence.
Dr Johannes Erasmus
Mr Gerbrand Mans
urdr@sun.ac.za
(021) 808-3577 (office)
(021) 808-3251 (fax)
AD
KOE
RO
Vierlanden
VIS
N
BER
O
GT
SER
IN
Crest Uitsig
LL
S HO
WE
Nerina Ext D29
Uitzicht
KR
OAD
Wellway Park
Morningstar Roosendal
Aurora Ext D33 Country Places
Durbanville Langeberg Ridge
FA IRTR
Aurora Ext D22 Goedgemoed
EES RO
Durbanville Ext 2
DURB Vergesicht
ANVIL Durbanville Ext 13
AD
LE RO
AD Sonstraal Heights
Valmary Park
oad
Durbanville Hills
R
Vygeboom Sonstraal Ext E16
ton
lling
Eversdal Heights
We
Kenridge Heights Ext Fisantkraal
Amandaglen Ext E15
R312
Springfield De Bron Bellville South
TYGERVALLEY ROA
Roosendal
Eversdal Ext 4
UE
Glen Ive
E AV EN
IVE
Welgemoed
DR
Stellenridge Vredenberg
Ridgeworth
JAGER
ANVILL
E
IE DRIV
Bellville Park RAD
N1
NS C ON
JIP DE
DURB
FRA Stellenberg
Loevenstein
Blomtuin Belair Roads
Hoheizen Ext 20
Oakdale
N1 O AD
Bo-Oakdale LR
P AAR
OLD Groenvallei
E DRIVE
AD
AY
Stikland
LE
EE W
Vredelust
BEL
Kempenville Thalmien
FR
LA
STR
IVE
Bellrail Sanlamhof
R
D
ILS
DE LA RE
Shirley Park
KU
Y ROAD
Labiance
Beroma
Bellville South
Triangle Farm Glenhaven
RO
M
R DA
DE
Peninsula Technicon
OD
M UWC Sources: StatsSA, Census 2001
Strategic Information Dept., City of Cape Town
In this section the research process as well as the different instruments for data collection will be
described. The results will be discussed in the next section. It is appropriate to make two
observations here. Firstly, the research has been conducted within the paradigm of participative
action research. Consequently, the researchers do not keep their distance by not involving the
community. People on the ground participate in the research, the locus of control moves away from
the University to the local community. The purpose of the research is not only to gather objective
information, but to change, to transform a community.
Secondly, during the empirical research process a multi-disciplinary approach has been adopted,
thereby utilising expertise from other social sciences. Although the Unit is situated in the Faculty of
Theology, other disciplines are consulted, for example, Sociology and Geography.
The challenge was to design a methodology that would provide appropriate results in the light of the
aims of the research.
3.3 Launch
On 22nd July 2004 the launch was held at the DRC Stellenberg in Bellville, where church leaders,
business leaders and representatives of government were invited to share our vision. The purpose of
the launch was to communicate this venture as a service to the community. Approximately 30 people
attended the launch.
3.4 Research
Two weeks of research, 26th July 6th August, followed the launch. During these two weeks two
processes ran simultaneously. The fraternal appointed a local coordinator for the research, Marius de
Kock. The coordinator was a key person with regards to organising the research. He liaised with
researchers from Stellenbosch, the fraternal and the community. He received training on several
occasions on what was expected of him.
The purpose of the needs analysis was to prioritise the social development needs specific to these
two areas by using the Priority Index (P-Index) research technique, i.e. a methodology that is
strongly based on the principles of PAR and which directly involves individuals and target groups in
3.6 Feedback
The feedback session will be held during the second half of 2004.
3.7 Website
Information is accessible to our research partners on the website of the University of Stellenbosch,
excluding information on an individual level, which will be protected. The Department of Geography
bought the internet software (ARCIMS) equivalent to the software package ARCView, which
enabled us to develop the website. The link to the website is: www.sun.ac.za/theology/urdr.htm.
4 RESULTS
Annexure 1 contains all the variants available from the research.
AD
KOE
RO
Vierlanden
N
VIS
BER
O
GT
SER
IN
Crest
LL
Uitsig
S HO
WE
Nerina Ext D29
Uitzicht
KR
OAD
Wellway Park
Morningstar Roosendal
Aurora Ext D33 Country Places
Durbanville Langeberg Ridge
FA IRTR
Aurora Ext D22 Goedgemoed
EES RO
Durbanville Ext 2
DURB Vergesicht
ANV IL Durbanville Ext 13
AD
LE RO
AD Sonstraal Heights
d
Valmary Park
Ro a
Durbanville Hills
Vygeboom Sonstraal Ext E16
n
gto
llin
Eversdal Heights
We
Kenridge Heights Ext Fisantkraal
Amandaglen Ext E15 R312
Springfield De Bron Bellville South
TYGERVALLEY ROAD
Glen Ive
E AV EN
E
Welgemoed
DRIV
Stellenridge Vredenberg
Ridgeworth
JAGER
ANVILL
E
IE DRIV
Bellville Park RAD
N1 C ON
NS
JIP DE
DURB
BR
FRA Stellenberg
AC
Loevenstein
Average age
KE
Blomtuin Belair
NF
Hoheizen Ext 20
Oakdale
EL
L
N1 D
OA
BO
Bo-Oakdale LR
AAR 0 - 19
U
P
OLD
LE
Groenvallei
VA
RD
DRIVE
OAD
Stikland 21 - 29
R
LE
Vredelust
BEL
RE
Kempenville Thalmien
RF
LA
STR 31 - 39
IVE
Bellrail Sanlamhof
R
D
ILS
DE LA RE
Shirley Park
KU
41 - 45
Y ROAD
Labiance
Beroma 46 and more
Bellville South
Triangle Farm Glenhaven
Roads
RO
M
DA
DE
R Peninsula Technicon
OD
M UWC Sources: StatsSA, Census 2001
Strategic Information Dept., City of Cape Town
The map shows the average age of the residents in each of the smaller areas in Durbanville/Bellville.
The average age of the whole area is 33.8 years. Compare this average, for instance, with the average
of the Western Cape Province, which is 28.7 years. The average age for the area of research rose
slightly from 33.2 years to 33.8 years from 1996 to 2001.
If one studies the map in conjunction with the legend, it is evident that the average age in areas south
of Voortrekker Road (or Strand Road as it is called here) is mostly younger than in the other areas.
On the other hand, there are areas with average ages of more than 46 years in Bellville West,
Stikland and Eversdal Ext. 1.
AD
KOE
RO
VIS
Vierlanden
N
BER
O
GT
SER
IN
Crest
LL
Uitsig
S HO
WE
Nerina Ext D29
Uitzicht
KR
OAD
Wellway Park
Morningstar Roosendal
Aurora Ext D33 Country Places
Durbanville Langeberg Ridge
FAIRTR
Aurora Ext D22 Goedgemoed
EES RO
Durbanville Ext 2
DURB Vergesicht
ANV IL Durbanville Ext 13
AD
LE RO
AD Sonstraal Heights
d
Valmary Park
Ro a
Durbanville Hills
Vygeboom Sonstraal Ext E16
n
gto
llin
Eversdal Heights
We
Kenridge Heights Ext Fisantkraal
Amandaglen Ext E15 R312
Springfield De Bron Bellville South
TYGERVALLEY ROAD
Glen Ive
E AV EN
E
Welgemoed
DRIV
Stellenridge Vredenberg
Ridgeworth
JAGER
ANVILL
E
IE DRIV
Bellville Park RAD
N1 C ON
NS
JIP DE
DURB
BR
FRA Stellenberg
AC
Loevenstein
Avg. income / household / year
KE
Blomtuin Belair
NF
Hoheizen Ext 20
Oakdale
EL
L
N1 D
OA
BO
Bo-Oakdale AAR
LR
0 - 66105
U
P
OLD
LE
Groenvallei
VA
RD
DRIVE
OAD
Vredelust
BEL
RE
Kempenville Thalmien
RF
LA
Bellrail Sanlamhof YR
R
D
ELAR
ILS
BOTT
DE LA RE
Shirley Park
KU
197787 - 290039
Y ROAD
Labiance
Beroma 290040 - 556340
Bellville South
Triangle Farm Glenhaven
Roads
RO
M
RDA
DE
Peninsula Technicon
OD
M UWC Sources: StatsSA, Census 2001
Strategic Information Dept., City of Cape Town
The areas in red indicate the lowest average income (in rand) per household per year. The average
income of the entire area of research is, as already indicated, much higher than the provincial
average.
However, there are areas to the south and Fisantekraal, indicated in red, with a low average income.
AD
KOE
RO
VIS
Vierlanden
N
BER
O
GT
SER
IN
Crest
LL
Uitsig
S HO
WE
Nerina Ext D29
Uitzicht
KR
OAD
Wellway Park
Morningstar Roosendal
Aurora Ext D33 Country Places
Durbanville Langeberg Ridge
FAIRTR
Aurora Ext D22 Goedgemoed
EES RO
Durbanville Ext 2
DURB Vergesicht
ANV IL Durbanville Ext 13
AD
LE RO
AD Sonstraal Heights
d
Valmary Park
Ro a
Durbanville Hills
Vygeboom Sonstraal Ext E16
n
gto
llin
Eversdal Heights
We
Kenridge Heights Ext Fisantkraal
Amandaglen Ext E15 R312
Springfield De Bron Bellville South
TYGERVALLEY ROAD
Glen Ive
E AV EN
E
Welgemoed
DRIV
Stellenridge Vredenberg
Ridgeworth
JAGER
ANVILL
E
IE DRIV
Bellville Park RAD
N1 C ON
NS
JIP DE
DURB
BR
FRA Stellenberg
AC
Loevenstein No schooling
KE
Blomtuin Belair
NF
Hoheizen Ext 20
Oakdale
EL
L
N1 D
OA
BO
Bo-Oakdale AAR
LR 0% - 2.94%
U
P
OLD
LE
Groenvallei
VA
RD
DRIVE
OAD
Stikland
R
LE
Vredelust
BEL
RE
Kempenville Thalmien
RF
LA
Bellrail Sanlamhof YR
R
D
ELAR
ILS
BOTT
DE LA RE
Shirley Park
KU
21.93% - 43.14%
Y ROAD
Labiance
Beroma 43.15% - 98.58%
Bellville South
Triangle Farm Glenhaven
Roads
RO
M
RDA
DE
Peninsula Technicon
OD
M UWC Sources: StatsSA, Census 2001
Strategic Information Dept., City of Cape Town
The purpose of this map is to show the percentage of adults (20 years and older) who did not have
the opportunity to complete any schooling. The percentage for Durbanville/Bellville is 1.9%. This is
below the provincial percentage of 5.8%.
Although the overall percentage is very low, there are areas with high percentages of adults with no
schooling, e.g. Fisantekraal (30.9%), Hoheizen Ext. 20 (14.8%), Bellville West Ext. 1 (14.6%) and
Bellville Park (10%).
AD
KOE
RO
VIS
Vierlanden
N
BER
O
GT
SER
IN
Crest
LL
Uitsig
S HO
WE
Nerina Ext D29
Uitzicht
KR
OAD
Wellway Park
Morningstar Roosendal
Aurora Ext D33 Country Places
Durbanville Langeberg Ridge
FAIRTR
Aurora Ext D22 Goedgemoed
EES RO
Durbanville Ext 2
DURB Vergesicht
ANV IL Durbanville Ext 13
AD
LE RO
AD Sonstraal Heights
d
Valmary Park
Ro a
Durbanville Hills
Vygeboom Sonstraal Ext E16
n
gto
llin
Eversdal Heights
We
Kenridge Heights Ext Fisantkraal
Amandaglen Ext E15 R312
Springfield De Bron Bellville South
TYGERVALLEY ROAD
Glen Ive
E AV EN
E
Welgemoed
DRIV
Stellenridge Vredenberg
Ridgeworth
JAGER
ANVILL
E
IE DRIV
Bellville Park RAD
N1 C ON
NS
JIP DE
DURB
BR
FRA Stellenberg
AC
Loevenstein
Informal houses
KE
Blomtuin Belair
NF
Hoheizen Ext 20
Oakdale
EL
L
N1 D
OA
BO
Bo-Oakdale AAR
LR
0% - 4.42%
U
P
OLD
LE
Groenvallei
VA
RD
DRIVE
OAD
Vredelust
BEL
RE
Kempenville Thalmien
RF
LA
Bellrail Sanlamhof
R
D
ILS
DE LA RE
Shirley Park
KU
35.01% - 71.08%
Y ROAD
Labiance
Beroma 71.09% - 100%
Bellville South
Triangle Farm Glenhaven
Roads
RO
M
RDA
DE
Peninsula Technicon
OD
M UWC Sources: StatsSA, Census 2001
Strategic Information Dept., City of Cape Town
The map shows the percentages of households, in each of the smaller areas of Durbanville/Bellville,
where the house can be classified in accordance with the Census as an informal dwelling.1 The total
percentage of informal dwellings in Durbanville/Bellville is approximately 1.7%. There are,
however, areas with 10% (Bellville South), 9.4% (Fisantekraal), 9.1% (Vredenberg) and 8%
(Fisantekraal SP) informal dwellings.
1
The official definition of Census 2001 for an informal dwelling is a combination of two dwelling types: Informal
dwelling/shack in backyard and Informal dwelling/shack, NOT in backyard, e.g. in an informal/squatter settlement
(www.statssa.gov.za).
AD
KOE
RO
Vierlanden
N
VIS
BER
O
GT
SER
IN
Crest
LL
Uitsig
S HO
WE
Nerina Ext D29
Uitzicht
KR
OAD
Wellway Park
Morningstar Roosendal
Aurora Ext D33 Country Places
Durbanville Langeberg Ridge
FA IRTR
Aurora Ext D22 Goedgemoed
EES RO
Durbanville Ext 2
DURB Vergesicht
ANV IL Durbanville Ext 13
AD
LE RO
AD Sonstraal Heights
d
Valmary Park
Ro a
Durbanville Hills
Vygeboom Sonstraal Ext E16
n
gto
llin
Eversdal Heights
We
Kenridge Heights Ext Fisantkraal
Amandaglen Ext E15 R312
Springfield De Bron Bellville South
TYGERVALLEY ROAD
Glen Ive
E AV EN
E
Welgemoed
DRIV
Stellenridge Vredenberg
Ridgeworth
JAGER
ANVILL
E
IE DRIV
Bellville Park RAD
N1 C ON
NS
JIP DE
DURB
BR
FRA Stellenberg
AC
Loevenstein
Unemployed
KE
Blomtuin Belair
NF
Hoheizen Ext 20
Oakdale
EL
L
N1 D
OA
BO
Bo-Oakdale LR
AAR 0% - 7.13%
U
P
OLD
LE
Groenvallei
VA
RD
DRIVE
OAD
Vredelust
BEL
RE
Kempenville Thalmien
RF
LA
Bellrail Sanlamhof
R
D
ILS
DE LA RE
Shirley Park
KU
29.35% - 43.90%
Y ROAD
Labiance
Beroma 43.91% - 66.67%
Bellville South
Triangle Farm Glenhaven
Roads
RO
M
DA
DE
R Peninsula Technicon
OD
M UWC Sources: StatsSA, Census 2001
Strategic Information Dept., City of Cape Town
An unemployed person, according to Census 2001, is a person between the ages of 15 and 65 who
did not have work, could not find work, has taken active steps to find employment and could start
within one week, if offered work.
Durbanville/Bellville has an unemployment percentage (according to StatsSAs definition explained
above) of 5.3%. It rose from Census 1996 (3.7%) to Census 2001 (5.3%). The area with the highest
percentage unemployment was Fisantekraal SP (32%) followed by Fisantekraal (26.7%), Greenlands
(24.4%) and Kaymor (19.2%).
AD
KOE
RO
Vierlanden
VISS
N
BER
O
GT
ER
IN
Crest Uitsig
LL
S HO
WE
Nerina Ext D29
Uitzicht
KR
OA D
Wellway Park
Morningstar Roosendal
Aurora Ext D33 Country Places
Durbanville Langeberg Ridge
FA IRTR
Aurora Ext D22 Goedgemoed
EES RO
Durbanville Ext 2
Vergesicht
oad
DURB
ANVIL Durbanville Ext 13
AD
LE RO
R
AD Sonstraal Heights
ton
Valmary Park
lling
Durbanville Hills
We
Vygeboom Sonstraal Ext E16 Fisantkraal
Eversdal Heights R312
Kenridge Heights Ext
Amandaglen Ext E15
Springfield De Bron Bellville South
TYGERVALLEY ROA
Roosendal
Eversdal Ext 4
UE
Glen Ive
E AV EN
E
Welgemoed
DRIV
Stellenridge Vredenberg
Ridgeworth
JAGER
ANVILL
D RIVE
R ADIE
Bellville Park N1
NS CON
JIP DE
DURB
BR
FRA Stellenberg
AC
Loevenstein Age of head of household
KE
Blomtuin Belair
NF
Hoheizen Ext 20
Oakdale (younger than 20yrs)
EL
L
N1 D
OA
BO
Bo-Oakdale LR
AAR
U
P
OLD
LE
Groenvallei 0% - 0.24%
VA
RD
E DRIVE
AD
AY
Stikland
LE
EE W
Kempenville Thalmien
FR
LA
STR
IVE
Bellrail Sanlamhof
R
D
ILS
DE LA RE
Shirley Park
KU
1.67% - 3.70%
Y ROAD
Labiance
Beroma
Bellville South 3.71% - 9.09%
Triangle Farm Glenhaven
Roads
Sack's Circle Industrial
AD
RO
AM
E RD Peninsula Technicon
D
OD
M UWC Sources: StatsSA, Census 2001
Strategic Information Dept., City of Cape Town
The purpose of this map is to depict the possible influence of, for example, HIV/Aids on households
by indicating the areas where children younger than 20 years are the heads of households. According
to the legend, there are no areas with percentages higher than 3.70%.
AD
KOE
RO
VIS
Vierlanden
N
BER
O
GT
SER
IN
Crest
LL
Uitsig
S HO
WE
Nerina Ext D29
Uitzicht
KR
OAD
Wellway Park
Morningstar Roosendal
Aurora Ext D33 Country Places
Durbanville Langeberg Ridge
FAIRTR
Aurora Ext D22 Goedgemoed
EES RO
Durbanville Ext 2
DURB Vergesicht
ANV IL Durbanville Ext 13
AD
LE RO
AD Sonstraal Heights
d
Valmary Park
Ro a
Durbanville Hills
Vygeboom Sonstraal Ext E16
n
gto
llin
Eversdal Heights
We
Kenridge Heights Ext Fisantkraal
Amandaglen Ext E15 R312
Springfield De Bron Bellville South
TYGERVALLEY ROAD
Glen Ive
E AV EN
E
Welgemoed
DRIV
Stellenridge Vredenberg
Ridgeworth
JAGER
ANVILL
E
IE DRIV
Bellville Park RAD
N1 C ON
NS
JIP DE
DURB
BR
FRA Stellenberg
AC
Loevenstein
Christians
KE
Blomtuin Belair
NF
Hoheizen Ext 20
Oakdale
EL
L
N1 D
OA
BO
Bo-Oakdale AAR
LR 0% - 39.27%
U
P
OLD
LE
Groenvallei
VA
RD
DRIVE
OAD
Stikland
R
LE
Vredelust
BEL
RE
Kempenville Thalmien
RF
LA
Bellrail Sanlamhof
R
D
ILS
DE LA RE
Shirley Park
KU
76.73% - 88.13%
Y ROAD
Labiance
Beroma 88.14% - 100%
Bellville South
Triangle Farm Glenhaven
Roads
RO
M
RDA
DE
Peninsula Technicon
OD
M UWC Sources: StatsSA, Census 2001
Strategic Information Dept., City of Cape Town
AD
KOE
RO
Vierlanden
N
VIS
BER
O
GT
SER
IN
Crest
LL
Uitsig
S HO
WE
Nerina Ext D29
Uitzicht
KR
OAD
Wellway Park
Morningstar Roosendal
Aurora Ext D33 Country Places
Durbanville Langeberg Ridge
FA IRTR
Aurora Ext D22 Goedgemoed
EES RO
Durbanville Ext 2
DURB Vergesicht
ANV IL Durbanville Ext 13
AD
LE ROA D
Sonstraal Heights
oad
Valmary Park
Durbanville Hills
R
Sonstraal Ext E16
ton
Vygeboom
lling
Eversdal Heights
We
Kenridge Heights Ext Fisantkraal
Amandaglen Ext E15 R312
Springfield De Bron Bellville South
TYGERVALLEY ROA
Roosendal
Eversdal Ext 4
UE
Glen Ive
E AV EN
IVE
Welgemoed
DR
Stellenridge Vredenberg
Ridgeworth
JAGER
ANVILL
E
IE DRIV
Bellville Park RAD
N1 C ON
NS
JIP DE
DURB
FRA Stellenberg
Loevenstein
Hoheizen Ext 20
Blomtuin Belair 125 Places of worship
Oakdale
N1 AD
O
Bo-Oakdale AAR
LR
OLD
P
Groenvallei
Places of worship
E DRIVE
AD
Roads
E W AY
Stikland
E
ELL
Vredelust
RE
Kempenville Thalmien
B
RF
LA
STR
IVE
Bellrail Sanlamhof
R
D
ILS
DE LA RE
Shirley Park
KU
Y ROAD
Labiance
Beroma
Bellville South
Triangle Farm Glenhaven
RO
AM
E RD Peninsula Technicon
DD
MO UWC Sources: URDR, University of Stellenbosch
Strategic Information Dept., City of Cape Town
AD
KOE
RO
VIS
Vierlanden
N
BER
O
GT
SER
IN
Crest
LL
Uitsig
S HO
WE
Nerina Ext D29
Uitzicht
KR
OAD
Wellway Park
Morningstar Roosendal
Aurora Ext D33 Country Places
Durbanville Langeberg Ridge
FAIRTR
Aurora Ext D22 Goedgemoed
EES RO
Durbanville Ext 2
DURB Vergesicht
ANV IL Durbanville Ext 13
AD
LE RO
AD Sonstraal Heights
Valmary Park
d
Ro a
Durbanville Hills
Vygeboom Sonstraal Ext E16
ton
lling
Eversdal Heights
We
Kenridge Heights Ext Fisantkraal
Amandaglen Ext E15
R312
Springfield De Bron Bellville South
TYGERVALLEY ROAD
Glen Ive
E AV EN
E
Welgemoed
DRIV
Stellenridge Vredenberg
Ridgeworth
JAGER
ANVILL
E
IE DRIV
Bellville Park RAD
N1 C ON
NS
JIP DE
DURB
FRA Stellenberg
Loevenstein
Hoheizen Ext 20
Blomtuin Belair 119 Liquor outlets
Oakdale
N1 AD
Bo-Oakdale L RO
AAR
OLD
P
Groenvallei Liquor outlets
DRIVE
OAD
Stikland
R
Roads
LE
Vredelust
BEL
RE
Kempenville Thalmien
RF
LA
STR
IVE
Bellrail Sanlamhof
R
D
ILS
DE LA RE
Shirley Park
KU
Y ROAD
Labiance
Beroma
Bellville South
Triangle Farm Glenhaven
RO
AM
E RD Peninsula Technicon
D
OD
M UWC Sources: URDR, University of Stellenbosch
Strategic Information Dept., City of Cape Town
The table below summarises the discussion regarding churches and liquor outlets in an effort to
establish possible connections. The columns contain the area, the population of that area, the
population in that area that are affiliated with the Christian religion, the percentage of Christians of
the population, number of liquor outlets, number of churches, ratio of people in that area per liquor
outlet and lastly ratio of people in that area per church.
AD
KOE
RO
VIS
Vierlanden
N
BER
O
GT
SER
IN
Crest
LL
Uitsig
S HO
WE
Nerina Ext D29
Uitzicht
KR
OAD
Wellway Park
Morningstar Roosendal
Aurora Ext D33 Country Places
Durbanville Langeberg Ridge
FAIRTR
Aurora Ext D22 Goedgemoed
EES RO
Durbanville Ext 2
DURB Vergesicht
ANV IL Durbanville Ext 13
AD
LE RO
AD Sonstraal Heights
Valmary Park
oad
Durbanville Hills
R
Vygeboom Sonstraal Ext E16
ton
lling
Eversdal Heights
We
Kenridge Heights Ext Fisantkraal
Amandaglen Ext E15 R312
Springfield De Bron Bellville South
TYGERVALLEY ROAD
Glen Ive
E AV EN
E
Welgemoed
DRIV
Stellenridge Vredenberg
Ridgeworth
JAGER
ANVILL
E
IE DRIV
Bellville Park RAD
N1 C ON
NS
JIP DE
DURB
FRA Stellenberg
Loevenstein
Hoheizen Ext 20
Blomtuin Belair 4 Places of sexual misconduct
Oakdale
N1 AD
Bo-Oakdale L RO
P AAR Place of sexual misconduct
OLD Groenvallei
DRIVE
OAD
Stikland
R
LE
Vredelust
BEL
RE
Kempenville Thalmien
RF
LA
STR
IVE
Bellrail Sanlamhof
R
D
ILS
DE LA RE
Shirley Park
KU
Y ROAD
Labiance
Beroma
Bellville South
Triangle Farm Glenhaven
RO
AM
E RD Peninsula Technicon
D
OD
M UWC Sources: URDR, University of Stellenbosch
Strategic Information Dept., City of Cape Town
AD
KOE
RO
Vierlanden
N
VIS
BER
O
GT
SER
IN
Crest
LL
Uitsig
S HO
WE
Nerina Ext D29
Uitzicht
KR
OA D
Wellway Park
Morningstar Roosendal
Aurora Ext D33 Country Places
Durbanville Langeberg Ridge
FA IRTR
Aurora Ext D22 Goedgemoed
EES RO
Durbanville Ext 2
DURB Vergesicht
ANVILL Durbanville Ext 13
AD
E RO
AD Sonstraal Heights
oad
Valmary Park
Durbanville Hills
R
Vygeboom Sonstraal Ext E16
ton
lling
We
Eversdal Heights Fisantkraal
Kenridge Heights Ext
Amandaglen Ext E15 R312
Springfield De Bron Bellville South
TYGERVALLEY ROA
Roosendal
Eversdal Ext 4
UE
Glen Ive
AVEN
DRIVE
Welgemoed
Stellenridge Vredenberg
VILLE
Ridgeworth
JAGER
E
IE DRIV
AN
DURB
FRA Stellenberg
Loevenstein
Hoheizen Ext 20
Blomtuin Belair 26 Places selling drugs
Oakdale
N1 AD
Bo-Oakdale L RO
P AAR Illegal drugs
OLD Groenvallei
IE DRIVE
AD
Roads
E W AY
Stikland
LE
Vredelust
BEL
RE
Kempenville Thalmien
RF
LA
STR
IVE
Bellrail Sanlamhof
R
D
ILS
DE LA RE
Shirley Park
KU
Y ROAD
Labiance
Beroma
Bellville South
Triangle Farm Glenhaven
RO
AM
E RD Peninsula Technicon
DD
MO UWC Sources: URDR, University of Stellenbosch
Strategic Information Dept., City of Cape Town
4.3.1 Fisantekraal
P-Index
A graph summarising the top 11 priorities is given below. The scale varies between 0 and 11, with 11
the highest priority.
P-Index Fisantekraal
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Creche 10
Neighbourhood watch 10
Muncipal Services 10
Churches 9.8
Library 9.8
Clinic 9.7
Police 9.6
Work 9.5
It is evident that the community is struggling with major issues. A summary of respondents
feedback on five clusters of these issues will be given below.
Police/security
Housing
11
Transport Health Care
9
Safety 7 Sanitation
3
Welfare Water
1
Religion Energy
Education Income
Bonding
Again the scale ranges between 0 and 11, where 11 is the highest value in a positive sense. Three
questions were asked to establish the level of bonding in the community. The average responses are
given below:
1. To what extent do you consider the community to be your home? 6.9
2. How close do you feel to your friends in the community? 8.5
3. To what extent can you rely on the community to come to your aid? 4.6
The average figure for bonding in Fisantekraal is 6.7.
The people in Fisantekraal are desperate for work. They have no money and this affects their lives
drastically. They are living in poverty and do not have many resources there are no shops, the
schools are poor, there is no day care, the healthcare facilities are ineffective. Bonding in the
community is not very strong one lady specifically said that if you dont know a person, you wont
help them. Religion is not particularly strong and the churches do not seem to have a great influence.
The morale of the people seems to be low. They seem rather indifferent for the most part, as if they
do not expect anyone to actually listen to their complaints. They spoke often for the squatters, who
seem to be the worst off regarding municipal services and sanitation.
AD
KOE
RO
Vierlanden
N
VIS
BER
O
GT
SER
IN
Crest
LL
Uitsig
S HO
WE
Nerina Ext D29
Uitzicht
KR
OAD
Wellway Park
Morningstar Roosendal
Aurora Ext D33 Country Places
Durbanville Langeberg Ridge
FA IRTR
Aurora Ext D22 Goedgemoed
EES RO
Durbanville Ext 2
DURB Vergesicht
ANV IL Durbanville Ext 13
AD
LE RO
AD Sonstraal Heights
d
Valmary Park
Ro a
Durbanville Hills
Vygeboom Sonstraal Ext E16
n
gto
llin
Eversdal Heights
We
Kenridge Heights Ext Fisantkraal
Amandaglen Ext E15 R312
Springfield De Bron Bellville South
TYGERVALLEY ROAD
Glen Ive
E AV EN
E
Welgemoed
DRIV
Stellenridge Vredenberg
Ridgeworth
JAGER
ANVILL
E
IE DRIV
Bellville Park RAD
N1 C ON
NS
JIP DE
DURB
BR
FRA Stellenberg
AC
Loevenstein
Deaths related to assault
KE
Blomtuin Belair
NF
Hoheizen Ext 20
Oakdale
EL
L
N1 D
OA
BO
Bo-Oakdale R
A AR L 0% - 3.23%
U
P
OLD
LE
Groenvallei
VA
RD
DRIVE
AD
EW AY
Vredelust
B EL
RE
Kempenville Thalmien
RF
LA
R
ILS
DE LA RE
Shirley Park
KU
15.85% - 28.73%
Y ROAD
Labiance
Beroma 28.74% - 57.08%
Bellville South
Triangle Farm Glenhaven
Roads
RO
M
DA
DE
R Peninsula Technicon
OD
M UWC Sources: City Health Directorate, City of Cape Town
Strategic Information Dept., City of Cape Town
The map shows the percentage of people in Durbanville/Bellville who died in 2001 as a result of
physical assault. The percentages are shown for each of the smaller areas of Durbanville/Bellville. If
one studies the map in conjunction with the legend, a few areas stand out. The first is Country Places,
coloured in red, indicating a very high percentage of people who died due to assault. Two other areas
are also noteworthy Bellville West and Groenvallei with high percentages.
AD
KOE
RO
VIS
Vierlanden
N
BER
O
GT
SER
IN
Crest
LL
Uitsig
S HO
WE
Nerina Ext D29
Uitzicht
KR
OAD
Wellway Park
Morningstar Roosendal
Aurora Ext D33 Country Places
Durbanville Langeberg Ridge
FAIRTR
Aurora Ext D22 Goedgemoed
EES RO
Durbanville Ext 2
DURB Vergesicht
ANV IL Durbanville Ext 13
AD
LE RO
AD Sonstraal Heights
oad
Valmary Park
Durbanville Hills
R
ton
Vygeboom Sonstraal Ext E16
lling
We
Eversdal Heights
Kenridge Heights Ext Fisantkraal
Amandaglen Ext E15 R312
Springfield De Bron Bellville South
TYGERVALLEY ROAD
Glen Ive
E AV EN
E
Welgemoed
DRIV
Stellenridge Vredenberg
Ridgeworth
JAGER
ANVILL
E
IE DRIV
Bellville Park RAD
N1 C ON
NS
JIP DE
DURB
BR
FRA Stellenberg
AC
Blomtuin Belair
NF
Hoheizen Ext 20
Oakdale
EL
L
N1 D
OA
BO
Bo-Oakdale AAR
LR 0% - 3.17%
U
P
OLD
LE
Groenvallei
VA
RD
DRIVE
AD
EW AY
Stikland
LE
Vredelust
B EL
RE
Kempenville Thalmien
RF
LA
Bellrail Sanlamhof
R
D
ILS
DE LA RE
Shirley Park
KU
17.55% - 31.48%
Y ROAD
Labiance
Beroma 31.49% - 55.59%
Bellville South
Triangle Farm Glenhaven
Roads
RO
M
RDA
DE
Peninsula Technicon
OD
M UWC Sources: City Health Directorate, City of Cape Town
Strategic Information Dept., City of Cape Town
The percentage of people in Durbanville/Bellville who died in 2001 as a result of some or other
disease together with related to HIV/Aids is shown on this map. Welgemoed and Morningstar are the
only areas that fall in the legend category of 3.18% to 9.64%.
K O EBERG
0.12% - 0.72%
AD
VI
S
S
E
RS RO
HO N
K TO
0.73% - 1.59% IN
G
RO
TABLE VIEW DURBANVILLE LL
AD
E
W
1.60% - 3.11%
KRAAIFONTEIN
DURBANVILLE
O AD
S T J OHN'S R
DU
R
B
5.33% - 9.02% A NVI L L E B R IG
F AI R
RO HT
AD O
BOTHASIG N N1
NG O
RO
TY
TRE ES
AD
MILNERTON
G
Roads
VENUE
E
O KAVA
RV
PAROW
AL
RO AD
LE
VI L L E A
BELLVILLE EV AD
Durbanville/Bellville ER
RO
YR
S DAL N
RO L
BRACKENFELL R DE B AR
OAD
GOODWOOD PA
OA
AN
LD
D
MP O
D UR B
RA
BO
KENSINGTON
TF
IV
V ENUE
SEA POINT
O
D
NT
OL IE
MAITLAND BELLVILLE SOUTH DO
AD
EIN
A
ELSIES RIVER RAVENSMEAD
RA
K
N
RO
S CO
RO
WOODSTOCK PINELANDS F R AN
C H OO
AD
AD
HEN
BR
CAPE TOWN CENTRAL LANGA D R IK
V AN S
AC
V E R W O E RD DRIVE
MOWBRAY
N1
K
BISHOP LAVIS BELLVILLE
EN
AD
IE
FE
O
RONDEBOSCH ATHLONE
IL L
DELFT R
LL
Y
D
W
BO
AR
CAMPS BAY BRACKENFELL
OA
RAVENSMEAD PAROW L
UL E
KUILSRIVIER TT
E
ER
BO
CLAREMONT MANENBERG E R RO A D
V ARD
REK K
EL L
GUGULETU VO ORT
LA B
LANSDOWNE
DE LA
NYANGA
AY
WYNBERG
RE Y RO
EW
F RE
VA
BELLVILLE SOUTH
N
AD
RIVE R
RIE
PHILIPPI RAVENSMEAD
BE
RO KUILSRIVIER
EC
M
KUILS
KHAYELITSHA DA
AVE N
KR
R
MITCHELLS PLAIN DE
OA
D
U
E O DELFT
D
M
GRASSY PARK MACASSAR R IC A DRI VE
E
KIRSTENHOF STEENBERG
STRANDFONTEIN SOMERSET WEST
FISH HOEK
MUIZENBERG
FALSE BAY
STRAND
OCEAN VIEW
CMA POLICE STATION BOUNDARIES
GORDONS BAY
It is evident from the graduated colours that the study area in total has a low (Durbanville), medium
(Bellville and Bellville South) and a high rate (areas part of Kraaifontein e.g. Fisantekraal) of
occurrences of violent crimes compared to the rest of the City of Cape Town.
VI
SS
E
R AD
SHO O
K R
N
TO
R
0.68% - 1.73% G
OA
L IN
EL
TABLE VIEW DURBANVILLE
W
K OE
1.74% - 3.64% KRAAIFONTEIN
BE
DURBANVILLE KRAAIFONTEIN
RG
3.65% - 6.16%
O AD
ST JO HN' S R
DU
RB
A N VILL B RI G
ER
FAI R
HT
6.17% - 14.23% O AD O N N1
NG O
RO
TY
BOTHASIG AD
T
RE ES ROAD
G
E
E
O KAVA
MILNERTON
L LE AVE NU
RV
Roads
AL
PAROW
L
EV AD
EY
ER
BELLVILLE SDA N RO
RO
ROAD
LR L
DE B AR
Durbanville/Bellville
VI
BRACKENFELL
O
PA
AD
AN
GOODWOOD P RI
VE O
LD
URB
R AM
D
IE
NUED
AD
KENSINGTON R
N
SEA POINT OL O
A VE
D
SC
MAITLAND BELLVILLE SOUTH OA
N
ELSIES RIVER RAVENSMEAD
K
A
R
FR
RO
CHOO
WOODSTOCK PINELANDS
AD
HE ND
BR
VAN S
CAPE TOWN CENTRAL LANGA
R IK
VE IVE
AC
R W OE R D DR
BELLVILLE
KE
MOWBRAY BISHOP LAVIS BRACKENFELL
L IE
NF
EL
W IL
RONDEBOSCH ATHLONE AD
DELFT
AD
L
PAROW
RO
BO
CAMPS BAY
RO
RAVENSMEAD
Y
UL E
KUILSRIVIER L AR
TE
LL E
MANENBERG B OT
VARD
CLAREMONT TIE
NI E M EYE R B
BE
YP
GUGULETU ASS
LA
LANSDOWNE
DE LA
NYANGA
AY
WYNBERG
EW
RE
BELLVILLE SOUTH
Y ROAD
FR E
VA
SY
N
RI VER
RIE
M
HO
35 TH
DIEPRIVIER
P
HOUT BAY PHILIPPI AD KUILSRIVIER
BE
RAVENSMEAD RO
NY
EC
M
KUILS
AVEN
KHAYELITSHA DA
W AY
KR
ER
MITCHELLS PLAIN DD
OA
UE
O
DELFT
D
M
GRASSY PARK MACASSAR
KIRSTENHOF STEENBERG
STRANDFONTEIN SOMERSET WEST
FISH HOEK
MUIZENBERG
FALSE BAY
STRAND
OCEAN VIEW CMA POLICE STATION BOUNDARIES GORDONS BAY
On this map we see the same phenomenon as on the previous map, which depicts the occurrences of
violent crimes. The graduated colours indicate that in total the study area has a low (Durbanville),
medium (Bellville and Bellville south) and a high rate (parts of Kraaifontein e.g. Fisantekraal) of
occurrences of violent crimes compared to the rest of the City of Cape Town.
5 DISSEMINATION OF INFORMATION
The feedback of the results will be presented at DRC Stellenberg during the second half of 2004.
The Unit also developed a website where the research partners can view the results of the research
(www.sun.ac.za/theology/urdr.htm).
6 CONCLUSIONS
In conclusion we want, firstly, to summarise the results and, secondly, direct concluding remarks to
the church leaders.
Summarising the demographics of Durbanville/Bellville, it seems that the following can be said:
Durbanville/Bellville consists of many different suburbs. There are a total of 108 subplace
names in the study area, with an average of 1,246 people.
The community is, socio-economically speaking, White and Coloured, Afrikaans/English
speaking, growing, middle aged and mostly wealthy.
The population in Durbanville/Bellville increased by 24,740 (12,464 households) people
from 1996 to 2001. 57.2% of this growth comes from the White population group, 27.5%
from the Coloured population group and 13.7% from the Black population group.
It is evident, however, that daunting challenges still face South Africa after the miracle of its
peaceful transition. Overwhelming poverty and poverty-related problems, such as the HIV/Aids
pandemic, face Africa. South Africa is comprised of both a rich and a poor world. Previously, the
apartheid laws marked boundaries between these two worlds. Now, new boundaries are developing
along, inter alia, political power and class-related lines. Social transformation, implying the way
society and culture change in response to such factors as economic growth, war or political
upheavals, is particularly relevant to the continuing transformation of communities in post-apartheid
South Africa.
Firstly, the paradigm of church leaders must be challenged. Many pastors only live, think and plan
within the paradigm of their own local organization. Sometimes, they are guilty of ambitiously
building their own kingdoms in their churches. Leaders must focus more on the kingdom of God and
the community. Instead of keeping believers inside the church, members should be empowered and
mobilised to live out there. Thus, when reflecting on community transformation, they should
consider strategies that operate at several levels. Churches need to form partnerships with the
community, other churches and other role-players. Transformation will not happen at only one level.
Secondly, lets examine the church from a development perspective. Since 1994 South Africans have
been living in a secular, pluralist, democratic society. Such a society has various public institutions,
organizations and initiatives that fill the public space. Free from government intervention,
individuals can organize themselves into autonomous organizations. The church is an example of
such an organization, competing with government and business for room in the public space.
The church is also a volunteer organization and thus forms part of the dynamics of volunteer
organizations, over against the government sector, which has the ability to demand resources by
means of threat, power and coercion. The business sector operates with economic power by selling
products and services, while volunteer organizations specialise in the power of consensus. People
commit to a volunteer organization to the extent that they identify with its vision and values. They
Copyright URDR, Stellenbosch University 37
remain committed to the point that they are able to realise their ideals through the organization. The
power of these organizations resides in their values, vision, independence and services that they
render to improve the communitys quality of life. On the other hand, such organizations are very
sensitive as regards their membership. Therefore, the more vital their vision and values, the greater
the number of members!
Thus, as a volunteer organization, the church competes for public space by communicating and
living a vision and values for the community.
A second developmental perspective on the church is its role as agent for development. Traditionally,
the church has always been involved in ministries of charity. These services focus on peoples
immediate needs, for example, food, housing and medical services, especially during and after wars
and natural disasters. In fact, the church probably has the best organized networks locally and
internationally for delivering these services.
However, if churches accept the challenge to play a role in developing sustainable communities, they
should also implement strategies other than merely providing relief. Churches must develop
strategies to increase peoples capacities to promote meeting their own needs through self-reliant
action (community development). Churches should also adopt strategies that attempt to develop
sustainable systems: churches that work with major national role-players to reorient policies and
working modes in a sustained process of using and raising resources in such a way that the
challenges can be dealt with effectively. Lastly, churches should develop peoples movements:
decentralized action to involve people in a movement at grassroots level, where there is less focus on
money and resources, and more on motivating social energy in movements.
The values underlying these activities are threefold. Firstly, development should be people-centred,
that is people must be able to participate in their own development, which must meet basic felt needs.
It often happens that churches start ministries in response to perceived needs, not the peoples real
needs. Their felt needs are a need to belong, to be significant and important, and a need for a
reasonable amount of security. Secondly, development must be sustainable and, thirdly, there should
be empowerment of both the helpers and those who are being helped.
In conclusion, the Christian religion has the potential to influence the community. The sets of
information presented on the Christian religion definitely indicate that the Christian religion does
have the potential to promote change. The success of initiatives will depend on:
1. The values/ideas which they employ; the symbols and images they use. Religious ideas about
poverty, women and family, the environment, the local community, safety and security,
peace, reconciliation, social justice, equity, etc. will have an influence;
2. Leadership - leadership that expresses the desired change and lives it, leadership that walks
the talk. These leaders must be prophets who declare the path, affirm the values and act as
symbol senders. Alternatively, leadership can be a networking organization;
3. Their capacity to be inclusive and effect unification will create the space for change;
4. The initiative must integrate deep spiritual transformation with social transformation;
5. The potential of the Christian religious group. The internal dynamics of religious
communities in Durbanville/Bellville might also influence this potential;
6. The dialectic relationship of the Christian grouping with the larger society. In other words
how is the church influencing society and how is society influencing the church? Are the
churches very negative towards society, withdrawing their influence and remaining aloof, or
do they assertively seek ways to influence society, based on their values, for the better?
Contact details:
Dr. Johannes Erasmus Gerbrand Mans
Tel. (021) 808-2614 Tel. (021) 808-2614
Sel. 082 7711 542 Sel. 083 2567 067
E-mail: egdn@sun.ac.za E-mail: gmans@sun.ac.za
Page
2. Description on index-diagrams 4
A. Personal variables 5
B. Economic variables 8
C. Household variables 9
The main content of the report is to provide you with comparative information
about your area in relation to a comparative area (CA) or town / city or province
for more insight into it's demographic profile.
- Two values are plotted on each axis, these are index values:
* the blue line is what the index value of your area would be if there is no difference
between it and the CA
* the red line is the actual index value of your area
* the actual index value of your area (red line) is calculated by taking for example the
percentage of people who are married in your area and dividing it by the percentage of
people who are married in the whole of the CA and multiplying it by 100, (25% / 10%) *
100 = 250. Therefore 2.5 times the national average
* as has been sad earlier; if there is no difference between the your areas average
and that of the CA, (25% / 25%) * 100 = 100, the index value will always be 100.
Therefore, the blue line always runs through the axis where the value is 100.
When looking at the diagram and the way the red line deviates from the blue
one, one gets a good idea of the differences there are between your area and
the CA with the index value on each axis showing the degree of deviation.
A. Personal Variables
Gender 1996 2001 '96 to '01 CA '01
Male 46.80% 46.71% -0.09% 48.49%
Female 53.20% 53.29% 0.09% 51.51%
Gender
Female
Male
African/ Black
Population group
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
Whit e 0 Coloured
Indian/ Asian
35 - 49 yrs 20 - 34 yrs
IsiNdebele
200
Language
180
English IsiXhosa
160
140
120
100
Afrikaans IsiZulu
80
60
40
20
0
Xitsonga Sepedi
Tshivenda Sesot ho
120
100
80
Divorced Married Civil/religious
60
40
20
Living together
Judaism
Hinduism
Islam
No Schooling Education
350
300
250
200
150
Post school qualif icat ion Grade 0 - 7
100
50
10 0
80
60
40
20
Industry
Agricult ure Forest ry Fishing
250
Communit y Social services 200 M ining
150
100
Financial Insurance Real est at e Business 50 M anufact uring
200
150
100
Skilled Agricult ure and Fishery workers Service workers Sales workers
200
150
100
50
Type of dwelling
House on separate st and
200
100
50
Room/ flat let on shared propert y Flat in block of f lat s
100
80
60
20
80
60
20
Paraf f in Gas
15 - 19 yrs
140
Household head age
120
100
80
60
40
20
60+yrs 0 20 - 29 yrs
30 - 59 yrs
Head of household
140 Relationship to head
120
100
Ot her-relat ive Husband/ wif e/ partner
80
60
40
20