Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Itisverydifficulttowriteaboutthistwolevels.ItisverydifficultbecauseIamthedirector
(principal)ofalargeadultdistanceschool,allwehavedoneoverthepast20yearshereat
ISEAiswhatHaroldStolovitch(HaroldStolovitch,2011)callsTellandtest.Wehave
beengivinginformationtoourstudentsandthenaskingthemquestionsthatgetansweredat
theendofthecourse;oncetheyanswercorrectlyatleast60%ofthemwegivethema
certificateandthatsall.
In2007theMinistryofEducationstartedacurriculumreform,theytransformedouralmost
noexistentcurriculaintoaCompetencyCurriculum.Thereisasayingthatgoodintentions
pave the way to hell; even though the competency model is a good idea, its
implementationhasbeenveryhardbecausetherewasnopriortraining.Fromoneschool
yeartoanothersuddenlyteachersandstudentshadtostartusingthisenormousdocuments.
A.V.Kellyusedtomockthisgreatbooks(Kelly,2009)sayingthatyouliterallycouldask
pass me the curriculum and they would hand you this enormous book. It was what
happenedtoourteachers.Theydidnotknowwhattodowiththis400pagedocuments,
each course has about 6 to 8 competencies; like 30 or more learning outcomes and
hundredsofpagecontents.
Kirkpatricktellsusaboutcriticalbehaviors,somethingverygoodwhenteachingadults,
providedwecanredesignourcurriculaandadaptittothecompetencymodel.Themain
issuehereishowtoreinforcewhenyouhave10thousandstudentsscatteredalloverthe
country.WehavecomeupwithacoachingmodelcalledKumool.ThisisawordinMayan
languagethattranslateslikebrotherbutissomethingcloser,weareencouragingstudents
tofindaKumoolatwork,athomeorwithhisherownfriends,thatwouldatthesame
time foster accountability; like J. Kirkpatrick says: Better methods of monitoring
performanceincludeobservationandworkreview.P73Wethinkthatpeercoachingcan
help.
Asforlevel4Iwouldliketowritetwomorepages,butwithmuchshameIhavetoadmit
thatwedonotdoLevel4evaluation.This2017wearepreparingalongitudinalstudythat
willlast4years,wewilltakeagroupofstudentsthatstartsfirstyearandthenfollowthem
untiloneyearaftergraduationtoseewhathappens,butrightnowwehavenone.
Trabajos citados
HaroldStolovitch,E.Y.(2011).TellingaintTraining.AlexandriaVA:ASTDPress.
Kelly,A.V.(2009).TheCurriculum:TheoryandPractice.London:SAGE.
Kirkpatrick,J.a.(2016).FourLevelsofTrainingEvaluation.AlexandriaVA:ATDPress.