Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
PII: S0378-7788(14)00941-4
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/doi:10.1016/j.enbuild.2014.11.016
Reference: ENB 5479
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication.
As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript.
The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof
before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process
errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that
apply to the journal pertain.
*Manuscript
Thermal insulating plaster as a solution for refurbishing historic building envelopes: first experimental
results
Lorenza Bianco1, Valentina Serra1*, Stefano Fantucci1, Marco Dutto2, Marco Massolino2
1
Department of Energy, Politecnico di Torino, TEBE Research Group, Turin, Italy
2
Vimark srl - Peveragno (Cuneo), Italy
Corresponding author* Valentina Serra, Politecnico di Torino, Dept. of Energy, Corso Duca degli Abruzzi 24,
t
ip
10129 Torino, 0039110904431, valentina.serra@polito.it
ABSTRACT
cr
In Italy, historic buildings constitute 20% of the built environment. Although historic buildings are usually
us
excluded from the obligation of adopting specific energy standard, energy related aspects should be
nevertheless faced and managed in order to exploit the building usability potential, to attain indoor
an
environmental quality and energy efficiency conditions. The energy refurbishment of this kind of building is,
however, a very complex matter that leads to a number of question concerning buildings conservation and
M
valorisation aspects. A non invasive technique, that is, the application of thermal plaster to the internal side of
a building envelope, has been investigated in this paper. Thanks to its relatively easy installation and
ed
reversibility, thermal insulating plaster seems to represent a very interesting solution as it is able to offer a
The aim of this work is to present a thermal, vegetal based insulating plaster, which has recently been
developed within a research project, and to investigate its potential to reduce the heat flux exchanged through
ce
the vertical envelope of historic buildings, by means of measurements carried out in both the laboratory and in
Ac
KEYWORDS thermal insulating plaster, building envelope, historic building, built heritage, energy
refurbishment, retrofitting.
1. INTRODUCTION
The refurbishment of existing buildings is a crucial point for the achievement of the energy and climate
objectives of the European Union (EU) for 2020 and 2050. The energy performance of existing buildings
is still very poor, and the construction sector is responsible, on average, for 35% of the energy
consumption in Europe and in Italy [1]. The problem is made, even more complex in Italy, by the
Page 1 of 24
remarked presence of historic buildings, which constitute 20% of the existing building stock (2 out of 10
Passing from energy related aspects to the cultural ones, according to the Italian Constitution (art.9),
historic buildings should be preserved and protected because they constitute a source of knowledge of the
architectural history of the country. Consequently, the strategy concerning the protection of historic
buildings must be enhanced, and it could be more easily implemented if buildings continue to have a
t
ip
function and a role, as theorized by Annoni in 1946 [3]. Specific maintenance interventions, are therefore
needed to refurbish the buildings from the energy point of view. Although historic buildings are usually
cr
excluded from the obligation of adopting specific energy standards, energy related aspects should be faced
us
and managed in order to exploit the building usability potential, so as to create acceptable indoor
question concerning conservation and valorisation of the building aspects and which require one case at a
M
time approach [3], when deciding how and where to intervene on a building.
A literature review has shown, that a qualitative and quantitative approach to the energy and sustainability
ed
of heritage buildings needs to be applied [4]. Furthermore, the lack of a methodology, technologies and
knowledge on historic building retrofitting has been observed. Till now, only a few experimental and
pt
modelling activity researches have been conducted on this topic [5,6]. One study has recently presented a
ce
methodology, based on MCDM analysis (multiple-criteria decision-making), to select the best solution for
Thanks to the relatively easy installation and reversibility, thermal insulating plaster seems to represent a
very interesting solution, as it is able to offer a good compromise between energy and conservation
aspects for those buildings where it can be applied (i.e. no frescoed walls). The first results of a research
project, aimed at developing new kinds of plaster and insulation materials with low embodied energy, are
presented. In this work, the analysis has focused on a new thermal, vegetal based plaster, developed
specifically for internal insulation. In particular, the study here presented deals with its applicability to the
internal side of an existing historical building envelope under refurbishment, and assesses the impact on the
Page 2 of 24
The thermal insulating plaster has been tested in the laboratory to assess its thermal properties and in a
real historic building, to investigate its potential to reduce the heat flux exchanged through the vertical
Plaster has been used for thousands of years as constructive element in buildings, especially in Europe. The
versatility of this material allows it to be both used internally and externally, with the possibility of applying
t
ip
rendering or plastering mortar to different substrates, constructions and compositions. Thermal insulating
plaster represents one of the possible solutions that can be adopted to face energy related problems in
cr
existing and historic buildings. The workability of thermal plaster is very similar to that of traditional plaster,
us
as it can be used on non-aligned, out of square, or even on curved supports. Thermal insulating plaster is in
fact flexible and can be suitable for any architectural or design solution. Moreover, thermal insulating plaster
an
is characterised by a high water vapour diffusion coefficient, with a water vapour resistance factor ( value)
of between 5 and 15. For this reason, the application of this technology to existing walls is possible for
M
envelopes affected by capillary rising damp, a problem which is very often present in historic buildings.
Thermal insulating plaster has been studied not only to be a finishing or a protection layer of the walls, but
ed
also to improve their thermal resistance. These special kinds of plaster are characterised by thermal
conductivity values that are more than ten times lower than traditional plaster (standard lime plaster 0.7
pt
W/(mK)) and they are divided into two categories: plaster with natural binders (natural hydraulic lime) and
plaster with cement or artificial binders. These types of plaster are usually pre-mixed and ready to use and
ce
are made with Light Weight Aggregates (LWA), such as cork, clay, perlite, pearls of expanded polystyrene,
Ac
expanded glass, etc. LWA are able to significantly improve the thermal and acoustical insulation
performances of the component. Additionally, the weight of the component is noticeably reduced, compared
New kinds of thermal insulating plaster are still being studied to reduce their thickness and to improve their
thermal conductivity. Research is moving towards new aggregates, that is, innovative or natural materials.
High-tech solutions, such as aerogel or phase change material (PCM) based plaster, are also being
investigated.
Page 3 of 24
In this paper, the results related to traditional and advanced materials for thermal plaster are presented, with
particular focus on the thermal properties of a vegetal based plaster. Vegetal aggregate materials, derived
from corncobs, were added to a natural Wasselonne hydraulic lime and expanded silica (perlite), and the
resulting plaster was tested through a laboratory analysis and in field measurements. The particle size
distribution of the ingredients was studied in the laboratory to obtain the best combination from the physical,
mechanical and thermal points of view. Wasselonne lime is a Natural Hydraulic Lime (NHL 2, according to
t
ip
the EN 459-1:2010 standard [8]) that has been extracted since 1932 in the Alsace region, France, and it
constitutes a significant percentage of the final product. The natural aggregate in these prototypes was 43%
cr
(33% corncobs and 10% of dried expanded silica) and it played a double role: firstly, it contributed to an
us
improvement in the insulation of the plaster by exploiting a waste material (i.e. the corncobs) and, secondly,
the mechanical properties of the plaster were improved and the risk of cracking was hence reduced.
an
Furthermore, the natural binder gave a high water vapour diffusion coefficient to the plaster (that is, higher
than cement binders). Application tests were carried out by spraying the thermal insulating plaster onto a test
M
wall using a plastering machine (Figs. 1a and 1b).
The results have showed that this technology is capable of supporting greater thicknesses of thermal
ed
insulating plaster (above 10 cm) than traditional insulating plaster. The same result could only be achieved
using a traditional plaster through the repeated application of thin plaster layers onto its support with the
pt
consequent risk of cracking. The sample that passed the first mechanical test and presented the best
performance was named VGT_04, and the results related to this sample are hereafter presented. The results
ce
concerning long - term decay and the marcescence and oxidation processes are not yet available, but these
Ac
important aspects are currently under investigation. Furthermore, on the basis of the ISO 14040:2006
3. THE MEASUREMENTS
Laboratory measurements have been performed to assess the equivalent thermal conductivity of the thermal
plaster samples (10 cm thickness and 60x60 cm size, as shown in Figure 2a). A set of experimental
measurements was carried out with heat flow meter apparatus, in accordance with the EN 12667:2001
international standard [10]. The apparatus, a Lasercomp FOX600, consists of a single sample, heat flow
Page 4 of 24
meter with a guarded ring equipped with two plates containing heat flow meters placed above and below the
sample (Fig. 2b). Specifications details of the equipment are given in Table 1.
The instrument was designed and set up in accordance with the ASTMC518, 1991 [11] standard and it was
calibrated with 1450b NIST SRM calibration reference samples and an EPS sample (expanded
polystyrene). All the samples were previously tested and certified by NIST. In order to avoid any additional
surface resistances, due to the sample discontinuity, all the specimens were sandwiched between two rubber
t
ip
3 mm sheets with a thermal conductivity of 0.073 W/(mK) at 10 C. The uncertainty of the measured thermal
conductivities were determined for each measurement in accordance with ENV 13005:1999 [12]. The
cr
resulting uncertainty values were within 2%, according to EN 12667:2001 [10] (annex B), including the
us
additional uncertainty caused by subtracting the resistance of the rubber sheets.
Laboratory measurements were performed on two different samples (A and B) of the same thermal plaster
an
(VGT_04 with natural Wasselonne hydraulic lime and vegetal aggregate materials). Before the tests, both
specimens were dried to constant mass in a ventilated oven for 48 h at 60C to determine their mass. The
M
relative loss in mass was calculated comparing the mass of the samples before and after the drying cycle. The
tests were carried out at three different mean temperatures: 10, 25 and 40 C, respectively, with a
ed
As is known the measurement principle is to create a constant temperature difference between the upper
pt
plate and the lower plate, and to measure the specific heat flux and surface temperatures in steady state
conditions. The equivalent thermal conductivity [W/ (mK)] is then calculated using Equation 1, where s is
ce
the sample thickness [m], q is the specific heat flux [W/m2] and ts is the temperature difference between
Ac
eq (s q ) / t s [W/mC] (1)
The sample specifications are shown in Table 2. Samples A and B differ mainly as far as the density is
concerned: sample A presents a higher density than sample B for both humid and dried samples. The thermal
conductivity of the two different samples is reported in Table 3. In Figure 3, which shows the equivalent
thermal conductivity vs. average temperature of the plates, it is possible to observe the influence of the water
Page 5 of 24
Both samples demonstrate quasi-linear behaviour: the difference between the dry and the humid samples is
between 8% and 17% for sample A, and between 3% and 4% for sample B, depending on the set-point
temperatures. The divergence between samples A and B was due to their different water contents.
The experimental results show that vegetal aggregates have a great potential to reduce the thermal
conductivity of plaster, compared to traditional cement thermal plaster with lime. From an analysis of the
results merges that, the thermal conductivity of the thermal insulating plaster (VGT_04) is 0.08 0.13
t
ip
W/(mK) range while the reference sample is the 0.25-0.27 W/(mK) range. This means that samples A and B
are 2.5 and 3 times more insulating than the reference sample. It should be emphasized that the results
cr
achieved with these natural aggregates are in line with the literature values [13] obtained for different
us
aggregates (i.e EPS, cork).
measurements was performed in a real application on the building envelope of a historic building under
M
refurbishment in Turin, the ex Albergo di Virt, 1580 (Fig.4). This historic building, which has a
monumental value for the city of Turin, will become to a top category hotel, reinstating its original function.
ed
The vertical opaque envelope of the building presents a 500 mm thick and heterogeneous (brick and stone)
wall. Thanks to the involvement of the contractor in the project, it was possible during the refurbishment to
pt
use two identical rooms with the same South - East orientation as test rooms. A 60 mm layer of thermal
insulating plaster, made up of Wasselonne natural hydraulic lime and vegetal aggregate materials (VGT_04),
ce
was applied to the wall of a room facing the external environment (Fig.5a); in the other room, the same
Ac
external reference wall was left without any internal finishing (Fig. 5b). The air temperature was controlled
in both rooms through electric heaters, with a temperature set point of 23C.
The thermo-physical behaviour and the energy performance of the vertical envelope was assessed by means
of the continuous measurements of the heat flux, surface temperature and air temperature (according to ISO
9869-1:2014) [14]. The position of the probes was decided after an infrared image campaign of the
investigated walls through a NEC Thermo Tracer (TH9100 MV/WV). In this way, the sensors were
positioned in homogenous and representative areas of the wall (avoiding thermal bridges and discontinuity of
the material). Heat flux meters, which had previously been tested in the laboratory, were placed on the
Page 6 of 24
internal surface of both walls. The internal and external surface temperatures and the indoor and outdoor air
temperatures were measured by means of thermocouples (TT-types, previously calibrated in the laboratory).
The instruments were connected to two data loggers placed in each test room, which retrieved data every 15
minutes. Hourly values were then calculated off-line for the data elaboration.
The thermal performance of the wall with VGT_04 was established, on one hand, through an assessment of
the thermal transmittance and, on the other hand, through the calculation of the daily transmitted energy. The
t
ip
equivalent thermal transmittance was evaluated through the progressive average methodology, where the
average values, of the specific heat flux (in W/m2) and the temperature differences between internal and
cr
external air, were used instead of the instantaneous values (ISO 9869 1994) [14], according to equation (2).
us
(Q / A) n
U* [W/m2C] (2)
(t s ) n
an
The total daily transmitted energy e24 (in Wh/m2) is defined as the energy transferred through the faade on a
daily basis. The convention used during the measurements was that a negative value of heat flux meant heat
M
losses and a positive one meant heat gains. The total daily energy (equation 3) was then obtained from the
integral over the 24 h (from 00 am to 00 pm of the following day) of the surface heat flux exchanged on the
ed
24:00
e24 (q )dt [Wh/m ] (3)
pt
00:00
ce
The first step of the infield measurement was an infrared image campaign. It was necessary to verify the
Ac
homogeneity of the walls in order to evaluate where to position the sensors. The infrared and visible images
of the two tested walls are presented in Figure 6. The surface temperature is slightly lower in the lower part
of the plastered wall, on the floor and below the window, due to thermal bridges and discontinuity of the
material. The surface temperature of the reference wall is affected to a great extent by the finishing
discontinuity. A central position, where the node with the lateral partition wall did not influence the surface
The daily energy of a seven days campaign, characterised by a rather high temperature difference between
the indoor and the outdoor environment, is plotted in Figure 7. Boundary conditions, during the selected
Page 7 of 24
days, were similar in the two test rooms. The average air temperature in the room with the thermal plaster
(VGT_04) in the selected days was between 22.6 and 23.6 C, while an average daily indoor air temperature
of between 22.5 and 22.8 C was measured in the reference room. A minimum average daily outdoor air
temperature of 11.7 and a maximum value of 17.7 C were measured in the considered days.
In Figure 7, it is possible to notice that the energy losses through the reference wall are always higher than
those through the wall with the thermal plaster. The measured heat flux values are negative for each day.
t
ip
Since the outdoor air temperature was always lower than the indoor air temperature, the daily energy that
crossed the reference wall was between 20% (day 3) and 41% (day 7) higher than the daily energy through
cr
the VGT_04 wall. As the boundary condition and the wall structure were the same, it is possible to state that
us
the difference monitored between the two test rooms was due to the presence of the thermal plaster layer.
In order to have a more complete picture of the energy performance of the tested wall, a new measurement
an
campaign was carried out in a more representative period, in order to collect enough data to assess the
thermal conductance/transmittance of the wall with the average method. The data collected in this first
M
campaign, which was performed in a cold April (very cold nights but also sunny days) shows highly
dynamic behaviour of the wall, and it was therefore not possible to define the stationary equivalent thermal
ed
The equivalent thermal transmittance of the plastered wall was 0.56 W/(m2K), as shown in Figure 8, which
pt
means a thermal transmittance of the bare wall of about 0.8 W/(m2K), calculated assuming the thermal
resistance of the thermal plaster as resulting from the ratio of the measured value of the thermal conductivity
ce
to the real applied thickness. Unfortunately, it was not possible to measure the bare wall in the other test
Ac
room since it was under refurbishment during the second measurement period. The comparison between the
two values confirm that 6 cm of VGT_04 thermal plaster can reduce heat loss by about 30%.
4. CONCLUSIONS
In this paper, thermal insulating plaster has been investigated as a possible option for historic building
refurbishment. A new thermal insulating plaster was obtained adding to the natural hydraulic lime of
Wasselonne, vegetal aggregate materials deriving from the waste of the corn production, which lend higher
Page 8 of 24
Results concerning laboratory measurement and the monitoring campaign in a real application on the
building envelope of a historic building located in Turin are discussed. The low thermal conductivity of the
new material, which is 2.5/3 times lower than conventional plaster, has led to a significant reduction in the
Other analyses are ongoing with the aim of further diminishing this value. However, its good hygrothermal
behaviour and its very low embodied energy already make it a real competitive and marketable solution for
t
ip
the retrofitting of existing buildings. Future work is necessary in order to evaluate the decay of the
cr
NOMENCLATURE
us
e24 Wh/m2 daily energy
eq W/mC equivalent thermal conductivity
W/mC thermal conductivity
q
Q
W/m2
W
specific heat flux
heat flux
an
s m thickness
M
ts C surface temperature difference
2
U* W/m C equivalent thermal transmittance
ed
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The research was developed in the framework of the POLIGHT project SI2 Sistemi isolanti innovativi,
pt
funded by the Regione Piemonte. The project was developed in co-operation with DAD_Politecnico di
ce
Torino, VIMARK s.r.l., AGRINDUSTRIA s.n.c., CLUSTER s.r.l., ARTI E MESTIERI and ATC Torino-
REFERENCES
[1] Strategia Energetica Nazionale: per unenergia pi competitiva e sostenibile, marzo 2013, approved by
DM 8 march 2013.
[2] ISTAT 2013. Rapporto Bes. Il benessere equo e sostenibile in Italia, capitolo 09, Il paesaggio e
[3] A. Annoni, Scienza ed arte del restauro architettonico. Idee ed esempi, Edizioni Artistiche Framar,
Page 9 of 24
[4] K. Fabbri, Energy incidence of historic building: Leaving no stone unturned, Journal of Cultural
insulation alternatives of historic brick buildings in Baltic Sea Region, Energy and Buildings, 78 (2014) 35-
42.
[6] F. Ascione, F. De Rossi, G.P. Vanoli, Energy retrofit of historical buildings: theoretical and experimental
t
ip
investigations for the modelling of reliable performance scenarios. Energy and buildings, 43 (2011) 1925-
1936.
cr
[7] L. M. Silva, R. A. Ribeiro, J. A. Labrincha, V. M. Ferreira,. Role of lightweight fillers on the properties
us
of a mixed-binder mortar. Cement & Concrete Composites, 32 (2010) 19-24.
[8] EN 459-1. 2010 - Building lime. Part 1: Definitions, specifications and conformity criteria.
an
[9] ISO 14040. 2006 - Environmental management - Life cycle assessment - Principles and framework.
[10] EN 12667. 2001 - Thermal performance of building materials and products - Determination of thermal
M
resistance by means of guarded hot plate and heat flow meter methods - Products of high and medium
thermal resistance.
ed
[11] ASTM C518. 1991. Test Method for Steady-State Heat Flux Measurements and Thermal Transmission
[13] F. Favoino, M. Perino, V. Serra, Improving thermal performance of plasters by means of recycled and
ce
phase change materials. Proceedings, in: Healthy Buildings 2012, Brisbane (AU), 8 - 12 July 2012, 1-2.
Ac
[14] ISO 9869. 1994. Thermal insulation - Building elements - In-situ measurement of thermal resistance and
thermal transmittance.
Page 10 of 24
Table(s) with Caption(s)
t
ip
cr
Table 2, Samples of VGT_04 specification
Name Time of Density Sample size Sample
us
drying thickness
[h] [kg/m3] [mm] [mm]
Sample A 0 507 600x600 100
SampleA dry 48 496 600x600 100
Sample B
SampleB dry
0
48
402
400
an
300x300
300x300
50
50
M
Table 3. Sample VGT_04 A and VGT_04 B thermal equivalent conductivity results for t=20C
ed
Sample A Sample B
taverage eq eq.dry eq eq.dry
[C] [W/(mK)] [W/(mK)] [W/(mK)] [W/(mK)] [%]
pt
Page 11 of 24
List of Figure Captions
Figure 1. a) Evaluation of the possible thickness for thermal insulating plaster applications (left)
Figure 2. a) Thermal plaster sample (left), b) Experimental apparatus: hot plate (right)
Figure 3. Experimental result: thermal conductivity vs average temperature of the plates for samples A and B
t
of VGT 04, for both humid and dry conditions, and a reference cement thermal plaster
ip
Figure 4, Piazza Carlina Turin, ex Albergo di Virt during the refurbishment
cr
Figure 5. a) Tested wall with the thermal plaster, b) Reference tested wall
Figure 6. Infrared images: test room with the thermal insulating plaster VGT_04 (upper), and the bare wall of
us
the reference test room (lower)
an
Figure 7. Daily energy through the reference wall and the thermal insulating plaster wall
Figure 8. Equivalent thermal transmittance of the tested wall with thermal plaster VGT_04 (b)
M
ed
pt
ce
Ac
Page 12 of 24
1a
Ac
ce
pt
ed
M
an
us
cr
i
Page 13 of 24
1b
Ac
ce
pt
ed
M
an
us
cr
i
Page 14 of 24
2a
Ac
ce
pte
d
M
an
us
cr
ip
t
Page 15 of 24
2b
Ac
ce
pte
d
M
an
us
cr
ip
t
Page 16 of 24
3
Ac
ce
pt
ed
M
an
us
cr
i
Page 17 of 24
4
Ac
ce
pt
ed
M
an
us
cr
i
Page 18 of 24
5a
Ac
ce
pte
d
M
an
us
cr
ip
t
Page 19 of 24
5b
Ac
ce
pt
ed
M
an
us
cr
i
Page 20 of 24
6
Ac
ce
pt
ed
M
an
us
cr
i
Page 21 of 24
7
Ac
ce
pt
ed
M
an
us
cr
i
Page 22 of 24
8
Ac
ce
pt
ed
M
an
us
cr
i
Page 23 of 24
*Highlights (for review)
- A new thermal insulating plaster vegetal based is investigated in the laboratory and infield on a real
historic building
- Vegetal aggregate materials lend higher mechanical properties to the plaster and allows higher layer
thicknesses
- The low thermal conductivity of the new material led to a significant reduction in the energy that
t
ip
crosses the wall
cr
us
an
M
ed
pt
ce
Ac
Page 24 of 24