Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Change
By Sosie Yorki
Yorki 2
Sosie Yorki
Greene
Capstone
16 January 2017
I. Introduction
Wyoming last summer, I conducted research with a neuroscience professor about Huntingtons
disease. I became fascinated with the human brain and its network of neurons, so I wanted to
center my capstone project on neurological diseases. I didnt pinpoint the diseases to focus on
until I found my mentor, Krista Qualmann, who is a genetic counselor at Memorial Hermann.
She introduced me to the disease she specializes in, Charcot-Marie-Tooth (CMT), which
degrades patients hands, feet, and leg muscles. I decided to make it a topic for my capstone
project because although 2.8 million people worldwide are diagnosed with CMT, its still widely
unknown.1 When patients receive their diagnosis, they are lost and confused. In addition, the
disease doesnt receive enough funding for research and as a result, there still isnt a drug or cure
for CMT. Because CMT mainly affects nerves in the lower body, making CMT my only topic
would make me miss out on the research I originally wanted to do about neuroscience.
Therefore, I also chose to look at Alzheimers disease (AD), which affects the mental health of
5.4 million senior citizens in America alone.2 Its prevalent, debilitating to patients, and
mysterious in the way it works. Research on AD gives me further insight on how the human
Yorki 3
brain and nerves interact with one another, and research on CMT teaches me how the nervous
The frequency, and thus the burden, of AD and CMT disease will increase as the worlds
population does. The burden of these diseases does not only rest on the patient, but individuals
close to the patient and a nation as a whole. On an individual level, Alzheimers and CMT
obstruct a patient from performing daily tasks, which in turn puts stress on the loved ones taking
care of him, who are informal caregivers. This stress can lead to depression and deterioration of
health for the informal caregivers as they worry about the patient.3 On a national level, federal
healthcare programs spend enormous amounts of money assisting those who cant help
themselves. For example, in 2011, Medicare spent $11 billion on helping those with Alzheimers
pay for their medical expenses.4 While there is not as much research about CMT spending, its
known that a notable amount of social security disability benefits goes towards CMT patients.5
Without a cure for these diseases, patients have no other option than to find a way to afford
costly treatment options and thus put a drain on federal assistance programs. But the amount of
money spent on victims of CMT and AD through Medicare and social security benefits does not
reflect the total amount of economic loss by these diseases. Patients usually end up losing their
jobs and informal caretakers could work less hours, work less productively, take unpaid leaves of
absence, or retire early.6 These possible contributors to the economy cannot work to their full
potential and end up making less money for themselves and putting less money in the nations
circulation.
The burden of CMT and AD arent only present in America, but in other less developed
countries (LDCs) as well. The rate of AD is increasing the fastest in LDCs, but with lower
quality of doctor training, little to no equal access to medical care, and a focus on communicable
Yorki 4
and neonatal diseases, AD patients do not receive enough care to improve or maintain their
condition.7 In developed countries, doctors are better aware of AD, diagnose it earlier, and are
more likely to meet with their patients regularly. 7 This same pattern can be assumed with CMT,
where patients have better access to treatment in more developed countries than LDCs. Patients,
regardless of income, deserve to have quality treatment to make their AD or CMT more
Association) and Alzheimers Association, would help equalize access to a better life for CMT
We, as global citizens, must accept and support the research community by donating to
Alzheimers and CMT organizations that fund their research. We must not be afraid of scientific
advancements and instead open our minds to new possible cures, no matter how seemingly
diseases, or diseases that break down neurons, and to pressure the scientific community into
To perform tasks such as walking, blinking, and lifting, our brain communicates with our
muscles via messenger carriers called nerve cells, or neurons. When we decide we want to do
something, our brain sends out a message in the form of electrical bursts or molecules called
neurotransmitters. Nerve cells receive the message and send out their own (called a nerve
impulse) to the muscles involved in the action we want to perform. For example, if one wants to
walk across a room, his brain will send a message, which can be neurotransmitters or bursts of
Yorki 5
electricity, out to the nearest neuron. That neuron will pass the message along to other neurons in
Neurons are all connected to one another in long chains from the brain to every muscle.
Each neuron has long, fingerlike extensions called axons that reach out to the neighboring
neuron, and there are tiny spaces called synapses between the axon and neighbor. It looks like a
line of people standing side to side with their arms out. Each person is almost holding hands with
the person next to him, but there is space between adjacent peoples fingers. This space is where
neurons release and receive neurotransmitters. Synapses are necessary for neurons to function
properly, because if a neuron cant release neurotransmitters, it cant perform its function.
Neurons also need their outer covering, called the myelin sheath, to protect the cell.
The spontaneous and damaging breakdown of neurons seen in CMT and AD is called
neurodegeneration. Neurodegenerative diseases can affect nerves in the brain, causing decreased
mental capacity, or throughout muscles in the body, causing loss of function. CMT and AD are
caused by neurodegeneration, but how neurodegeneration occurs in each disease causes the
different symptoms.
Alzheimers
Alzheimers is caused by a deformation in a protein called tau and blockages called amyloid
plaques. To understand how tau works, we must discuss neurofibrils. Neurofibrils are small
fibers that act like the skeleton of the neuron. They are train tracks for nerve impulses, or
electrical messages, to travel on. The tau protein makes sure that the neurofibrils lie in parallel,
Yorki 6
orderly rows so it can function properly. In Alzheimers, the tau protein is deformed and forms
tangles with the neurofibrils. Amyloid plaques, or clusters of a protein called amyloid, are
another cause of Alzheimers.8 These plaques exist in synapses and block the space neurons need
CMT
Neurodegeneration in CMT happens in neurons that cause movement in the hands, feet,
and legs. There are plenty of conditions that induce neurodegeneration, but one that is of special
that undergo chemical processes to provide neurons with the energy needed to function. CMT
patients contain a genetic mutation in a gene called Mfn2 that makes mitochondria smaller than
normal and forces the organelle to produce less energy. Without enough energy to keep itself
alive, the neuron will break down.8 Neurons in CMT and AD break down in, and thus affect,
Alzheimers
Alzheimers patients can experience both physical and mental changes. Mental symptoms
include delusions, hallucinations, agitation, anxiety, and memory loss, because the neurons in the
frontal cortical brain lobe and anterior cingulate cortex that support emotional capability
phenomenon called mental age regression, which means that the patient ages backwards
mentally.10 For example, if one day an 80 year old patient no longer recognizes the 40 year old
daughter who has been taking care of him, its because he thinks he is at an age where his
Yorki 7
daughter was younger than 40. The patient may think he is 50 years old, which is when his
daughter was only 10. The patient wont recognize the daughter at the present time, but if one
shows him pictures of his daughter when she was 10, he will remember her and may wonder
gait, and muscle rigidity.11 Although the exact brain region where these functions are controlled
and how they are affected by AD is unknown, physical symptoms, or motor signs, predict how
severe ones AD will be. Patients with motor signs are more likely to be institutionalized and
require pricier treatments, but little correlation has been seen between motor signs and cognitive
CMT
Oxford University found that patients with the most common subtype of CMT, CMT1A,
experience muscle weakness almost exclusively in muscles near the feet and that the weakness
progresses from muscles that straighten limbs to muscles that bend at the joints. This data
suggests that CMT1A degenerates in a length-dependent pattern where only long neurons present
in the feet and legs are affected.13 The same group also claims that loss of sensitivity could be
explained by the degeneration of sensory axons, or the extensions of neurons that make
organisms feel pain.13 Patients of CMT tend to experience sleep apnea, a condition where ones
breathing is interrupted while asleep, and depression, but scientists still dont know why.14 These
two side effects could result from the drastic change in lifestyle one experiences when he
develops CMT or from neurological impairment, but less data supports the latter.14
Yorki 8
Symptoms of CMT and AD can worsen if the patient has risk factors, which are the
conditions that increase ones risk of contracting a disease. Right now, doctors just use risk
factors to determine if someone will get a disease, but this knowledge about risk factors can be
expanded to improving the current inefficient diagnosis system for CMT and Alzheimers.
Alzheimers
Risk factors for Alzheimers include heart and brain conditions that are common among
middle-aged adults. Hypertension is a risk factor because it impairs blood flow and directly
brain injury, alcoholism, and smoking also increase ones risk of developing AD because these
conditions decrease mental and brain health. 16 On the surface, risk factors may seem like they
dont play a huge role in disease onset, but its projected that if there was 10%-25% less people
who had one of the seven risk factors for AD common in middle-aged adults (diabetes,
inactivity), there would be 17.2 million less cases in the world.17 ADs risk factors explain why
the disease is so prominent in America since there are high rates of depression, hypertension,
Senior citizens with Alzheimers usually are not diagnosed in time for treatment to improve
their quality of life. Since the symptoms of AD are similar to those of Parkinsons,
frontotemporal dementia, Huntingtons, and other forms of dementias, the only real defining
characteristic of the disease is the presence of malfunctioning tau proteins and amyloid plaques
in the brain.18 Therefore, doctors either rely on brain imaging and neurological, cognitive, and
Yorki 9
neuropsychological tests (which is only around 85% accurate), or wait until the patient reaches a
somewhat defining characteristic of the disease, dementia, to diagnose it. 19,20,21 At this point,
treatment is useless since patients have already faced severe memory loss and are dependent on a
caretaker. Doctors should be able to accurately diagnose AD once earlier symptoms, such as a
decline in memory and psychosis, arise, but currently cant because early symptoms can be
confused with other diseases. ADs early symptoms can be recognized by requiring 50 year-old
patients with two or more risk factors (as determined by ones doctor) to take tests that measure
attention, memory, and language skills once every six months until decreased ability starts to
show.
CMT
CMTs risk factors come from defects in the peripheral nervous system, or the network of
nerves throughout the body, excluding those in the brain. Certain vitamin deficiencies can
damage nerves and prevent muscles from functioning properly. For example, lack of vitamin
B12, which is a building block for the myelin sheath, can degrade the outer layer of neurons.22
Vitamin B6 and E deficiency can cause the symptoms of CMT seen in the feet, such as
numbness, high arches, and burning pain.22 People who stray from a recommended, healthy diet
are at risk for vitamin deficiency. Supplements are affordable and easily accessible in drug
stores, so doctors should suggest for patients with CMT in their family history to take them.
Vitamin deficiency alone is not an indicator of CMT, but it can still be considered by doctors
and should be tested before diagnosing patients. The symptoms of CMT are similar to those of
multiple muscular disorders, so doctors can use inexpensive urine tests to see if patients have
both the vitamin deficiencies and the symptoms before narrowing the diagnosis down to CMT. If
patients show symptoms of a muscular disorder without vitamin E, B12, or B6 deficiencies, then
Yorki 10
doctors can assume they dont have CMT. This method is cheaper and faster than the current
method of diagnosis. Urine test results come back to the patient in three days maximum, but
genetic tests and nerve biopsies (the extraction a nerve for analysis to see if it shows a pattern of
degradation specific to CMT),23 which are the current tests doctors order for possible CMT
patients, take about a month for the results and data analysis to be processed. Urine tests are also
cheaper as they can be bought in drug stores, while nerve biopsies and genetic testing can cost
Not only is the method for diagnosis of CMT and AD being improving, but the treatments
are as well. To develop a new drug or treatment, scientists synthesize it in their lab, test it on
animals numerous times, and finally test it on humans to prove it is safe. This extensive process
prevents many drugs from reaching pharmacies, and even when a new drug is approved, it could
still be proven ineffective years later. CMT and AD currently have approved treatments but not
cures.
Alzheimers
There are two classes of drugs that are currently on the market to treat Alzheimers:
memantine and cholinesterase inhibitors. Memantine blocks neurons receptors and prevents
them from receiving glutamate, a neurotransmitter that, when overproduced, can overexcite
neurons, waste their energy, and cause them to degenerate. Memantine has proven to slow
dementia and, when combined with other drugs such as donepezil, maintain cognition. In
Yorki 11
addition, AD patients find memantine tolerable and its side effects (which are headaches,
Cholinesterase inhibitors (ChE-Is) can come in the form of a pill, syrup, or patch. They work
however, the improvement doesnt last for long. As AD progresses, neurons produce less of
progresses to a point where the amount of acetylcholinesterase produced is not enough to keep
the patients cognition at a healthy level. 25 Patients find the side effects of ChE-Is, which include
nausea, diarrhea, vomiting, and anorexia, less tolerable than those of memantine. 26 Memnatine is
Outside of drugs, caregiving can be considered a form of treatment because caregivers soothe
patients and make their AD more tolerable. The U.S currently employs a nursing home system
for AD patients, but residents of the home lack one-on-one care, and nursing homes are costly.
Therefore, some people have turned to seeking care in other countries such as Thailand, where
professional caregiving is cheaper and culture mandates that nursing homes use one-on-one
methods to help the patient.27 Buddhism, which is prominent in Thailand, emphasizes the
importance of karma, which implies that if ones elder falls ill, its because he and his elders
deeds in their past lives have caused the elder to fall ill and him to become his caregiver.26
Because of these Buddhist beliefs, Thai caregivers could take their job more seriously as it is
seen as a spiritual obligation instead of a way to make a living. Caregiving needs to be reformed
in the U.S because it is something that will always be needed, even if better treatments are found.
The U.S should try to improve their nursing home system by employing more nurses and giving
Yorki 12
incentives for companies to pay them more in order to give the ultimate care to AD patients and
reassurance to informal caregivers that their loved one will get quality care.
CMT
Treatments for CMT include rehabilitation, corrective surgery, orthopedic braces, exercise,
and pain and fatigue management, which treat symptoms and are not perfect remedies. In
rehabilitation, physical therapy has high risks for patient injury and could worsen muscle
weakness if the patient is overworked.28 Corrective surgery normalizes high-arched feet, hand
deformities, and scoliosis,28 but surgery could go wrong and does not work for all patients. When
I conducted field work with a genetic counselor, I was able to consult with patients and meet one
whose surgical procedure went wrong. Her surgery was supposed to lower the arch in her foot,
but her arch ended up heightening and she began experiencing more pain than before. Patients
that do not want to undergo surgery turn to ankle-foot orthoses, which help patients control their
foot better and normalize their gait, and crutches, which prevent them from falling. If the patient
is experiencing weakness in their arms or hands, they may do exercises that involve stretching
rubber bands and stretching putty to strengthen their forearm and fingers. For any patient
experiencing pain and fatigue, doctors prescribe drugs specialized for neuropathy-related
symptoms.29
An interesting, natural form of treatment for CMT, called Ayurvedic treatment, can be found
in India. In a phone call interview with Krista Qualmann, M.S. (January 2017), I learned that this
treatment involves taking various herbs, such as Ashwagandha (which stimulates nerve activity)
and Boswellia (which can decrease inflammation in the feet), in a pill form. Although these
treatments are not popular in the American market, they can viewed as examples by the scientific
Yorki 13
community for possible drugs that can be developed to treat CMT. Future treatments are looking
Alzheimers
Scientists are looking into microtubule (MT) stabilizing agents as a cure for Alzheimers. In
AD, deformities in the tau protein tangle up microtubules, which are the train tracks for
neurotransmitters. They are alongside neurofibrils and a part of the neurons skeleton. MT-
stabilizing agents promote order in microtubules by removing tau from or changing the structure
of MTs. Since MT-stabilizing agents come from natural sources such as tree sap and bacteria,
they are not likely to cause harsh side effects and could prevent or cure AD.29 Scientists struggle
when trying to make MT-stabilizing agents into drugs because they must ensure the treatment
only targets front lobe neurons. In addition, scientists have to experiment with what stage of AD
is most effective to start prescribing MT-stabilizing drugs. After MT-stabilizing agents are tested
on humans and proven safe, it will still face issues with getting approval from the general public
Genetic modification is another type of possible controversial treatment being looked at for
Alzheimers. By changing the mutations in our genetic code that cause us to develop AD,
scientists can essentially eliminate AD for all those who can afford it. In Europe, genetic
modification is undergoing intense research, and three years ago, 11 new locations in our DNA
where mutations determine Alzheimers disease have been found. 30 This approach towards
CMT
A future cure for CMT could be gene therapy, which is the removal or suppression of the
problematic mutation that causes the disease. This possible treatment is being heavily researched
in the U.S., Italy, and Japan, where they have the money for such costly experiments.28,31 It
sounds foolproof, since CMT is caused by mutations, but getting the foreign genes past the
bodys immune system and the chance of adversely inducing other genetic diseases are obstacles
to the development of gene therapy. 28 Current advancements in technology today allow for gene
therapy to become a reality, but the modification of DNA raises questions about ethics.
Therefore, this new therapy receives little support from the public and the Food and Drug
Although gene therapy is of huge controversy, drugs are not. Pharnex, a pharmacy company
in France, is testing a combination of three drugs (baclofen, naltrexone, and sorbitol) that has
shown to increase myelination, or the process of building the outer protective layer of neurons
that degenerate in CMT1A. The combination of the drugs, called PXT-3003, does this by
suppressing the pmp-22 gene, which contains the mutation that onsets demyelination. PXT-3003
could be the future of possible cures for CMT as it showed no side effects in lab mice and has
proven to be the most promising potential treatment. 32 For now, the future for PXT-3003 will be
VIII. Conclusion
Even though the U.S is at the global forefront of research, there is still a great need for
collaboration among research institutions around the world. Due to cultural differences and
Yorki 15
access to different resources, scientists of every country approach treatments and research
differently. Although a country may not be as advanced in medical treatment as the U.S. and
other wealthy countries, it still has a valuable perspective to offer towards advancing research.
promote action on dementia [, or Alzheimers, and CMT] and address the challenges posed by
[these diseases] and [their] impacts. No single country, sector or organization can tackle this
cultures, the U.S can advance CMT and AD research even further and come up with a cure
within the next few decades. But before the U.S. collaborates with other countries, we must gain
With basic knowledge of science, some of the general public sees scientific research as
playing God and are fearful towards it. With support for new scientific breakthroughs, the
people will show desire for change and can influence the FDA to approve new treatments and
cures. Although the future of treatments for CMT and Alzheimers, such as gene therapy, may
seem scary, change must be welcomed in order to advance society. People must vocalize their
support, spread it to others, and show that that they arent afraid.
Support for the scientific community begins with awareness and can be continued with
constant donations. With increased awareness, more patients will be concerned about CMT, and
doctors will be coerced to learn about and specialize in the disease. More pressure will be placed
on scientists to find a cure and donations to charities such as the CMT Association and
References
1. What is CMT? Charcot-Marie-Tooth Association Web site.
2. 2016 Alzheimers Disease Facts and Figures. Alzheimers Association Web site.
http://psychsocgerontology.oxfordjournals.org/content/55/1/S2.full.pdf.
4. Hurd MD, Martorell P, Delavande A, Mullen KJ, Langa KM. Monetary Costs of
Dementia in the United States. The New England Journal of Medicine. 2013; 368:
5. Carter GT, Han JJ, Abresch RT, Jensen MP. The Importance of Assessing Quality of
6. Neal MB, Wagner DL. Working Caregivers: Issues, Challenges, and Opportunities
http://archives.pdx.edu/ds/psu/15447.
7. Alzheimers Disease International. World Alzheimer Report 2015: The Global Impact
of Dementia. http://www.worldalzreport2015.org/downloads/world-alzheimer-report-
10.1016/j.tcb.2012.10.006.
10. Lokko HM, Stern TA. Regression: Diagnosis, Evaluation, and Management. The
10.4088/PCC.14f01761.
Correlation with The First Symptom. American Journal of Alzheimers Disease and
12. Scarmeas N, Albert M, Brandt J, et al. Motor signs predict poor outcomes in
10.1212/01.WNL.0000162054.15428.E9.
13. Krajewski, KM, Lewis, RA, Fuerst, Dr, et al. Neurological Dysfunction and Axonal
Degeneration in CharcotMarieTooth Disease Type 1A. Brain. 2000; 123 (7): 1516-
Psychiatric Indicators and Quality of Life: A Systematic Review. ASN Neuro. 2014;
15. Kivipelto M, Helkala EL, Laakso MP, et al. Midlife Vascular Risk Factors and
doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.322.7300.1447.
Alzheimers Disease and Dementia. Journal of Internal Medicine. 2014; 275(3): 229-
17. Barnes DE, Yaffe K. The Projected Impact of Risk Factor Reduction on Alzheimers
10.1016/S1474-4422(11)70072-2.
18. Dementia and Related Disorders. Alzheimers Community Care Web site.
19. Albert MS, DeKosky ST, Dickson D, et al. The Diagnosis of Mild Cognitive
for Alzheimers Disease. Alzheimers & Dementia. 2011; 7(3): 270-279. doi:
10.1016/j.jalz.2011.03.008.
5374.2012.32.006.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1176/ajp.157.1.4.
doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/00019442-200303000-00004.
011-0115-z.
28. Ballatore C, Brunden K, Huryn DM, Trojanowski JQ, Lee V, Smith AB. Microtubule
http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/104365960001100302.
31. Maeda MH, Mitsui J, Soong BW, et al. Increased gene dosage of myelin protein zero
10.1002/ana.22658.
32. Ekins S, Litterman NK, Arnold RJG, et al. A brief review of Charcot-Marie-Tooth
10.12688/f1000research.6160.1