Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
1
Department of Pharmacy, The
SUMMARY
Review criteria Alfred Hospital, Melbourne,
Background: Antihypertensive medicines are to known to cause diverse distur- We undertook a systematic review of electronic Vic., Australia
2
Monash Alfred Psychiatric
bances to electrolyte homeostasis; however, their potential to affect zinc is less databases and collected all English language
Research Centre, Melbourne,
well known. The primary aim was to explore whether antihypertensive medicines articles, which reported on results from clinical
Vic., Australia
studies, which were relevant to meeting the aims 3
have the potential to affect zinc status. Methods: A review of electronic databases Cardiothoracic Research Unit,
of the review. We only included studies when the Department of Surgery, Monash
was undertaken. Full-length English language articles describing clinical trials
full-length article was available so that important University, Melbourne, Vic.,
involving antihypertensive medicines and reporting on zinc measurements were details, such as number of study participants, Australia
reviewed. Results: Eight eligible studies were identified which involved the use of medicines used, time frames for use and zinc
ACE inhibitors, thiazide diuretics, beta blockers, or ARB drugs of which five measures were clearly reported. Correspondence to:
included a control group Studies used urinary zinc excretion, plasma zinc levels or Lesley Braun,
Message for the clinic Pharmacy Department, Alfred
erythrocyte zinc as key measures of zinc status. Studies reported increased urinary Hospital, Commercial Road,
The take home message for clinicians is that
zinc losses for captopril (from 50 mg day), enalapril (20 mg day), losartan current evidence suggests that patients using ACE Melbourne, Vic., 3004,
(50 mg day), losartan (50 mg day) together with hydrochlorothiazide inhibitors, ARBs and thiazides long-term could be Australia
(12.5 mg day), captopril (75 mg day) together with frusemide (40 mg day) and Tel.: +61 3 9076 2408
at risk of low zinc. Clinicians should consider the
Fax: +61 3 9076 3407
stand-alone hydrochlorothiazide (25 mg day). Serum levels of zinc decreased with possibility of low zinc nutriture in patients with
Email: l.braun@alfred.org.au
captopril (50150 mg day), verapamil (240 mg day), atenolol (50150 mg day) poor dietary intakes, the elderly people and
and the combination of losartan (50 mg day) and hydrochlorothiazide diabetic patient who has taken these medications Disclosures
(12.5 mg day), eryrthrocyte levels decreased with use of valsartan (80 mg day) long-term. A trial of zinc supplements in suspected LB and FR have received
cases of low zinc is a safe option. research funding from
and in some studies for captopril, but not for metoprolol (100 mg day), atenolol nutraceutical companies
(50150 mg day), verapamil (240 mg day), doxazosin (4 mg day) or amlodipine however the latter were not
10 mg day). Major limitations were that most studies were small and did not involved in any aspect of this
report on dietary zinc intake. Conclusion: The available evidence suggests that review.
deficiency, but also those living in relatively affluent blockers (metoprolol, atenolol). The most commonly
countries who rarely consume foods rich in bioavail- used measures were urinary zinc excretion and
able zinc and consume foods that are rich in bio- plasma zinc levels with some studies reporting on
availability inhibitors, chiefly phytates (4) erythrocyte zinc levels. Typically, studies involved
Hypertension is prevalent in Western societies and only a small number of participants; however, five
most commonly treated with antihypertensive medi- studies included an untreated control group adding
cines that are prescribed long-term. Resistant hyper- more rigour to their findings. Several intervention
tension has been estimated to make up 2030% of studies were also identified thereby enabling compar-
those diagnosed with hypertension and is commonly isons between baseline and after treatment effects. Of
treated with combination therapy, which may prove all the relevant studies identified, only one consid-
more effective for some patients, but also raises the ered the effects of dietary zinc intake.
risk of adverse consequences (5). It is known that
antihypertensive medicines cause diverse disturbances Thiazide diuretics
to electrolyte homeostasis and drug-induced electro- Thiazide diuretics are widely used for volume reduc-
lyte alterations are relatively common with the use of tion and hypertension and have been shown to
diuretics, angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE) induce zincuria in two small pilot studies (8,9).
inhibitors and angiotensin 2 receptor blockers According to one study, a significant 60% increase in
(ARBs) (6). 24-h zinc excretion was observed (8). A larger study
The possibility that long-term use of antihyperten- conducted by Khedun et al. (1995) evaluated serum
sive medicines affect zinc pharmacokinetics is of partic- zinc in 39 middle aged hypertensive men who had
ular relevance for patients with conditions associated taken hydrochlorothiazide for at least 6 months and
with disturbances of zinc homeostasis, such as diabetes, compared it to 27 unmedicated, healthy middle aged
liver cirrhosis, bowel diseases and impaired immune controls (10). Serum zinc levels were shown to be
function and for those people at risk inadequate dietary significantly lower in 20 of the treated patients.
zinc intakes and more likely to use combination ther-
apy, such as the elderly people (7). Beta blockers
The primary aim of this systematic review was to Two studies have investigated the effects of beta-
explore whether commonly prescribed antihyperten- blocker usage on zinc (11,12). One study found no
sive medicines have the potential to affect zinc sta- significant effects on plasma or erythrocyte zinc levels
tus. for metoprolol (100 mg day) taken for 3 months
when compared with a healthy, untreated group used
as controls (11). In contrast, another study found a
Methods
significant decrease in serum zinc after 3 months and
In this review, we searched MEDLINE and Science again after 6 months of atenolol (50150 mg day)
Direct for relevant clinical studies using the keywords use by people with mild or moderate essential hyper-
zinc and diuretic, thiazide, beta-blocker, beta tension, but no change in erythrocyte zinc levels
receptor antagonist, angiotensin converting enzyme (12). In this study, patients were also put on a modi-
inhibitor, ACE inhibitor, angiotensin receptor fied diet to alter their lipid profile, which was suc-
inhibitor, ARB calcium channel blocker and the cessful after 6 months. Unfortunately, dietary zinc
disease-specific terms hypertension and blood pres- intakes were not compared before or after the test
sure, Reference lists of articles reviewed were system- period, hence, the contribution of a modified diet
atically examined for further relevant studies. Only cannot be ruled out.
full-text articles limited to the English language and
studies that involved adult cohorts taking antihyper- Calcium channel blockers
tensive medicines were considered. The effect of 3 months treatment with amlodipine
(10 mg daily) on plasma and erythrocyte zinc was
tested in 20 hypertensive volunteers and compared
Results
with 51 healthy, untreated controls (11). After the
Eight clinical studies met the inclusion criteria for test period, no significant changes were seen for
this systematic review (Table 1). Studies had been either plasma or erythrocyte zinc measures when
conducted since the 1980s involving various antihy- compared with the untreated group.
pertensive agents, including thiazide diuretics, fru-
semide, ACE inhibitors (mainly captopril, but also ACE inhibitors
enalapril, perindopril), losartan and valsartan, the Abu-Hamdan et al. (1988) measured plasma zinc lev-
calcium channel blocker amlodipine and several beta els and urinary zinc excretion in 31 hypertensive
Patient Antihypertensive
Clinical trial N characteristics drug therapy Treatment period Zinc measures and results ( total range) Other relevant findings
Koren-Michowitz 17 Mild-to-moderate Losartan (50 mg day) 4 weeks on sole Urinary Zn creatinine ratio: There was a significant correlation
et al. (2005) (18) hypertensive patients with Losartan (50 mg day) therapy Treatment with losartan resulted in a significant increase between baseline serum Zn levels and
Patient Antihypertensive
Clinical trial N characteristics drug therapy Treatment period Zinc measures and results ( total range) Other relevant findings
Golik et al. 44 Hypertensive Captopril (75 mg day) > 3 months Urinary zinc excretion:
(1990) (17) patients (n = 36) Hydrochlorothiazide captopril, hydrochlorothiazide, combination captopril
and healthy (25 mg day) and hydrochlorothiazide resulted in significantly greater
control group Captopril (75 mg day) zincuria than controls and untreated hypertensives
(n = 8) and hydrochlorothiazide Controls vs captopril vs hydrochlorothiazide vs captopril
(25 mg day) and hydrochlorothiazide vs untreated hypertensives
Captopril (75 mg day) 473 vs 1550 vs 1196 vs 1230 vs 404 (lg 24 h)
and frusemide Serum zinc:
(40 mg day) No significant differences between groups
Un treated hypertensive
controls
Pharmaco-nutrient interactions
Healthy controls
Golik et al. 52 Hypertensive Captopril 6 months Serum zinc: *Drug doses not reported
(1998) (11) patients (n = 42) Enalapril Remained unchanged from baseline for all three groups
and healthy Unmedicated healthy 24 h urinary zinc excretion:
controls (n = 10) controls A significant increase was observed for captopril compared
to baseline (1244 154 lg 24 h vs 461 32
(p < 0.001)
No significant change for enalapril treatment
Intracellular zinc:
Captopril treatment resulted in a significant decrease from
5.8 2.4 to 3.9 1.2 nmol mg protein (p < 0.01)
Enalapril treatment resulted in a significant decrease from
5.3 2.5 to 4.1 2.3 nmol mg protein (p = 0.04)
No significant changes for controls
Baykal et al. 153 Hypertensive Valsartan (80 mg day) 3 months Intra-erythrocyte zinc (lg dl):
(2003) (13) patients (n = 102) Metoprolol Valsartan induced a significant decrease from 8.84 2.45
healthy controls (100 mg day) to 6.58 2.42 lg ml (p = 0.005)
(n = 51) Doxazosin (4 mg day) Metoprolol, doxazosin and amlodipine did not induce a
Amlodipine significant change to erythrocyte zinc
(10 mg day)
Trasobares 35 Heart failure Treatment: ACE 3660 h after Serum zinc (lg dl):
et al. (2007) (26) (n = 11) patients inhibitors and treatment Serum zinc levels were lower in the treated group
and healthy age frusemide further commenced compared to controls (67.27 vs 87.32) (p = 0.001)
matched controls treatment details Urinary zinc excretion:
(n = 24) not reported Urinary zinc excretion was significantly higher in the treated
group compared to controls (2.24 vs 0.21) (p < 0.001)
101.52 20.58
102.09 21.95
els (11).
Antihypertensive
50150 mg day
50150 mg day
Atenolol
controls (n = 30)
and healthy
Hypertensive
did not.
et al. (1995) (12)
several proposed mechanisms of action provide bio- zinc losses. Interestingly, thiazide diuretics also
logical plausibility to support the available findings. decrease glucose tolerance, unmasking latent diabetes
Clinical studies suggest that the interaction mecha- mellitus during therapy, a consequence, which may
nism has a pharmacokinetic basis and is most likely in part be mediated by zinc losses and is worthy of
caused by inhibition of kidney zinc reabsorption further investigation.
resulting in zincuria. Whether drug treatment also Beta blockers affect the regulation of circulation
affects zinc absorption from the gastrointestinal tract by reducing myocardial contractility and cardiac out-
or other routes of excretion, such as the faeces or put and as a consequence of treatment, also reduce
skin, remains unknown. the secretion of renin with a resulting fall in the level
ACE inhibitors are structurally classified as sul- of angiotensin II (24). Theoretically, decreased tubu-
phydryl containing ACE inhibitors, such as captopril, lar reabsorption of zinc may occur as a result of
di-carboxyl containing ACE- inhibitors, such as per- decreasing angiotensin II levels, much in the same
indopril, enalapril and ramipril and phosphonate way that ARBs and ACE inhibitors cause zincuria.
containing ACE- inhibitors, such as fosinopril, on To date, there are no published studies, which have
the basis of their binding with ACE. It is well estab- reported on the effect of beta blockers on urinary
lished that structural changes to a drug can affect its zinc excretion, hence, this theory remains untested.
activity, an observation which may explain the differ-
ences found for the effects of different ACE- inhibi- Clinical significance
tors on zinc. Drug-nutrient interactions are an important yet
It has been proposed that the sulphydryl group poorly appreciated category of adverse drug interac-
acts as a chelating agent and binds to bivalent metals tions. The effect of antihypertensive medicines on
such as zinc, thereby inducing zincuria (15). This magnesium, sodium, potassium and calcium are well
theory has been used to explain why captopril has a documented; however, the effect on zinc is less well
more potent effect on zinc levels, as measured by known (6).
changes in urine, serum and erythrocytes, when com- Although zinc is ubiquitous in food, low dietary
pared with enalapril whose effects are relatively less zinc intake is not uncommon as many food com-
impressive. Clinical studies comparing other di- pounds, such as phytate, oxalate, polyphenols and
carboxyl containing ACE inhibitors, such as ramipiril fibre can form complexes with zinc and inhibit its
and perindopril ,to sulphydryl containing ACE inhib- gastrointestinal absorption (20).
itors have not been conducted, hence, this theory Long-term use of some antihypertensive drugs
remains poorly tested. may result in reduced zinc nutriture which becomes
More recent research has identified that losartan significant in patients already at risk for zinc defi-
also induces urinary zinc losses confirming that the ciency such as those with Type 2 diabetes, alcoholism
presence of a sulphydryl group is not essential for and malabsorption syndromes, as well as renal insuf-
significant zincuria to ensue. The observation that ficiency (25). The elderly people may be at particular
valsartan induces decreased erythrocyte zinc levels risk of deficiency caused by their compromised renal
argues for a class effect possibly related to hemody- function, tendency to inadequate diets and use of
namic or metabolic effects of angiotensin II (18). multiple medications, which can affect appetite and
Zinc handling in the kidney involves both proxi- gastrointestinal function.
mal and distal reabsorption of filtered zinc, mecha- Zinc is such a critical element in human health that
nisms which are facilitated by the Na H antiporter. even a small deficiency can lead to significant adverse
Angiotensin II is a potent inducer of the Na H an- outcomes, such as anorexia, loss of appetite, smell and
tiporter in the proximal tubule, an effect which taste failure and compromised immune function (22)
increases sodium chloride and bicarbonate reabsorp- (See Table 2). Furthermore, concurrent zinc deficiency
tion. As such, another proposed mechanism for the can complicate the clinical features of several chronic
ACE-inhibitor ARB interaction with zinc suggests diseases, such as atherosclerosis, some malignancies,
that blocking angiotensin II causes decreased renal neurological disorders and age-related degenerative
Na H antiporter activity and a resultant decrease in diseases (21). Zinc deficiency complicates clinical con-
tubular reabsorption of zinc leading to zincuria sequences by adversely affecting immunological status,
(18). increasing oxidative stress and increasing generation
Thiazides are amongst the most commonly pre- of inflammatory cytokines, which can play an impor-
scribed diuretics used in hypertension treatment and tant causative role in disease. As such, it is important
are known to inhibit NaCl transport in the distal to assess zinc status in cases where low zinc status may
tubule. It is herein where zinc reabsorption is also affect clinical outcomes and potentially lead to frank
likely to be affected, resulting in increased urinary deficiency if left unaddressed.
Central nervous system Behavioural changes, anorexia, depression, psychosis, hypogeusia, hyposmia, night blindness, seizure disorder, impaired
cognitive performance
Integumentary changes Bullous, pustular lesions; keratotic lesions; rough skin; loss of scalp, facial and body hair; impaired wound healing
Gastrointestinal manifestations Diarrhoea, impaired nutrient digestion and absorption
Impaired growth and development Linear growth retardation; weight loss
Altered reproductive biology Oligospermia; hypogonadism and reduced potency; fetal teratogenesis
Impaired immunity Recurrent infections; reduced delayed cutaneous hypersensitivity
The most common test used for zinc status is Large prospective studies using several measures
measuring circulating concentrations of zinc (in and taking into account important confounders, such
plasma or serum) followed by whole-blood zinc. as dietary zinc, are necessary to truly examine the
Although measuring circulating zinc is a relatively influence of antihypertensive medicines on zinc status.
uncomplicated process, it only represents a very
small pool of zinc in the body, and is easily influ-
Conclusion
enced by other factors, such as stress and infection,
prolonged fasting and the oral contraceptive pill Good clinical care extends beyond mere diagnosis
(21). Erythrocyte levels can remain stable in the pres- and treatment of disease to the appreciation that
ence of deficiency and decline much later than nutrient deficiencies can accompany effective drug
serum, platelets or lymphocytes so are not the ideal therapy and result in adverse consequences if left un-
indicator of zinc status either. Confounding factors managed. The available evidence suggests that long-
should be considered when interpreting test results, term use of thiazide diuretics, ACE inhibitors and
such as increased zinc losses, as a result of recent angiotensin 2 receptor antagonists may reduce zinc
haemorrhagia or gastrointestinal wastage into stool. levels in many, but not all hypertensive patients. The
Because of the difficulties in determining an indi- evidence is most consistent for long-term captopril;
viduals zinc status, building a clinical picture sugges- however, there is research also suggesting decreased
tive of low zinc is useful (Table 2). It has been zinc for other ACE inhibitors, thiazide diuretics and
suggested that a therapeutic trial of zinc supplemen- ARBs (valsartan 80 mg day; losartan 50 mg day)
tation where low zinc is suspected is a reliable whereas the effects of beta blockers on zinc nutrition
approach to assessing the prevalence of zinc defi- remains uncertain.
ciency. People responding to supplementation with a The clinical significance of these drug-nutrient
functional improvement, such as improved appetite, interactions needs to be considered on a case-by-case
accelerated growth and improved physiological or basis and large-scale recommendations cannot yet be
cognitive performance could be classified retrospec- made until larger studies are performed which take
tively as zinc deficient (21). Ideally, detection and into account dietary zinc intakes and confirm current
treatment of suboptimal zinc levels before frank defi- findings. Theoretically, the significance of drug-
ciency develops is the optimal approach thereby pre- induced changes to zinc status is of most relevance
venting more serious consequences from developing. to people at greatest risk of deficiency such as the
elderly or diabetic patient and those patients taking
antihypertensive medicines long-term. It is also of
Limitations
most concern in those people where decreased zinc
The information included in this review results from levels will have the greatest clinical consequences.
an extensive literature search, however, was limited
to English language articles that were available in
Author contributions
their entirety. The limitations of the present data are
largely based on the small sample sizes of the studies LB developed the concept, undertook the review and
and lack of information about dietary zinc intakes drafted the article, FR undertook a critical revision of
and whether these changed during the test periods. the article and aided in writing the final manuscript.
10 Khedun SM, Naicker T, Maharaj B. Zinc, hydro- prospective open-label study. Am J Hypertens 2005;
References chlorothiazide and sexual dysfunction. Cent Afr J 18: 35863.
Med 1995; 41: 3125. 19 Lowe NM, Fekete K, Decsi T Methods of assess-
1 Little PJ, Bhattacharya R, Moreyra AE, Korichneva
11 Baykal Y, Yilmaz MI, Celik T et al. Effects of anti- ment of zinc status in humans: a systematic review.
IL. Zinc and cardiovascular disease. Nutrition 2010;
hypertensive agents, alpha receptor blockers, beta Am J Clin Nutr 2009; 89:2040S51S.
26: 10507.
blockers, angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors, 20 Groff J, Gropper S. Advanced Nutrition and Human
2 Braun L, Cohen M. Herbs and Natural Supplements
angiotensin receptor blockers and calcium channel Metabolism, 3rd edn. Belmont, USA: Wadsworth,
An Evidence Based Guide, 3rd edn. Sydney: Else-
blockers, on oxidative stress. J Hypertens 2003; 21: 1999.
vier; 2010.
120711. 21 Solomons N Zinc. In: Encyclopedia of Food Sciences
3 Hambidge KM, Miller LV, Westcott JE, Sheng X,
12 Rubio-Luengo MA, Maldonado-Martin A, Gil- and Nutrition, Benjamin Caballero, ed. 2nd edn.
Krebs NF. Zinc bioavailability and homeostasis. Am
Extremera B, Gonzalez-Gomez L, Luna del Castillo Elsevier, 2003: 627783.
J Clin Nutr 2010; 91: 1478S83S.
JD. Variations in magnesium and zinc in hyperten- 22 Tubek S. Role of zinc in regulation of arterial blood
4 Maret W, Sandstead HH. Zinc requirements and
sive patients receiving different treatments. Am J pressure and in the etiopathogenesis of arterial
the risks and benefits of zinc supplementation. J
Hypertens 1995; 8: 68995. hypertension. Biol Trace Elem Res 2007; 117: 3951.
Trace Elem Med Biol 2006; 20: 318.
13 Abu-Hamdan DK, Desai H, Sondheimer J, Felicetta 23 Tubek S. Increased absorption of zinc from alimen-
5 Calhoun DA, Jones D, Textor S et al. Resistant
J, Mahajan S, McDonald F. Taste acuity and zinc tary tract in primary arterial hypertension. Biol
hypertension: diagnosis, evaluation, and treatment:
metabolism in captopril-treated hypertensive male Trace Elem Res 2001; 83: 318.
A scientific statement from the American Heart
patients. Am J Hypertens 1988; 3: 303S8S. 24 Oates J, Brown N. Chapter 33: Antihypertensive
Association Professional Education Committee of
14 Golik A, Modai D, Averbukh Z et al. Zinc metabo- agents and the drug therapy of hypertension. In:
the Council for High Blood Pressure Research. Cir-
lism in patients treated with captopril versus ena- Hardman J, eds. Goodman and Gilmans The Phar-
culation 2008; 117: e51026.
lapril. Metabolism 1990; 39: 6657. macological Basis of Therapeutics, 10 edn. Sydney:
6 Liamis G, Milionis H, Elisaf M. Blood pressure
15 Golik A, Zaidenstein R, Dishi V et al. Effects of cap- McGraw-Hill, 2001: 883.
drug therapy and electrolyte disturbances. Int J Clin
topril and enalapril on zinc metabolism in hyperten- 25 Reyes AJ, Olhaberry JV, Leary WP, Lockett CJ, van
Pract 2008; 62: 157280.
sive patients. J Am Coll Nutr 1998; 17: 758. der Byl K. Urinary zinc excretion, diuretics, zinc
7 Jansen J, Karges W, Rink L. Zinc and diabetes
16 Golik A, Averbukh Z, Cohn M et al. Effect of deficiency and some side-effects of diuretics. S Afr
clinical links and molecular mechanisms. J Nutr
diuretics on captopril-induced urinary zinc excre- Med J 1983; 64: 93641.
Biochem 2009; 20: 399417.
tion. Eur J Clin Pharmacol 1990; 38: 35961. 26 Trasobares E, Corbaton A, Gonzalez-Estecha M
8 Wester PO. Urinary zinc excretion during treat-
17 Tubek S. Urinary zinc excretion is normalized in et al. Effects of angiotensin-converting enzyme inhi-
ment with different diuretics. Acta Med Scand 1980;
primary arterial hypertension after perindopril bitors (ACE i) on zinc metabolism in patients with
208: 20912.
treatment. Biol Trace Elem Res 2006; 114: 12733. heart failure. J Trace Elem Med Biol 2007; 21
9 Golik A, Modai D, Weissgarten J et al. Hydrochlo-
18 Koren-Michowitz M, Dishy V, Zaidenstein R et al. (Supp. 1): 5355.
rothiazide-amiloride causes excessive urinary zinc
The effect of losartan and losartan hydrochlorothi-
excretion. Clin Pharmacol Ther 1987; 42: 424.
azide fixed-combination on magnesium, zinc, and Paper received June 2012, accepted September 2012
nitric oxide metabolism in hypertensive patients: a