Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
throu
Core Banking
Systems Survey
Survey results 2008
Capgemini has conducted a comprehensive study of current trends in core banking and
the functionality of the major core banking systems available in the main financial markets
in the world.
This survey was written and compiled during the period from September to December
2007. The report is based on desk research and on a request for information sent out to
the leading core banking system vendors.
The authors selected the vendors and their products after consulting with Capgeminis
international Core Banking/Banking Packages network. The survey focused specifically
on core banking solutions for top-tier banks having a strong position in the important
financial markets in the world and offering the solution in more than one country.
The Core Banking Systems Survey 2008 is the latest in a series of banking systems
surveys. The Asset Management Systems Survey and the Treasury Systems Survey were
published in 2007. The previous Retail Banking Systems Survey was published in 2006.
The authors of the Core Banking Systems Survey are Gert Jan van Dorsten, Andr Spruit
and Arthur Barendsen. They are leading consultants within the core banking community
of the Capgemini banking practice in the Netherlands.
Gert Jan van Dorsten is a principal consultant specialized in banking packages in general,
with a focus on the domain of core banking back-office solutions and selecting and
implementing package-based solutions for financial institutions. Gert Jan is also expert
group manager in the Netherlands for core banking and manager of the global FS
Industry Packages Center of Excellence.
Andr Spruit is a managing consultant specialized in selecting and implementing
package-based solutions for financial institutions. Andr focuses on core banking
packages and before joining Capgemini at the end of 2006 worked for one of the leading
vendors in this domain and in the financial services industry itself.
Arthur Barendsen is a consultant with experience in embedding packages in a global
banking organization.
Preface
into the state of the package solution vided in the Rightshore offers
providers industry serving the core which combine on-, near and off-
banking business in top-tier banks shore sourcing models), combined
throughout the world. with strong regional teams with
excellent local delivery capabilities.
The main objective of this survey is to
help you understand the various core Should you require any further infor-
banking systems that are available in mation or assistance in this area, please
the world. It gives you insights into contact the appropriate Capgemini rep-
business trends, banks and vendors, resentative, whose details you can find
package selection criteria, implementa- in the appendix, or contact our local
tion methods and information concern offices.
ing and provided by the solution vend
ors. It should assist you in efficiently We welcome feedback and sugges-
and fundamentally narrowing down tions for improvements to this survey.
the search for the right solution pro-
vider and make it easy to connect with I would like to thank all the partici-
the vendors on a well-informed basis. pating vendors and all colleagues
involved for their efforts and contri-
Capgemini can provide financial insti- butions, especially Martijn Rom
tutions with considerable benefits in Colthoff, Maurice Vuijk, Pascal Breet
the area of system selection and imple and Henk Dekker for their inputs for
mentation, including: the chapter on trends.
a broad spectrum of services and in-
Contents
4 Vendor solutions 18
4.1 Introduction 18
4.2 History of core banking systems 18
4.3 Recent market developments 19
4.4 Recent developments in package solutions 21
4.5 Competitive landscape 22
4.6 Future of the market 22
4.7 Specialized best of breed solutions 23
5 Package-based solutions 24
5.1 Integrated Architecture Framework 24
5.2 Stage 1: Make or buy 25
5.3 Stage 2: Selection 26
5.3.1 Methodology 26
5.3.2 Integrated or best of breed 28
5.3.3 Selection criteria 29
5.4 Stage 3: Implementation 30
5.4.1 Methodology 30
5.5 Stage 4: Operation 33
5.5.1 Organization 33
5.5.2 Location 34
6 Capgemini in core banking 35
Reference List:
The Banker - Retail Banking Performance
BCG - Renewing core banking IT systems, 2006
BCG - Striving for organic growth in Retail Banking
Capgemini/EFMA/ING - World Retail Banking Report 2007
Capgemini/EFMA/ING - World Retail Banking Report 2008
Capgemini/EFMA/ABN AMRO - World Payments Report 2008
Capgemini - SOA and Retail Banking Industrialization: An amazing fit
Datamonitor - European Core Systems Strategies, 2007
Forrester - Banking Platform Renewal, 2005
Forrester - Banking Platform Wins 2005: Vendors
Forrester - Banking Platform Wins 2006: Vendors
Forrester - The wave of core banking suites 2007
Gartner - Dataquest Insight - Banking Industry Primer, 2006
Gartner - Magic Quadrant 2006 Retail Core Banking
Gartner - Hype Cycle for Emerging Back Office Technologies and Applications
(Banking and Investments) 2007
IBS - Sales League Table 2006
IBS - Sales League Table 2007
IBS - Core Banking Systems - 30 case studies
SAP/EFMA - Retail Banking Study 2006
Financial Services the way we see it
The 2008 Core Banking Systems Survey is based on desk research and a survey
sent out to a group of sixteen vendors of core banking solutions.
We feel it provides the reader with professionals from all over the world
valuable insights into the trends and have provided valuable input for the
solutions in the domain of core survey. Essential information was
banking. gathered from current and previous
assignments conducted by Capgemini
This survey is the third edition and for core banking clients with package
follows on from the 2003 and 2006 selections or implementations.
Retail Banking Systems Surveys. It is
the latest report in a series of Based on requested information, the
Capgemini publications in the area of survey presents a practical overview of
package-based solutions in the bank- the solutions currently available and
ing domain. The other areas covered the capabilities of each system. The
are asset management, private bank- main objective is to help users to
ing, payments, treasury management understand the various products that
and risk management. exist in the market and to narrow
down the search and make it easy to
The list of vendors requested for par- connect with the vendors on a well-
ticipation was compiled after con informed basis. This is very important
sulting the banking packages and in the initial phase(s) of the package
core banking network of Capgemini selection process. It should always be
and various publications. It includes kept in mind that package selection is
all the important vendors for the main a challenging, complex process and
markets in the world which operate that it also marks the start of a rela-
globally or at least regionally in one tionship with one or more external
continent (see figure 1). Capgemini suppliers.
Europe-South 5%
15% 10%
Europe-West
Europe-Central
Europe-North 15%
Asia 25%
America
Australia 20%
10%
Vendor Package
Accenture Alnova Financial Solutions
Callata & Wouters S.A. Thaler
Delta Informatique Delta-Bank
Fidelity National Information Services (FIS) Corebank
Profile
Systematics
Fiserv, Inc. ICBS
i-flex solutions Flexcube
Infosys Technologies Ltd Finacle
Misys Equation
Midas
Nucleus Software FinnOne
Polaris Software Lab Ltd Intellect Suite
SAP AG SAP Transactional Banking
Sungard System Access Symbols
TCS Financial Solutions TCS BaNCS
Temenos T24
TEMENOS CoreBanking (TCB)
TietoEnator Corporation Core Banking Suite
T-Systems Enterprise Services GmbH MBS banking suite; GEOS
The following core banking solution Finally, it should be noted that answers
providers participated in the survey to survey questions are quite depend
(in alphabetical order): see figure 2. ent on the individual perception of the
There are several aspects that should question and cannot be fairly com-
be considered when selecting a core pared on an individual level. Also, as a
banking system, based on the compa- result of habitual vendor optimism,
nys business vision. These range from system functionality on paper is not
functionality, architecture and non- always the same as system functionality
functional requirements to vendor sta- in a real setting.
bility and implementation capabilities.
Financial Services the way we see it
Almost all of the top retail banks in the world are still using old legacy systems
(originating in the 1960s/1970s) for core banking (in the home markets).
10
Financial Services the way we see it
The expected CAGR in 2006-2017 in global roll out of a centralized system ing for their consumers in order to
the mature markets is 2.5 percent and with central data. The corporate improve customer retention;
in the remainder 6.4 percent. As a banks (and their clients) want an major corporates are developing in-
consequence, the relative financial integrated global view of the custom- house banking capabilities, often not
power of the mature markets will er with the possibility for treasury only for their own company, but also
weaken compared to the main high departments to have transparent for the outside world.
growth markets such as India or online and daily insight to all accounts
China, which are growing at more globally. 2.4 The core banking domains
than 8 percent per year. Mature mar- There are a lot of drivers for renewing
kets, which will still account for 2.3.3 Others the systems, as listed in the table
65 percent of total retail banking in There are some other interesting devel below. The characteristics of the lega-
2017, will nevertheless remain of key opments regarding core banking solu- cy systems and the new solutions are
importance to large banks in the years tions: detailed for each area, see figure 6.
ahead. start-up of banking activities in new The general drivers are changing from
The market has seen a tremendous (emerging) markets. Sometimes this cost reduction to growth.
level of consolidation, especially in is carried out by existing banks from
Europe. Of the list of leading European other countries, sometimes by other The paragraphs below describe the
banks from fifteen years ago, only three companies. The internet is usually changes and developments in each
remain! Core systems replacement has used as a delivery channel and busi- banking domain. This is especially rel-
recently emerged as an issue. Banks ness can be conducted using a evant for the more Western economies.
feel increasingly limited by the capa- bank-in-a-box solution (less risk); For the emerging markets, these trends
bilities of their existing core banking finance departments/subsidiaries of can be regarded as visions (with a lon-
systems. The Datamonitor report enti- car companies often choose core ger time horizon) because sales forces
tled European Core System Strategies
(April 2007) summarizes the key sur-
Figure 6: Drivers for change
vey findings, which can be broadly
characterized as follows:
lack of flexibility is causing the most
12
Financial Services the way we see it
use very basic products to fulfill the The most important drivers are com-
demanding targets in such growing pliance with all kinds of requirements,
markets. Basic improvements to busi- often with specific business terms:
ness processes with adequate platforms many compliance initiatives, for
are still crucial in banking operations example KYC, FATF7, SEPA and
in these countries. Business issues and the PSD;
legal and regulatory requirements are infrastructure consolidation and
also mergers and acquisitions - and CredEuro and SDD are not easily
cost reduction are the main drivers for reconciled with domestic standards
renewal of back-office systems. Leading (for example use of SWIFT MT103,
banks, which previously saw payments paper or electronic signature and
as a back-office issue, are now tending consumer protection standards),
to bring payments much more to the and consistency in implementation
forefront. The processing of payments, has yet to be achieved;
domestic and cross-border, with clear- Pan-European structures have
ing houses and correspondents but emerged for cards (Visa & M/C) as
also with strategic sourcing, is at the well as for high-value payments
top of the boards strategy agenda. The (TARGET2) and retail payments
reason is very well stated in the World (EBA STEP2);
Payments Report 2007 of Capgemini: as consolidation towards emerging
All-in-all, leading banks are being able products due to national and
forced to increase their range of savings international legislation and regula-
products and place greater emphasis tion;
on product development. Targeting break-up of the mortgage product
multiple, segmented parts of the mar- into elements that can be included
ket with a high number of savings or excluded;
products seems necessary in order to straight-through processing to meet
14
Financial Services the way we see it
be too risky for some customers and creation of BPO centers for securi-
In line with the current positive global economic environment, banks have
generally done well over the past year.
This chapter gives an overview of the same positive trend with regards to
biggest market players and the chang- profitability.
ing landscape, illustrated by a show-
case on mergers and acquisitions. 3.1.3 Asia
Top-ranking banks in Asia:
3.1 Banks worldwide 6. Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group
The six sections below are based on (Japan)
the rankings presented in the 2007 7. ICBC (China)
edition of The Banker magazines 9. Bank of China (China)
renowned top 1.000 World Banks 14. China Construction Bank
(based on strength of tier-one capital). Corporation (China)
15. Mizuho Financial Group (Japan)
3.1.1 North America
Top-ranking banks in North America: The majority of banks in Asia are also
1. Bank of America (USA) showing healthy growth in profita
2. Citigroup (USA) bility. With two banks in the global
5. JPMorgan Chase & Co (USA) top10, China is leading in the region.
16. Wachovia Corporation (USA) In parallel with the positive results in
18. Wells Fargo & Co (USA) China, other (new) successful banks
are rapidly emerging in Asia. The best
Although cracks are appearing in of the rest is the Kookmin Bank in
North American banking, US banks Korea (62).
remained very profitable in 2006 and
2007. However, Canadian banks 3.1.4 Australia
showed a higher return on their bank- Top-ranking banks in Australia:
ing capital than US banks. 38. National Australia Bank
59. ANZ Banking Group
3.1.2 Europe 60. Commonwealth Bank Group
Top-ranking banks in Europe: 71. Westpac Banking Corporation
3. HSBC (United Kingdom)
4. Crdit Agricole (France) While China and Japan are home to
8. The Royal Bank of Scotland the largest tier-one capital banks in
(United Kingdom) the APAC region, Australian banks
11. BNP Paribas (France) remain rock-solid regional players.
12. Barclays Bank (United Kingdom)
13. HBOS (United Kingdom) 3.1.5 South America
17. UniCredit (Italy) Top-ranking banks in South America:
19. Rabobank Group (Netherlands) 54. Banco Ita Holding Financeira
20. ING Bank (Netherlands) (Brazil)
64. Banco Bradesco (Brazil)
Compared to the banks in the United 73. Banco do Brasil (Brazil)
States, the growth in Europe has been
higher. Emerging Central and Eastern Banks in the South American region
European banks differ from the large showed very positive profitability fig-
established banks in Western Europe, ures in 2006 and 2007.
although both sub-regions show the
16
Financial Services the way we see it
3.1.6 Africa necessary capital in order to offset offer, which at that time was worth
The top-ranking bank in Africa is: big losses from mortgages and other approximately 72 billion.
116. Standard Bank Group (South investments; A precondition of the offer was that
Africa) Chinese insurer Ping An acquired ABN AMRO would abandon its sale of
4.3 percent of the share capital of LaSalle Bank to Bank of America.
Whilst African banks have consider- Fortis and appointed a member to However, during the shareholders
ably less tier-one capital than the major the Supervisory Board. meeting on the following day a majori-
global players, developments in Africa ty of the shareholders voted in favor of
match up to the global trend in growth 3.3 Showcase: ABN AMRO the sale of LaSalle.
over the past year. acquisition In July 2007, Barclays raised its offer
The changing landscape referred to for ABN AMRO to 67.5 billion. It
3.2 A changing landscape earlier applies very much to the did so after securing investments from
Although very positive overall, the Netherlands. From 1991 to 2007, the governments of China and
banking landscape seems to be chang- ABN AMRO was one of the largest Singapore. The offer remained below
ing rapidly. The mergers and acquisi- banks in Europe and had operations the offer made by the consortium in
tion (M&A) and consolidation trend, in about 63 countries around the the previous week. At the end of July
both on a domestic and cross-border world. Originating in the Netherlands, 2007, the ABN AMRO board withdrew
level, is generally expected to continue its history dated back to 1824. A con- its support for the Barclays offer, which
in the near future. The M&A trend has sortium of three European banks, The was lower than the offer by the group
materialized in a number of interesting Royal Bank of Scotland Group, Fortis led by RBS. The board stated that it
deals completed in the last year, for and Banco Santander, announced on could no longer recommend the offer
example: October 8, 2007, that an offer for from a financial point of view.
the acquisition of ABN AMRO Bank 86percent of outstanding ABN AMRO At the beginning of October, Barclays
by the consortium consisting of The stock had been accepted, paving the withdrew its bid for ABN AMRO and,
Royal Bank of Scotland, Fortis Bank way for the largest ever bank takeover with 86 percent of the shareholders
and Banco Santander; in history. accepting the consortium bid and
the acquisition of LaSalle Bank by Fortis completing its financing, the
Bank of America from ABN AMRO; The dismantling of ABN AMRO has consortium was able to formalize its
the acquisition of BNL by BNP commenced after many months of offer and take control of ABN AMRO.
Paribas; uncertainty about its future. Events
the acquisition of Capitalia by started when in February 2007 TCI
UniCredit in Italy; hedge fund asked the ABN AMRO
the merger of Banca Intesa and Supervisory Board to actively investi-
Sanpaolo IMI. gate a merger, acquisition or break-up
of ABN AMRO, since, in its opinion,
Interestingly, another trend is the the market capitalization of ABN
investment of huge amounts of cash by AMRO did not reflect the value of the
non-traditional, non-Western investors underlying assets.
in the financial services industry of the In April 2007, ABN AMRO and
Western world. The fourth quarter of Barclays announced the proposed
2007 saw a number of investments by acquisition of ABN AMRO by Barclays.
Chinese and Middle Eastern entities in The deal was valued at 67billion
European and North American finan- and included the sale of the LaSalle
cial institutions, examples being: Bank to Bank of America for 21 bil-
the Abu Dhabi Investment Authority lion. A few days after the joint announ
invested $ 7.5 billion in Citigroup, cement by Barclays and ABN AMRO,
offering the largest US bank the the consortium issued their indicative
When did core banking become a market for vendor solutions, and what
generations of solutions have there been?
4.2 History of core banking The 1990s saw new players emerging
systems in India, benefiting from the opening
The first core banking solutions up of the Indian economy, the avail-
appeared in the 1970s in the United ability of English language skills, and
States. Most of them ran on main- the huge pool of highly skilled engi-
frame computers and were designed neers. i-flex solutions (and its legal
by the banks themselves or by third predecessor CITIL) can be considered
parties in conjunction with the large as the first successful software product
US banks. Limitations to exporting company from India that managed to
these systems outside the US were sell outside the Indian subcontinent. It
that these were mainly single-currency- was followed by the likes of Infosys
based as they were designed for the and Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) -
US market only. In the 1980s, these companies that originally focused more
solutions moved to all continents, on providing off-shoring, consulting
mostly as a result of following the and outsourcing services but moved
major US banks such as Citibank. into the software product business -
and later by other product companies
During the 1970s, 1980s and most of such as Polaris Labs and Nucleus.
the 1990s, packaged banking solutions
flourished in international operations. At the end of the 1990s, new players
For domestic retail operations, howev- made their entry. ERP giants such as
er, most large banks preferred to stay SAP and IBM started entering the mar-
with the systems they had developed ket (following a strategy of organic
in-house. Some brave top-tier institu- growth and development and with a
tions did try replacing the in-house presence at the heart of the accounting
systems with package solutions cus- domain in many banks), followed a
18
Financial Services the way we see it
few years later by Oracle (through the 4.3 Recent market developments opments in the core banking market
acquisition of i-flex solutions and Increasingly, the core banking market from 2006 onwards:
Siebel and aligning these to their tech- is hot, and since 2005 (our previous
nology and application strategies). edition of this survey) the market has Fiserv completed the acquisition of
Profile
Fidelity Systematics
Corebanking
Midas
Misys
Equation
Fiserv ICBS
Accenture Alnova
T-Systems
Callatay & Wouters Thaler
Tietoenator Core Banking Suite
Temenos T24
TCB
Infosys Finacle
Nucleus Finnone
Source in the United States Move to all continents Take-overs/shake-out Important sources India
First backoffice systems Booming business Entrance new players Replacing core banking
Build in house, third party Follow banks oversea Replacing first systems Customer focus
Evolved to first packages Failed to replace core Failed to replace core Outsourcing
Vendor solutions 19
SAP and Accenture ended their stra-
Figure 8: Vendors revenues tegic cooperation in the banking
domain.
SAP acquired Business Objects. The
20
Financial Services the way we see it
operational support, are quickly out- banks access to a much larger set of specific legacy environments.
stripping the capacity of development vendors and solutions. Banks can
organizations to facilitate change. operate core banking systems on their Don Free
Most of this is due to trapped, platform of preference. Some banks Research Director Banking
line-of-business logic buried in appli- prefer to stay on their well-embedded Gartner
cation-specific legacy environments, and reliable mainframe infrastructure.
says Gartners Don Free. The matura- Others move to highly scalable com-
tion of middleware messaging archi- modity platforms, freeing them from a
tectures, the evolutionary path to serv lock-in to an increasingly small set of
ices and event-driven constructs and expensive mainframe specialists.
new development techniques, such as
service-oriented development, are Messaging, service orientation and
simplifying maintenance and support architecture
of products while reducing volatility With regard to business expectations,
commonly associated with the intro- the expectations for rapid time to
duction of new products and services. market for products and the corre-
Some core banking vendors are sponding operational support are
already progressing quickly to achieve quickly outstripping the capacity of
componentization of their back-office development organizations to facilitate
offerings. change. This is leading to major devel
Vendor solutions 21
opments in the core banking area,
namely messaging, service orientation Figure 9: Identified competitors
and architecture. Messaging middle-
ware has become a de facto standard.
Service orientation and loose event- Vendor What are your major competitors?
based coupling have become part of Accenture
mainstream thinking. We have seen Callata & Wouters Temenos
i-flex solutions
the arrival of the first business process Delta Informatique i-flex solutions
frameworks for banking. Business Fidelity (Corebank) i-flex solutions
process modeling and orchestration is TCS
on the rise. All this will give banks a Fidelity (Profile) i-flex solutions
great deal of freedom. A bank can buy Temenos
TCS
the services that are available on the
Fiserv
market from vendors, service-enable In-house development
existing legacy systems or create its Fidelity (Systematics) Fiserv
own services in areas where it feels Metavante
this gives the bank an advantage in CSC
the market. And it can outsource In-house development
Fiserv Infosys
when it feels that a service is not its
i-flex solutions
core competence! We have seen vend Misys
ors coming up with strategies in this Temenos
area in the last two years and we have SAP
also seen the first resulting products. I-Flex Temenos
Infosys
Misys
4.5 Competitive landscape SAP
As part of the survey, we asked the Infosys Temenos
participating vendors to tell us which SAP
vendors and solutions they consider i-flex solutions
to be their main competitors. The fol- Misys Temenos
i-flex solutions
lowing figure lists the answers to this
Nucleus
question, see figure 9. Polaris Temenos
i-flex solutions
4.6 Future of the market SAP AG i-flex solutions
In the past, there were a large num- Temenos
ber of specialized solutions in the In-house development
SunGard i-flex solutions
market. Some were strong in account
Temenos
handling, others strong in wholesale Path Solutions (Islamic Banking)
or retail lending and finally there Misys
were separate financial accounting TCS
solutions. All these packages had Infosys
their own, proprietary architectural TCS i-flex solutions
Temenos
footprints. Temenos Fidelity
Infosys
Nowadays there seems to be a move i-flex solutions
towards alignment with the architec- TietoEnator
ture stacks and frameworks of the ERP T-Systems Kordoba
Fiducia
giants SAP and Oracle in this market.
22
Financial Services the way we see it
Alongside the core banking offerings of The Indian pure players have so far
the ERP giants (or subsidiaries), most chosen to remain agnostic in this
independent vendors are aligning respect and have come up with SOA
themselves to one of these platforms. and BPM stacks of their own.
This should deliver the additional bene 4.7 Specialized best of breed
fits promised in some of the initiatives solutions
of these ERP giants: embedded busi- Besides the core banking solutions,
ness intelligence, integrated customer there are also some very good special-
relationship management, integrated ized solutions in specific domains.
financial accounting and reporting and Figure 10 lists some of these in the
integrated risk management, regulatory domains of Payments, Lending and
compliance and fraud detection. Securities.
Vendor solutions 23
5 Package-based solutions
Contextual WHY?
Security
Governance
Technology
Business Information Information systems
infrastructure
Conceptual
Artifacts & views Artifacts & views Artifacts & views Artifacts & views WHAT?
Logical
Artifacts & views Artifacts & views Artifacts & views Artifacts & views HOW?
Physical
Artifacts & views Artifacts & views Artifacts & views Artifacts & views WITH WHAT?
24
Financial Services the way we see it
IAF addresses four architecture aspect IAF reduces the risk of losing
areas: Business (B), Information (I), requirements between the phases.
Information Systems (IS), and Techno IAF provides an approach for Enter
IAF ensures completeness of the Although cost and risk may well rule
design. this out, this is still the biggest com-
Package-based solutions 25
petitor, mostly because of the influ- 5.3 Stage 2: Selection
ence of the IT department, and from
the end-user perspective the number
of changes will be limited. If this
Make or buy Selection Implementation Operation
alternative is chosen, risks can be
mitigated by opting for approaches
based on service-oriented architec-
ture or model-driven architecture.
5.3.1 Methodology
Procure a packaged solution.
Capgeminis well-proven system selec-
The challenge of this option is to tion methodology has been applied
find a packaged solution that is suit- for leading customers in the financial
ably scalable and that will integrate services industry around the world
into the banks technical environ- and has minimized the risks involved
ment. Plug-and-play packaged solu- in system selection. Selecting the right
tions provide flexibility in product system can make an enormous differ-
development and deployment and ence in terms of market offerings and
enable lower cost development process efficiency.
through buying commoditized devel-
opment services from third-party In this section, we give a brief over-
suppliers. Changes in the current view of Capgeminis system selection
processes are unavoidable in order to methodology, see figure 12.
benefit from the strengths of a pack-
aged solution. Choosing a packaged Figure 12: Delivery selection method
solution makes it possible to take
advantage of functionalities devel-
oped for other banks. This makes it Milestone
possible to benefit from these func-
tionalities within short timeframes. Phase 1 Start up Approved project plan
26
Financial Services the way we see it
It has been developed and continu- that there is sound management buy-
ously refined over a number of years in to the project.
as a refinement and adaptation of gen-
eral system selection methodologies Focus and direct
for the specific needs of the bank and The focus and direct phase scopes the
other financial service institutions. package selection project, answering
The package selection method is used the questions as to why the business
to select a software package that best will start the project, what goals the
matches the business needs of the cli- business will attain, what approach
ent. The method supports and objec will be used by the project to attain the
tifies decision making with respect to goals and what the limits of operation
software selection and consists of of the project are. While the start-up
seven streams and five phases. phase has a strong focus on preparing
the - organizational - conditions for
The starting point of the method is a conducting the project appropriately,
business requirement to automate a the package selection project starts in
business functionality by using a stan- earnest with the focus and direct
dard software package. Standard soft- phase. The focus is business-oriented,
ware is defined as a software package or one might say content-oriented.
that is supplied by a software vendor
and has 80 percent of the required Define shortlist
functionality out of the box. A stan- In this phase the project team tries to
dard software package may be highly deliver a shortlist of three to five
parameterized. Therefore, a large set- packages which most closely match
up may be necessary to achieve the the current and future requirements
80percent of productive functionality. specified by the organization. After a
The method can be used to select one long list of packages has been drawn
or a combination of software packages. up, with the aid of the Capgemini
packages database, a Request for
The selection method is used to devise Information (RFI) is sent to these
objective criteria so that the decision vendors. Based on the answers to the
process is rationalized. Besides sup- RFI, a shortlist is drawn up which will
porting the decision making process, serve as the basis for the remainder of
the package selection method pre- the selection process.
pares the organization for the imple-
mentation of the software package. Evaluate
A properly executed package selection This phase provides the package eval-
can save a lot of time during imple- uation process. During this package
mentation of the package! selection phase, the project team will
conduct a thorough review and analy-
Start-up sis of several potential short-listed
The purpose of the start-up effort is to software tools which meet the clients
ensure that sufficient resources are business requirements and enable the
available to the project, so that a clear desired business processes. This phase
plan with deadlines is in place, the ends with one preferred potential soft-
members of the project team are ware tool which meets the clients
aware of their responsibilities, and business requirements.
Package-based solutions 27
Validate port in the future. It is essential to
In the validate phase, the package select a system that not only supports
solution will be tested in full practice. the current situation, but also allows
The provider will have to install the the organization to respond to future
system in a clients test environment. market demands and change its value
The reason for doing this is to elimi- proposition and customer experience
nate the final uncertainties. accordingly.
In the previous phase, a short valida- An important aspect is the choice of
tion of the package is included as part an integrated system or a best of breed
of the package selection. This short infrastructure. Smaller institutions will
validation may be a proof of concept often have a preference for integrated
in which specific functionality is test- systems. A well-chosen system pro- The selection of a core banking
ed. This test is included to ensure that vides all the necessary functionality, system is a strategic decision
the package can be parameterized or causes not too much trouble with with long-term implications.
extended to support the required interfacing and innovation, and is
functionality. This short test is not supported by the vendor. Large and
used to test all functions of the pack- sophisticated banks, however, will opt
age. The validate phase is included for for a best of breed infrastructure. No
the checking of all functions. To start single system totally covers their
this phase, the client signs a letter of requirements, so they have to choose
intent. In this letter of intent he specific software components for spe-
declares that he will purchase the cific functionalities.
package subject to a positive valida-
tion in this phase. A solid architectural basis is key in
these cases. These infrastructures intro
This validation phase is optional. In duce the need for a middleware com-
most situations, all the information ponent. This is vital, since it reduces
gathered in combination with a short the interfacing issues to a minimum
proof of concept in the evaluation and guarantees flexibility in a complex
phase will be sufficient to reach a environment, see figure 13.
decision.
Figure 13: Best of breed or integrated solution
Confirm and finalize the preferred
solution
The objective of this phase is to get Best of breed Integrated solution
(multiple systems) (one system)
the final sign-off of the package selec-
tion project. With this sign-off the cli- Pros Advanced functionality No interfaces in the transaction flow
ent agrees to the solution as advised Switching parts of the systems architecture Makes reporting easier across the transaction
by the project team. gives lower costs flow
Less dependence on one vendor Easier maintenance of databases
28
Financial Services the way we see it
Package-based solutions 29
Business value
Return on investment (ROI) is an Figure 14: Principles
important criterion, but does not solely
define the true value of IT investments.
A more practical measure is the busi- Business principles IT principles
ness value of IT that takes ROI into Multi-language Scalability
consideration as well as other impor- Multi-channel Technical platform, hardware, operating system
tant factors, such as strategic alignment, Multi-brand (white labeling) Service and message architecture
architecture, risk, and business process
Flexibility to product changes Flexibility to technology changes
impact.
5.4.1 Methodology RAPID strives to accelerate the speed To implement the package on
To implement the package on a solid to value by focusing the redesign a solid basis, the best option is
basis, the best option is to use a struc- effort on those processes that will to use a structured approach
tured approach based on best practices. yield the greatest value to the organi- based on best practices.
Capgemini offers an implementation zation while adopting the package
method and a multi-site implementa- processes in non-core/strategic areas.
tion framework, which can also be The business case serves as the
combined. benchmark by which value is mea-
sured. Key project decisions should
RAPID be evaluated based on their quantita-
The Redesign through Application tive benefit versus qualitative opin-
Package Iterative Development ions on what is critical to the organi-
(RAPID) method resides between the zation.
extremes of just implementing a pack-
30
Financial Services the way we see it
quality. Some of the major areas are tested route map covering all aspects
noted below: of a large package implementation,
Accelerated Workshops: the method where the package is seen as an
recommends the use of Accelerated enabler of business change.
Workshops to improve the speed The main characteristic of RAPID is
Package-based solutions 31
Business changes will be involved:
Figure 16: The Capgemini methodology for a roll out at multiple (local/global) they are not necessarily a business
locations
process re-design initiative, but are
more than the traditional/simple
alignments to allow the use of a
new IT solution.
Implementation of an IT solution
Support
Improvement
ents organization.
Deployment
units to share and leverage best is not to be limited to the new sys-
practices to support the framework. tem training at IT level, but should
An important part of this method is a include all types of education and
pilot in one location and, after training needs allowing harmonious
improvement, a roll out to the other operation with the new organiza-
locations. tion. Training should be extended
Implementation features to define a to cover new organization and busi-
MIR initiative include: ness processes. Training is necessary
Multi-site implementation: not nec- in the different steps of a program
essarily international, but ten or and includes the training for the
more sites at different levels from project teams, implementers, train-
upper global or coordination level ers, end-users, et cetera.
to local or users site level. Change management in the broadest
32
Financial Services the way we see it
Package-based solutions 33
economies of scale (better lever-
Figure 17: The organization for an implemented package solution
age of fixed cost and R&D cost).
These are the same activities/pro-
cesses in each financial institu-
tion. The Transaction Bank is
often a joint venture between an High In House
IT company and a number of par- department
ticipating banks.
- Business Process Outsourcing
SSC
(BPO). BPO is the contracting out Shared Service Center
of a specific business task to a
true third-party service provider. Control,
Stake Transaction
Bank
5.5.2 Location Outsourcing
Business Process
Outsourcing
Near shore SaaS,
Near shore moves operations or jobs Software as a Service
Onshore
Onshore moves operations or jobs
Figure 18: The location for a package solution
from internal production to an exter-
nal entity within the same country.
On-site On-site
On-site leaves part of the service with- Onshore
in the client facilities.
Complexity
Risk
Rightshore
Rightshore is a Capgemini operating
approach that leverages global deliv- Offshore
34
Financial Services the way we see it
We have worked closely with the and subject matter experts around the
worlds most prominent and success- world. Within these structures you
ful financial institutions and have total will find the FS Industry Packages
worldwide revenues of more than Center of Excellence. In this center, all
$ 1 billion in financial services. the knowledge is concentrated around
a wide variety of package-based solu-
Because of the acquisition of Kanbay tions in the financial services industry.
in 2007, Capgemini had the strongest
presence in India of the top-three It is not possible to draw a clear dis-
consultancy companies in the world tinction between core- and non-core
and became a very strong player in FS consultants, but most of the
the financial services industry. knowledge and experience is in this
Capgeminis global FS Centers of area. The knowledge is captured in all
Excellence drive global sales & deliv- kinds of ways, including process
ery support, leveraging best practices models for each area.
Telecom,
Media & Consulting
Professional
Networks Other Services
Services
6,5%
9,6% 11%
Energy & 15,9%
Utilities Manufacturing,
13,1% Retail &
29,0%
Distribution Technology
34%
14,0% Services
39,1%
Financial
Services 27,8%
Outsourcing
Services
Government
North America
6.441
Asia Pacific Capgemini FY 2007
United (India 6,979)
Kingdom 8.231
and Ireland 8.7 bn A $ 13b Global Player
9%
8.785 12% 17,500 Professionals in Network
Benelux
Serving Financial Services
13%
13% 9.014
Southern 7,000 Dedicated India FS
Europe 9% Platform
8%
6.235 Central 20,000 Offshore headcount
5% 6 Major Indian Hubs
31% Europe
5.137 900+ Clients Worldwide
Nordic
Countries France
3.608 20.438
From benchmarking to best practices, global or local, Capgemini brings the latest in industry innovation and insights with 4 global reports to help
organisations be more competitive and responsive to market demands.
World Retail Banking Report World Wealth Report World Payments Report World Insurance Report
WORLD
2008 INSURANCE
WORLD RETAIL world REPORT
BANKING REPORT
World Wealth Report payments
REPORT 2007
2008
2007
Annual price index of banking Annual collaboration between Annual report produced by Annual report produced by
services across national Merrill Lynch and Capgemini Capgemini and industry leaders Capgemini
markets Leading source of information ABN AMRO and EFMA Leverages insurer client
Covers 194 banks in 26 on Wealth trends Investigates the payments interviews and over 11,000
countries Provides a deep understanding business and revenue and long proprietary customer surveys
Produced with ING and the of the investment needs of the term implications of the SEPA Addresses markets in twelve
European Financial Manage- worlds high net worth for users and providers of countries covering over 60
ment & Marketing Association individuals (HNWIs) - and the payments services in the euro percent of the global insurance
Features - Driving profitable evolving implications for the zone premiums written
growth in domestic markets wealth management industry Features - Issues banks need to Features - An examination of the
address to adapt their payments evolving global insurance
business to the new SEPA market
environment
36
FinancialServices thewayweseeit
Capgemini frequently publishes surveys for specific banking domains with the latest trends in that market and an overview of the most important
vendors in the mature markets. It also describes the ways to select, implement and run the solutions.
Retail Banking
European Asset Treasury Systems
Systems Survey Management Report 2007 Survey 2007
Retail Banking Systems Survey Survey Results 2006
www.nl.capgemini.com
The insights given into business The insights given into business The European Asset Manage- Takes a look at trends and
trends, package selection trends, vendor market and ment Report 2007 takes a look at developments in the Treasury
criteria, methods and information selection and implementation trends and developments in the sector including the influence of
provided by the solution vendors methods together with an high asset management sector, BPO, globalization and compli-
should assist you in efficiently level overview of the main including the influence of ance legislation.
and fundamentally narrowing solutions in the mature markets globalization and compliance
down the search for the right assist you in efficiently legislation.
solution provider and make it narrowing down the search for
easy to connect with the vendors the right solution.
on a well-informed basis.
Company name Solution Address of headquarters Telephone number E-mail address Website Contact
Accenture Alnova Financial For Alnova FS related questions, our +34 915 966 000 info@alnovatech.com www.alnovatech.com, Raul Gonzlez Antn
Solutions headquarter is: www.accenture.com/alnova Senior Executive Alnova Lead
Accenture-Financial Services Solution Group
(FSSG):
35, Ramrez de Arellano Str., 5th floor 28043
Madrid S
Callata & Wouters S.A. Thaler Rue P. de Deken 14 B +32 2738 1700 company@c-w.be www.callatay-wouters.com Diederik van der Linden
1040 Brussels Belgium Direct: +32 2 740 14 13
Delta Informatique Delta-Bank 47, rue Christiaan Huygens B.P. 97315 +33 247 871 100 g.ayoub@delta-informatique.com www.delta-bank.com Georges AYOUB
37073 Tours Cedex 2 France
Fidelity National Information Services (FIS) Corebank 601 Riverside Ave. Jacksonville +1 904 854 5000 fnfis.marketing@fnis.com www.fidelityinfoservices.com Michelle Kersch - SVP Marketing
FL 32204 USA & Corporate Communications
Fidelity National Information Services (FIS) Profile 601 Riverside Ave. Jacksonville +1 904 854 5000 fnfis.marketing@fnis.com www.fidelityinfoservices.com Michelle Kersch - SVP Marketing
FL 32204 USA & Corporate Communications
Fidelity National Information Services (FIS) Systematics 601 Riverside Ave. Jacksonville +1 904 854 5000 fnfis.marketing@fnis.com www.fidelityinfoservices.com Michelle Kersch - SVP Marketing
FL 32204 USA & Corporate Communications
Fiserv ICBS (International Fiserv Inc., 255 Fiserv Drive; Brookfield, WI +1 262 879 5000 general_info@fiserv.com, www.fiserv.com, Joan Skimmons, Corporate VP,
Comprehensive 53045, USA +1 407 299 5400 info@cbs.fiserv.com www.fiservcbs.com Fiserv Inc.
Banking System) Fiserv CBS Worldwide, 600 Colonial Center Carol Cowan, VP Global
Parkway Lake Mary, FL 32746, USA Marketing, Fiserv CBS Worldwide
i-flex solutions limited Flexcube 399 A-Subhash Road, Vile Parle (East) +91 226 718 5000 t.mathew@iflexsolutions.com www.iflexsolutions.com Thomas Mathew
Mumbai, Maharashtra - 400 057, India Direct: +91 80 6659 7160
Infosys Technologies Ltd. Finacle #44 Electronic City, Hosur Road +91 804 105 7577 girish_ch@infosys.com www.infosys.com/finacle/ Girish Vishwanath
Bangalore - 560100 India
Misys Equation 1 St Georges Road, Wimbledon, SW19 4DR +44 208 879 1188 daniel.scott@misys.com www.misys.com/banking Daniel Scott
Misys Midas 1 St Georges Road Wimbledon, SW19 4DR +44 208 879 1188 simon.lord@misys.com www.misys.com/banking Simon Lord
Nucleus Software FinnOne A-39, Sector-62, Noida 201307 Uttar Pradesh, +91 120 240 4050 bdguk@nucleussoftware.com www.nucleussoftware.com Gladwin Thomas
India
Polaris Software Lab Ltd. Intellect Suite Polaris Software Lab ltd., Polaris House +91 442 852 4154 marketing@polaris.co.in www.polaris.co.in UK:Ramesh Ramakrishnan
244 Anna Salai, Chennai - 600008, India India: Venkatesh Sarvasiddhi
SAP AG SAP Transactional Dietmar Hoppe Allee, 16 Walldorf 69190 +49 622 774 7474 www.sap.com www.sap.com Simon Shores
Banking (TB) Germany
SunGard System Access SunGard System Access 8 Temasek Boulevard +65 6333 4533 Info.corebanking@sungard.com www.sungard.com/ Mavis Liew, Marketing Director
Symbols #28 01 Suntec Tower 3 Singapore 0389988 systemaccess
Company (part two) Contact information
Company name Solution Address of headquarters Telephone number E-mail address Website Contact
TCS Financial Solutions, SBU of Tata TCS BaNCS TCS House, Raveline Street Fort Mumbai, +91 226 778 tcs.bancs@tcs.com www.tcs.com/bancs Dennis Roman
Consultancy Services Ltd. 400001, India 9999/9974
Temenos T24 Temenos Headquarters SA 18 +41 227 081 150 www.temenos.com www.temenos.com Manjinder Jaul
Place des Philosphes CH -1205 Geneva
Temenos TEMENOS Temenos Headquarters SA 18 +41 227 081 150 www.temenos.com www.temenos.com Manjinder Jaul
CoreBanking (TCB) Place des Philosphes CH -1205 Geneva
TietoEnator Corporation Core Banking Suite Kutojantie 10, PL 33 +358 9862 6000 kjersti.b.revelsby@ www.tietoenator.com Kjersti Breivik Revelsby
T-Systems Enterprise Services GmbH MBS banking suite; Mainzer Landstr. 50 +49 696 6531 3050 berthold.kaib@t-systems.com www.t-systems.com Dr. Berthold Kaib
41
42
Company Regional offices
Accenture Alnova Spain, Madrid USA, Murray Hill Accenture has offices and operations Accenture has offices and operations Accenture has offices and operations
(Financial Services Solution Group) (Financial Services Solution Group) in more than 150 cities (49 countries) in more than 150 cities (49 countries) in more than 150 cities (49 countries)
across the word, some of them in this across the word, some of them in this across the word, some of them in this
geographic area. geographic area. geographic area.
Fidelity Corebank UK, London Jacksonville, Florida, USA Brazil, Sao Paolo Thailand, Bangkok
Fidelity Profile UK, London USA, Jacksonville, Florida Brazil, Sao Paolo Thailand, Bangkok
Fidelity Systematics UK, London USA, Jacksonville, Florida Brazil, Sao Paolo Thailand, Bangkok
Fiserv ICBS UK, London (EMEA HQ) USA, Lake Mary, Florida, USA, Lake Mary, Florida Singapore UK, London
Poland, Warsaw USA (NA and Fiserv CBS Worldwide (Canada, LatAm and Australia, Sydney
Russia, Moscow HQ) Caribbean HQ); China, Beijing
USA, Arlington Heights, IL USA Mexico, Mexico City
Colombia, Bogota
i-flex solutions Flexcube Netherlands, Amsterdam USA, New York USA, Miami Singapore India, Mumbai
Infosys Finacle UK, London USA, Fremont, CA Argentina, Buenos Aires India, Bangalore
Misys Equation Luxembourg USA, New York Mexico, Mexico City Singapore UAE, Dubai
Misys Midas Luxembourg USA, New York Mexico, Mexico City Singapore UAE, Dubai
Nucleus FinnOne UK, London USA, New Jersey Singapore Nigeria, Lagos
Polaris Intellect Suite UK, London USA, Iselin, NJ Chile, Santiago Singapore
TCS TCS BaNCS UK, London USA, New York Chile, Santiago Singapore South Africa, Cape Town
Temenos T24 UK, London USA, Florida, Orlando USA, Florida, Orlando Singapore Switzerland, Geneva
Temenos TCB UK, London USA, Florida, Orlando USA, Florida, Orlando Singapore Switzerland, Geneva
T-Systems MBS; GEOS Germany, Frankfurt USA, New York Brazil, Sao Paolo Singapore South Africa, Midrand
Company Size
Company Solution Revenues whole Revenues whole Revenues of core No employees whole No employees core No employees in R&D No employees in
company as reported company in EUR banking division company banking for core banking Europe for core
(2006) (2006) banking
Accenture Alnova $ 19.695.814.000 14.921.071.212 Not public 170.000 Not public Not public Not public
Callata & Wouters Thaler 50.000.000 50.000.000 50.000.000 500 500 120 460
Delta Informatique Delta-Bank 24.000.000 24.000.000 22.000.000 295 270 120 255
Fidelity Corebank $ 4.200.000.000 3.181.818.182 Not public 20.000 Not public Not public Not public
Fidelity Systematics $ 4.200.000.000 3.181.818.182 Not public 20.000 Not public Not public Not public
Fiserv ICBS $ 4.410.000.000 3.340.909.091 Not public 23.000 19.700 4.700 156
i-flex solutions Flexcube $ 467.630.000 354.265.152 Not public 10.778 Not public Not public Not public
SAP AG SAP TB 9.400.000.000 9.400.000.000 Not public 39.355 Not public Not public Not public
TCS TCS BaNCS $ 4.300.000.000 3.257.575.758 128.787.879 100.000 3.000 1.200 350
TietoEnator CBS 1.647.000.000 1.647.000.000 35.000.000 16.000 250 Not public 250
Financial Services
T-Systems MBS; GEOS 12.600.000.000 12.600.000.000 50.000.000 56.000 400 300 400
Euro $ 1,32
Euro 0,67
43
the way we see it
44
Solution General solution information Description of costing model for example
Company Solution Company Year Current version Year of users branches entities countries accounts trans- assets Other Annual
start to of first number release actions under maintenance
offer instal- of this mgt fee
banking lation version
software?
Fidelity Corebank 1969 1998 Release 4.4 2007 X X X X Flexible license, maintenance, Not disclosed
hosted cost models
i-flex solutions Flexcube 1991 1997 FLEXCUBE V.UM 2007 X X Registered subscribers Not disclosed
Release 10.0
FLEXCUBE V.CO
Release 2.4
Misys Equation 1977 1978 v3.8.2 2007 X X X X Flexible on usage Not disclosed
Polaris Intellect Suite 1993 2002 Intellect Core v9.5.1 2007 X X X X X X X 22%
TietoEnator CBS 1990 1992 6.4 2007 X X X X X Flexible on modular building 20%
blocks, nr or end-customers,
transactions, etc.
T-Systems MBS; GEOS 1995 1990 7.0 (MBS banking suite) 2007 X X X X X 20%
Solution Services
Company Solution SaaS References BPO References Con- Help Imple- User Other
sulting Desk mentation Training
Services Support
Callata & Wouters Thaler X Clearstream, Luxembourg X Ordina BPO, The Netherlands X X X X
Fidelity Profile X Client names confidential at this time. X Client names confidential at this time. X X X X
Fidelity ICBS
Fiserv Systematics X All solutions are offered on an out- X Fiserv provides BPO services for UK X X X X
sourced or in-house basis. Currently mortgage lenders and banks. Client
80 outsourced clients, European names confidential.
client names are confidential.
i-flex solutions Flexcube X Fullerton India Credit Company X One of the top 5 non-prime lenders X X X X
State Bank of Mauritius, India Ops in US (Customer under NDA)
Infosys Finacle X X Mortgage bank in the US. X X X X Technology Led Business Process Trans-
formation, Value Mining, Bespoke Application
Development & Maintenance, Disaster
Recovery and BCP, Software Engineering,
Performance Tuning, Independent validation
Misys Equation X X X X
Misys Midas X X X X
Nucleus FinnOne X X X X
SAP AG SAP TB X X X X X
Financial Services
SunGard Symbols X X X X
TCS TCS BaNCS X Provider - Finaclear, Orbay X 3 Private Banking Customers, Client X X X X
In discussion with Prospects names confidential.
45
the way we see it
Company Solution Benelux UK North Central South East Europe # clients # accts # trxs per Reference 1 Reference 2 Reference 3
(Nordic; (D, A, (Es, P, F, (rest) Overall day
Baltic) CH) I, Cr, Se,
Gr, Tu)
Accenture Alnova 0 3 0 1 75 4 83 8.000.000 17.000.000 10.500.000 Alliance & Leicester PKO Bank Polski BAWAG (Austria)
(UK) (Poland)
Callata & Wouters Thaler 35 2 0 0 1 0 38 40.000.000 40.000.000 15.000.000 National Savings & Rabobank BNP Paribas (France)
Investment Bank (UK) (Netherlands)
Fidelity Corebank 0 0 152 0 1 0 153 3.500.000 5.500.000 SDC (Denmark) Terra Gruppen
(Norway)
Fiserv ICBS 4 12 0 1 11 9 37 4.740.707 2.237.520 ING Bank Slaski BM Solutions Bank Zachodni WBK
i-flex solutions Flexcube - - - - - - 69 2.000.000 3.500.000 890.000 BAWAG UniCredit Bulbank DNB Nord
Infosys Finacle 1 3 0 1 3 2 10 5.500.000 6.000.000 5.000.000 Zurich FS (UK) Uralsib (Russia) HPB (Croatia)
SAP AG SAP TB 3 2 6 50 2 8 71 12.000.000 30.000.000 10.000.000 Deutsche Postbank UBS (Switzerland) ABN AMRO
(Germany) (Netherlands)
SunGard Symbols 0 0 1 0 0 7 8 3.500.000 4.500.000 3.000.000 SEB Unibanka Erste Bank (Hungary) Slovenska Sporitelna
(Latvia) (Slovakia)
TCS TCS BaNCS 4 7 12 15 3 11 52 1.700.000 2.800.000 1.000.000 Societe Generale Nova Ljubljanska BIN Bank (Russia)
(France) Banka (Slovania)
TietoEnator CBS 2 2 15 0 1 0 20 9.450.000 9.000.000 12.000.000 Nordea (Nordic) Rabobank (NL) Barclays
T-Systems MBS; GEOS 0 0 0 30 0 0 30 3.500.000 6.000.000 9.000.000 Sparda-Banken BMW Bank (Germany) Sal. Oppenheim & Cie
(Germany) (Germany)
North America Numbers of largest reference Most important references
Company Solution Number of # clients # accts # trxs per day Reference 1 Reference 2 Reference 3
different clients
Accenture Alnova 5 13.700.000 15.000.000 18.000.000 BBVA Bancomer (Mexico) Banco Azteca (Mexico) Santander Serfin (Mexico)
Fidelity Corebank 0
i-flex solutions Flexcube 12 1.200.000 3.000.000 500.000 Citibank International Monetary Fund Federal Home Loan Bank of New York
Misys Midas 56
Nucleus FinnOne 0
SAP AG SAP TB 6 50.000 100.000 Farm Credit Canada Epargne Placements Quebec ProMutual Canada
SunGard Symbols 0
Temenos T24 21
TietoEnator CBS 0
47
the way we see it
48
South America Numbers of largest reference Most important references
Company Solution Number of # clients # accts # trxs per day Reference 1 Reference 2 Reference 3
different clients
Accenture Alnova 25 BBVA Banco Francs (Argentina) Ita (Chile) Banco Santander Brasil (Brazil)
Fidelity Corebank 0
Fidelity Profile 1
Fidelity Systematics 6 13 13.000.000 Banco de Credito del Peru Banco de Bogota INFONAVIT
Fiserv ICBS 31 4.000.000 Banco Popular Dominicano CoopDeSarrollo SCL de CV Caja Popular Mexicana
i-flex solutions Flexcube 16 2.300.000 3.000.000 600.000 Banco De Chile (Chile) Inverunion Banco Comercial C.A. First Caribbean International Bank
(Vezezuela) (Barbados)
Infosys Finacle 4 1.338.582 1.627.650 240.000 National Commercial Bank Jamaica Bank in Bermuda Bank in Panama
Misys Equation 8
Misys Midas 19
Nucleus FinnOne 0
SunGard Symbols 0
TCS TCS BaNCS 3 10.580.000 18.840.000 430.000 Banco Pichincha (Chile) Large Retail Bank (Chile) Private Bank (Chile)
Temenos T24 76
Temenos TCB 0
TietoEnator CBS 0
Company Solution Australia; Japan China India Other APAC # clients # accts # trxs Reference 1 Reference 2 Reference 3
New Overall per day
Zealand
Callata & Wouters Thaler 2 0 0 0 2 4 Commonwealth Bank Rabobank (New Sarasin (Singapore)
of Australia (Indonesia) Zealand + Australia)
i-flex solutions Flexcube 0 0 0 0 0 63 17.600.000 13.400.000 3.000.000 Ta Chong Bank Shinsei Bank(Japan) HDFC Bank (India)
(Taiwan)
Infosys Finacle 2 1 1 4 1 9 34.000.000 36.000.000 13.000.000 ICICI Bank (India) DBS Bank (Singapore) ABN AMRO Bank
(Greater China)
Nucleus FinnOne 0 3 1 20 0 24 3.000 12.000.000 2.000 ICICI Bank Shinsei Bank ACOM Financials
Polaris Intellect Suite 2 1 0 4 1 8 1.800 264.000 600.000 ICICI Bank Shinsei Bank City Bank
SunGard Symbols 0 0 4 2 11 17 3.000.000 3.500.000 400.000 China Development Muslim Commercial Vietnam International
Bank (China) Bank (Pakistan) Bank (Vietnam)
TCS TCS BaNCS 14 0 10 45 30 99 90.000.000 120.000.000 17.500.000 State Bank of India Bank Negara Indonesia National Bank of Dubai
Financial Services
TietoEnator CBS 0 0 0 0 0 0
49
the way we see it
50
Africa Numbers of largest reference Most important references
Company Solution Number of # clients # accts # trxs per day Reference 1 Reference 2 Reference 3
different clients
Accenture Alnova
Fidelity Corebank 0
Fidelity Profile
Fidelity Systematics 1
i-flex solutions Flexcube 75 1.500.000 1.650.000 150.000 South African Post Office Old Mutual Investment Bank Misr
Administrators
Infosys Finacle 30 3.400.000 4.600.000 1.100.000 United Bank for Africa (Nigeria) First Bank Nigeria (Nigeria) Bank of Alexandria (Egypt)
Misys Midas 41
SAP AG SAP TB 6 11.000.000 Standard Bank of South Africa Nedbank Corporate Landbank SA
TCS TCS BaNCS 7 1.000.000 3.000.000 330.000 First National Bank (South Africa)
Temenos T24 93
Temenos TCB 0
Company Solution Outgoing Outgoing Incoming Domestic Direct International Standing Orders Collection of Debit Cards Deferred
Domestic Credit International Payments Debits Direct Debits Cheques Debit Cards
Transfers Transfers
Accenture Alnova Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Partial
Callata & Wouters Thaler Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
Delta Informatique Delta-Bank Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
Fidelity Corebank Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Partial
Fidelity Systematics Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full No
i-flex solutions Flexcube Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full No
Misys Equation Full Full Full Partial No Full Partial Full Full
Misys Midas Full Full Full Partial Partial Full Full 3rd Party 3rd Party
Nucleus FinnOne 3rd Party 3rd Party Full 3rd Party 3rd Party Full Full 3rd Party 3rd Party
Polaris Intellect Suite Full Full Full No No Full Full Full Full
SAP AG SAP TB Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full No
SunGard Symbols Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
TCS TCS BaNCS Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
Temenos T24 Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full No
Temenos TCB Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Partial Partial
T-Systems MBS; GEOS Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
51
the way we see it
52
Functional coverage Account & cash management
Company Solution Current Saving Term Cash FX in Cash Bank Travellers Zero Zero Notional Notional
Accounts Accounts Deposits Withdraw/ Cheques Cheques Balancing - Balancing - Pooling - Pooling -
Deposits Cross Border Cross Border Cross Border Cross Border
Single Cross Single Cross
Currency Currency Currency Currency
Callata & Wouters Thaler Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
Delta Informatique Delta-Bank Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
Fidelity Corebank Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Partial Partial Partial Partial
Fidelity Profile Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full No No No
Fiserv ICBS Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
i-flex solutions Flexcube Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Partial No Partial No
Infosys Finacle Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
Misys Midas Full Full Full Full Full Full Partial Full Full Full Full
Nucleus FinnOne Full Full Full Full 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party Partial Partial Full Full
Polaris Intellect Suite Full Full Full Full No Full Full Full Full Full Full
SAP AG SAP TB Full Full Full Full 3rd Party Full 3rd Party Full Full Full Full
TCS TCS BaNCS Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Partial Partial
Temenos T24 Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full No
Temenos TCB Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Partial No Partial No
TietoEnator CBS Full Full Full Partial Partial Partial No Full Full Full Full
T-Systems MBS; GEOS Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
Company Solution Securities Giro Investment Mutual Funds Wholesale Retail Corporate Order Position Settlement
Management Services Actions Management Management
Accenture Alnova Full 3rd Party Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
Callata & Wouters Thaler Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
Delta Informatique Delta-Bank Full Full 3rd Party Partial Full 3rd Party Full Full Full
Fidelity Corebank No 3rd Party Partial 3rd Party Full Partial Partial Partial Partial
Fiserv ICBS 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party Full 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party
i-flex solutions Flexcube Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Partial Full
Misys Equation 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party
Misys Midas Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
Nucleus FinnOne 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party Partial 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party Partial
Polaris Intellect Suite Partial No Full Full Full Full Full No Partial
SAP AG SAP TB 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party
TCS TCS BaNCS Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
Temenos T24 Full Partial Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
T-Systems MBS; GEOS Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
Financial Services
53
the way we see it
54
Functional coverage Loans (incl. mortgages) Others
Company Solution Guarantees Overdraft Personal Revolving Mortgage Leasing Asset Insurance Trading Treasury Pensions Financial Workflow
on Current Loans Facililty Loans Manage- Instruments Planning Manage-
Account ment ment
Accenture Alnova Full Full Full Full Full Full 3rd Party Full Full Full Full No No
Callata & Wouters Thaler Full Full Full Full Full 3rd Party Full Partial Full Full Full Full Full
Delta Informatique Delta-Bank Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Partial 3rd Party 3rd Party Full
Fidelity Corebank Full Full Full Full Full No 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party No 3rd Party
Fidelity Profile Full Full Full Full Full Full No Full Full No No No No
Fiserv ICBS 3rd Party Full Full Full Full 3rd Party 3rd Party Partial 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party Full Full
i-flex solutions Flexcube Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Partial Partial Full
Infosys Finacle Full Full Full Full Full Partial No Full No Full No No Partial
Misys Equation Full Full Partial Full Full No 3rd Party No Full Full No No Partial
Nucleus FinnOne Full Full Full Full Full No 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party Full
Polaris Intellect Suite Full Full Full No Full Partial Partial Full Full Full No Full Full
SAP AG SAP TB Full Full Full Full Full Full 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party 3rd Party No Full
SunGard Symbols Full Full Full Full Full Full No No Full Full No No Full
TCS TCS BaNCS Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full Full
Temenos T24 Full Full Full Full Full Full Full No Full Full Partial 3rd Party Full
Temenos TCB Full Full Full Full Full Partial No Partial No No Partial No Partial
T-Systems MBS; GEOS Full Full Full Full Full Partial Full No Full Full No Full Full
Company Solution Intel/AMD IBM System i IBM System p IBM System z SUN AMD SUN SPARC HP Integrity Other
Accenture Alnova X
Fidelity Profile X X X X
Fiserv ICBS X X
Infosys Finacle X X X
Misys Equation X
Misys Midas X
Nucleus FinnOne X
SAP AG SAP TB X X X X X X
SunGard Symbols X X X X X X X
Temenos T24 X X X X X X
Temenos TCB X X X X X X
TietoEnator CBS X X X X X X
55
the way we see it
56
Technical coverage Operating systems Database servers
Company Solution HP-UX SUN Solaris MS Windows Linux AIX IBM i5/OS IBM z/OS IBM DB2 Oracle MS SQL Other
Server Universal Database Server
Database
Accenture Alnova X X X X X X X X X
Fidelity Corebank X X X X X X
Fiserv ICBS X X X
Infosys Finacle X X X X
Misys Equation X X X
Misys Midas X X
Nucleus FinnOne X X X X X X X
SAP AG SAP TB X X X X X X X X
SunGard Symbols X X X X X X X
TietoEnator CBS X X X X X X X
Company Solution IBM Oracle Jboss BEA Other Business Crystal Other SAP Oracle People- Other
Web- Appli- Weblogic Objects Reports E-Busi- soft
sphere cation ness
Server Suite
Fidelity Corebank X X X
Fidelity Systematics X X X
Nucleus FinnOne X X X X X
Emphasise etc.
Temenos TCB X X X X X
57
the way we see it
58
The 5 most important strengths of your system? (part one)
Company Solution
Accenture Alnova 1. Customer-centric 2. Anytime (7x24x365 realtime processing), anywhere (servicing from any selling point) 3. Multi-concepts: channel, currency, language, company 4. Parameter driven
5. Business process and Serviced Architecture Oriented.
Callata & Wouters Thaler 1. Ease of integration through SOA 2. Broad modular functionality 3. Scalability, performance 4. Flexibility through parameter setting & product factory 5. Operational excellence (Customer centric &
full STP).
Delta Informatique Delta-Bank 1. Comprehensive functional coverage 2. Robust to support 12.000 concurrent users and fifteen million accounts 3. Modular yet integrated 4. Evolutive technology 5. Open standards, Java, XML,
GMS etc.
Fidelity Corebank 1. Corebank J2EE is a true real-time, event-oriented, fully J2EE compliant core banking system. This platform independence makes Corebank capable of adapting to cutting-edge global IT
standards while delivering Corebanks proven business functionality. Corebank does not use any proprietary tools or technologies. 2. Corebanks structured, documented data model is based
on IBMs Information Framework (IFW) Financial Services Data Model (FSDM), and improves development efficiencies and decreases ongoing maintenance costs, while providing ease of user
access to data. 3. Corebanks service-oriented architecture approach enables consistent processing across various delivery channels and facilitates integration of Corebank business com-
ponents and third-party applications. 4. Corebank is a customer-centric application with customer data stored only once in a robust operational customer database. Corebank can also be inte-
grated with external customer systems as necessary. All Corebank components are fully integrated without siloed applications for lending, deposits etc. 5. Corebanks Product Build component
provides a robust product factory that will allow banks to build banking products and product packages in real-time without IT intervention using an extensive array of parameters and processing
conditions. Corebank has a comprehensive list of predefined product components, including pricing and interest profiles that are used and re-used in the definition and release of new products
within the product portfolio.
Fidelity Profile 1. Lower total cost of ownership 2. Improved time to market 3. Increased reliability and unlimited scalability 4. Eased integration 5. Improved customer experience.
Fidelity Systematics 1. Feature rich functionality 2. Unrivaled market share, global install base amongst top tier banks 3. Nearly fourty years of development and implementation expertise 4. Proven in-house and
outsourced deployment options.
Fiserv ICBS 1. ICBS is a flexible, parameter driven, solution which enables users to launch and create new products quickly (including multiple products in a day) to respond to changing market demand.
2. Real-time retail banking and consumer finance core processing in a single core system for banks that want to offer consumer finance and vice versa. 3. SOA-based for integration with Fiserv
and third party cores and home grown banking host systems and applications. Integration proven in production with over sixty clients worldwide. 4. ICBS is robust and scalable to meet business
growth from de novos to clients running eight million accounts. 5. Integrated suite of products for multi-country, and multi-currency core processing, smart client tellering, customer interaction
management/BPM and business intelligence for global financial services institutions. Business process oriented with business process created and delivered across multiple banking channels
via integrated customer interaction management solution: Fiserv Aperio.
i-flex solutions Flexcube 1. Rich functional footprint covering the needs of wide variety of banking models and niche segments like virtual banks, central banks, retail and commercial banks. 2. Strong SOA capabilities
with Process Orchestration, webservices, open standard based technology 3. Rich functionality and compliance to regional requirements, with deployments in over 120 countries 4. Ability to
integrate and co-exist with diverse application landscapes 5. Ability to scale from needs of small green field deployments to addressing needs of tier one institutions.
Infosys Finacle 1. Differentiated Product Spread - Finacle core banking solution offers an unlimited palette of features for banks to design and deploy products for varying market segments. The product
bundling capabilities of the solution offers a wide range of possibilities for banks to create products with innovative features. The facilities provided for differential pricing, channel rules and
customization through Finacle Studio - the scripting engine, empower banks to continuously innovate and extend their suite of products, across segments. 2. Agile Operations - The Service
Oriented Architecture (SOA) enables the IT team at the bank to effect changes without touching the base code, ensuring lesser vendor dependency and faster adaptability to changing business
conditions. 3. Robust Cross-sell Framework - The CIF and CRM capabilities in Finacle offer a unified view of the customer across the entire solution and across multiple back-end applications,
enabling the bank to view the customer from a completely informed angle. This empowers banks to effectively manage customer relationships and aggressively explore cross-sell opportunities.
4. Increased Operational Efficiencies and Productivity - Finacle core banking solution supports business events automation and process orchestration, thus eliminating manual tasks and reduc-
ing process time. The elimination of error and data redundancies also results in increased branch productivity. Straight Through Processing (STP) abilities enhance reduction in turnaround and
processing time, increasing output and enabling speedy completion of tasks. 5. Scalability - The Finacle core banking solution offers unparalleled scalablity demonstrated through lab bench-
marks as well as its support for some of the largest retail banking live sites in the world. 6. Business process management capability - The solution includes business process management
capability through the built-in PEAS framework which enables the orchestration of business processes and services.
The 5 most important strengths of your system? (part two)
Company Solution
Misys Equation 1. Rock solid, proven reliability 2. Breadth and depth of functionality 3. Flexibility in terms of product design & reporting 4. Integrated branch automation applications (with full off-line capabilities)
5. Scalability (from single site to thousands of branches).
Misys Midas 1. Breadth and depth of functionality. 2. Proven reliability with over 500 live sites across 85 countries. 3. Integration capabilities. 4. Track record in delivery/implementations. 5. Proven upgrade
path.
Nucleus FinnOne 1. A Specialist software vendor operating solely in the Banking & Financial Services domain. 2. Global recognition in the specialized domain of lending - FinnOne was ranked as the No. 1 selling
Lending System in the world, in the calendar year 2006, by International Banking Systems, UK. 3. A single integrated (yet modular) platform for the processing of most types of loan products
- with complete loan life-cycle coverage. 4. Proven scalability (volume processing) and extensibility (product coverage) in lending. 5. Experience with cash management projects and deployments
at tier 1 banks like Citibank, ABN AMRO and Standard Chartered Bank. 6. Corporate and financial maturity of the company. Been in existence for 20+ years and has demonstrated year-on-year
Polaris Intellect Suite 1. It is a client Service Platform enabling fully integrated relationship management, allows customer to design their customer experience 2. Teller to Seller transformation capability. Fully inte-
grated, customer attribute based Teller system 3. Modular design and SOA backplane makes it unique in the market place today, compared to competing products. Built on open standards and
modular design - highly modularized. This architecture allows for non disruptive modernization of legacy core banking systems in a measured and steeped approach. 4. Fully integrated workflow
and highly effective operations management leading to straight through processing. 5. Single sign on, 24x7, scalable and secured system.
SAP AG SAP TB SAP main value proposition is based on the delivery of more than just a piece of software that covers only the current features and functions requirements. Features and functions are important,
but a commodity. The important value for a customer making a large investment in core banking software is how the software will meet the future business and technology requirements which
today are not known. SAP therefore stresses the following topics in addition to functionality: 1. Standard software SAP believes in the long term positive effects of using true standard software
to cover standard/commodity processes, and to use the same basis to allow for innovate based on components, reuse and a strong technology framework. Clear release upgrade cycles, with
elaborate software logistics to protect customer investments, both in terms of own development, using different release stages of different parts of the SAP stack, and all configuration and date
existing in one release One code base, one product base without distinction of retail vs. corporate functionality, thus enabling future convergence of product and services offerings to both
retail and corporate customers 2. SOA/technology proposition Technology stack separation: application independence and decoupling from the underlying hardware and software platforms,
be it operating system and database system. Business application interfaces independent of technology and environment, enable applications in different environments, may it be zOS/Cobol,
Java or .Net to access the same business functionality. Open standards communication having interoperability with Websphere, .Net and other platforms. Complete Service Orientation, in
the internal development model, in the development of new services, in the deployment of services and in the industry interaction. 3. Integration/best of breed proposition SAP provides a broad
portfolio of solutions ranging from basic ERP products through CRM through core banking back office to front end applications, price optimization, etc. The portfolio has been built organically,
creating a consistent, integrated, componentized software and platform landscape. Each solution can be implemented stand-alone delivering a best-of-breed functionality or as a part of an inte-
grated solution in a long-term SAP application landscape strategy. 4. Flexibility/scalability SAP delivers a highly flexible, parameterizable solution covering different types of business (retail/cor-
porate) allowing customer to combine these business in one single system. It is also one solution for both small and large banks, allowing banks to grow within being limited by their IT systems.
The development methodology allows a strict division between the standard code and customer extensions, allowing customers to extend the system without affecting the upgradeability on long
term. 5. Solution architecture The SAP solutions have, by design, a number of solution architectural foundations which are part of the foundation architecture. - Multi-entity. It is possible to have
a number of legal entities sharing the same system instance, thus limiting the needs to run separate systems for different branches. - Multi-country. It is possible to have a number of different
banks in different countries sharing the same system instance, also in case they are in different timezones and cut-off times. - Multi-currency. It is possible to have have multiple currencies in the
system. Cash management hierarchies can include accounts with different currencies. Automatic currency exchanges are performed during movements between accounts with different curren-
cies. - Multi-language. It is possible to have multiple user languages in the system, enabling usage of the same system in different language areas. All parameterization can be done in different
languages, adapting the user interface to the original language of the user. Customer communication can be performed in the language of the customer, independent of country of the bank.
Multi-channel. SAP offers through SAP NetWeaver and its open infrastructure and a rich variety of interfaces to enable multi-channel integration independent of channel application. During the
design of the applications, channel specific processing rules, if there are any at all, have been made configurable through parameterization. - 24x7 availability The solution offers a 24x7 availabil-
Financial Services
ity with real time capabilities. There is no need to close the system during end-of-day processing.
SunGard Symbols SunGards System Access is a comprehensive and integrated solution covering wholesale and retail banking for both conventional and Islamic banking operations. These give banks a wide
breadth of banking products to offer and the flexibility required to innovate and become product leaders. Built on Open platform and latest technologies, SunGards System Access give banks
the ability to introduce products and services quickly into the market, much faster than mainframe-based systems. The Service-oriented Architecture design of SunGards System Access gives
banks the ability to integrate data, applications, and business processes across multiple 3rd party and legacy systems. Customer-centric architecture gives banks a complete, 360-degree view of
their customers across products and applications. This gives banks a better view of overall profitability and risk exposure through MIS consolidations. SunGards System Access has been imple-
mented in several customer sites across the globe. It is multi-language and multi-currency and has in-built international banking best practices that can help banks achieve operations efficiency
at par with the best banks in the world.
59
the way we see it
60
The 5 most important strengths of your system? (part three)
Company Solution
TCS TCS BaNCS 1. Ease and speed of Implementation 2. Performance and Scalability 3. Breadth and Depth of Functionality and Extensibility 4. Reliability and Availability 5. Agility and flexibility of Architecture.
Temenos T24 1. Breadth of functional coverage. 2. System agility for new product/channel/geography/process deployment. 3. Modern and wide technology support leading to scalability and resilience of
deployment. 4. A depth of functionality which matches the breadth. This is driven by ongoing product investment. 5. The packaging of best practice example functionality in the Temenos Model
Bank structure together with easier deployment tooling to help banks achieve their objectives in a faster and safer manner.
Temenos TCB 1. A data architecture based on the global IBM standard: Financial Services Data Model. 2. An N-tier application architecture that reduces development and maintance, and adapts to changing
technology standards. 3. Modern development standards based on componentization and re-usability. 4. A platform independent technology built for any business scale. 5. Maximum flexibility
through a core, parameter-based Product Builder.
TietoEnator CBS 1. Product Composition, allowing business product managers to create and customise new products (loans, saving, cards) without the involvement of IT staff and a minimal launching time.
2. Service-oriented architecture, component based and event-driven accounting engine. Designed for sophisticated and complex tier 1 and tier 2 banks. 3. Multi-everything (channel, bank, cur-
rency, language, calendar, cross-border processing). 4. A variety of integration methods are supported by a connectivity framework for both on-line and background interfaces. 5. The modularity
and flexibility of the architecture is specifically designed with low TCO (total cost of ownership) in mind. The cost for maintaining the core components could be shared across several institutions
under a common product strategy. Low processing and operation cost - regarding both low hardware and software resource consumption and simplicity of operation.
T-Systems MBS; GEOS 1. Modular and modern design. 2. Excellent Fit for Retail/Automobile Banks. 3. High Volume capacity and security. 4. High actuality because of a practical relevant development (Usergroup).
How do you act on the trend towards service orientation and business process management? (part one)
Company Solution
Accenture Alnova The technical design criteria of the Alnova solution are aligned with the basic principles of service oriented architectures (SOA). These principles are translated in a series of guides at the time
of SOA implementation. The fundamental components that provide these capabilities are Alnova Architectures, Alnova Multi-channel Technical Architecture (AMTA) at client and middle-tier level
and Alnova Server Technical Architecture (ASTA) at back-end level, complemented by a modular design of the Back-End. This design has been tested with success in multiple implementations,
in which, the services provided by the back-end were integrated via the Multi-channel architecture, at times with the Financial Terminal of Accenture, or with the office channels of the client
(integrated via Web Services), and with other alternative channels.
Alnova is now in the road towards an evolution in order to reinforce current SOA capabilities of the Alnova Solution in accordance with a process-centric approach. A key challenge is the
decoupling between logical model and implementation in order to align software solution to business need, and the Business Process has to be the key element for it.
One of the main challenges is to find a rational approach for a suitable combination of assets and products in terms of economy and leveraging synergies. Suitable integration scenarios must
be designed in order to get a rational usage of own capabilities together with third party expert products. Alnova is counting on IBM collaboration around the exploration of adequate integration
paths.
Callata & Wouters Thaler Our Thaler solution is full SOA. We have a BPM tool which allows to build your own process flows into our banking solution. It uses the different Thaler services to orchestrate the banks
business processes.
Delta Informatique Delta-Bank We implement service orientation through the usage of Java and SOA. We do not support business process orchestration and business process management.
Fidelity Corebank Corebank was designed to participate in a Service Oriented Architecture. Corebank is technologically very open, and can participate in SOAs built on a variety of tools and styles. Corebanks
API structure is implemented as approximately 150 EJBs with well over 1000 methods in total. Access classes also exist that encapsulate the logic to locate and call the EJBs and these classes
can be used as the faade for the system if desired. Both methods can coexist.
Corebank does not have a built-in workflow mechanism, but instead has been designed to expose a clean, well-structured and technologically open interface that can work with various generic
business process orchestration tools. Corebank API functions have been designed to be big enough that they dont unnecessarily complicate creating larger-grained services, but small enough
that they dont cause problems for workflow tools and decrease re-usability. Corebanks API structure has evolved specifically to make it easier to flexibly aggregate API functions into larger-
grained services. Micro-workflow tools can be used to assemble Corebank API functions into larger services, which can be highly reusable, while macro workflow tools can be used at a higher
level for Business Process Management. Corebank API functions, being Java method calls, can also be exposed as Web Services, if desired, by using tools provided with WAS to generate the
necessary WSDL.
Fidelity Profile Profile can be accessed via IFX messages via the Xpress Enterprise Services layer. It can participate in process orchestration via this enterprise services layer. Profile integrates to any business
process management tool via the Xpress integration layer.
Fidelity Systematics Systematics is a services-enabled host system. It offers process orchestration via integration with FIS Xpress SOA integration layer and has native case management capabilities.
Fiserv ICBS ICBS is built around a service oriented architecture. ICBS functionality is manifested in the form of XML/IFX based messages, which are combined into services and exposed through Fiservs
CBS Communicator integration hub. These services can then be combined into business processes and consumed by both Fiserv and third party front- and back-end applications and systems
to integrate disparate systems and channels in an enterprise.
CBS Communicator is currently in use in over 50 financial services institutions and is an integral part of Fiserv Aperio, Fiserv CBS Worldwides multi-channel customer interaction and business
process management solution. Business processes are created and deployed via the Fiserv Aperio Business Process Management solution. Aperio comes with 300+ pre-packaged financial
services business processes which cover key areas such as new account open, financial transactions, customer updates and complaint management. Business processes and workflows can
Financial Services
also be built via drag and drop modeling to create customized processes. Thus a single process can be built and deployed across multiple channels.
the way we see it
61
62
How do you act on the trend towards service orientation and business process management? (part two)
Company Solution
i-flex solutions Flexcube i-flex sees SOA as the next evolution of technology, which enables financial institutions to take a process oriented view to their application landscape, and ease the ever increasing complexities
of integration within the enterprise. As financial institutions look for achieving customer intimacy and competitive differentiation while maintaining compliance to regulation and keeping costs
down, customers are taking a hard look at their business processes, to find areas of improvement. As a first step customers look for a ready repository of business processes to benchmark
against. For this i-flex has brought together its experience in working with over 775 customers across 130 counties, in publishing i-flex Process Framework for Banking (iPFB), a rich repository of
business processes built on global best practices across the entire array of banking functions. This repository is built on Oracle BPA suite. As a second step, i-flex has released the next genera-
tion of its application offerings which take advantage of the business processes documented in iPFB, and provides executable BPEL processes and underlying web services. i-flex has recently
launched the SOA enabled release of FLEXCUBE with web services available for almost every business function in the suite. Thirdly, with process orchestration comes the need for having user
interfaces which are task based, and are agnostic of business logic, which makes them more amenable for change in case of change in business processes. With this in mind, FLEXCUBE comes
with a new Task Oriented UI which is based on industry standard Java, and XML. i-flex leverages the Oracle Fusion Middleware stack for Process Management. Processes are documented in
Oracle Business Process Architect (BPA) suite, and are measurable via Oracle Activity Measurement (BAM) toolset. Additionally business processes documented in Oracle BPA suite can serve
as critical input into the Oracle Governance, Risk and Compliance framework for enterprise wide Governance, Risk Management and Compliance initiatives.
Infosys Finacle Finacles architecture has been designed using SOA principles. The solutions modular architecture allows it to expose granular business functionality as services which process requests based
on business parameters. Benefits include the capability to orchestrate services to create new functionality using a transaction coordinator. These services are exposed to other applications
through the integration framework thereby separating application logic from the front end enabling addition of delivery channels without re-writing back end code. Current functionality supported
through services can be classified into multiple areas like customer relationship management, demand deposit, loans, bill payment, teller operations, back office operations, limits & collateral
management. Finacle provides process orchestration through its GUI based business process definition and deployment tool called PEAS using which the banks can parameterise and deploy
the business processes that suit their environment. PEAS has the following components - a modeler, process execution engine, process monitoring and administration and lastly the process
execution audit component. PEAS is based on the BPML specification. Using the above mentioned components banks can carry out the following steps in defining their processes: definition
using the process automator, deployment and execution using the process deployment and execution engine.
Finacle interfaces with Infosys Influx Business Process Management tool to provide business process management capabilty. Finacle uses the Process Execution Analysis and Simulation
Engine (PEAS) in Influx based on BPML for modelling, and BPEL for execution, monitoring and administration of business processes.
Misys Equation Misys has adopted a low risk, evolutionary approach to moving towards an SOA environment. Midas Plus and Equation are created extensively in a J2EE and IBM WebSphere environment for
increased flexibility and simplified management. A large number of APIs provide excellent integration capabilities. Furthermore, new modules of Midas Plus and Equantion will be created through
Misys new component-based core banking technology, Misys BankFusion. Misys BankFusion provides the tools for Misys to develop the next generation of Midas applications within a Service
Oriented Architecture. This strategy will make the functionality available as service based components, offering a higher degree of customisation, platform independence and a mechanism for
preserving any tailoring when the software is upgraded. Adherence to SOA principles was and is a key design point of the BankFusion platform.
BankFusion is a process centric platform, all functionality in a BankFusion solution is delivered by a process. BankFusion supports the ability to orchestrate its own and external services through
a graphical editor. The resulting business process can incorporate both interactive and non-interactive tasks. The business process may be long running - spanning multiple user sessions and
cross channel. However it is a key principle of BankFusion that it is non-prescriptive, and bearing in mind many organisations will wish to make there own choice of orchestration tools, it is
possible to replace BankFusions own orchestration with a 3rd party. All BankFusion processes can be published as WSDL interfaces. Invocation can be through SOAP and RMI. The services
are stateless and transactional and can readily be orchestrated by any tool/engine supporting the WSDL interface.
The BankFusion platform provides tools for designing, instrumenting and monitoring its own services and work flows, and these are fully integrated with the core solution. For some installations
this may be all that is needed but BankFusion does not aspire to be an enterprise wide BPM system. We fully expect Banks to make their own enterprise decisions in this area. By adhering to
J2E design patterns and exposing all services through standard WSDL interfaces the task of integrating with 3rd party BPM is simplified.
Nucleus FinnOne We are in a movement to open platform architecture with progressive service orchestration. Our FinnOne solution is already workflow enabled; with consistent improvements in BPM capabilities.
Polaris Intellect Suite Polaris is one of the early adopters of SOA and commenced work on SOA in 2003. Intellect Suite comprises of 56+ departmental solutions using the principles of SOA and comes complete
with its own security, integration layers. Intellect Workflow is used internally to orchestrate Workflow.
Most Modules have APIs for Integration. Integrator, is a middleware for integration with external systems. Some of our generic product services like Fees and Charges are SOA enabled.
Also we have an expertise center for SOA.
We have done substantial research work on Process Orchestration with various BPEL vendors and plan to implement as part of our product roadmap as well as on need basis.
We have expertise on IBM process server, Oracle BPEL, Active BPEL.
Intellect Workflow acts as a Business process management layer, orchestrating the workflow between various functions of core banking like origination, Lending and collection.
How do you act on the trend towards service orientation and business process management? (part three)
Company Solution
SAP AG SAP TB SAPs Enterprise Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA) addresses the business issue that most companies are facing - extending existing IT assets to support business change and innovation,
while lowering total cost of ownership. Enabled by the SAP NetWeaver platform, Enterprise SOA provides an open outline for adaptive business solutions. Building on the benefits of Web
services, it delivers on the promise of services-oriented architectures, enabling both flexibility and business efficiency without increasing costs. With Enterprise SOA, companies have a cost-
effective blueprint for composing innovative new applications by extending existing systems, while maintaining a level of flexibility that makes future process changes cost-effective. SAP offers
comprehensive, standards-based solutions for banks in its SAP for Banking solutions portfolio. This portfolio can include a business process platform (BPP) for banking that combines the power
of the SAP NetWeaver platform with industry-specific business and banking solutions. Although Enterprise SOA provides a strong promise for banks and an attractive means for future develop-
ment of SAP partners businesses, neither SAP nor its customers and partners can afford to discard existing solutions and start again from scratch. The aim of the BPP for banking is not only
to provide complete banking solutions but also to put banks on the fast track to an enterprise services architecture. SAPs existing solution architecture is the starting point for the Enterprise
SOA transition. During this transition process, SAP will open the solution architecture by harmonizing business processes, decoupling user interfaces, and making business objects and services
accessible through open, standards-based access mechanisms. The transition process will ultimately lead to an architecture that offers maximum flexibility and powerful functions for building
doing in relation to their team members. This is what delivers the people empowerment.
- Business Workflow, the SAP Web Application Server workflow tool, which is used to automate the busines processes taking place within an SAP component and integrate the SAP users with
the business process. This is what delivers the workflow empowerment within the SAP components.
- Cross-Component BPM to automate the cross applications processes taking place in a heterogeneous system landscape. This delivers the total Business Process Empowerment in a system
landscape.
BPM covers the full process lifecycle: design, automation, execution, monitoring, analysis and optimization.
SunGard Symbols SunGards System Access universal banking solution is built on an open platform and designed on SOA. Enterprise infrastructure integration is facilitated through our proven architecture.
SunGards System Access universal banking solution includes System Access Customer Service Manager that provides Business Process Orchestration (BPO). This gives the ability to orches-
trate and control the execution of a business process across different systems and organizational boundaries. SunGards System Access Customer Service Manager has built-in BPM capabili-
ties. System Access Customer Service Manager is fully integrated with the System Access Symbols core banking solution.
TCS TCS BaNCS TCS BaNCS is SOA enabled across the entire Product Set which includes Commercial Banking, Capital Markets and Insurance. Over 2000 services are available through Biztalk, Websphere and
Weblogic adaptors.
TCS BaNCS incorporates a STP engine which manages orchestration of atomic level fine grain services at the application level, coarse grain services which are composed of multiple fine grain
services are exposed via adapters and BPEL is used to orchestrate coarse grain services across one or more applications.
Additionally TCS BaNCS Channels solution comes with a User Interaction Manager which allows user/customer interactions to be workflowed. This is an additional layer that sits above the BPEL
orchestration layer.
Temenos T24 T24 has an inbuilt capacity to operate in an SOA environment since it exposes all of its functionality as web services which can be addressed by other systems. Temenos continues to monitor
industry initiatives and trends in this area to help to define how this technical system capacity can be best deployed by banks. Various technology proof of concept activities are underway
accompanied by an ongoing engagement with clients, prospects, partners, analysts and other industry bodies.
T24 can be address by a BPEL engine. This technical capacity is being exploited by ongoing client implementation work and technical proof of concept activities being carried out. Temenos also
offers a Business Consulting service centred around BPM activities which is aimed at supporting the implementation and subsequent use of T24. The use of process orchestration technology
and approaches is inherent in this offering. Temenos uses 3rd party tools for BPM activities.
Financial Services
63
the way we see it
64
How do you act on the trend towards service orientation and business process management? (part four)
Company Solution
Temenos TCB TEMENOS CoreBanking currently supports most of the SOA standards and significant funding is being allocated in the development programs to expand the coverage of SOA standards
and capabilities. The publication of Corebanking services is currently oriented to the integration of an overall banking solution. The development effort in this direction will also result in a higher
usability of services in the orchestration of a process through BPEL or other standards. BPM tools are not included in CoreBanking.
TietoEnator CBS The Core Banking Suite is built using open standards and a modern Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA) combined with a processing engine built using an effective Event-Driven Architecture
(EDA). TietoEnators strategy towards SOA, is firstly to divide SOA in two domains, Integration and Business Process Management (BPM).
Our SOA Integration strategy is divided in sub-domains, such e.g. Client (MDM), General Ledger, etc. The sub-domains are implemented in the SOA integration strategy by Proof of Concept
teams, which are guided by a general policy. Most of our systems rely on the ability to control the internal processing. For our Core Banking System, the focus is on accounting; for other
systems it is usually around clearing, payment and settlement. We also support orchestration outside our system on the basis of the services that we provide.
The BPM domain is to be implemented in our mortgage suite. The experience, knowledge and functional offers will then be implemented in full scale in all system domains. Currently we provide
more than 1300 business services for use by potential subscribers of Core Banking. We also play an active role in the international arena related to SOA, i.e. OOPSLA07 on SOA with a focus on
harvesting patterns and architectural design decisions to support the evolution of SOA in practice. We typically rely on external standardized BPM tools, such as BEA Aqualogic and Websphere
Process Server as well as our own internal processing engines for the optimized processes close to Core Banking (i.e. the accounting engine).
T-Systems MBS; GEOS According to customer expectations/client working groups. Software is designed in a modular way to satisfy SOA requirements. We already provide Web Services. We support the process
orchestration with our web configurator. This tool enables the operation of services according to the business process.
What are the major developments that you are planning for your system during 2008? (part one)
Company Solution
Accenture Alnova Technological areas of evolution: - Continuous SOA alignment for our technical architectures Business areas for evolution: - SOA business applications evolution aligned with our view of a High
Performance Banking - Credit services evolution to support Credit BPO field Software vendor reliability: - Industrialization (Product development and Delivery center) - Packaging - Delivery
Accelerators.
Callata & Wouters Thaler Integration with SAP - Netweaver Java development - new user friendly WUI.
Delta Informatique Delta-Bank Fully Java based solution - Flexible accounting scheme.
Fidelity Corebank The next release of Corebank, Release 4.5 is targeted for 1st quarter 2008. Below are listed some of the targeted enhancments: - Enhancements for combined statements - Enhancements to
value-based authorisations - Enhancements to fee funds sufficiency check and retry - Enhancements to interest funds sufficiency check and retry - Enhancements to delinquency loan payment
Fidelity Profile Credit card funtionality - Building compilers for Java - Reverse mortgage functionality - Commercial cash management.
Fiserv ICBS Within core: additional functionality for enhanced control and research, product packaging, credit and payment management and auditing to enable banks to deliver better customer service,
profitability, efficiency and risk management. Also fully integrated trade, treasury and capital markets functionality within ICBS (ongoing development post launch in October 2007). New releases
of Fiserv Aperio with additional customer interaction and business process management including analytics. Fiserv is also set to offer a full front-to-back Islamic banking solution based on its
ICBS and Fiserv Aperio products. In Europe, Fiserv will continue to offer BPO in financial services using ICBS core systems.
i-flex solutions Flexcube Oracle and i-flex are investing in a broad range of areas to continuously enhance the value we provide to our customers. These investments include 1. Functional enhancements in the applica-
tions to meet the ever changing banking environment 2. Technology enhancements in adoption of additional components of Fusion Middleware 3. Pre-integration of our application assets with
Oracle Application Integration Architecture (AIA) 4. Enhancement of our process framework to provide an industry reference model for banking.
Infosys Finacle Finacles strategy continues to focus on delivering leadership & innovation in the banking solution space. We see banking solutions playing a role of enabling agents in business transformation
programs that will make banks into responsive, high performance businesses. Finacles product strategy will thus continue to evolve towards: Delivering a componentised, maleable SOA archi-
tecture facilitating growth & expansion; Delivering a comprehensive product factory that uses intelligent business, process & technology building blocks for bundling and advanced relationship
pricing capabilities; Delivering a reliable, high-performant information & knowledge store relating to customers, banks products & services; An integrated, IP enabled 24*7 scalable & open multi-
channel platform; Enhance CRM in financial planning, loyalty mgmt, Integrated Channel Management; Delivering innovative productivity & efficiency features; Comprehensive support for modern
IP enabled & wireless devices; Support for multi-entity capability; Delivering end-to-end Wealth Management solutions; Islamic banking.
Misys Equation The Equation roadmap for the next 12 months will see a broad range of functional improvements in multiple areas, as well as the coexistence phase on the new Misys BankFusion platform.
This will deliver Equation components on a J2EE-based core banking platform which will provide a common framework for all future banking development. Based around an SOA architecture,
it is a highly flexible, interoperable and scalable platform.
Misys Midas Enhancements to Global Processing such as local time and date stamp for transactions, automated back up and restore; new regulatory reporting; Global cash management engine enabling
banks to deliver cash pooling services across multiple currencies and countries; support for a range of regional and local regulatory requirements and standards, e.g. MiFID, SEPA and SWIFT,
and Euro adoption.
Financial Services
65
the way we see it
66
What are the major developments that you are planning for your system during 2008? (part two)
Company Solution
Nucleus FinnOne Nucleus corporate vision is to be a leading global player in its specialty arena of Financial Lending - addressing all aspects of the assets business. Within the solutions portfolio, new and
improved versions of Nucleus products - FinnOne Lending, FinnOne Collections and FinnOne Customer Acquisition System - are continuously being released.
New system tools - a communication engine, single sign-on features and loan calculators are also being released. Two new business segments are being addressed by new products that have
recently come into our solutions portfolio - FinnOne Forecaster (for enhanced Business Analytics) and FinnOne Operational Risk (addressing Basel II requirements for Operational Risk manage-
ment).
Polaris Intellect Suite Development phase is more or less completed during 2002-2005. Currently we are in the go to market phase and will be refining the product based on localized requirements such as
regulations etc.
SAP AG SAP TB Further enhancements in terms of the business process platform for banking concerning functionality (based on customer requirements).
SunGard Symbols SYMBOLS core banking next 12 months initiatives: - Islamic Banking version of SYMBOLS core banking; - XML API of common banking business logic for delivery channels, branch front-
end solution and co-existence with other legacy applciations - Multi purpose lines products enabling banks to configure unique credit lines and products for each client, SME and Corporates
- Common Fee module across all banking core banking products and service offerings - SEPA support CSM Related Enhancements: SOA based Complaince Framework: The compliance
framework is envisaged to provide adherence to Regulatory and Complaince norms and provide Risk Management in the Banks through a set of policies and procedures that can be defined and
managed by the using various controls like Criteria definitions, Limits management, Collateral management, Rules governing Basel accords, SOX and AML controls which will be orchestrated
via Business rules and process flows. This framework is evisaged to provide Real-time Monitoring and control of Risk exposures with respect to products, services, transactions and customer
demographics Comparison, analysis, decision-making and prevention or initiation of corrective business/operational transactions/ actions. Enhancements to Deposits Management system
based on SOA supporting in the areas: Overdraft management Cheque processing - inward and outward clearing For each of these deposit products Banks can provide flexible Interest, fee,
tax and service charge computations plans Liquidation and unutilised deposit processing Enhancements to Payments System supporting: Complete support for Domestic payments including
flexible payment formats Mass payments Direct debit mandates Support for RTGS, ACH, Interbank clearing Queuing & Repair features SWIFT Support. All of the above features will
leverage on the Sungard System Accesss SOA Framework for Banking and the related fundamental (existing) building blocks like Unified Customer Insight, Customer Relationship Management
(CRM), Origination Framework, Pricing engine. Card Management Related Enhancements: SOA Based Card Center (Front-office): Leveraging on Sungard System Accesss SOA Framework for
Banking and its fundamental building blocks, the front office features of Card Management system will be redefined to provide various Card services to support the front-office needs. A single
unified Customer insight across banking services and Card services will provide dash board features to ehnace the Customer service across contact centers, Relationship Managers, elf-service
channels and Product Managers. Card Origination processes: Card Orgination processes across customer on-boarding, Application processing and Account management will be made available
using the CSM (Customer Service Manager) Origination framework.
TCS TCS BaNCS Cash Management cross border notional pooling and financial supply chain management - Product Bundling and Preferential Pricing - Mobile Banking - Mobile Payments.
Temenos T24 Some of these initiatives are not currently publicly disclosed and we cannot therefore discuss them here. Public ones include Structured Products Manufactured Further CRM enhancements.
TietoEnator CBS Cash Management: - Financial messaging support enhancements such as XML-Swift messages based on the ISO20022 standard initiative to establish a Universal Financial Industry message
scheme (UNIFI); - New solutions on platform: Cash forecasting and financial supply chain; - Product composer for business users on our Multi-Channel Platform (web-based); - More flexible and
configurable event engine; - Possibly deployment support for Oracle.
Release 6.4.1 will be released in January 2008. New and enhanced functionality are: - Non-Approval platform (for failed transactions and manual acceptance of certain transactions); - Additional
Swift messages (XML format); - Bulk changes; - Retrospective changes; - Retrospective processing; - Prices up to 18 digits; - 2 or 3 decimals depending on currency; - Cash Management
improvements.
Releases after January 2008 have not been planned in detail yet. Some of the functionality currently being considered: - Extensive framework for verification of data; - Possibilities for 2nd author-
ization; - Multiple base rates per product; - Maintenance of general services; - Calculation of costs based on boundaries.
T-Systems MBS; GEOS SEPA Direct Debit - flat rate withholding tax (Abgeltungssteuer) - pre-financing for retailers (Hndlereinkaufsfinanzierung) - disclosure in relationshop to the Solvabilittsverordnung - controlling
of interests (duration, rates) of the asset ledger - integration mortgage stock register.
Financial Services the way we see it