Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
a b s t r a c t
China depends on naphtha (derived from oil) as the main feedstock for ethylene plants, resulting in margins that are
negatively co-related with the price of oil. Clearly, light hydrocarbons provide cost advantages over the conventional
naphtha feedstock. Consequently, the recovery of light hydrocarbons from renery gas has been gathering more and
more signicance. Nonetheless, the cryogenic separation needs low process temperatures, substantially increasing
the refrigeration load requirements and, attendantly, the compression requirements associated with the refrigera-
tion system. In this paper, the cold energy of liqueed natural gas (LNG) is applied to light hydrocarbons cryogenic
separation process to replace the compression refrigeration system on the basis of one China renery. The results
show that LNG can provide 14,373 kW cold energy for the separation process, resulting in a direct compression power
saving of 7973 kW and making the utilization rate of LNG cold energy as high as 71.9%.
2014 The Institution of Chemical Engineers. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: LNG; Cold energy; Light hydrocarbons; Cryogenic separation; Compression refrigeration; HEN
Corresponding author. Tel.: +86 020 87112044; fax: +86 20 87114677.
E-mail addresses: liyajun@scut.edu.cn, 939687668@qq.com (Y. Li).
Received 9 October 2013; Received in revised form 24 March 2014; Accepted 11 April 2014
Available online 26 April 2014
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cherd.2014.04.009
0263-8762/ 2014 The Institution of Chemical Engineers. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
chemical engineering research and design 9 3 ( 2 0 1 5 ) 632639 633
cracking (FCC), delayed coking unit (DCU), hydrocracking unit is introduced as top reux feed into the demethanizer
(HCU), petrol and diesel hydrotreating unit (HDT), and con- (D-301). The bottom product stream from demethanizer (D-
tinuous catalytic reforming (CCR). As shown in Table 1, a 301) goes through deethanizer (D-401), ethylene fractionator
stream of renery gas at a rate of 81.05 tonnes per hour (t/h) (D-402), depropanizer (D-403), and debutanizer (D-405) in
(68 104 t/a) comprised of methane and signicant quanti- sequence to separate the heavier hydrocarbons, thereby com-
ties of light hydrocarbons (C2C4 hydrocarbons) contaminated pleting the separation process (Li and Yin, 2009; Wang et al.,
by hydrogen, inert gases, acidic impurities such as H2 S or 1996).
CO2 , water and quantities of C5 and heavier hydrocarbons are
processed to recover light hydrocarbons. 2.3. The cold energy distribution
The treatment methods of compression, caustic wash-
ing, purication and drying have been used to remove The light hydrocarbons cryogenic separation process is sim-
non-hydrocarbons, impurities, and other constituents that ulated by Aspen Plus engineering software. As shown in
adversely affect the properties of nished products or reduce Tables 3 and 4, the refrigerant system provides refrigeration
the efciency of the conversion processes. Afterwards, as load for the heat exchangers by the vaporization of refrigerant
shown in Table 2, the light hydrocarbons of 78.56 t/h, 288 K, at different temperatures.
3.45 MPa can be obtained.
F-603
T=171.7 E-351
P=0.1169 F-601 TV1
E-326 E-1313 E-313 F-602
T=211.0
E-311
P=0.6977
T=194.7 T=194.7
P=0.3637 P=0.3637
TV3 TV2 T=222.4 T=222.4
E-445 T=260.7
E-310 E-401
P=0.395
TV5
E-405 F-502 E-604
E-315
E-605 TV4 TV6
F-501 T=232.7 T=260.5
P=0.14 E-403 E-442
P=0.395
T=260.7
TV8
TV9 P=0.395
TV7 T=272.4
T=262.8
T=260.7 P=0.57
P=0.395 L/E-316
T=305.2 F-503
P=0.57
T=268.6
T=260.2 T=268.4 P=0.585
T=291.6
T=232.7 P=0.975 E-457 TV2
P=0.14 T=315.2
E-446 F-504
P=1.86 E-603
E-501 E-502 TV1
Units: G-501 E/L-321 E-602
Temperature T: K T=291.6
Pressure P: MPa T=292.1 P=0.975 T=273.3
TV3 E-220
P=0.585
The total cold load that the hot streams in HEN need is to start where it is most constrained. If the problem has
is 14,373 kW. In order to meet the requirements, LNG of pinch point, the problem is most constrained at the pinch. If
110,000 kg/h, namely 92.4 104 t/a is needed, and it can there is no pinch, the problem is called threshold problem that
provide 19,978 kW cold energy. The components of LNG are: needs either hot utility or cold utility but not both. As shown
88.77 mol% methane, 7.54 mol% ethane, 2.59 mol% propane, in Fig. 6, it is a threshold problem with minimum heat trans-
0.45 mol% i-butane, 0.56 mol% n-butane, 0.09 mol% nitrogen. fer temperature difference (Tmin ) 15.5 (in pseudo-pinch) that
Considering that the heat capacity of LNG varies greatly when needs just heat utility. The minimum requirement for hot util-
it is vaporized from 128.2 K to 273.2 K, LNG is divided into three ity for this optimal value is 5605 kW and there is no need for
sections to estimate its heat capacity and cold load. cold utility.
A HEN is a system of several heat exchangers connected The HEN enables several streams to exchange sufcient
together. In the design of HEN, the pinch technology leads amounts of thermal energy so that they can attain the
towards obtaining the minimum values for several parame- respective temperature values (targets) specied by process
ters of the process such as utility types and levels, minimum requirements. As shown in Fig. 7, the grid diagram of com-
number of heat exchanger units and their areas, and operating pleted design for optimal value of Tmin is obtained by Aspen
and capital costs. The philosophy in the pinch design method Plus and Aspen Pinch engineering software. Hot streams are
Fig. 6 Hot and cold composite curve at minimum heat transfer temperature difference of 15.5.
located in the upper side of the grid diagram and cold stream suggest that the total exergy loss associated with heat transfer
is in the lower side. is 5766.4 kW (52.4 kWh/t), while the available cryogenic exergy
As shown in Fig. 7, the hot streams are cooled to the tar- during the process of LNG changing from the initial state of
get temperatures by LNG cold energy, and the cold utility is 8 MPa, 128.2 K to the nal state of 7.5 MPa, 273.2 K is 92.3 kWh/t;
not needed, resulting in a cold energy saving of 14,373 kW. accordingly the exergy efciency of the HEN is only about
Meanwhile, LNG is heated from 128.2 K to 237.8 K, and the 43.2%.
heat utility is needed for the sake of providing 5605 kW load From the above analysis it is concluded that the LNG cold
to heat it from 237.8 K to 273.2 K which means about 5605 kW energy cannot be utilized efciently with a single utilization
cold energy has not been utilized in the total LNG cold energy technology. Therefore by applying LNG cold energy in a cas-
of 19,978 kW. Consequently, the utilization rate of LNG cold cade using different temperature ranges, large energy savings
energy is 71.9%. will be achieved. Meanwhile, the seasonal disparity in LNG
Some heat transfer temperature difference being too large demand should also be taken into account. In fact, the amount
leads to a relatively large HEN exergy loss. Calculation results of cold energy differs depending highly on the time of the year.
5605kW
554kW
Methane refrigerant 144.9K
149.1K
69kW E-326
Demethanizer feed 174.2K
176.2K
507kW E-1313
Demethanizer feed 174.2K
188.2K
E-HPS
139.1K
The demand for nature gas (NG) in the daytime and winter is Hua, B., Guo, H., Li, Y.J., Xiao, Z., 2005. Optimization of ethylene
larger, and consequently LNG can provide more cold energy in feedstock in China by using more light hydrocarbon
the vaporization process. While the demand for NG at night resources. Petrochem. Technol. 34 (8), 705709.
Kumar, S., Kwon, H.T., Choi, K.H., et al., 2011. LNG: an
and in the summer reduces, and hence the cold energy that
eco-friendly cryogenic fuel for sustainable development. Appl.
can be utilized also reduces. Energy 88 (12), 42644273.
Li, Y.J., Chen, X.S., Chein, M.H., 2012. Flexible and cost-effective
4. Conclusions optimization of BOG (boil-off gas) recondensation process at
LNG receiving terminals. Chem. Eng. Res. Des. 90 (10),
Renery gas recovery process consumes a large amount of 15001505.
Li, Y.J., Yin, H., 2009. Utilization of cryogenic energy of LNG in
compression power associated with the refrigeration system.
ethylene cryogenic separation process. J. South China Univ.
In respond to this problem, the cold energy of LNG is applied Technol. (Nat. Sci. Educ.) 37 (3), 6265.
to light hydrocarbons cryogenic separation process. Such tech- Malaty, W., Mccue, R., Brown, D., Larson, W., Malaty, W. et al.,
nology described here will contribute greatly to the promotion 2012. Producing olens by pyrolytic cracking of renery
of energy conservation and improve operational efciency at off-gas. WIPO Patent 2012027554.
the renery. The research shows that LNG can provide cold National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC), 2012.
energy 14,373 kW for conventional separation process and Available at:
http://www.sdpc.gov.cn/jjxsfx/t20130228 530239.htm
consequently 7973 kW power consumption of compression
Shi, X.J., Che, D.F., 2009. A combined power cycle utilizing
refrigeration system can be saved. The utilization rate of LNG low-temperature waste heat and LNG cold energy. Energy
cold energy in the separation process reaches 71.9%. Convers. Manage. 50 (3), 567575.
True, W.R., 2010. Global ethylene production continues advance
References in 2009. Oil Gas J. 108 (27), 3438.
Wang, H.S., Zhou, P., Song, W.D., 1996. Optimization analysis of
low pressure demethanization process. J. Chem. Ind. Eng. 47
China Export & Credit Insurance Corporation (CECIC), 2013.
(3), 287292.
Available at: http://www.sinosure.com.cn/sinosure/
Wang, Y.F., Hua, B., Li, Y.J., 2008. Study on comprehensive
xwzx/rdzt/ckyj/ckdt/xyzt/qcxy/dzspyj/157067.html
utilization of renery dry gas. Mod. Chem. Ind. 28 (2), 6974.
China Export & Credit Insurance Corporation (CECIC), 2013.
Wu, C.P., Sun, L., 2001. Separation and comprehensive utilization
Available at: http://www.sinosure.com.cn/
of renery dry gas. Mod. Chem. Ind. 21 (5), 2023.
sinosure/xwzx/rdzt/ckyj/ckdt/xyzt/qcxy/dzspyj/159702.html
Wu, X.S., Wang, Z.W., 2002. Process improvement of chilling
Fabrega, F.M., Rossi, J.S., dAngelo, J.V.H., 2010. Exergetic analysis
separate system in ethylene plant. Chem. Ind. Eng. Prog. 21
of the refrigeration system in ethylene and propylene
(10), 763765.
production process. Energy 35 (3), 12241231.
Yu, J.N., Zhang, L.J., Li, J.C., 2010. Development status and its
Gao, T., Lin, W.S., Gu, A.Z., 2011. Improved processes of light
prospect of PetroChinas ethylene industry. Petrochem.
hydrocarbon separation from LNG with its cryogenic energy
Technol. Appl. 28 (3), 258263.
utilized. Energy Convers. Manage. 52 (6), 24012404.
Zhao, X.P., Wu, L.J., Wang, L.G., 2007. Recovery of light olens
Holmquist, K., 2010. Global ethylene surplus to last through 2011.
from renery dry-gas. CN Patent 1919975A.
Oil Gas J. 108 (27), 4652.